How would it be an insult if she didn't know who he was? She knows now doesn't she. You don't just come out of the womb with a knowledge of rock music. You have to discover these things in your own time.
I don't understand why everyone is upset with the girl doing these videos, she simply narrates it you don't need to be a Syd Barrett expert to read his Wikipedia page out loud...
wtf? no I dont want to see myself as a cartoon no I dont want to pimp my phone with a new ring tone. whats happening to youtube? I just wanna watch a vid about syd barret.
to be fair, she probably does tons of these things without knowing anything about the subject. the producers are the ones at fault, telling syd's story this way just dumbs it down; shes only doing her job.
Why is the song at the beginning and end "Let There Be More Light"? Syd didn't play on that song, it was all Gilmour. Nothing against Gilmour, but when you're doing a piece on Syd don't give us a song he isn't on. Would it really have been that hard to play "Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun" instead?
@pesmith8768 None of us 'know who Syd Barret was'. All we know is his work - the wonderful collection of single-minded expression. Unique. The band were great then too; young and wiry; lean yet rich-sounding. The thing is, if this little 'documentary' brings more 'salutes' to Syd then....ah what the fuck am I going on about? it's shit isn't it! Give her some acid and do her over her stupid chair....ice cream...tastes good if you eat it soon ! Good day!
This chick gets on my nerves. But its a good introduction to Syd I s'pose. I think she could have been more intellectual about it instead of so casual. Like...well here it is he was mentally ill. Simple story for the teenagers.
Love you Syd. Thank you darlin.
Too brilliant to live with the rest of the world. Thats all it was.
Wow, what a terrible reporter. Did you guys catch at the end where it shows the bald guy in the bookstore? That wasn't Syd. That was a spoof someone had done on a website {I can't remember which site but I just saw it the other day}. How pathetic that these people didn't even bother to check to see that the images they had of Syd were actually SYD! ManiaTV should be ashamed of this pathetic excuse for a tribute. Oh Syd - you deserved so much better than this.
This reporter sucks, and Syd didnt form Floyd he simply came up with the name, Roger, Nick, and Rick had already been playing together for some time before Syd entered the band.
It's obvious the 'reporter' doesn't know the first thing about Syd. I would almost guess she'd never heard of him before due to her young age. She sounds so scripted and mechanical. Wish they'd gotten someone to report it that felt something for Syd.
I think you are right. Yet, there are many young people who do appreciate Syd Barrett and are knowledgeable of him and his influence. This sounds like someone doing a book report using the old Cliff Notes.
How would it be an insult if she didn't know who he was? She knows now doesn't she. You don't just come out of the womb with a knowledge of rock music. You have to discover these things in your own time.
shatterdwing 9 months ago
Syd was not on acid in that short movie,just a bunch of crap,David Gale is in that movie and said, that syd was only immitating someone on acid.
jefduf 11 months ago
I don't understand why everyone is upset with the girl doing these videos, she simply narrates it you don't need to be a Syd Barrett expert to read his Wikipedia page out loud...
WolfpackUnleashed 1 year ago
From what I hear Syd chaged his name after a drug not a drummer.
93hipgnosis 1 year ago
@93hipgnosis wrong....he changed it based on a SAXOPHONIST in his hometown...he changed it SYD because the drummers name was SID Barrett.
harveydents 1 year ago
@harveydents Correct!
And SYD overrated but thats mho ...
Secondlifecreator 6 months ago
wtf? no I dont want to see myself as a cartoon no I dont want to pimp my phone with a new ring tone. whats happening to youtube? I just wanna watch a vid about syd barret.
patsyd80 1 year ago 3
to be fair, she probably does tons of these things without knowing anything about the subject. the producers are the ones at fault, telling syd's story this way just dumbs it down; shes only doing her job.
bopka45 1 year ago
Comment removed
Queslington 1 year ago
Comment removed
Queslington 1 year ago
Is she just reading his wikipedia article?
friendofidiocy 1 year ago
@friendofidiocy haha sounds exactly like it.
skint0n0minted 1 year ago
This is very very very poor
coldasbutter 1 year ago
She's a doll... some fat, sweating producer sent her this monologe and so she rehearsed it...
The result is an incomprehensive and boringly monotonous speech...
KissMyAssWMG 1 year ago 2
Did she say "Arnold Lame"?
I can't understand her focking voice.
There will never be another Syd Barrett.
Nobody will ever have that genius brain of his...
vminassa 1 year ago
Haha, totally! She's mumbling...
KissMyAssWMG 1 year ago
"syd, we salute you."
syd wouldn't have given a crap about being saluted.
nomorerocketships 2 years ago 4
Why is the song at the beginning and end "Let There Be More Light"? Syd didn't play on that song, it was all Gilmour. Nothing against Gilmour, but when you're doing a piece on Syd don't give us a song he isn't on. Would it really have been that hard to play "Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun" instead?
Hershberger24 2 years ago
@Hershberger24 - thank you! thats what i was about to say!
meltedcandlewax 2 years ago
"Syd, we salute you" She has absolutely no clue who Pink Floyd is, let alone Syd Barrett, what an insult.
pesmith8768 2 years ago 12
@pesmith8768 None of us 'know who Syd Barret was'. All we know is his work - the wonderful collection of single-minded expression. Unique. The band were great then too; young and wiry; lean yet rich-sounding. The thing is, if this little 'documentary' brings more 'salutes' to Syd then....ah what the fuck am I going on about? it's shit isn't it! Give her some acid and do her over her stupid chair....ice cream...tastes good if you eat it soon ! Good day!
theonlyantony 11 months ago
Well, she obviously got the job for how good her dictation actually was...off camera.
pesmith8768 2 years ago 4
This has got to be the most inexpressive reading of a teleprompter ever...her diction is awful, and voice horribly annoying
FantasticHysteric 2 years ago 4
SHINE ON !
lukolino03 2 years ago
yes, read that cue card you little tart
JesustheLizard 3 years ago 15
I agree body
siddartha1 2 years ago
SYD Is My idol
..crazy like am.
00Jose00 3 years ago
rip syd
lov u man
djdib 3 years ago
This chick gets on my nerves. But its a good introduction to Syd I s'pose. I think she could have been more intellectual about it instead of so casual. Like...well here it is he was mentally ill. Simple story for the teenagers.
Love you Syd. Thank you darlin.
Too brilliant to live with the rest of the world. Thats all it was.
stacyblue1980 3 years ago
she talks way to fast
poleradmas 3 years ago 2
This broad probabily never even knew the floyd before this assignment!
paddyoak 3 years ago 2
Hahaha! I was thinkin the same thing but you said it for the rest of us. She seems so fkn clueless. Thanks. XD
stacyblue1980 3 years ago
Como el PICO!!!
Madcapgrove 3 years ago
The picture at 3:18 is not Syd. It was a hoax posting on you tube showing a bald overweight guy in a story looking at magazines.
bocephus18 3 years ago 2
Hey, you're right.
66MadcapLaughs 2 years ago
this "reporter" should stick to fluff pieces of Paris, Britney & boy bands...
ravner1976 4 years ago
ug.
her airline stewardess voice just put me in a coma.
deconstructionist67 4 years ago 6
syd no muere sigue vivo en los corazones rockandroleros
saludos baby
panxitomoloko 4 years ago
For a better Syd story, search..."7 ages of Rock Syd"
dullsville 4 years ago 2
Wow, what a terrible reporter. Did you guys catch at the end where it shows the bald guy in the bookstore? That wasn't Syd. That was a spoof someone had done on a website {I can't remember which site but I just saw it the other day}. How pathetic that these people didn't even bother to check to see that the images they had of Syd were actually SYD! ManiaTV should be ashamed of this pathetic excuse for a tribute. Oh Syd - you deserved so much better than this.
gottalovesyd 4 years ago
I know, he does.
66MadcapLaughs 2 years ago
She must have researched with Wikipedia
jv4runner 4 years ago
This reporter sucks, and Syd didnt form Floyd he simply came up with the name, Roger, Nick, and Rick had already been playing together for some time before Syd entered the band.
fluffyruffy17 5 years ago
syd and roger did know each other from school when theys was kids
wuovp 4 years ago
youre right, alot of the information was wrong
buganey32 5 years ago
she says: " he took the name of a famous drummer named syd barrett " :|
I also wish someone told the story with more feeling, not in a 3 minut news.
fraserjeremy 5 years ago
he changed his first name to 'syd' after the local drummer 'sid barrett'
theverysexypanda90 3 years ago
syd is god
unseenbadass 5 years ago 2
yes he is....
66MadcapLaughs 2 years ago
Exactly my thoughts, but ahh, nomater that...
Artas1984 5 years ago
It's obvious the 'reporter' doesn't know the first thing about Syd. I would almost guess she'd never heard of him before due to her young age. She sounds so scripted and mechanical. Wish they'd gotten someone to report it that felt something for Syd.
sydsbluestar 5 years ago
I think you are right. Yet, there are many young people who do appreciate Syd Barrett and are knowledgeable of him and his influence. This sounds like someone doing a book report using the old Cliff Notes.
MKFaizi 5 years ago
im young and i love and appreciate syd but i know most kids dont :]
modandmarvelous 4 years ago
Yep, I can DEFINATLY relate to you there!!
66MadcapLaughs 2 years ago
<3Barrett®
Wannabeautiful 5 years ago
Good on them for honoring Syd, but they got a lot of the story wrong and used a pic that was supposed to be latter-day Syd that's been debunked.
creepus 5 years ago