American Idol 7 - Top 6 Performance - "All I Ask Of You"

[izzyesquire]

it shoulda been a kristy leek cook and brooke white finale and brooke coming out on top

[izzyesquire]

go brooke!

[MsBrezee]

the guys were so great,but the girls...really bad =(

[lululuvu]

yucks if i was andrew lloyd webber i would have flipped...really bad rendition of a lovely song...

[TheTony2013Rocks]

I pronouce this song butchered.

[Tokyomewmew626]

The guys were so good...but the girls...

[CookieLove1983]

One of my fave groups songs! Love it!

[UpdownCourt09]

Why did they ruin Andrew Lloyd Webbber songs like this?

OMG this is terrible... so boring, emotionless and like a nursery rhyme...

and don't get me started on the poor singing.

[ANewMe16]

Ew. the girls don't blend well at all, they sound kind of disgusting.

[PessimisticOptimist2]

well...

it was better than seasons of love...

[gjBFF]

the girls don't sound christine-ish, but the guys sound pretty nice.

[LISxoMHM]

woah omg this is so low. what happened here?!?

[meganjoyfan23]

i love you carly jason and brooke sucked carly all the way!

[indiannacroker]

i love it!

[KaylaS999]

Damn that was awful! They totally ruined the song!

[macybutgey]

em.. i loved this song, but not after they sing it...

[scarednconfused]

high pitched!?! They've transposed it *down* several keys!

[lavender40]

I only like the guys part of the song.

the girls made it so high pitched.

[popelbopel]

hehe funny i like the girls part more cause its so high pitched

[maitezy]

very nice