If homeopathy works ... I'll drink my own piss

[RebornHammer]

find a link to the whole story put this quote into google to find it. "Mr Vithoulkas challenged this statement and with this idea a new experiment was conceived that would prove that the highly potentized remedies could actually have a biological effect upon the human organism."

[wawei67]

@thonaker1

yes, they are ALL like this--not one of these bozo's even understands how to make or prescribe homeopathy. This outrageous anti-scientific fraud simply panders to peoples' ingrained (by the medical/pharma/media alliance) prejudices and hate. They are all emotionally charged (like racism etc) and you often can't even TALK to these guys (YES IT"S MOST ALL GUYS lol) cause they are fucking IRRATIONAL with their religious belief in "science" haha

[wawei67]

Hi --you can start urinating in a tall glass from now on cause the evidence for homeopathys' efficacy can be easily found on the net--try PubMed for starters (ever heard of it lol)

Good thing you didn't say you'd eat your own shit (though of course you'll be forced to figuratively if you actually look at the studies) hahahha

[noronhal]

better start drinking.



[StevenBee2]

You only shook #27 & #29 2 times instead of 3... how do you expect the medicine to develop the proper memory of piss that way?

[wstevenschneider]

@thonaker1 (As per previous post) By solute I meant solvent, sorry.

[LBurris597]

You're the dude that looks like Bon Jovi! Brillant video!

[criskity]

12C = about where Avogadro's number is.

[jackdeath]

Successions are up and down 10 times, back and forth 10 times, and side to side 10 times. You are doing it all wrong in the eyes of homeopathy proponents. Not that it really matters, as the results would likely be the same, but you have given the proponents ammunition.

[wawei67]

@jackdeath

You don't know anyhting about succussion lol. Too bad for you its been proved succussion does transmit 'memory' of a substance...but don't let that worry you lol

[jackdeath]

@wawei67 I won't let it worry me, but maybe you should take a course in high school science and learn about the composition of water. You will find that nowhere in its chemical makeup does it have the capacity to *remember* anything, thus proving the homeopathy is a fraud.

[emerickscott]

@wawei67 you're an idiot. 10*23 power is the absolute limit of any molecule. Anything after that won't even have one molecule.

[barcabourke]

I wonder if homeopaths actually bother to go through this nonsense or do they just say "bugger it nobody'll tell the difference, pass the sugar pills."

[MrOttopants]

That's funny. Is the dog filiming you?

[Smithpolly]

If it's good enough for Bear Grylls....

[ArcadeBumstud]

I don't think anyone actually believes in homeopathy. The problem is that they come in packages that look like real medicine and promise to do things that real medicine does. They're even sold in the drug aisle. It should be illegal.

[vincentdelporte]

@ArcadeBumstud : But then, how many people in the world believe in god?

[quantumtao1980]

The pharmaceuticals want to rubbish it because if everyone used homeopathy (which is cheap and very effective) there would little illness in the world to suppress/cover up with chemicals and they would be out of a business. Really ... open your minds a little. You will see the truth and it will make your life infinitely better. Good luck :o)

[noliesundead]

@quantumtao1980 " if everyone used homeopathy (which is cheap and very effective) ".....if homeopathy worked tap water should cure everything, since it would be the most diluted

[Celephaith]

@quantumtao1980: You're exactly as diluted as the people who still think the Earth is flat. They think that the idea of the Earth being round is some huge conspiracy perpetrated by scientists, governments, and globe makers. Your perception of modern medicine and big pharma is eerily similar. The only aspect of your conspiracy theory that holds any water (or piss) is that big pharma is only out to make money. Well no shit. So's every other industry. (cont.)

[Celephaith]

@quantumtao1980: If we were to apply your logic to, say, the car industry, we would all be riding horses. Yes, car makers are evil corporations that only want your money. But that doesn't mean I'm riding to work on a fucking donkey! And I'm also not going to drink herbal tea if I get cancer...I'm going to a doctor! Because I know that the technology isn't the problem. Modern medicine has taken what nature provided and enhanced it. Nature doesn't give a shit if you die; people do.

[byteresistor]

@quantumtao1980 Look here people, we have a person who believes homeopathy works. Let's point and laugh at him. What a dumbass.

And no, I don't need to open my mind. I just need evidence for your assertions, which you obviously can't present because you have to resort to the "it's obvious" argument.

[quantumtao1980]

I, for example was in a carcinosin state and was very ill - to the point of being bedridden and desperately depressed, tired, ill and suicidal. 2 weeks of Carcinosin LM1 and I am 100% again. It is not placebo as it works on animals and babies.

[quantumtao1980]

JTrillo quantum physics has everything to do with it. Everything in the universe has a vibrational state or level (animal, veg or mineral) and everything is connected at the zero point field. The vibrational state of an individual is affected by what is happening in their relative field as well as globally/universally. Individuals move into different states depending on their situation and can be treated with homeopathy. Read Einsteins space-time theory to get basic understanding

[Celephaith]

@quantumtao1980: You have no clue what you're talking about. You're using a field of science that you have no understanding of to justify nature worship, when basic chemistry completely disproves what you believe in. Crystals, natural cures, wishing upon a star...it's all bullshit. Nature is an unconscious, utterly uncaring thing. It didn't provide all the magic ingredients to make us better. WE had to do that; just like we had to build houses. Unless you like living in a cave?

[quantumtao1980]

You guys! Read up on it. If you have an understanding of how quantum physics works and if you have actually tried it THEN criticise it!

When does the vid come out of you drinking your own piss? Look forward to seeing it. lol

[JTrillo]

@quantumtao1980 What's quantum physics got anything to do with it?

[quantumtao1980]

You guys! Read up on it. If you have an understanding of how quantum physics works and if you have actually tried it THEN criticise it!

When does the vid come out of you drinking your own piss? Look forward to seeing it. lol

[Annu1tco3pt1s]

Bear Grylls would be proud!!!

[Mugsi]

"I have a degree in homeopathy!"

"YOU HAVE A DEGREE IN BALONY!"

[DrSpooglemon]

But if it's homeopathic piss then it would be, like, a sort of piss antedote (or something)...

[SkruffyPretzals]

the reason why he took so long in the toilet was because he drank most of his piss and thus questions why he didnt have much piss in a cup :L have fun kids and goodnight.

[DustinThePooper]

"Homeopathy doesn't work.

Better drink my own piss"

-Bear Grylls

[nag73]

That's taking the piss.

[lynth]

"I'm actually making my piss more potent."

[drchristoaa]

so drink your piss and eat shit/stool.....u failed

Homeopathy works and is the most advanced science of healing, scientists has proved it,(search IIT BOMBAY HOMEOPATHY) and the research paper appeared in PEER reviewed well established journal and the result was published after 4 years of study on nanotechnology and homeopathy by scientists of IIT Bombay.

This definitely shows that HOMEOPATHY is the MOST ADVANCED science of healing and medicine of present and future.

[murdocha]

@drchristoaa So you cut and paste your nonsensical replies, you fail. Again and again and again you unsinkable rubber ducky. Either provide some real evidence or stop spamming your crap around.

[wstevenschneider]

@drchristoaa - Mr. Bonking, I honestly do wish that the government would treat Homeopathy like actual medicine. Then the Homeopathy mfrs would have the same scrutiny applied to them as drug mfrs. Homeopathy mfrs would have to prove that their formulas work as claimed. The Homeopathy mfrs would also then be liable for any products they sold that failed to meet said claim. Homeopathy mfrs would have to pull any product that has yet to be proven, or has failed the test procedure.

[drchristoaa]

@wstevenschneider IGNORENT FOOL...

[wstevenschneider]

@drchristoaa - So are you opposed to Government regulation and control of Homepathy then? I mean drug manufactures are regulated and controlled by a government body to enforce their good behaviour.

Your knee-jerk reaction tells me that you don't like this idea. Why is that, Mr. Bonking?

[murdocha]

@drchristoaa illiterate moron.

[griffonsa]

homeoPATHETIC!!!

[daemonowner]

Who wants to try this with Cyanide? I'm tempted.

[romeprince11]

and this accomplishes...

[murdocha]

@romeprince11 a tangible demonstration of the nonsense of homeopathy.

[mralkumar3]

You look so frustrated. you must utilize your time in something else rather than in your pis!!! ha ha

[raszabo]

This experiment tells about homeopathy nothing. It only tells, that You are not able to investigate homeopathy objectively, and that You are not able to step out from the stiff thinking of materialism. Look the latest results of modern sciences: it states the material also has non-material attributes ... The atomic physics did not find nothing inside the atom, only spaces and small particles, which are not act like matter. Homeopathy is a non-material medicine, that is why You cant understand.

[Mapariensis]

@raszabo Oh please, take fundamental physics 101... And look up "quantum flapdoodle".

1) Quantum mechanical effects do not manifest on a macroscopic level. (basic statistics tells you that)

2) even if I grant your premise of non-material activity, whatever you mean by that, claiming "homeopathy works" is special pleading.

So please spout your bullshit somewhere else. I hate it when morons like you rape physics, while rational people who actually study it have to call you out on your bullshit.

[tison345]

@Mapariensis No, but you see, it works because I'm certain of it and someone told me it works. Get your big pharma "science" out of here!

[murdocha]

@tison345 Do you realize who owns the largest homeopathic labs? Can you spell Merck? If you want to discuss income potential. A 30C dilution from a 1ml original volume could fill a volume of water 10^54 cubic metres. That's equivalent to a sphere with a diameter of 131.1 light years. So, even if you paid $1,000,000 for 1mL of oscillococcinum (which doesn't exist to begin with and was a misidentification of an artifact from poor slide preparation), the profit margin is HUGE. It sells for $20!

[daemonowner]

I've seen 30cc solutions, what does that mean?

[ampeyro]

if the efect is the opposite of the original, and stronger as more ch it have, you must have cured your need of peeing

unfortunately it don't work

[SovietChris]

Like the video. Also, is that a People's Republic of Cork t-shirt I spy?

[koppadasao]

If anyone watching this experiment still believe in homeopathy they could swap brains with a sheep and become smarter than before.

I pity the sheep who gets the believer's brain though...

[mvszao]

Ha! Awesome! I'll drink my own shit now!

[RassieDog]

great!

[TheSaarth]

my best frnd who is studyin h'pathy of 5yrs stopped tokin 2 me for being an atheist n callin her future proffesion stupid :P

[tetenterre]

Won't work, Crispian: You didn't surcuss (or whatever the word is) it on a leather-bound Bible. Silly billy!

[ingliss]

This *is* a cure for being pissed or hungover. Drink a glass of this homeopathic remedy every half an hour for 12 hours and you'll see that your drunkenness / hangover is very significantly reduced.

[uriituw]

How is it that people come to believe in this shit?

[devpunk93]

Did he die?

[Hasenkuss1]

Hat der mal die Pipette gewechselt?

[BibleLovingAutomaton]

This video is brilliant! I notice you didn't use leather and horsehair for the succussion process. I'm sure that's very important.... NOT!

They should show videos like this in Boots before they allow you to buy the homeopathic stuff.

[munavvar9]

u should do so we think!!!!!!

[pomonanist]

I think he might have used a different pipette for each stage.

Otherwise he's potentially contaminated the final glass with residual piss, in or on the pipette, from the first. The degree of contamination may be slight, but when you're dealing with dilutions this great it has to be an issue.

[TheBigMclargehuge]

Subscribed because of great content and A pin. You may receive 100 internets as a reward.

[woodwanderer]

Just generally, if that is indeed your "piss" then you should probably drink more water and try and eat healthier. The fact it's so yellow/gold reflects on your diet. If you go a day eating really healthy things and have lots of water your pee could be almost as colorless as water.

[hanslol]

@woodwanderer

You can't tell from the colour of his pee wheater he is healthy or not. There are diffrences from human to human. It doesn't matter if your food is "healthy" or not - just whats in it. For example Vitamin B6 can turn your urine into deep yellow, even if you drink 3 litres of water a day.

[Akira0ws]

lets calculate

we assume, that your "piss" is H2O, which has a molar mass of 18g/mol.

the dilution is 30 times 99% => 100^(30), means its the [10^60]th part of the origin mass.

1ml piss/h20 is 1/1000l ~= 1g --> 1/18mol h2o

1mol = 6.022*e23 particles

1/18th of this 6.022*e23 particles is 33455555555555555555555.55556 (33*e21) particles (thank you, windows calculater >_>)

aaaand now, ladies and gentleman, the 10^60th part of those 33*e21 h2o particles is 3^e-38.

you didnt drink piss, sorry :)

[IamtheLordofDoom]

Next time use a goddamn motherfucking TRIPOD!!! Otherwise, good video...

[skirlo]

very nice video :)

[pabobfin]

Thank you for being a THINKER.  You unfortunately are a rarity in these days of medical fraud. Can you come up with one for Chiropractic next? They need roasting, then REIKI!!!

Bravo

[mlhah]

haha, best demonstration of *homeoapathy* so far! :D

[acorntechnique]

What a waste of 7 mins of good server space.

[acorntechnique]

'If homeopathy works ... I'll drink my own piss'

un-quote.

well, whether you believe it or not, it works.

Ok so now upload a video of you drinking your own piss.

[macleod57]

You do not "believe" something works. Either it can be proven to work or in can not. Homeopathy has been proven over and over again to work no better than a placebo in other words it does not work. But hey, if you want to pay $20 for sugar pills more power to you. A fool and his money are easily parted.

[klnxmonkey]

maybe invest in a tripod?

[andiwand111]

damn and there are actually people who believe in this stuff...and pay for it ;) poor world

[SaganAppreciationSoc]

Brilliant/Favorited.

[dotcompals]

thank you for this nice and informative video. Wake up India, wake up.

[larryadmin]

I won't be going round his house for drinks any time soon :S

[mdilip]

Piss of Homeopathy, lol!

[MegaAtheistman]

I pissed myself laughing!

[TheWisemonkey8]

Thats some title... lol.

[acorntechnique]

The guy clearly has a fetish for his own piss...

Whatever turns him on I guess...

[bambusbln]

Guy, you should at least follow the procedure required by homeopathy itself, in order to prove it wrong, isnt it? So here : 1) potencies must be shaken in a closed bottle How to shake vigourously in an open glass? It is the kinetic energy input which is producing the efficacy of the medicament, not the dilution. Are homeopathy sceptics too stupid to understand this little difference? 2) shaking must be 10 times, not 3 times. 3) Yes, you should drink your own piss to wash your brain.

[SilverWingedSeraph]

It's all bullshit, so who cares?

[gabbergandalf667]

In some countries, it's subventioned by government health care.

What is more, people waste precious time on homeopathy instead of using real medicine.

[dantheman1507]

@gabbergandalf667

you're a dumbass

[gabbergandalf667]

@dantheman1507

Don't know bout that. Who is again practicing voodoo medicine to cure real, organic diseases? Surely not me.

Btw, ad hominem, how sophisticated. Congratulations. How about explaining the chemical or physical mechanism through which homeopathy works, instead of insulting me? Diluting an agent to a point where not a single molecule is left seems slightly unscientific to me, but I would be pleased if you can prove me wrong!

[MidgardEagle]

@bambusbln Backpedalling, are we?

[kirtanaddict]

Urine therapy has more benefits than most Rx drug treatments drs push with their de-population agenda!

[benji5]

Thats so awesome ! I love that video !

[stripymccatpuss]

Homeopathy is complete shite ! , unfortunately you have little understanding of their methods or mindset, or infact the mathmatics, Watch james Randi, then re edit this vid.

Ps beards are not a good look ! (Randi is excused)

[xRawlins]

I love this guy. Indeed, homeopathy is bullshit mysticism.

Check out this real-life homeopathy emergency room!

watch?v=HMGIbOGu8q0

[imameatcom]

Okay, what you hit the water on and what the water is contained in will not change what is in it. Which is water, and most likely nothing else.

[BriscoCountyJr23]

Did you rule out the formation of clathrates? Do your even know what a clathrate is?

Of course not, because you are ignorant of basic material sciences. This video proves nothing other than the general ignorance of people and science.

And no you did not create an homeopathic cure for piss, you created an isopathic remedy, which yet again shows your ignorance of homeopathy.

This deserves a big L.

[1985elfy]

Indeed, clathrates are very important! It's a very important distinction between the final solution being basically water with a tiny chance of finding a single molecule of the active substance - which would obviously not work at all - and the final solution being basically water with a tiny chance of finding a *clathrate containing* a single molecule of the active substance - which is very potent indeed.

[dlcu38]

@1985elfy I can't see BriscoCountyJr23's comment for some reason, but what on earth have clathrates to do with anything? Urine is a mixture, so you can't have a clathrate of it. Why is the probability of finding a molecule with a clathrate greater than finding a molecule without a clathrate?

[imameatcom]

Homeopathy is stupid.

[1985elfy]

Oh for goodness' sake. Of COURSE it looks ridiculous if you do it in those little plastic cups on an ordinary table. And it won't work, either. You need it in a proper phial, and it needs to be struck TEN times - not just a lousy three - on a proper leather striking board stuffed with horsehair.

This is the sort of deliberate distortion that so-called 'scientists' and allopaths like to do to 'prove' that homeopathy doesn't work by missing out essential parts of the process!!

[aimsbabes92]

I can't work out if you're being serious... I hope not.

[pvbonafina]

lol

[DefaultPosition]

@1985elfy

That's either great irony or profound hilarity

[235711131723]

1985elfy is not serious about his comment i think,

but from what i expirienced from homeopaths he could be and his comment later on could be not sarcasm.

poes law.

[thomasthavalathil]

Have you heard about the absent minded homoeopathic patient who forgot to take his medicine and died due to an overdose?

[keydetpiper]

Excellent.... I've shared this with several of my homeopathy-believing friends. I hope they get the idea.

[keydetpiper]

One of my friends saw this and said "Well of course he'd drink it at the end, he's diluted it so many times." She then tried to tell me all about how and why homeopathy works; she couldn't see any connection between this video and the nonsense she was trying to spread.

[psychobollox]

@keydetpiper

ROTFPMFHOL!

excellent comment, showing the fucking HUGE disconnect between homeopathy and real life!

[Gilgamesh417]

@keydetpiper is she still your friend? i'd stop being friends with her.

[RassieDog]

@keydetpiper Great post, thanks. (and I hope you have some more rational friends than that one.)

[JimERoy]

@keydetpiper Homeopathy has been working for over 200 years for millions of people. Granted we don't know exactly how if works in terms of a scientific explanation but we have a immense amount of clinical evidence. Not to fear though, if the presenter drinks his own piss, it is apparently a good Ayurvedic treatment - for scepticism.

[keydetpiper]

@JimERoy Incorrect. People have been thinking that homeopathy has been working for over 200 years. It's pretty clear that the only impact of the treatment is due to the placebo effect, because there is literally nothing in it but pure water. We understand the science behind it very well, i.e., there is none.

[murdocha]

@JimERoy Regardless the mechanism for the action of homeopathy, the scientific method would show IF it works. Time after time, in study after study, the more we blind and control for bias, the more negligible the effect.

We honestly don't need to know how it works (it doesn't) because we've shown pretty damn conclusively that it doesn't. All the arm waving and caps lock ranting doesn't change that.

[eleberr]

awesineee

[EdgarNr2]

Can I make a german version of this video?

[dominictemple]

Always makes me laugh.

[elgringos]

brilliant xDDD!!!

and i love the title!

i hope you don't mine if i use it myself ;P

[eebamxela]

oh sweet jesus thats a win.

[Gnometower]

Good experiment, but JESUS, please get a tripod or stop drinking 4 gallons of coffee before holding the camera. thanks, the rest of us.

[stevebritgimp]

Even if you did shortcut the process using 1 litre, I think it would still take 20 goes. Can anyone check my maths?

I think this is the process they use to make Strongbow Extra Cold - it's so bloody pale.

[waspbloke]

Hang on...you do actually drink your homeopathic piss, so does that count as an endorsement? And were you cured by your remedy? Were you even pissed when you took the remedy? And couldn't you shortcut the process by doing 1L dilutions?

[synsei1]

if you dilute 1 ml piss in 1 liter water you have a 1/1000 dilution, or 10^-3. if you dilute 1 ml piss 10 times in 100 ml water glasses you get 1/100, then 1/10,000, then 1/1,000,000 and so on. the final dilution will be 10CH or 10^-20.