That is obviously live, and my ear can hear a difference between the live and the studio version. Don't be jealous because Christina can actually sing live. Pointless video.
Lame, if you're going to accuse her of using playback you should find better examples. 0:55 - 1:01 you can hear the difference cuz the first take is shakier than the second. Also, 1:29 - 1:40 you can hear her voice gets unbalanced due to the dancing in the second clip. It's not her fault she's an amazing singer who wants to give her fans consistently amazing performances...Geez you people are lame.
oh please.. just because she has the talent to sing almost identical to the studio version... does not mean she lipsyncs.. lol...
look at Mariah, or Whitney (in her non drugged up days), beyonce, etta james etc... they all sound amazing live and almost identical to the studio version and other live performances...
im going to say that this video is a fail .. at trying to belittle an extremely talented woman
lmao tghe *oh*sound different...if u hate her so much why do u go getting her vids and listening to it O.o lmao play back hahahaahah pklayback ohh wow...lame
so she's supposed to make up a completely different coreography for the same song?! 'Putinagritera2' - I know you're a bit of a knobhead, but i didn't know you were mentally retarded aswell!!
It's pretty obvious to all sane people she isnt miming! And queen of playback? Hunni, I think you spelt playback wrong, it should be spelt M-U-S-I-C
like someone else said "if you did watch the back to basics tour in some songs you can hear her tick on the mic". plus, the second video looks like a special on tv. sometimes artists use playback on tv shows because they have no time to rehearse or they don't have an appropriate equipment, THIS IS A FACT. last, can you really prove it? with ANY video editing software, you could (I'm not blaming you but... you know...) extract an audio track (yeah, even the same track!) and lay upon a video...
like someone else said "if you did watch the back to basics tour in some songs you can hear her tick on the mic". plus, the second video looks like a special on tv. sometimes artists use playback on tv shows because they have no time to rehearse or they don't have an appropriate equipment, THIS IS A FACT. last, can you really prove it? with ANY video editing software, you could (I'm not blaming you but... you know...) extract an audio track (yeah, even the same track!) and lay upon a video...
like someone else said "if you did watch the back to basics tour in some songs you can hear her tick on the mic". plus, the second video looks like a special on tv. sometimes artists use playback on tv shows because they have no time to rehearse or they don't have an appropriate equipment, THIS IS A FACT. last, can you really prove it? with ANY video editing software, you could (I'm not blaming you but... you know...) extract an audio track (yeah, even the same track!) and lay upon a video...
Christina the queen of playback? You are a fucking joke! Christina actually sings! PIGney Spears cant sing for shit and she proved that when HBO recorded her real voice in 2001.
PIGney fans, get a life. Christina forever shits all over PIGney!
on attend de voir et jespère quon sera pas déçu! cette fille a du coffre, du talent et est connue pour çanon pas pour sa vie privée comme sa pathétique consoeur pigney!
je lui souhaite un retour glorieux
et pour moi cest une vraie artiste qui bosse.elle est dans la trampe madonna
She wasn't lip-syncing you retards just can't fucking tell whether its lip-syncing or live, I went to this tour and it was live and you could tell it was, just cause she can sing the same way she did on her tour and on another show WHICH WAS SANG LIVE does not mean its lip-syncing! Its cause she has the voice to pull it off un like some other ppl!
wow... people are actually retarded enough to think she lipsyncs?
look at mariah carey and whitney houston etc... their live performances are same as the others... because, like christina, they have the voice and musical talent to do that... unlike shitney and you lowlives who hide behind computer because you cannot sing for shit without killing everyone
I asked a question, you didn't answer it. Where is the proof. & your previously calling xtina a bitch on this video, doesn't make your statement seem plausible.
first this is one of the proof that u refuse to believe , and for the average people she is lipsynching , just type xtina lipsynching or something , i forget the name of the video !
what's worst than having a weak voice and lip sync is HAVING A STRONG VOICE BUT STILL LIP SYNC , why isn't she singing live ?!?!?!? !?!?!??!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!what's the reason ?!?!?!?!?!??!?!?!??!?!?!
ok maybe Britney lyp sinc too but Britney's voice deteriorated for unknown reasons... so she use playback, this is an excuse, what about Christina ???
deteriorated??? dude u still think she ever had a voice to sing??? have u seen spears vma performances, have u been at any of those circus show starrin: play back!!!!!!christina needs to care about her voice, cause it is a treasure, and yeah, that is the excuse. But if u don't have a voice to care why should u use playback?? to make some one believe u at least try to deliver an average show....even though promotion says: LIVE!!!
go and watch what britney's voice was like when she was at the mickeymouse club and explain me why it isn't like that anymore, unlike justin and christina ....
britney had an amazing voice , in her baby one more time era and below it , her voice was way way stronger then xtina trust me i saw video of them britney would beat the shit out of her but now britney is all about dancing and singing 2 but not very much ! britney sang you oughta know live on circus tour it was amazing !
Freaking out over a single video acting like its some crazy conspiracy to take down and tarnish Aguilera's name.
All I have to say is some fans need to learn to take what they dish out. Always dissing Britney for lip syncing and acting like Christina is some super women who would never do such a thing when I'm sure C has done it atleast once before.
ooo si esto es playback, lo que yo noto xD es que ella hace la grabacion con notas altas xD claaaro si aleja y acerca el microfono y total se le oye igual jasjdajdsjajsdjsajdjajdajdjajsdjasd
i dont get why it's okay for BRITNEY!!( who i actually do like) to lipsync while doing "energetic routines" but when christina ( who is my idol :D ) can't what is it one rule for one and one rule for another?? the person who made this video needs to wake up and smell the coffee, its pathetic that you make them hahaha!! it's okay we can just compare all the other live outstanding performances to britneys oh ... wait ....
no its because many people are complaining about britney lypsynching..while xtina does it many times but no one bitching her.. xtina is also expert when it comes to playback!
fair enough but christina has got talent, so has britney but, tbh this whole britney christina thing has bored me now, its silly, and christina has sung more live than britney, who cared they are both great artists just a shame the way the media portrays them :/ but i do love christina
That Christina always sings live, not like Britney that always lipsycs. By the way one of the most powerfull voices, 4 grammys and has a worderfull family. Something that a drug adict, crazy depressive, lipsync singer and horrible performer like the MTV VMA'S it wishes to have. Thank you!
playbackkk!!!!!!!!!!!!!! maldita perra escandalosa ajajajaj todas las canciones de esta zorra son el mismo grito destroza timpanos ,tras de que ni baila ni hace coreo y swolo grita hace playback ajjajaj pobre perra!!
what an indiot, it's obvious that she sings live, i guess you are a Britney Spears fan (xtina's haters). Britney is the true Queen of playback. But i don't hate her, i like her music, i don't waste my time hating people.
Q idiota eres, es obio q ella canta en vivo, es gracioso ver lo q haces, hasta dond llegas con la envidia o no se q es lo q tienes contra ella. Por cierto Britney es la Reina del Playback, no Christina. Pero me gusta mucho la música de Britney.
everybody knows she lip syncs!!! she has a powerful voice, so nobody suspects, BUT, AT LEAST ain't no other man and candyman were playback at the B2B tour!
i don't know the rest, cause i haven't seen the whole show!
at her B2B tour was live because even the F#5 she did there was a bit longer than the studio version and you can hear some differences between these two performances. moreover in candyman she just lipped her E5, the rest was live
Si chirstina graba sus canciones y las usa en algunas presentaciones es para cuidar su voz, en serio no tengo nada contra spears, pero etso me molesta, ella no tiene q cuidar su voz porque no la tiene, y por eso todo el tiempo canta con pista. No te parece mediocre, insultante y falso que un emocionado fan diga "y hasta canta en vivo algunas de sus canciones!", en un tour que dice "Britney Live!"...hahahaha esto si me ha hecho reir, sigue así, nunk me viene mal reírme un rato al día
i think you love christina, when you spend so much time to find fails.i mean, all of this where live
CooolioBaby 1 month ago
christina is amazing!! buscate una vida amigo recuerda que la envidia es el mayor homenaje que la mediocridad le rinde al talento
Xtinobma 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos
Perra no sabes que hacer de la desesperacion viejo asqueroso Xtina es magica eso es cantar tarado tarado infeliz comprate una vida
EDISONSMILER 4 months ago
gilipollas la cancion va aser igul no?? y un gritito lo ace mas larga
DDmusic24 5 months ago
Right it's her song she can sing it how she wants too.. It's called experimenting and that's what she's doing obv's!!
clibopink123 6 months ago
OMG!! how wrong these, you can say BRITNEY the queen of PLAYBACK
its ridiculous this video
aapascrom96 7 months ago
britney always does playback! is real QUEEN OF PLAYBACK stupid!
asdf090380 9 months ago
She is actually singing. She doesn't lipsync ever.
ticklemetyler3392 11 months ago
This is live come on!! You are so jealous your face must be green...
jennifernew21 1 year ago 2
so what
she's amazing :P
we love her ever
Xtinaa4ever 1 year ago 2
Nice try but that was live, just admit it Britney is god of lipsynching and playback, sorry! (britney fan)
shazu1990 1 year ago
That is obviously live, and my ear can hear a difference between the live and the studio version. Don't be jealous because Christina can actually sing live. Pointless video.
budavo97 1 year ago
Lame, if you're going to accuse her of using playback you should find better examples. 0:55 - 1:01 you can hear the difference cuz the first take is shakier than the second. Also, 1:29 - 1:40 you can hear her voice gets unbalanced due to the dancing in the second clip. It's not her fault she's an amazing singer who wants to give her fans consistently amazing performances...Geez you people are lame.
asciisski 1 year ago 4
I think putinagritera2 'love' making this 'hate' video while listening to christina's song.
nestcompany 1 year ago 3
it's a different note, run and everything, it's not a playback
bonniepink19 1 year ago
oh please.. just because she has the talent to sing almost identical to the studio version... does not mean she lipsyncs.. lol...
look at Mariah, or Whitney (in her non drugged up days), beyonce, etta james etc... they all sound amazing live and almost identical to the studio version and other live performances...
im going to say that this video is a fail .. at trying to belittle an extremely talented woman
UnleashTheVoice 1 year ago
SO becuz Christina Aguilera is ALWAYS amazing it can't be her LIVE??? THINK AGAIN! THAT IS WHAT GREATNESS DOES!!!
earlearlerica 1 year ago
Xtina lo hace tan bien que no es necesario que lo haga mas veces, con una basta!!XD
La gente decia que Michael jackson hacia siempre playback, la verdad es que su voz siempre le salia igual. A eso se llama talento
soulandmore 1 year ago
asshole you're a shtter xtina don't sing some high note during the concerts -.-
giammy96ctr 1 year ago
OOOH! SOO THIS IS PLAYBACK?? HAHAHA FAILED! BEST VOICE EVR!
frannco027 1 year ago
do u know what is playback ???
brucioz 1 year ago
hater
ddtluna 1 year ago
Eso no es playback solo que el sonido se oye más alto idiota!
Nancynaughty 1 year ago
She Is the QUeen Of The ZOo jajaj
tadeoboy 1 year ago
lmao tghe *oh*sound different...if u hate her so much why do u go getting her vids and listening to it O.o lmao play back hahahaahah pklayback ohh wow...lame
JulyzW0rld 1 year ago
so she's supposed to make up a completely different coreography for the same song?! 'Putinagritera2' - I know you're a bit of a knobhead, but i didn't know you were mentally retarded aswell!!
It's pretty obvious to all sane people she isnt miming! And queen of playback? Hunni, I think you spelt playback wrong, it should be spelt M-U-S-I-C
xXxl0tti3xXx 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
like someone else said "if you did watch the back to basics tour in some songs you can hear her tick on the mic". plus, the second video looks like a special on tv. sometimes artists use playback on tv shows because they have no time to rehearse or they don't have an appropriate equipment, THIS IS A FACT. last, can you really prove it? with ANY video editing software, you could (I'm not blaming you but... you know...) extract an audio track (yeah, even the same track!) and lay upon a video...
calamic 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
like someone else said "if you did watch the back to basics tour in some songs you can hear her tick on the mic". plus, the second video looks like a special on tv. sometimes artists use playback on tv shows because they have no time to rehearse or they don't have an appropriate equipment, THIS IS A FACT. last, can you really prove it? with ANY video editing software, you could (I'm not blaming you but... you know...) extract an audio track (yeah, even the same track!) and lay upon a video...
calamic 2 years ago
like someone else said "if you did watch the back to basics tour in some songs you can hear her tick on the mic". plus, the second video looks like a special on tv. sometimes artists use playback on tv shows because they have no time to rehearse or they don't have an appropriate equipment, THIS IS A FACT. last, can you really prove it? with ANY video editing software, you could (I'm not blaming you but... you know...) extract an audio track (yeah, even the same track!) and lay upon a video...
calamic 2 years ago
I can't believe it, but she also lypsynch. Dunno how Xtina fans can criticise Britney's playback when she at least dances...
PieroMG28 2 years ago
@PieroMG28 She is not making playbak, listen, every video sound a little different
angie9222 1 year ago
Christina the queen of playback? You are a fucking joke! Christina actually sings! PIGney Spears cant sing for shit and she proved that when HBO recorded her real voice in 2001.
PIGney fans, get a life. Christina forever shits all over PIGney!
magyarwho 2 years ago
on attend de voir et jespère quon sera pas déçu! cette fille a du coffre, du talent et est connue pour çanon pas pour sa vie privée comme sa pathétique consoeur pigney!
je lui souhaite un retour glorieux
et pour moi cest une vraie artiste qui bosse.elle est dans la trampe madonna
1921kev1 2 years ago
OMG!! she is an Epic fail!!! .. at least britney always used her lip lipsynching because of dancin.. now waths xtina's talent??? LMAOOO!!!!
bribribritbrit 2 years ago 2
haha
sorry but .. the queen of the play back is actually britney spears :D
maybe u are confusin' britney spears with Christina Aguilera :D
pakoiamme 2 years ago
She wasn't lip-syncing you retards just can't fucking tell whether its lip-syncing or live, I went to this tour and it was live and you could tell it was, just cause she can sing the same way she did on her tour and on another show WHICH WAS SANG LIVE does not mean its lip-syncing! Its cause she has the voice to pull it off un like some other ppl!
xtinaandravenfan 2 years ago
wow... people are actually retarded enough to think she lipsyncs?
look at mariah carey and whitney houston etc... their live performances are same as the others... because, like christina, they have the voice and musical talent to do that... unlike shitney and you lowlives who hide behind computer because you cannot sing for shit without killing everyone
sproggos 2 years ago
Could you at least prove where it is playback if you're gonna say that. Because to average people, it looks like she's singing live
LifeisMusic07 2 years ago
she is lipsynching come on wake up stop living in a lie ! other video proove it also !
1riicardoo1 2 years ago
I asked a question, you didn't answer it. Where is the proof. & your previously calling xtina a bitch on this video, doesn't make your statement seem plausible.
LifeisMusic07 2 years ago
first this is one of the proof that u refuse to believe , and for the average people she is lipsynching , just type xtina lipsynching or something , i forget the name of the video !
1riicardoo1 2 years ago
...................
LifeisMusic07 2 years ago
what's worst than having a weak voice and lip sync is HAVING A STRONG VOICE BUT STILL LIP SYNC , why isn't she singing live ?!?!?!? !?!?!??!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!what's the reason ?!?!?!?!?!??!?!?!??!?!?!
ok maybe Britney lyp sinc too but Britney's voice deteriorated for unknown reasons... so she use playback, this is an excuse, what about Christina ???
SHITtina666 2 years ago 2
deteriorated??? dude u still think she ever had a voice to sing??? have u seen spears vma performances, have u been at any of those circus show starrin: play back!!!!!!christina needs to care about her voice, cause it is a treasure, and yeah, that is the excuse. But if u don't have a voice to care why should u use playback?? to make some one believe u at least try to deliver an average show....even though promotion says: LIVE!!!
Cristiano0oKISS 2 years ago
go and watch what britney's voice was like when she was at the mickeymouse club and explain me why it isn't like that anymore, unlike justin and christina ....
SHITtina666 2 years ago
britney had an amazing voice , in her baby one more time era and below it , her voice was way way stronger then xtina trust me i saw video of them britney would beat the shit out of her but now britney is all about dancing and singing 2 but not very much ! britney sang you oughta know live on circus tour it was amazing !
ur excuse of xtina lipsynching is retarded
1riicardoo1 2 years ago
xtina is bitch
1riicardoo1 2 years ago
Aww looks like the person who made this video is a flop.
playinaclown 2 years ago
Some of you are so paranoid lmao
Freaking out over a single video acting like its some crazy conspiracy to take down and tarnish Aguilera's name.
All I have to say is some fans need to learn to take what they dish out. Always dissing Britney for lip syncing and acting like Christina is some super women who would never do such a thing when I'm sure C has done it atleast once before.
2OOPoVstrechnoy 2 years ago
britney lip-sync all the time ??
why make a video with some one that has a voice ??
tinkerbellxx101 2 years ago
ooo si esto es playback, lo que yo noto xD es que ella hace la grabacion con notas altas xD claaaro si aleja y acerca el microfono y total se le oye igual jasjdajdsjajsdjsajdjajdajdjajsdjasd
BiiRdYe 2 years ago
i dont get why it's okay for BRITNEY!!( who i actually do like) to lipsync while doing "energetic routines" but when christina ( who is my idol :D ) can't what is it one rule for one and one rule for another?? the person who made this video needs to wake up and smell the coffee, its pathetic that you make them hahaha!! it's okay we can just compare all the other live outstanding performances to britneys oh ... wait ....
xxcheekyxxleexx 2 years ago
no its because many people are complaining about britney lypsynching..while xtina does it many times but no one bitching her.. xtina is also expert when it comes to playback!
dominiczoe 2 years ago
fair enough but christina has got talent, so has britney but, tbh this whole britney christina thing has bored me now, its silly, and christina has sung more live than britney, who cared they are both great artists just a shame the way the media portrays them :/ but i do love christina
xxcheekyxxleexx 2 years ago
thats true that xtina sung more live cause she not dancing like britney....
dominiczoe 2 years ago
It isn't playback she can just sing.
bugerbiger 2 years ago
poor bitch xd
toxicxsensati0n 2 years ago
Ok, and what are you triying to show?
That Christina always sings live, not like Britney that always lipsycs. By the way one of the most powerfull voices, 4 grammys and has a worderfull family. Something that a drug adict, crazy depressive, lipsync singer and horrible performer like the MTV VMA'S it wishes to have. Thank you!
turabo19 2 years ago
hahahahahahahahaha
a britney fan who is Calling christina 'The Queen of Playback'
TunsiaXprincess 2 years ago
playbackkk!!!!!!!!!!!!!! maldita perra escandalosa ajajajaj todas las canciones de esta zorra son el mismo grito destroza timpanos ,tras de que ni baila ni hace coreo y swolo grita hace playback ajjajaj pobre perra!!
musicbackwards 2 years ago 2
loser! Britney lipsyncs
basketballguru45 2 years ago
AND CHRISTINA TOO (:
BritneyMadonnaTour 2 years ago
what an indiot, it's obvious that she sings live, i guess you are a Britney Spears fan (xtina's haters). Britney is the true Queen of playback. But i don't hate her, i like her music, i don't waste my time hating people.
hebg1989 2 years ago 13
Q idiota eres, es obio q ella canta en vivo, es gracioso ver lo q haces, hasta dond llegas con la envidia o no se q es lo q tienes contra ella. Por cierto Britney es la Reina del Playback, no Christina. Pero me gusta mucho la música de Britney.
hebg1989 2 years ago 2
A Britney Spears fan calling CHRISTINA AGUILERA 'the queen of playback'?....LMAOOOOO You made my dayyyyyy loooooooooooooool
fffeeemmm 2 years ago 17
everybody knows she lip syncs!!! she has a powerful voice, so nobody suspects, BUT, AT LEAST ain't no other man and candyman were playback at the B2B tour!
i don't know the rest, cause i haven't seen the whole show!
argentineguy 2 years ago 2
at her B2B tour was live because even the F#5 she did there was a bit longer than the studio version and you can hear some differences between these two performances. moreover in candyman she just lipped her E5, the rest was live
rocketto8 2 years ago 2
i know it's not the studio version, but it is a pre recorded version for the show...
and don't get me wrong, i don't even care, i don't think it's bad, and it's ok to admit it...
argentineguy 2 years ago
Si chirstina graba sus canciones y las usa en algunas presentaciones es para cuidar su voz, en serio no tengo nada contra spears, pero etso me molesta, ella no tiene q cuidar su voz porque no la tiene, y por eso todo el tiempo canta con pista. No te parece mediocre, insultante y falso que un emocionado fan diga "y hasta canta en vivo algunas de sus canciones!", en un tour que dice "Britney Live!"...hahahaha esto si me ha hecho reir, sigue así, nunk me viene mal reírme un rato al día
viniceo 2 years ago
omg! desperate pigney fans! desperate desperate desperate
poor this pathetic vid don't prove anything, lies and more lies, only two vids???? what happenes with others ah??? ohhh so sad hahahaha
EDGARCUENK 2 years ago
don't you hear that her voice sounded more nasal during her B2B tour? OMG you must be really stupid
rocketto8 2 years ago
those are the same! the difference is just because of the quality of the two videos...
besides, it's so obvious when she makes the exact same noises after the pices of song she sings...
argentineguy 2 years ago
how can you call it playback when it was obviously live
rocketto8 2 years ago