American Idol - Top 6 - All I Ask Of You

[ShellTard]

hell. no.

[vampiresninjasohmy]

I wanna hump Jason Castro's face!

[swimmingtrumpets10]

The guys sound good by them selfs, but when you add the girls in it's just horibal. What a shame this is a magnificent song

[sebastianpzk]

Holy crap, this is the worst thing i've ever seen!

[ejhobbs18]

I love this song, but this sucks.

[colt413]

theres absolutely no emotion in this song!! I can honestly say I hate this being a Phantom of the Opera fan...

[Emimi33able]

no offense, this sort of sucks

it doesn't sound like they mean what they're saying

[angelsunny8]

I kind of thought that they would have split the song up a bit so that everyone will have a tiny solo...

[AuroraGuiniverePrice]

david cook = ultimate phantom

yuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­m

XD

[Klorenemagic]

no feeling! FAIL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[gluedhand]

Hated it except David Cook.......who could be a exceptional Raoul but thats my wishful thinking

[Andyhp14]

THIS SUCKS

[acolorfulmessxo]

this song is meant for 2 people, not six.

[azadarham]

This is horrible - One of the most BEAUTIFUL songs ever.. mutilated :( It sounds like they are in a Glee club or something... :/

[1AdrianR]

How did Idol do it, how did they manage to ruin all the ALW songs they sung?

[xoxoaldaxoxo]

ahhh they just ruined the song for me. what is this??? as much as i've loved idol for years, this is just horrible

[goldenwings1988]

While I agree that this is not a group type of song, I will say that this song is not an easy one to do and I commend them for their effort. It's also not every day that you have Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber playing the accompaniment, I would kill for a chance like that!

[MavRckProductions]

season 7 was my favorite. but this just sucks. i hate them all as a group. as individual singers ? AMAZING. but no. just no.

[StrawhatxLuffy]

not nice.

[Kathryn8748]

K, I love this song, But they RUINED IT !!! </3

[crazysquirrel7]

How exciting it would have been to sing one of Andrew Lloyd Weber's famous songs with HIM playing the piano!!!!!!! I would have fainted!!!!!!!

[toughcookie5454]

all you can hear is david cook :)

[DarthxErik]

this is terrible!!!!

[elsabear99]

I would somewhat like this if it wasn't sung by RAOUL and Christine. I would like it if it was sung by the Phantom and Christine. And yea, it kinda sounds like a middle school choir.

LONG LIVE PHANS.

[MrCrowIey]

it sounded like 6 individuals trying to each show off what they can do. They could of been alot tighter and used harmonies...

[lifetimeperformer]

I don't like this. I don't know how Andrew let them get away with this.

[shortbutstrong]

Well the guys were okay at least...poor Andrew Lloyd Webber. If this is how they sounded on the final show, imagine how badly they sounded during rehearsals.

[isaysx]

the guys blended really really well, and in contrast, the girls blended horribly. so sad. :(

[gummie1066]

oh my i totel forgot about they did this song it sounds really bad they should'nt of sang it all together the boys sound ok the girls sound bad and thats a shame every one of them has a good voice justed when they all sang this song it sounded horrible

[springfairy556]

I love this song. But I really don't think they should have had six people singing it. It was made for two. They should have done Prema Donna or Masquarade. Something that had many people singing it.

[rene24hour]

i agree should not have been done with so many people.

[AintNoCinderella]

omg this is beautiful. i love andrew lloyd webbers. this is such a beautiful song.

[strawberrylemon]

the male part was okay. but the females just ruined it.....a lot..

[TheDoggielover1]

where can you find David Archuleta's version for this song?

[FanofApawk18]

You can hear david really well too. but i listened to just david's versions. and its amazing. better than all of them together.

[isayhi72]

BLEH. SUCK. lol. It did. I really hate how they try to make The Phantom of the Opera music into pop. The only rendition of Phantom music I can somewhat get behind is Cook's The Music of the Night. Think of Me was just.... horrendous.

[asparch]

wow this is really bad. it sounded like a middle school choir singing a pop song, not two people in love essentially saying their vows, as it's supposed to be

[SawyersSexy]

They killed one of my favorite songs. Yuck.

[crAzyXx3]

ewthe girls suck. the boy were pretty good:]

[beavmaverick]

the girls part at the beginning wasnt quite on...

[SubarusXangel]

no, it wasn't, nice catch, they aren't quite getting up there on this song

[osahju914]

cough cough Syesha

[tfoyjr]

The Phantom of the Opera is my favorite movie and the All I Ask Of you scene is my favorite and i think this group did a wonderful job

[ShelbyLynnSchleuning]

but yeah I really loved the top six I was pissed when Carly got eliminated though

[katiekat09]

AMEN.

i LOVED that performance!

[ShelbyLynnSchleuning]

LOVE LOVE LOVE DAVID COOK! LOL

[PinayPopstar125]

This was one of my favorite group performances last season :)

except for at 1:15 if you listen really closely, jason ruins it with his awful harmony.

but other than that i loved it! <3

[Lys2911]

Actually, I'm pretty sure that's Cook you're hearing.

[IzzyandGwen]

CRAPPY DAY Carly S got eliminated

[power992000]

I think MC sounds better then all of them but david cook does have a good voice he did a good job too

[frazzler9]

MC????????????????????????

[ScarfaceClaw13]

Michael Crawford- He was the original Phantom when the show first hit the stage.

[scarscar93]

Whoah. Imagine singing this with JUST DC.

-thud-

[ShelbyLynnSchleuning]

haha well at least I'm not the only one Thank god! LOL

[suzierugrat]

shitty version. this song is supposed to be sung between two people who are madly in love with each other, not a bunch of 6 people without any feeling.

[atamoura]

agreed!

[tiarnantman]

Yuck at Cook's bum note at 1.48. Brooke sounds pretty though.

[Cblotnicky]

I would have loved to hear just Syesha and David Cook sing that song. I agree with whoever said that having all six sing the whole thing was just too much. This is a one-on-one piece.

[onekrispix]

i wish they had done solos instead. :( all i ask of you is too delicate to be weighted down by all those voices throughout the entire song

[wtrmelonislife]

In the end Simon was also on his feet giving them a standing ovation.

[qg6ff]

yeah prolly because of webber. you thinik he'd stand up for the contestants yeah right he's a poop. but ya never know

[whuhumuch]

this was the worst results show of american idol ever bc carly went home wshe was one of the best people ever one this show she has the best voice and im my opinion can be compared to mariah carey

[phantomfan15]

yeah she was good that week she sang Jesus  christ super star very well@

[CarolinaGirl316]

David Archuleta!!! <3

[LOZO71489]

I love Brooke and Jason! they're perfect together.

[tellindatruth]

she shudnt have gne bt nxt to go shud be brooke then jason.

an i wnt syesha in the final with david cook

[GreenHeartz]

omg omg omg BEAUTIFUL. Thats so awesome i was like cryig its so good. TY Carly got voted of though. I hope It goes like this

Syesha,Jason,BRooke, and One of the Davids

[CONCERTCHOIR6]

Concertchoir6

I love that version of all I ask of you on Idol because all the girls were the Christines from Phantom Of The Opera & all the boys were Rauols in this performance.

[coramunroe]

Carly shouldn't have left, Jason should have.

[dmgamboa]

Waaah. I wanted a Carly/DC solo. :( xD