No to war always? Non violent direct action as a strategy for defeating the Nazis wasnt a big sucess. Sophie Scholl's action against the Nazis was brave and shows her personally to be a giant. But it was Montgomery and Patton that bought peace for my mother and numerous other little girls.
People need REAL help - not just inspiring ideas, no matter how beautiful.
I can't stand these whiney girly covers of what is a beautiful, raw song, it's not about X Factor warbling it's about visceral 80s weltschmerz, Morrissey and he alone does justice to this wonderful masterpiece of a song,. Tinderbox, fuck off.
@kimmois1 I often don't like covers of songs, especially when the original was done by The Smiths but I do like this one, I think the video and the music work well together. You're entitled to your opinion but sometimes I think that people need to try and be a little more open minded about covers or remakes, myself included, and certainly telling them to fuck off is not going to make your opinion seem any more valid than anyone elses - quite the opposite in fact.
@kimmois1 Also I take it you've taken the time to go and deride everyone else's cover that's present on youtube including various male singers. Personally I'd say this is a major improvement on the cover done by Muse for example...and I often like stuff by Muse...
@mentally42 Actually, the Muse one is better as at least they're trying to do something radically different with the song, regardless of whether or not it "works" it's not a cheap whiney derivative copy by some stupid bitch on her period.
@kimmois1 and now you've said what I was sure you wanted to type originally by calling her a "whiney bitch". For what it's worth I agree that Morrissey's vocal can't be beat on any of his songs and I'd probably be more vociferous than you should someone like Mariah Carey or, god forbid, Little Mix decide to try and cover this song.
the video is rubbish no armed forces would attack a small child in what looks like a desert, what goals could that achieve...surely they would be attacking military and/or industrial targets. We wouldn't have beaten the Germans if we had focused all our bombers and tanls on taking out some small child running around in the bavarian hills!!!!!
@kerslarn libya, afghanistan, palestine, iraq etc. Our armed forces bombed schools in three of those conflicts, mostly by accident, but we still did. In Palestine the Israelis went out of their way to bomb schools.
Also England and America bombed the shit out of residential areas in germany in the second world war, America nuked two towns of no military importance.
@texasyankee44 So Dresden and Baroque were building bombs? No they weren't, and Dresden was the city we bombed in WW2 the most severely. In Britain Bath and Norwich were bombed a lot, Bath wasn;t making bombs and most of the bombing in Norwich was over residential areas miles from where they wee building aircraft parts. Your counter must be the stupidest I've ever seen.
what the fuck?!?!?! what a fucking stupid ending, it was ll nice and lovely and then she randomly fucks over some tanks using her mind?!?!?!?! who ever made this was on crack....good version of the song though, cant beat the smiths but then again no one can
Simplicity blowing down the walls of evil.Of course,these aren't your walls,nor your evils,,there the one's your used to brushing,hearing about them everyday,but believe me,your heart feels for these ways....And it's a shame that such a cruelly simple clip and song have to remind you what reality is,when you're faced with it like it's another matter of minutes....
I've NEVER, and mark my words, never, cried just because a song made me. Yes, I've sometimes cried listening to a song but it was because I was already sad or upset in the first place. Here, tonight I'm cool, I'm calm, I'm happy. But I had to cry anyway. This is deeply touching.
im crying so bad right now. oh this song is so beautiful.. This video has such a powerful meaning.. god i am so thankful i have never had to go through war.. i am only sorry for the ppl in my past that have.. I miss you Cannon..Julie, Dane, & Mahayla..I love you, & I'm sorry i couldn't save you. Wait for me in heaven. Ill be there for you once again, I promise. I know that if you had a chance to come back & live in this world, you wouldn't. I miss you.. i miss you..
here's tae the new year xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
@hammer2010 It doesn't always have to be Morrissey, you know. People will be singing his songs years after he is dead and buried. This was a wonderful version of a heartbreaking song, and the video only served to make it even more touching.
Oh my goodness, reminds me of a story my friends parents would tell us of a little vietnamese girl he met during the war she looked like the character in my head
Sometimes, I feel like that. I wish I could wave my hand and wipe armies off the face of the planet and snap my fingers and grow trees. I guess about the next best thing would be to turn every automobile into an exercise mobile with built-in air cleaner. By the way, I love her long black hair, reminds me of the dark matter / dark energy metaphors of ancient storytellers.
Comment removed
mellowscaroline 6 days ago
Beautiful and so sad.
TheRarrio 3 weeks ago
Beautiful
BAswingsteps 3 weeks ago
No to war always? Non violent direct action as a strategy for defeating the Nazis wasnt a big sucess. Sophie Scholl's action against the Nazis was brave and shows her personally to be a giant. But it was Montgomery and Patton that bought peace for my mother and numerous other little girls.
People need REAL help - not just inspiring ideas, no matter how beautiful.
BAswingsteps 3 weeks ago
Woman singing makes no sense to me.
SEADiablo 1 month ago
@SEADiablo
hahahahahahaha
2davivadiva 4 weeks ago
saw tinderbox at larmer tree, really good :)
itsrekka 1 month ago
Its The Smiths song so lets leave it there Mozza rules!!!!!
lilaclainey 1 month ago
I like the Smiths original - and I like this cover equally, but differently. And I really really like the animation. It's beautiful.Thankyou
metaludicsm1le 1 month ago
I can't stand these whiney girly covers of what is a beautiful, raw song, it's not about X Factor warbling it's about visceral 80s weltschmerz, Morrissey and he alone does justice to this wonderful masterpiece of a song,. Tinderbox, fuck off.
kimmois1 1 month ago
@kimmois1 I often don't like covers of songs, especially when the original was done by The Smiths but I do like this one, I think the video and the music work well together. You're entitled to your opinion but sometimes I think that people need to try and be a little more open minded about covers or remakes, myself included, and certainly telling them to fuck off is not going to make your opinion seem any more valid than anyone elses - quite the opposite in fact.
mentally42 1 month ago
@kimmois1 Also I take it you've taken the time to go and deride everyone else's cover that's present on youtube including various male singers. Personally I'd say this is a major improvement on the cover done by Muse for example...and I often like stuff by Muse...
mentally42 1 month ago
@mentally42 Actually, the Muse one is better as at least they're trying to do something radically different with the song, regardless of whether or not it "works" it's not a cheap whiney derivative copy by some stupid bitch on her period.
kimmois1 1 month ago
@kimmois1 and now you've said what I was sure you wanted to type originally by calling her a "whiney bitch". For what it's worth I agree that Morrissey's vocal can't be beat on any of his songs and I'd probably be more vociferous than you should someone like Mariah Carey or, god forbid, Little Mix decide to try and cover this song.
mentally42 1 month ago
The birth of alma wade!!!!
roguetrooper96 1 month ago
Best cover of this song.
marsvolta1001 1 month ago
Imcredible.
cucumberfarmgirls 1 month ago
loved it really loved it keep it up.
ALLIGEE1 2 months ago
i love the Smiths and this is an amazing cover! <3
DjLongBoss 2 months ago
:']brought a tear to my eye x
jedilovespotter 2 months ago
Amazing and made me cry thank you for making this
sallywags1 2 months ago
wtf this video is amazing wow if you dislkie this you clearly have no taste at all
kingstevokingstevo 2 months ago
the video is rubbish no armed forces would attack a small child in what looks like a desert, what goals could that achieve...surely they would be attacking military and/or industrial targets. We wouldn't have beaten the Germans if we had focused all our bombers and tanls on taking out some small child running around in the bavarian hills!!!!!
kerslarn 2 months ago
@kerslarn libya, afghanistan, palestine, iraq etc. Our armed forces bombed schools in three of those conflicts, mostly by accident, but we still did. In Palestine the Israelis went out of their way to bomb schools.
Also England and America bombed the shit out of residential areas in germany in the second world war, America nuked two towns of no military importance.
TheDocGoblin 1 month ago
@TheDocGoblin that's because that's were they build there there bombs
texasyankee44 1 month ago
@texasyankee44 So Dresden and Baroque were building bombs? No they weren't, and Dresden was the city we bombed in WW2 the most severely. In Britain Bath and Norwich were bombed a lot, Bath wasn;t making bombs and most of the bombing in Norwich was over residential areas miles from where they wee building aircraft parts. Your counter must be the stupidest I've ever seen.
TheDocGoblin 1 month ago
@kerslarn its metaphorical you silly beagle :)
emmyisadinosaur 1 month ago
what the fuck?!?!?! what a fucking stupid ending, it was ll nice and lovely and then she randomly fucks over some tanks using her mind?!?!?!?! who ever made this was on crack....good version of the song though, cant beat the smiths but then again no one can
ThisCharmingman16 3 months ago
omg this is so beautiful <3
angelakia 3 months ago
Where did the animation come from?
I would like to see more.
ascii7085 5 months ago
Simplicity blowing down the walls of evil.Of course,these aren't your walls,nor your evils,,there the one's your used to brushing,hearing about them everyday,but believe me,your heart feels for these ways....And it's a shame that such a cruelly simple clip and song have to remind you what reality is,when you're faced with it like it's another matter of minutes....
Velvetspoonful 6 months ago
This is brilliantly fantastic!
itremble 7 months ago
I NEED to download this
MsBrightside182 8 months ago
Great cover, great video thanks for posting well done
XMANGOB 11 months ago
LOVE THIS! You've reignited my love for The Smiths.
SayAllHearNone 1 year ago
Please, please, please bombing all around now!
Preferably with nuclear...
ivornovello985 1 year ago
this is beautiful.
thesingerofsongs 1 year ago
:-(( say NO to war, always, and remember "when the rich wage war it's the poor who die."
franzfaramir 1 year ago 7
Vibrato....
chohakkai87 1 year ago
please please please no more war...
taytrong 1 year ago 3
hermoso..y triste..tanks
skoty9999n 1 year ago
only morrisey can sing this and make it sound honest everyone else is cloying to me
truemansparks 1 year ago
without tears there is no emotions ...powerfull song !
urbanadis 1 year ago
Čarobno
urbanadis 1 year ago
its alma from fear! :P seriously an amazing cover!
shakunkadunk 1 year ago
Stunning video, i also cried.
CorropoliUnited 1 year ago
I've NEVER, and mark my words, never, cried just because a song made me. Yes, I've sometimes cried listening to a song but it was because I was already sad or upset in the first place. Here, tonight I'm cool, I'm calm, I'm happy. But I had to cry anyway. This is deeply touching.
TheSuperSpongy 1 year ago
omg this is beautiful thank u
VanVanVanni 1 year ago
I fell like I need to pay the person who made this beautiful piece of art. That was moving to say the least.
bssalazar 1 year ago
Im a dude too - and i love the way they make her run at the start o the vid by droppin bombs after her - its class!!!
eoinroe47 1 year ago
Wow that made me cry.... This video is so sad.
MissOmochikaeri 1 year ago
im crying so bad right now. oh this song is so beautiful.. This video has such a powerful meaning.. god i am so thankful i have never had to go through war.. i am only sorry for the ppl in my past that have.. I miss you Cannon..Julie, Dane, & Mahayla..I love you, & I'm sorry i couldn't save you. Wait for me in heaven. Ill be there for you once again, I promise. I know that if you had a chance to come back & live in this world, you wouldn't. I miss you.. i miss you..
~ Sarah.. (strawberiluv95)
StrawBeriLuv95 1 year ago
Bacana!!!
vivacce65 1 year ago
itzz a heart touchin song......by Smith. Tinderbox...covered it very well,
nd he video iz awsome......... :)
TheStolenpunK 1 year ago
amazing!
borikuafx3000 1 year ago
Great great cover.
davinm1 1 year ago
But this is addiciting to listen to
connorpolo 1 year ago 4
No one can beat the smith(orginal)
connorpolo 1 year ago 2
im a dude and i love this song
pyromaniak4lfe 2 years ago
I cant stop listening to this, love the vid too who is the artist????
az9359 2 years ago 3
Lovely animation. Who's the artist?
nathaara 2 years ago 3
Wonderfully wonderful
rothsaygardens 2 years ago
very good. great even.
zanahoy 2 years ago
here's tae the new year xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
pdpmdocherty 2 years ago
beautifuly sung
pdpmdocherty 2 years ago
deserves more views
jxlnfm 2 years ago
At first i was like :-(
But then...
I lold
MiharuNV750 2 years ago
oh please please please dont make me cry..
dieinlima 2 years ago
Impressive vid...
I cried too !!
XXXMicky91XXX 2 years ago
Beautiful...
CurryKey 2 years ago
I cried..
TheRosaelefant 2 years ago
Good, powerful video. But it's probably the most depressing video I've ever watched. It brought tears to my eyes :(
VeryUniqueX 2 years ago 39
amazing video, great voice. good cover
visigod 2 years ago
amazing.
janesmithdotMD 2 years ago
I love this song and this is the best version that I have listened.also the video is much beautiful one.
SKDProduction 2 years ago
è proprio una bella cover....complimenti!
beavisanimation 2 years ago
simply beautiful
setanta78 2 years ago
I cried. Thank you for this video.
tkmelowebo2 2 years ago
she got powers all of the sudden?
this is a good cover.
probably not the best but its good none the less.
greenguy111 2 years ago
Rad. <3
RadBrad13 2 years ago
Coupled with the moving video, this cover manages to surpass the Smiths in its emotional depth.
I love it!
SirMozz 2 years ago 2
Completely agree,
heartbreakingly beautiful.
A gentle giant of a cover.
butterfly8collector 2 years ago 4
Beautiful.
yalroug 2 years ago 20
il testo di questa canzone e formidabile...geniale anche l interpretazione
29ludus 2 years ago 3
Incredibile... e senza nulla togliere agli Smiths, questa versione commuove irrimediabilmente!
lizardale 2 years ago
amazing song
mudvayneyo1994 2 years ago
gah! i though the smiths version gave me a lump in my throat! christ!
jimmo1392 2 years ago
Where can I get the mp3 for this?
Sarahfreckle 2 years ago
its not morrissey, but its good. :p
hammer2010 2 years ago
@hammer2010 It doesn't always have to be Morrissey, you know. People will be singing his songs years after he is dead and buried. This was a wonderful version of a heartbreaking song, and the video only served to make it even more touching.
m0zc0re 1 year ago
Oh my goodness, reminds me of a story my friends parents would tell us of a little vietnamese girl he met during the war she looked like the character in my head
StunnerRunner79 2 years ago
Omg. Goosebumps. Tears. I love this one. Thanks
xKiSSE 2 years ago
beautiful work
congratulations
a warm greeting
Raul ...
conejolua 2 years ago
thanks to starlight for this share! I love it! 5 therapeutic stars!!! :-)!!!
Therapist1972 2 years ago
This is beautiful and feel a lump in my throat, so moving, thanks : ) 5***** x
starlighteds1 2 years ago
Sometimes, I feel like that. I wish I could wave my hand and wipe armies off the face of the planet and snap my fingers and grow trees. I guess about the next best thing would be to turn every automobile into an exercise mobile with built-in air cleaner. By the way, I love her long black hair, reminds me of the dark matter / dark energy metaphors of ancient storytellers.
CloudyChambers 2 years ago
Thanks dear Friend for this lovely, lovely sharing!
Excellent movie cartoon, beautiful music..Is superb and most sensitive..i love it..
Thank you much for posting Tinderboxacoustic.
satothequeen 2 years ago
we do love this video very very much
Thank you
xxxxx
CDmagz 2 years ago
So emotional & quite simply beautiful:)
SparkyGerbil 2 years ago
Wonderful :)
CliveWinslet 2 years ago
beautiful, simply beautiful
fakeplasticstar 2 years ago
Awesome Cover. =D
21death12 2 years ago
Lovely.
loveyoutodeathbut 2 years ago
Simply beautiful. The best cover I've heard of this incredible song... Does anyone know who sings?
anitagua 2 years ago
Google for Tinderboxacoustic.
Charmidas 2 years ago
who is this itis beautiful
gabbalabbawoop 2 years ago
That was lawhlha.
williap3 2 years ago
great cover, who did the video?
Xan x
ShowcaseUK 3 years ago
That was truly wonderful and beautiful. :]
Loved it.
Aidanadia 3 years ago 3