I seriously think why Karisma didn't win an other National award. She deserved atleast an other National award for '' Fiza'' or ''Zubeida''. She was exceptional.. National awards commitee once again proved that they dont recognise true talent. Why the hell priyanka was given National award for ''Fashion''? I just wonder.. even though she did work hard but her performance was not worth a National award. Even Rani mukherj's performance in ''Black'' was ignored at National awards..Crap just crap.
karishma is very good actress compare to others...u can feel her emotion and is real.she can make u entertain,cry,revengful etc.she's versatile....n she can cry very well in other movies she cry too but not the same as this which means u can see her different every movies u cant even recognise her.As kareena she has d same scene in every movies expresion never change boring
kajol and kareena both doesn't even come close to karisma.. They are just over-rated actors.. Kajol has never experimented with roles, she only did commercial films while kareena had a bad taste of films but she experimented a lot compared to karisma and kajol but kareena should learn something from her sister when it comes to accepting films and selecting roles.. I wonder why kareena keeps rejecting challenging roles like page 3, fashion,kal ho na ho.. Lets see if she accepts '' HEROINE ''
@kaminoneh Really? I want to know if you cry over your dear mother who has died tragically. Before Fiza burst into tears & scream, she has resisted all sorrow & tenderness with a very calm and controlled. Look at this scene CAREFULLY.
In this movie, Fiza and her family are portrayed as Shias, but it doesn't matter because Pashtuns usually wear white as funerals, not black to symbolize the the soul is pure and peaceful.
@mai5oul you are absolutely right..kajol in the same scene not effective at all..karisma was so heart touching and one can see her heart boiling...Media has always underrated her as an actress. she was great in shakthi too
Sarika was given National award in 2005 where we saw Outstanding performance by Rani in ''Black''. she deserved it..
nitinme88 1 month ago
I seriously think why Karisma didn't win an other National award. She deserved atleast an other National award for '' Fiza'' or ''Zubeida''. She was exceptional.. National awards commitee once again proved that they dont recognise true talent. Why the hell priyanka was given National award for ''Fashion''? I just wonder.. even though she did work hard but her performance was not worth a National award. Even Rani mukherj's performance in ''Black'' was ignored at National awards..Crap just crap.
nitinme88 1 month ago
karishma is very good actress compare to others...u can feel her emotion and is real.she can make u entertain,cry,revengful etc.she's versatile....n she can cry very well in other movies she cry too but not the same as this which means u can see her different every movies u cant even recognise her.As kareena she has d same scene in every movies expresion never change boring
khairul19841 5 months ago
kajol and kareena both doesn't even come close to karisma.. They are just over-rated actors.. Kajol has never experimented with roles, she only did commercial films while kareena had a bad taste of films but she experimented a lot compared to karisma and kajol but kareena should learn something from her sister when it comes to accepting films and selecting roles.. I wonder why kareena keeps rejecting challenging roles like page 3, fashion,kal ho na ho.. Lets see if she accepts '' HEROINE ''
nitinme88 7 months ago 3
really done fantastic JOB .......real and touching
karismalove 8 months ago
i loved this scene
btramimalekflover 9 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the scene was over dramatic.
Going from no emotions to screaming on the top of your lounges in a span of 3 seconds in unrealistic (unless you're a mental case.)
The emotional transitions should have been a lot more suttle.
kaminoneh 1 year ago
@kaminoneh Really? I want to know if you cry over your dear mother who has died tragically. Before Fiza burst into tears & scream, she has resisted all sorrow & tenderness with a very calm and controlled. Look at this scene CAREFULLY.
bilbinna 1 year ago 9
@bilbinna all i can say she must be a kareena fan...who can't act
VarunMehtasWorld 11 months ago
In this movie, Fiza and her family are portrayed as Shias, but it doesn't matter because Pashtuns usually wear white as funerals, not black to symbolize the the soul is pure and peaceful.
xsarahz 1 year ago
kareena isnt as good as karisma
and doesnt pick good movies either
prasad604 1 year ago
Shocked and Amazed at how will Karishma did in this scene... Cry every time I see it Oscar for sure:)
sukhster09 1 year ago 2
speechless, awed ans completely spellbound. karishma must come back. her sister is extremely disappointing and nowhere close to her
sabbirsa 1 year ago 2
she deserved an oscar. only a real daughter could cry like that with so much pain and anger.
xsarahz 1 year ago 5
why is she actually crying? did hritik die? :S
Niiki91 1 year ago
kajol scene in my name is khan copied this when she cried in front of her dead son. but kajol failed... just failed!
mai5oul 1 year ago 17
@mai5oul you are absolutely right..kajol in the same scene not effective at all..karisma was so heart touching and one can see her heart boiling...Media has always underrated her as an actress. she was great in shakthi too
youxyz 1 year ago 5
kajol scene in my name is khan copied this when she cried in front of her dead son. but kajol failed... just failed!
mai5oul 1 year ago
Most powerful scene ever. She deserved an Oscar for this one scene alone. SUPERB.
Misteron20 2 years ago 23