Rock/Metal is by far my favorite genre of music but James never really made me think "wow, this guy is special." He only reminded me of an 80s hair metal band lead singer. Scotty has the best voice in this entire competition followed by Haylee.
James rocks and he should've won. He is so much better than Lauren, Haley, or Scotty. I mean, really. Two pop-country singers and one country guy? Can we get any less diverse here?
He was starting to repeat himself. There's only so much you can do with high notes being the main thing of your song before it gets old. Every song he just sang a high note as the big moment when he should of actually did something creative. Don't get me wrong, he has talent, but he isn't that creative.
james was my favorite and it sucks cuz my favorite the past 4 seasons has made it to the finale and he deserved to be there. tonight was freaking boring except for haley. so i'm voting for haley tonight becuz i wanted it to be a james / haley finale cuz then it wouldn't have been boring. scotty and lauren finale is probably going to be the most boring finale ever. there's nothing exciting there. i loved david cook, adam lambert, and james durbin cuz they kept me entertained every week.
@ohwowza3 u summed up my thoughts perfectly.Scotty and Lauren are just plain country singers with good vocals but still suck compared to haley and james (and even casey)
JAMES DURBIN ROCKS! I CANT BELIEVE COUNTRY TEEN CONTESTANTS AND A GROWLER BEAT A ROCKER WITH VERSATILITY SO SO WRONG AMERICA .JAMES IS AN AMAZING PERFORMER.I WOULD BE SO PROUD TO HAVE HIM AS AN IDOL. ROCK ALL THE WAY ROCK ON JAMES!
Some people just can't understand that Rock and Metal are the only genres that can truly get you jumping and screaming at a concert. Are world is suffering from a greater disease then AIDS and cancer, it is JB disease.
@SuperFenderFan are you serious? take james' performance of will you still love me tomorrow by Carole King. that was fantastic! and when he sang while my guitar gently weeps. that was a slow song and he did great.
@luvthewayoulie scotty all the way! haley can go fuck her boyfriend, she doesn't deserve it like James did. He had a family to care for. Haley is a bitch with no talent. Wait to go America! James and Scotty are the only ones I really liked.
Okay thats wasn't for sure my favorite song he ever sang. But the other song of the night was good but this.. I dont know. But he is my favorite just did like this one that much..
why dont suck your own dick and lick your butthole jerk stop kicking him down already you got what you want shut the fuck up and get out of here if you dont want to listen to the sone. Seriously you go sing it asshole I want to see you sing you little bitch!!!!!!!!!! Haley supporters are mean as hell man. I would of voted her but they just keeep piling on. Im rooting for SCOTTIE now because he was the only one with class to hug james and say your still great man. Haley smirked at the result
She smiled when Pia left too. Little bitch she can go screw steven tyler thats what he wants to do. MAN IHATE PEOPLE STILL BASHING him you got what you want. You got the most talented contestant out congrats. Will be a boring ass show without James.
Durbin is a poser, a karioki prat who can't sing straight to save his life. He is always sharp and and can't sing without screaming even on a soft song. he sucks.
To me he's the best contestant in this competation and he deserves to win. I loved especially his performance of Uprising a few weeks ago. To the haters, stop comparing him to Adam Lambert just because he can also sing extremely high tones. They're two different people and James is a star.
@kelkihel But just think he will have a record deal soon probly and most the time you don't hear about the american idol winner after about 1-2 months so if haley gets it no big lose there
eh. i like his style but i don't think he's really all that good. he's like the "not-as-good" version of adam lambert. i hope it comes down to the two girls. they have the best voices by far.
Haley is the only reason I watch American Idol this year. If she is home, I'm done watching it. Scotty is a one trick pony he picks easy basic songs every week, James screeching high pitches to impress, Lauren's tone range is too small she needs to WOW me. Haley is the only one that gives impressive performance week after week her voice is the most unique in this top 4
wow he's awesome
SaraVii 8 months ago
FAR ILOVE THIS SONG I CAN'T STOP LISTENING TO IT !!!!!!!!!!!
TheSherbert1234 9 months ago
Rock/Metal is by far my favorite genre of music but James never really made me think "wow, this guy is special." He only reminded me of an 80s hair metal band lead singer. Scotty has the best voice in this entire competition followed by Haylee.
ButterflyWars 9 months ago
1:45 then all of a sudden fire works shooting out from the back stage.
znazn13 9 months ago
I'll bend down, turn around and give you a wink baby!
kfpruitt 9 months ago
This is Ronnie James Dio song right?
SymphonyOfDestruct99 9 months ago
James rocks and he should've won. He is so much better than Lauren, Haley, or Scotty. I mean, really. Two pop-country singers and one country guy? Can we get any less diverse here?
dogpy59 9 months ago
He was starting to repeat himself. There's only so much you can do with high notes being the main thing of your song before it gets old. Every song he just sang a high note as the big moment when he should of actually did something creative. Don't get me wrong, he has talent, but he isn't that creative.
SnivelyTheGlamful 9 months ago
this twitchey ticky goof should not be allowed to have access to guns and knives.
People who know him admit that he once held a knife to the throat of an innocent 8 year old kid.
brilliantWISEgenius 9 months ago
James is my favorite wonder why I cant get enthused about what is left. Rock on James
chattynilla 9 months ago
wish you were here tonight <33 then haley wouldnt have been the only interesting one
aeroja13 9 months ago
james was my favorite and it sucks cuz my favorite the past 4 seasons has made it to the finale and he deserved to be there. tonight was freaking boring except for haley. so i'm voting for haley tonight becuz i wanted it to be a james / haley finale cuz then it wouldn't have been boring. scotty and lauren finale is probably going to be the most boring finale ever. there's nothing exciting there. i loved david cook, adam lambert, and james durbin cuz they kept me entertained every week.
ohwowza3 9 months ago
@ohwowza3 u summed up my thoughts perfectly.Scotty and Lauren are just plain country singers with good vocals but still suck compared to haley and james (and even casey)
Dantethedemon16 9 months ago
Ugghh With exception of Haley American Idol is boring now!!!!!!!!!!
tenordrum1988 9 months ago 2
JAMES DURBIN ROCKS! I CANT BELIEVE COUNTRY TEEN CONTESTANTS AND A GROWLER BEAT A ROCKER WITH VERSATILITY SO SO WRONG AMERICA .JAMES IS AN AMAZING PERFORMER.I WOULD BE SO PROUD TO HAVE HIM AS AN IDOL. ROCK ALL THE WAY ROCK ON JAMES!
anitagorsic82 9 months ago 3
I've been waiting all season for him to get the boot...YES!!
BonesRipper 10 months ago
@BonesRipper now youre gonna get the boot. go back to watching your scotty videos you pussy
wwejeffhardy619TV 9 months ago
Idol got this one wrong....... He shoulda been in the finale...
neuman7 10 months ago 6
i hope he pulls a Chris Daughtry and get a record deal that sells out faster than the one who wins American idol
MrDioXIII 10 months ago 13
Some people just can't understand that Rock and Metal are the only genres that can truly get you jumping and screaming at a concert. Are world is suffering from a greater disease then AIDS and cancer, it is JB disease.
Darkninja7396 10 months ago 3
@JadeSparrow92 I couldn't agree with you more! Ur so right. She should have gone James is amazing
rachelerin03 10 months ago
im hoping he gets a record deal...if anyone deserves one it's him...haley should have gone home.
JadeSparrow92 10 months ago 3
@SuperFenderFan are you serious? take james' performance of will you still love me tomorrow by Carole King. that was fantastic! and when he sang while my guitar gently weeps. that was a slow song and he did great.
KazeKage572 10 months ago
@KazeKage572 Yes I agree with you for Haley should've gone home James was excellent besides all Haley was doing was a Barbie taking up space
PRO5017 10 months ago
it's way* to go you illiterate pitch def 12 year old girl
PhillFxC 10 months ago
The American Idol finale will go like this without James: zzz.......ZZZZZ.......zzz......zzzzzz......ZZZZZZZ..........
shadowunderdrums3 10 months ago
SCOTTY deserves to win!!!! sorry you went home James :(
luvthewayoulie 10 months ago
Comment removed
dacorner8 10 months ago
@luvthewayoulie why does scotty deserve to win? is he that amazing of a singer?
dacorner8 10 months ago
@luvthewayoulie Sorry but if anyone that deserves to win now that James is gone is Haley. Scotty and Lauren are ok but no where near Haley.
Cbhan2108 10 months ago 4
@Cbhan2108 Haley sucks and her singing is worse than a dying moose I don't mean to be mean but I feel like I gotta speak my mind
PRO5017 10 months ago
@luvthewayoulie scotty all the way! haley can go fuck her boyfriend, she doesn't deserve it like James did. He had a family to care for. Haley is a bitch with no talent. Wait to go America! James and Scotty are the only ones I really liked.
Illinoisgirl1012 10 months ago
Okay thats wasn't for sure my favorite song he ever sang. But the other song of the night was good but this.. I dont know. But he is my favorite just did like this one that much..
breezecowgirl 10 months ago
CLICK ON MY NAME....CHECK OUT MY SHIT....I AM ORIGINAL MUSICIAN, NOT AN "AMERICAN IDOL"
MichaelJohn5570 10 months ago
i never knew screeming was the same as singing
SuperFenderfan 10 months ago
why dont suck your own dick and lick your butthole jerk stop kicking him down already you got what you want shut the fuck up and get out of here if you dont want to listen to the sone. Seriously you go sing it asshole I want to see you sing you little bitch!!!!!!!!!! Haley supporters are mean as hell man. I would of voted her but they just keeep piling on. Im rooting for SCOTTIE now because he was the only one with class to hug james and say your still great man. Haley smirked at the result
MrBrockilus 10 months ago
She smiled when Pia left too. Little bitch she can go screw steven tyler thats what he wants to do. MAN IHATE PEOPLE STILL BASHING him you got what you want. You got the most talented contestant out congrats. Will be a boring ass show without James.
MrBrockilus 10 months ago
YAY HE DID AWESOME
egondog 10 months ago
Durbin is a poser, a karioki prat who can't sing straight to save his life. He is always sharp and and can't sing without screaming even on a soft song. he sucks.
TEN3112 10 months ago
@TEN3112 ur the poser and i would like to hear you sing retard.... and ur talkin bout haley fucktart....
xMLGshane97x 10 months ago
To me he's the best contestant in this competation and he deserves to win. I loved especially his performance of Uprising a few weeks ago. To the haters, stop comparing him to Adam Lambert just because he can also sing extremely high tones. They're two different people and James is a star.
kelkihel 10 months ago 18
@kelkihel But just think he will have a record deal soon probly and most the time you don't hear about the american idol winner after about 1-2 months so if haley gets it no big lose there
PRO5017 10 months ago
eh. i like his style but i don't think he's really all that good. he's like the "not-as-good" version of adam lambert. i hope it comes down to the two girls. they have the best voices by far.
halicm84 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Haley is the only reason I watch American Idol this year. If she is home, I'm done watching it. Scotty is a one trick pony he picks easy basic songs every week, James screeching high pitches to impress, Lauren's tone range is too small she needs to WOW me. Haley is the only one that gives impressive performance week after week her voice is the most unique in this top 4
TvRealityTv 10 months ago
AWESOME! I LOVE JAMES AND HIS STYLE! =)
jussara2851 10 months ago 2
Here you go James you are almost there so hang in there and you have this in the BAG!!!
SuperMike328 10 months ago
James is the best!
Harleyboy54 10 months ago
I Hope, James in the finale, GOD Bless him.
florbela1 10 months ago
SHOWMANSHIP.
Durbin has this in spades.
i guess i'll see him in the finale then.
tomtompataygutom 10 months ago
very good you rock James
chattynilla 10 months ago
Pure Shit...
CP9er 10 months ago
@CP9er So go listen Lady Gaga and Kesha lol!!.
jussara2851 10 months ago