Added: 1 year ago
From: harvarder18
Views: 8,333
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (28)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Yea hide the black faces you motherfucking honky crackers.

  • Remember Shang Dynasy was also considered to be a myth until the oracle texts surfaced about 100 years ago. Once these newly discovered "Xia" texts carved on jade plates and jade objects are deciphered (some have already been translated (blog.sina.com.cn/zhenzhenghua­­xiazhuren)), the existence of "Xia" Dynasty will be confirmed.

  • i will , and call what ever you want too, freedom of speech.

  • IF ANY ONE CAN UNDERSTAND CHINESE YOU MAY SEE THIS LINK, THEY DID FIND SOME EVIDENCE FROM THE LATE XIA DYNASTY, AND IT WAS CITED ON SIMA QIAN SHIJI BOOK. TRY THIS SEARCH ON YOUTUBE. 国宝档案 - 二里头青铜器 高清720HD

  • @DQFXPRESS i concur... called it whatever you want ... but the Shang is already considered 'developed' for a bronze age civilization... Hence a dynasty prior to it does exist ...

  • @ComradeMing

    Yes, hopefully, but right now, it's not even considered a dynasty.Shiji might be accurate in some parts, but sometimes it isn't. You should know that Shiji is a Sino-centric material (Han Chinese POV) in things, so they can dilute some parts of other people's history as well.

  • @ComradeMing

    Actually, Shang was thought to be semi-legendary, but it was backed by different sources. As for Xia, there's no archeleogical evidences for such a dynasty to appear in Chinese Neolithic stage. Xia sources are primarily from Sima Qian Shiji, nothing else.

  • terrible documentary which is what you would expect from a doc made by westerner for westerners. so much mistakes in here cant watch it. most uneducational

  • the most ancient ~~ Xia Dynasty.. but it is regarded as possibly mythical by some writings thats why others think that it is Shang...

  • @friendzhipOnline

    Xia is probably a myth along with other myths that precede the Shang dynasty.

  • THE HISTORY CHINESE TEXT ALSO CITED THE LOCATION WHERE THE XIA WAS LOCATED AND THEY FOUND NEW DIGS NOW. WATCH AND SEE FOR YOURSELF. SHANG WAS A MYTH BACK THEN TOO.

  • THIS IS WRONG SHANG DYNASTY IS THE 2ND CHINESE DYNASTY, XIA OR HSIA IS THE FIRST CHINESE DYNASTY.

  • @DQFXPRESS Xia dynasty is still considered myth due to the lack of conclusive evidence. IF the Xia (sha) dynasty can be proved as real then it will be considered the 1st dynasty. But for now, Shang is considered the 1st.

  • The statement by Dr. Campbell and Dr. Flad regarding horses and chariots appeared first in Shang Dynasty might be incorrect. There are newly identified jade plates from Xia Dynasty depicted both horses and chariots (blog.sina.com.cn/zhenzhenghua­xiazhuren) . In addition many unidentified ancient Chinese characters were also carved on these Xia jade plates. According to the author there are more than several hundreds of this type of characters in his jade collection.

  • Interesting to learn a bit of Chinese history preceeding even the Zhou Dynasty.

    However, I can still independently research the Shang and Xia if I need to.

    Thank you very much for posting this documentary, harvarder18.

  • so was this the period before ethnic han came in power

  • @muaspheeb Yes.. The Shang Dynasty was a 1000 years before the Qin and Han Dynasty.

  • @QiLuHmongHeritage thank you

  • @QiLuHmongHeritage Ethnic Han was known as ethnic Huaxia before Han Dynasty. Although the name changed, the ethnic is still the same. Before Han Dynasty doesn't mean before ethnic Han came in power.

  • @anotherzly Now and then everyone refers Huaxia as Han Chinese -Descendants of the Yan-Huang. While not acknowledging that the First Emperor of Han Dynasty "Lui Bang" came from Yi barbarian in Xuzhou. Liu Bang originally came from Xuzhou, the capital of the Dongyi State of Xu.

  • @QiLuHmongHeritage We know clearly where Liu Bang is from. I already told you that Dongyi refers to different peoples at different times. And I never heard people calling him Dongyi.

  • @muaspheeb Ethnic Han was known as ethnic Huaxia before Han Dynasty. Although the name changed, the ethnic is still the same. Before Han Dynasty doesn't mean before ethnic Han came in power.

  • @anotherzly so wat ethnic is the empress belong to

  • @muaspheeb Huaxia.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more