so its a time lapse of the ice melting and he couldn't touch it coz then it would expose the time lapse. Its boring once you know.... next fake vid please.
The water holds its shape by sudden thermal formation and when his finger gets close to the water, the warmth from his finger tips end up getting absorbed by the water, thus braking the thermal formation structure duh!!
Well thats easy, Obviously you guys didnt see it!, How about a thin layer Ice Glass under the real glass, which makes it to be floating water, and then Ice melting makes a hole in the ice glass which makes the water fall because air has untered the glass! that could be the truth!
i did it once but it was only for like 10 seconds that it worked and you have to use a plastic cup with spray non-stick solution like pam to get it to work. try it out!
Actually, water would be very sensitive to it's surrounding especially because they take things shape, therefore the momentum and ability to sustain gravity at that amount of force, clearly means after a few seconds of constant motion, the water would be due to splashing once gravity overpowered it, but the disruption of his motion towards the water cause it to reformat and take the counter's shape which was ending in a splash.
@iiDeadlyVortex all of that its complete bullshit xD "...therefore the momentum and ability to sustain gravity at that amount of force..." makes no sense D:
The water is obviously supporting itself because it is still spinning. The angular momentum keeps it suspended. As soon as it slows down enough, it falls. Touching the water has nothing to do with it. Do your research before trying to disprove something next time.
@aGoatTriedToEatMe If you take a look at his profile, he's a computer animator. Didn't Cameron do this type of thing in the Abyss? About 20 years ago?
@VoxMot if you were to cause a (however minute) vacuum within the cup, the water could easily spin with the cup (again, surface tension). I am not claiming whether or not this trick does work. Just use what your teachers in high school taught you! USE YOUR BWWAAAIIINNNNZZZZ.
I AM DISAPPOINT. All the preceding comments fail to examine a connection between centriputal force and surface tension. Not to mention the water is spinning (think inertia). Without actually trying it, you'll never see the answer.
are you all insane. water can't stay in the form of a glass. it's the laws of nature. it has to be computer imaging. what the hell is body heat going to do? it doesn't have any force with in it, his body heat doesn't have some sort of telekinetic force. think.
here's a thought...maybe the water slowed down and stopped spinning...BEFORE HIS FINGER GOT TO IT :OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
@laynecaffy Just to clarify: it doesn't violate the laws of physics if you make them up as you go. You're obviously just guessing about this so lets see if I can help you in the right direction.
Go get a cup of water, put a small ice cube in the cup. Now turn the cup. You'll notice the ice cube stays where it is for the most part. The spinning motion of the cup doesn't do jack to the water. The rest of what you said is wrong too, I'm just not willing to spend that much time on a troll/moron.
@ffxfriki what about physics? that is what this video is mostly about. Go easy on the sarcasm when you aren't completely sure what you want to convey...
@DrekenShark This has a lot to do with surface tension but that can also be described by chemistry and how on the surface the bonds between water molecules are stronger than in the center.
@DrekenShark You're an idiot. He doesn't have to touch it, it was suspended because of the spinning motion of the water. So, the water stops spinning and is no longer suspended.
@DrekenShark actually u fucking moron in chemistry you learn that liquid takes the shape of its container thus proving this is imposible on account of the fact that the liquid basically has no container unless you count the room ,but theres really not that much water so you get what i mean and also proving you dont know what the word convey mean :D
It worked for me... just jelly cause you cant figure out how to do it, and I am not sharing the secret. I am just gonna keep using it to win bets at bars and bag chicks, ( they love this shit!)
Honestly, who HASN'T worked it out? Yes, it's a neat effect that is all but obviously fake and requires one viewing to work out. You mean there are people that were ""actually"" tricked by it? LMFAO :D:D:D
If you weren't grinning at the thought of the dullards who were going to attempt this "amazing trick" then you should probably be wearing a helmet. But congratulations on "figuring it out"
YOU THINK THAT SOMEONE WHO CAN MAKE THIS WITH SPECIAL EFFECTS DID NOT THINK ABOUT MAKING IT LOOK LIKE HIS FINGER REALLY TOUCHED THE WATER!?!?!?!?!??! !! ?!?!
dude,he used his soundwave trick from one of his other video to disturb the water flow.i think it's when you move your fingers in a specific order/manner it throw a soundwave blast,a bit like a kamehameha
You are soooo dumb for taking the time to make this video... He doesnt have to touch the water to make it fall.. It falls because there wasn't enough speed in the water rotation.
Why don't you just tell me there is no Santa Clause while your at it or there is no gold at the end of a rainbow. Which by the way I will get. You just don't have the necessary muscle co-ordination to get the required 21.763 mph counter clockwise spin in a 32 degree left right south north motion. You sir are a failure. Oh and you have to do it on your computer for best results.
Erm, nothing spins or stays suspended forever. I'm pretty sure it just stopped spinning enough to hold itself together before he got the chance to break it. If it's true.
@JarSqwuid you're fucking retarded, nothing as a liquid can keep its form without a container even if it spinning at a batrillion miles per hour................. balls.
Hello, I dont really know if the trick is real, and I also dont know if what im about to tell you is the real reason but, the bonds in water got an electric nature and you can break it without touching them directly. Sory my bad english, thats the reason cause i can´t explain my self correctly
@Simpliey Hurrrrdurrrrrr oh I so sorry. I no mean to offend. I bow down. Oh wait, I never did mention anything about me believing the video now did I? Hmm. Please don't embarrass yourself by putting words into people's mouths just so you can fortify your own point. I mean you watched this video, which of course means, you're saying you believe it too. So yeah, see how your logic works? It doesn't. Derp
@BraidenFerguson Never put words in anyone's mouth, and your the one who's embarrassing your self by trying to act like a intelligent human being, after what you said above. Which in my perspective, your not... lol and I'd suggest you stop putting large and meaning less words into your sentence because it just makes you look like a total.. erm... Douche-bag?
@Simpliey The only word I used that could possibly be considered large was "fortify," which is sad since it isn't large at all. Right now you're just continuing this argument because you're doing you're best to stray from the point which you obviously realized you were wrong in. and for the record:
you're* yourself* an* (no comma)* (comma after which)* you're* meaningless*
Seeing as you were attempting to look and sound smart, I figure I'd help you fix mechanical errors you constantly make.
@Simpliey I bet you did. And I was fairly certain you would say something like that as well, since you refuse to stay on topics that you can't back up.
@BraidenFerguson Yup, because I said what I said to this guy: GrassCityGaming and you're obviously not him... I don't even know why I was arguing with you :/
@Simpliey I jut thought it wrong for you to make horrible judgements upon people for giving their opinion on something about how they thought it worked.
@BraidenFerguson I think I misjudged you, you seem like a cool guy and totally not a penis :) and for that guy. Sometimes it's good to be harsh; when their about the make a similar comments they can re-consider what their typing, also I'm not taking 'away' their right to say what's on their mind I'm just.. can't find the right word to describe it .. :(
@Simpliey And for the record, yes you did put words in my mouth. Quote unquote "Coming from a guy who thinks liquid can stay in a particular shape with out a container, real smart :)"
@GrassCityGaming You sound retarded for actually agruing the legitimacy of such an obviously fake video. How the hell would the fact that it's spinning make any difference? Did you forget about gravity or something?
@pyro251086 you can defy gravity by spinning, you know.
the reason it's definitely fake is because the water molecules would move outwards as they spin and it wouldn't retain it's glass-shape like that for such a long time for that reason because they are all joined by forces
@nishihs I'm aware of the principle of centrifugal force, if anything that would work against what this video is trying to claim to be possible. Since centrifugal force pushes things outwards, not inwards.
@casketgrind oh well, genius, centripetal makes things go TOWARDS the center. centrifugal means center-fleeing and describes when things are being pushed AWAY from the center. however, it is not a real force.
simple physics, my friend.
next time get your facts straight before you try to make someone else sound like an idiot because you just did it to yourself.
@AnarchisticLeper and we can assume his spin is strong enough to generate centrifugal force strong enough for the water to maintain it's shape, also completely ignoring the water flow and gravity. I also have superman's hands. another obvious problem here is how he lifted the cup off without a single drop escaping. the air pressure alone would gush into the cup and generate push onto the water, thus disturbing whatever superstrong centrifugal force you have going and causing a mini typhoon.
Actually it is quite possible... He left out the part where you freeze the cup of water just so to where the outer is frozen and not one inner... Duhhh :)))
The hand is not required to make direct contact. If you put a drop of water on a table and slowly move your finger towards it, you will find that once you get too close, the water will touch your finger before you reach the drop. This is due to the gravitational pull between the two. In this particular video, the hand moves too close to the water and disturbs the surface tension of the water and causes it to collapse. Maybe you should know what you're talking about before you make assumptions.
He didn't have to touch it, it's not like if he doesn't touch it the water will keep spinning forever it has to fall at some point, wether it needs help or not.
The original video still cracks me up, it's such troll physics. If anything, spinning the water gives it even less of a chance of it being able to do that.
If you were in space, for example, you'd be able to do this no problem (without spinning it). Spin it, though, and this would never happen. =)
Are you people that bord with your lives!? How much time have you devoted to this one freaking video!? The word possible means there's a chance of failure....multiple times!...just like your lives...
@CentOKIlo That wasn't my point. It is fake. Stop trying to protect the original video when it only ends up making you look bad. To go off of the point you were trying to make... BOTH the water AND air would have to be moving around the water column as shown in the original video; imagine a mini tornado of water and air. That simply wasn't the case as it is IMPOSSIBLE to sustain water in a shape other than it's container (and in this case because the glass was missing... it would collapse.)
@DrekenShark Try this experiment to further prove what I am getting at. Fill a bowl with water. Slowly move your hand/finger towards the surface of the water. Does it make any movement? No. Why? Because if you move your hand slowly towards the water the air around the surface of the water hasn't been accelerated enough to make an impact on the water. NEXT, repeat the same process but this time move your hand quickly towards the waters surface but then abruptly stop before you touch the H2O
Respond to this video... Take note of what happens. Did the water move? YES! Why? Because the acceleration of your hand was quick enough to change the speed of the air directly above the water which then in turn made the water move/ripple a bit. You see my point this time?
@DougieFwesh Prove it! Come on... show how it is done... like the original video says, "ANYONE CAN DO IT"... so give it a shot. Make a video response showing how you did it yourself and post it by end of day Saturday July 16 or you are a liar just like everyone else who has tried to protect this myth!
@DrekenShark poeple cant do it cause look at other video. other poeple turn and pull it up side ways not straight up just look at ther videos they will pull it up side was. also if you put your hand near it you will disturb it and it will lose its spin. so i still believe it works. if you put nevgative cooment then keep it to yourself.
so its a time lapse of the ice melting and he couldn't touch it coz then it would expose the time lapse. Its boring once you know.... next fake vid please.
TazPessle 1 hour ago
The water holds its shape by sudden thermal formation and when his finger gets close to the water, the warmth from his finger tips end up getting absorbed by the water, thus braking the thermal formation structure duh!!
Anyone knows this!
intheshitter 11 hours ago
Well thats easy, Obviously you guys didnt see it!, How about a thin layer Ice Glass under the real glass, which makes it to be floating water, and then Ice melting makes a hole in the ice glass which makes the water fall because air has untered the glass! that could be the truth!
Sangoreborn 1 week ago
noooooo! he edited it and saw the edit fail and came up with another way to say its awsome!r
ilovewaffles561 2 weeks ago
when you have been around long enough you would know this was fake with no question. interesting hoax however...
popeye1579 2 weeks ago
Why does everyone keep saying its fake =.= you need to delete this...
XenoDuskAngel 2 weeks ago
its not fake its just ice
211darthreven443 4 weeks ago
i did it once but it was only for like 10 seconds that it worked and you have to use a plastic cup with spray non-stick solution like pam to get it to work. try it out!
goldenArcherwolf 1 month ago
Ice. Looked at this for 40 seconds!
MadeInAmerica020685 1 month ago
NAH REALLY??? I THOUGHT IT WAS REAL DERP HURP
mav6771 1 month ago
why would you believe it in the first place?
TheGizmoTruck 1 month ago
the water tension keeps it together for while, while its spinning
killermoth384 1 month ago
It was fine till it took an arrow to the knee
tupos 1 month ago
@tupos derp
fui54uhrf4 1 month ago
Do people actually sit and fucking try this....
BlackMethuzela 1 month ago
dude -_- please if its fake so what?? its awesome anyway if you hate it dont watch it.. still its awesome
cokbagus23 1 month ago
in the future everybody show this video to their child and make fun of with it.
smnknc 1 month ago
hahahahahahahah he never wanted to touch it you idiot! he wanted to shou you that this isn't a double shot !!! hahahahah
leonblackhack666 1 month ago
The idea was the introduction of heat from his palm not by touching it.
bobbysnobby 1 month ago
It WAS suspended, until some A-hole opened up a portal right underneath it.
TheCaphits 1 month ago 2
frozen?
Santunamoon 1 month ago
its not even animation i do it now :)
Shaking3poppyrolls 1 month ago
It went down because the black pointer hit it
branmann19 1 month ago
that is like magic!
melissa23girls 1 month ago
Actually, water would be very sensitive to it's surrounding especially because they take things shape, therefore the momentum and ability to sustain gravity at that amount of force, clearly means after a few seconds of constant motion, the water would be due to splashing once gravity overpowered it, but the disruption of his motion towards the water cause it to reformat and take the counter's shape which was ending in a splash.
iiDeadlyVortex 2 months ago
@iiDeadlyVortex all of that its complete bullshit xD "...therefore the momentum and ability to sustain gravity at that amount of force..." makes no sense D:
Strikedead444 1 month ago
maybe it stopped twisting
jmvalenzuelad 2 months ago
well, all i can say is he didnt have to touch it. im not saying im a chemistry major but the force applied by the air was probably enough.
pivotmasterxd100 2 months ago
The water is obviously supporting itself because it is still spinning. The angular momentum keeps it suspended. As soon as it slows down enough, it falls. Touching the water has nothing to do with it. Do your research before trying to disprove something next time.
iamcypress 2 months ago
hey not to be mean but it is possible y?? my brother did it in his high school science class and worked
moonwolf802 2 months ago
...Nothing is impossible difficult but not impossible....
MrElmalo11 2 months ago
Umm, I think everyone but you already knew it was fake. I mean, a basic understanding of physics proves that.
SpoonFilms 2 months ago
and what about the sunlight passing through the water?? on the counter?? notice that
halfway2hell333gmail 2 months ago
Does that water look animated to you?
aGoatTriedToEatMe 2 months ago
@aGoatTriedToEatMe If you take a look at his profile, he's a computer animator. Didn't Cameron do this type of thing in the Abyss? About 20 years ago?
azimuth361 2 months ago
or the electricity of our fingers. in this case his fingers collapsed the water
TheHaukkuja 2 months ago
Are you mad? No one was 'duped' only stipid dumb-asses.
Mattyrdom 2 months ago
My friend believed it was possible. He even pretended to be a physicist for a few minutes. He was such a twit. Good thing he succumbed to logic :D
theguy12346 2 months ago
Is there anyone who actually believed this trick was possible? Seriously?
RossSimsProductions 2 months ago
@VoxMot if you were to cause a (however minute) vacuum within the cup, the water could easily spin with the cup (again, surface tension). I am not claiming whether or not this trick does work. Just use what your teachers in high school taught you! USE YOUR BWWAAAIIINNNNZZZZ.
caswellrienzo 2 months ago
I AM DISAPPOINT. All the preceding comments fail to examine a connection between centriputal force and surface tension. Not to mention the water is spinning (think inertia). Without actually trying it, you'll never see the answer.
caswellrienzo 2 months ago
very simple
1. take glass cup and put it in freezer for about an hour
2. take cup fill it with water put it back in freezer ..
3. wait 30 min check if its frozen if not check back every 10 min
end result the top and sides will be frozen but middle be water.. not fake .. just little "magic" trick .. just like instant freezing water
anthony00011 3 months ago
lol people are seriously trying this at home wasting fresh water n shit....
STOP ITS FAKE
ap2pat 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i is confused :( is it real or not?
chuchaosa 3 months ago
are you all insane. water can't stay in the form of a glass. it's the laws of nature. it has to be computer imaging. what the hell is body heat going to do? it doesn't have any force with in it, his body heat doesn't have some sort of telekinetic force. think.
TheLiquoriceC 3 months ago
It's his body heat that makes the water spill all over
Xander4Metin 3 months ago
I actually did it.... IT DOES TAKE A WHILE
10RexTheWolf01 3 months ago 3
here's a thought...maybe the water slowed down and stopped spinning...BEFORE HIS FINGER GOT TO IT :OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
bryanx1031 3 months ago
how in the world do u do this it dont work
TheBrisinger108 3 months ago
thats because it was a disturbance
ProBlocks 3 months ago
this other retard on utube did it with ice. lol, this is real water tho right? i guess cuz its spinning.... but just to clarify
violetsings 3 months ago
doubt its real ..... like if you want another video for evidence !!!
lov2draw2death 3 months ago
This trick is real.... The water will eventually collapse on it's own no matter what.
scott71785 3 months ago
Yeah you can tell it's fake because he doesn't actually touch the water. Not like it violates the laws of physics or anything.
VoxMot 3 months ago 76
@VoxMot its real,the spinning motion of the cup makes a whirlpool inside keeping the center of gravity inside the water making it remain shape.
When the spinning stops it will fall or when it is disrupted
laynecaffy 3 months ago
@laynecaffy Just to clarify: it doesn't violate the laws of physics if you make them up as you go. You're obviously just guessing about this so lets see if I can help you in the right direction.
Go get a cup of water, put a small ice cube in the cup. Now turn the cup. You'll notice the ice cube stays where it is for the most part. The spinning motion of the cup doesn't do jack to the water. The rest of what you said is wrong too, I'm just not willing to spend that much time on a troll/moron.
VoxMot 3 months ago
@VoxMot yes i was guessing,doesn't mean you have to be an asshole to everyone who didn't take physics class.
instead of fucking argueing to anyone who thought this was possible try doing something else.
laynecaffy 2 months ago
you just owe me 1:18 seconds of my life
theeps2000 3 months ago
yay lets comment and imagine we know something about chemestry
ffxfriki 4 months ago 19
@ffxfriki what about physics? that is what this video is mostly about. Go easy on the sarcasm when you aren't completely sure what you want to convey...
DrekenShark 4 months ago 53
@DrekenShark His body heat made the water collapse or it just doesn't last very long. We will wait and see when mythbusters test it.
Fuukx 3 months ago
@DrekenShark This has a lot to do with surface tension but that can also be described by chemistry and how on the surface the bonds between water molecules are stronger than in the center.
TheZohaun 2 months ago
@DrekenShark You're an idiot. He doesn't have to touch it, it was suspended because of the spinning motion of the water. So, the water stops spinning and is no longer suspended.
holt91122 1 month ago
@DrekenShark actually u fucking moron in chemistry you learn that liquid takes the shape of its container thus proving this is imposible on account of the fact that the liquid basically has no container unless you count the room ,but theres really not that much water so you get what i mean and also proving you dont know what the word convey mean :D
erik4307 6 days ago
@ffxfriki *chemistry
skillzdatkillz900 3 months ago
@ffxfriki how about we comment and imagine we know something about spelling?
PopeRellik 3 months ago
@ffxfriki yay lets pretend like we know something about what we cant even spell.
C H E M I S T R Y dip shit.......go read a book.
njim891 2 months ago
@ffxfriki yay lets comment and imagine we know how to spell chemistry
gregblunier 2 months ago 2
my unkel did it -_-
zachredka 4 months ago
Who... who was duped?
tready124 4 months ago
It worked for me... just jelly cause you cant figure out how to do it, and I am not sharing the secret. I am just gonna keep using it to win bets at bars and bag chicks, ( they love this shit!)
caatabatic 4 months ago
Honestly, who HASN'T worked it out? Yes, it's a neat effect that is all but obviously fake and requires one viewing to work out. You mean there are people that were ""actually"" tricked by it? LMFAO :D:D:D
krizan1 4 months ago
Hey, everyone... of course its fake! Whoever thinks its not, just think about gravity. And i could do that speacial effect in my sleep
dubjy7 4 months ago
@dubjy7 No its called surface tension look it up ;D
BottomsUp999 4 months ago
@BottomsUp999 uhh no its actually gravity, if there was no gravity that would be possible... duhh
dubjy7 4 months ago
@dubjy7 you obviously not take biology yet
BottomsUp999 4 months ago
me and my friend tried for about 2 hours...thank you for telling us it is fake...
xxxCrazyBannanaZxxx 4 months ago
Dumb ass his finger did nt even touch the water and dude do u think water can stay that way for ever???
jezebelquek 4 months ago
i still remember it (just a minute ago)
spores90 4 months ago
154 people tried thisXD LIKE???:D
RestlessSparkz 4 months ago
all this is real the reason it collapsed is coz the kids finger created air and the air hit the water!!
Daham619 4 months ago
It is not only water, it is frozen at the outside, a thin layer of ice broke after touching it
kitchenfromhell 4 months ago
Comment removed
kitchenfromhell 4 months ago
Ice !!!!!!!
Nampu1930 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If you weren't grinning at the thought of the dullards who were going to attempt this "amazing trick" then you should probably be wearing a helmet. But congratulations on "figuring it out"
r0b135 4 months ago
i think its a fake
thumbs up if you argree
thumbs down if you disagree
miafisher01 5 months ago
umm he disrupted the wind gathered around it slowing down the speed of the water hereby causeing the water to collaps
katanaxitachi 5 months ago
how come it sounded like ice when it fell?
ghostlyBoots 5 months ago
YOU THINK THAT SOMEONE WHO CAN MAKE THIS WITH SPECIAL EFFECTS DID NOT THINK ABOUT MAKING IT LOOK LIKE HIS FINGER REALLY TOUCHED THE WATER!?!?!?!?!??! !! ?!?!
I HATE MANKIND
7ebuss 5 months ago
realflow realflow, ...and, realflow
owenkilleen 5 months ago
I will bet my tits the guy who made this video is American.
AuGwaRRaRawprrp water water and stuff
I7ARR3N 5 months ago
Da water had to break at sum point dERRrRRr ya DERP
viennasausagelova 5 months ago
Wouldn't the spin you put on the glass perpetuate the waters need to escape the shape of the glass? Like the spin cycle in the washer?? Just sayin??
rakanajo 5 months ago
dude,he used his soundwave trick from one of his other video to disturb the water flow.i think it's when you move your fingers in a specific order/manner it throw a soundwave blast,a bit like a kamehameha
malfurio 5 months ago
dude his body heat disturbed the water and it collapsed...dumb ass
haybaybayily 5 months ago 47
@haybaybayily hahahahhahahahhahahahahhahahahah not remotely close
MrJamesthe4th 3 months ago
@haybaybayily lol so you think that it's possible? Good luck ;) bet you can't do it huh?
TheBeBeCaCa 3 months ago
ok ill defend this, you dont have to touch it, rotation will rapidly fall in liquids making the gyroscopic stability 0, making the water fall,
i am still not convinced if this is trick is plausible, im just telling that it is not necesary to touch it in order for it to fall down on it's own.
filipposan87 5 months ago
you are all morons. As if the water would stand like that forever if you wouldn't touch it.
7ebuss 5 months ago
that is impossible
liquid has no definite shape
tonxiot 5 months ago
It IS posiable! I tried that!!!
gimnasticgirl11 6 months ago
VFX Realflow + 3D camera tracking/ Boujou + material/light setup + render = Water Trick
alldin 6 months ago
Thank u I was about 2 try this lol
ajwiggins01 6 months ago
You are soooo dumb for taking the time to make this video... He doesnt have to touch the water to make it fall.. It falls because there wasn't enough speed in the water rotation.
TheKiidwatson 6 months ago
haha.. no shit Sherlock.. When you say "duped us all".. I think you speak for yourself.. lol.
brawnbear 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
U must have a lot of time on ur hands.
peaceloveandwwe1 6 months ago
Why don't you just tell me there is no Santa Clause while your at it or there is no gold at the end of a rainbow. Which by the way I will get. You just don't have the necessary muscle co-ordination to get the required 21.763 mph counter clockwise spin in a 32 degree left right south north motion. You sir are a failure. Oh and you have to do it on your computer for best results.
patrick258181 6 months ago
i think it's a fake. if the water is spinning, wouldn't the water will be pushed aside because of centrifugal force?
syahirSQRT2 6 months ago
It doesn't mean anything ... its called surface tension. Look it up
69lemoncake 6 months ago
Erm, nothing spins or stays suspended forever. I'm pretty sure it just stopped spinning enough to hold itself together before he got the chance to break it. If it's true.
JarSqwuid 6 months ago
@JarSqwuid you're fucking retarded, nothing as a liquid can keep its form without a container even if it spinning at a batrillion miles per hour................. balls.
DenizB112 6 months ago
@DenizB112 You're fucking retarded. See /watch?v=vCeAfKCC2ng
Not even spinning.
JarSqwuid 4 months ago
@JarSqwuid i could honestly care less, i saw someone say something about the water spinning so i threw it in there
DenizB112 4 months ago
Hello, I dont really know if the trick is real, and I also dont know if what im about to tell you is the real reason but, the bonds in water got an electric nature and you can break it without touching them directly. Sory my bad english, thats the reason cause i can´t explain my self correctly
Solerxxx 6 months ago
i dont care if its fake it looks cool :)
MrDeuceBunny 6 months ago
is this fake?
Enterta1nmentVideos 6 months ago
your retarded it collapsed cause the water stopped spinning
GrassCityGaming 6 months ago 51
@GrassCityGaming its fake u little bitch
TurkishHegemony 6 months ago
@GrassCityGaming LMAO, how old are you? 2 or you never went to school, so you are the retard LOL
Simpliey 6 months ago
@Simpliey I can't understand your sentence. I'd suggest going to school, you might learn sentence flow and grammar.
BraidenFerguson 6 months ago
@BraidenFerguson Coming from a guy who thinks liquid can stay in a particular shape with out a container, real smart :)
Simpliey 6 months ago
@Simpliey Hurrrrdurrrrrr oh I so sorry. I no mean to offend. I bow down. Oh wait, I never did mention anything about me believing the video now did I? Hmm. Please don't embarrass yourself by putting words into people's mouths just so you can fortify your own point. I mean you watched this video, which of course means, you're saying you believe it too. So yeah, see how your logic works? It doesn't. Derp
BraidenFerguson 6 months ago
@BraidenFerguson Never put words in anyone's mouth, and your the one who's embarrassing your self by trying to act like a intelligent human being, after what you said above. Which in my perspective, your not... lol and I'd suggest you stop putting large and meaning less words into your sentence because it just makes you look like a total.. erm... Douche-bag?
Simpliey 6 months ago
@Simpliey The only word I used that could possibly be considered large was "fortify," which is sad since it isn't large at all. Right now you're just continuing this argument because you're doing you're best to stray from the point which you obviously realized you were wrong in. and for the record:
you're* yourself* an* (no comma)* (comma after which)* you're* meaningless*
Seeing as you were attempting to look and sound smart, I figure I'd help you fix mechanical errors you constantly make.
BraidenFerguson 6 months ago
@BraidenFerguson I'd knew you say that.
Simpliey 6 months ago
@Simpliey I bet you did. And I was fairly certain you would say something like that as well, since you refuse to stay on topics that you can't back up.
BraidenFerguson 6 months ago
@BraidenFerguson Yup, because I said what I said to this guy: GrassCityGaming and you're obviously not him... I don't even know why I was arguing with you :/
Simpliey 6 months ago
@Simpliey I jut thought it wrong for you to make horrible judgements upon people for giving their opinion on something about how they thought it worked.
BraidenFerguson 6 months ago
@BraidenFerguson I think I misjudged you, you seem like a cool guy and totally not a penis :) and for that guy. Sometimes it's good to be harsh; when their about the make a similar comments they can re-consider what their typing, also I'm not taking 'away' their right to say what's on their mind I'm just.. can't find the right word to describe it .. :(
Simpliey 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Simpliey And for the record, yes you did put words in my mouth. Quote unquote "Coming from a guy who thinks liquid can stay in a particular shape with out a container, real smart :)"
Please show me where I said this.
BraidenFerguson 6 months ago
@GrassCityGaming You sound retarded for actually agruing the legitimacy of such an obviously fake video. How the hell would the fact that it's spinning make any difference? Did you forget about gravity or something?
pyro251086 4 months ago 2
@pyro251086 you can defy gravity by spinning, you know.
the reason it's definitely fake is because the water molecules would move outwards as they spin and it wouldn't retain it's glass-shape like that for such a long time for that reason because they are all joined by forces
nishihs 4 months ago
@nishihs I'm aware of the principle of centrifugal force, if anything that would work against what this video is trying to claim to be possible. Since centrifugal force pushes things outwards, not inwards.
pyro251086 4 months ago
@GrassCityGaming when some thing spins. centripetal forces makes things go away from the center. NOT into it or stay in place, genius
casketgrind 3 months ago
@casketgrind oh well, genius, centripetal makes things go TOWARDS the center. centrifugal means center-fleeing and describes when things are being pushed AWAY from the center. however, it is not a real force.
simple physics, my friend.
next time get your facts straight before you try to make someone else sound like an idiot because you just did it to yourself.
rickrollerify 3 months ago
@rickrollerify Nonsense, centrifugal force exists for observers in a rotating frame of reference.
AnarchisticLeper 3 months ago
@AnarchisticLeper and we can assume his spin is strong enough to generate centrifugal force strong enough for the water to maintain it's shape, also completely ignoring the water flow and gravity. I also have superman's hands. another obvious problem here is how he lifted the cup off without a single drop escaping. the air pressure alone would gush into the cup and generate push onto the water, thus disturbing whatever superstrong centrifugal force you have going and causing a mini typhoon.
Melablood 3 months ago
@Melablood I wasn't supporting the trick, merely pointing out that it's fallacious to claim that centrifugal force doesn't exist.
AnarchisticLeper 3 months ago
@AnarchisticLeper actually it depends on how you look at it.
Melablood 2 months ago
just..... lol
Blitzwolf44 6 months ago
no I actually did it if you boil it and then put salt in it along with some certain household detergents you can increase the surace tension!
NaacnudsProductions 6 months ago
dude your so stupid is that wat people like u do just going around looking at videos and trying to prove them wrong
freerunning346 6 months ago
Dammit!
TheAlebandro 6 months ago
i still think it is true. but he has a point :P
jose1fastking 7 months ago
i'm pretty sure that water without can't sustain forever so it could've lost it's balance to sustain itself before he even touched it...
TheRockinbeast 7 months ago
Right that is a very good point but
Bobdedu 7 months ago
Actually it is quite possible... He left out the part where you freeze the cup of water just so to where the outer is frozen and not one inner... Duhhh :)))
lyhong210 7 months ago
The hand is not required to make direct contact. If you put a drop of water on a table and slowly move your finger towards it, you will find that once you get too close, the water will touch your finger before you reach the drop. This is due to the gravitational pull between the two. In this particular video, the hand moves too close to the water and disturbs the surface tension of the water and causes it to collapse. Maybe you should know what you're talking about before you make assumptions.
pggraphite 7 months ago 2
@pggraphite Are you fucking stupid! , its impossible
elliot14 6 months ago
fuck all that damn water i wasted
MrMinibike2 7 months ago
lool its not camera effects its just plastic
tiagoalexandreribeir 7 months ago
He didn't have to touch it, it's not like if he doesn't touch it the water will keep spinning forever it has to fall at some point, wether it needs help or not.
306mario 7 months ago 2
ok its a fake but its a great video? why people dislike this?
CameraPranks 7 months ago 14
Did u even read the category films and animation it's not real
opplk9 7 months ago
it wasn't because he pretended to touch it, it's because the water stopped spinning, look closer.
TheSilverhedge2010 7 months ago
you guys it water + it is possible you now why the guy is a water bender or god
know wonder it is a water trick or its ice or he just edited it just kidding its real or not
chrisiscool4402 7 months ago
GOOD JOB!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :) good thing i watched this video before i tried it!
Thank u
622Selena 7 months ago
Ummmm..... have you taken a look at the OP's web page? He's a CGI animator. James Cameron did the same thing in The Abyss.
azimuth361 7 months ago
The original video still cracks me up, it's such troll physics. If anything, spinning the water gives it even less of a chance of it being able to do that.
If you were in space, for example, you'd be able to do this no problem (without spinning it). Spin it, though, and this would never happen. =)
KikiTottori 7 months ago
It is IMpossible.
DrekenShark 7 months ago
Are you people that bord with your lives!? How much time have you devoted to this one freaking video!? The word possible means there's a chance of failure....multiple times!...just like your lives...
Kyouryouku00 7 months ago
your 'figure out' is lame and the original joke was genius
air can disturb water's movement, NO NEED TO TOUCH THE WATER ITSELF to make it crash
CentOKIlo 7 months ago
@CentOKIlo That wasn't my point. It is fake. Stop trying to protect the original video when it only ends up making you look bad. To go off of the point you were trying to make... BOTH the water AND air would have to be moving around the water column as shown in the original video; imagine a mini tornado of water and air. That simply wasn't the case as it is IMPOSSIBLE to sustain water in a shape other than it's container (and in this case because the glass was missing... it would collapse.)
DrekenShark 7 months ago
@DrekenShark Try this experiment to further prove what I am getting at. Fill a bowl with water. Slowly move your hand/finger towards the surface of the water. Does it make any movement? No. Why? Because if you move your hand slowly towards the water the air around the surface of the water hasn't been accelerated enough to make an impact on the water. NEXT, repeat the same process but this time move your hand quickly towards the waters surface but then abruptly stop before you touch the H2O
DrekenShark 7 months ago
Respond to this video... Take note of what happens. Did the water move? YES! Why? Because the acceleration of your hand was quick enough to change the speed of the air directly above the water which then in turn made the water move/ripple a bit. You see my point this time?
DrekenShark 7 months ago
I know it's fake when I saw it, but I really want to know how he did the effects.
pchackal 7 months ago
It's actually possible. I saw it at my cousins birthday party. When your hand or anything gets too close, the water will loose its momentum
DougieFwesh 7 months ago
@DougieFwesh Prove it! Come on... show how it is done... like the original video says, "ANYONE CAN DO IT"... so give it a shot. Make a video response showing how you did it yourself and post it by end of day Saturday July 16 or you are a liar just like everyone else who has tried to protect this myth!
DrekenShark 7 months ago
@DrekenShark poeple cant do it cause look at other video. other poeple turn and pull it up side ways not straight up just look at ther videos they will pull it up side was. also if you put your hand near it you will disturb it and it will lose its spin. so i still believe it works. if you put nevgative cooment then keep it to yourself.
belinkster 7 months ago
@belinkster All I am saying is PROVE IT! (Make a video response)
DrekenShark 7 months ago
@DrekenShark well i cant cause my mom will scream at me -.- sad right?
belinkster 7 months ago
@Timotehrey I know XD there's no way in hell it would keep it's shape man unless you use jello all your gonna get is a wet table :P