@Ariand54321 I hope I explained the "weapon" and "appendage" more clearly in the other comment. Mr.GameandPichu had also said in his video that they will "act as one". Instead of control two identical character. Luigi as a weapon is just used to describe what kind of team attacks will be done as in who is the leader. Still it will be a bit comical. Like in M&L when luigi hits the hammer over Mario to make him gush out water....cont'd
@smashkote Luigi as an appendage is used to describe the mechanics of the gameplay as in who the player controls. To swap to play as Baby Luigi would have to require a change in the A-set.
@Gnorcteen1 Toad and Vaati I understand, in fact I have done that. but why Deoxys. He reps the 3rd gen which is the only generation not to get one yet (not counting gen 5 who will probably get Zoroark replacing Lucario). More important with Mario having 5 and Zelda Having 5, Pokemon should get 5. I mean Pokemon has plenty of good choices and is more popular then Zelda. So should atleast be tied with Zelda.
@MrGameandPichu You say it should at least be tied with Zelda but in this roster, Zelda has 6 and Pokemon 5. But anyways..... although it is the best way, there are more ways too give a franchise spotlight other than characters. What Gnorcteen was getting at is that you don't need a bunch of series with many characters.So he took the three with the most and knocked it down one each. Personally, i don't think having one less isn't is an issue.
@smashkote Ok. My ideas have changed since I made this roster. I understand there are other ways but leaving out Deoxys? Thats just unfair to 3rd Gen. Btw did you read the other comment I posted? This is an old roster. I still wanted you to look at this but I have a new one that is not posted. I would like to do a response to this with the new one. Both to show my new one and to give my counterarguments. I just wanted to make sure you're ok with it so it doesnt get out of hand.
@smashkote Ok. My ideas have changed since I made this roster. I understand there are other ways but leaving out Deoxys? Thats just unfair to 3rd Gen. Btw did you read the other comment I posted? This is an old roster. I still wanted you to look at this but I have a new one that is not posted. I would like to do a response to this with the new one. Both to show my new one and to give my counterarguments. I just wanted to make sure you're ok with it so it doesnt get out of hand.
Alright cool. Thanks for doing this. I actually have updated my roster awhile ago but I haven't posted it and I did want you do critique this one. But if you dont mind Id like to make a response to this addressing some of your points with the updates I have made. I think you make a lot of good arguments about this.
What is with you and using Baby Luigi as a Weapon?
Ariand54321 5 months ago
@Ariand54321 I hope I explained the "weapon" and "appendage" more clearly in the other comment. Mr.GameandPichu had also said in his video that they will "act as one". Instead of control two identical character. Luigi as a weapon is just used to describe what kind of team attacks will be done as in who is the leader. Still it will be a bit comical. Like in M&L when luigi hits the hammer over Mario to make him gush out water....cont'd
smashkote 5 months ago
@smashkote Luigi as an appendage is used to describe the mechanics of the gameplay as in who the player controls. To swap to play as Baby Luigi would have to require a change in the A-set.
smashkote 5 months ago
leave out the following characters: Toad, Deoxys, and Vaati
Gnorcteen1 5 months ago
@Gnorcteen1 That's is an excellent edit to start with.
smashkote 5 months ago
@Gnorcteen1 Toad and Vaati I understand, in fact I have done that. but why Deoxys. He reps the 3rd gen which is the only generation not to get one yet (not counting gen 5 who will probably get Zoroark replacing Lucario). More important with Mario having 5 and Zelda Having 5, Pokemon should get 5. I mean Pokemon has plenty of good choices and is more popular then Zelda. So should atleast be tied with Zelda.
MrGameandPichu 5 months ago
@MrGameandPichu You say it should at least be tied with Zelda but in this roster, Zelda has 6 and Pokemon 5. But anyways..... although it is the best way, there are more ways too give a franchise spotlight other than characters. What Gnorcteen was getting at is that you don't need a bunch of series with many characters.So he took the three with the most and knocked it down one each. Personally, i don't think having one less isn't is an issue.
smashkote 5 months ago
@smashkote Ok. My ideas have changed since I made this roster. I understand there are other ways but leaving out Deoxys? Thats just unfair to 3rd Gen. Btw did you read the other comment I posted? This is an old roster. I still wanted you to look at this but I have a new one that is not posted. I would like to do a response to this with the new one. Both to show my new one and to give my counterarguments. I just wanted to make sure you're ok with it so it doesnt get out of hand.
MrGameandPichu 5 months ago
@MrGameandPichu i hope your roster also has 4th gen then, haha. and no problem please go ahead and do the response.
smashkote 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@smashkote Ok. My ideas have changed since I made this roster. I understand there are other ways but leaving out Deoxys? Thats just unfair to 3rd Gen. Btw did you read the other comment I posted? This is an old roster. I still wanted you to look at this but I have a new one that is not posted. I would like to do a response to this with the new one. Both to show my new one and to give my counterarguments. I just wanted to make sure you're ok with it so it doesnt get out of hand.
MrGameandPichu 5 months ago
Alright cool. Thanks for doing this. I actually have updated my roster awhile ago but I haven't posted it and I did want you do critique this one. But if you dont mind Id like to make a response to this addressing some of your points with the updates I have made. I think you make a lot of good arguments about this.
MrGameandPichu 5 months ago