Added: 4 years ago
From: Deepthroat1990
Views: 71,030
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (183)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • ChickenBone Nowison

  • shake junt brought me here!

  • 1968

  • Good call with this song!! Well played, Sir!

  • FIGGY!!

    

  • One of the best songs bob ever did

  • @Cooldude1956 Roll me away was great too.

  • one of the best songs bob every idi

  • Great song, thanks!

  • shake junt

  • he kicked that ass!  awesome BS

  • Justin "Figgy" and Don "The Nuge" are THE beasts !

  • CHICKEN BONE NOWISON !!!!

  • POW please come home ; (

  • press the thumbs up if u thought figgys tre bomb down that 5 flat 5flat 5 was orgasmic

  • fucking nuge and fucking figgy gnarly ass shit!!!

  • SHAKE JUNT! CHICKEN BONE NOWISON!

  • CHICKEN BONE NOWISON

  • I was blown way when Jack White said this was his favorite Seger song. This is a brilliant classic that nobody knows about and one of my all time favorite songs period. I always loved Jack and this made me have even more respect for him. Stop the WARS

  • this song is sick, keeps growing keeps bringing hype!

    Figgy is a beast!!

  • Amazing, absolutely amazing! :O Thanks for uploading! ;D

  • Oh yeah baby!! What a fu-kin turn on!!

  • one of the best protest songs ever

  • @wallosund Vietnam sucked AND was stupid.

  • Comment removed

  • Whoa! RulerL0rd, another Supernatural fan here now too! This song rocks! Very important message, too. That show uses excellent music, all the time! Thanks for posting, Deepthroat1990 ! :D

  • I don't know why nobody knows that this song is in reference to the novel 1984...when winston keeps tellon O'brien that two plus two is four not five and they keep torturing him. :)

  • @kiarahnama

    Wow never noticed that and thats my favorite book.

    Thats obviously not the main point of song though, as its a protest of the Vietnam War.

  • Here because of Jack White. I understand now why he likes this song.

  • @Cryptonyte1

    I can totally see Jack covering this

  • Jack White has good taste in music

  • wonderful :)

  • who's here because of Stephen Colbert's interview of Jack?

  • Who else is hear because of Jack White?

  • What wildhias said.

  • jack whyte on the colbert report broufht me here

  • @wildhias - Jack Whyte WOULD love this song.

  • @wildhias Me too! Haha.

  • @wildhias Jack is not only one of my favorite musicians, he also got good taste, this is his favorite bob song, but mine is. I dont know because bob got a lot of good songs, like Lucifer,Looking Back,White Wall, River Deep Mountain High, Teaching Blues, Mongrel, louise, You know who yo are.... man let me tell you this: Bob Newer stuff have nothing to do agaisnt the bob seger system albums and some of his first singles, too bad he doesnt sing this songs nowadays, only rambin gamblin man... : /

  • Thanks for the flashback!

  • caught bob seger,back in the hideout days at the k-of-c hall in clawson.one of the great wailers of all time.he did outstanding covers of old classics like tin soldier by the small faces,you keep me hanging on by vanilla fudge,and procul harems,whiter shade,of pale.just listen to his singing at the end of the single of heavy music.DEEPER,DEEPER ,DEEPER,hell yes!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Was just checkin' out the '67 riot on Wikipedia. I lived just west of downtown near Clark Park on W Vernor Hwy. We were under martial law for 4 days. I was 14 and I was ready to defend the neighborhood. Had a fishing pole loaded with a double, treble hook lure. And I could hit the telephone pole across the street about neck high every cast. It's a wonder I'm still alive =)

  • I grew up in Detroit but only saw Seger once in a battle of the bands at J.L. Hudson's Store. He's come a long way. I guess I have too.

    Great to hear this song again =) Thanks for posting.

  • @SixCards54

    PS: I also went to the Eastown a lot. It has been interesting reading the comments on here. How do you guys remember so much? lol

  • yeah heroin was the problem that took them down to a level less then heights they knew before. you know the second album had some good work and is viewed better today then then,but the reputation of the group as the "bad boys of detroit" started to slip as they distenced themselfs from sinclair...the general view I remember with fans were they "sold out to commercial intrests". they would forgive them for a less then great album, but not for going slick. I was born 1953 so we have common history

  • Damn here I go back into another Viet Nam flashback . Seger enough said

  • I heard this on the way to get a draft physical in '69.

  • bob played at my high school gym in troy michigan in 1969 or 70. even then he was trying to stay away from some earlier songs. I remember someone yelling for 2+2 and seger saying "naaaa.....we dont want to play that." for some reason I have never really heard him give an explanation for he is opposed to his early work. to bad....the bob seger system album,along with noah,and mongrel,albums feature the music detroit and ann arbor loved him for!

  • @TheBabyboomkidof53 Maybe Bob took a warning from his friends in the MC5 whose career's were killed by (among other things) their highly politicized early management. JUst a thought.

  • @newaccountdebzbd speaking as a detroiter, and actually from those days let me say this....just the opposit is true in the case of the MC5. they lost momentem when they tried to abandon their past and go commercial. perhaps you recently seen how detroiters served up charlie sheen on a platter when he decided to put on a show and be commercial and make money. detroiters will get up in your face if they see you backing away from a stance they endearingly know you for. it was'nt jonh sinclair.

  • @TheBabyboomkidof53 Hey, Homey. I'm an Eastsider, born '54. Alter-Warren and Jefferson-Chalmers. I've followed the '5 from Tartar field to the grim Park Shelby Rainbow Room, and was at Second Chance in Ann Arbor for taping of the triumphant resurgence of Fred Smith with Sonics Rendevoux. Not sure what you mean by them abandoning their past and going commercial. It was a stupid and pointless White Panther stunt that made Hudsons ban the sale of their first album. Next bad move was heroin....

  • @TheBabyboomkidof53 (hope my first comment gets posted) Local sales debacle cost them their Electra contract. But the heroin and their general naivete made them too stupid to see how hideously their second album was being produced. I should not have implied that Sinclair and his idiot cohorts were the five's total problem, but did them no good. I applaud your faith in Detroiters and share it to a degree. But only to a degree. So, what "stance" did Mr. Sheen have from which he could back away?

  • @newaccountdebzbd the hudsons deal I thought was in keeping with their persona. that was something we seen as anti establishment and we were noting if not anti establishment in those days.that endeared them all the more to us and made us go get the album. I dont think hudsons is what did their electra contract in. they just did'nt breakout beyond the area in big enough numbers. the record company was the culprit for poor sales by changing MF to brothers and sisters. it took the balls out of it.

  • @TheBabyboomkidof53 I guess we must agree to disagree. I recognize your viewpoint. There's a great site called something like the History of Southeastern Michigan rock ' roll -- at least those words are somewhere in the name -- and it's got the DL on just about everyone you or I could remember. If you haven't been there already, you should check it out. It's been good rapping with you (remember how we used to say rapping just to mean talking?) Take care.

  • @newaccountdebzbd yeah I still recall most of the old slang we used. I never told you about charlie sheen and detroit. charlie said the tour would be a lecture tour on the subject of taking on the power structure in the entertainment field and his battle with it. so detroiters went expecting such. instead they find charlie trying to do "standup comedian" type stuff. he also treats them to having his two "goddesses" making out and fondling eachother. they hated it. he backed off the tour pupose.

  • @newaccountdebzbd I'll check out the site you mentioned....did you know their is a grande ballroom site? its about the ballroom exspecially but everyone talks about the east town,birmingham paladium,hideout,silver bell, and all the others. just go to google and put in grande ballroom detroit michigan. peace.

  • @TheBabyboomkidof53 and @sixCards54 Hi I lived in Ann Arbor and know that Bob Seger went to school at what is now called Pioneer High. I saw him many times in Ann Arbor and one time in Oakland CA. Good times..keep bringing on the old songs..

  • There is smn strange about this man...Some strange energy, its like he was half a century ahead of his time. Amasing song, powerful, mysterious even.

  • I remember hearing this song on CKLW-The Big 8! Thanks for the memories Deepthroat1990.

  • Old Seager i love it!

  • talk about an anti viet nam war song this is a classic!!!!!

  • jasonpp1973 im with ya his ealy stuff with the last heard and the bob seger system is my favorite of all of bob segers catalog. I like pretty much everything hes done but the stuff from the 60's wow eo

  • amazing. 

  • A Supernatural fan was here!

  • @RulerL0rd Same here! :D And I also love this song!

  • @RulerL0rd beast!

  • Can't understand why Seger dislikes his early stuff? I like ALL phases of his incredible career. I got BOTH the Ramblin' Gambin Man and Mongrel CD's brand new back in the early 90's at the now defunct Circuit City for 8.99 each, before they went OOP! I WILL NEVER SELL THEM AS I TREASURE THEM SO MUCH!

  • @jasonpp1973 You are a very lucky person!

  • The Bob Seger System was the shit! When I turn people on 2 this stuff they cant believe this is the same guy who did "Old Time R&R"

  • One of my favs from '69.

  • great song

  • This is my favorite Bob Seger song to this day. I first saw a Seger concert at a Uof D High School dance when I was a freshman at CC. It is one of the best Vietnam War protest songs ever. Just chnge the words to over there in desert land and it has the same meaning for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and wherever we go next. Peace.

  • Got this from Amazon. Wasnt cheap though.

  • @tommy5075 can you tell me what you purchased so I can go to amazon as well?

  • For some reason, I can't find this album on any CD. Anyone know if it was ever made to one?

  • Bets Seger song ever! Deep meaning when I was a kid,

  • im in michigan born in jackson and live there!! seger motown nugent grand funk this is my hometown (home state ) music

  • its so simple , simple as the answer to 2+2 that is on his mind

    why was we fighting in nam , now the answer to that was not easy

  • If you change the words "buried in the mud on a foreign jungle land" to buired in the sand on a foreign desert land, unfortunately, nothing changes.

  • I'm feelin it

  • Joy rd @ Inkster here...Livonia corner.

  • @Deepthroat1990

    CKLW..The Motor City........Those hot summer nights in Gaylord we could still get the station.

  • @keefer2111 CKLW.....been years since I have heard those call letters. brings back a lot of memories though

  • Great song - thanks for sharing this! :)

  • This the kind of great music often overlooked or forgotten by mainstream radio, (yes, some of us still listen). Instead, they play the SAME Bob Seger hits over and over, in thier rotation of 60-70 songs.

  • Wow. Just wow. I miss Peter terribly. Dead of drugs, 1977.

  • The best riff ever.

  • Saw Bob at the Grosse Pointe War Memorial in December 1969? Some martian death flu was going around, so it was the bass player (Dan?) and 'Peppy' on drums and Bob Seger playing keyboards & guitar all night - opened with Rambling Gambling Man, remember that like yesterday!

  • Awesome

  • This version is missing the distorted slide guitar near the end where it goes quiet here.

  • @Greenames This is the LP mix; the one you're thinking of was the Capitol 45 single. They reportedly were afraid to release a single for airplay with six seconds of dead air in it, so they asked him to fill that space, and he did... with a guitar impression of a plane crash!

    Not that it mattered, it didn't get any airplay anyway. Great song, though.

  • Does anybody know where a person can get a copy of this great music??????

  • @jerryal1000 wal mart

  • Sweeeet! Haven't heard it since The Hideout days in the late 60s. Great Stuff!!

  • one of the earliest and best Vietnam War protest songs. Maybe on the Feel like I'm Fixing to Die rag by Country Joe comes close

  • Man...this track makes the hairs on my arms stand on end! Killer!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Released in 1968 after he signed with Capitol Records. They changed the group's name to the Bob Seger System. Ramblin', Gamblin' Man was the second song released in the summer of 1968. 2+2 was a huge hit in Detroit but my cousin in California had never heard of it until he visited Lansing, MI in the summer of 1968. He took the single back to Cali and played it for all of his friends in LA.

  • That's cool. I like this song also. I come from California, but don't live there now.

  • This song fits in now 2009 .......sigh ..so sad can we ever learn.

  • I wonder why he has not done this live

    By the way I love Fuzz guitar

  • I've got the 7" record of this. It rules ballz.

  • this song is differant

  • Best Seger song ever.

  • What year was this song?

  • 1969

  • oh wow... he sounds alot younger than that

  • Are you sure that's the exact year?

    Not only have I heard Ramblin Gamblin Man credited to 1968 but somebody mentioned this song was released in the summer of 68 months before the LP was released.

  • @Deepthroat1990

    got this on 7", think it was `68 ;).....

  • Comment removed

  • eas tside story and vagrant winters are my favorits from him, looove the old stuff....

  • @Deepthroat1990 earlier than that

  • @Deepthroat1990 Actually it's from early 1968, but included on the Ramblin' album from '69

  • @DMSOG it was during nam

  • amazing

  • Another amazing Early Seger classic. Thaks

  • This is the first time I've ever heard this track I've heard so much about it and always regretted that Seger won't allow his early work to be re-released. Songs like this are excellent examples of that amazing Motor City Soul/Rock style. Just a technical question, was this transferred from vinyl and "cleaned up" because I never knew of a digital version of this song or the album it came from? Thanks for getting this up on the 'tube!

  • yeah i think so...but i didnt do it by myself

  • @ronbo11 I hear ya. Seger's 60's output really needs to be officially released in remastered, pristine digital sound. I know there are a few bootlegs around that collect most of his early singles, but the packaging is shoddy and sonics sub par. Heard he won't release his "Back in '72" album because he didn't like a couple performances. A shame because it's one of his best albums.

  • @ronbo11 I can understand why he wouldn't want this re-released now considering it was written in the Vietnam Era. Some people might think he was trying to capitalize on that and he also might not be too proud of doing something like that. I say let his fans say whether its good or not to re-release. If we want to hear it its our choice. Hint Bob! We love ya man no matter when you released it.

  • @ronbo11 they have been rereleased i have them on new cds ive bought recently

  • This is my favourite Seger tune... although his ballad for the yellow beret is contrary to the sentiment of this track

  • It shows he's not a mindless Zealot but can understand all points of view.

  • Liberal!

  • Realistic.

  • Go Blue...

    Big Seger fan... searched a long time for this song.. Two vets in the family...yes war sucks..we can't back down...we have to continue to fight for freedom...freedom isn't free

  • If you are from Michigan SOUND OFF!

  • @keefer2111 Michigan girl and proud of it! You hear this song still on some of the classic rock stations. Not very often...

  • Man! that takes me back.

  • Thanks so, so much for posting this song! I heard a snippet of it once, and haven't been able to hear the whole song in good quality until now. I LOVE this song!!! Very good message and song! :)

  • 2nd that motion bettablue1

  • Cool

  • PHYCO DELIC

  • not really....its about vietnam war but never mind

  • Sorry it made such big picture in your mind , my brothe was 265 on the hat draft. His friends went and they to have bad memories...WAR SUCKS...My MoM lost 5 of her 7 brothers in WWII :-(

  • so you are about 80 years old?

  • Wow, I remember this song! I love its lyrics. Thanks for uploading it!

  • Man I hadn't heard this song in ages, thanks for posting it. It's sadly still true.

  • man this is a good son! thanks for posting it. you cant find this song anywhere, and i like the video quality

  • this is great, i wonder if it inspired radioheads 2+2=5 at all? who knows

  • Saw Seger play this at the Note at Gun Lake MI. about 1967 with Brownsville Station and several other groups. A day i'll never forget!

  • We watched him on a dirt road near Rochester 1972....WOW ...Great time...

  • rochester mi....? what rd.

  • Maybe its because of the University of FL being here, but Gainesville, FL had both Ramblin Gamblin Man and 2+2 on the airwaves when they were out. Now, those of us that know both songs are trying to find them - thank heaven for Ipods and their users! Glad to hear them both on You Tube.

  • This has been one of my favorite songs since high school. Unfortunately, if you change the words "buried in the mud in a foreign jungle land" to buried in the sand in a foreign desert land, nothing changes.

  • yes, sad but true

  • The Bob Seger System played at the legendary "Inferno" back in the summer of 1968. They played 2 plus 2 to a full house. At that time, the Bob Seger Systems equipment along with speakers must of cost no more than $500.00 tops! Tell you one thing, both sets they played were outstanding!

  • Great song! I can't believe you posted this song! I've lived in the U.S. for 51 years and I've never met anyone outside of Michigan or northern Ohio that ever heard of it. I grew up in the Pontiac Mich. area during the 60's and 70's it brings back a lot of great memories. Thanks for posting it!

  • great to hear that. I happened to heared that song a couple of years ago

  • This was a hit in Columbus Ohio

  • oh, you mean that state which elected Bush pres for a 2nd term? you mean that bridge to Kentucky from Michigan. I hate ohio...too many vowels

  • Yes...I can remember now...when I had to go out to the 141's to verify the can count back in the late 60's...I'd attest to anything to get out of the plane. You would hear this on AFR late at night depending on who was the DJ...but not very often...verboten!

  • F...ing EXCELLENT tune from the Fantastic "Ramblin' Gamblin' Man" album!!!

  • can anyone post SchoolTeacher by Seger, an intense rocker?

  • Still one of my favorite songs -- after all these years!

  • Just as powerful as when it came out.

  • Great song and really needed once again.

  • Man, i played this song in high school, thru a Vox Royal Guardsman amp and a homade fuzz pedal 1973 Dexter high-- Dexter Michigan, fuck what a hoot!! Still playin axe at 51 Whoo-hoo!

  • Righteous.

  • haven't heard this in forever. thanks! any chance ya have death row?

  • no sorry

  • Great song, brings back so many memories of the Detroit rock/ music scene of the late 60's early 70's. Put this song next to Fortunate Son by Creedence and Monster/Suicide by Steppenwolf and you see some of our best young minds commenting on mankinds need to take a good... long hard look in the mirror and asK WHAT IS THE POINT?

  • Great lost Seger classic. Playing in my memory for years.