Actually it is possible since most of these aircraft have a greater thrust to weight ratio. Furthermore, there are other video's of skilled R/C pilots landing with the loss of one wing. Furthermore, it is on record that a U.S pilot flying and F-15 Eagle landed with one wing after a mid air collision with another aircraft during a training exorcise. True he landed at about 300 knots.
see 1:00 scene: aircraft was replaced with montage (see for examlple better back scenes). At the end you see real plane, and with BOTH wings. Not seeng of cuase, one that was "lost". It is hidden by fuselage. :-)
its all fake. I fly scale rc planes, and have seen tons of wings come off on sport scale yak's, or in this case and extras.Yet have never seen anyone land there plane (all crashed misiralby) especioly since rc planes are much more minuverable than real ones with controlling the amount of throw, travle...
funny how some people are fooled by the CGI, its way to unrealistic, and if that dont get ya, when he first lands and bumps into the air, he doesnt get any real hangtime, just plummets hard back, and miraculously completely stops in i dont know, say 50 feet?
This is just amazing skill- this is a stunt plane, and they have VERY powerful engine- he just dragged himself at full throttle and found it stabilized, and was lucky enough to land.
ok look there a tons of eros in this vid. the plane is at two completly defernt angels and the marks that you have to show thats this is a fake are not going to be right for one example the plane is flying level when u used the mark for the horizantal stab and on the ground the plane is not level cusing the marks to be off a slight hair and the same with the distance to the front of the wing this is very posible to do and the piolit just used 3d flying skill and trianing to lad the plane.
It's fake. It's not physically possible to fly a plane like that with one wing. You lose lift on a whole side of your aircraft, flip over and from there you can not get level because of the weight of the remaining wing. The only thing that's going to happen to this plane is fall out of the sky like a stone.
It is possible for a stunt plane to land like this, there is little weight to them. Pilots can hang these planes on the prop with 2 wings, at this angle the wings produce no lift. So doing it with one wing is possible, and there's even less weight.. As as long as there is something to stop the fuselage from spinning, which is what the other wing is doing. Having said that, this video is totally fake using large RC planes.
Thanks for not calling me retarded. I read your posts and have realised you don't actually know anything about aviation. But I wont call you retarded either.
yeah i seen that, a few times now, at first i didnt believe it, untill i saw the actual photos of it on the ground, that sort of damage wouldnt happen if something mundane like a hangar collapsed on it
Of of of....so. My opinion....this is a fake, but only teoretical this can be do. Is true that if the engine is very powerfull this can be real, but in this case if fake. i thing that the firs plane is a RC plane...and the second is a real plane.
I have seen planes with verry powerfull motors do this . The torque ( power of the motor and the proper ) in raport with wheigth should be supraunitar . In this case the power of the motor need to be very high in order to compensate the loss of the portance.
Your an idiot if you think this is real...This was made by a college student for a 3D modelling project. Look at the plane at 0:54 that kind of stress upon landing would have snaped the wheels of at least! If you really, truely think this video is real then you have no understanding of physics or aviation...
no,no you don't understand man...no need to get agressive. I was just telling you that this is a fake. It IS a fake. it's not a matter of opinion, this WAS made for an advert. That's not an opinion that's a fact. I'm not contesting your opinion I'm telling you that this is an advert. That's the truth. Hey, don't you call me a Pussy Girl! I'm a guy...
Hey, it's a good thing they remembered to land the "Fake" plane on miniture fake grass. Otherwise we'd be able to scale the plane by the fact that the grass along the run way was towering above its wheels like it does in other videow of model airplanes.
I have seen this done with a model airplane, However the real give away is the very short landing roll. very possible with a 7 to 14 KG model but not on a full size. very cleaver thou.
This airplane would have stayed in a spin all the way to the ground from the moment the wing broke off. There is NO recovery in a situation such as this on a real full scale airplane regardless of the size of the verticle Stab!
At the end the pilot opens the cockpit canopy and steps out of the plane labeled as a "model". it 1) has no white striping, 2) does not have a raised instrument panel, 3) has the same wheel nacelles that are on the wingless plane and 4)has the same short wing to propeller distance proportions. I still think its a fake but a lot of the ideas used as evidence just aren't so. In other words, somehow he climbs out of the model plane.
its an experiment of german televison (pro7) they invented the name James Anderssn and made a homepage with fake pics. the video is made with an model airplane and was then faked by professionals ;). in this moment i'm seeing that in tv!
These are still shots taking from the video clips. The only thing I did as I stated was enlarge it a little to match the plane sizes, and then rotate it a little so it looked more level.
Actually it is possible since most of these aircraft have a greater thrust to weight ratio. Furthermore, there are other video's of skilled R/C pilots landing with the loss of one wing. Furthermore, it is on record that a U.S pilot flying and F-15 Eagle landed with one wing after a mid air collision with another aircraft during a training exorcise. True he landed at about 300 knots.
Puff29646 1 week ago
Just type "killa thrill making of" and you will find the answer.
glxflames 1 year ago
fake.
tweakleton 1 year ago
Comment removed
SierraCharley 1 year ago
see 1:00 scene: aircraft was replaced with montage (see for examlple better back scenes). At the end you see real plane, and with BOTH wings. Not seeng of cuase, one that was "lost". It is hidden by fuselage. :-)
For want they make this fake?
inetTVchannel 1 year ago
Anybody saw it? Can they tell - is is a real fact?
Why no any official reports on it?
inetTVchannel 1 year ago
Ha,ha,ha.Pic na wodę fotomontage!!!
nifur1 1 year ago
cgi IT is
boomkinblugill 2 years ago
its all fake. I fly scale rc planes, and have seen tons of wings come off on sport scale yak's, or in this case and extras.Yet have never seen anyone land there plane (all crashed misiralby) especioly since rc planes are much more minuverable than real ones with controlling the amount of throw, travle...
nberlin94 2 years ago
funny how some people are fooled by the CGI, its way to unrealistic, and if that dont get ya, when he first lands and bumps into the air, he doesnt get any real hangtime, just plummets hard back, and miraculously completely stops in i dont know, say 50 feet?
landmine21 2 years ago
CGI is amazing isnt it?
Only the first part is real. The second part where the wing comes off is completely computer generated.
powerstroke01 2 years ago
This is just amazing skill- this is a stunt plane, and they have VERY powerful engine- he just dragged himself at full throttle and found it stabilized, and was lucky enough to land.
mkosak00 2 years ago
ok look there a tons of eros in this vid. the plane is at two completly defernt angels and the marks that you have to show thats this is a fake are not going to be right for one example the plane is flying level when u used the mark for the horizantal stab and on the ground the plane is not level cusing the marks to be off a slight hair and the same with the distance to the front of the wing this is very posible to do and the piolit just used 3d flying skill and trianing to lad the plane.
Aircraftfreak155 2 years ago
It's fake. It's not physically possible to fly a plane like that with one wing. You lose lift on a whole side of your aircraft, flip over and from there you can not get level because of the weight of the remaining wing. The only thing that's going to happen to this plane is fall out of the sky like a stone.
ShadowXII 2 years ago
Actually some fighter planes can fly with one wing.
Weirdo10o4 2 years ago
While this is true, it counts a lot on the skill of the pilot as well.
But for a plane like this? No chance.
ShadowXII 2 years ago
It is possible for a stunt plane to land like this, there is little weight to them. Pilots can hang these planes on the prop with 2 wings, at this angle the wings produce no lift. So doing it with one wing is possible, and there's even less weight.. As as long as there is something to stop the fuselage from spinning, which is what the other wing is doing. Having said that, this video is totally fake using large RC planes.
PorkyPiggles 2 years ago
I'm not going to bother telling you how retarded you are.
ShadowXII 2 years ago
Thanks for not calling me retarded. I read your posts and have realised you don't actually know anything about aviation. But I wont call you retarded either.
PorkyPiggles 2 years ago
@ShadowXII you just did meanie
CrowbarOfJustice 1 year ago
Hey u need to tell ur science teacher to quit his job bc he's a dumb ass.Its fake.
91Racing426 2 years ago
26 hes spining the wrong way
BrandonLeo3 2 years ago
NOPE THIS IS NOT FAKE IT WAS EVEN ON TV and my science teachers friend can do it
Coolie0037 2 years ago
do a search on google. it was created by a marketing firm
negativeeffect15 2 years ago
ohhh my gudness its are really 2 differend planes O.o
ThePieMan159 2 years ago
Of course it's fake...any basic aerodynamics course will tell you the truth:
Plane - wing = CRASH.
But of course, there are so many idiots that believe everything they see anyway, so I'm just wasting my time here.
thatdood001 2 years ago
Actually an Israeli F-15 landed with one wing before....
thatdood001=Idiot
rap1800 2 years ago
yeah i seen that, a few times now, at first i didnt believe it, untill i saw the actual photos of it on the ground, that sort of damage wouldnt happen if something mundane like a hangar collapsed on it
kineticdeath 2 years ago
Of of of....so. My opinion....this is a fake, but only teoretical this can be do. Is true that if the engine is very powerfull this can be real, but in this case if fake. i thing that the firs plane is a RC plane...and the second is a real plane.
yrzbg 2 years ago
This is real , this can be done .
I have seen planes with verry powerfull motors do this . The torque ( power of the motor and the proper ) in raport with wheigth should be supraunitar . In this case the power of the motor need to be very high in order to compensate the loss of the portance.
So i thing this is real.
burceavc 2 years ago
and an ant is therefore a bird of prey.
idiot
franktbird 2 years ago
Your an idiot if you think this is real...This was made by a college student for a 3D modelling project. Look at the plane at 0:54 that kind of stress upon landing would have snaped the wheels of at least! If you really, truely think this video is real then you have no understanding of physics or aviation...
SimulationGuy121 2 years ago
Go F...K your self this is my opinion is you have now wright to contest me.
Pusyy girl ....mortii matii de prost ce esti ....
Baga..mi... as pula in mata.....de idiot .....planteaza ti elice la cur si sa vezi ce frumos aterizezi .
burceavc 2 years ago
To burceavc
no,no you don't understand man...no need to get agressive. I was just telling you that this is a fake. It IS a fake. it's not a matter of opinion, this WAS made for an advert. That's not an opinion that's a fact. I'm not contesting your opinion I'm telling you that this is an advert. That's the truth. Hey, don't you call me a Pussy Girl! I'm a guy...
SimulationGuy121 2 years ago
i can prove its fake look it has white trim in the air watch right when it lands not when its stoped but when it just hit the ground
huntingfreak901 2 years ago
I'm not saying it couldn't be done, but COME ON :D
Did we actually see the SAME CLIP?
TRUST ME, it's fake. And you only need to LOOK AT IT to tell somethings way off.
sarkasmi83 2 years ago
Then prove it.
thatdood001 2 years ago
what kind of dumb ass reposts an obvious fake in light of the fact that the 'not fake' response thread says nothing but FAKE time after time.
ipon: you've something to get back to....?
uyesu 2 years ago
you cant land with one wing
no balance you can hold its fake.
Kalenichtenneuker 2 years ago
look at 0:57 . The plane grows up =O
Xeripheas 2 years ago
Thank you for proving this. Obviously, there are thousands of others who think the wing falling off the plane in the CGI video is real.
Again, never underestimate the power of stupid people with access to the internet.
thatdood001 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i can prove its fake look it has white trim in the air watch right when it lands not when its stoped but when it just hit the ground
huntingfreak901 2 years ago
FAKE
XxMotoChrisxX 2 years ago
Hey, it's a good thing they remembered to land the "Fake" plane on miniture fake grass. Otherwise we'd be able to scale the plane by the fact that the grass along the run way was towering above its wheels like it does in other videow of model airplanes.
bmbirdsong 2 years ago
Ich habs bei galileo gesehen, aber davor hab ich das video noch nie gesehen
hotknight2000 2 years ago
I have seen this done with a model airplane, However the real give away is the very short landing roll. very possible with a 7 to 14 KG model but not on a full size. very cleaver thou.
finecutpost 2 years ago
Also, during the landing of this one winged airplane, the gear would have collasped!
groovee63 3 years ago
This airplane would have stayed in a spin all the way to the ground from the moment the wing broke off. There is NO recovery in a situation such as this on a real full scale airplane regardless of the size of the verticle Stab!
groovee63 3 years ago
At the end the pilot opens the cockpit canopy and steps out of the plane labeled as a "model". it 1) has no white striping, 2) does not have a raised instrument panel, 3) has the same wheel nacelles that are on the wingless plane and 4)has the same short wing to propeller distance proportions. I still think its a fake but a lot of the ideas used as evidence just aren't so. In other words, somehow he climbs out of the model plane.
artdever 3 years ago
The pilot and the guy running upto the plane are both computer generated. Very cleverly done, but very clearly fake.
Timmayx 2 years ago
yeah right^^
Joshi576 3 years ago
thats fake!
its an experiment of german televison (pro7) they invented the name James Anderssn and made a homepage with fake pics. the video is made with an model airplane and was then faked by professionals ;). in this moment i'm seeing that in tv!
Sattler2611 3 years ago
ich auch...um ehrlich zu sein wusst ich bis eben nich mal was von diesem video xD
prehisNell 3 years ago 2
ich auch nicht. und ich bin fast nur im youtube
hotknight2000 2 years ago
You´re right!
I´ve seen it, too.
On PRO7´s tv show "Galileo" on Monday.
First I believed what I´ve seen!
But now I know...
BSSchumacher 3 years ago
So is 'KillaThrill' a fake clothing company too?
One of Killathrill's directors was the person who registered Andersson's website.
I wish I could watch the programme!
conversely123 3 years ago
thats a fakre from the german show "galileo"
druideka 3 years ago
This is a great pilot, no comparison...........anything can be twisted to fit anything..
CortesZ666 3 years ago
its a fake video from a german tv show ;) this never happens... look at the landing is seems unnatural...
MatrixMol 3 years ago
These are still shots taking from the video clips. The only thing I did as I stated was enlarge it a little to match the plane sizes, and then rotate it a little so it looked more level.
ipon70 3 years ago
I don't stt the point of the comparison. Where did the second photo come from?
JohnAPeters1939 3 years ago