Evanescence "My Immortal" (Mystary EP Version)

[PinkPenguinPajamas]

Amy's voice gives me goosebumps.... I <3 This band.

[Krillebej]

I think this version of the song is the best, and it is more emotional,. Just wished that the quality of the sound was better.. :)

[pimpkdogg]

:'( this song always makes me cry .......... I lovee this song so mutch tho it makes me think of my ex I hate that I still have feelings for my ex :'( but nobody knows ...... Nobody knows anything about me

[DimaKats2]

So many songs and versions of My Immortal

[JonnyMonsterGaga]

Amo Evanescence!!!

[juneous3]

vid is crap

[evanescenceakii]

grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr oh i am so angry with youtube!! it hasn't left any version of the original my immortal video and the previous version is nowhere! -.- if anyone knows a video which hasn't expired yet and it has the PREVIOUS VERSION , NOT THE NEW ONE please send me its url. vote this comment if u want ALL the evanescence ( but not only evanescence and other songer's/band's) songs back WITH THEIR VIDEOS TOO!!! on 22 of december don't log in ur utube account to make youtube give us the videos!

[adaymac]

@evanescenceakii what are you talking about? what previous version of the video? if you mean the original version of the song, just check it on youtube typing "evanescence my immortal original," someone uploaded that version

[XTV3NOMXT]

This was my moms fav song before she died.

[EvanescenceXKISS]

@XTV3NOMXT I'm so sorry about your mom. You know, I don't have a mom anymore either.

[HidingfromtheDay]

This song breaks my heart into a thousand small pieces ...

[beaniebabe22]

i love this version. she sounds more...idk...just...different. i like that. Evanescence is so wonderful and impowering. These songs have helped me through some really tough times.....ive listened to them since the daredevil album dropped. <3 <3 <3 <3 <3 thank you amy lee and the crew for making music.

[IntheWeepingRain]

Even though this one and the original version sound similar you'd be able to tell the difference between this one and the original. I <3 them both.

Amy Lee has a brilliant voice and I agree that she definitely adds to the group, but NO ONE is nothing without the singer. Well, most no one. I <3 Evanescence and Amy Lee

[sobretierra21]

whats the name of the cd mystary ep or mystery ep?

[catdemonninja]

mystary.

[hercprsound]

3 09 is like sex without the O

[SarahIsRockin]

Love this version. Amy lee should stay in Evanescence. Without her its just nothing :(

[XEvanescence4EvaX]

They're releasing a new album can't wait!!!! Next year love this song!

[SarahIsRockin]

but their splitting up ? loll ,.

[XEvanescence4EvaX]

go on their official website! lol

[SarahIsRockin]

what is it ?! Their open door website ?

[catdemonninja]

that's good since she isn't leaving...

[Citykitty2000]

Is she seriously leaving? When!?

[SarahIsRockin]

Well i dont know when but theres this newsletter thing saying she wants a solo album and leave the bannddd :(

[Citykitty2000]

:( it's the end of the world as I know it . . .

[SarahIsRockin]

I know !!! She cannot leave , i need her to stay all the Ev. fans will cry and probaly comment suicide !!

[Citykitty2000]

Yeah. :(  Evanescence without Amy is like the night sky without the stars... :(

[SarahIsRockin]

totally .  i love amy and the bandd .

Amy plus band = EVANESCENCE :D

[Citykitty2000]

yep :)

[IMMORTALGIRL4]

Amy plus Ben = Evanescence

[SarahIsRockin]

but without amy..................:(

[IMMORTALGIRL4]

Hmm without amy = good music..ben wrote most of evanescence's good songs and that includes my immortal !

[SarahIsRockin]

wow if ur saying theres no point in amy staying then you should seriously go away cause i love Amy , i dont care if she didnt write the songs she sings them !

[IMMORTALGIRL4]

Ok love her I didnt say there's no point in amy ..ben makes up Evanescence (with) amy''s existence

[SarahIsRockin]

you just said without amy= good music. Which is not true .

[IMMORTALGIRL4]

Yes it is just liswten to the instrumental version of every song that ben has written

[GoldenSun96]

Evanescence isn't good without Amy Lee. Have you seen Ben's new band 'We are the fallen.'

Everyone's been dissing them and telling them that Evanescence is NOTHING without The Voice. Amy Lee!

[catdemonninja]

who do you think wrote the piano?

[IMMORTALGIRL4]

The original version of my immortal was entirely written by Ben Moody but Amy recomposed it

[catdemonninja]

I figured he'd written the piano for the first version, all chords... not Amy's style.

[sTapleEVA]

@IMMORTALGIRL4 but the biggest hit was you know whos. ben wrote two songs.....and yes, i know its been a year

[CaletheGray]

@SarahIsRockin That's not true.

[loveyydoveyy822]

her voice is so so beautiful.

i love amy lee and evanescence

[Jenzke]

this version is not the one from fallen (not even track 12)..

neither is is the track from the album origin...

Where'd you get this???

Could you please please please send it to me???

[margaretandlee]

mystery ep, you have to download it or you could find the rare disk that i have because i am her 1# FAN

[catdemonninja]

It's on Mystary Ep, there wera copies of it sold at Juanita's in 2003 for five dollars. You can download at evanescencerefeence. info/music

[twilightcoffin]

okay i like the song but it actually seems the unoriganal

[No1983rA]

the pic is great, i want it ..

[k19evil1230]

amo esta concion bueno rola

salu2

desde mexico

[avalonw7]

love the pic

[BBBLuvsEvanescence]

I heard a karaoke version of this song

[Dixonoia]

It's definitely not from Fallen :/

[Lovedreamerin]

I Love this song!

[mmmgood111]

this is from fallen

[aimaloo333]

This sounds like the Fallen version.

[poetgirl]

My BF just broke up with me 30 minutes ago... this is my song...

[sk8erelf8]

i like this one waaay better than the one onthe radio and stuff. how do i download it?...so i can like get it on my ipod n stuff

[KapperzSean]

this is her original version.....the other one with the guitars was the producer or whoever was in charge at the time the version with the guitars was their idea

[alex3erynys]

the vocals are different and unaltered on this one too. and not so much attention is payed to the flow. she's just kinda singing.

[hhoitovirhe]

this version is better than the original version. :)

[leachrode]

this was on mystary but was a bonus track on the end of some versions of fallen

[ELECTRiCKiDZ666]

This isnt the EP Version.

The EP Version Is Way Different than this one.

This version is in The Fallen CD.

[manshealth89]

The Mystary EP version is like the band version's demo recording. Amy is playing piano with added strings in the background. It also has some similarities to the Fallen version. Amy also takes short pauses in the chorus. The verses don't have much of a difference to the band version. Like the Fallen version, this version doesn't include the rock part at the end. (source: evanescence reference)

[manuchamp99]

Hang on. I've got Fallen, and there's no rock part at the end of my version of My Immortal.

[leeanne14]

Yeah, it was either the Europian bonus track or the UK bonus track, like i think you would have missing?? I think that's what it is anyway...

[GabbyGasoline]

Theres 2 versions of 'My Immortal' on Fallen. There's track 4, which has no rock part, and theres track 12, which is the the one from the 'My Immortal' video that has the rock part

[meentagranizadaa]

Fallen has 11 tracks...

in some editions, has 12.

[poetgirl]

This is the EP version. Listen to the one on Fallen (Track 4) carefully. The piano at the beginning of that one is different. Also the way she sings "When you cried I'd wipe away all of your tears" is different in this one then the one on Fallen.

[TripleA3]

this is the best version i've ever heard

[AlexAlbor]

tHIS VERSION IS ON THE FALLEN CD?? I DONT HAVE IT....=( I DONT THINK IT IS..

[manshealth89]

This version is on Mystary EP realesed in January 2003

[catdemonninja]

the people saying that are thinking of the band version which has the sae piano, but has rock music towards the end of the song. If you got the re-released fallen you'd have that version as well as the falllen version.

[back2black85]

i have this version on my fallen cd! and its also on the dare devil soundtrack!

[thcalmeida26]

Is 'Mystary EP' or 'Mystery EP'?

[wikipedia103]

It was supposed to be Mystery, but they made a spelling mistake: Mystary.

[xxkewldudexx]

no it was on purpose.

[catdemonninja]

EvRef says amy says it was an intentional mispelling, like my freind's dad's band, payne.

[rainbowskinnyjeans]

I think the violin sounds better than the guitar. It fits this song more.

[xmichelx014]

Hermosa Canción :)

[evanescencelord]

5/5!!Beautiful!!!!!

[cilla310]

This song always puts me to tears, and then I feel like I am going through an emotional breakdown. This song reminds me of my friend going suicidal, me almost dying from a concussion and fever, and getting my heartbroken.

[addictedtobooks]

I am always amazed at how Evanescence's music can evoke such a powerful emotional response from its listeners.

[REALSTRENGTH78]

@addictedtobooks she sings at a frequency that is connected to the frequencies that were used in ancient times that had a healing effect on the body. She is tied to that genetic bloodline somehow.

[addictedtobooks]

@REALSTRENGTH78

No wonder! She is truly powerful. I love it!

[sonicinuyasha528]

I love it ^_^ 5/5 stars

[sonicinuyasha528]

This song is awesome

[Cockatiellover453]

i know and have ALL versions

[leo201083]

i can, but in album "Mystary EP" "Imaginary" is the same like in album "Fallen"

[catdemonninja]

supposedly it has the ending of tournaquet in the ending of it, but I think you have to listen REALLY close.

[H2OJustAddWaterFan20]

@leo201083 And My Last Breath and Everybodys Fool

[catdemonninja]

can you put up imaginary?

[catdemonninja]

It's mystary, they did it on purpose. I love the song, I think I know 6 versions! (I'm including the acoustic) please delet the last one so my brother doesn't find out.

[catdemonninja]

thank you.

[Kukisha]

i know 5 versions xD

[UglyCrazyWorthless]

wow, i know 3 versions now!

[darkempress1066]

This rocks.

[Kukisha]

great song love it more than the rock version!