I may be wrong, (but I would hazard a guess) that this audience was not expecting the most gut-wrenching song ever written about heroin addiction. You would likely be better off watching the "official" video...before EMI sued them for not making commercial music!
this song was very kindly than seriuos..his voice was fantastic..and I really don't understand why they gone away ..left secretly by world music ..nobody haven't seen them somewhere at these days? not actual videos pictures? but are they alive yet ??
This album has gone so far beyond pop and rock music that no wonder so few people grasped the beauty of 'Spitit of Eden' at the time. NOw... it's one of the most influential albums when it comes to post pop , ambient etc. among artists of course :)
I love music. New, old.....talk talk is sooogoooooddd. Great post. please don't bash newer band that are gooooddd too. I am sure you can trace/attribute talk talk's influence to pink floyd, Harper, and even Monk. get on with it and enjoy. All this soccer club type worship does nothing....Pele was good, so is Beckham....enjoy.
Tell me how I fear it I buy prejudice for my health Is it worth so much when you taste it? Enough there ain't enough hidden hurt A time to sell yourself A time for passing Spirit How long? Spirit How long? Spirit How long? Spirit...
but nowadays....what you think of the band no-man? they have the same manegement as talk talk back in the days...the voice of tim bowness is if i hear god singing..steve wilson on guitar..check them out guys!!
Talk Talk 's last two albums have stood the test of time. They are probably more relevant now than they were back then. Those albums paved the way for Radiohead and all the other post rock bands.
Beautiful. Listening all this day and the more I listen the more perfect it is to me. See how butifully constructed Talk Talk songs are at all, especially from last 2 albums. Timeless music..
it kills me - this album was considered the death knell for Talk Talk (from a popular perspective) but how similar is it to Radiohead and Coldplay today???
If this was released today it'd probably be an iTunes commercial. (ok maybe not QUITE, but you know what i mean)
Tell me how I fear it I buy prejudice for my health Is it worth so much when you taste it? Enough there ain't enough hidden hurt A time to sell yourself A time for passing Spirit How long? Spirit How long? Spirit How long? Spirit....... I'm speechless... so beautiful in it's melancholic sadness ... Thank you for up ...
Because they spent a year in the studio to make the soundtrack you hear ? There's no way this could be played live...there's a real cathedral choir on it, and a beautifully recorded Leslie Organ.
41 years old ,heard loads of music in my time,but talk talk blow me away every time,my wife cant see the point in loving a band so much,but eh i didnt marry her for her musical input,not that id listen to her anyway haha
correct me if i'm wrong, but i think his brother died due to drug addiction, hence the line "i've seen heroin for myself". it is often stated in articles that mark hollis did heroin in the eighties, but i'm not sure that is true. but hey, who am i to speculate? i wasn't there....
hmm, maybe my comment can be misinterpreted. i am not saying mark hollis ever did heroin, but the song could be about his brother. again, this is me speculating.
Utterly gorgeous, yeah. I believe the organ's a bit of a nod to Bowie's wonderful, hymnlike "Word on a Wing", just as the Velvet Underground's "Heroin" is referenced on "Eden". _Spirit of Eden_ is a record which makes you hear in a new way....
@BillyBird Hope it wasn't an obvious question...don't know what a Mexican Bass is!! Just credit where it's due, that's all. And that part after the first chorus has always hit a resonant frequency with me, and a lot of other people, it seems, too.
But, there's a point where you can deconstruct a song into dust though, eh? Not trying to do that.
Ik wordt er gelukkig van om te zien dat er nog meer mensen zijn die nog weten wat echte muziek is/was. Het wachten is nog op een goede audiofiele DVD van meneer Hollis en Co..
I also taped a blooper interview they tried to do before they recorded this one (the one that the girl in the start of the song is telling about)but never seen that one online yet...
I dunno about that. I guess he did this for the record company, but if you look at the actual video released with 'I Believe in You', it's very well executed. First verse, he looks like he's on heroin, nodding off. Second verse, he looks like he's castigating the heroin addict. And then, for the 'Spirit, how long' section at the end, he appears to have shaken off the shackles of the drug to find personal redemption. Either way you look at it, it's such a class song.
I have a feeling that MH's closed eyes and withdrawn manner are emotional statements. If you watch his stuff you can see how his shyness or withdrawn tendencies progress through the years. Originally he's OK, then he starts to look up allot from looking down, then it's the ever-present sunglasses to avoidance of the world in general.
It's not so difficult to make the difference between live and recording versions. It is exactly the same version that the one on the album. The last Talk Talk's albums were impossible to reproduce in live. They were based on improvisation and re-build in song format.
When an artist has the focus on an idea, there's nothing to make change his mind. And when Mark Hollis says : " Talk Talk is over ", believe him ( even everyone here wants a comeback ). Talk Talk never performed the last two albums live. Was it fear to make wrong ? Perfection is hard to reproduce. Mark Hollis was tired of Show-biz.
i realize, considering the rest of the music on their last two albums, that this is the best choice for a "live" performance, but still not exactly something one would expect to be played on stage. Nonetheless, one of my all-time favorite tunes by any band, ever. Those last two albums were masterpieces.
Nope he only did 1 solo album, simply called "Mark Hollis" in 1998. He did do the odd obscure collaboration here and then since then, but has practically vanished from the music biz (and the music world in general)
I guess this is the closest they ever got to a live performance of any of the songs off the last two albums.. pity. Still great to see it. I don't think Mark Hollis is a drug user, he just got sick of the music business and retreated into privacy. Such a shame, it'd be so interesting to see what sort of music he'd be making now.
"I Have Seen Heroin For Myself" is a pretty good hint to why they did not tour the last two albums. Did you hear his solo lp? Heavy mother that one..... wOw
Nah actually u're in the wrong there, pal. Hollis couldn't see the point in going on the road trying to reproduce what had taken them so long to craft in the studio.
Actually the heroin bit is about his brother Ed, who died then in the late 80's.
Superb, this sheer brilliance even though it is mimed, it is stillfrom the heart. Does anyone know how to save vids from this site? to save into a folder or somewhere other than favourites.
yeah indeed he hated it, hence no tour for Spirit of Eden and Laughing Stock. I even wonder how they convinced him to take part in that tv show.
As for being underrated, I'm not sure. Maybe sales went a downward spiral with each album, but the critics always had praise, and the music world don't forget how influential they still are to many artists/bands.
That was typical Mark Hollis. He hated all the crap that went with it, all he wanted to do was make music. The guy was close on genius in some respects tho, and TT were so underrated it's unfair....
I may be wrong, (but I would hazard a guess) that this audience was not expecting the most gut-wrenching song ever written about heroin addiction. You would likely be better off watching the "official" video...before EMI sued them for not making commercial music!
mcampeau11 1 month ago
Grandiosi
Colporombo 1 month ago
I just can't understand hoe Mark can abandon music so consequently from his life.
The space he left was never filled. Still hoping so muc that he will be heard again
baloulule 4 months ago
I like his hair shorter. Where Are you Mark We want you back?
carbine125 5 months ago
its about time mark hollis/talk talk were in the rock and roll music hall of fame with the fab four the beatles.
marty9040 6 months ago 2
@marty9040 - DAMN RIGHT. They took music to the next level as much as the Beatles ever did. Also, their last two albums are utterly timeless.
TelboyD 4 months ago 2
nothing compares to Mark Hollis....he's unique!!
Yolagataloca10 1 year ago
Mark , i believe in you...
thank you ....spirit....
LAFKO1 1 year ago
this song was very kindly than seriuos..his voice was fantastic..and I really don't understand why they gone away ..left secretly by world music ..nobody haven't seen them somewhere at these days? not actual videos pictures? but are they alive yet ??
9TEODORA 1 year ago
@9TEODORA They are still alive. Singer Mark Hollis has retired from public life, and
it seems has stopped doing music altogether. Bass player Paul Webb & drummer Lee Harris have formed a band called O.rang
BillyBird 1 year ago
Their peak song. The most beautiful song I've ever heard.
My eyes water EVERY TIME I hear the opening chords. So much pain in such a beautiful voice. And then rising above it all at the end.
Spirit.
mcampeau11 1 year ago 2
Hollis is...out of borders.
jdombey 1 year ago
This album has gone so far beyond pop and rock music that no wonder so few people grasped the beauty of 'Spitit of Eden' at the time. NOw... it's one of the most influential albums when it comes to post pop , ambient etc. among artists of course :)
comadivine1 1 year ago 3
Why did i ever stop listening to talk talk? Best band ever.
Gunuph 1 year ago
One of the best songs ever recorded !
Hollis voice is unique. BTW, where is he nowadays , even Google has been not able to find him :-(
pablof59 1 year ago
He's not involved in music anymore now, no writing nor producing, nothing. He's living the quiet life in london with wife and kids (and goats)
BillyBird 1 year ago
@BillyBird Wow, that's kind of amazing....I guess he just got it all out then....wow...
dovie2blue 1 year ago
@BillyBird In 2001 he did perform and coproduced Anja Garbarek's 3rd studio album, Smiling and Waving. Still, that's not very recent.
MrAugust767 10 months ago
@MrAugust767 That's right. He also played on UNKLE's debut album, "Psyence Fiction", as well as on the Allinson / Brown "AV1" album in 1998.
BillyBird 10 months ago
Coś niesamowitego!!!Ach te wspomnienia....
gadzio74 1 year ago
its about time mark hollis/talk talk were in the music hall of fame.
marty9040 1 year ago 5
Brilliant song
sengland70 1 year ago
I am a muzo - this puts me right. Thank you X
GillyDangerous 2 years ago
Shame its playback..
Simmekbh 2 years ago
Comment removed
jjooooose 2 years ago
Think he's singin about his brother, Ed. A heroin addict once.
Mark, you legend!
Come back, you're needed now.
copeyattamsworth 2 years ago 2
HUGE BAND! his voice is so enormous. 5s
88cheyenne 2 years ago
mmmmmmmmmmmmmm,,,,,,,,,,,
Blissfull.
ruralgraffiti 2 years ago
great song, cheers m8.
arent keane shit?!
thestarsgoblue 2 years ago 2
This beautiful song can be appreciated only by the real fun of Talk Talk...and I am certainly !!! Great Talk Talk !!!
DavidCurci 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I am tired of hearing this song. I have 41 years and when you have 80 (if you get to that age) want to keep listening.
iscariotesrock 2 years ago
Ich hatte bisher noch keine liveaufnahme
zu diesem Song gesehen!
Echt cooooooooooool
Roohoo67 2 years ago
I love music. New, old.....talk talk is sooogoooooddd. Great post. please don't bash newer band that are gooooddd too. I am sure you can trace/attribute talk talk's influence to pink floyd, Harper, and even Monk. get on with it and enjoy. All this soccer club type worship does nothing....Pele was good, so is Beckham....enjoy.
donblackparks 2 years ago
lotreamon01 3 years ago 4
This is the real start of the genre Postrock. And it is still one of the most important recordings of the late 80ties.
mikesch0815 3 years ago 5
great sound for just 2 guitars and a drum kit :-)
amazing song
mozwerk 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
And without even having to strum the guitar! Awfully talented so he is
neopolitanicecream 2 years ago
Beautiful, timeless, just flat out gorgeous music. Come back Mark.
Topnikko 3 years ago 2
but nowadays....what you think of the band no-man? they have the same manegement as talk talk back in the days...the voice of tim bowness is if i hear god singing..steve wilson on guitar..check them out guys!!
kuwaharalaserlite 3 years ago
Talk Talk 's last two albums have stood the test of time. They are probably more relevant now than they were back then. Those albums paved the way for Radiohead and all the other post rock bands.
ruffian1868 3 years ago 3
You're right Radiohead etc must have been influenced by this wonderful music wish they would reform-can't we get a petition going???
7h89m 3 years ago
From the Spirit of Eden Album, just timeless beautiful music, come back Mark we miss you -Thanks for posting
Darrell9029 3 years ago
Imperious sadness and consummate genius - come back Mark - the world needs you
toddbulky 3 years ago 6
Me niego a creer que Mark Hollis sufra una "sequia creativa" después de tres joyas como son los últimos discos de Talk Talk y el album solista.
Se te extraña, amigo. Que bueno seria verte en Buenos Aires.
ilpezkato 3 years ago
kippevel en tranen in mijn ogen....
japy40 3 years ago
"spirit..." MASTERPIECE
"Laughing..." MASTERPIECE
"Mark hollis" MASTERPIECE
...
dipsomane 3 years ago 3
Gran tema uno de mis favoritos....
metabaron38 3 years ago
Beautiful. Listening all this day and the more I listen the more perfect it is to me. See how butifully constructed Talk Talk songs are at all, especially from last 2 albums. Timeless music..
apocwiar 3 years ago 5
it kills me - this album was considered the death knell for Talk Talk (from a popular perspective) but how similar is it to Radiohead and Coldplay today???
If this was released today it'd probably be an iTunes commercial. (ok maybe not QUITE, but you know what i mean)
swelstead 3 years ago 5
i wish mark hollis came back to the music world again and create what only he is capabe of. Speak with the voice of transcendence!!
aproachingsilence 3 years ago 5
beautiful voice, beautiful lyrics, beautiful music. i listen to it over and over and over...
alana3darkangel 3 years ago 3
lotreamon01 3 years ago 2
Superb, I'm wordless;
Jeannot090207 3 years ago 4
its class pal nice one!
dermotoblong 3 years ago
To be honest this song reminds me of a nightmare i would rather 4get but i just cant stop listeneing to it.
Midnight0190 3 years ago
Best ending in a song ever...well maybe not in this youtube version but it sounds beautiful in the original song
darkduende 3 years ago
That's the single edit (aka the 7" single. the middle section and end are edited a lot to fit the 3.30 min. frame)
BillyBird 3 years ago
hi again just found a talk talk video at a car boot cost me 50p what a bloody bargain,and it still plays bonus
cloudbuster66 3 years ago
Beautiful song......
Great band.........
Only seen them 'Live' once, on 'The Colour of Spring' Tour....Way back in the 80's
Mint....
PatsyS3 4 years ago
talk talk most uderated band ever .years ahead of there time i dare you to listen and not be moved by it
pdood101 4 years ago
why was it lipsynced?
Sieist23Jahrealt 4 years ago
Because they spent a year in the studio to make the soundtrack you hear ? There's no way this could be played live...there's a real cathedral choir on it, and a beautifully recorded Leslie Organ.
Can't just do that in a crappy TV studio
beebfader 2 years ago
41 years old ,heard loads of music in my time,but talk talk blow me away every time,my wife cant see the point in loving a band so much,but eh i didnt marry her for her musical input,not that id listen to her anyway haha
cloudbuster66 4 years ago 14
Mark hollis is one of the most under rated singer song writers of our time.
deancooky 4 years ago 21
i agree deancooky,
theBESTelvis 3 years ago
Here there be Gods.
iris2gamera 4 years ago
This is such a beautiful song but so sad at the same time, all about heroin addiction.
timeitstime 4 years ago
And here is THE SONG.
LunaSeaSane 4 years ago
I love this song...does anyone know it's history or it's meaning?
klarney 4 years ago
correct me if i'm wrong, but i think his brother died due to drug addiction, hence the line "i've seen heroin for myself". it is often stated in articles that mark hollis did heroin in the eighties, but i'm not sure that is true. but hey, who am i to speculate? i wasn't there....
ConnieXX 4 years ago
You're wrong, about drugs, Mark said : alcohol yes, but heroin no.
Nuche45 4 years ago 2
hmm, maybe my comment can be misinterpreted. i am not saying mark hollis ever did heroin, but the song could be about his brother. again, this is me speculating.
ConnieXX 4 years ago
THis song haunted me back in the early nineties... still does... that organ at 02:50 blows me away...... every time....
gerryhoey 4 years ago
Utterly gorgeous, yeah. I believe the organ's a bit of a nod to Bowie's wonderful, hymnlike "Word on a Wing", just as the Velvet Underground's "Heroin" is referenced on "Eden". _Spirit of Eden_ is a record which makes you hear in a new way....
markdcarter 4 years ago
BEAUTIFULL SONG
johnstonutd 4 years ago
Can I say this is the most beautiful single ever?
auranoctis 4 years ago
Yes i think you can... Sublime...
buchd151a 4 years ago
Eat your heart out Radiohead a.o.!! Such a beautiful song, the bass dropping in at 1.45.... Chillsszzzzz!
Pettenderk 4 years ago 2
Yeaaaah that deep mexican bass, gave me the chills when I first heard the single back in '88, and still does ^^
BillyBird 4 years ago
Comment removed
mcampeau11 1 year ago
@BillyBird Thanks for the info...always wondered about that spot in the song. So that would be Simon Edwards playing?
mcampeau11 1 year ago
@mcampeau11 yes I think it's safe to assume Edwards did it.
BillyBird 1 year ago
@BillyBird Hope it wasn't an obvious question...don't know what a Mexican Bass is!! Just credit where it's due, that's all. And that part after the first chorus has always hit a resonant frequency with me, and a lot of other people, it seems, too.
But, there's a point where you can deconstruct a song into dust though, eh? Not trying to do that.
Thanks
mcampeau11 1 year ago
Ik wordt er gelukkig van om te zien dat er nog meer mensen zijn die nog weten wat echte muziek is/was. Het wachten is nog op een goede audiofiele DVD van meneer Hollis en Co..
IguanART 4 years ago
wonderful stuff
sengland70 4 years ago
WOOWW!! Finally some live from the greatest record EVER (Spirit Of Eden)
auranoctis 4 years ago
geez long story mate, try and find some online ressources.
Btw I don't think they've split up officially :)
BillyBird 4 years ago
does anybody know why they stopped and got separated?
bluechristophe 4 years ago
Look for his solo album 'Marc Hollis' - utterly beautiful... Nothing since tho... Alas.
buchd151a 4 years ago
I also taped a blooper interview they tried to do before they recorded this one (the one that the girl in the start of the song is telling about)but never seen that one online yet...
appeboy 4 years ago
Hmmm... I never got credit for taping this vid... but still it is fasinating that stuff ends up on the net... :)
appeboy 4 years ago
Brilliant!!!
georgenorthwood 4 years ago
I dunno about that. I guess he did this for the record company, but if you look at the actual video released with 'I Believe in You', it's very well executed. First verse, he looks like he's on heroin, nodding off. Second verse, he looks like he's castigating the heroin addict. And then, for the 'Spirit, how long' section at the end, he appears to have shaken off the shackles of the drug to find personal redemption. Either way you look at it, it's such a class song.
atmos111 4 years ago
I have a feeling that MH's closed eyes and withdrawn manner are emotional statements. If you watch his stuff you can see how his shyness or withdrawn tendencies progress through the years. Originally he's OK, then he starts to look up allot from looking down, then it's the ever-present sunglasses to avoidance of the world in general.
stefan103 4 years ago
This is my favourite bassist who's reduced to accompanying dull stuff.
mfcexpert 4 years ago
he had a guitard but he didn't use it.
toorlooo 4 years ago
that's cuz the song is being mimed, not actually played live
dozytwatcockface 4 years ago
I know so it's like in the videoclip, a guitar for nothing.
In the song, the guitar is robbie mcintosh but not Mark Hollis.
Still my favourite song.
toorlooo 4 years ago
In the song, the guitar is played by Mark Hollis not Robbie McIntosh (a session musician who played 12 string guitar)
dozytwatcockface 4 years ago
Really?
Mark play great music with his guitar.
PS:Note: You can see the same guitar on ''Why is it so hard'' IOTV show
toorlooo 4 years ago
Superb!
Baxtercycling 4 years ago
why are we sure that it's lipsynced?
pterygota 5 years ago
It's not so difficult to make the difference between live and recording versions. It is exactly the same version that the one on the album. The last Talk Talk's albums were impossible to reproduce in live. They were based on improvisation and re-build in song format.
adrianborland 4 years ago
impossible?
pterygota 4 years ago
When an artist has the focus on an idea, there's nothing to make change his mind. And when Mark Hollis says : " Talk Talk is over ", believe him ( even everyone here wants a comeback ). Talk Talk never performed the last two albums live. Was it fear to make wrong ? Perfection is hard to reproduce. Mark Hollis was tired of Show-biz.
adrianborland 4 years ago
Are you not an actual person? There's a certain lack of logical flow to your writing. Or maybe english is a second language for you?
pterygota 4 years ago
I'm not an actual person.
adrianborland 4 years ago
I just love this band!
nakanda 5 years ago
i realize, considering the rest of the music on their last two albums, that this is the best choice for a "live" performance, but still not exactly something one would expect to be played on stage. Nonetheless, one of my all-time favorite tunes by any band, ever. Those last two albums were masterpieces.
jeepinlizards 5 years ago
That was easily the most moved I've ever been by a lip-synched TV performance. Mark Hollis and Talk Talk are incredible.
tenracsha 5 years ago
Nope he only did 1 solo album, simply called "Mark Hollis" in 1998. He did do the odd obscure collaboration here and then since then, but has practically vanished from the music biz (and the music world in general)
BillyBird 5 years ago
A beautiful song and video. So mark hollis did 2 solo albums, the latest in 1998, and disappeared?
supermaho 5 years ago
yes they are
BillyBird 5 years ago
quite a new discovery for me, but wow, these guys are serious. brilliant.
andya32 5 years ago
Yeah well oogenesis, the last TT album was 1991, and he did one solo album in 1998. Nothing since...
BillyBird 5 years ago
um, raverill, he's still making music, though solo now...much in the same vein as this, though much less synth-driven.
oogenesis 5 years ago
i love this song. makes me think of xmas for some reason. thanks for posting!
jejelad 5 years ago
Such a great thing to see Talk Talk again. Outstanding!
Thanks BillyBird!
srecko666 5 years ago
Eyes wide shut all the song, did he really want to be on stage ?
I'm not sure. It's not a disco show, that's true. Thanks for this document.
adrianborland 5 years ago
I guess this is the closest they ever got to a live performance of any of the songs off the last two albums.. pity. Still great to see it. I don't think Mark Hollis is a drug user, he just got sick of the music business and retreated into privacy. Such a shame, it'd be so interesting to see what sort of music he'd be making now.
raverill 5 years ago
Im pretty sure Hollis took Heroin and faded away. How else can you explain the cover on his solo album? :)
EsromFF 5 years ago
"I Have Seen Heroin For Myself" is a pretty good hint to why they did not tour the last two albums. Did you hear his solo lp? Heavy mother that one..... wOw
EsromFF 5 years ago
Nah actually u're in the wrong there, pal. Hollis couldn't see the point in going on the road trying to reproduce what had taken them so long to craft in the studio.
Actually the heroin bit is about his brother Ed, who died then in the late 80's.
BillyBird 5 years ago
Great "live" clip !
EsromFF 5 years ago
Superb, this sheer brilliance even though it is mimed, it is stillfrom the heart. Does anyone know how to save vids from this site? to save into a folder or somewhere other than favourites.
porca41 5 years ago
Yeah you you can download a plugin for firefox at mediapirate en to play it download riva flvplayer
industrialbirds 4 years ago
Thanks..
theporca 4 years ago
yeah indeed he hated it, hence no tour for Spirit of Eden and Laughing Stock. I even wonder how they convinced him to take part in that tv show.
As for being underrated, I'm not sure. Maybe sales went a downward spiral with each album, but the critics always had praise, and the music world don't forget how influential they still are to many artists/bands.
BillyBird 5 years ago
That was typical Mark Hollis. He hated all the crap that went with it, all he wanted to do was make music. The guy was close on genius in some respects tho, and TT were so underrated it's unfair....
JJ62 5 years ago 2
EXCELLENT upload, thank you! It's a shame it's lipsynched, but what are ya gonna do? Beautiful song.
rinfy 5 years ago
Yeah great song. It's funny how u can see how bored/not wanting to be there Mark is.
BillyBird 5 years ago
Yeah, he pretty much stares at the floor the whole time. And you have to wonder why he's holding a guitar, since he never touches it. Brilliant.
rinfy 5 years ago 2
Also notice how he doesn't even care to sing into the microphone, which is not pointed towards his mouth :-D
BillyBird 5 years ago