Added: 1 year ago
From: xplay
Views: 23,303
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (214)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Fuck you x-play this is one of the few games on the fucking piece of shit wii that I love, of course it didn't sell well because most wii fans are fags and retards (aka casual gamers) that only buy shitty casual games. I hope they make a 3rd on the PS move because it's to good for the fucking retards at nintendo (also so I can finally have one reason to buy a Ps move)

  • what is this.....2D or 3D,?? :\\\q

  • Okay Redsteel one epic! Redsteel 2 stupid. First off the fact they gave a positive review for this game destroyed all respect for X-play me.

  • @masterjim23 i think you have them mixed X)

  • @masterjim23 this game is so much better 1 controls actually work story is good predictable but good 3 graphics wise it beats red steel 1

  • 5/5 for me! I played this game 4 times and after the first time i played back to back each difficulty too. I think its replayable just because its fun

  • As much as I love this game I will have to agree with XPlay. On all of it's points except needing to use "broad movement's." I think they could have used a better word than that cause that term might scare some people away from it. There'nt very huge movements. "Slightly Broad swings" I think it a slightly better term. But you won't have to do huge swings like a real sword.

    These issues can be fixed if Ubisoft gives this game the full treatment. It can be the first 3rd party AAA motion title.

  • uncreative? have you ever seen a futuristic wild west yakooza fps game? what a dumbass

  • This guy only gave it 3 stars because he couldn't beat the first boss, I finished and I love it second best game on the wii the first being monster hunter tri. 5/5

  • What a review that does not agree with what I think about the game??? This must be the wrost review ever you guys must not even play video games and know nothing about them to have a different opinion about a game other then mine!! how dare you Xplay!

  • eh in my opinion this game deserves atleast a 4 if not 5 considering its the wii but i get what xplay is saying...

  • OPINIONS PEOPLE!!!!! Stupid

  • Remember, this review is personal opinion, idiots.

  • @Godzillah1 Before calling other people stupid you should watch some more X-play/G4 reviews. Whenever there is a new action title for the Wii they HAVE TO rate it low just because they can't stand the fact that the Wii actually has a mature audience.

  • "However, the game setting feels very seemly uncreative, the developers have fused Western-Samurai-Futuristic elements; that's the sort of thing a 13 year-old sci-fi inspired writer would do."

    holy crap that's the worst excuse I have ever heard. And that is not uncreative, that is just pretty darn badass.

  • It was pretty short and the loading times were awefull. But still the gameplay is so much fun! It has its flaws but the basic gameplay is among the the best I`ve played in years.

  • Typical XPlay Wii hating. If it isn't PS3,XBox360 or Mario, it is executed immediatly. That is why I avoid G4 now (That and Olivia Munn is on the Daily Show :*( ) I give Adam and Morgan -5 stars for there reviewing techniques :P. This game is awesome. Short, but awesome.

  • I wish I did not watch Xplays reviews. It just proves that they do not know anything about video games, their really just a bunch of wannabe's.

  • What the fuck? 3?

  • I would have given this game a 4/5. And i usually agree with x-play reviews.

  • i miss g4tv :(

  • I love this game. Hate this reviewer.

  • I rented the game, and while I did enjoy it, it was filled with major flaws it got really boring as soon as I beat it on the highest difficulty. And there's really no incentive to play the lower difficulties, since the game is easy regardless of the difficulty that I play.

    So while it is a fun experience for a short time, it's definitely not worth full price.

  • @gamingrocks100 I agree i wish i didn't drop 60 for this game. I wouldn't say i got burned but i did get scolled.

  • LOL @ fanboys. For the most part, this is review is very accurate.

    This is one of the easiest & shortest games I've ever played in a while. The voice acting & dialogue is so awful at times, it's not even funny. The missions are some of the most boring & repetitive I've ever experienced.

    If it wasn't for the exciting use of motion controls, the combos, the good mix of swords & guns, and the amazing graphics (for a Wii game), then it would probably be a 2/5.

  • @gamingrocks100 People complain that the first game also got 3 stars. This may be a major improvement, but that doesn't automatically make it a great game.

    What people don't release is, RS1 was released in 2006, when motion control was relatively new & crappy motion controls were at least somewhat acceptable. In 2010, 1 year after Motion+ came out, you can expect more.

    I can respect others' opinions, but I honestly think the ONLY reason they praise it this much is because it's a decent Wii game.

  • reason this got a 3 from xplay . . . isnt it obvious. . . its not halo. . . morons

  • @M3TR01DFANBOY or call of duty

  • i love xplay but realy cmon this game is good

  • adam fails

  • lol AT 140

  • Haha he's complaining about LOADING SCREENS? Doesn't every CD/DVD/Blu-Ray based game have a loading screen? Should've gotten a 4, since really he doesn't list out any real problems with the game. The setting may come off cheesy but I think thats what the developers wanted, cheesy but not TOO cheesy.

  • Common Adam... your better then this :/

  • u get a 0 out of 1000 xplay

  • This reveiw is a fail.

  • How to know X-Play is epic fail: They gave it the same review as the first one. Guess Adam doesn't feel the game is any better. ...... Prick.

  • loading thats not very well hidden? are you serious. how DO you want them to hide it. atleast its not like other games where its just a picture with a painfully slow moving bar.

  • Who's narrating this thing, sound like Howie Mandell

  • @Zimwibwe Adam Sessler

  • EVEN IGN IS BETTER THAN THESE GUYS

  • @FKnox123 butthurt shithead

  • @FKnox123 x play's got tons of funny jokes ign not so fun to watch they just say theyre opinion but x play have a good sense of humor

  • "Im gonna cut your throat with your own Katana!" XDD

  • Shooting is about the same. Fail. I dear anybody to go back and play the original red steel now and tell me that shooting is the same. This is why wii owners can't trust xplay. They are simply to basis and don't invest enough time on the console.

  • This OR monster hunter tri 2 OR LOD Twilight princess

  • There was a Red Steel?

  • You think I can download it whitout wii motion plus?

  • @KNGergely You need it

  • Comment removed

  • really bad review, desagree with almost everything u said. And i see im not the only one thinking it, bad, baaad reviewer.

  • ...continuing from my previous comment.

    I hate this review, myself, because Adam often says stupid, redundant things, but the score is pretty accurate, and it's not nearly as bad as you seem to think, so stop saying things like, "This deserves 4 or 5 stars".

    Besides, some of the comments defending this game are just as redundant as the review. They say things like, "This is on par with 360 & PS3 and it only got 3/5," (which makes absolutely no sense at all), or, "Controls + upgrades = 4/5".

  • Calm down, guys, 3/5 is not a bad score, or at least not nearly as bad as you guys seem to think. Watch X-Plays Ratings 101 video. They said that 3 stars means, "Good, but not great,", and that's pretty much what I think about RS2

    It's a great swordplay game, the FPS elements really add to it, and overall it's pretty unique. But as a regular retail game, it's good at best. It's extremely fun, but ONLY for a short time (unless you find single-player MotionPlus swordplay to be EXTREMELY addictive)

  • 3/5 mah ass...ur only looking at the shitty stuff...i mean wat about the awesome story line and upgrades available......

  • @Empoleon2568 Awesome story line? LOL

  • @nerftendo005 decent -___-

  • @Empoleon2568 I consider it to be mediocre. The voice acting and dialogue is really bad, and the characters lack development or personality. Thankfully, storyline plays a small role in the game (although I still wouldn't consider it non-existent).

  • @nerftendo005 true...but can u help me...im stuck on the end of the chase chapter and the door in the tunnel wont open...PLZ HELP ME!! >_<

  • @Empoleon2568 I forget which chapter that is. I rented the game a long time ago, near the time of the game's release.

  • @nerftendo005 its the one after the train...where ur in an abandoned cowboy town place...but i cant get passed it cuz the door won't open :'(

  • @Empoleon2568 Which door?

  • Well, the voice acting is VERY shitty and the game could've been much longer and executed its concepts further.

    But it was fun. Very fun. I'd give it an honest 3.8 out of 5 for them trying to make something really good for the Wii.

  • @dAMike2468 I completely agree, graphics look amazing for a Wii game, and the game has, by far, THE BEST swordplay I've ever experienced in any game. I rented it, and it was really fun. If the price goes down to $30 ($40 with MotionPlus), then this would be worth buying IMO.

  • WTF BAD REVIEW!! R.S.2 Is one of the best fps games on the wii so why would it get a three out of five? Because xplay still is a fanboy of halo and mw2.

  • @Ron457X2 You do realize that saying that it's "one of the best fps games on the wii" really isn't saying much, right?

    I agree that X-Play is MW2 and Halo fanboys, but compared to other games on the market, this game still deserves 3/5 stars IMO.

    To be honest though, I wouldn't classify this as an FPS, as half of the gameplay focus is on sword-fighting.

    I agree that this is WAY BETTER than the 1st, but that should've gotten 2/5.

    Although I disagree with most of what X-Play says in the review.

  • Also you don't play a game like this for the story.

  • Did they even know that orientals and sometimes martial artists were brought to the west to work on railroads. That's what the setting is, and it's cartonny like kill bill not ment to be taken to serious. Also, could you really call it 'futuristic' because of the doors.

  • The game pulls a THAW with the loading.

  • So they give red steel 2 a 3/5 and Red Steel (1) a 3/5 even though Red steel 2 is clearly FAR superior?

  • @The28thplatypus I know, right? I mean, I know that gaming has advanced A LOT since 2006, but the 1st still should've gotten a 2/5. It was mediocre, even by 2006's standards.

  • xplay sucks.

  • dude this is at last a 4.5/5. but then again ur x play so i shouldnt be surprised

  • What the hell man, this game should get a 5/5 damn man, wii finally gets a game that is on par with 360 and ps3, and you are to biast to see past your own stupidity. Damn man, this is a beast game. you should take a cold shower and rethink it.

  • @tsdspyj (Sigh) Graphics are everything to you, aren't they?

  • @nerftendo005 Hey think about it, if graphics were everything to me, you think I would have a wii, hell no. I would have a ps3, and I still play gamecube games and ps2 games and n64, no graphics aren't everything to me. It,s all about the gameplay. This game has awesome gameplay, I mean it. I like the sword fighting, I wouldn't keep the game game if it didn't.

  • @tsdspyj You said that this game is on par with the 360 and PS3. That statement makes absolutely no sense at all, unless you're talking about graphics.

  • @nerftendo005 See, there I was talking about graphics. but you said graphics are everything to me, and I was saying they weren't. They say Wii graphics suck, and I am just saying here is a beast game with great graphics. That is all I was saying.

  • i own the game and what they said was true they forgot to mention ho creative you can be with your kills. the story is horrid, but fight large groups of weak enemies is so much fun with the skills you unlock.

  • Looks like a pretty shitty game to me.. I pitty Wii owners, they'll never know what it menas to have fun with videogames until they buy a PS3 or a Xbox 360

  • @McLovin123ify The wii has a lot of fun games. Such as galaxy, muramasa, and so much more. The focuses more on fun than graphics. The PS3 and Xbox 360 focus more on graphics than fun. Their audience is hypnotized into thinking that because a game has such amazing graphics that the game is automatically an awesome game when it truly isn't.

  • @Ryanmiller70 i guess u never played red dead redemption..or AC2 i non stop fun, plus the graphics

  • @McLovin123ify Wii has great games, too, you know, and that's coming from someone who prefers the PS3.

  • @Ryanmiller70 OK, I can definitely tell from your statement that you're a Wii owner who's either jealous that the 360 & PS3 have way better graphics, or is just extremely stereotypical. 360 & PS3 have great gameplay, too.

    The Wii is a good console with a good selection of games, but most of the good games on the system are exclusives, while the 360 & PS3 get most of the multi-platform games (and they aren't dumbed down versions) as well as exclusives.

    PS3, 360, PC, and Wii are all good systems.

  • @McLovin123ify I own a wii and I have fun with videogames all the time, and no, I don't have a 360 or a ps3

  • Once again, they gave one the greatest ever...a 3 out of 5...just like the first Redsteel!

  • r u stupid are you really expecting a game that runs 60 frames per second that dosnt slow down to load a room or enviroment as quick

  • @psp2s2 Metroid Prime 3 runs 60 frames, and most of the doors don't take very long to load. In fact, even the Metroid Prime games on Gamecube (which also ran 60 frames) had much quicker load times on doors.

  • "wait! Why is that wii fit model demonstrating moves in red steel 2?" "SHE IS HELPING US!!"

    Humor aside, this was yet another biased review from xplay in which they are judging a wii game with xbox and ps3 standards. Wii is not the same as those "hardcore" consoles. And why is sessler judging the style of the game? That's just a matter of preference. I think futuristic cowboy japanese settings are cool >:(

  • @RLbitClassica (Sigh). I'm sick of how people like you claim that these guys are 360/PS3 fanboys just to defend this game. When will you accept that the game has flaws, and just because it has awesome swordplay, upgrades, and graphics doesn't automatically mean it deserves 4 or 5 stars? I admit, I disagree with most of the things that they said in this review, and I think that RS1 should've gotten 2 stars (as RS2 is WAY BETTER), but I think 3 stars is a fine score for RS2.

  • a 3 out of five fuck that noise! how about a 5 this review can suck my balls this game kills!

  • the game is actually very gimmicky, I got it, then returned it. had tonnes of potential tho.

  • Fair enough review. I for one love the dialog though, I mean, it's gotta be the funniest shit I've heard in years.

  • same hear, clockdud556 amen

  • Who cares about loading time they over exaggerate it so much.

  • I have this game and I love it. Your review sucks.

  • @krishnaramdeep I agree. I bought it just for the motion plus but I end up liking it.

  • Shit the scenario is awesome and Im 21 and not 14...

  • Wow disgrace to reviewing Wii games! Your so biased and always find something wrong with a Wii game no game is perfect and every wii FPS is like its compared to Halo!They give one good compliment then they always find 2 negatives for a Wii game, review a game and dont compare it to another game like Halo(i know they didnt directly compare them,just a good Ex.) Review a game like you've never played another game b4,do what IGN and GT do and review it from the ground up l

  • I WANT A WII

  • you know whats sad is that adam and morgan dont even play the games that are reviewed the just read what other people say

  • A 3?! Come on!!!!!111

  • WOWOWOWOW, this is such a horrible review, 3/5... seriously!

    I would give this game like a 4.5/5

  • i still like xplay

  • honestly fuck x play they rarely have new episodes anyway i remember when they used to be on tech tv then they went and merged with g4 and ruined everything by showing cops all day and cheaters basically stuff that has nothing to do with video games or technology. The only 3 shows left are X play, attack of the show, and mabye web soup. What happened to Arena,and all those other good shows.

  • i got this game today and i disagree on this review i love the game the only thing i dont like about the game is it takes a long time to open a door i give it a 4 out of 5

  • it just looks an awesome game....

    fuck xplay....

  • good game but they shouldnt call it red steel 2 becuz new character new setting different graphic style and u can switch all the time so they should call it another title

  • no replay valeu? dude I have beaten this game 2 times and I still want to replay it.

  • I actually agree with this review, a good wii game is a decent game when compared to the other consoles. The main story is pretty cool and the controls are much, much better than the first, but theres absolutely no replay value. Ubisoft can't expect people to pay 60$ for a game they're only going to play once.

  • that shit deserves a 5 not 3. AT LEAST A 4

  • this deserve at least a 4.5/5 stars!!!!

  • Wow, it got the same score as the last one, eventhough Red Steel 2 is a vast improvement over the first one.

  • God, these reviews suck. It got knocked points because it's a Ninja Shooter? How is it fair that the basis of the game is bad because it isn't a typical setting?

  • xplay is being paid off by game companies to give good and bad reviews

    you cant trust them any more...

  • I think X-Play is right with this review. It is actually a positive review because it highlights how fun it is, but face it - its just filler until the next Mario, Metroid & Zelda come.

    Its good filler, but its filler. Its worth your time & money, because its short & sweet.

  • your review gets a zero out of 10

  • He is such a dicki 3 out of 5 its way better than that

  • He is such a dicki 3 out of 5 its way better than that

  • I have a 360 and a Ps3 and a wii. I have almost no wii games. Can you guys please help should I get this or no more heroes 2

  • @cantosa222

    get both

    also u should get more wii games

  • Huh, no replay value? So basically today's game needs tons of unnecessary unlockables and a tacked on multiplayer with even more unnecessary unlockables to be considered a classic. If you can't see the old school 80's/90's brawler goodness that is Red Steel 2, then you probably just started playing games now.

    It's like saying the original Double Dragon, or the original Shinobi had no replay value, and that would be a stupid thing to say.

  • Great game. U suck

  • Imagine you telling these guys about an amazing game, and they're like DUDE THAT SOUNDS AWESOME! And you say it's on the Wii, then they say Oh...then it must suck.

  • C'mon Adam. This isn't a masterpiece, but it's a solid 4 out of 5.

  • 3 stars? damn....Wii is dying

  • @supatoker420 Fuck off, actually play the game instead of relying on these piece of shit reviews.

  • @LiamRproductions whoa whoa whoa, calm down dude. and even if this game was good, what does wii have besides mario and some other lame shit?

  • @supatoker420 1000s of VC games, Twilight princess, Smash bros., Okami, MOH:Heroes 2, Muramasa, The Conduit, The best version of RE4, de Blob, Madworld, No more heroes 1 & 2, Disaster: day of crisis, Samba de amigo, Strikers charged, MK wii, Red steel 2, Wii sports, sports resort, Rage of the Gladiator, Monster Hunter Tri,Tatsunoko vs Capcom, Silent Hill: Shattered memories, House of the Dead: Overkill, Zack n Wiki, Dead space extraction, Boom Blox 1 & 2, Punch out... I'm out of space -_-

  • @supatoker420 Part two: Little King's story, Endless Ocean 1 & 2, Excite truck and Excite Bots, Wario ware, Wario land, Lost winds 1 & 2, Y,M&the cubes, Castlevania: Rebirth, Dracula: Undead Awakening, the Bit trip series (5 games), Contra Rebirth, Nyx Quest, Dr Mario, My life as a king, my life as a darklord, Chrono trigger DX, Crystal bearers, Metroid prime trillogy, Deadly creatures, Tales of monkey island series, Excite bike world challenges, Lit, Protothea, Mr Driller W, Bonsai Barber...

  • @supatoker420 Part three: Gradius Rebirth, FF: The after years, Bubble Bobble plus, Strong bad series, Pop, Star soldier R, Toki Tori, TV Show king 1 & 2, you could also count the wii version of COD5 as it is completely different, Tetris party, Wii fit plus, Max & the magic marker, Art style: Orbient, Swords and soldiers, Bomberman blast - Just to name a few. And there's plenty more coming too.

  • @LiamRproductions

    Part four: all rated E and up, some rated T, few rated M, all for kids. lame.

  • @supatoker420 That made no grammatical sense at all.

  • @LiamRproductions you list games, i tell you about the games you listed. simple.

  • It's not a very good review. That and I disagree with it completely

  • nice brief review, 3's a good score.

  • do noot get this game...unless your wii is like modded whit chip or so..

  • you know if red steel 2 came out on the xbox or ps3 it would have gotten a 5, can't wait till the weekend so i could get this

  • you guys are fuckin stupid, i liked u guys before but now youre being gay and giving dumbass reviews, i bet if it was on a different system you would have gave a 5

  • @blazilfrazil2 excactly they just talk smack on the wii

  • xplay never has their head straight when giving a review. I'd much rather go with IGN or something.

  • Oh look a great wii game gets a 3/5 on X-play......why am I not surprised?

  • @Hazmatkr3w i know right!

  • this is one shitty review

  • i'm fucking tired listening to xplay on there reviews, they are extremely biased towards the wii, fuck it's pissing me off. This game is amazing in every way, it's fine tuned shooting, swordfighting and everything else. It's graphics top anything on the system yet, fuck you xplay and have a bad day :)

  • THANK YOU

  • i'm still going to get it

  • i have been watching xplay for years and have been caught on on gamespot too but sadly they are both becoming xbox and ps3 fanboys. the wii has a FEW good worthy tittles and redsteel 2 should be one of them. Adam Sessler disappointed me big time with this review.

  • You know you look very immature freaking out like this right?

  • only 60% ????????

  • harsh

  • I got this game... and i disagree...

    They definitely under rated this game.

  • @Flunkorg everyone may have a diffrent opinion if xplay gave it an average score than they must have thought the game was average its THIER OPINION not yours, if you thought the game was better than average than thats YOU'RE OPINION not theyres

  • it at least deserves a 4 out of 5 in my opinion, great game!!

  • If I see this same Expedia add 1 more time...

  • Bought RS2 the other day, and this review definitely underrated it. Most other well-known reviewers gave this game 8's and above, GameStop gave it a 10. Honestly this is one of the best games I've seen on the Wii, and if you're unsure, pick it up @ Blockbuster and try it out.

  • Ign gave it an 8.6 and applauded the graphics and art direction. I like X-play but they have been wrong before. Battlefront on Xbox a 3 out of 5? That was crazy talk lol.

  • The first battlefront on Xbox was fun, but extremely flawed. Just look at where the franchise is at now with BF:BC2. 3 out of 5 was generous.

  • @dante666diaz what? battlefront and bad company 2 aren't the same franchise, they're not even made by the same companies.

  • Sorry. I read it as "battlefield" but still wrote it as battlefront. Sorry, major brain lapse. Disregard my previous statement. I completely agree with you.

  • The main characters avatar looks like a bad Alucard cosplayer.

  • I got this game yesterday and totally don't agree with this review, it's just so much fun. Should of got a 4/5 at least.

  • SAME HERE MAN

  • this game looks badass i cant wait til i pick it up tomorrow ^^

  • X-play just doesnt know what it wants for 5/5!

  • @Gun10001 they are very bias

  • I got the game kinda hard to learn with getting shot or cut but it's alright

  • People are acting as if 3/5 is a bad score. I've played the game and I personally think it deserves 8/10. It's be no means a spectacular game, but it's pretty damn fun. If you bother to actually listen to the review, most of what Adam says is positive.

  • yeah but stile....... 3/5 seems low (i've been watching xplay for years... I know what the ratings mean)

  • you really think a show all about games that makes reviews didnt play the game? these guys are experts. been doing it for a lot longer than you and you all think your opinions are better? is that why you have your own show? is that why ppl watch your video game reviews on youtube? is that why you get all the hands and previews before everyone else? oh wait.... you dont. cuz your not experts. geez everyone thinks their opinion is so important. i trust x play 100% they have yet to fail me

  • What the hell do they bleed? Sand?