Katharine McPhee audition

[TheMontoGawe]

I stopped watching American Idol when she lost to Taylor (?).

[libbyrock123]

I don't care how well you sing... do NOT sing "God Bless The Child!" I'm so glad Robbie Rosen didn't pull that one out his back pocket!

[the100blogger]

do people really consider her overweight?

[ThatwasTERRIBLE]

She looks fat.

[scarletrose10]

That lip-syncing is horrible. But I love her voice. :)

[laneylikewhoa]

@scarletrose10 The video just didn't synch correctly.

[BeccaBearize]

i think the sound is off but she's a really good singer

[littleangel05322]

i still can't believe she lost but i'm glad she got a recording deal anyway

[kcmet79]

Simon was right, parts were fantastic, but parts were whiny/erratic/unpleasant.

S5 was incredibly talented... any one of the top 4 woulda been justified with the win. Taylor may not have had the best voice/talent, but he was charismatic/fun to watch, with a BIG fanbase, and an awesome vocal tone.

[VBVids012]

Where's Sanjaya's Audition?

[helmut4lyfe]

Elliot got robbed.

[kcmet79]

@helmut4lyfe I agree. By < 1%. :-(

[hinatababe97]

SHE'S GRREAT! :D

[BLACKBEAUTYWINS]

them riffs and runs were phenomenal! she was superb!

love her voice..

[Blakmajik78]

I cant understand why this girls career didn't go as far as it should have. This heifer could sing her hind parts off! She, Paris and Elliot were my favorites that season. Is this the season where Taylor Hicks won? Yeah no wonder I stopped watching this show lol

[MyahhYup90]

Taylor could sing but she got robbed! BIG TIME! But at the same time who is Taylor Hicks now if you asked somebody who Taylor Hicks is someone would be like Who?

[ywillburn]

kath got married to get away from her dominating mother !!!!!!!! that's why she married an much oler man: sorry mom, live your own life !!!!!!!!! you will not dictate kath's career and dreams NO MORE!!!!!!! GET YOUR OWN LIFE!!!!!!!!!!

[DoubleDBlogXX]

I LOVE HOW HER MOM IS A VOCAL COACH ON THE SHOW NOW!

[msymsed]

Katherine has a good voice but she cannot perform. She is so bland and boring.

[wozniacki15]

oh and did i mention melinda dolitttle smh i still cant believe it

[wozniacki15]

i really hate this season of all the pl they had america chose taylor hicks? i mean katharine mcphee, chris daughtry, elliot yamin, mandisa, and paris bennett and they chose taylor hicks? where the hell he at now?

[didiNintendo97]

AHHHHHHH!!!!! THAT WAS SO GOOD!!!! :D

[MusicallyUbiquitous]

LOL @ 0:24

[JacobPalmer0209]

Everyone it's Katharine! Get it right! She's amazing so at least spell her name right! Ahahahaha! (:

[mercedessss100]

i think elliot yamin should have won.

[Desttinyy]

@atlballer81 That's not right. Who are you to call someone ugly?

[atlballer81]

@Desttinyy Sorry, I never really cared about Elliot's looks but I heard alot of people say he is. I think it should be about the SINGING!

[mercedessss100]

@atlballer81 well I guess we have our own opinions & he was a HELL of a lot BETTER than Taylor Hicks Katherine should jave won that finale . But whatever it's over and done with now .

[SoftGuitar]

The making of a true Star.....she will go really far from her humble beginnings.

[MissRLA]

I don't really like her with the short blonde hair she has now. She looked nicer with long hair.

[princessanna57]

@MissRLA I haven't seen a pic of her with short blonde hair but that sounds ugly!

[MissRLA]

@pricessanna57 check out her single 'had it all' on youtube and you'll see her with short blonde hair.

[steamyboy69]

for me Katherine mcphee 's still pretty whatever hair she has, She played the pregnant teen in the 2008 film The Huse bunny ,right,?

[nocents81]

@steamyboy69 yes she did

[MIYOKOatl]

this is my favorite audition, I wished she would've stayed with that theme throughout her career though.....she would've been fantastic as a jazz artist!

[xStarheartx]

Of course she is singing! The audio is just off timing with the vid.

[puppies22724]

it does not look like she is singing

[qg6ff]

NO CRAP! The timing is off.

That's even more obvious...

duhhh

[puppies22724]

It looks like she is lip singing

[popcorn10124]

dude, if youre going to call someone out

spell lip SYNCING right

[soccer101sporty]

LimeAndCherryTree so agrre with u i hate taylor i called for katherine 5 and taylor still won geesh people why u have to like taylor

[cinqoctaves]

This is officialy the ONLY time when I found her voice outstanding.After she never reached that level

[uwoeric]

Probably cuz she's had months or even years to master this song, whereas the ones she had to do on the show she had about a week.

[StrawberryBigMac]

i totally agree she is stellar here

[artty132]

out.of.sync.

[DaniG13]

she was an amazing actress on house bunny!

[ducky811]

Katherine McPhee is one of my favs. I hope Katty Mac enjoys major success in love and marriage. She was so good it almost was not fair for the other competitors.

[carlotapuig]

Not only she was superior to the other competitors, she was by far the most beautiful and sexy contestant, and nevertheless not arrogant

[dbmd6892]

Katherine was robbed worse than Melinda Doolittle, considering that she was beaten by the worst singer to make it to the final rounds on AI.

[LimeAndCherryTree]

Hear, Hear!! taylor sucks!! The thing is, everyone seems to hate him... who in earth voted for him... and over KAT!!

[bwlingod26]

@LimeAndCherryTree chris daughtry should have won mcphee would ave taken second either way

[thewordthatpierces]

@dbmd6892 I highly disagree, Taylor is NOT a bad singer, he completely different kind of singer, Katherine has a wonderful voice, but Taylor does have a lot of expressiveness and he is a very good interpretive singer, which is just as impressive.

[lee4ivy]

i dunno about her general performances, but this has got to be one of the best auditions on idol.

[qtanna101]

what did u do to the video?? i watched this on teeveee and it wasnt like thiss. thee video is off from the soundd. -___- weiirrrdddddd

[doubleDdog09]

how come the sound is off from the video?

[blondiebabay999]

ok so she needed to win the only reason tayl0r won was bec they felt bad for him he song like a dying walrus!!!!!!!

GO KAT!!!!!!

[musiclover4life1991]

amazing voice!

[sarkey101]

McPhee's the best but this version needs to be removed- the audio and video are out of sync

[34cherry]

Do you think the marriage with her and Nick will last?

[chippie1024]

shes totally amazing!!Love her awesome voice!!

[necrowic]

the video is lagging...oh well.

[LaydeexKirsty]

Amazing!

[afrodude73]

there is no synchronicity between the voice and the video. But Katharin McPhee is awesome. I can't have enough of her!!! She's so beautiful and talented.

[BVLGARI99]

she is sooooo cute.....i love her so much!!!

[wannabeurbaby]

I love Kat