rudolf hess looks like such a dork. so does himmler. in fact, all the top nazis except goering looked like major dorks. what gives?? ahaha i dunno :~P
I still don't like this video. I don't think Billy Corgan would like it either. There's nothing "historically significant" about using a great song like Tonight Tonight alongside images of Nazis.
Billy Corgan would not be pleased at all. None of the Pumpkins would appreciate their music as the backdrop to bullsh*t Nazi propaganda AKA Triumph of the Will.
Well, this is a dangerous thing. You like it or not, history is history - and we should NOT pick what we like and shy from the rest. THAT is really dangerous!! What if the generations to come would simply not know what happened because someone hid it? EVERYTHING that happened is historically significant, whether YOU (or I or someone else) likes it or not!
This doesnt explain what happened in history. This is just a bunch of pro nazi footage. If someone who didnt know what happened in history and watched this to learn about it all they would think is oh nazis are great they like the smashing pumpkins. Where is the part explaining about how millions of innocent people were massacered just because hitler was psychotic and thought they were bad.
Agree! But such people, with such an idiotic judgment, would deserve the effects of their naivete, no? If people learn history by making analogies with the smashing pumpkins, well.. I find the polarization of discussion disturbing - people cannot talk cold-headed even 60 years after. Where is the history? In the footage - it's authentic, isn't it? Where's the bizarrrerie? In the soundtrack's uninspired combination. Just read the comments on this video: most of them are extremely polarized.
Funny.. most all the 'positive' comments about this video are written in a civilized language, while most 'negative' ones are plainly suburban, let alone written in sad English. Any correlation one spots here? (BTW, if you the bad-language-guys don't know what correlation is, then I rest my case..)
Precisely what I mean. You retard, how many English mistakes do you think you just made in your sentence? I leave you the rest of 2008 (and ok, 1st half of 2009) to figure that out. Just don't get too depressed, it's OK, you just didn't have the chance for a civilized education.. Hm, but BTW, weren't we just trying to make the same point, after all? I really get confused here.
Is that really true? One may see it as a case of a parenthetical word or, even better, a case of emphasizing the last part of the sentence. But you may be right (after all, [note the correct comma usages], I humbly argue that there are a few more embarrassing mistakes in the text I referred to). But all's in the eye of the beholder of course.
Still a great video, no matter how many times ive watched it. The song fits perfectly with the clip from "Triumph of the Will". Anybody interested about WWII and that kind of stuff should check it out
This is ridicolous! Hitler is sick! He doesn`t diserve appear in a video in the tv or in anywhere! He`s sick! Only diserve the forgiveness..... Coldstatic if billy, james, d´arcy or chamberlin watch this video their gona hate.... like all of us......
this is rediculous.and also dangerous.people have lost their lives because of this crazy motherf""er called Hitler.he doesn t deserve this perfect song.
I think that everyone who has commented negatively on this video is being a reactionary pussy and isn't using sound judgment.
Nothing in this video alludes to or glorifies any of the atrocities committed by the Third Reich. It's a brilliant artistic statement that perfectly captures the mood that was undoubtedly in the air that night. The song fits so perfectly with the video.
I am a graduate student studying history and I spent last semester studying propaganda and the Third Reich. First of all, if you don't think the intention of this video was to glorify Hitlers, then you aren't mature enough or educated enough to be watching it. Secondly, the only people who ever claimed that this piece of propaganda was "considered one of the greatest films ever made" was those who were members of the Third Reich. You should not be tarnishing the SP by using their song.
Well being a college student myself I find most graduate students(and college students in general) are just propagandists and lobbyists for Israel(the Nazi terror state our troops are dying in Iraq for). The majority of so-called "professionals" that get degrees nowadays are just puppet golem's doing the devil's deeds for him. You don't believe me? Checkout: jewishvirtuallibrary dot com The site will tell you who funds what school and why. The Zionists love to brag.
It seems people have forgotten that this is considered (or was once) considered one of the greatest films ever made. I highly doubt whoever made this video made it to glorify the Nazis. Think beyond the content people! Anyway the music actually fits the video rather well.
Maybe I'm over-estimating Coldstatic, but this doesn't seem to be a video to shock jock. Germany was going through a bad time, and a man with his own ambitions appeared to them like a savior. It's horribly sad what people can fool themselves to believe when all they can do is hope for an answer. Everybody looked so happy in the footage, and I could only imagine what they felt when they realized what this caused. I think the song adds to the foolishness of depending on another to save you.
The humour factor from this clip is fuckn ZERO! I can't understand how anybody would destroy such a beautiful song with such filth!! Get a life Fuckers!!
you fucking nazi bastard I and im sure many more people are disgusted about this spread your hate and your lies somewhere else not with the music of the smashing pumpkins it dosnt belong here or any where. You make me and im sure millions of other people sick get a life.
I don't think many people, especially those who happen to love this song would appreciate what it is put to. A love song should not be a soundtrack for the most evil man on the planet.
SIEG HEIL!!!!
Slumminbum 9 months ago
this sucks
SmEmOrAnDa1979 11 months ago
haha hermann goring isd such a fat poppy plant
cordfluidnevoie 1 year ago
Hitler was a man who seen into the future and seen what the world would become. He fought for the white race. I wish he won.
lastwhiteman23 1 year ago
Comment removed
cordfluidnevoie 1 year ago
This is the most beautiful of all Coldstatic. Compliments!
Windiria 1 year ago
rudolf hess looks like such a dork. so does himmler. in fact, all the top nazis except goering looked like major dorks. what gives?? ahaha i dunno :~P
slimedud 1 year ago
This is offensive to ALL Jews Who died in the Holocaust, It is offensive to all living relatives of Jews killed by Hitler.
IRISEILEENHARDIG 1 year ago
ok..can anyone tell me why are you all talking bout the past and WW2?
can't you just enjoy the video?
sure, it's nazi footage, but what the hell?
the person who made this video
really did a good job. it's a little piece of art.
respect it.
5 stars btw.
Starvoid7 1 year ago
Comment removed
quest8899 1 year ago
The Soviet Union fucked up Nazi Germany.
quest8899 1 year ago
thanks.
dinosaurjerk 2 years ago
hahah nice joke. The man who is incarnation of love and peace against the being named Hitler. Who gave more to the world?
billytdakid 2 years ago
youre a fucking idiot
bunsofmolybdenum 2 years ago
Hitler is faguet!!! If you like him go to hell and let him fuck you!
billytdakid 2 years ago
hahahaha i dont know why but this is the funniest thing ive ever seen.. hashaha
johnsnith 2 years ago 2
wtf??
1Starlight19 2 years ago 2
wow
nousernamefool 2 years ago
hitler and amashing pumpkins? I dont get it.
amagadz 2 years ago
ich lieben das schön drehen !! <3<3
<3<3<3 yo got me smile in love !!!!danke !!
beoargentocorp 2 years ago
Great! :D
boegeniburen 3 years ago 3
look at those idiots
bassplyr01 3 years ago
smashing nazis sucks
mellamoinvierno 3 years ago
NO NO NO dude wtf is THIS SHIT?
sooprcool 3 years ago
Omg, the guy who posted the vids a fucking zionist, everyone get your facts straight!
MrsPeteDoherty 3 years ago
this movie isnt nazi propaganda its a peice of history. with a good song :)
and without historic movies like this we would forget what happened and possibly make the same mistake again.
ericthehurdler 3 years ago
I still don't like this video. I don't think Billy Corgan would like it either. There's nothing "historically significant" about using a great song like Tonight Tonight alongside images of Nazis.
UbiquitousGeek 3 years ago
Billy Corgan would not be pleased at all. None of the Pumpkins would appreciate their music as the backdrop to bullsh*t Nazi propaganda AKA Triumph of the Will.
TheVerve31 3 years ago
Well, this is a dangerous thing. You like it or not, history is history - and we should NOT pick what we like and shy from the rest. THAT is really dangerous!! What if the generations to come would simply not know what happened because someone hid it? EVERYTHING that happened is historically significant, whether YOU (or I or someone else) likes it or not!
melkquelk 3 years ago
History or not, it's distasteful.
UbiquitousGeek 3 years ago
This doesnt explain what happened in history. This is just a bunch of pro nazi footage. If someone who didnt know what happened in history and watched this to learn about it all they would think is oh nazis are great they like the smashing pumpkins. Where is the part explaining about how millions of innocent people were massacered just because hitler was psychotic and thought they were bad.
jcs1234jcs 3 years ago
Agree! But such people, with such an idiotic judgment, would deserve the effects of their naivete, no? If people learn history by making analogies with the smashing pumpkins, well.. I find the polarization of discussion disturbing - people cannot talk cold-headed even 60 years after. Where is the history? In the footage - it's authentic, isn't it? Where's the bizarrrerie? In the soundtrack's uninspired combination. Just read the comments on this video: most of them are extremely polarized.
melkquelk 3 years ago
Funny.. most all the 'positive' comments about this video are written in a civilized language, while most 'negative' ones are plainly suburban, let alone written in sad English. Any correlation one spots here? (BTW, if you the bad-language-guys don't know what correlation is, then I rest my case..)
melkquelk 3 years ago
yea how about we get them in the gas chamber..just kill em off...pffftt your an idiot
jcs1234jcs 3 years ago
Precisely what I mean. You retard, how many English mistakes do you think you just made in your sentence? I leave you the rest of 2008 (and ok, 1st half of 2009) to figure that out. Just don't get too depressed, it's OK, you just didn't have the chance for a civilized education.. Hm, but BTW, weren't we just trying to make the same point, after all? I really get confused here.
melkquelk 3 years ago
"the same point, after all?"
I guess in the midst of educating that guy on his english, you forgot how to use a comma. English can be hard. :D
str8ngthofh3rc 2 years ago
Is that really true? One may see it as a case of a parenthetical word or, even better, a case of emphasizing the last part of the sentence. But you may be right (after all, [note the correct comma usages], I humbly argue that there are a few more embarrassing mistakes in the text I referred to). But all's in the eye of the beholder of course.
melkquelk 2 years ago
Still a great video, no matter how many times ive watched it. The song fits perfectly with the clip from "Triumph of the Will". Anybody interested about WWII and that kind of stuff should check it out
herps 3 years ago 7
How did a misguided guy like you get such good music taste?
theonekeyblade 3 years ago
This is not hateful. It's an interesting, artistic snapshot of an intense period of human history.
rick3001 3 years ago
Look at this guys other videos and his friends comments on his channel.He's a nazi who makes nazi propaganda videos.Not an artist.
theonekeyblade 3 years ago
Nazi cunts
theonekeyblade 3 years ago
Can some of the idiots here appreciate the irony displayed here and give this video 5 stars. Thank u assholes! ^^
LutjeKabal 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Okay, that was just fucktarded. I don't think Billy Corgan would want his music associated with this asshole.
MacGeeek 3 years ago
Maybe it was pulled from a documentary of WWII. The video has historical importance, regardless of it's significance.
RaySzulc 3 years ago
I was mostly just kidding btw
alsatiancousin1 4 years ago
this is funny as hell
and a lot of artists dig the nazis
and collect nazi memorabilia
some of their clothes were pretty goodlooking and almost mods-style btw
Im not a racist or anything but to islam is just as offensive as nazis and such
actually worse cause at least the nazis had a sense of humour
alsatiancousin1 4 years ago 6
They knew how to dress for the occasion in the good ole' days.
SiliconBong 4 years ago 2
@alsatiancousin1 - Those are stupid artists then. Mods were also pretentious, uneducated losers for the most part. Why bring Islam into this?
BayviewFinch 11 months ago
i don't get it why so many people make all this fuzz about.
it's original, never done before!
if this video would be a real disgrace, youtube would have removed it by now.
realnuts 4 years ago 3
LOLOLOLOL- I don't know what the purpose of this was, but it was funny
AcidTrout 4 years ago
This is ridicolous! Hitler is sick! He doesn`t diserve appear in a video in the tv or in anywhere! He`s sick! Only diserve the forgiveness..... Coldstatic if billy, james, d´arcy or chamberlin watch this video their gona hate.... like all of us......
undermyown 4 years ago
this is rediculous.and also dangerous.people have lost their lives because of this crazy motherf""er called Hitler.he doesn t deserve this perfect song.
kill hitler tonight!tonight!
RedSkyBlues 4 years ago
I think that everyone who has commented negatively on this video is being a reactionary pussy and isn't using sound judgment.
Nothing in this video alludes to or glorifies any of the atrocities committed by the Third Reich. It's a brilliant artistic statement that perfectly captures the mood that was undoubtedly in the air that night. The song fits so perfectly with the video.
godis4sale 4 years ago 4
I am a graduate student studying history and I spent last semester studying propaganda and the Third Reich. First of all, if you don't think the intention of this video was to glorify Hitlers, then you aren't mature enough or educated enough to be watching it. Secondly, the only people who ever claimed that this piece of propaganda was "considered one of the greatest films ever made" was those who were members of the Third Reich. You should not be tarnishing the SP by using their song.
TheVerve31 4 years ago
Well being a college student myself I find most graduate students(and college students in general) are just propagandists and lobbyists for Israel(the Nazi terror state our troops are dying in Iraq for). The majority of so-called "professionals" that get degrees nowadays are just puppet golem's doing the devil's deeds for him. You don't believe me? Checkout: jewishvirtuallibrary dot com The site will tell you who funds what school and why. The Zionists love to brag.
dancewithme220 4 years ago
It seems people have forgotten that this is considered (or was once) considered one of the greatest films ever made. I highly doubt whoever made this video made it to glorify the Nazis. Think beyond the content people! Anyway the music actually fits the video rather well.
herps 4 years ago 2
smashing pumpkins kick hitler ass!!!!!!
go kill yourself for tarnishing good music
alicekilledherself 4 years ago
Some people say Hitler was too soft....
DOWDLE 4 years ago
Germans ate all of hitlers lies...sad
ripvanwinckle 4 years ago
Maybe I'm over-estimating Coldstatic, but this doesn't seem to be a video to shock jock. Germany was going through a bad time, and a man with his own ambitions appeared to them like a savior. It's horribly sad what people can fool themselves to believe when all they can do is hope for an answer. Everybody looked so happy in the footage, and I could only imagine what they felt when they realized what this caused. I think the song adds to the foolishness of depending on another to save you.
alusiddreamer 4 years ago 2
these 'happy' people were lied to. they had no idea what they were doing. is that your idea of happiness?
rasputindonie 4 years ago
Some say "ignorance is bliss". I don't disagree with you.
alusiddreamer 3 years ago
you are one sick mother fucker, not for the nazism but destroying this song, you are just as bad as hitler
bloube0123 4 years ago
The humour factor from this clip is fuckn ZERO! I can't understand how anybody would destroy such a beautiful song with such filth!! Get a life Fuckers!!
ratbov 4 years ago
yeah but you guys should see his ace to base video, this shit is somehow funny
NapalmKid 4 years ago
PUTO NAZI DE MIERDA!! LOS SMASHING SON GENTE HONRADA, ESTO DEBERIA ESTAR PENADO!!...Nazi scum
felizuco 4 years ago
Smashing Pumpkins+Nazis= BAD.
LoveForAAR 4 years ago
hope this is ment critical
SmashedBurger 4 years ago
Verdamte Nazi schweine
SmashedBurger 4 years ago
omg, this is soooooo funny. its offically fav'd.
jared81799 4 years ago
omg. this is fucking hilarious!
LMFAO LMFAO!
MaltLiquorPanda 4 years ago
you fucking nazi bastard I and im sure many more people are disgusted about this spread your hate and your lies somewhere else not with the music of the smashing pumpkins it dosnt belong here or any where. You make me and im sure millions of other people sick get a life.
bastardchildren 4 years ago
Not cool.
mocarro 4 years ago
I don't think many people, especially those who happen to love this song would appreciate what it is put to. A love song should not be a soundtrack for the most evil man on the planet.
shockfaul 4 years ago
what the fuck is all this shit about!
billford2593 4 years ago