This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I think Manson looks a little bit Hitler 'cause of his short hairtstyle. :D But his voice sounds horrible in this. (my opinion) And Girger is like a little boy with his first drums or something. :D
get off Gingers case, look up his medical records and you will know why he isnt that good at the drums like he once was. He said it hurts everytime he plays, and sometimes it goes numb and wont move.
As much as I hate to admit it it's all about style. I'm a huge Skold fan, so I think the stuff he did with manson was amazing, but twiggy was a huge part in the past as well, and wrote a lot of amazing songs, so neither can be denied. Either way Manson has a talent of finding great musicians to take advantage of... I hope Skold goes back to doing solo shit...
I agree on you that the lyrics are great. But you should acknowledge that twiggy wrote most of the music for the three album epopee. Starting with AS to HW. In my opinion that is the period that defines MM as band. And besides Twiggy is back on the new album (working title)
First of all. He isn't a goth. he is a Glam/shock rocker.
Second of all. wether or not he is good live depends on who you are. some people don't like how his voice is when he sings live, other loves it. depends on who you are.
well all i wanted was an opinion but what i got from you was that opinions will differ and didn't give me your opnion therefore leaving me without an answer moron.
and as for the goth king comment.
dont you think that the (I dont like using this word) majority of Goths will listen to marilyn and look up to him. therefore i think that he would be given the FITTING title of goth king wouldn't you agree?
well most of the goths i know don't see Manson as a goth and because of that they don't look up to him as a goth king. actually i only know about 2 goths that listen to the music of the band Marilyn Manson.
Maybe where you come from goths listen to Marilyn Manson. I don't know.
but if you want an answer for your first question then yes i belieave that Marilyn Manson is great when performing live.
look good and play loud doesnt make u a good bassist...listen to the bass line in irresponsable hate anthem, and tell me if twiggy isnt a great bass player...
i said not to mention his looks were better than twiggys. twiggy just straight out sucked, i dont care how close manson and twiggy were, that doesnt mean twiggy was better.
Twiggy fucking wrote almost every song on ACS, MA, and Holy wood. you cant say that twiggy sucks cuz that would be saying almost every MM song sucks. so, fuck off Twiggy.
exactly!! twiggy is the brain and soul of the band, manson is just a good liryc writer and a great performer, but what twiggy did with the music, is way better than what tim did...so, twiggy is better than tim! =P.
thank you! most of these people who are fighting over whos the better bassist are probably like 20 years old. im 13 and i get it. im not saying that tim is a bad musician because hes not, but tim has nothing on twiggy.
Once again it comes down to preference. Skold has been playing bass since the mid eighties atleast... Not sure about Twiggy. Skold's songwriting I think is extremley strong though, as I prefer a much more industrial sound, such as songs from GAOG.
You idiot, who are complaining about his voice, ever thought that it could be the equipment that did not work well during the show? Just think......a little please...??? Do world a favor____think.
I like his music, and his movies, etc.. But I hate it when people defend him like he's a god or something. Blame it on the equipment, blablablabla.. You can hear his voice was not at the top with this show, and its not because of the equipment. Listen to it agian and I think you'll realize that. But thats because he damaged his voice with this tour.. If you're going to defend him, base your arguments on facts, not what "you think". He's not a god, he's a good musician.
I like your passion and the mission you have to change people through Youtube comments. Lol you're relatives must be Christians who try to convert people on Youtube and forums.
But to show how ignorant you are of the video you ,hopefully you watched, have you seen other performances from this concert? If you have a few brain cells you will notice that his mic was off the whole appearance and the guitars were much louder. And with your "logic" you're almost saying Manson sucked here because he can't naturally scream louder then than the instruments. T%his is also something else he might've tried to do, because instruments were too loud so he wanted to scream louder.
Can you show me those other videos? All I'm sure of is that it wasnt the instruments, because in that case, they woulld most likely do something about it. And also, in the end of the movie, fans are screaming, all of them- the volume is in no comparison to mansons volume. Also, if it was the mic, why did he still have it in his hand? He could have thrown it away to impress fans... And in the case that the instruments were loud and he tried to scream louder, it really was his voice..
LOL they are to you're right in related videos section. Check out the (s)aint video from the same concert. Not all technical problems with equipment can be fixed. You need to see plenty of bands live. As well as the stage is being set up and evrything taking back apart and how much of a hell it can be. It's not as easy as switching the mic or adjusting the volume. Technicians mess up too, cables break, wireless doesn't work, too many bands are at the fest. too much ehll in other words.
Therefore it caused him not to sound top notch. Well i hope it brings clarity to you of what i said and i wish you all the best with your mission, maybe a career, in trying to change people's minds via internet.
Also, I don't have a mission? Why do you always bring up subjects that aren't related at all? Really, because if you're going after personal attacks, you're aiming fucking low.
very good song and the piano very well and gitarra leaves me with open mouth and a good beat that drummer
miespho 2 weeks ago
I love Manson, an i do enjoy him live.. seen him every time since 1999 but he sounds like horse shit here.
XxComablackxX1937 6 months ago
i think he was losing his voice.
childrenofthecorn666 7 months ago
many pepole think i am crazy just because i like Marilyn, but i dont see the problem, he is fucking amazing!! <33
MM 4ever<33
katzy98 7 months ago
great best bettrer song!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
qwq1991 8 months ago
best song ever !
crossfirehackerbest1 8 months ago
I Like This Song <3
rachid007Law 9 months ago
9 people uses there mouth and not there fist
TheStingerxxx 9 months ago
Comment removed
MrZhIkes 9 months ago
I have some of this concert on vcr... however i must have missed THIS SONG! F*CK!
bidefordrfc 10 months ago
Skold and john 5 are awesome!!!
RockDrumWorld 10 months ago 2
Marilyn Manson is kewl
xMcGlockin 10 months ago
His voice gets hard to hear at some points. Completely understandable.
TheAceman901 11 months ago
I am here everyday...
kinsag 1 year ago
best of luck ginger fish :) we'll miss you
SatanasAngel 1 year ago
Rock am Ring 2003 yeaaaaaa
luigicuau22 1 year ago
omg i wanne be there
hellokittylove890 1 year ago
cool
Vladimir368813 1 year ago
The Instrumental sound is incredible...
kinsag 1 year ago
i really love manson, but he's not that good live..:/
andrew19891019 1 year ago
@andrew19891019 have you watched them live??? I've seen them twice and one of them is the best i have EVER seen
evryk21 1 year ago
@evryk21 well I've never been on a Manson concert.. So I only 'judge' by the vids I'm watching on youtube, you're right..
andrew19891019 1 year ago
JOHN 5 = GUITAR GOD
rockhurstalum09 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
8 jonas brothers fans
xXfrankillXx 1 year ago
Skold barely got any camera time :(
Marcoticka 1 year ago
Great
Zic577 1 year ago
i dont really like his style in that era of manson
TheComaDay 1 year ago
love his hair on this tour :)
chevz92 1 year ago
nice song from the prince of darkness :)
Rudidennis123 1 year ago
I love this song in this very old game...i think it was Spawn
TonyLongEpix 1 year ago
@TonyLongEpix it is spawn (spawn armageddon) the most kick-ass character ever.
sweettooth395 1 year ago
1:33 i love how the guy hit the cymbals. BAM!
mogi32688 1 year ago
Fuck Twiggy, Tim and John were Manson's best string techs. Why couldn't Tim at least stay in the band?
MISANTHROPY647 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wtf... i like this song at official version but manson live is SHIT....
i dont like this shit at all....
really really bad..-1 by me...
Maestr00o 1 year ago
Rock Am Ring. Kick ass.
thegrotesksuperstar 1 year ago 2
FUCKIN AMAZING! JOHN5 AND TIM SKOLD ROCK!
shadowspast1 1 year ago 2
@shadowspast1 OMG THAT JOHN 5 OMFG OMFG I LOVE JOHN FIVE!!!!!
sweettooth395 1 year ago
wow.. he sounds like shit live... his voice sounds like a 80 year old woman
11tstaib 1 year ago
MARILYN MANSON AND JOHN 5 KICKS ASS!!! I LOVE YOU GUYS! FUCKING ROCKS \m/!!!
leichivanhell 2 years ago 2
they need to turn his mic up..... John 5 is a bad ass
firebirdzcb 2 years ago 2
Rock Am Ring
Lto1234 2 years ago 2
where was this at? ozzfest maybe?
moshpittttt 2 years ago
nooo. rock am ring
NovacCky 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
They should play this song right now. Twiggy!!!! Practice this song for me now!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
hitterbrehm 2 years ago
perfect !!!!!!!!!!!
JakubBarttys 2 years ago 5
i like mm so much!!
MrDragonface666 2 years ago 5
great song!
the guitar and the bass are so powerfull!!!
ShootMySelfToLoveYou 2 years ago 47
OMG... people who went to this concert are soo lucky.. i fookin lurrvvv this song!!!
MarilynMansonfan1011 2 years ago 55
This is why he has been my favorite artist since the 6th grade.
xlTruthBeTold 2 years ago 17
what grade are you in now cause i have too XD
gillysuitman9 2 years ago 3
sopho
xlTruthBeTold 2 years ago 5
very good fuckin' song!!!!!!!!
Raznatovic88 2 years ago 11
i luv john and marilyn
CUTEYfreak 2 years ago 5
if the sound would be good, this would be the best video from that concert.
Gregoses 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
so will ich manson wieder haben..das ist noch der der einzig wahre..nicht so wie heute..mit augenbrauen..hallo!?!?!?!?!?
MrManson120881 2 years ago
SONG KICKS FREAKING ASS !
KaiserVadin 2 years ago 9
\,,\ one of my fav manson song /,,/
this guy knows how to rock :)
The golden age of grotesque is one of gods (or maybe satans) gifts to music...and it will be worshipped...
shame hes fat nd stoned now :(
superaven1 2 years ago 10
my favorite
snowdragon6 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
i freaking hate this damn clown he sucks balls at singing
The1bengalsfan 2 years ago
to whitefox60, he never tried to be 'pretty' to look at so whats ur point?
jakethehen08 2 years ago
Comment removed
hunk867 2 years ago
damn awsoemm usic i want that giutar :P !!!!
markevilyn 2 years ago 3
That is the greatest keyboard stand I've ever seen!
mindstormsabrewin 2 years ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
LOL LOSER
rockstar123qweasdzxc 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
his music is aweomse but he his ugly as fuck in ths video
whitefox60 2 years ago
he's sooooo cool. ^ ^
Eliiwa 2 years ago 3
good song
snowdragon6 2 years ago 2
its good people are in to tis shit
tjaytizza 2 years ago
this the shit homies
krliltiger 2 years ago
@krliltiger AGREED
rockhurstalum09 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I think Manson looks a little bit Hitler 'cause of his short hairtstyle. :D But his voice sounds horrible in this. (my opinion) And Girger is like a little boy with his first drums or something. :D
KiddieGrueger 2 years ago
get off Gingers case, look up his medical records and you will know why he isnt that good at the drums like he once was. He said it hurts everytime he plays, and sometimes it goes numb and wont move.
odoc346 2 years ago
Well, i didnt mean it like that. Theres nothing wrong with how he plays. He just look like little boy, ''yay, i got my own drums!''
KiddieGrueger 2 years ago
3:29 "Why so Serious?"
FoxxWolfe 2 years ago
don't know but it makes him even more hot "_"
cochos2x4 2 years ago
Oh yeah, kill jonas brothers =D
wahoutch 2 years ago 11
marilyn manson is the best band of all times, thats my opinion, and.....FUCK jonass brothers
sICmushroomMaGGot13 2 years ago 16
thats a fact not a opinion
wahaha
kill jonas brothers!!
jeryco25 2 years ago 13
Its allways hard watching this show because man it was just falling apart after The New Shit
and Manson is killing himself the whole way through.
Antichrist2000 2 years ago 2
man this performance just didn't do his voice justice
spookymax18 3 years ago 6
rock 'n roll man :)
isoperuna2 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
wat is the thing called he has on his keyboard he can fling back and forth
pxoxgxo 3 years ago
spring lol!
jeryco25 2 years ago
Man his screams need to go back to 1996!!! He screamed WAY better back then... MM forever
theXfaction 3 years ago
I don't know what you would call it but its not screaming,and back in 1996 it was more like he was roring.
Antichrist2000 2 years ago 6
@Antichrist2000 AGREED
rockhurstalum09 1 year ago
man, he's losing totally the voice, his screams sucks his throat, but i still like him xD
aiovas94 3 years ago
eh, It was only this concert I've heard his voice sucks. not the others after 2003 either.
Steinbiten 3 years ago
I love this ! =D
Lindyx1494x 3 years ago 4
The bass *ç*
beriiichigo 3 years ago 5
favorite song by him <3
HiImChelsee 3 years ago 3
i like his attitude in this one
KoRnfan969 3 years ago 4
cool
i fucking love this band!!! <3
rutee1000 3 years ago 3
Duuuude.. The bass is awesome O.O
ThimSkold 3 years ago 7
MANSON IS MY GOD *-*
MissMineux 3 years ago 14
i love thismuther fucker.
literali
santomasdim 3 years ago 6
great performance, to sad that the sound disappear some times.
oceanspirit 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
just say it he cant sing live
but i like it the same
YAAAAAAAAAAARRRRR
deadrider24 3 years ago
je trouve qu'il force un peu sur sa voix non?
gesuileplubocar 3 years ago
the drummer looks happy and he do his work^^
deadrider24 3 years ago 8
Peut-etre un peu, mais ici, il est malade.
Great performance, he should still do this live.
DarthKrattus 3 years ago
omg so bassy ^^
kerplunk098 3 years ago 7
Wow look that, fucking Awesome live, live yeah!!!
GoodMarilynManson 3 years ago 3
im totally 100% naked now hehe O
attle410 3 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
my bf just got done f**king me and I am so tired and sore :( he took pics and put them on my page lol! C
malljan 3 years ago
cool :) but i like twiggy ...and his not here :(
rutee1000 3 years ago
You can tell he's not lip-synch his voice is blowed
6stringgunslinger 3 years ago
i've only seen him lip-synching once at the comet thin in 04 or 04. They are really professional and 99% of the time play live
Rumble200 3 years ago
As much as I hate to admit it it's all about style. I'm a huge Skold fan, so I think the stuff he did with manson was amazing, but twiggy was a huge part in the past as well, and wrote a lot of amazing songs, so neither can be denied. Either way Manson has a talent of finding great musicians to take advantage of... I hope Skold goes back to doing solo shit...
Placid09 3 years ago
I agree on you that the lyrics are great. But you should acknowledge that twiggy wrote most of the music for the three album epopee. Starting with AS to HW. In my opinion that is the period that defines MM as band. And besides Twiggy is back on the new album (working title)
mattislengi 3 years ago
buen video
john5ygonza 3 years ago 2
its a shame mansons not close with ginger fish considering hes been in the band the longest now.
MISANTHROPY647 3 years ago 4
aside for manson
PhoneLad 3 years ago
dont get me wrong. i luv this video, but manson does sound like he has a bad cold. it still sounds cool though.
demonns8 3 years ago
yeah rock am ring 2003 was a bad show
GunsGodAndGovernment 3 years ago 3
but wat about manson, does he always sound like that live?
demonns8 3 years ago
no, not at all
most of the time manson is better live
GunsGodAndGovernment 3 years ago
thisvideo rocks if u dont like it u need a lot of help
66655447 3 years ago
this song fucking rocks so does marilyn manson
SKITT4658 3 years ago
love ginger&john5 they are so sexy
KeaneQueen11981 3 years ago 3
I heared that the goth king wasn't terrific live.
can anyone tell me what he is like live?
imthebest3101 3 years ago
First of all. He isn't a goth. he is a Glam/shock rocker.
Second of all. wether or not he is good live depends on who you are. some people don't like how his voice is when he sings live, other loves it. depends on who you are.
talkar 3 years ago
dude. it was a simple question.
you didn't have to answer like a fucking cunt. it was uncalled for.
and your answer doesn't answer my question anyway.
imthebest3101 3 years ago
well if you don't want an answer then why ask a question ?
talkar 3 years ago
of corse i wanted an answer.
but what you gave me didn't help me at all.
all i was looking for was a yes he is good or no he aint that great.
and btw he has the title of the goth king you tit.
imthebest3101 3 years ago
you can't just say yes or no to you'r question.
it's a question that will give you a different answer from each person you ask. Some will love it, some will like it, some will hate the show.
you can't just say yes or no.
btw show me a link where the statement of MM being a Goth King is. and no Tainted love music video isn't a good source.
talkar 3 years ago
well all i wanted was an opinion but what i got from you was that opinions will differ and didn't give me your opnion therefore leaving me without an answer moron.
and as for the goth king comment.
dont you think that the (I dont like using this word) majority of Goths will listen to marilyn and look up to him. therefore i think that he would be given the FITTING title of goth king wouldn't you agree?
imthebest3101 3 years ago
well most of the goths i know don't see Manson as a goth and because of that they don't look up to him as a goth king. actually i only know about 2 goths that listen to the music of the band Marilyn Manson.
Maybe where you come from goths listen to Marilyn Manson. I don't know.
but if you want an answer for your first question then yes i belieave that Marilyn Manson is great when performing live.
talkar 3 years ago
:-)
thanks man thats all i wanted to know :)
and yeah most goths where im from do listen to marilyn.
imthebest3101 3 years ago
all goths where im from listen to MM including me
dna448 3 years ago
labels are for soup cans
dont call people goth!!!
12345MM54321 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
faggot
B0NEL0C0 3 years ago
why u say that?
imthebest3101 3 years ago
hes amazing live
12345MM54321 3 years ago
glad to hear it :)
imthebest3101 3 years ago
ginger&john5
very good!
Wormboy55 3 years ago 2
Bass in this music is great, perfect!
coziwan2bangyou 3 years ago 6
ok if you dont like it, dont watch it...
I still think that hes amazing, great......
his face is ubelievable when hes singing:
"I woke today and wished for tomorrow
I dont want to be like anyone else
I woke up today and wished for tomorrow
I dont want to even be myself"...
thealla7 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
LMFAO this song sucks live. stay studio style XD
USpoon 3 years ago
its just his vocals that suck
MISANTHROPY647 3 years ago
yeah tahts wat imm getting at lol
if any1 likes screamo or w/e this guy is they shud listen 2 killswitch engage live there amazing
USpoon 3 years ago
killswitch fucking suck, all hardcore and screamo bands suck.
MISANTHROPY647 3 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
still betta then this cock sucker
USpoon 3 years ago
nah, this guy owns them. and hes not hardcore, so yeah.
MISANTHROPY647 3 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ok ok
listen to arms of sorrow by killswitch engage and learnt hat this guy sucks live and that KSE dont :D
USpoon 3 years ago
i dont like killswitch period cause theyre harcore and cause theyre a christian band.
MISANTHROPY647 3 years ago 5
lol XD
USpoon 3 years ago
LMFAO this song sucks live. stay studio style XD
USpoon 3 years ago
awesome:)
666latino666 3 years ago
Haha..Twiggy...Yeah..Go Tim!
EyeOfTheNorth83 3 years ago 2
Twiggy is a way better bassist than tim skold.
6I6Cum6Blood 3 years ago 2
you wish.
MISANTHROPY647 3 years ago
look good and play loud doesnt make u a good bassist...listen to the bass line in irresponsable hate anthem, and tell me if twiggy isnt a great bass player...
6The6Berzeker6 3 years ago
i said not to mention his looks were better than twiggys. twiggy just straight out sucked, i dont care how close manson and twiggy were, that doesnt mean twiggy was better.
MISANTHROPY647 3 years ago 2
Twiggy's best bass player ever!
Just watch the Coma White Music Clip :)
Incredible performance <3
koreanstyler 3 years ago 3
Twiggy fucking wrote almost every song on ACS, MA, and Holy wood. you cant say that twiggy sucks cuz that would be saying almost every MM song sucks. so, fuck off Twiggy.
12345MM54321 3 years ago
exactly!! twiggy is the brain and soul of the band, manson is just a good liryc writer and a great performer, but what twiggy did with the music, is way better than what tim did...so, twiggy is better than tim! =P.
6The6Berzeker6 3 years ago
thank you! most of these people who are fighting over whos the better bassist are probably like 20 years old. im 13 and i get it. im not saying that tim is a bad musician because hes not, but tim has nothing on twiggy.
12345MM54321 3 years ago
Once again it comes down to preference. Skold has been playing bass since the mid eighties atleast... Not sure about Twiggy. Skold's songwriting I think is extremley strong though, as I prefer a much more industrial sound, such as songs from GAOG.
Placid09 3 years ago
GREAT SONG!!
and he has beautiful teeths !!
<3 manson
MaXl0vE 4 years ago
You idiot, who are complaining about his voice, ever thought that it could be the equipment that did not work well during the show? Just think......a little please...??? Do world a favor____think.
aCuntTookMyName 4 years ago 2
I like his music, and his movies, etc.. But I hate it when people defend him like he's a god or something. Blame it on the equipment, blablablabla.. You can hear his voice was not at the top with this show, and its not because of the equipment. Listen to it agian and I think you'll realize that. But thats because he damaged his voice with this tour.. If you're going to defend him, base your arguments on facts, not what "you think". He's not a god, he's a good musician.
steffen7063 3 years ago
oops!!! Somebody's taken commenting on youtube way too siriously lol!
aCuntTookMyName 3 years ago
If that's your best reply, it's been a waste of time trying to talk sense into you.
steffen7063 3 years ago
I like your passion and the mission you have to change people through Youtube comments. Lol you're relatives must be Christians who try to convert people on Youtube and forums.
aCuntTookMyName 3 years ago
But to show how ignorant you are of the video you ,hopefully you watched, have you seen other performances from this concert? If you have a few brain cells you will notice that his mic was off the whole appearance and the guitars were much louder. And with your "logic" you're almost saying Manson sucked here because he can't naturally scream louder then than the instruments. T%his is also something else he might've tried to do, because instruments were too loud so he wanted to scream louder.
aCuntTookMyName 3 years ago
Can you show me those other videos? All I'm sure of is that it wasnt the instruments, because in that case, they woulld most likely do something about it. And also, in the end of the movie, fans are screaming, all of them- the volume is in no comparison to mansons volume. Also, if it was the mic, why did he still have it in his hand? He could have thrown it away to impress fans... And in the case that the instruments were loud and he tried to scream louder, it really was his voice..
steffen7063 3 years ago
LOL they are to you're right in related videos section. Check out the (s)aint video from the same concert. Not all technical problems with equipment can be fixed. You need to see plenty of bands live. As well as the stage is being set up and evrything taking back apart and how much of a hell it can be. It's not as easy as switching the mic or adjusting the volume. Technicians mess up too, cables break, wireless doesn't work, too many bands are at the fest. too much ehll in other words.
aCuntTookMyName 3 years ago
Therefore it caused him not to sound top notch. Well i hope it brings clarity to you of what i said and i wish you all the best with your mission, maybe a career, in trying to change people's minds via internet.
aCuntTookMyName 3 years ago
Also, I don't have a mission? Why do you always bring up subjects that aren't related at all? Really, because if you're going after personal attacks, you're aiming fucking low.
steffen7063 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Go in on my profile and look at my video on "use your fist and not your mouth"
steffen7063 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Go in on my pr