Added: 4 years ago
From: refreshe2
Views: 180,452
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,037)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • can someone please tell me what ben is doing now? just randomly thought about him today. after idol finished I was really hoping he would go far with his singing...

  • @toniisisethen, He went to my school and my friend is friends with him, and I actually asked her about him the other day what he was up to, and apparently he moved to Sydney, and he's an artist.. and apparentally he hates it when you mention idol to him because he's trying to 'move on' with his life. :/ It's so sad :(

  • whos adam?

  • shut up marsha

  • Gary jules was the best version but this one takes a shit on adams version

  • i remember watching this all those years ago and being blown away!

    it is absolutely beautiful.

    i hope ben is still doing his thing and singing! :)

  • FUCK YOU MARCIA!!!!!!!!

  • I think this version is heaps better than that american tosser..... Ben should have released this as a single... much better than the original from tears for fears I reckon!

  • OMG I've had to sign up just so I can add a comment to defend Ben and his beautiful take on this song! Personally, this is my favourite version. It's what ever reaches your soul, and speaks to you. I found Ben's performance to be honest and down to earth. I found Adams to be over the top....Maybe too many drama classes? I dont care what anyone says in reply to my comment...I know what I like and I'm sticking to it!

  • This version shits on Adams who I cant stand live.

  • I really don't get why people get so heated about this. I MUCH prefer this version to Adam's because I love the tone of Ben's voice. The huskiness (as Mark mentions) of his tone sends shivers down my spine. I think while Adam's version may be more difficult to sing it is a bit contrived and it sounds too 'perfect' for me. But hey we all have different opinions! Just listen to what you like & remember that music is like art - not everyone likes the same thing (that would be a boring world!)

  • dicko!!!! :D <3

  • he reminds me of an older justin beiber

  • This guy can sing .. But saying that Adam was inspired by his version is foolishness..

    I completely agree that Adam is the best singer that have been found in talent shows..He's got an unique voice.. The way he hits high notes is absolutely mind blowing .. Adam did sing this song live in AL and that was the best performance in the history of idol.. !!!

  • Damn killer. He killed that song. Stating my opinion, that's it.

  • LOL, Glad to see Adam got no influence from this guy. Might have got the ideal to sing it, but i doubt this version would inspire anyone to want to sing it.

  • That guy at 2.50 is highly offensive about teen acne, that was uncalled for and unprofessional. I know Aussies speak with no nonsense but thats a step too far Mr!

  • @PhobiaGuy Lol were just like that :)

  • Benjimac - oh we loved you darling!!! You shoulda won. But all you twits going on about Adam pinching this for his version. LMAO PULEASE! This is just the Jules version arranged to suit Benji's voice. Adam used the same Jules version and ripped it up to make it something completely unique.

  • Love the way he specifies the "Gary Jules" version. This is in no way even close totthe Gary Jules version.

  • lol this is not the ben mckenzie i was looking for

  • this version sucked 

  • amazing<3 sorry to say but it's much better than adam lambert's version...

  • Amazing......

  • I'm french. I didn't know this singer and I like :) . A french guy also sang this song in "Nouvelle Star", the Australian Idol in France. You can see the video -> "Benjamin nouvelle star 2010 mad world" :) enjoy

  • Don't like the way he is standing, love his version very beautiful suites his voice =)

  • Damn He sucks!

  • This kid is good but doesn't have the range that Adam has just listen his range stays same doesn't vary.

  • I think Tears for Fears, Gary Jules, and Ben all tried to get across different emotions with their performances and arrangements. I feel like they each have their own interpretations of a "Mad World."

    Tears for Fears: feeling overwhelmed,

    Gary Jules: Depression and confusion

    Ben McKenzie: Fear and anxiety

    I think Adam's version tries to convey feelings of depression and isolation, so I would agree that he's probably more inspired by Gary Jules version than anyone else's.

  • sorry but it BAD the original is really bettre ...

    mais vraiment koi C clair y a pas photo ^^

  • i love this version, no idea why people are hating on it. his voice is incredible!

  • u suck

  • Beurk.

  • Beurk.

  • omg the original is much better that THAT!

    i don´t like it.....

  • Pure and absolute magic. Beautiful!!

  • he not using the rythm of the song but his voice is good in other words bad cover good voice

  • after living in Australia for 7 years, I cannot believe this poofer is the top talent they can produce, I heard (and saw) better singers at RFL clubs.. This guy is a simpering whining ...what? don't tell me he won? What a shitty version

  • @usmctanks1 no he didn't, Natalie Gauci won. but she turned out to be crap as well. Pretty crap season.

  • Awesome job and it is easily better then Adam Lambert who sounds like crud live.

  • ruined it -_-

  • Good but not as good as Adam of American Idol, and not as emotional as Benjamin in la Nouvelle star. And I prefer Benjamin's voice though IMHO Adam's voice is better controlled.

    But the only version which really moves me is Benjamin's.

  • wow...what an emo fag.

    i hope he slit his wrists after this performance.

  • @moondy11 I hope you slit your wrists you homophobic idiot.

  • GAY

  • good voice, but very bad cover

  • Im sorry but bens version was so much better then the american idol adam. I stoped watching the show when he got voted out, only voice i heard with color

  • hes very good

  • The difference between Ben's and Adam's version of this song is the emotion they're trying to portray. Adam really tried to get across feelings of depression, sadness, and confusion even, in addition to showing of his vocals. Ben really tried to push feelings of fear and anxiety and vulnerability. At least that's the impression I get.

  • witch witch witch , let's all burn him

  • @btecterrocks i like your logic.. dumbass

  • thats Rg what ever the fuck.......fag

  • extremely good

    but after watching adam lambert's version .. cant compare

  • Not trying to be biased but Adam Lambert's version RAWKS! however, Ben has a lot of talent, too! That's great! (:

  • is this a guy or a girl.........this song is gay i want to hear the original

  • Didn't really care for this song before...until I heard Ben's version. He almost sounded "new wave".

  • Just listened to Adam Lambert's version. IMHO, Ben's version is better. Nice tone, confident singing....very recordable. Ben's voice is very natural while Adam's is too "trained". I agree with one of the judges: his lower register is very soulful while his higher register is very pure. : )

  • No problem.. poor guy maybe he's got talent....but that is an insult for the song...oh please

  • adam lampert can sing but he takes it up the ass.

  • Omg ben was my fave!! he is amazing. perfect song for him!!

  • you americans out there that say this guy cant sing...Go screw yourselves bloody yankee pricks...Ill give you that much Adam Lambert is talented but there is no way in this world that Adam lambert did a better rendition of this song than Ben Mackenzie...besides they sound completely different and both performed the song in their own way....Go B mac...AUSSIE AUSSIE AUSSIE

  • wow, he bitchered this song.... gary jules would be rolling in his grave..... if he was dwad lol

  • How old was Adam? Huh? Huh? Ben was 17...so he's still kinda raw with his talent, but I thought this was amazing, first time I'd even heard of the song. [2007]

  • who the fuck is adam lambert

  • BAD !!!

  • Best Cover Of This by an Idol!!

  • i don't see any similarity between Ben's version and Adam's version.....none at all that didn't already come from the original song.

    Adam sang it....better.

  • I loved it when I first heard it too - was my favourite year on Aus Idol - show stopper.

    I like Adam Lamberts version too - these boys are exceptional singers. Good luck to both of them..

  • This boy was fantastic & was eliminated way too early. Sooooooo good! Go Ben! :)

  • I'm pissed at Ben.. have you heard Adam Lambert's single of this song? He was on American Idol and recorded this song. Now it's used for "Flash Forward' and sounds AWFULLY similar to this. I wish Ben had recorded it! Grrrr

  • It sounds similar because they both used the Gary Jules version.

  • Look, I've heard Gary Jule's & Adam Lamberts versions, and I still think Ben's version is the best. He was only a little kid when he sang this, and he blew me away when I watched it over two years ago.

  • Now we know where Adam got his influence for his version.

  • @magbear

    I think he was influenced by Gary Jules not this idol contestant.

  • @magbear we do

  • @magbear Can't agree with you. Adam got his inspiration from watching the version in "Donnie Darko." This kid is good but doesn't show any range variation.

  • @magbear what the hell are you talking about? their versions is nothing alike. Adams is 10 times better than this, both arrangement and voice wise.

  • @xamphie

    This version is better, and the reasons have nothing to do with arrangement or voice. This song is actually about something, not just a high-priced studio arrangement while someone hits high notes and reads lyrics off a page.

    This version might even be better than the original. Having a teenager sing it, with some actual hint of emotion and understanding in his voice...makes this much more poignant, almost haunting. If you want empty, note-perfect karaoke, go back to Adam's video.

  • Comment removed

  • @EGarrett01

    How can you even compare Adams version with karaoke? You obviously have no clue about music. I don't like the original myself, so I can't disagree with you saying this might be better than the original. In Adams performance you can see it's passionate and a lot of emotions.

    Adam is born to be on the stage, the biggest star america's found on talent shows so far, no doubt in my mind.

  • @EGarrett01 You have no clue as to what talent is. This version is OK. Nowhere near the greatness of Adam's version. This singer isn't half the singer that Adam is. If you actually had an ear for music you would know how much more difficult it is to sing Adam's version than this. Adam has control throughout the whole song and when he sings quietly, he draws you in. It is difficult to maintain control singing high notes quietly. This singer has breathing issues along with the pitch issues.

  • @BIEDS4U

    In the very first sentence of what you replied to, I said that the reasons had NOTHING to do with arrangement or voice. Are you retarded?

  • @EGarrett01 Are you really that stupid!! I didn't point out arrangement, or voice. If you actually had a brain you would know that having emotion is being able to draw you in. Adam's voice and style, especially his high singing just draws out the pure emotion of this song. Unlike Ben who is airy and under pitch throughout the song. That is not emotion! Maybe in your shallow marshmellow-filled world it might be. Maybe you ought to think before you post so you don't sound so ignorant!

  • @BIEDS4U No one gives a shit you pisshead. Adam can suxk a dick coz his version was fuckin dick!

  • Nice....but, the benchmark will ALWAYS be Adam Lambert!

    The End.

  • Oh I remember this. I was in love with this guy. He was my fave to win. Too bad he hasn't done anything since...

  • hasnt done anything?

    have you heard his songs?

  • No I haven't. You're right I should have checked. But I kinda meant he hasn't done anything mainstream.

  • ah well, you should check out his myspace (:

  • Wauw, he has a beautiful voice...

  • Comment removed

  • > HatchetWarr1or

    You right!!!

  • No one will every respect your opinion with a name like MissxPattinson

  • And I will never accept a rebuttal that in no way, shape, or form pertains to the topic at hand.

    Don't like my opinion? Well, that's just grand. I've never been a people-pleaser, and I sure as heck won't start now.

    You wanna' argue, son? Then give me something to work with.

  • alright... daughter..

    Nah, you know, you just made yourself look pretty dumb as it is, i think ill leave it at that.

    Ben McKenzie is the bomb!!

  • My god, calm down. Adam is better, I know, but dont go on these videos and bash them. Aright daughter?

  • American Idol is "dude", Australian Idol is "mate". :P

  • i dont get how ppl dnt think this is gud? its different yeah, but the kid has an awsum and unique voice and he sings it great. he has a great tone.

  • are u kidding me? u cant say who is better? ofc u can... adam is 10000x better than this guy, and he just ruined the song, what i can see is that besides him being not good, the judges arent good either, how can they say he was great? bah...

  • His voice is a little weird to get used to, but once you do it's alright I guess. lol

  • love yooooooooh Ben love your voice!!!!!!!!

  • you guys are so friggen rude....... its australian idol he has to make it different jesus get over yourselves.... i neva liked this song until ben sang it he puts more into it than just bland straight singing. good on him at least he is getting up there and having a go....

  • whats that? your having your period?

  • omw he bloody ruined the song!!!!!

    whats with all that crappy emphasis?

    just go with the song instead of trying to make it ure own way of singing it

    cant listen to this crap anymore

  • Adam vs. Ben = who cares.. everyone has their own opinion of who is better. You can't really say which one is BETTER, you can say which one you like more.

  • fuck you. it's a shit

  • he is cute!

  • this is such an awesome song! it think he did a good job ;)

  • Adam Lambert's version is so much better tbh..

  • yes.

    you can't compare adam with a strange nerd

  • mega lame!

    this ben is such a faggot

    ruined the all song

  • ou ega see nüüd nii mega lame ka ei olnud.. tee järgi- aga nuh kui aus olla siis originaal on ilusam küll..

  • Are you kidding?

    There was so much feeling, and he has such an easy voice, I could listen to him forever.

  • I rkn he did a good job with this song.. i would have never liked this song if i never heard his version..

  • man, this sucks. You can tell me kill me, you can tell me that I have no music feeling, but this doesn´t ring any bells to me. That song was very nice by the way.

  • I didn't like it too, but I can say that is tehnically more or less OK

  • Comment removed

  • They're both emotionally invested in the song, but imo, it seems like different emotions. I thought Adam's version was chilling, very depressing - made you think about everything wrong in the world. And contrary to a prev post, I think this version is oddly hopeful, trying to bring about a change sort of. I think it might be the phrasing and simplicity of the stage setting of au idol

  • This one is definately more uplifting than any other version other than the original. It is the pitches in my opinion that make it more uplifting. On another note: I don't find this too great .-. I like every version better than this one... and the original is still my favorite ;D TEARS FOR FEARS ftw!

  • is it me or he sounds like a girl? O.o

  • not to me, but he acctually looks like one

  • He destroyed one good song...

    He is not signing - he's showing a perfomance, it's looks like a theatre.

    But there is not a music, not a song...

  • yeah.. he has nice voice, but he can't sing song like this... :/

  • i love him ! i really want to dowload this but i cant find it anywhere.. :(

  • It was ok. He sounds out of breath all the time though. Adam has more emotion, enunciation, control, and it was hauntingly beautiful.

  • Better than Adam Lambert's imho. AL's version is too smooth...Ben brings out the darkness in the song.

  • If I do not look @ his expression when he sings, maybe I will buy Ben's version as being more emotional, but his expression just spoilt it.

  • I was so annoyed when he got voted out in 2007. There were others that should have gone before him. His performances were always so moving...HE SHOULDA WON!!!

  • i like adams version and this guys version~

  • This is by far the better version. Easily superior than Adam Lamberts. EASILY.

  • Fail

  • adam is much more better!!!

  • I like both this version and Adam's

  • DomionesTequila: no, i simply disagreed with his comment, obviously this version really sucks, it is forgettable and i didnt believe ben

    adam is far better and more talented, it is so clear =S

  • This just goes to show what a great song this is. As an American woman in her 60's, I was looking for Adam's version when I ran across this. I've listened to a dozen or so versions by now. My preference is for the stripped-down, piano-and-voice-only. Always gives me goose-bumps. This kid is pretty good. I will look for other songs by him.

    Adam just has one of the best voices I've ever heard.

  • is this guy gay ?

    no insult intended

  • Really lovley so is Adam Lambert's, nice to hear two version of this.

  • his songchoices are so... AMAZING xD

  • very beautiful, better than originial

  • He Shuldd Of Onee <//33

  • agree. this shits all over Adam Lamberts version.

  • Cool voice! I like this version better than Adam Lamberts. I reckon Adam heard this version!!

  • I'm sure he did. No one had ever done Mad World on American Idol.

  • Who the hell is Adam????

  • Adam Lambert is the runner up on this year's American Idol. He also sang Mad World on the show, hence the comparison people are making.

    I'm guessing you're not from the US?

  • lol na im australian hence "australian Idol' watching :D

  • well, you could've been like me, searching for Mad world and end up watching this video hehe. So how far along is Australian Idol now? Do they have a winner yet?

  • oh well this is from 2007 and yeah Ben got to like 4th or 5th, not as far as he should have. We havent got Australian idol running this year yet... think it starts in like a month or so.

  • "Who the hell is Adam????"...

    Have you been living in a cave for the past few months?

  • lol no just living in australia....not everthing revolves round america

  • ok. I just know alot of people from around the world that are Adam Lambert fans.

  • actually living in a cave its like watchin tv all the time in ur house lol

  • chimpanc8:

    umm..was that suppose to be funny?

  • glitterbug49.. I am American and still feel that Ben McKenzie captured the emotion of this song better than Adam Lambert. Both were good. But this guy was more passionate.. Just so you know.

  • Ben mckenzie and my sis were best m8s he is soooooo good

  • both ben and adam do really great versions of this beautiful haunting song

  • God, the judge panel in aus AI were so boring..... regarding Ben, he has a pretty cool voice but I found Adam's version more emotional.

  • ben.....was.....amazing......

  • Ben's version is way fucking better than Adam Lambert's.

  • This lad did an amazing job as well. I can tell how much I love this song. Adam Lambert did a smashing job on this, but this lad did his own version to. Thanks lad well done Ben, Well done......

  • I LOVEEEE ADAM LAMBERT.

    But this is pretty decent aswell

  • I love the way he sang "look right through me.." at 1:35. I'm hoping Adam wins A.I. this year, but Ben's performance of this song was also stellar - the perfect song choice for a 17 yo.

  • i love adam lambert but ben did this song waaay better

  • This guy is an excellent singer. A lot of character in his melody line and although Adam from American Idol is another excellent singer and probably this years winner, Ben's version is better.

  • What does being gay have to do with the quality of singing? Fkn Idiot.

    They're both different artists with different interpretations of the song. Deal with it.

  • I like this better than Adam's....sorry.

  • Adam who-is A.I. still on this year with it's no talent and those show robbing producers who steal titles.Try watching Fringe. This kid and Adam prolonged the song almost ausing agony. Bring Back Davey A.

  • That was incoherent "kenefick". Adam Lambert from American Idol has tons of talent, obviously but, what is even more telling, is that you said they prolonged the song. Prolonged it by singing it? Both contestants did a SHORTER version of the song. People on these shows don't get the full song. Adam from AMERICAN Idol is much, much more talented than this kid though.

  • OH HELLLLLL YESSSSSS, ADAM RULES