This is why Roger is my hero. When your too tired to go on, too burnt out on life, too depressed, and beatdown... The show must go on. Its a song of strength.
I was thinking today. I know you are saying, finnaly! But think of this, its a wonderful VETERNS DAY, and if their was the most logical day to thank the FALLEN, it would be a Gracious day, for Gilmore to play his one song, wouldn't it !
That's amazing! Could someone uplode the whole thing -would be great! I'm a '78 child in a Post-socialist country and even being an infant at that time I still remember that movie and the horror I still feel about it...
first i must ask if someone know what flutelike instrument they're using right after the verses, cus that's probably the most beautiful sound i've ever heard, then i just want to say that this verision of this song is wort at least 10/5 stars
Thanks for posting it. I don't know how you get google ads on it, but hey more power to you. the irony is i was bummed thinking about my fledgling show which i post on youtube too & at one time had google ads on it too. Google banned me from adsense when i broke no copyright laws. i only made the mistake of accidentally clicking my own ads. Since then i have lost most all revenues for the show & now i am looking at insurance sale to survive. To pump myself up i found your song and was shocked.
I wish you could see the band..but none the less, this short piece has so much meaning for me anyway.. I have to always play it.. I like this one better than the album as it has an extra little verse..
Waters wanted the Beach Boys to do backing vocals and, amazingly, they agreed; until they realised the 'theme' of the wall, they quickly reneged and pulled out to do their own tour! lol! but Waters actually got some beach boys' backing session singers to tour with the wall.
The last lines of this song alone has special meanings to me.. And the way David sings it..nothing fancy, but powerful in it's own right. Great lyrics Roger, great arrangements to DG, RW & NM
Also 3 Dog Night had a song The Show Must Go On as well. All three bands are different..this one is made for The Wall so it fit into that category, unlike 3 Dog Night and Queen
There's good bands and bad bands...and then there's Pink Floyd, I've yet to hear any band who comes near their level of excellence, almost every single song they've made is like magic to my ears.
And my friend, there is Queen. A band in the category of Pinlk Floyd. The uncomparable though, as they are different styles of rock. Floyd's meaning is so deep, but Freddie Mercury is probably the best singer of all time.
@gorillazhead ill be there in arnhem april 9th, couldnt get a ticket in the uk so im off to holland to get meag wasted and see roger play the wall, cant wait
@ReaperOwnz I think i over heard my geometry teacher say that there was a concert of pink floyd as of November20,2010. You should take a look at it if you want ot go.
@ReaperOwnz I think i over heard my geometry teacher say that there was a concert of Pink Floyd as of November20,2010. You should take a look at it if you want to go.
i know its just the filming is not so good because this was in the beginning a failed recording secuence of the show but anyway they edited it and sell but i dont know where to buy this video
the show is incredible but its so sad that the quality is soooo bad
it would be nice to see this show with a decent quality
I jus love when dave starts with must the show go on.......... this song is short but i find it more strong than the queens one ... though i love tat one as well... this blows me everytime i hear it and its not the same wit the queens one for me....jus an opinion and fuck off who wanna give me thumbs down lol
It's not a cover. Pink Floyd wrote this song in 1979 and Queen in 1991. What happened was that Queen thought the title was wright for their song so they put it. But it's not a cover, stupid.
ppl got to stop comparing, both bands are great and both are legends, don't compare, and originally
Queen wrote the song, so..do not compare, i am personally more a queen fan but dude it's harsh to trash on one of the bands obviously pink floyd respects queen enough to cover one of their songs so.. it's not right to compare when the respect is mutual btwn the bands.
ohh my bad it's not a cover, but either way both songs are gud, it's not cool to trash either one especially when Queen's version is from the heart both bands are legends either way but both are awesome period!
wtff u guys upto comparing this with the queens??? dont u get a feeling when gilmour starts with Must the show go on.......?? so beautifully composed and vocals by gilmour is jus awesome.. i jus love it
Hey croc rocker, i am also a big fan of EJ. Let's go al the way back to skyline pigeon and madman across the water. Honky chateau Mona lisa and mad hatters, eldeberry wine. F'ing genius the 2 of them, B & E. Don't you be a tool
Hmmm. COmparing again. Taking a song out of the context of an album again. Winners losers, AGAIN. Queen is Queen, Floyd is FLoyd I love them both. I love floyd more. I don like the spoon to the beatles comment though. THe show must go on in the context of it's placement is irrreplaceable, sure as hell not with the queen version. Grow up crackheads
I assume the full version of this song was cut down for time and even a 2 album set couldn't fit every song it. The liner notes in the jacket features Rogers full lyrics. Empty Spaces (What Should We Do Now) was another song that was trimmed and only the concerts and the film featured the full version.
love the piano and synthesizer in this version. R.I.P. Rick Wright, Wish You Were Here
Lambs619 2 months ago
20 Dislikes?! Who are these morons!!!
Greatest song ever!
zsbtlb 2 months ago
first to comment in 5 moths... how sad
yourmotherslover1056 2 months ago
Comment removed
TheSupersaxman94 6 months ago
nusssssssssssssssssss lol
pqp sem palavras p/ descrever essa obra!
luiziix 8 months ago
Pink Floyd- The Show must go on 10/10 Queen- The show must go on 10/10
Two of mine favorites bands performing two different songs with the same title and both of them are outstanding....
DeDvaO 10 months ago 2
19 people tried to stop the show.
InfidelAntichristian 1 year ago
My god, even for such a short song, this is easily one of Pink Floyd's best. It's so sublime. I LOVE YOU PINK FLOYD
419CrazyDiamond 1 year ago 2
Two totally different songs Yes I'm a die-hard Queen fan but this is pretty cool.
Paul8820 1 year ago
BEAUTIFUL. Pink Floyd are GODS
Lambs619 1 year ago
what a magnificent voice...
systemshock73 1 year ago
must the show go on?
tomiko183 1 year ago
This is why Roger is my hero. When your too tired to go on, too burnt out on life, too depressed, and beatdown... The show must go on. Its a song of strength.
uh0oo 1 year ago 2
una de las mejores bandas del mundo ,un super grupooooo de mis favoritos
fmaykall 1 year ago
ahhhh such a great tune!!!!
NALRAMOREG 1 year ago
I was thinking today. I know you are saying, finnaly! But think of this, its a wonderful VETERNS DAY, and if their was the most logical day to thank the FALLEN, it would be a Gracious day, for Gilmore to play his one song, wouldn't it !
ernbar 1 year ago
Absolutely Fabulous!! The best band in history!
chef4cook 1 year ago
I love Queen, but this is not the same song and can´t be compared, this is a great song, but it is not the same as the queen song i know so well..
nyhuseriksen 1 year ago
What do you mean Queens version? Two completely different songs
Lawen78 1 year ago 9
That's amazing! Could someone uplode the whole thing -would be great! I'm a '78 child in a Post-socialist country and even being an infant at that time I still remember that movie and the horror I still feel about it...
adgaper 1 year ago
Beautiful, just beautiful. Pink Floys is the best.
NALRAMOREG 1 year ago 2
Do I have to stand up, wild-eyed in the spoltight?
What a nightmare! Why don't I turn and run?
Freaking great!!!!!
The bass thuds behind him are be-a-utiful
tfurrh1 1 year ago 4
queen's version is better
kingb212212 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kingb212212 Retard, two different songs. Why dont you go back to sucking on mommys teet. Stupid fag that you are.
NALRAMOREG 1 year ago
@NALRAMOREG u suck queen owns u and ur garb band/song suck on that big one bich low life low class trash
kingb212212 11 months ago
@DhakanRaj i agree queen version is holier than holyness
kingb212212 1 year ago
@kingb212212 Not even the same song jackass, Freddy was a Homo......
7777dmith7777 1 year ago
i love that synth at around 1:37
benlorenc 1 year ago
woah, extra stanza.
IamPersonMan 1 year ago
first i must ask if someone know what flutelike instrument they're using right after the verses, cus that's probably the most beautiful sound i've ever heard, then i just want to say that this verision of this song is wort at least 10/5 stars
FenderMeddle94 1 year ago
@FenderMeddle94 synthesizer
benlorenc 1 year ago
Thanks for posting it. I don't know how you get google ads on it, but hey more power to you. the irony is i was bummed thinking about my fledgling show which i post on youtube too & at one time had google ads on it too. Google banned me from adsense when i broke no copyright laws. i only made the mistake of accidentally clicking my own ads. Since then i have lost most all revenues for the show & now i am looking at insurance sale to survive. To pump myself up i found your song and was shocked.
tomestokes 1 year ago
theres some additional lyrics in this song that arent in the studio version. thats cool
freddiebarry93 1 year ago
Terribly underrated. Amazing live. This really should have been in the film. Would've liked to have seen its depiction.
TheRockNRollFan 1 year ago
where's the feeeeeling gooone
thedeadliest 1 year ago
Comment removed
fuckyoufuckyou1 1 year ago
pure class and some of the beach boys backing classic voices .floyd the greatest mucic ever and the beach boys.
roadend78 1 year ago
Comment removed
AlessioCircelli 1 year ago
Comment removed
Brrrrr43 1 year ago
I wish you could see the band..but none the less, this short piece has so much meaning for me anyway.. I have to always play it.. I like this one better than the album as it has an extra little verse..
Brrrrr43 1 year ago
@Brrrrr43 Well, you can't see the band because it is The Wall, of course. "Act like you don't want to pay attention, OK. We won't let you."
schmittelt 1 year ago
Que bien suena esta canción en el directo, genial.
LedColin 1 year ago
i never get fed up ov listening to pink floyd, they r beyond a doubt the greatest band ever !!!
coolchefcarl1963 1 year ago
the world will never again see a so beautiful music ... thanks pink floyd!
LeandroFloydMason 1 year ago
the world will never again see a so beautiful music ... thanks pink floyd!
LeandroFloydMason 1 year ago
@mattdavgra Thankfully we at least get to see Roger bring it back. Can't wait for the show to go on
jbelcher74 1 year ago
Waters wanted the Beach Boys to do backing vocals and, amazingly, they agreed; until they realised the 'theme' of the wall, they quickly reneged and pulled out to do their own tour! lol! but Waters actually got some beach boys' backing session singers to tour with the wall.
marcusbondi 1 year ago
Pero escucha esta cancion en el disco 2 is there anybody out there? y es la misma!!!
wargt06 1 year ago
The last lines of this song alone has special meanings to me.. And the way David sings it..nothing fancy, but powerful in it's own right. Great lyrics Roger, great arrangements to DG, RW & NM
Brrrrr43 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
a masterpiece, like always PINK FLOYD el mejor,
gracias SYD....
saludos desde Guate
LuisferSk8r 1 year ago
a master piece... like always. PINK FLOYD el mejor, q viva el fucking rock...
saludos desde Guatemala
LuisferSk8r 1 year ago
am I too old? Is it too late?
pfbsn 1 year ago 2
I wonder if Queen their song name from this
Lawen78 1 year ago
@Lawen78 yes in deed mercury was doing a tribute to the song. first is this song and then queen
marios745 1 year ago
The show must go ooooooooooooooooooooooooooOOOOOOOOn...
Awesome Pink floyd!
dedoesxxxinho 1 year ago
Awesome, thank you Pink Floyd an Thank you for posting it.
tomestokes 1 year ago
Nice......
redwhitch17 1 year ago
no se para quien es la pregunta... por si las moscas... es made at home
marcela421 1 year ago
No puede ser!!! ese video es del disco is there anybody out there? donde lo conseguiste???
Por cierto que buena esa cancion!!
wargt06 1 year ago
el disco no es is there anybody out there, el disco se llama The Wall, y este video es del concierto de ese album en 1980
Randropz 1 year ago
Esta es mi respuesta en video. La hice con muchas ganas de trasmitir algo... Espero le guste a alguien.
marcela421 1 year ago
I love this version with the added verse. The "where has the feeling gone" etc. gets to me every time.
Brrrrr43 1 year ago
gilmours voice sends a chill up my spine im not whorthy of his excellence
hogwarts09 2 years ago 58
Complete agreed with you +1!
SoloNetherlands 1 year ago
aw thanks mate
hogwarts09 1 year ago
@hogwarts09 i am LOL
kalen486 1 year ago
@hogwarts09 Seeing your statement ,i am sure that you are so worthy of his excellence.
pfloyd1987 1 year ago
@hogwarts09 awwwwww. u r so humble!
NebulaSu 11 months ago
muy buena cancion, donde es ese concierto
MARIOFER323 2 years ago
muy buena cancion de pink floy lo mejor de lo mejor, por cierto que concierto es ese
MARIOFER323 2 years ago
sucha an under ratted song,and it shoulda been put in the movie
EclipsedMind 2 years ago 6
is this a different version?
nbomb1204 2 years ago
yes they added another verse
zzzzzzooioriotrt 2 years ago 2
Hey.. How did you get this Video? well Doesnt matter You did a good Job
chavarigo 2 years ago
hey man i lost my account im greenguy.
greenguy13ofgta2 2 years ago
I think this version of the song is better than the original from the studio album.
nicolasdelariva 2 years ago 6
wow, i'm the 111,111th viewer
dangaertner7 2 years ago
woopee....what do you want? a cookie??
looloorex 2 years ago 2
Fuck the movie, this is the REAL thing. Pink FLoyd or bust!
matt72582 2 years ago 6
Comment removed
smilingpug 2 years ago
Asshole.
baseballfuries08 2 years ago
"There must be some mistake... I didnt mean to let them take away my soul. Am I too old, is it too late?"
warftrat87 2 years ago 5
heh, sounds bit like Queen - Boheman Rhapsody with the "ooooohh Take me home, Take me home, Take me hooome..."
ANFTAMMI4EVER 2 years ago
they changed the lyrics a bit....also, is this concert on DVD yet??? i want it
WlSEGUY 2 years ago
I have the DVD in NY and Earls Court...
matt72582 2 years ago
the vocal harmonies are awesome in this song
fantacist 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
che canzone di merda...
shicurum 2 years ago
ognuno ha i suoi gusti, torna ad ascoltare la sigla dei puffi...:S
Davideibanez 2 years ago
mierda tu puta madre perro.....
juegas 2 years ago
deficienti
shicurum 2 years ago
It would be so nice if they put these additional lyrics in the record.
I love this song.
TheIsabel7 2 years ago
When gilmour's voice crept in at the beginning... chills ran up and down my whole body!
IngridsFloydianslip 2 years ago 4
Me too !!! Same feeling as you .
Brrrrr43 2 years ago
David Gilmour is God
.... so is Roger, Richard and Nick
brandtus 2 years ago 2
Rip Richard Wright
stilox000 2 years ago
Also 3 Dog Night had a song The Show Must Go On as well. All three bands are different..this one is made for The Wall so it fit into that category, unlike 3 Dog Night and Queen
Brrrrr43 2 years ago
the Genius of Dave Gilmore & Roger Waters- Roger said he was haunted by his dead father who served in the War 1 or 2. i read that in a magazine-
paddygeo 2 years ago
It was 2
acholl980 2 years ago
this and queens show must go on couldent be more different , not much to compare..
gixxerich 2 years ago
Not bad.
See the "The Show Must Go On" by Queen.
Not much of a comparison, really ...
avi10000 2 years ago
those are two completely different songs and styles.
BearsRule43 2 years ago 2
There's good bands and bad bands...and then there's Pink Floyd, I've yet to hear any band who comes near their level of excellence, almost every single song they've made is like magic to my ears.
God I wish I could've seen them live...
ReaperOwnz 2 years ago 70
They were truly in a league of their own, and during a time when the best of the best were out there. They made their mark in music history.
Brrrrr43 2 years ago 13
And my friend, there is Queen. A band in the category of Pinlk Floyd. The uncomparable though, as they are different styles of rock. Floyd's meaning is so deep, but Freddie Mercury is probably the best singer of all time.
verilux83 2 years ago 3
@ReaperOwnz OMG, Roger Waters is touring "The Wall!"
Check concert times/locations.
gorillazhead 1 year ago
@gorillazhead ill be there in arnhem april 9th, couldnt get a ticket in the uk so im off to holland to get meag wasted and see roger play the wall, cant wait
timshill 1 year ago
@ReaperOwnz you apparently never heard of queen ;)
rnedisc 1 year ago
@ReaperOwnz you probably know this but roger waters is doin a tour of the wall in north america, which would if you live in like england or something
ImTotallyWithStupid 1 year ago
@ReaperOwnz nobody understands how much i want to make a time machine just to see this one concert the wall would of been amazing to go to
scarface92myway 1 year ago
@ReaperOwnz I think i over heard my geometry teacher say that there was a concert of pink floyd as of November20,2010. You should take a look at it if you want ot go.
214campos 1 year ago
@ReaperOwnz I think i over heard my geometry teacher say that there was a concert of Pink Floyd as of November20,2010. You should take a look at it if you want to go.
214campos 1 year ago
Their voices harmonize beautifully in this song. Better than on The Wall album I have. Little longer version too ! X:D
Brrrrr43 2 years ago 3
It was just a mistake, I didn't mean to let them take away my soul, am I to old? is it to late?
Where has the feeling gone? Will I remember the song?
THE SHOOW MUSST GOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOON!
GeezaGooderz 2 years ago 8
David... David ....David... Marry me in our next life! Saleda!
saledabyerly 2 years ago 3
PINK FLOYD FOREVER
THE BEST OF THE BEST
lostmymindbaby 2 years ago 2
oh... OK.
12greenguy 2 years ago 2
Porque meten a Queen? si esto es de Pink Floyd! -.-" Que tengan canciones con el mismo nombre es otra cosa..
Mafeeee17 2 years ago 2
why! you son a bitch! why!
12greenguy 2 years ago 4
must the show go on?
12greenguy 2 years ago 4
I love this song... is amazing
One of the best of P Floyd
Saludos desde Argentina
Nico89Cani 2 years ago 2
This is one of my all time fave Floyd songs! and I'm wondering why its not in the movie or Rogers live in Berlin
idropped77 2 years ago 2
AMAZING SONG
gixo92 2 years ago
This is Pink Floyd's The Show Must Go On ... Queen have their own The Show Must Go On ... the 2 tracks are totally different
kimchappers 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
is this a queen or pink floyd song?
metalmakis 3 years ago
pink floyd
link9367 2 years ago
i mean this song is great and that all but this video is like a picture is just the wall with the lights
angusyoung98 3 years ago
but it's all part of the greatest live show ever
wootenwannabe 3 years ago 3
i know its just the filming is not so good because this was in the beginning a failed recording secuence of the show but anyway they edited it and sell but i dont know where to buy this video
the show is incredible but its so sad that the quality is soooo bad
it would be nice to see this show with a decent quality
anyway this is THE greatest show in history
angusyoung98 3 years ago 2
why are there different lyrics???
nbomb1204 3 years ago
it's slightly extended
TetsumiKato 3 years ago 4
Comment removed
idropped77 2 years ago
yeah i noticed it too.
meetmeatthe1 2 years ago
how beautiful! :>
idakaroline93 3 years ago
I jus love when dave starts with must the show go on.......... this song is short but i find it more strong than the queens one ... though i love tat one as well... this blows me everytime i hear it and its not the same wit the queens one for me....jus an opinion and fuck off who wanna give me thumbs down lol
9841496228 3 years ago 4
who cares if they have the same title.. they are two different songs
You coulda named them peice of shit 1 n peice of shit 2 and I would still love both of em
stupidexample 3 years ago
What's with the comparisons to the Queen song? The only thing that's the same is the title...
ydargc 3 years ago 3
It's not a cover. Pink Floyd wrote this song in 1979 and Queen in 1991. What happened was that Queen thought the title was wright for their song so they put it. But it's not a cover, stupid.
sianinesse 3 years ago 5
Damn right!Beside it's stupid to compare this two great bands!
scarzzy11080 3 years ago 5
ppl got to stop comparing, both bands are great and both are legends, don't compare, and originally
Queen wrote the song, so..do not compare, i am personally more a queen fan but dude it's harsh to trash on one of the bands obviously pink floyd respects queen enough to cover one of their songs so.. it's not right to compare when the respect is mutual btwn the bands.
crtunlvr 3 years ago
ohh my bad it's not a cover, but either way both songs are gud, it's not cool to trash either one especially when Queen's version is from the heart both bands are legends either way but both are awesome period!
crtunlvr 3 years ago
@crtunlvr actually the pink floyd version came before the queen version
achedd 1 year ago
Great Song!...And Album....Classic
onlythepianoplayer 3 years ago
PINK FLOYD IS THE BEST BAND EVER!
leopardgeckoWV2 3 years ago
when youre right youre right.
saruman84 3 years ago
Genial cancion en mi grupo favorito.
OS QUIERO QUEEN Y PINK FLOYD
bebytaa85 3 years ago
wtff u guys upto comparing this with the queens??? dont u get a feeling when gilmour starts with Must the show go on.......?? so beautifully composed and vocals by gilmour is jus awesome.. i jus love it
The show must go on........
9841496228 3 years ago
Great song Great band Pish videoing
kenny306 3 years ago
Hey croc rocker, i am also a big fan of EJ. Let's go al the way back to skyline pigeon and madman across the water. Honky chateau Mona lisa and mad hatters, eldeberry wine. F'ing genius the 2 of them, B & E. Don't you be a tool
FRANKIEFRIPP 3 years ago
I meant I did like the spoon coment ;-)
FRANKIEFRIPP 3 years ago
Hmmm. COmparing again. Taking a song out of the context of an album again. Winners losers, AGAIN. Queen is Queen, Floyd is FLoyd I love them both. I love floyd more. I don like the spoon to the beatles comment though. THe show must go on in the context of it's placement is irrreplaceable, sure as hell not with the queen version. Grow up crackheads
FRANKIEFRIPP 3 years ago 3
comparing queen to pink floyd is comparing spoon to the beatles... pink floyd wins so hard... this song is seriously ecstacy in music form
PinkFloydd77 3 years ago
pink floyd at its best. R I P Rick you lengend
philgeff 3 years ago
must the show go on?
12greenguy 3 years ago
jak
dima4ever 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
what the hell....
it's not queen's ..
teddyqueen 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
queens sucks compared to pink floyd
ThaCrystalMeathod 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
what???!!
oh you're so funny
rofl
teddyqueen 3 years ago
Bocchinariell''....Nun capisc' nu cazz' Te' capit'???
Cunctator88 3 years ago
im sorry i dont speak ? no offence
ThaCrystalMeathod 3 years ago
Oh yeah. Because this song can hold it's own like Queen's can.
Tool.
CrocodileRocker 3 years ago 2
This is the best version I've heard of this song!! It's the best, especially with the extra lyrics!!
heycoll 3 years ago
I assume the full version of this song was cut down for time and even a 2 album set couldn't fit every song it. The liner notes in the jacket features Rogers full lyrics. Empty Spaces (What Should We Do Now) was another song that was trimmed and only the concerts and the film featured the full version.
acholl980 2 years ago 13
and the Original Film Sessions bootleg.
PanekPL 2 years ago
must the show go on?
12greenguy 3 years ago 7
i believe Bob geldof's name in the movie was "Pinky"
livelli 3 years ago
"Pink"
qwerty09121209 3 years ago 2
you're right,my mistake :)
livelli 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fuck !! fuck !!! fuck !!!
sorinellAmore 3 years ago
The Floyd Pinkleton was just a storyline for the movie. There is no, was no "Floyd Pinkleton." Is that even the characters name?
gamerboy290 3 years ago
Was the additional lyrics in this version written by Gilmour or Waters?
eazylee369 3 years ago
All of the lyrics were Waters.
Bluesub6 3 years ago 2
....i can just say i love floyd...
19johnlennon89 3 years ago 2
must the show go on?
12greenguy 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The video doesn't show anything.
45Akira 3 years ago
That's the whole point. It's about THE WALL.
TheLegend313 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
queen pwns this song
kingb212212 3 years ago
ass wipe...
BlowoutBob 3 years ago
Hmm...you're a dumbass...hmm
Quackerdoodle44 3 years ago 3
p w n s ?
daddybecks 3 years ago 4
pwn is a misspelling of the word own coined by W.O.W. aka world of warcraft
will90fire 3 years ago 4