Scala and Kolacny Brothers - With or Without You

[RCD608]

Thumbs up if you are here for Derek Brien (R.I.P buddy. You were a inspiration to a lot of people).

[rentahubby1]

Beautiful

[wishing2fly]

And they say pop songs don't work in a classical setting.

[SuperScott2010]

that girl in the back at 0:45 looks like a young Lady Edith

[DuchessAliana]

This version reminds me of Katniss singing to Rue in The Hunger Games. It fits the pain of that scene so perfectly that I'm seriously close to tears right now. Poor Rue :'(

[magicmisti]

Thumbs up if you appreciated good music before you watched crap t.v shows.

[kamuigaga]

smashing looks, smashing voices. 240p didn't give them any justice.

[RoryAstenBell]

If you love this kind of music please take 3 minutes and listen to a song me and my friend did on my profile please. You'll like it if you like beautiful women and pianos. She's a right stunner take a look please :)

[ifann88]

Downton Abbey brought me here.

[Jp4lcfc1993]

play it with /watch?v=AYw7eJYadco

[marleyisthebest]

Hollyoaks :') xx

[spannahan]

Hollyoaks :')

[PoliticalZachG]

Thumbs up if you're here because of Downton Abbey!

[coachleenie1938]

This is so beautiful it just takes me to a special place in my head. Thank you.

[GleekChannel]

DOWNTON ABBEY!!! <3

[Greenockianx]

Wow!!!!!

[1234Zoex]

They sing this really well, but the video creeps me out, it is a sad and emotional song and they are all weirdly smiling at the camera =/ lol

[TheRadicalNights]

downton abbey!

[Jenj073]

Hollyoaks. beautiful song

[lispecial175]

How can any musical retard dislike this?

[justsomewammyskid]

@lispecial175 they were so blinded with tears that they missed the like button

[k0alatea]

Doug :'(

[MissHenny98]

im here because of hollyoaks ;)

[benbenalen]

@MissHenny98

Me too, I googled the lyrics

[MissHenny98]

@benbenalen haha, me too!;D

[jkws2007]

@MissHenny98 me 2 :)

[alvarezdhy]

watch something funny

youtube user mychonny

[pownallcross]

I'm here because I have taste in music. Not because of a tv program!!

[RedaIex]

Hollyoaks and Downton Abbey. =) Merry Christmas!

[StreetArtist1995]

like if you're here because of hollyoaks 23/12/11

[MissHenny98]

@StreetArtist1995 Doug scared me :(

[soots1978]

love this version very pure voices keep up the good work

[havanna1860]

Wow...So clear...

[mumnursewife]

Amazing version.

[alanwoodall]

Simply beautiful rendition.

[iiFyoUCK]

OMFGOOSEBUMPS!

[ansoerrealzale]

increible...

[uwesersch]

diese musik ist wie medizin. als es mir sehr schlecht ging und ich kurz vor dem letzten schritt stand, hörte ich diesen song und es wurde alles wieder lebenswerter. scala und kolacny brothers müsste es auf ärztliche anordnung geben. auch dem medizinschen personal fiel das auf.

[xyoojtsimnuj]

So RELAXING........

[toomanycats305]

I heard this on my public broadcast station last night and had to write it down. I just ordered their CD...AMAZING...gives me chills!

[tomaca14]

I want this played at my funeral.

[TheMamacona]

!Que hermosas voces !!! para tan linda cancion

[damusicjunkie96]

voices of angels :)

[hiearthling]

Wow, this is the most relaxing music!!! :-) Im opening iTunes already

[hiccups141]

this song was played on a retreat I went on with my school and moved me to tears. Incredible

[adenandnic4eva]

Wow i mean Wow what a group !! GO ON X FACTOR

[coffeepie]

I must say I find this version SO much more beautiful than the original even (which I love), it's haunting and intense and tender

[K1WORLD]

Downton Abbey Forever!!!!!

[Darcy4562]

Beautiful Piano playing :)

[lifeismusic38]

love this xx

[MichelAngeloCap]

Dear Wilma.. i cant live without you.. you`re two weeks gone and i miss you so much... love you 4-ever !!!

[rbain007]

Arrgghhh!!! The season finale of Downton Abbey is in 2 days!!! Just listening to this song makes me want to cry!!! Especially at 3:16 !!!!!

[DannyJvideos]

What a beautiful song. :')

[bribiba]

I love this so haunting and beautifully done.

[meestryal]

Saw this very song in Villers-la-Ville Abbey 4 years ago. I don't think I'll forget that night. I don't even like U2, but this is some powerful stuff.

[nigriffi]

my choir did this when I was in school, brings back memories! :) search "Pres choir with or without you" if you want to hear!

[blackrebel0]

Their version of French singer Raphael`s Caravane is stunning.

[ashleyxms]

Amazing



[JustMe828282]

Beautiful! I get tears in my eyes!

[LoltotheHol]

downton abbey.. you have good taste in music!!

[masht11]

Stanley Kubrick - The Works

[TheFilmCuts]

@masht11

Indeed!

[blackrebel0]

If you like this, listen to their version of Counting Crows` " Colorblind "

[XxHakunaXxMatata]

Totally amazeballs!!! I heard this on the Downton abbey advert and finally tracked it down!!!

[NeilJones1973]

Oh. My. God. Absolutely AWESOME. Love it!

[davidcurran87]

never heard of them until downton abbey. But now i have their album and its really good>>>>>........

[maiii0608]

gosh, i really got goosebumps in the first 5 SECONDS! so beautiful x3

[The47thbelmon]

I heard it on the Downton Abbey advert too...it's such a beautiful version!

[imedi]

the beauty of u2s lyrics and soul in scalas voices perfect combo

[MauriceLAFIT]

better than U2's version, thank u downton abbey for showing us this version!!

[015LiiS]

Muy Buenoo

[xvilmagirlx]

beautiful cover, im loving it.

love from Finland ^^

[2011TheSaturdays]

They're AMAZING!

[MissSiriusBlack]

number 1 on irish itunes (: thank you downton abbey ad :D soooo good (:

[Shakyfan1970]

Number 6 in the Irish singles chart this week!

[tkeegan2336]

Well done UTV for lanuching this Song!

[bedonkadonkdonk]

@essmbee , currently No 1 ON ITUNES :D

[bedonkadonkdonk]

I liked U2's version. But this makes me cry.. Much more emotional.

[annefan235]

LOVE THIS SONG SOOO MUCH. I HEARD IT FROM DOWNTON ABBEY AND KEEP PLAYING THE DOWNTON ABBEY AD JUST TO HEAR IT :)

[sophieee98xo]

I love this song and want to learn it on piano but i can't find anything to teach me it! :(

[mellowsman]

cant stop listening to this... changed this song completely for me!

[ilovecdn]

absolutely amazing.

[essmbee]

currently no 6 on the Itunes chart

[PsychoBisket]

what is a weekend?

[uLabelmePink]

omg this video is 5 years old :0

[ThisEveningsPortrait]

This song made me want to watch downton abbey! Its TOO good!

[ssecretloverr]

Trying to watch the X Factor, and keep getting distracted by this awesome song! I shall have to watch Downton Abbey now...!

[Lalelu9901]

This is so beautiful, i have tears in my eyes, listening to this, it's just amazing! Thank you for this beautiful peace! <3

[Spuddy0108]

Who the fuck is Downton Abbey?!?

[2011TheSaturdays]

@Spuddy0108 tv show, this is on the ad

[7xXSE7ENXx7]

silly tarts

[imaginarylives]

I've known this long before Downton Abbey (as Scala, I'm from Belgium), but it's great that it brought so many people here.

[anitawee]

@imaginarylives I got introduced to Scala from the version of Creep they did for the film The Social Network.

[leishyb]

@anitawee love their version of creep too..

[hannarebecca19]

soo beautiful is this on itunes?? want this on repeat!

[MrBumnut1234]

Wonderful! All in sinc, sounds great!

[ElizabethBennet17]

wow, this has given me goosebumps, not many songs can do that to me.



[xXAmyDHXx]

I love this... thanks to the Downton Abbey advert!

[arkanox111]

@xXAmyDHXx THe British WW1 soap opera?

[Blogkingdom]

@arkanox111 The term we use is period drama. Series 1 wasn't WWI.

[2frey84]

this is so beautiful, can't stop listening to it, so glad I saw the trailer for downton abbey!

[Gymnasticscrazy27]

The true meaning of angels ♥

[Tim0500]

Don't know what else to add to what people have already said. This choir is simply awesome. Look at all the wannabe's on X-Factor, with a very few exceptions, and then look at this........no comparison what so ever. This song is absolutely amazing. They deserve all the success they get.

[nicool1987]

CHECK OUT PRES CHOIR SINGING WITH OR WITHOUT YOU SEE WHAT YA THINK..:)

[KittehHawk]

Yes, I heard this on the Downton Abbey advert on ITV, but the reason I decided to try and find the song is because the trailer moved me to tears. I personally think the advert should win an award (I know, it sounds silly). It's one of the best adverts I have ever seen for a TV series. This version of With Or Without You is just beautiful, angelic even. I don't even like Downton Abbey!

[FloraJay]

@KittehHawk I totally agree with you. That advert almost made me cry and I've never even watched the program so it's not like i'm attached to any of the characters.

[Darcy4562]

@KittehHawk wait.... you dont like Downton Abbey?! WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU?!?!

[KittehHawk]

@Darcy4562 LOL I'm sorry, I tried to watch it a few weeks back, but I just didn't like it. Please don't hate me :)

[Darcy4562]

@KittehHawk Apology Accepted :D

[smclo03]

@KittehHawk I can relate especially the last thing you said:)

[kissefur80]

U2?? U2 who?? this arrangment is SO freaking amazing, its magical, think i'm gonna have to think bout buying the album

[isabel5176]

amazing ....this song made me cry :'( ...and you give yourself away and i give myself away ....WITH OR WITHOUT YOU <3<3 I LOVE THIS SONG

[marqueeman54]

Ok Downton Abbey brought me here this time, but it was their work with Milk Inc....especially "Wide Awake"...that brought me here a long time ago....their voices are incredible....love this

[davebeales1]

cant wait till they come back to the uk

[oldishjack]

Superb

[fromsmallacorns]

goosebumps, a gorgeous choir, they manage covers so so well.

[loonygoldfish]

whoever makes the downton abbey trailers has great taste in music

first Every Breath You Take and now this... outstanding

[tplami]

I don't have any words to describe the magnificent of this song.

[Miloloverforever]

Heard it on the advert for Downton Abbey and had to find it cause its just too brilliant!

[here4alaff1]

How BRILLIANT is this ?? Bono..eat your heart out; SCALA blow u2 out of the water on this .. and Yes , Downton brought me here as i had to find out who had done that version. LOVE IT LOVE IT LOVE IT !!!

[eliseee1992]

lovely, but can't take 'with or without chawww' seriously...

[mr1168726]

U 2 Being a Crap band, led by a posing " save the worlder ", should be grateful for this lovely version being released.

[angloitalian1]

This is  just beautiful xx

[guavamutt]

i actually love you guys and the cover of this song, one of the best songs of all time! been singing it all day, gave me chills the first time xxx

[MrElliotbyrne]

this is fucking incredible

[Charlottaaa1]

is it just me or can you hear some squeaking noises occasionally?... I hope i'm not going mad :|

[drummer4916]

glorious.

[NinjaaUnicorn]

Woah.



[altizzle22]

Can't wait for Downton Abbey to be back!! The promo looks brilliant!

[joshalos1]

Downtown Abbey. You brought me to Scala from season 1 with Every Breath You Take. Please, bring me here year after year. <3

[joshalos1]

Downtown Abbey <3

[Padingtonslamin]

quite possibly the shittest video ever. still, nice song...

[LarLarLand100]

Downton Abbey season 2!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! <3

[jambbie]

magical

[Charlottaaa1]

A beautiful song sung by beautiful people with beautiful voices,so inspiring,24 people must be deaf,you cant dislike this amazing singing!

[helstan]

Beautiful

[vidsbygeeksrus]

beautiful :) x

[chrisiesim1]

This song is lush, but gotta say the video is a bit weird :S

[badgern100]

awe inspiring

[mi9worm]

Lyric meaning doesn't really fit!!

[hawkbit13]

I just thought this was something done for the ITV ad...Im so pleased and happy to find its a full song!

[ThePinklady55]

The original U2 version is amazing....but omg this touches so many nerves it's truly inspirational...its going on my favourites list right now as I want to listen to this over & over again !!

[RadcliffeWatson]

So beautiful. When I saw the Downton Abbey trailer it just made me cry. What an amazing piece.

[GreenEyez1982]

Just saw this on a trailer for Downton Abbey and it sent shivers down me - had to find out who it was - amazing

[rebeccasweenz]

This makes me miss being in a choir :( Beautiful <3 Their version of 'Creep' is Amazing!

[YorkGod1]

Hell that touched a nerve i just began to cry!!!!

[loonygoldfish]

Quite ironic that i'm listening to this just after being in Berlin and seeing all those sights in this video :D

[TwentyEightySeven]

Also heard it on the Downton Abbey advert, such an amazing U2 cover.

[SuperAlexWall]

im 13... hate chiors normaly but this one is so nice yet so fun

[rattleandhumgirl]

the string arrangement is stunning!!! the voices are beautiful, I love it

[MrCoronary]

heard this song on the advert of Downton Abbey, a tv show in the uk, had to find it and glad i did

Pure awesome

[MrEggman2009]

This has just reset everything I thought I originally knew about music.

A truly beautiful piece of music. Nothing more can be said.

[betunysangre]

Thumbs up if Downton Abbey brought you here <3

[tuandybonita]

I met this choir through a friend! I met them with the cover of smell like teen spirit and now I love scala

[SwanKnight700]

That let me believe in a world with peace, charity and happiness and without hatred, hurt and grief. This is so heavenly beautiful.

[boudavin]

when they all laugh its obvious someone farted, about 4 of em hold there nose!

[QueenBeeLW]

SHIVERS!!!

[44Neely44]

I found my new favourite Youtube video.

[19dec1981]

1:25 cuteness

[genigore]

chilling, just chilling.

[hendric1000]

1:25 i want to be the busdriver

[PunkWUR1983]

2:30 Gänsehaut....

[Blasenfuss]

23 people are without you...

[ninnypiggy]

huh I cried to this :-/ normally never do

[fr33d0m0f3xpr3ss10n]

So incredibly beautiful.

[livremm]

lindo!!! momentos que alegram nossa alma

[Looking4UserNamesSux]

i want to buy you... get on itunes... grrr

[slickcross]

My heart is about to pop out of my chest. Tremendous job

[luisronaldofigo]

creepy how they look at the camera

[mooncapsule]

terrible! wonderful, so beautiful, big up ladies!!!!

[micvrom]

By 3:17 my eyes are already watery, not knowing there was more to come. Truly mindblowing.

[micvrom]

Just wow.

[drohegda]

exactly who gets to pick who comments stay's and who's goes. youtube