EricaRoane -You'll Never Walk Alone- Idol Search 3 E&S Round

[MzPenspeaks]

i loved this..

[ericaroane]

@MzPenspeaks Thanks Steph! I get mixed reviews on this... but alot of folks dont realize the objective was to NOT sound like the original.... I appreciate you watching & commenting. I hope your New Year is off to a great start! =D

[mario1983xy]

This was anything but "You'll never walk alone".

Absolutely terrible!

[ericaroane]

It wasnt suppose to sound like the original...... sorry you were disappointed....

[trevorhoen]

That was so beautiful, the whole video was just amazingly beautiful. I'm favoriting! :) Love it!

4th place buddies,

~Trevor~

[ericaroane]

Thanks that means alot considering this was one of my least favorite rounds =/ HugZZZ~

[penspeaks]

this was beautiful!

[ericaroane]

Thanks Steph! HugZZZ~

[ElishaJordan]

Man, I wish a bluesy backing of this existed so we could have heard more.. This just seemed so short and I wanted to hear more dangit LOL  You sound beautiful and the whole visual atmosphere just added to the organic/earthy quality of your vocals.. nice singing girl! You will definitely be "walking on" to the next round! ;) *hug* ~Ej

[ericaroane]

Yeah I did kinda of forget to mention that in the description box... if I could have found a backing I would have went the oprea route, but I couldnt so I just interpreted the song the best I could my way with also trying my best to tone it down, a level or 2 or maybe even 3 LOL Thanks for your continued encouragement =) HugZZZ

[barabarag]

nice song well done

[ericaroane]

Thanks Mom~

[chubbaluvva]

Vocally, this is your best. You made this song fit your own style, but you were able to stretch yourself vocally. And I much respect you for keeping the artistry aspect of you...cuz I feel that you are one of the few contestants that still HAS that distinct "something".

[ericaroane]

Thanks Charly... I just hope I am giving off "something" that will make you want to vote for me! =)

[creeingles]

very nice.. good luck

[ericaroane]

Thanks Cree~

[jsills108]

Loved the a cappella. Great job! Got my vote this week ;)

[ericaroane]

Thanks! I'd be proud to have it~ =)

[EASings]

Good job, Erica! Good luck!

[ericaroane]

Thanks Eron~

[ronandetta]

I also put this one in my favorite

[ericaroane]

Cool, Thanks~

[ronandetta]

wow,, again you did a good one,, loved the thought you put into this video too.. but you really did great on the song too.. I loved the video as much as your song.. lol.. Oh well, we are juding you on the singing though.. great job..

[ericaroane]

Thanks~

[timaru19]

nice originality , liked the thought that went into making the vid and the rendition was ok also,

[ericaroane]

Thanks~

[jwipe]

I really love the way you sing that Erica. That softer side of your voice is SO beautiful. And you really made it your own. Wonderful job!

[ericaroane]

Thanks~

[rafz89]

one of my favorite songs and you did a great job. definitely original, but that's what made it so interesting. good job and good luck!

[ericaroane]

Thanks~

[SoutherlandJL]

You go girl! thats what im talking about dynamics! you did good! and im proud of you, keep it up!

[ericaroane]

Well I have to be honest I am alot more comfortable singing loud & proud, but I know I had to show you judges that I can sing softer if I choose to. I tried my best. Thanks~

[SoutherlandJL]

this has been my favorite from you! keep adapting the dynamics in the upcoming performances. build your songs up! and then belt out

[ericaroane]

I'll do my best~ =)