Added: 3 years ago
From: JSullivanFan2009
Views: 247,988
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (406)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • her is toooo monotonal.

  • @BunnyRabbitYNVMe oh shoot i just realized that i put beyonce's name instead of jazzmine. I meant jazzmine has natural soul. Silly mistake anyway we can all agree to disagree. Opinions VS. facts!!!

  • I wish people stop comparing Jasmine and Beyonce both of them song this song to the best of their ability like Victoria Beckam's did it to the best of hers n there will be someone else who would do it to the best of theirs..leave it at that.

  • @Lordfinese19 ur right...i didnt know at first that it was V.B.'s song originally (my bad on that one) but yes they both did the song to the best of THEIR own ability and they both did well, i was just saying that i liked the way Jazzy did it vs. the way B did it...dnt get me wrong at all i love B's voice n the way she sings HER song (n etta james' songs) i just dont think that THIS particular song was for her...i wasnt bashing or anything of that nature just stating my opinion

  • It's more believable beyonce she has natural soul.Beyonce has manufactured soul.

  • @reneeLuvmj1 Beyonce verison is better and it does have soul..however u can't compare the two because they r 2 completely different version of singing..

  • @reneeLuvmj1 no ma'am...although B may have more SOUL Jazz has more EMOTION...in fact ALL of Jazz's songs manifest a lot of FEELING N EMOTION, like u can feel her pain in it...B has songs that do that too, but this one wasnt one of them...ijs

  • Comment removed

  • i have loved this version since like 05 more like Victoria Beckham – Resentment you can feel her pain in the song it was not recorded right by beyonce lacked the emotional feelling bey just sounded happy to me

  • @MrCubanito221 EXACTLY!!!!!!!!

  • LOVE this and Beyonces!!

  • Beyonce sings it better cuzz u can tell she's in to the song more.... jazmine stayed on one note during the whole song...!!!

  • yess @euachodigno1 her rasp is everything!!!!!!!!!!

  • OK...I must say....I am an AVID Curtis Mayfield fan, may he R.I.P. So, because I am an avid Curtis Mayfield fan, I was somewhat OFFENDED that ANY artist (Victoria Beckam, Beyonce, or Jazmine Sullivan) would put LYRICS to a classic instrumental like "Think" by Curtis Mayfield on the Superfly album back in the day, which is one of my favorite cuts of all time. Anyway, having listened to all three artist do this song with lyrics.....I must say that I am more partial to Jazmine Sullivan's style.

  • that is not jasmine it dony even sound like her

  • @htiffanytropical (no beef) just a heads up: she sings at the end, "I know you're probably thinking, what's up with Jazzy?"

  • and it has nothing to do her being younger cause Jazz is younger than Beyonce so it has nothing to do with what music they grew up around.

  • lol

    

  • but i still like B's better

  • Okay I would appreciate it if no one jump on me for saying this cause its my opinion. I love Jazmine Sullivan just as much as Beyonce and any other artist out there. I think they both did a wonderful job singing this song i really do. But the main thing is that each singer probably had there own experience and each one was different. They expressed it there own natural way. Like I said before both artist did they thang and thats all there is to it

  • @modupe22 perfectly said...thank you for that people to worried about who song what better and it's not even about that..both voices are unique in their own way..

  • Lol Your To Mad Huh???? Ahhhhh Its Alright....Its Something Called An Opinion And Thats Mine P E R I O D Lmdao Its funny how yall be getting so ANGRY Over a artist who Aint Doing Nada For You Poor Tink tink lmfao...

  • I love this version...i would love to hear Tweet sing it. The beginning reminded me of her.

  • Comment removed

  • @icesbrowngroupie no she didn't . it isn't even beyonce 's song. it's atually victoria beckhems song .

  • @heytheresjanae

    it aint her song, she just sang it first.

  • @cushe83 Victoria Beckham wrote the song first & she sung the song first as well .

    So it is her song .

  • @heytheresjanae

    she di nto write the damn song, curtis mayfeild, and three other people wrote the song, so what the hell are you talkign abotu, she just BOUGHT the song first. Nobody even knew she sang the damn song, why the hell do you think the people who owned the publishign tot he song sold it to beyonce if it was infact victorias song .....

  • @heytheresjanae the song was actually written by a songwriting team called "the clutch"(walter millsap and candace nelson) and originally recorded by jazmine sullivan.

  • @supersoloman81 Nope, it was originally recorded by Victoria Beckham. Look at the Wiki for the song

  • @foxesamu YOU'RE RIGHT......THIS IS ORIGINALLY VICTORIA BECKAM'S SONG....VERY FEW PEOPLE KNOW THAT!

  • @heytheresjanae YUP.....THIS IS VICTORIA BECKAM'S SONG!

  • @icesbrowngroupie - ...Lmfao you know shit about the music world u dummy...

  • @icesbrowngroupie um excuse me, actually beyonce was the one that stole the song, just like she stole "if i were a boy", so fall back plz...btw, b did her thing on her version, but jazzy sings it better :)

  • @BunnyRabbitYNVMe Stop lying she didn't steal the song she wanted to re recorded just like jasmine wasnted to re record it because they like the song. N she didn't steal if I was a boy..stop with all this negativity talk more positive ..u have to talented sisters doing their thing and both sound good on this song. both have different styles of singing leave it at that..

  • This was originally recorded by Victoria Beckham. Hers isn't the best vocally, but the emotion is beautiful. Still love this version, as well as Beyonce's.

  • she is such a beast... so underrated though:-(

  • I love this

  • Her voice needs to go to the ER cuz it is siiiiiick!!! Damn, I love this girl.

  • actually jazmine sullivan wrote and recorded this song and beyonce bought it

  • I wish this version what longer lol! I just keep repeating it. Her voice is flawless and soulful!!

  • You go Jazzy...Love it!!!!

  • Great cover. I love both of Jazmine Sullivan and Beyonce!!! The raspiness and rich timbre of Jazmine Sullivan's lower register is gorgeous.

  • I'll stick to Bey's version. This version is good though.

  • I love Beyonce's version.......but this one is better to me. More soul....B had the emotion, yes. But Jaz just took you there.....my opinion!

  • this was a bit plain beyonce did betta...

  • i love the har$onies in this song ! but i don't think she showed as much emotion as Beyonce .

  • Jazzy kiiiilled! It was better than Beyone's version AND Posh's!

  • beyonce's is better

  • I love how 90% of her songs has that 90's beat to it..

  • Beter

  • i agree beyonce version had more feeling of sorrow n the pain .... this is nice but b version is better

  • This is hott...way more soulful!!!

  • They both sing it great but beyonce has more feeling

  • Jazmine wrote the song , but she did right giving it to Beyonce. Beyonce song it with more emotion , ecspecially when Beyonce sung this live . Jazmine is an amazing song writer thoe .

  • @1MissBreezyBaby Victoria Beckham wrote the song, Jazmine covered her.

  • I like this version better because it sounds more churchy and Jazmine is not a game vocally at all!

  • I agree with @karmaisab, I don't hear all the emotion in this everyone is talking about. It is really good, don't get me wrong, I just hear so much heartbreak in Beyonce's version, this just sounds like a plain-as-day cover. You've got your bread with this one, but Beyonce slapped the damn meat on that sandwich and chewed the fuck out of it.

  • @freeBITCH you know you are wrong. saying she just gave us bread with no meat. she killed this song. im not sayin beyonce aint do a good job but jasmine did a much betta job in showin her emotion...without soundin like she cryin at the end,.,,

  • @HeLubzMe24 I'm not wrong. it's an opinion.

  • 2:44 is dope

  • and i am a huge beyonce fan

  • Sorry Beyonce she did a lot better so soulful and raw!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • @goneloopy26 people don't compare her to every single black woman. They are comparing her to Jazmine cause she has another version of this song. I am SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO confused at these comments though. I love Jazmine Sullivan but I am NOT hearing all this emotion and soul everyone else seems to be hearing. Beyonce SANG this song. Her vocals were ridiculous. She changed keys and hit the highest notes without sounding like she was screaming. Jazmine stayed in one key so idk how she's "better."

  • Okay Im A HUGE Beyonce Stan But I Have To Admit I Love This Version Better ! It Was Just Something About Her Voice That Just.... Gave This Song So Much More LIFE ! Get It Jazmine !!

  • @laqueshagirl177 beyonce was way better

  • @PuddinPOP1239 Beyonce's Studio Version Of This Song Is Not Better than This One For ME! But Her Live Version At The Wynn SLAYED!

  • I WISH YALL WUD STFU N JUS ENJOY THE SONG DAMN WHO CARES ABOUT WHO IS BETTER..THEY BOTH ARE GREAT...DAMN PEOPLE MAKE ME FUCKIN SICK

  • "It sounds like a 50's record, but thats allright with me"

  • She set the mood for this song, her voice was perfect.

  • Agree mrzchocodrop

  • JASMINE SULLIVAN IS THE SHIT HANDS DOWN, BEYONCES VERSION SUCKS HARDCORE! I CHOOSE JASMINE SULLIVAN OVER BEYONCE ANY DAY!!

  • @Jhopes911 Jaz's vociferous is better! Beyonce's vociferous arent bad either. We have to give credit where credit is due. For both of these lady's ethereal talent

  • ACTUALLY IF ANYONE KNOWS ANYHTING ABOUT ARTISTS AND BEYAONCE SHE STEALS EVERYONES SONG.....AND BEYONCE HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH THIS SONG SHE REWROTE SOME WORDS TO GET CREDIT AS CO-WRITER JAZMINE SULLIVAN WROTE THIS SONG AND SANG IT HERSELF FOR VICTORIA BECKHAM WHICH THAT VERSION SOUNDED TOO OLD SPICE GIRLY THATS Y IT NEVER WENT FAR AND NO ONE KNEW SHE CAME OUT WITH IT AND JAZMINE'S VERSION IS BETTER BC IT IS MORE HEARTFELT LIKE MAGOO SAID PLUS SINCE SHE WROTE IT AND ITS ABOUT HER LIFE U FEEL HER

  • That rough voice... OHLORD! ♥

  • I just heard beyounce version and even though she can sing; Jazzmine Sullivan version sound so damn soulful, raw and real! But their different people with different life experiences. And yes both ladies can sing.

  • @6615267844 tru!! couldn't have said it better!

  • Mrs. Jazmine Sullivan you have a beautiful voice and it's unique. I just love hearing her sing. Thank You!

  • IF YALL LISTEN TO BOTH JAZZ SOUND WAY BETTER B DO TO MUCH YELLIN JAZZ KEPT IT COOL WITH HER JAZZ VOICE I MEAN B CAN SING BUT DAMN SHE CAN SING EVERYTHING JAZZ KILLED IT HANDS DOWN:}

  • Jazz has so much soul to be let out, it's just rediculous!! that makes Jazz's version better

  • actually victoria beckham wrote the song and beyonce co wrote the song. jazmine and beyonce both got the song from her. they both sound good

  • @MsMusicjunkii #CoSign...people really should do some research before they comment

  • Beyoncé puts a lot more heart and soul in her version...

  • Well I Like Beyonce's Version Better, Because Her And Jay-Z Actually Went Through This ...If You Listen Carefully At The End Of Her Version She Says "Been ridin' with you for six years why did I deserve

    To be treated this way by you?" At That Particular Time They Were 2gether For 6 Years, An The Most Powerful Line In The Whole Song "Loved you more than ever More than my own life" Even Though I Think That Line Is Flat Out Retarded I Believe She Actually Does Love Him More Than Her Own Life.

  • booooring

  • PS JAZMINE WROTE THE SONG BEYONCE BOUGHT IT!!! CASE AND POINT WHY THE ORIGINAL SOUNDS BETTER!!! DAM DO YOUR RESEARCH PEOPLE!

  • Basically beyonce version has more runs and is more exciting but jazz is way more soulful when I cover it it'll be a mixture of the two .

  • Love this song and Jazmine Sulliven.

  • It's just my opinion people so don't CRUCIFY me, but Jazmine's voice is annoying and she shouts rather than sings in most of her songs. Beyonce has more feeling and life in her version, Jazmine's version is FLAT and boring...

  • @Caligirl5757 R U Serious There's No Screaming That's Pure Soulful Singing. If U Like Beyonce's Version Better Then Just Say That. But Don't Say Stuff Thats Not True About Jazmine To Get Ur Point Across. #Seriously

  • @lisalopes Excuse me buuuut, If you would re-read my comment a little more carefully, then you will realize that I said she usually shouts IN MOST OF HER SONGS. I said her version to this song is FLAT and BORING, unlike Beyonce's in my OPINION. Actually read things before you criticize people... : )

  • @Caligirl5757 Okay Cali Let's just Agree To Disagree but personally Jazmine Sullivan Is Never Caught Not Being Soulful. Doesn't Matter What Type Of Song She's Singing She's 100% Soulful All The Time And Thats Just The Truth. While Beyonce Is Rather Fickled If You Asked Me. Dont Get Me Wrong I LOve Bey But She Is A Fickled Woman.

  • @lisalopes I'm not a fan ofJazmine's AT ALL , but I agree with you on the part that she is always soulful, and yes Beyonce is Wishy-Washy as to what type of music she comes out with, I just perfer beyonce's version :)

  • @Caligirl5757 Understood

  • Amazing cover love her voice and beyonce's also.. Both have a certain feel to the song and sang it with such passion. It's not a competition it's more of a song expressing ones feelings

  • Do something to my soul!

  • fuck beyonce

  • I see why they would compare them on this particular song, Beyonce song it first and killed it lol

  • oohhh I like her voice, it's so sultry and soulful

  • I don't get why everyone always compares beyonce with every single black woman singer...they all have their own styles and they should all be appreciated....after all there is only ONE beyonce and no one is trying to be like her or outdo her, give it a rest peeps!

  • @goneloopy26 They're only comparing because Jaz covered BEYONCE'S song, lol. Obviously not a good reason, but it still makes sense.

  • Beyonce was on a world tour so she didnt fall of. There both beautiful and have a gift. So stop debating its dumb.

  • J love both of the versions but I will say I like Jazmines more because she has a more soulful feel with hers and that's what I live for. And to the ppl who keep fighting over who's better or not you can't compare the two. Their singing styles are completely different. Jazmine is jazzy and soulful while beyonce is RnB pop. But I love them both to death no matter what

  • more soulful than beyonce,

  • I hate that people fight with each other on Youtube. It's futile. #spreadlove

  • Beyonce's version is better, but this is good though!

  • I love her!

  • Comment removed

  • OMG I FELT......

  • SING TO DADDY BABY

  • uhhhh i think i broke the replay button! <3

  • My Opinion is

    1. Beyonce

    2. Victoria

    3. Jazmine

    I think I like Bey's the best because every saw and heard the rumors of what she went through and it was easier to relate and feel the pain she was going through (and of course because she's an amazing singer. I love VB, but I forgot she was a singer (since she's such an amazing designer) and I actually like her voice. And I have and love both of JS's album but I don't hear the passion and emotion in this song that everyone seems to here.

  • What the heck does Beyonce got to do with Jazmine Sulliven? If you're talking about this song, then both of them remade it. It's not their song. I like Jazmine's version better tho. More soul and emotion. I like Beyonce, but she isn't the only singer that can do something.

  • @TiffanyTahiti I agree with your comment except that this is Beyonce's song! This song has been covered by Viictoria Beckham and Jazmine Sulliven. Four people wrote this song Bey is one of them. Victoria's cover just came out first befor B-Day. Also, this happens all the time in the music business. Please, Please look for the CREDITS to this song, you will only find those 4 writes not V Beckham song. she NEVER released it as hers, she just COVERED it!

  • @nolaa64 Im Sorry Ur Mistaking Beyonce Even Said It herself She COVERED IT Its Victoria Beckman's Song Originally.

  • @lisalopes Sorry sweetheart YOU ARE MISTAKEN! Please LOOK UP THE CREDITS FOR THIS SONG!

    Also, ONLY ONE ARTIST featured this SONG on their CD (BEYONCE, B-DAY). There are four writers who are credited to this song (Bey is one of them). Again, don't believe me, PLEASE look it UP! Again JS wrote songs for Monica, JH, and CM (the Dreams x wife)! JS and VB both COVERED this song it was NEVER released as a SINGLE or on their CD. No big deal, it happens all the time. I'm a fan of jaz and Bey !

  • @nolaa64 No Nobody's Saying That She's Not The Only Person To Release It, But Victoria Beckham Was The First To Write And Record It. #JustSaying

  • @lisalopes Again, it is CREDITED, NOTED & a FACT that Victoria Beckham NEVER wrote this song

    (AT ANYTIME), she COVERED it! Victoria Beckham has only WRITTEN/CO-WRITTEN 8 songs. Several are from her SPICE GIRLS ERA & the others are from her SOLO PROJECTS. I thought the same as you are thinking until one of the co-writers pointed it out that they co-wrote this song with Bey & two others on ACESS HOLLYWOOD & I looked it up. Also, I love your blog name lisalope. I 'm A HUGE TLC stan, lol!

  • @nolaa64 Okay Did Not Know Abt The Access Report I Just Remember Jazmine Sullivan Saying Victoria Wrote It U Might Be Right. And Thank U TLC Is The Best Girl Band Of All Time. =)

  • @lisalopes I didn't know either until I looked her up( co-writer Candince Nelson). I found out she wrote or co-wrote for a lot of my fav. like Brandy, and Mary J "I AM' which I LOVE, LOVE LOVE, lol. She can sang pretty well too. She is on youtube and I remember seeing her somewhere, I just didn't knew she penned so many songs that I love. Also, Lisa WAS/IS my fav. from the group. When I saw her docu. on MTV or VH1 about her last days It just made me LOVE and RESPECT her even MORE!!

  • @TiffanyTahiti

    Well said!

  • @TiffanyTahiti She wrote alot for beyonce and alot of other people for years like Neyo.

  • ok -- how much did she sing this song -- smh

  • i love jazmine ! her version is the best

    

  • This is good, but the Queen's better, more emotion, heart, and soul

  • I love beyonce and Jaz...but Jaz version is more heartfelt, she's amazin

  • jazmine come back !!!!

  • I love da way jazmine sung this song i liked beyonce but jazmines was better

  • I Liked Beyonce's better . she sang it with more emotion

  • Victoria Beckham's version was bland and boring. This version is sung great but it has no feel. Beyonce sung it like she meant it and felt it. Honestly, Beyonce owned it because she's use to singing break-up songs, she's always bitter in her lyrics..

  • Beyonce killed this!!! Jaz not so much!

  • Typo: loved* Bey's version first. ...Jaz sounds genuinely DISAPPOINTED, as if this dude keeps hurting her.

  • I'm riding with Jaz on this one. Heard and lived Bey's version first, but though they both sound hurt, Bet sounds more pissed where Jaz sounds genuinely pissed.

  • she is bad....'

    

  • vocal the best in my eyes i love her voice

  • The POWER behind her version is amazing. She's a better singer. I like Bey's version though it's the only song of hers that I really believe the emotion behind, aside from Halo, and that's prob because it's HONEST emotion on her part.

  • Major love to the musical genius of Curtis Mayfield for ever creating this beautiful piece of music. RIP Mr. Mayfield!

  • Plus theses are beyonces lyrics Curtis Mayfield think was only an instrumental.

  • Comment removed

  • @twarren20 actually...beyonce' wrote this song...betta check da credits...came out in 07

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @twarren20 riiiiiite..pretty sure she didnt write the music but she always writes her own songs.....dats y she won the awards from ascap....which is a SONGWRITERS AWARD if you didnt know

  • Comment removed

  • @twarren20 lol.one of these days yall people will stop hatin on beyonce'!! but as long as people hatin i know she doin something right...none of her cd's sound the same and the newest one is a totally different sound.her appeal has went no where.prolly why her cd is numba one huh?but personally i appreciate music..even tho i like beyonce's version of this song betta i havent hated on jazmine once...jaz is great..but again i lyke all types of music,we need 2 stop comparin.she grindin jus lyke jaz

  • Comment removed

  • @twarren20 i actually appreciate that comment...but i love her and i call myself her "biggest fan" but who doesnt??i love everything she does and to me everything she does IS great.but i love the latest cd..the only thing i'd change about what she does is the fact that she dont give us a chance to miss her b4 da next cd comes out,but then again i'd be pissed for havin to wait too long,but maybe thats what she should do..take away the videos,the dancin...i still love the voice...im still obsessed

  • @twarren20 Well it is her most critically acclaimed album to date so there seems to be a much different OPINION on what's great or not.

  • Comment removed

  • @twarren20 In great respect to music - PERIOD! The album went #1 on the worldwide charts. #1 in 17 countries!

  • Comment removed

  • @twarren20 I'm not upset at all. I just think you are misinformed. By the way, those stats are from 2010. As it's been publicized, Beyonce was on break from work & the public so of course she did not make as much money and have as much publicity because she was spending time with her husband. LOL. You are entitled to have your opinion but speak facts please.

  • Comment removed

  • @twarren20 If you read where you got your information, it accounts for stats in 2010. To answer your question, Beyonce was not on tour in 2010. The bulk of her touring was in 2009. So, wrong again. How did this go from you pretending to make a factual statement on Beyonce's music to trying to debate money and personal earnings? Yes Gaga achieved all of this in 2010 but it means nothing to Beyonce who was on a break from her career.

  • Comment removed

  • @Sc0rpion When you finish...i still love Bey to death. haha

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @twarren20 smh bye.

  • @twarren20 uhm this was only last/this year....beyonce didnt even have an album/movie/anything because she was on a long ass vacation...lets see Lady Gaga make that much money with no product out. now YOU can step her game up to compete with Beyonce.

  • Comment removed

  • @elithesmartguy fuck beyonce ya'll beyonce worshipers ya'll kill me always comparing somebody to her she cool but she aint all that leave beyonce name on her videos ya'll stans are always stuck up her ass so much ya'll act like no one can compare to her fuck her and you too.