When she loved me Crona / Chrona X Maka

[MetaRothSephKnight]

lik dis if u cry evertim

[ninjascrag]

If you follow the anime as I do, you would call ceiba a boy as they refer to crona as a 'he' in the English dub. I don't know about the manga though, or the Japanese version, so feel free to correct me here, but I think that crona's a guy.

[MrLawlz100]

this song...i know...it was in toy story...damn it!!! mom wheres the dvd for toy story!!!

[HayleyWolf1]

Im pretty sure that Chrona is in love with Maka, but I think maka is in love with Soul.... Chrona's whole story is heartbreaking

[sveetdumplings]

You know whats sad, You can tell that Crona really does love Maka but you know Maka doesn't feel the same way about Crona. :(

[sheenababe202]

Cried. SO hard.

[Stickkiller97]

if you watched the anime you will cry :')

[athena7100]

crona is a boy

[YGolover13]

I dont care if Crona is a boy or a girl, the only think that maters is that we love him/her <3<3<3!

[hgdge]

ok. fucking love crona. im done :3

[NZthou]

omg the ending is SO SAD! btw this may the last time i say this but CRONA IS A BOY!!!

[Appletinibuisness]

does crona die what happens

[Shammymew101]

This video reminds me so much of me and my best friend. I was like Chrona in a way, what with my antisocialness and finding it hard to "deal" with certain things, but my bestfriend was my Maka all the way through since pre-k. Now we're in highschool and we've sort of drifted apart. This video charmed me to tears. You did a wonderful job. It's perfect for Maka and Chrona.

[xXxSasukeTaka]

i almost cried

[ChristinaLoveAnime04]

this is a perfect couple, song, and video! :)

*Favs*

[MISSLADYJUGGERNAUT]

Makes me think of my ex ;  ;

[smallpaws14]

waaaa im so sad its such a purfect song for them too

[animelove8101]

I love this video.

I don't see them as a pairing (because sometimes I think that that's way to simple of an anime relationship), but sometime much deeper. This is so beautiful, it honestly brought me to tears. Thank you!

[TheOldsnake47]

1:32 the cuttest expression that maka made in the video

[sango180]

@TheOldsnake47 I love tht face too

[TheOldsnake47]

@sango180 the fact that i love yuri and i am a boy... my god, my mind is totally destroyed.

[KillJoysMakingNoise]

I wonder what volume in the manga is the begging and ending of the video?

Thank you. ;D

[foreverkhin]

its soo beautiful. the song, the pairing and this video. its soo lovely. it teared me up :') love crona and maka!!

[foreverkhin]

omg. dont tell me.. crona died?? NOOOO NOOO

[sango180]

@foreverkhin no he didnt die he ALMOST did

[TsubakiYakani]

Q.Q aww i cried....

[Robbase231]

I could actually hear the dubbed version of Crona singing this song, there voices are vary similar. Soul Eater impressed me vary much, I was not really expecting such an awsome and unique anime like it was, and I cannot wait to read the manga.

Chrona struck me as an interesting character from the beginning, and I was vary touched by Makka's forgiveness and acceptance of him/her, And I personally love the pairing alot!!

[jessicasuyo1]

wow great couple.... but soulxmaka is still good right????

[lightninglarxene]

Perfect couple! I LOVED IT!

Crona x Maka forever! X3

[UltimateShipperAnnie]

I always considered Chrona a he, though I did think he was a girl at fist. Now I can't think of him as a girl, really, but this video is the best <3

[AruOkami]

I personally believe Crona is and always will be a he but I can connect with that quote =)

[ThePaulium]

Crona is a guy, he is referred to as "he" or "his" throughout the entire show. There are also a lot of things other characters say to or about him that hint at him being a male.

[MattiBros]

Listen to me, Crona is a girl, but she was joined to Ragnarok, that is male, so she became boy and girl at the same time... but, if there wasn't Ragnarok, SHE WOULD BE A GIRL!

Sorry my bad English, I'm Italian.

[mellosgf]

well damn ;^; this is really nice, even though i dont like this pairing yuri or not, i only think of them as friends but still i loved it~

[edi0s0ed]

if you look it up crona is meant to be gender neutral, it just dos not translate well into english

[InsanityWithHumor]

who remembered toy story when they heard this?

[ninjascrag]

@InsanityWithHumor this song always makes me cry....TuT

[MintyZebras]

@InsanityWithHumor OMG! POOR JESSE D;

[InsanityWithHumor]

@MintyZebras lol i never knew my comment was top comment. XD I totaly went to all comments to find it when i didnt need to.

[XxSoulEaterChicxX]

awww so cute but poor chorona

[Kikifrox13]

Crona is a BOY!!!!!!!!! if u accually paid attention to the series and HIS reactions to some of the episodes with HIM in it u would get that fact by the hinting clues!!! Like in one episode Medusa even said "my son.." So There!!!!!!!

[brentwaller37]

even if Chrona is a boy, I would still consider this a yuri pairing. ;)

[DarkOrMisunderstood]

toy story?

[DarkOrMisunderstood]

´Crona=boy

fansubbers ocg dúbbers are wrong!!

[RRonawu]

I made video with same song, and with same pairing. I didn't watch this video before it.. these have almost same scenes... I hope you don't mind it?

[xxPunkyRaverPoneyxx]

I LUV CRONA HE IS A AWSOME GUY I LOVE HIS HAIR :)

[emowannabe97]

Omg! i felt like crying at the end!

[puffyluvr]

awwwww.....such a sad vid!!

personally i think crona's a boy, but this was so well done!

[Nekologic]

This made me cry. ]:

[NiaRose111]

Awww that made me cry TTwTT

[8x13Wolf]

Crona + Maka + Sarah McLachlan AND OH CRUD THE TEARS WON'T STOP.

[Samfeeney64]

cool

[princesscripz98]

what is?

[xodis9]

spelled crona first the right time jackass

[TheGoblinCat]

Where'd you find your clips?

[TheAnimeGirlfan]

this was so beutifull i give it 1000000000000 stars is was a sweet lovely awesome sad+cute video i lvoe it is so amasing

[crona0fan0sylvia]

thats just sweet

[TheKimico16]

cute

[DeathNoteFangirl13]

This vid made me cry.X'(

It's so beautiful...

[Rin7713]

Crona is a boy according to the show lol

such a cute couple either way though x3

[xXMiniMissXx]

I always loved Crona x Maka since they seemed to understand each other. AND...Crona totally has a crush on Maka anyway. ;D

The mangaka himself has stated he doesn't know Crona's gender, so weather it's Yuri or Het coupling, still best couple ever! xD

[greyhawlk]

what episode?

[MicMacz]

Wow, this is so touching! =) the song goes good! Its vary sweet...=) nice job

[chiyoxosakafan]

I love this thank you and we need more Maka x Chrona vids!

[Jesus00000000000]

I'd like to see them as a canon painring, but it would mean that the creator would have to specify Crona's gender... And I like the ambiguity :D

[draganryo]

Haha! Another great vid! ^_^

This is not only the best pairing in SE....BUT THE BEST YURI PAIRING IN HISTORY! (Crona is a girl imo).

I kinda wish that there would be more vids of this pairing though ^_^! Like with BEATLES music xD. "Something" is one of the greatest love songs ever.

[XxXSaKuXSaSuXxX95]

@draganryo nooo!! crona is a boyyyy

[draganryo]

@XxXSaKuXSaSuXxX95 Nope xP

3 Words: Read the Manga.

Trust me. It leans more to girl xDD

[8x13Wolf]

@draganryo Girly figures prove nothing. It's anime, remember.

[draganryo]

@8x13Wolf How about the way Crona acts? Guys usually aren't that shy and in the manga Crona covers her chest. A guy definitely wouldn't do that. And actually...it depends the anime/manga. If they were going to have guys with feminine physiques, they would have other male characters like that. Crona is the only one so it is a valid argument.

[LoonarX]

@draganryo ahhhhhhnot really. Im a guy, I have curves, lashes and a feminine voice when its cold. that, and When Im insecure about something holding myself really DOES help believe it or not... so ya, arguable, yes, valid, not really as much, lol

[LoonarX]

@8x13Wolf BOO YA!!! THANK YOU!!! you just brought up the point that I meant to, LOL

[vampireanjumaaka]

@draganryo actually there is proof crona is male it's in his voice and soul called Crona him so HA U CRONA HATER!!

[draganryo]

@vampireanjumaaka Please, you half-wit. Crona's the main reason I like Soul Eater. Soul called Crona "him" because he doesn't know what Crona is. That...and the anime is pathetic like that. But read the manga. Look at form. GUYS don't have hips like that. And in the manga Crona tries to cover her chest. GUYS don't do that. And besides. Crona's voiced by a girl in both English and Japanese. Idk why you use that as an argument.

[8x13Wolf]

@draganryo Well, I was going to respond to you like you were a mature, sensible person...but then you called someone else who didn't agree with you a "half-wit". This is too nice a video to fill the comments with bickering, so PM me if you have any more venom to spit.

[LoonarX]

@draganryo actually the voice actor was a boy for both O_o I actually researched this rather thoroughly. and look at my above comment please, LOL

[LoonarX]

@draganryo but if Crona WAS a she, then why would Maka SMASH him one for the skirt flipping incident? O_o

[draganryo]

@LoonarX Because Maka hit Crona on accident because Maka was aiming for Ragnarok but he used Crona as a shield. You saw when Crona was apologizing profusely that Maka apologized to her for it because she obviously didn't mean to hit Crona.

[LoonarX]

@draganryo Crona's a dude -_- it says so in the Manga, the Anime, and his voice acter was a guy, so thats all I really gots to say

[justbuythecookies]

@draganryo eh-hem, NOT TRUE.

lol, not saying this pairing/video isn't boss, but FYI the anime NEVER EVER SPECIFIES WHETHER OR NOT CRONA IS A GIRL OR A BOY. There's been hints in both directions, but it never specifies.

personally, i always thought crona was a dude. :/ it just appeals to me more that way. i'm not homophobic or anything, i just like the idea of yadda yadda, why am i explaining myself to people on teh interwebz...>^<

[draganryo]

@justbuythecookies But....I never said it the anime/manga specified it. I specifically stated Crona is a girl in my own opinion from having read the manga and seen quirks in her personality. You're free to believe however you wish :-)

[sango180]

@justbuythecookies I'm not trying to cause a conflict but in one of the episodes Medusa actually says crona is a boy when she says " Well...It seems you've seemed to tame Him quiet well" but crona is a Girl in the japanese manga when everything is written in Japanese but please dnt yell at me

[justbuythecookies]

@sango180 Oh...then the internet lied to me. XD Yeah, I knew Crona is a girl the manga, though. Sorry if it seemed like I was yelling at you, I was just trying to put emphasis on my words, and you can't do bold or italics on youtube >.<

[aisling27XxX]

@draganryo crona is a boy -.-

[draganryo]

@aisling27XxX Does ANYONE read the manga or look at the wiki? The English language has no gender-neutral way of defining a person aside from it and both the Anime and Manga translators felt it would be insulting to refer to Crona as it. In Japanese manga the artist has not given Crona a defined gender and the anime artwork gives Crona a more feminine feel so I refer to Crona as she.

[VoreTechz1985]

@draganryo They do refer to Crona as "it" several times.

[aisling27XxX]

@draganryo i don`t care what you say crona is a boy for me i fucken give a shit if you kept on telling me crona is a girl

[draganryo]

@aisling27XxX Seriously. It's called a life. Get one. If not, at least research what you're talking about. Crona is a boy to you? Good for you! I picture Crona as a girl. No defined gender gives people to have their own opinions. Even in my original comment I said Crona is a girl in my opinion. How very rude to not allow me to have my opinion. And to go around cursing like a 2 year old who's learned a new word. If you love Soul Eater, respect people's opinions then.

[momogurl311]

this is just....great! i cant explain how GOOD this is!!!!! it made me cry....T^T i like this pairing alot there very cute together but i still like soulXmaka more. cuz i usually picture chrona as a girl and i like chronaXkid!(but can someone tell me her gender, cuz im really confused wit her gender) but this is very good 5 starz!!!!!!!!

[ArisaThePKMNtrainer]

...ill say it again,this actualy made me cry....god,i love you...

[LilKyoWarumono]

beautiful....simply, awesomely beautiful

[MagicaLamia]

This is wonderful! T^T...I just thought the same! And I cried when chrona almost sacrifised the own life to safe maka Q_Q...

[RinLockhart]

I am truly flattered that I've been quoted here.

This anime pairing is just too charming to pass up.

[klahaschik]

lol well u were right about it all so i figured u deserved to be mentioned

[ivyriddler]

@RinLockhart I agree whole heartedly with your quote!

I don't care if Crona is a boy or a girl or whatever or how her/his name is spelled, after watching those two I don't know how everybody doesn't ship them. c: