Quite beautiful how it seems to tell Tchaikovsky's life. Through the notes. I don't believe he commited suicide but IF he did. I i believe he died like his music was played. Outstandingly beautiful...
This music destroys me every time. This is a magical performance with Charles Dutoit seeming to suffer the music more than conduct it. It is sadness beyond words. Incredible. One of the greatest works of art (by which I mean not only music) ever made by man. I'm entirely serious. Utterly devastating, as Tchaikovsky intended it to be. No more words now... I need a break...
One of the greatest performances of Pathetique I have ever heard :-)
Maestro Dutoit is incredible, like Masur, Ozawa and Karajan he feels Chaikovsky in his soul. This orchestra is an extraordinary ensemble of great musicians, immensely beautiful sound comparable to the Berlin and St. Petersburg. Thank you for uploading :-))
@Bret6464 A very good comparison! Karajan, Ozawa, Masur and Dutoit have Tchaikovsky in their soul, at least in the interpretation of the "Pathetique"!
And there is no better final in the entire symphonic music, although very painful ...
@calidris2003 Thank you. I was very fortunate to attend concerts with Ozawa and Masur conducting the Pathetique, and also saw the St. Petersburg with Temirkanov, another great maestro.
Pathetique is the most painful but beautiful symphonic music ever composed.
This performance with Dutout and the NHK Symphony is extraordinary :-)
To me, this is the greatest piece of music ever written. It is the encapsulation of all the anguish and pain that a human soul can possibly bear. It is the Passion of Christ expressed in music. A superhuman masterpiece beyond belief. The Hand of God guided Tchaikovsky when he wrote this.
@MoviesByMiles You should wash your brains out, maybe. I feel sorry for you. If you can't appreciate this music, then listen to a vacuum cleaner instead.
Sir, I have just read your comment about Jesus and my idea of the song has shifted greatly. Seeing my God die on the cross in my head as I listen to this makes it movingly dramatic and dark. For me, the works of the better known composers seem easier to qualify as one tone. This song, however, jumps between multiple feelings and emotions, and I can say that I didn't even listen to the whole thing when I made that remark. I really enjoy it now when I have a visual to match it(:
This orchestra plays like only russian one can play Tchaikovsky.....strings' vibration in some playses creates the impression of woman's voice, it's for my point. Incredible! Thanks a lot!
@thesilvershining If there is, I don't think I want to hear it. Tchaikovsky was probably "happy" for a total of five minutes in his entire life, yet we get to hear this. It's almost as though the darker the experience, the brighter the creative light has to shine. Sadder than this? Perhaps the music of Clay Aiken, though I don't think he intends it be so wretched. I can't listen to his music without wanting to kill myself. Pretty much goes for 99% of anything on the radio.
@thesilvershining The Hungarian suicide song, maybe; or the song 'If You Go Away' by Jacques Brel. Mahler's 5th symphony, slow movement, is really sad as well, as is Albinoni's Adagio, Schubert's 'Unfinished' symphony - I could go on.
@thesilvershining If you go beyond the classical genre there are some excellent modern artists that play melodic death metal. Some is so melancholic, so brutal yet beautiful. I would highly recommend it to all classical music listeners that can appreciate music that is a little "beyond the pale".
Talk about ignorance. If you knew anything about music, which you evidently do not and were not close minded, you would realize that some melodic death metal bands utilize a lot of classical stylistic features in their music, for example 'In Flame's' Subterranean album contains a lot of baroque influence. But you can't even spell "they're" correctly so there is no point having an intellectual debate with someone like you.
@thesilvershining Not sure if you meant this to be rhetorical or not, but you might look into Barber's Adagio for Strings; Albinoni's Adagio & even the 4th movement of Shostakovich's 8th.
the best piece of music ever. I want this music one day on my funeral. Love this finale, the deepest depression and dissapointment of life... very depressive, but truly and sincere. Let me cry and listen to Tchaikovsky for one moment of perfect sadness which carresses my soul...
so extricate, relaxing, takes your breath away, the refrains are fantastic, this is one melancholy melody-Tchaikovsky last symphony. The sound of this symphony is his greatest voice
As a senior in high school, we played this song. At first I didn't think we could do it justice, because the movement, the whole symphony is beautiful. Tchaikovsky was an amazing composer, able to write symphonies, so beautiful so complicated, that grand orchestras such as this, can be moved, yet so simple that even a high school band can play it!!! Bravo
Beautiful. I can barely play this piece whenever it comes around in the concert series. Its so emotional and full of sorrow that I just have to start weeping.
Strangely, no one actually plays that haunting falling melody at the begining of the movement. The first and second violins swap the melody and lower harmonies from one note to the next. If you heard the first violins alone, you may be surprised what they actually play! Does anyone know why Tchaikovsky did this?
With this "swapping-technique" Tchaikovsky created a kind of an "stereo-effect". By this effect the melody becomes much more fragile and painful. But this is only hearable when an orchestra uses the "classical" seating arrangements with the second violins vis-à-vis the first violins.
I heard the Monterey Symphony perform this piece a few weeks ago - it was an amazing performance and, as expected, I cried through the whole 4th movement. Sadly, as a hornist, I have never had the opportunity to perform this piece, though I'm not sure i could make it through this symphony, especially the final movement, even on stage without tears running down my face
Dutoit's facial expressions and movements show his passion for this piece - his face shows the joys and sorrows of each phrase, the despair, it is so beautiful...
I love this piece. I saw Dutoit conduct in San Francisco today and was really amused by how passionate and physical he was -- it was like he was conducting with his entire body, even jumping up and down sometimes. I had to see more of him. Also, I love this piece!
This was Tchaikovsky's last composition. His last words before committing suicide were, "At last, I have finally written a piece that I am satisfied with."
Indeed, the Maestro's last breath and final heartbeat can be heard in the final measures.
I'd like to add that, you probably do not understand, a movement like this has a very tragic theme to it, but it is not proof of suicide, emotion is transferred to this composition, but that does not mean it indicated suicide. He may have just died of cholera or just killed himself. But you will never know how a person really thought about life, just from this piece.
People can make as sad pieces can get, but that means they kill themselves right? They didn't.
Sadness has a whole spectrum to it, yes the it is coined by people to be a Requiem to Tchaikovsky himself, but I thought it was kind of arrogant for you to say that you can feel truly feel as he did through his music.
"Don't come here with that posh talk, you nasty stuck-up twit."
The truth is also subjective to many interpretations in today's world, sir; perhaps you should have realized this before you made your incredibly arrogant claims.
And, see, you only proved JiRocket's point. I am not German (and the only reason my username is 'Mr. Wozzeck' in English is because I love that opera so much), I do not love Hitler, and I am not a Nazi.
And now, for something completely different:
This is still beautiful music. It doesn't really matter who's right and who's wrong about what this has to do with Tchaikovsky' death when the music is beautiful, right? Two words: Shut up. I'll hate you less. ;)
This piece is the most heart breakingly poignant in the entire world literature of music. If you are not moved after listening to this, you are not human.
I love it, but i think that scriabin's sonata opus 53 no 5 is every bit as awe inspiring. The sonata is an eclectic collection of near hysterical passion, very mellancholy appreciation of what was once had, and religiously driven thought that speaks of so much more than the closed off little box of a realm we call home.
This movement makes us realize the mortal moment. I encounterd this symphony at 14 years old, I've listened to it and was moved so many times ever since.
And now I've reached the age at which Tchaikovsky died just after he conducted this symphony.
I wonder if this movement tempted him to death. I'll listen to it till I die.
Una pieza que resume una vida, y la despide, dejando plasmado el autor sus inmenso y futil deseo de continuar, de vivir aunque sea un día más. Parece como si la muerte le hubiese llevado acto segido de escribir la última nota, y el hubiese sabido que esa nota sería la última.
"The form of this symphony will have much that is new, and by the way, the finale will not be a noisy allegro, but on the contrary, a long drawn-out adagio. You can't imagine what bliss I feel, being convinced that my time is not yet passed, and I can still work" (Tchaikovsky)
Indeed!!! The only trouble is that people don't dare go almost at all below the metronomic markings, so it doesn't got to be as drawn-out as it surely should!!! I STRONGLY FEEL that, excepting the coda (THERE he could move it somewhat faster than he does), Bernstein (on DGG, NYPO) has the best feeling of all for this movement I've heard so far.
This is a very good performance, in front of an exemplarily good audience, with excellent playing - but it could have been better yet if slower...
The low brass chorale from 7:58 to 8:46 is about as good as I've ever heard; blend, intonation, balance, tempo, dynamics, etc. And the coda following in the celli and basso is absolutely haunting. And.....big kudos to the audience's etiquette - I didn't hear any coughing or other annoying distractions.
The Symphony no. 4 4th Movement really made me sad that how depress is Tchaikovsky is. Almost his whole life, he never gets any happiness, not even during his music composition. And worse still, Tchaikovsky passed away 9 days after this final symphony.
O Mighty Lord, May you bless him with happiness that he desires during his lifetime.
I often think Tchaikovsky was the Jesus of music. He came to earth and gave us the gift of music and melody, but the world was too stupid and evil to accept him and, almost inevitably, he was claimed by his Maker at far too young an age.
My number one favorite symphony of all time. My first time hearing this was a recording of Dutoit conducting Montreal. The NHK here do an amazing job as well.
omg......... that was incdredible the imagry you see from it, the change of mood it has upon you, its like on a sunny day how a shadow falls over you as it suddenly becomes overcast and it all goes cold and chilling unbeleivable
I've watched a beautiful ballett performance by Boris Eifman about Tchaikovskys life with Vladimir Malakhov today here in Berlin , and this was the last part of it where Tchaikovsky died, really makes me cry at the end, so touching and wonderful but really hertbreaking ,love it forever !
To be able to write something with such emotional and musical maturity is not normal. I don't know how any human being can create such a beautiful work of art. Is there seriously anything in the world that has surpassed this in beauty?
Oh man, this song is great. It's super depressing, but still beautiful. I'm playing it at my highschool, and it's one of my favorites. I love how everybody in the rooms never talks until our conductor breaks the silence. And that's saying a lot, because the wind ensemble never shuts up. It completely changes the atmosphere.
Deathly sad and heartbreaking part, a brilliant and amazing masterpiece, as is the whole Symphony ! Tchaikovsky is a genius, one of my favorite composers,so sad, how much he's been desperated about his own live ,tragic ending !
Last bars in this movement are always darker... Amazing interpretation, we cry in front of the Tchaikovsky's sadness. This is the reason because this symphony is called "Pathètique".
I get through about 3 minutes of the fouth mov. and crack up in tears! I will one day bite my lip a be able to listen to it fully. This has to be the most desperate yet powerful few minutes of music ever put to paper, thank god for the musical poety the Russians gaves us
Charles Dutiot is one of the all time great Tchaikovsky interpreters.Just listen to his swan lake recording with the montreal symphony and you will see what i mean,plus his other recordings of Tchaikovskys music as well.
Oh no! They took away the music :(
radioplug14 2 months ago
One of the finest interpretation I ever heard of the 4th movement.
Atramentumink 3 months ago
if i were conducting this i would just start crying
phazonruler3000 4 months ago
Most beautiful and heartbreaking piece of music ever...Tchaikovsky!
straycat316 4 months ago
only a Russian could could have written this majestic piece
paul4876 7 months ago
Man if I was sitting in that room, I'd be balling out like niagara falls.
drgrinch123 7 months ago
Quite beautiful how it seems to tell Tchaikovsky's life. Through the notes. I don't believe he commited suicide but IF he did. I i believe he died like his music was played. Outstandingly beautiful...
TheAftermath8 7 months ago
pete t has deftly summarized the eternal epic tragedy of humanity in one fell swoop...and, certainly, this..a magnificent rendition.
dennistodd 8 months ago
what is this instrument in 2:26
TSkniaz 10 months ago
@TSkniaz Bassoon?
ugnex3 9 months ago
Thanks for sharing.
This is so Intense, Thoughtful, touchy and humane.
Truly he is Master of expressing human emotion in an absolute excellent
manouchehr7 11 months ago
Well with a name like Tchaikovsky how could he not write the saddest music in the world?
Paint 11 months ago
Comment removed
katinkers 1 year ago
either the music isn't quite in sync with the video or i'm just not good at following him. still beautiful though.
katinkers 1 year ago
played it recently, this piece is complete genius
MozasFury 1 year ago
This music destroys me every time. This is a magical performance with Charles Dutoit seeming to suffer the music more than conduct it. It is sadness beyond words. Incredible. One of the greatest works of art (by which I mean not only music) ever made by man. I'm entirely serious. Utterly devastating, as Tchaikovsky intended it to be. No more words now... I need a break...
ComposerInUK 1 year ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
Wonderful Music
YouTube the Great Great Grandfather in Composition of Peter I. Tchaikovsky:
Iosif Andriasov
immapubrec 1 year ago
NHK sympony orchestra is my favorite orchestra..
they are good plays..i like it..
1115youha 1 year ago
A wonderful performance TY.
paulostroff99 1 year ago
Played with such tenderness and pathos.....Charles Dutioit and the NHK offer a truly definitive rendition of this ode to monumental grief.....
shishirth 1 year ago
One of the greatest performances of Pathetique I have ever heard :-)
Maestro Dutoit is incredible, like Masur, Ozawa and Karajan he feels Chaikovsky in his soul. This orchestra is an extraordinary ensemble of great musicians, immensely beautiful sound comparable to the Berlin and St. Petersburg. Thank you for uploading :-))
Bret6464 1 year ago 5
@Bret6464 A very good comparison! Karajan, Ozawa, Masur and Dutoit have Tchaikovsky in their soul, at least in the interpretation of the "Pathetique"!
And there is no better final in the entire symphonic music, although very painful ...
calidris2003 1 year ago
@calidris2003 Thank you. I was very fortunate to attend concerts with Ozawa and Masur conducting the Pathetique, and also saw the St. Petersburg with Temirkanov, another great maestro.
Pathetique is the most painful but beautiful symphonic music ever composed.
This performance with Dutout and the NHK Symphony is extraordinary :-)
Bret6464 1 year ago
To me, this is the greatest piece of music ever written. It is the encapsulation of all the anguish and pain that a human soul can possibly bear. It is the Passion of Christ expressed in music. A superhuman masterpiece beyond belief. The Hand of God guided Tchaikovsky when he wrote this.
marcusantonius90 1 year ago
Dutoit is a great conductor - known mostly for French music and his Planets recording, but I think he's fantastic with most anything
uluru28 1 year ago
Comment removed
MoviesByMiles 1 year ago
@MoviesByMiles You should wash your brains out, maybe. I feel sorry for you. If you can't appreciate this music, then listen to a vacuum cleaner instead.
marcusantonius90 1 year ago
Comment removed
MoviesByMiles 1 year ago
@marcusantonius90
Sir, I have just read your comment about Jesus and my idea of the song has shifted greatly. Seeing my God die on the cross in my head as I listen to this makes it movingly dramatic and dark. For me, the works of the better known composers seem easier to qualify as one tone. This song, however, jumps between multiple feelings and emotions, and I can say that I didn't even listen to the whole thing when I made that remark. I really enjoy it now when I have a visual to match it(:
MoviesByMiles 1 year ago 2
I enjoy it, without any tear production...Rabintranath Tagore telling us " death is only putting out the lamp because the (real) dawn has come. ."
EineAlpensinfonie 1 year ago
me encanta!
EnvyAbomination 1 year ago
the best one!!
orchestrauniversita 2 years ago
This orchestra plays like only russian one can play Tchaikovsky.....strings' vibration in some playses creates the impression of woman's voice, it's for my point. Incredible! Thanks a lot!
annu4e4ka 2 years ago 3
Their performance impresses me!
Thanks!
Apache3X 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
Apache3X 2 years ago
God, is there *ANYTHING* sadder than this song in the entire 500+ years of classical music?
thesilvershining 2 years ago 14
i don't think so
otherjoe1234 2 years ago
@thesilvershining If there is, I don't think I want to hear it. Tchaikovsky was probably "happy" for a total of five minutes in his entire life, yet we get to hear this. It's almost as though the darker the experience, the brighter the creative light has to shine. Sadder than this? Perhaps the music of Clay Aiken, though I don't think he intends it be so wretched. I can't listen to his music without wanting to kill myself. Pretty much goes for 99% of anything on the radio.
zoetropez 1 year ago
@thesilvershining The Hungarian suicide song, maybe; or the song 'If You Go Away' by Jacques Brel. Mahler's 5th symphony, slow movement, is really sad as well, as is Albinoni's Adagio, Schubert's 'Unfinished' symphony - I could go on.
marcusantonius90 1 year ago
@thesilvershining Mozart's requiem...
TSkniaz 11 months ago
@TSkniaz sure, Mozart's requiem is sad, but in an other way...this piece is just so dark and you can see how depressiv tchaikovsky was at his end.
This is one of the greatest symphonic moves.
DerBayer1843 10 months ago
@thesilvershining If you go beyond the classical genre there are some excellent modern artists that play melodic death metal. Some is so melancholic, so brutal yet beautiful. I would highly recommend it to all classical music listeners that can appreciate music that is a little "beyond the pale".
pspvampire 9 months ago
@pspvampire
dont compare your horrible death metal to fucking classical what a shame man what a shame to even think there on the same level is ignorant kthxbai
bin4ryst4r 9 months ago
@bin4ryst4r
Talk about ignorance. If you knew anything about music, which you evidently do not and were not close minded, you would realize that some melodic death metal bands utilize a lot of classical stylistic features in their music, for example 'In Flame's' Subterranean album contains a lot of baroque influence. But you can't even spell "they're" correctly so there is no point having an intellectual debate with someone like you.
pspvampire 9 months ago
@pspvampire
ai do not has inteallectuals debatez ?
bin4ryst4r 8 months ago
@bin4ryst4r I stand corrected.
pspvampire 8 months ago
@pspvampire
did i say you can stand?
bin4ryst4r 8 months ago
@bin4ryst4r It's an idiom.
pspvampire 8 months ago
@pspvampire
and your and idiot
bin4ryst4r 8 months ago
@bin4ryst4r "And", "you're", "an" "idiot."
Oh, the irony.
pspvampire 8 months ago 4
@pspvampire HAHAHAHA
ItzhakRoxMySox 8 months ago
@pspvampire
thats the point :D
bin4ryst4r 7 months ago
@thesilvershining Not sure if you meant this to be rhetorical or not, but you might look into Barber's Adagio for Strings; Albinoni's Adagio & even the 4th movement of Shostakovich's 8th.
ewparkentity 6 months ago
@thesilvershining Adagio for Strings - Samuel Barber would get pretty close!
xaviervandepoll 6 months ago
@thesilvershining Mauersberger's Dresdenner Requiem
Jonlovescake 3 months ago
Tears.....no words. All my credit for the composer, NHK Symphony Orchestra and Charles Dutoit.
raoultak 2 years ago 4
nice song
tubamarius 2 years ago
Slow and soft, yet SO compassionate, SO powerful...
mario54671 2 years ago
never heard my favorite piece of music conducted so well.........total fan of Charles
soccerloverbc 2 years ago 3
the best piece of music ever. I want this music one day on my funeral. Love this finale, the deepest depression and dissapointment of life... very depressive, but truly and sincere. Let me cry and listen to Tchaikovsky for one moment of perfect sadness which carresses my soul...
MartinSlovakian 2 years ago 5
so extricate, relaxing, takes your breath away, the refrains are fantastic, this is one melancholy melody-Tchaikovsky last symphony. The sound of this symphony is his greatest voice
tranthethong95 2 years ago
El dolor que exhuda es casi insoportable...
jordan3461 2 years ago 4
Unbelieaveble. Such an incredeble piece of music. A giant work, maybe his best work. (Or 1812 Ouverture)?
desjterc4 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
So many nutriding faggots in here. I weep.
Trequartista99 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
And who the fuck are you, dickhead?
marklavar 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm your daddy faggot. Now get on your knees and suck my dick like yo momma did.
Trequartista99 2 years ago
I'm coming to find you. People like you need to removed from the planet.
marklavar 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
And who the fuck are you, shithead?
marklavar 2 years ago
I can't listen to this without shedding a tear. Truly majestic.
marcphilos 2 years ago 21
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I can't listen to this without falling asleep. Truly majestic.
Trequartista99 2 years ago
Go back to sleep then.
marcphilos 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I can't listen to this without wanting to beat the shit of out of your brain.
marklavar 2 years ago
omg! es la mejor sinfonia que he escuchado, tsn depresiva... te hace pensar en cosas tristes y dramaticas... fue un compositor algo apasionado
mi favorito!
PEBELICIOUS 2 years ago
sad but gorgeous.makes one cry
soccerloverbc 2 years ago
As a senior in high school, we played this song. At first I didn't think we could do it justice, because the movement, the whole symphony is beautiful. Tchaikovsky was an amazing composer, able to write symphonies, so beautiful so complicated, that grand orchestras such as this, can be moved, yet so simple that even a high school band can play it!!! Bravo
basikgurl11 2 years ago 2
You guys are just a bunch of educated old ladies. Stop arguing over the music and just listen to it. gosh!
samdajellybeenie14 2 years ago 2
Such pain. Such despair. I weep.
WMJBJS 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
JiRocket 2 years ago
incredible ...beautiful...a wonderous masterpiece ...
mischevious3 2 years ago 2
Beautiful. I can barely play this piece whenever it comes around in the concert series. Its so emotional and full of sorrow that I just have to start weeping.
firstalto13 2 years ago 3
Wonderful Huge fan of Charles Dutoit......sad yes.but more beautiful than sad
soccerloverbc 2 years ago 3
8:50
kwrkrlz 2 years ago
This gives me goosebumps every time I hear it.
RANDOMNAMEISRANDOMQQ 2 years ago
Strangely, no one actually plays that haunting falling melody at the begining of the movement. The first and second violins swap the melody and lower harmonies from one note to the next. If you heard the first violins alone, you may be surprised what they actually play! Does anyone know why Tchaikovsky did this?
EASYTIGER10 2 years ago
With this "swapping-technique" Tchaikovsky created a kind of an "stereo-effect". By this effect the melody becomes much more fragile and painful. But this is only hearable when an orchestra uses the "classical" seating arrangements with the second violins vis-à-vis the first violins.
violinscratcher 2 years ago
Beutiful interpretation!!!
danolpe 2 years ago
I heard the Monterey Symphony perform this piece a few weeks ago - it was an amazing performance and, as expected, I cried through the whole 4th movement. Sadly, as a hornist, I have never had the opportunity to perform this piece, though I'm not sure i could make it through this symphony, especially the final movement, even on stage without tears running down my face
ljringley 2 years ago 2
ljringley
As a hornist, I have played this heartbreaking symphony. An experience I will never, ever forget.
maestrojeremy 2 years ago
This beautiful piece of music has such an emotional power which penetrates to deepest level of ones feeling
manouchehr7 3 years ago
anytime i have ever played or heard this movement i cry without fail, and this performance definitely does this masterpiece justice!
mjd5157 3 years ago
this is the most beautiful , breathtaking and heartbreaking music piece ever ,
Tchaikovsky is THE GENIUS , anf this is an amazing performance LOVE IT !))))))))))
nocturne163 3 years ago 5
Dutoit's facial expressions and movements show his passion for this piece - his face shows the joys and sorrows of each phrase, the despair, it is so beautiful...
ljringley 3 years ago 2
Brings tears to my eyes! What a talented man!
lillamb33 3 years ago
James Garner from "The Rockford Files!"
ljringley 3 years ago
I love this piece. I saw Dutoit conduct in San Francisco today and was really amused by how passionate and physical he was -- it was like he was conducting with his entire body, even jumping up and down sometimes. I had to see more of him. Also, I love this piece!
hollywdliz 3 years ago 2
Bill Muray?
mothanas 3 years ago
Dutoit looks amazingly like an American good old actor. I cant remember his name.
ianislios 3 years ago
Tchaikovsky is an amazing composer
im only 14 yrs old, and I hope to play some of his music as I grow.
No words can describe his music.
He poured his soul into this beautiful song.
May he Rest In Peace
derek44344 3 years ago 2
i agree wholeheartedly
im 16, and therefore a young musician myself
i, too, hope to play some of his amazing music
ericgsant92 3 years ago 2
You hear a great deal.
This was Tchaikovsky's last composition. His last words before committing suicide were, "At last, I have finally written a piece that I am satisfied with."
Indeed, the Maestro's last breath and final heartbeat can be heard in the final measures.
This was his final statement.
mishima1974 3 years ago
Tchaikovsky committing suicide is a myth. Just like how Mozart never made any revisions of his compositions.
radioplug14 3 years ago
these are not equivalent stories.
fagoon 3 years ago
No myth. Listen to the heartbeats and breaths at the end.
Anyone wilth enough sensitivity will come to the conclusion that Tchaikovsky did indeed commit suicide.
mishima1974 2 years ago
i see what you're saying, tchaikovsky just doesn't seem like someone who would kill himself.
MillyProductions 2 years ago
i wouldn't say tchaikovsky commited suicide, more like death by unwise actions.
MillyProductions 2 years ago
LIsten to the last movement again.
The final breaths and heartbeats are all the confirmation that I need.
Tchaikovsky killed himself.
mishima1974 2 years ago
That is kind of silly to say, you will never understand how anyone of the past truly felt!
JiRocket 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Learn to be more musically sensitive.
Then you'll understand.
mishima1974 2 years ago
Still impossible.
JiRocket 2 years ago
I'd like to add that, you probably do not understand, a movement like this has a very tragic theme to it, but it is not proof of suicide, emotion is transferred to this composition, but that does not mean it indicated suicide. He may have just died of cholera or just killed himself. But you will never know how a person really thought about life, just from this piece.
People can make as sad pieces can get, but that means they kill themselves right? They didn't.
JiRocket 2 years ago
This particular piece is different.
It goes far beyond simple sadness.
Calling this piece 'sad' is like calling WWII 'unfortunate'.
mishima1974 2 years ago 2
Sadness has a whole spectrum to it, yes the it is coined by people to be a Requiem to Tchaikovsky himself, but I thought it was kind of arrogant for you to say that you can feel truly feel as he did through his music.
JiRocket 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Arrogant, schmarrogant.
The truth is the truth nomatter if the person saying it is arrogant, polite or otherwise.
I have spoken.
mishima1974 2 years ago
Very well then.
JiRocket 2 years ago
"Don't come here with that posh talk, you nasty stuck-up twit."
The truth is also subjective to many interpretations in today's world, sir; perhaps you should have realized this before you made your incredibly arrogant claims.
HerrWozzeck 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Go fuck yourself you German Nazi cocksucker.
Yi mach schmo vesichro.
I am right and you are wrong. Ha ha ha.
Go play with your toys, Hitler lover.
mishima1974 2 years ago
"Ah, chicken, sir? Certainly!"
And, see, you only proved JiRocket's point. I am not German (and the only reason my username is 'Mr. Wozzeck' in English is because I love that opera so much), I do not love Hitler, and I am not a Nazi.
And now, for something completely different:
This is still beautiful music. It doesn't really matter who's right and who's wrong about what this has to do with Tchaikovsky' death when the music is beautiful, right? Two words: Shut up. I'll hate you less. ;)
HerrWozzeck 2 years ago
bassoon ftw
this is a sobering piece indeed
ericgsant92 3 years ago
Tchaikovsky died six days after it's first performance, so this is indeed his requiem to himself...
Lukecash12 3 years ago
This piece is the most heart breakingly poignant in the entire world literature of music. If you are not moved after listening to this, you are not human.
marklavar 3 years ago 5
I love it, but i think that scriabin's sonata opus 53 no 5 is every bit as awe inspiring. The sonata is an eclectic collection of near hysterical passion, very mellancholy appreciation of what was once had, and religiously driven thought that speaks of so much more than the closed off little box of a realm we call home.
Lukecash12 3 years ago
esta sinfonia si que me hace llorar es demasiado buena !!!!1
gnrtacos 3 years ago
nothing short of spectacular.
kurikokaleidoscope 3 years ago
This movement makes us realize the mortal moment. I encounterd this symphony at 14 years old, I've listened to it and was moved so many times ever since.
And now I've reached the age at which Tchaikovsky died just after he conducted this symphony.
I wonder if this movement tempted him to death. I'll listen to it till I die.
RainyTaro 3 years ago 2
Una pieza que resume una vida, y la despide, dejando plasmado el autor sus inmenso y futil deseo de continuar, de vivir aunque sea un día más. Parece como si la muerte le hubiese llevado acto segido de escribir la última nota, y el hubiese sabido que esa nota sería la última.
Grandioso. Gracias Piotr Ilich
jrmvm 3 years ago
かっこいい。
N響って感じだわ。
music0923 3 years ago
"The form of this symphony will have much that is new, and by the way, the finale will not be a noisy allegro, but on the contrary, a long drawn-out adagio. You can't imagine what bliss I feel, being convinced that my time is not yet passed, and I can still work" (Tchaikovsky)
Chatlein 3 years ago 2
Indeed!!! The only trouble is that people don't dare go almost at all below the metronomic markings, so it doesn't got to be as drawn-out as it surely should!!! I STRONGLY FEEL that, excepting the coda (THERE he could move it somewhat faster than he does), Bernstein (on DGG, NYPO) has the best feeling of all for this movement I've heard so far.
This is a very good performance, in front of an exemplarily good audience, with excellent playing - but it could have been better yet if slower...
LJBSasha 3 years ago
The low brass chorale from 7:58 to 8:46 is about as good as I've ever heard; blend, intonation, balance, tempo, dynamics, etc. And the coda following in the celli and basso is absolutely haunting. And.....big kudos to the audience's etiquette - I didn't hear any coughing or other annoying distractions.
edcassells 3 years ago 4
The Symphony no. 4 4th Movement really made me sad that how depress is Tchaikovsky is. Almost his whole life, he never gets any happiness, not even during his music composition. And worse still, Tchaikovsky passed away 9 days after this final symphony.
O Mighty Lord, May you bless him with happiness that he desires during his lifetime.
ltmikepowell 3 years ago 4
I often think Tchaikovsky was the Jesus of music. He came to earth and gave us the gift of music and melody, but the world was too stupid and evil to accept him and, almost inevitably, he was claimed by his Maker at far too young an age.
marklavar 3 years ago
During that time, most Russians were familiar or like musics from more nationalistic The Five.
But Tchaikovsky is different, he emphasized Cosmopolitanism in his music despite some public rejection at that time.
ltmikepowell 3 years ago
I saw Mr. Dutoit conduct this in Dallas- with the DSO last spring.
It was a fantastic performance. He was so into the first movement - I had chills the whole time.
waltts 3 years ago 4
My number one favorite symphony of all time. My first time hearing this was a recording of Dutoit conducting Montreal. The NHK here do an amazing job as well.
maestrojeremy 3 years ago 5
I wrote this while listening to this music .A bridge of sighs, that looms in long sojourn.
To bring unexpected solace at final step.
Remembered place, in light's shadow.
The last step remembered, by hangman and earth.
Last breath heard not forgot.
Solace in time, the breath of the earth.
Remembered, not forgot.
Love's grace, always supreme.
Ok, I'm not not the worlds best poet, yet some' my better stuff harder forgot.
galaxyrainguy 3 years ago
Oh I cannot hold back my tears ...
xcydnas 3 years ago 10
A good interpretation and performance. Thank you for posting. Heartbeaking music.
AnthonyBlunt 4 years ago 3
omg......... that was incdredible the imagry you see from it, the change of mood it has upon you, its like on a sunny day how a shadow falls over you as it suddenly becomes overcast and it all goes cold and chilling unbeleivable
mistressmystery022 4 years ago 4
this is the most amazing piece of music i have ever heard
theblastocyst 4 years ago 4
Heartbreaking i mean, but whatever, it's amazing !
Berceuse59 4 years ago 4
I've watched a beautiful ballett performance by Boris Eifman about Tchaikovskys life with Vladimir Malakhov today here in Berlin , and this was the last part of it where Tchaikovsky died, really makes me cry at the end, so touching and wonderful but really hertbreaking ,love it forever !
Berceuse59 4 years ago 3
The most intense and saddest music ever written.
ophicleide77 4 years ago 5
To be able to write something with such emotional and musical maturity is not normal. I don't know how any human being can create such a beautiful work of art. Is there seriously anything in the world that has surpassed this in beauty?
ItzhakRoxMySox 4 years ago 3
Oh man, this song is great. It's super depressing, but still beautiful. I'm playing it at my highschool, and it's one of my favorites. I love how everybody in the rooms never talks until our conductor breaks the silence. And that's saying a lot, because the wind ensemble never shuts up. It completely changes the atmosphere.
izzomizzo 4 years ago 5
amazing! how beautyfully played....! BRAVO!
zagonielod 4 years ago 5
Deathly sad and heartbreaking part, a brilliant and amazing masterpiece, as is the whole Symphony ! Tchaikovsky is a genius, one of my favorite composers,so sad, how much he's been desperated about his own live ,tragic ending !
Berceuse59 4 years ago 3
Last bars in this movement are always darker... Amazing interpretation, we cry in front of the Tchaikovsky's sadness. This is the reason because this symphony is called "Pathètique".
APiazzolla 4 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
4:56...he spits, you can even see the saliva coming out.
IsaacDelarge 4 years ago
Peter Ilich Tchaikovsky-HE IS A REAL MUSIC PROPHET - AND THEN THE STORM BREAKS OUT.!!! A GIGANTIC DUEL BETWEEN LIFE AND DEATH BEGINS.!
GOD's STORMS!! Age 6 and you unknown!!! listen and feel !! who is it !!!
fort65 4 years ago
i can not get enough of this tragic song.Tchaikovsky captured such beautiful sadness in this piece.
ragmoz 4 years ago 8
I get through about 3 minutes of the fouth mov. and crack up in tears! I will one day bite my lip a be able to listen to it fully. This has to be the most desperate yet powerful few minutes of music ever put to paper, thank god for the musical poety the Russians gaves us
NickSayle 4 years ago 7
La parte più bella di questo capolavoro
sinfonico, bella per la musica triste che
contiene. Grazie di essere esistito genio
musicale. Grazie del video ottimo.
macciboma 4 years ago
My favourite movement of this simphony:)amazing!
peshkin 4 years ago 6
he looks like munch ,hahaha,his teacher
henrykkingdom 4 years ago
la evidente amalgama entre sollozos y desesperación en el arte musical
nachogoras 4 years ago
The more I listen to Dutoit's performances and read about his ideas the more I absolutely love his work.
maestrojeremy 4 years ago 4
Love this piece to pieces.
VonRichter 4 years ago 4
Charles Dutiot is one of the all time great Tchaikovsky interpreters.Just listen to his swan lake recording with the montreal symphony and you will see what i mean,plus his other recordings of Tchaikovskys music as well.
prokofiev24 4 years ago 6