Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (164)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • ive heard ben with different girls singing this song ive yet to find one i dont like.....they all do an amzing job and plus its amazing to think one song can have so many different sounds.

  • I'm 6,000,000 years old and I think Beau Aurthur sings this much better than Regina or Sarah...and Beiber rocks.

  • @clarkbailey1973 that was sarcasm for those that don't get it....

  • ben > chair

  • better than regina

  • @Stephabelles You are totally right. They are both different so you guys can't compare them and start hating on them. They are both totally AWESOME. How can you like one more than the other? I love you Regina and Sara!!!!

  • she's off key....

  • im still completely baffled by this but some how it seems that Ben Folds is sexy as hell.

  • In the Rehearsal video of Ben and Regina, you would be surprised at how similar Sara and Regina sound. I like the rehearsal much more, because it's got French horns that are abdfkaj

  • not as good as it is with regina spektor but she's awesome.

  • SARA IS THE MOST AMAZING MUSICIAN THE WORLD HAS EVER SEEN AND SHE WILL ONLY CONTINUE TO PROVE IT IN THE YEARS TO COME.

  • When Ben plays the piano, his hands seem to grow extra fingers. It's fascinating; I literally can't watch anything else.

  • @audball911 he's really not that good...

  • @MenAmongPoodles Whether or not he's skilled has nothing to do with my statement. Fast fingers, of course, don't equal good piano playing.

    However, we might have differing opinions as to the quality of the music coming from those fingers, which is fine.

  • @audball911 I love his music. I just don't think he's very technically advanced when it comes to piano playing, which is what i thought you meant.

  • @MenAmongPoodles Oh, no, nothing of that caliber. I was going for "look at da pretty hands sooo fast"

  • @MenAmongPoodles seriously?

  • @troymcklure2002 yeah. that's my opinion.

  • @MenAmongPoodles Have you ever seen/heard him improv?

  • Did anyone else see Napoleon Dynamite playing the drums back there?

  • Sarah has the voice of an Angel.

  • Why does everyone feel the need to be a music critic when they watch these videos? Sara B has an amazing voice. So does Regina. Can't we just leave it at that?

    Unless one of you haters is better of course...

  • Guys. This isn't an audition. He's inviting people to come on stage and sing a duet with him. He's having fun, she's having fun, they're making music, etc. Y'all need to chill.

  • say it

  • I know who Ben Folds reminds me of now. He's like a hipster Bill Gates.

  • @cho4d Or Bill Gates is a non-hipster version of Ben Folds.

  • I don't think its really fair to compare Sara Live with Regina on the Recording. Of course if you have seen both live then I guess thats fair.

  • Who gives a shit? If Ben wants her, he gets her; it's his damn song. The only approval needed is his, not mine or yours.

  • I love Sara a whole lot, and she had the guts to know that she most likely would be compared to Regina's version with Ben, and did it anyway ... and obviously had fun in the process. Nonetheless, NO ONE can compare to Regina. Her innocence and playfulness is so natural, and her New York (Bronx) / Russian Jewish accent is just perfect for this (and frankly whatever she does). Not complaining. Just sayin.

  • i just hope ben folds don't sing the same songs with different people... just to avoid comparison :) i love regina and sara :) a jewish and an american :) haha MAZEL TOV! :D great song though! :D really great song :)

  • how many hipsters were present at this concert?

  • @gatorsrok123 Probably none.

  • @gatorsrok123 Neither of these artists are obscure enough for hipsters. :P

  • Amazing live an I think she fits pretty well but I still like spektor better

  • Sara did an awesome job but i kinda think regina does it better... no offense... sry...

  • sara is so much better live than regina. Regina just does WEIRD things on this song live.

  • two of my favourite singers together:)

  • I'm probably late to the party, but I think that each version I've seen/heard of this song with different voices is fantastic. It's kind of like each person put their own spin on it, which almost made it a different song every time...subtle differences make it a wonderful and universal song that a LOT of people can relate to.

  • I love both versions ... they both have their strengths + this is very good live!

  • You guys are crazy, Sara did this flawlessly.

  • sarah should be in australia the same time as ben in MAY so it would be awesome if this worked out cause she is also a fav of mine.

  • KMH's version is the most unique one i've heard.. its so different and sooo goood!!!

  • I think Kate Miller Heidke is doing a better job than all of em ;)

  • Geez, with all the dissing of Sara by Regina fans I decided to listen to Regina's version, expecting to be totally blown away (I do like Regina) and....NOTHING. Totally underwhelmed. If my eyes were closed I would have thought it was some average amateur. The ends of her phrases just stop--no resonance whatsoever. I realize the song is a spoken/sung hybrid, but still! Sara's is vocally richer.

    Again, no disrespect to Regina, but she hardly 'owns' this song, so get over yourselves Regina fans!

  • @mysticsmb Dissing her just makes you no better than them.

  • @lumrules Point taken. I really do like Regina, I was just surprised after all the ballyhooing that it seemed kinda average--from a strictly musical perspective. But I understand that performers bring all kinds of things to the table, including personality, that can't be objectively measured. So thanks for picking me up on that. No need for Sara and Regina fans to go to war over this one--they're both fab and together swim against the tide of what passes for pop music these days.

  • @mysticsmb I agree 100%. I love Regina, and I mean I really love Regina, but I also think Sara is very good, and part of the beauty of this song is that each time a different girl sings it, it gains a another new dimension. Anyway, this is YouTube, there's never going to be an end to stupidass flame wars.

  • This makes me happy :)

  • She did a good job though. She just sang on her style. I think it 's better to sing on her style instead of copying Regina's style. Be yourself!

  • She did a good job though. She just sang on her style. I think it 's better to sing on her style instead of copying Regina's style. Be yourself!

  • that dress is just not very flattering is it.

  • She did a very good job, I dont think people realise actually how hard this song is to sing.

  • I completely agree with tangyturtletwentytwo

  • she missed a few notes. :|

  • at least she's better than missy higgins...i think she and regina are both great in their own ways. honestly, i don't dislike either one, but i think it would be easier to compare if they were both studio recorded. only thing is i love the way regina says "say it" as opposed to sara.

  • both Sara and Regina are completely amazing in different ways. People should stop complaining and just appreciate these two lovely ladies.

  • this is awesome =] i like her voice.. and his ofcourse

  • this song + sara bareilles = epic. stop bitching about sara's performance.

  • more lively version -- completely different than Regina -- Regina's voice may be more suited for this song but usually like Sara.

  • Oh! I love this. I love Ben, Regina, and Sara.

    Sara does it justice. Love it. Thank you very much.

  • why does everyone have to jump on Sara's performance? Its just a song

  • She has a good voice and I like this version but he should have not switched Regina Spektor for her.

  • Holy smokes.

    Could people stop being such babies? Seriously, she just sings it a different way and people go hectic about it. Sara has a different voice then Regina, a fantastic voice might I add.  Regina's voice is more suited for the song yea, but people don't have to get all defensive.

    Jeesh

  • @Stephabelles Well said. Like the douchebag below you, people don't seem to understand that no one is entitled to one song. Ben Folds can have someone else sing it for a night. And beautifully. No one's ganging up on Regina, threatening her original placement in the song. Sara was there, and they had her sing it. She's an amazingly talented singer, with great presence and great pipes- you'd think people would be happy to see someone like her on stage.

    <3 Go Sara. You rock that song, girl.

  • @whatmusicsfor I'm just glad to see that someone else thinks all these people's comments against Sara are completely off-base and childish.

  • @Stephabelles i thought it was a fantastic rendition.

  • @tommyquality It's weird, when I read your comment I puked a little..

  • Excellent combo ...... think Sara Bareilles has it all going on!

  • Bareilles has sexy biceps ; )

  • I love it when someone in the audience shouts "SAY IT!"

  • wow she isn't trying to be like regina spektor, they are both talented women and I think people should stop bitching about it, it sounds okay to me, she's doing it her way and missy higgens and regina all have their own way of singing this song so stop whining goddamn.

  • does anybody else notice that ben looks like he's floating around 3:10 or so on?

  • I love how he leans into it while he's playing. It's hawt.

    What?...o.o

  • the bridge is soooo beautiful oh my gah

  • she didn't try to make it bedcome her song !

    and you know she has other stile and regina other any way i know you will think i rong but i love sara's more... sara is my idol!!

  • regina spektor is soooooo much more amazing at this it stinks with sara bareilles. i love sara but i love regina soooooooooooo much more.

    GO REGINA SPEKTOR

  • regina is so much better than her. fuck Sara

  • Kate Miller-Heidke Destroyed Regina Spektor Imo when she sang this song. KMH has such an amazing voice with her blend of soft vocals and Opera style

  • every Sara Bareilles performance should be broadcast live.

  • This is Regina Spektor's song and no one can sing it like her:)

    Sara Bareilles is good but doesn't touch Regina Spektor.

  • @icyblueeyesx3 Soooo truee.

  • @icyblueeyesx3

    I believe its "Ben Folds FEATURING Regina Spector...NOT the other way around...

  • @HLGGanoth

    Well obviously. When I said it's Regina Spektor's song, I meant that no one can sing the part better than her because she's on such a different level than Sara Bareilles, Missy Higgins, or anyone else that has attempted to sing it.

  • @icyblueeyesx3 This is ben folds song..

  • @lufc550 Well obviously, but we were discussing which GIRL sings it best.

  • @icyblueeyesx3 I was just wondering if you didn't know it was ben folds song, wrong end of the stick.

  • Love both these artists so thrilled to see them playing together!!

  • Sara is one of my favorite singers :) she did it justice and even better than Regina. This song is great!

  • Regina does it much better. She also has better chemistry with Ben.

  • i'm not trying to call you out, but just in general because it's weird so many people have been saying the same thing on this video. sara isn't trying to be regina. my guess is she was just in LA while ben folds was there, she came on stage, he let her sing and this was the part she sang. it was awesome to have her there as a surprise guest, the crowd loved it even if she's not regina. she was just having fun.

  • and anyway i think sara did an excellent job. although of course i love regina too.

  • @sendalittlerain agrees....i think its unfair to bring in regina in this at all. Or else anyone could easily make a statement of Tori is 100000x better than Regina as well... i think its unfair, they r not copying, they r just role models for modern feminine pop/rock n each carries their own impact and inspires ppl differently.....

  • @xxxruzzelxxx chill out, sara is a great talent. she and regina have two very different styles of music, i thought it was great

  • i know she's great, its just that Regina is excellent

    :)

  • @xxxruzzelxxx agreed (: there is a regina song for every mood you're in.

  • @xxxruzzelxxx

    Dude, get over it...

  • I'm over it and sorry for being honest

  • Regina Spektor has a very unique style of singing so replacing her is quite impossible. Nevertheless, I think Sara Bareilles is a very talented singer and does a good job by doing her own thing here instead of trying to copy Regina.

  • i loke regina more

  • sara beirelles isn't that attractive to me, she always appears so slobby on stage, maybe that's ok, though, she's comfortable in her own skin

  • Love Sara B, but that part was written for Regina and it is only Regina who does it justice.

  • agreed. it's probably because the song itself is more of a regina style than a ben style.

  • I think the song is definitely a "Ben-style" song almost a "Zak and Sara" a few years later. Other than "Samson" and maybe "Summer in the City," Regina does not generally go for dissecting relationships in song. (Even "Folding Chair" and "Fidelity" are less direct than Ben usually is, as he is in this song.)

    I find both Ben and Regina to be indispensable but in different ways. Having them together was---I knew this even before I heard the song--- as great as it can get.

  • well the song definitely has elements taken from both of their styles, but i meant that the musical style was more like regina. i wasn't really referring to the lyrics, but you're right there.

    and i definitely love the song, but i was hoping there would have been a more prominent piano part, considering it was merging two phenomenal pianists. oh well, it's catchy and bouncy anyway :P

  • Oh, I agree with that last part. Regina has no piano part in that song. I would love to hear Ben and Reg both at the keyboard (not the same one) in one song.

    K Ishibashi, Regina's violinist and the lead guitar in the band Jupiter One reported from Regina's European tour that he played "lounge piano" with Reg on one song in Oslo He says he is one of the three who have ever played piano for Regina in public and that, of course, Ben is another.

  • I definitely prefer Regina Spektor. Sorry Sara..

  • Is she touring with him this year?

  • most adorable man alive.

  • sara is the bestest

  • My ranking:

    1st - Regina

    2nd - Sara

    3rd - Missy

    :)

  • agreed. Love you, missy, but the songs doesn't quite fit you dear.

  • same here (:

  • Hey! You're the guy who uploads regina's videos!

    You're the best, man. Keep on uploading her vids.

  • @richardpaulgriffin "This channel is no longer available because the user closed their account." Sad.

  • i love this! it's my favorite song by Ben folds, he's amazing live!! i wish i could write songs like this.

  • better then missy but not as good as regina

  • This makes me chuckle. It seems like Sara B and Ben Folds have a pretty similar range, whereas Regina Spektor sings quite a bit higher.

  • mmm...its good but saras voice doesnt compare to reginas

  • totally true,

    at least her voice when singing live doesn't

  • AGREED.

  • best video of this song i've ever seen

  • why thank you

  • I like this but I would love to find a live version of him and regina doing this =)

  • Sara's voice is so wonderful for this song! I love it!

  • i love this song!! waahh!! especially now that sara sang it..

  • ah, i was there. it was great... (: i would reccomend a ben folds live concert to anyone, hah

  • Mike, just...

    Leave me alone.

    If you aren't going to face me and talk to me, just get out of my life.

  • i love sara.

  • love the song... w/ both regina and sara!!!

  • it wasn't horrible but regina is so much more lovely with this song

  • agreed

  • I don't understand how this comment has 6 thumbs down, I agree completely.

  • i love regina, so im biased. but i love sara as well. she just doesnt know how to be simple in her voice like regina. but i love them both for different reasons. and ben folds is beyond fantastic.

  • The perfect combination is Regina + Ben, that is why those two are in the official live recording... but, Sara is alright. I really can't stand Missy Higgins doing this though- have you seen that?

  • Yeah. Sara's a little flat

  • you are right. I fucking hate how youtube has turned into this place where if you have an opinion you get 6 thumbs down

  • Comment removed

  • I find it an honor for 6 people to even give a damn about my opinion. liked or disliked.

  • I gave you a thumbs up because I think getting 6 thumbs down is ridic. I don't know if she's flat, I think it might be that their vocal styles aren't fit for each other, if that makes sense.

  • thank you!

  • She almost has TOO much voice for this song, her voice is so big and lovely. <3

    It's weird, Regina, Ben Folds, and her are my three favorite artists. My worlds. They're colliding. xD

  • I know... they're so great... can you imagine the 3 together!!!

  • omg aw man i wish they did this when they both performed at MIT and i was there!!! fantastic!

  • sooo coool!

  • They're both adorable.

  • so awesome.... doesn't matter if it's regina spektor or sara bareilles, this song is still so good!

  • luv it!! <3

  • AHHH there is so much awesome on that one stage. i don't even know if i can handle it!

  • Amazing !! i lov this song with Sara ... !!!

  • Two of my favorite piano player/singers ever. I wish I was there for this soooo bad.

  • Jared must have been jealous, I bet he loves taking the place of Regina in concert lol.

  • Did you know that Sara saw your video ? Haha ^^ She put it on her facebook/myspace !! =) It's awesome. Amazing performance !

  • haha holy shit that's so cool i just went and saw it!

  • I love Sara! BUT this is definitely not the song for her. Regina is much better at this one.

  • oh come on, ENJOY what we have... Sara always sweet :)

  • omg!!! i'm soooo jealous!! was sara there by surprise?!

  • sweeeeeeeeeeet!!!! I had the chance to see him live and I totally missed it! AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHH!!

    How many times do you think he'll visit Maine? Probably NEVER again grrrr!!!!

  • Thanks a lot! Great to see Sara there.

  • That was an awesome show wasn't it!? I was just to the left of you, and I think I remember seeing your camera too. =)

  • haha yeah it was a great show and that's funny you were to my left

  • I loooove it ! Thanks !

  • they were great

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more