I'm late to the party but so glad I found this video! Lovely lovely work! I'm not the biggest fan of AUs usually but this was a great idea and very well executed. The editing is wonderful and the entire video is so cleverly done. Extremely creative! I'm looking forward to checking out more of your stuff.
the most clever vid ever ever! thought that it was great and really enjoyed fact that you made it seem as if the doctor was stalking rose cos he loved her! loved it!
Oh my god! I'm like, about to cry. I loved that he locked the door so that she and 9 would meet. And looking in on them all at the restaurant! This is so adorable.
Very clever editing indeed. I particularly loved the moment where Rose and The Doctor were walking on the grass and his other self is following them at a distance. Very convincing. :-) 5/5 stars
Wow, wow, wow, wow, wow! Love it! Fantastic editing, really absolutely brilliant! I've never seen such seamless editing, it works so well and it's all just so great. 100 out of 5, now excuse me while I favourite it and watch it a dozen more times :D
Woops, posted this in the wrong bit! It was supposed to be in response to a comment made by someone who was reminded of this video by a fanfic.
Adored this, by the way. Especially love the scene where rose is running away from the autons, and how seemlessly you've added 10 into the mix. Genius! Favourited :P
Oh I don't know if I can remember the exact one that I was talking about right now, but one along the same lines is Cheating Time by Gillian Taylor and wmr on whofic. I hope that helps. :)
...my system. And I had to do SOMETHING for Jack/Grey. I watched your Torchwood Prelude and really enjoyed it. You use effects (such as repeats and zooms) so originally to the beats of your song. I'll have to run again soon but I will definitely peruse your channel when I get the chance!
Yeah, I watch Doctor Who on the internet. Hehe, and oh that's is so cool. We only gather around the television when X-Files is on. You've got the beginners version, oh. That's not so good :/ But I can help you get SOny vegas 7.0 if you'd like :D Btw, I think I will continue this in a comment on your channel, so I'm not spamming your vids XD
Okay, you might not do fast-paced as we talked about, but manipulation and stalking is deffo your thing. This video was amazing! Loved the mani's you did, with the Doc and Rose. Perfectly imagination you have :D
Hey, thanks! 'Stalking definitely my thing' sounds a bit of a worry though :D I really need a new program - the one I have is really not up to what my imagination wants out of it. I re-ran through my vids and I think the closest I have to fast is "Prelude" but thats cos its got minimal story/SFX. Thanks for checking out my stuff, I'll be looking through yours for sure!
Hahah! The stalking part weren't meant negativetely though, it's just a cool thing to be able to make in a vid. Okay, I'm talking rubbish now. Lol, oh what programme do you have then? Oh, read above it was Sony Vegas, I have got that too? :D Version 7.0, to be exactly. Prelude was amazing! I watched it awhile back, perfect vid for Grey and Jack! And sure. Expect more comments from me soon :)
Yeah I know, just joking :) I will reply in full soon, I've just gotta run cos DW starting! (I'm an Aussie, and we're up the Doctor's Daughter). Be back soon!
Sorry about that! I watch DW with my whole family, its about the only time we all get in one room together so I didn't want to miss it. Yes, I do have Sony Vegas, but only the beginners version so I can't do all that much more then WMM. Most of my SFX are a combo of 7-8 effects to try and achieve the one look. I'm glad you liked Prelude! It was the only vid I knocked together in one afternoon (they normally take me a month or so) because I had to get some of my emotions from the ep out of
This is Brilliant work . Great use of ideas and imagination . Its Beautifull piece , the song , the video compliments it all . Secondly i love the scene 0.54-1.12 its unforgetble .
Thankyou! I don't mind at all - I use Vegas Movie Studio (the cheapest version) so most of my effects are the cumulative effort of five or six SFX cos my version is fairly basic. But it was what I could afford! :D
Hey no probs! It is an awesome program - I've seen vidders with the next step up Vegas do some truly amazing effects. My version is good too, I've just had it for a year and want to expand :) Good luck!
Oh, that was absolutely brilliant! I love the idea of the Doctor seeing Rose when she was younger, post-Doomsday. Loved everything about this vid! Your wonderful editing made me even believe for a second that it was real. :D
Thankyou very much! I thought I had responded to this comment but I came back on youtube and my response wasn't there? Stupid youtube. So I'll say again thanks for letting me know how much you enjoyed it - gives me a big thrill everytime :)
Brilliant. I would never have thought to put all those clips together. Really well put together...man, the Doctor is a major stalker. :) Cheap tricks.
Thankyou! I think any Rose/Doctor shipper would. Since Turn Left I've started wondering how many times she crossed her own timeline too... Glad you enjoyed!
I wasn't particularly in love with it either (I'm more a MCR person) but it was fairly inoffensive and set the scene so well. Great to know you liked the editing though!
Just watched it again! Also had to say I LOVED the bit where she's running to the door and he quickly locks with the sonic, and its like, if he hadn't done that, she would have escaped that way and maybe never met him in the first place, so you've set up this idea that he was the reason for their meeting at that moment anyway! Brilliant!!!!!
Wow, thankyou for your amazing (double!) comment! (Hope you didn't choke on your tongue there :D) I've heard since that there are quite a few fanfics like this out there, so its worth looking around. In the meantime I'm chuffed you found my vid a realistic substitute! *beams* That wsa exactly what I meant by the sonic screwdriver locking the door and its great to know you picked it up :D Your wonderful comment has absolutely made my day, thankyou!
I actually am speechless. Seriously. For the really first time! But I shall make an effort to untie my tongue. Umm...ugh...lol ;)
The bit where he grabbed her hand and they ran, and he was there just round the corner...OMG my heart stopped, because you have such a brilliant brilliant brilliant way of making it look real. I ALWAYS thought this would make an interesting fanfic, but never thought of looking for a vid like this!! OMG!!! xxx FAVED definitely!
Oh that is just sooo good, I really wish i could make vids like that...what type of movie maker do you have???? cos mine is just rubbish hence my videos being rubbish...
But that is brill, I dont think the Doctor would go into his past...I think it would be too painful...but still you made it look as he does do that...:D
I use Vegas Movie Studio (beginners version.) I started off with Windows Movie Maker and my parents got me this one for Christmas. Now I'm saving up for the next upgrade!
Glad you enjoyed it. I don't really think he would either but it was a fun idea to play with.
Really? *listens again* No, his voice is more whiny (in a good way, but that's the only way I could think to describe it.) Their themes are normally darker too. But I don't know - this is the only song I have from this band, I just discovered it on my itunes.
Thankyou, the fact that you include all my videos in that is a wonderful compliment! I'm not often mainstream in my video themes and the fact you find many of them affecting is fantastic. *beams* And thanks for the best wishes, only one exam to go!
This is absolutly amazing and I enjoyed it a lot, it made me laugh every now and then and it's amazing how well the clips are put together. You've blended them -subscribes-
Thankyou! I'm glad someone thought it was quirky, its what I had in mind but everyone seems to find it sad! I was beginning to think I was just odd :D Glad you liked!
Oh my god. I love it. This video just makes me love the doctor and Rose even more! Oh, seriously- your editing is amazing. You put everything together beautifully. five billion stars!
Thanks a lot! I'm glad the editing worked out well. And for the stars! (Gosh, where will I put them all? Lol.) I think we're all holding out for next wks episode. *shakes pitchfork threateningly* Stuff it up RTD and you'll have fangirls coming after your hide!
stunning seamless work, all around. On lj, I uplaoded my first dw fanfic (2012, which about the doctor going to watch him and rose in 'fear her') and they loved the consept of him watching her/them, so would you mind if I advertised your stuff for you on livejournal? Under your name of course, just cause I'm sure a lot of people would love to see this.
Wow, thanks, I'm glad I'm living up to your subscription! Its one of the reasons there are such long gaps between my vids - I can't make one unless I think it something different or I can tell it a different way, and it takes time for inspiration :) Its fantastic to know the storyline was so clear too, 'cos that's a very important indicator of the construction of the vid. Thankyou for your lovely comment! And sure you can advertise it - I'm flattered that you'd want to.
It's stuff like this that assures me why I've subscribed to your work. It still stunns me how easily you can impress me. Man, I want to make screencaps of it and comment underneath every little thing that I liked! ...so i may have to split this comment into to two.
You know, even if you hadn't wrttent what was going on in the video discription, we'd still all understand what was going on, that's how you can tell how good this is!
That was absolutly fantastic! I loved the long manip of the tenth Doctor and Rose in Henricks. It looked so brilliant! You got his facial expressions perfectly for seeing her and I especially liked the way you had him lock the door so she'd then meet the ninth him. That was utter genious! Loved it! Can't speak any more hightly of it! 5* and *faved*
That manip was the basis for the whole vid, I just had to get the idea out of my head :D Thats why Henricks pops up a few times. And you picked him locking the door so she would meet himself! I wondered if that was clear. Thankyou very much for all the lovely compliments! *bounces happily*
That was amazing! I loved your scene manipulations, and (as others have said)they were wonderfully believable. You had a great degree of matching eyelines, so it actually looked right! Just brilliant. :D xx
Thankyou! You can see I've been procrastinating on my exams a bit :D You know I really admire what you do so your comment is wonderful to receive, thankyou.
The editing of this was truly brilliant. I know people like to cut and try to manipulate scenes often, but it rarely works to a believable degree. You, however, did it wonderfully! You were very careful with the scenery of the two clips matching, and I just was blown away by the seemlessness of it all. Beautiful and very heartbreaking idea. Lovely! Bravo, m'dear, bravo.
Thankyou! I'm glad you noticed the scenery, I took a lot of time to sift through clips to find the right ones and I still wasn't sure about them. That you thought it came across seamlessly is a wonderful compliment, so thanks! Your comment has given me a wonderful buzz :D
Thankyou! Yeah that section was the first bit I did- I wanted to show him in Hendricks and the rest of the vid sort of spiralled from there. Great to know you found it believable!
AMAZING. I loved it. Your editing was perfect! I can totally see the Doctor doing that. But it's really sad at the same time! Great job, really great.
...WOW!!! *AMAZING* editing!!! Fantastic choice of song! VERY believable storyline! (Though the zeppelins in Pete's World kinda threw me.) Wonderful work! I could definitely see the Doctor doing this before he summons up the nerve to say good-bye to the Rose he lost. Talk about the dark side of being in love...yet it's also sweet in a stalker-ish way.
Gack! I completely forgot about the zeppelins! *facepalm* Oops. Oh well, couldn't have done anything about them anyway. Didn't think of it being prep for the Doomsday-goodbye either - you should write my summaries!
Absolutely brilliant. I love how you did that, it's a really great idea, and a lot of videos with this plot would have looked fake and obvious but you made it believable, and to someone who hasn't seen the show, they might think this is how it really happened. Well done! (:
Thankyou, realism was what I hoped to achieve and I'm glad you thought I did! Downside is I get my non-dw friend to critique my vids and she didn't get the point :D Glad you enjoyed!
Your welcome. Your vids always merit a comment. ;) I almost missed this one, though. Somehow YT didn't alert me. But someone on my LJ flist recced it. :)
What amazing editing! Can't believe I haven't seen this already!
Bethywethy6 8 months ago
I'm late to the party but so glad I found this video! Lovely lovely work! I'm not the biggest fan of AUs usually but this was a great idea and very well executed. The editing is wonderful and the entire video is so cleverly done. Extremely creative! I'm looking forward to checking out more of your stuff.
hoodatwhatzit 1 year ago
Amazing :) I loved it! There were some scenes that were so in sync with each other, it was hard not o believe that it wasn't a part of the show!
misschevious123 1 year ago
stunning. Just beautiful!
I was almost brought to tears, and it was so well put together! My all-time favourite Doctor Who fan-vid!
RosesAreRed4242 2 years ago
Excellently put together!
brytning 2 years ago
Aww I love it.
His grin when she ran to the Tardis makes me happy!
This was an excellent idea and brilliantly put together!
Leanne2201 2 years ago
Very cute and clever! Kinda sad though. you did a great job matching the clips together. Bril vid!
PurpleMango2010 2 years ago
love this ;D
missaussie911 2 years ago
Brilliant!!!
LouisaGlasson 2 years ago
the most clever vid ever ever! thought that it was great and really enjoyed fact that you made it seem as if the doctor was stalking rose cos he loved her! loved it!
DoctorAndRose4ever 2 years ago 5
Oh my god! I'm like, about to cry. I loved that he locked the door so that she and 9 would meet. And looking in on them all at the restaurant! This is so adorable.
PrincessPotato 2 years ago 2
I love this!
ArabellaElfie 2 years ago
loved it !
brilliant editing =)
MissxDannii 2 years ago
nice
Larixlaricina 2 years ago
such a beautiful idea!wonderful!!
byakabuku 2 years ago
Very clever editing indeed. I particularly loved the moment where Rose and The Doctor were walking on the grass and his other self is following them at a distance. Very convincing. :-) 5/5 stars
EllenRebecca3 3 years ago
Lovely video :-) I particularly like the bit at 0:43 and when Rose goes into the TARDIS at the end and the Tenth Doc watches her. :-)
Thebigbluemeany 3 years ago
I love the bit when it implies that he's the one who triggers their meeting in the first place!
Just lovely, and a really clever idea.
sommersprechen 3 years ago
That was so cute! I love how he's dodging around, making sure she doesn't see him (or he doesn't see himself for that matter.)absolutely adorable :D
bast713 3 years ago
so love this video I so wanted to make one like that but yours is so brillant I could not stand a chance ^^
misscynthia17 3 years ago
That was an awesome video! Great editing.
thedoctorsdonna 3 years ago
Wow, wow, wow, wow, wow! Love it! Fantastic editing, really absolutely brilliant! I've never seen such seamless editing, it works so well and it's all just so great. 100 out of 5, now excuse me while I favourite it and watch it a dozen more times :D
Thanks for such a lovely video.
ChemicalsAndRomance 3 years ago
fricking genius
AshenSoul 3 years ago
Excellent! :)
helenluvsboo 3 years ago
I ABSOULTLY love this vid! when i get it up & running you can enter my comp 4 doctor who!
rahao 3 years ago
I love this. Pure genius. Thank you!
daydreamxx 3 years ago
Wow! Such a brilliant idea, and very well carried out. Absolutely wonderful editing!!
PirateTillTheEnd 3 years ago
I still love this vid. Its so incredably clever! XD I just read a fan fic and it instantly reminded me of this. He he.
THEpowerOFme 3 years ago
Can I ask which fic? I've been looking for one that's based around this sort of theme, but alas...
starbrights90 3 years ago
Woops, posted this in the wrong bit! It was supposed to be in response to a comment made by someone who was reminded of this video by a fanfic.
Adored this, by the way. Especially love the scene where rose is running away from the autons, and how seemlessly you've added 10 into the mix. Genius! Favourited :P
starbrights90 3 years ago
Oh I don't know if I can remember the exact one that I was talking about right now, but one along the same lines is Cheating Time by Gillian Taylor and wmr on whofic. I hope that helps. :)
THEpowerOFme 3 years ago
this is such a clever vid! luvs it!
izblu42 3 years ago
That is such a brilliant video! And such a cute idea that it was in fact the Doctor who caused Rose to meet the Doctor (0:54-1:12)
Favved and 5 stars!
xx
DeathEater100 3 years ago
fantastic!!!! jst fantastic!
girlex 3 years ago
wow that was so good :D 5*
prettykitty007 3 years ago
I always imagined The Doctor would go back to see her again but never make contact.
It's lovely. Great job! :)
Padme0013 3 years ago
Thankyou! I think many of us *hoped* so anyway. Glad you liked!
piffo 3 years ago
...my system. And I had to do SOMETHING for Jack/Grey. I watched your Torchwood Prelude and really enjoyed it. You use effects (such as repeats and zooms) so originally to the beats of your song. I'll have to run again soon but I will definitely peruse your channel when I get the chance!
piffo 3 years ago
Yeah, I watch Doctor Who on the internet. Hehe, and oh that's is so cool. We only gather around the television when X-Files is on. You've got the beginners version, oh. That's not so good :/ But I can help you get SOny vegas 7.0 if you'd like :D Btw, I think I will continue this in a comment on your channel, so I'm not spamming your vids XD
CILLEXD 3 years ago
Okay, you might not do fast-paced as we talked about, but manipulation and stalking is deffo your thing. This video was amazing! Loved the mani's you did, with the Doc and Rose. Perfectly imagination you have :D
Cilleh xx.
CILLEXD 3 years ago
Hey, thanks! 'Stalking definitely my thing' sounds a bit of a worry though :D I really need a new program - the one I have is really not up to what my imagination wants out of it. I re-ran through my vids and I think the closest I have to fast is "Prelude" but thats cos its got minimal story/SFX. Thanks for checking out my stuff, I'll be looking through yours for sure!
piffo 3 years ago
Hahah! The stalking part weren't meant negativetely though, it's just a cool thing to be able to make in a vid. Okay, I'm talking rubbish now. Lol, oh what programme do you have then? Oh, read above it was Sony Vegas, I have got that too? :D Version 7.0, to be exactly. Prelude was amazing! I watched it awhile back, perfect vid for Grey and Jack! And sure. Expect more comments from me soon :)
CILLEXD 3 years ago
Yeah I know, just joking :) I will reply in full soon, I've just gotta run cos DW starting! (I'm an Aussie, and we're up the Doctor's Daughter). Be back soon!
piffo 3 years ago
Oh sure thing. Doctor Who is actually not shown here :/ (I'm not English nor American XD) So have fun :)
CILLEXD 3 years ago
Sorry about that! I watch DW with my whole family, its about the only time we all get in one room together so I didn't want to miss it. Yes, I do have Sony Vegas, but only the beginners version so I can't do all that much more then WMM. Most of my SFX are a combo of 7-8 effects to try and achieve the one look. I'm glad you liked Prelude! It was the only vid I knocked together in one afternoon (they normally take me a month or so) because I had to get some of my emotions from the ep out of
piffo 3 years ago
OMG< i can't rememeber half of this... what seasons and, well, what the frak is going on?
kittenmaia 3 years ago
This is Brilliant work . Great use of ideas and imagination . Its Beautifull piece , the song , the video compliments it all . Secondly i love the scene 0.54-1.12 its unforgetble .
xxelm0xx 3 years ago
Wow, that was fantastic.
What video editing software do you use, if you don't mind me asking?
XenaWillAlwaysRock 3 years ago
Thankyou! I don't mind at all - I use Vegas Movie Studio (the cheapest version) so most of my effects are the cumulative effort of five or six SFX cos my version is fairly basic. But it was what I could afford! :D
piffo 3 years ago
Will have to have a gander at that. Been trying to find something good for ages :)
Loved your video and thanks so much for answering my question. x
XenaWillAlwaysRock 3 years ago
Hey no probs! It is an awesome program - I've seen vidders with the next step up Vegas do some truly amazing effects. My version is good too, I've just had it for a year and want to expand :) Good luck!
piffo 3 years ago
Oh, that was absolutely brilliant! I love the idea of the Doctor seeing Rose when she was younger, post-Doomsday. Loved everything about this vid! Your wonderful editing made me even believe for a second that it was real. :D
PadmeKenobi 3 years ago
Thankyou very much! I thought I had responded to this comment but I came back on youtube and my response wasn't there? Stupid youtube. So I'll say again thanks for letting me know how much you enjoyed it - gives me a big thrill everytime :)
piffo 3 years ago
Oh, oh I loved this SO much! So perfectly done!! Is it available anywhere for download?
munimundos 3 years ago
We all know he breaks his own rules, don't we? I'm chuffed you thought it pulled together well, thanks for the lovely comment!
piffo 3 years ago
I absolutely love that little sequence starting at 00:55. Works so well! :D
lizZzzy87 3 years ago
Thankyou! That sequence was the whole reason for the vid actually, I had that eating out of my brain and made the rest up around it :D
piffo 3 years ago
It's a really really great vid. The Doctor is so cute !!!!
eloeie 3 years ago
Ten is rather glompable isn't he? Lovely to hear you liked!
piffo 3 years ago
This is brilliant! Perfect editing.
LadyGlove2000 3 years ago
Thankyou very much, great to hear :)
piffo 3 years ago
Nice. Cool idea, even better editing. :D
midvacent 3 years ago
Thanks!
piffo 3 years ago
Brilliant. I would never have thought to put all those clips together. Really well put together...man, the Doctor is a major stalker. :) Cheap tricks.
AmaranthineSomnuim 3 years ago 2
Thankyou! The idea was born from too many bus trips staring out the window :D Glad you liked!
piffo 3 years ago
what is the name of the song?
ocfan1111 3 years ago
Left and Leaving.
piffo 3 years ago
Woohoo Brilliant simply brilliant :)
salx77 3 years ago
Thanks :) Great to know you enjoyed!
piffo 3 years ago
Rose is the best!
Mad4DrWho 3 years ago
*smiles* sweet and a little bit funny
EosHeliosSelene 3 years ago
It tis a bit of a silly idea ;) Glad it made you smile.
piffo 3 years ago
Oh my gosh that's so sweet! You use the clips so cleverly, you pick the perfect music and you make them so GOOD! Congrats! :0)
MusicMadSuperAwesome 3 years ago
*beams* Thanks for the lovely comment!
piffo 3 years ago
No problemo. Thanks for the lovely vid! =D
MusicMadSuperAwesome 3 years ago
Yet another fantastic vid from you.
That was just brilliant!
Dawnofthedusk 3 years ago
Thankyou very much!
piffo 3 years ago
oh, wow!! this is so poignant-- i love to think the doctor would have gone back to watch her. great job!
sorcha425 3 years ago
Thankyou! I think any Rose/Doctor shipper would. Since Turn Left I've started wondering how many times she crossed her own timeline too... Glad you enjoyed!
piffo 3 years ago
Absolutely excellent! The editing was very, very well done indeed. You've clearly been conscientious about it :-) 5/5
EllenRebecca3 3 years ago
Thanks! Yeah it did take a lot of trial and error, but I'm happy you thought it worked out well! Thanks for the rating too :)
piffo 3 years ago
beautiful, simply beautiful.
ottermum 3 years ago
Thankyou very much :D
piffo 3 years ago
this is a brilliant vid HOWEVER i didnt like the song :( thats the only thing bad about it
troyella02 3 years ago
I wasn't particularly in love with it either (I'm more a MCR person) but it was fairly inoffensive and set the scene so well. Great to know you liked the editing though!
piffo 3 years ago
Very good! :D
nimppiii 3 years ago
Thankyou!
piffo 3 years ago
I still absolutly love this vid so much! :) I don't know how many times I've watched it and yet it's only been up for 4 days! O.o lol 5* as always.
THEpowerOFme 3 years ago
*beams* From a fellow vidmaker thats the best compliment of all, thankyou. I hope you still like it as much after 5 days! Lol :D
piffo 3 years ago
Just watched it again! Also had to say I LOVED the bit where she's running to the door and he quickly locks with the sonic, and its like, if he hadn't done that, she would have escaped that way and maybe never met him in the first place, so you've set up this idea that he was the reason for their meeting at that moment anyway! Brilliant!!!!!
FairyFlossHunny 3 years ago
Wow, thankyou for your amazing (double!) comment! (Hope you didn't choke on your tongue there :D) I've heard since that there are quite a few fanfics like this out there, so its worth looking around. In the meantime I'm chuffed you found my vid a realistic substitute! *beams* That wsa exactly what I meant by the sonic screwdriver locking the door and its great to know you picked it up :D Your wonderful comment has absolutely made my day, thankyou!
piffo 3 years ago
No problems, its well deserved! :)
FairyFlossHunny 3 years ago
I actually am speechless. Seriously. For the really first time! But I shall make an effort to untie my tongue. Umm...ugh...lol ;)
The bit where he grabbed her hand and they ran, and he was there just round the corner...OMG my heart stopped, because you have such a brilliant brilliant brilliant way of making it look real. I ALWAYS thought this would make an interesting fanfic, but never thought of looking for a vid like this!! OMG!!! xxx FAVED definitely!
FairyFlossHunny 3 years ago
now this is a great vid.. well done.. ur vids are so good
laurabatham 3 years ago
Thankyou, its great to know you like them! Gives me a wonderful warm fuzzy feeling :D
piffo 3 years ago
Wow thats brill, reli fits!! x
gothchick1515 3 years ago
Thanks, glad you liked.
piffo 3 years ago
wow! i luv the way you put the clips together so that it made it look like they were in the same episode! this has realli cheered me up!
XiamLaLaX 3 years ago
Hey, glad its made you happy! Thanks for commenting ;)
piffo 3 years ago
No problem :)
XiamLaLaX 3 years ago
Thankyou!
piffo 3 years ago
Beautiful. Perfect. Gorgeous. Amazing. Did I mention perfect? Love it completley, every minute!
CaptainDjaq 3 years ago
Wow! I am overwhelmed with adjectives :) And a warm happy feeling, so thankyou!
piffo 3 years ago
i love you.
haha i'm over reacting.
but damn your videos are amazing.
goggles226 3 years ago
Thankyou very much. *beams*
piffo 3 years ago
aww... Doc's a stalker. poor guy. (great execution! ^^)
katesmeow 3 years ago
All he needs now are the binoculars and the bush to peer out of :D Great to know you liked!
piffo 3 years ago
Oh that is just sooo good, I really wish i could make vids like that...what type of movie maker do you have???? cos mine is just rubbish hence my videos being rubbish...
But that is brill, I dont think the Doctor would go into his past...I think it would be too painful...but still you made it look as he does do that...:D
DWaDDLJ 3 years ago
I use Vegas Movie Studio (beginners version.) I started off with Windows Movie Maker and my parents got me this one for Christmas. Now I'm saving up for the next upgrade!
Glad you enjoyed it. I don't really think he would either but it was a fun idea to play with.
piffo 3 years ago
This was brilliant. Editing is flawless and the story melted my heart. Favorite and 5 stars. Thank you for warming my heart today. :o)
abstractvmilk 3 years ago
Hey no probs! Lovely to know you liked it that much and it had that much emotional impact. Thanks for commenting!
piffo 3 years ago
Wow amazing editing. You' think it was in the actual episodes. Well done. :D
sirius136 3 years ago
I wish, but no such luck. Glad you liked!
piffo 3 years ago
THAT. IS. BRILLAINT.
No, seriously. Brillant. Like, 5 stars.
CaptainJackForever 3 years ago
Thanks, glad you liked :)
piffo 3 years ago
By the way that sounded a LOT like the lead singer from Placebo...but I saw it was another band..
gracefulangel47 3 years ago
Really? *listens again* No, his voice is more whiny (in a good way, but that's the only way I could think to describe it.) Their themes are normally darker too. But I don't know - this is the only song I have from this band, I just discovered it on my itunes.
piffo 3 years ago
Ahh this was amazing. I luv it how u put the clips together :) it looks like that actually happened :P faved!
XLunaRocksX 3 years ago
Thanks, I'm glad you found it realistic! Glad you enjoyed.
piffo 3 years ago
What a wonderfulfully sad premsie for a video- your videos are always so brilliant and affecting, great work, hope your exams go well:)
gracefulangel47 3 years ago
Thankyou, the fact that you include all my videos in that is a wonderful compliment! I'm not often mainstream in my video themes and the fact you find many of them affecting is fantastic. *beams* And thanks for the best wishes, only one exam to go!
piffo 3 years ago
This is absolutly amazing and I enjoyed it a lot, it made me laugh every now and then and it's amazing how well the clips are put together. You've blended them -subscribes-
An amazing job, absolutly loved it!
tehshinyfox1 3 years ago
Thankyou! I'm glad someone thought it was quirky, its what I had in mind but everyone seems to find it sad! I was beginning to think I was just odd :D Glad you liked!
piffo 3 years ago
Oh my god. I love it. This video just makes me love the doctor and Rose even more! Oh, seriously- your editing is amazing. You put everything together beautifully. five billion stars!
kmgproductionz 3 years ago
Thanks a lot! I'm glad the editing worked out well. And for the stars! (Gosh, where will I put them all? Lol.) I think we're all holding out for next wks episode. *shakes pitchfork threateningly* Stuff it up RTD and you'll have fangirls coming after your hide!
piffo 3 years ago
stunning seamless work, all around. On lj, I uplaoded my first dw fanfic (2012, which about the doctor going to watch him and rose in 'fear her') and they loved the consept of him watching her/them, so would you mind if I advertised your stuff for you on livejournal? Under your name of course, just cause I'm sure a lot of people would love to see this.
Genne 3 years ago
Wow, thanks, I'm glad I'm living up to your subscription! Its one of the reasons there are such long gaps between my vids - I can't make one unless I think it something different or I can tell it a different way, and it takes time for inspiration :) Its fantastic to know the storyline was so clear too, 'cos that's a very important indicator of the construction of the vid. Thankyou for your lovely comment! And sure you can advertise it - I'm flattered that you'd want to.
piffo 3 years ago
It's stuff like this that assures me why I've subscribed to your work. It still stunns me how easily you can impress me. Man, I want to make screencaps of it and comment underneath every little thing that I liked! ...so i may have to split this comment into to two.
You know, even if you hadn't wrttent what was going on in the video discription, we'd still all understand what was going on, that's how you can tell how good this is!
Genne 3 years ago
You know, I always thought that the Doctor would do that!
The way you blended the clips together was just so well done...it seemed very realistic the whole time =)
Great job!
neonXsoda 3 years ago
Thankyou! Its great to know it seemed realistic, that was the aim so I'm glad it succeeded! Glad you enjoyed.
piffo 3 years ago
This is a fantastic AU. If only this occurred in the show...
1SHAZ1 3 years ago
Thankyou very much! Yeah, I wish. Even just a shot of him walking past her estate would have been awesome.
piffo 3 years ago
Brilliant. Gave me chills! Especially loved the crossover between Family of Blood and Tooth and Claw!
Allawnsy 3 years ago
Thanks! Yeah the Doctor and Rose were so wrapped up in each other in that scene I doubt they would have noticed being followed by an elephant :)
piffo 3 years ago
just amazing :) :)
Rhumer 3 years ago
Thankyou very much!
piffo 3 years ago
You did an amazing job editing!
midnightzstorm 3 years ago
Thankyou very much, glad you liked!
piffo 3 years ago
That was absolutly fantastic! I loved the long manip of the tenth Doctor and Rose in Henricks. It looked so brilliant! You got his facial expressions perfectly for seeing her and I especially liked the way you had him lock the door so she'd then meet the ninth him. That was utter genious! Loved it! Can't speak any more hightly of it! 5* and *faved*
THEpowerOFme 3 years ago
That manip was the basis for the whole vid, I just had to get the idea out of my head :D Thats why Henricks pops up a few times. And you picked him locking the door so she would meet himself! I wondered if that was clear. Thankyou very much for all the lovely compliments! *bounces happily*
piffo 3 years ago
That was amazing! I loved your scene manipulations, and (as others have said)they were wonderfully believable. You had a great degree of matching eyelines, so it actually looked right! Just brilliant. :D xx
seduff 3 years ago
Thankyou! You can see I've been procrastinating on my exams a bit :D You know I really admire what you do so your comment is wonderful to receive, thankyou.
piffo 3 years ago
I have put this up on my channel as a video of the week, hope you don't mind. I also hope all your exams are going well. All the best. :) x
seduff 3 years ago
No probs, I'm flattered actually. Thanks for the wishes, only one to go now!
piffo 3 years ago
The editing on this was brilliant!! I teared up just a wee bit! I love it!
smcgrg 3 years ago
Thankyou! *hands tissues* I didn't intend it to be sad, it just seems to have happened!
piffo 3 years ago
The editing of this was truly brilliant. I know people like to cut and try to manipulate scenes often, but it rarely works to a believable degree. You, however, did it wonderfully! You were very careful with the scenery of the two clips matching, and I just was blown away by the seemlessness of it all. Beautiful and very heartbreaking idea. Lovely! Bravo, m'dear, bravo.
nolaespoir 3 years ago
Thankyou! I'm glad you noticed the scenery, I took a lot of time to sift through clips to find the right ones and I still wasn't sure about them. That you thought it came across seamlessly is a wonderful compliment, so thanks! Your comment has given me a wonderful buzz :D
piffo 3 years ago
Loved it
PiliHalliwell 3 years ago
Great to know, thankyou!
piffo 3 years ago
-mouth hangs open- WOW, that editing was fantastic. 5* and fave.
HootyMcBoon 3 years ago
*fly zooms in* Thankyou very much!
piffo 3 years ago
AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!
pinktails6 3 years ago
Thankyou!
piffo 3 years ago
Very clever. The editing was amazing, it was totally believable. I especially liked :54-1:12
annamaureen 3 years ago
Thankyou! Yeah that section was the first bit I did- I wanted to show him in Hendricks and the rest of the vid sort of spiralled from there. Great to know you found it believable!
piffo 3 years ago
Brilliant. I love the idea and the editing is great.
lastglitter 3 years ago
Thanks, glad you liked!
piffo 3 years ago
wow, once again your editing skills have left me speechless! Great job!
maxthestargirl 3 years ago
Thanks, especially for the 'once again!' *beams*
piffo 3 years ago
AMAZING. I loved it. Your editing was perfect! I can totally see the Doctor doing that. But it's really sad at the same time! Great job, really great.
alittlemoresonic 3 years ago
Thankyou very much! He does tend to break rules a bit doesn't he? Can't wait for next wks ep!
piffo 3 years ago
WOW
totallyDT 3 years ago
Thanks!
piffo 3 years ago
...WOW!!! *AMAZING* editing!!! Fantastic choice of song! VERY believable storyline! (Though the zeppelins in Pete's World kinda threw me.) Wonderful work! I could definitely see the Doctor doing this before he summons up the nerve to say good-bye to the Rose he lost. Talk about the dark side of being in love...yet it's also sweet in a stalker-ish way.
ghidorah15 3 years ago
Gack! I completely forgot about the zeppelins! *facepalm* Oops. Oh well, couldn't have done anything about them anyway. Didn't think of it being prep for the Doomsday-goodbye either - you should write my summaries!
piffo 3 years ago
That was absolutely incredible, well done!!
hippiebanana13 3 years ago
Thankyou very much!
piffo 3 years ago
Absolutely brilliant. I love how you did that, it's a really great idea, and a lot of videos with this plot would have looked fake and obvious but you made it believable, and to someone who hasn't seen the show, they might think this is how it really happened. Well done! (:
jessnimrod25 3 years ago
Thankyou, realism was what I hoped to achieve and I'm glad you thought I did! Downside is I get my non-dw friend to critique my vids and she didn't get the point :D Glad you enjoyed!
piffo 3 years ago
Wowza ... just, wow.
pencilsharpners 3 years ago
Thanks! (I love your youtube name btw)
piffo 3 years ago
Superb editing as always! Absolutely wonderful vid!
allchanges 3 years ago
Thankyou, and thanks for commenting as always! Its lovely how you always give me feedback :)
piffo 3 years ago
Your welcome. Your vids always merit a comment. ;) I almost missed this one, though. Somehow YT didn't alert me. But someone on my LJ flist recced it. :)
allchanges 3 years ago