Holy shit, this is amazing. Makes me wish i had learnt violin instead of guitar =/ Its such a beautiful instrument, you guys played this VERY well. Props.
@brophythebest20 Worst game? Go to Halo fest and say that, Why does CoD no have a convention, because it's a shitty war based game with no real story behind it, just the multiplayer, Halo has games, books and comics shaping the universe it's in, Halo is a better made game, no better made franchise, no better made universe than CoD can ever hope to be, now shove your type 95 up in your ass and pull the trigger.
@ryakoasakora actually COD is based on the wars we have had in the united states and in other countries you moron. you wouldnt know becuase your obviousley a lame halo fan!
@brophythebest20 Now now kiddo, wars isn't like they seem in CoD, you should know that by now. And the problem with CoD is that it's poorly made, the developers doesn't even put any time into making it anymore. It's all just the same over and over again.
@brophythebest20 Wake up, idiot. You're on a halo video, and any arguement you provide about CoD being better will be proved invalid. Captain Price, or whoever the FUCK he is, can go suck Alex Mason's half-inch dick. And that's my tirade.
@brophythebest20 Hah! Worst game? Look at CoD. The developers don't even put much effort in to their game anyway. Unlike Bungie who looks out for their community. And Halo pretty much made the fps genre.
@brophythebest20 I'm sorry, Did you just say Halo sucks and CoD is better. MY GOD!!! when will CoD fans realize without Halo, Cod wouldn't be here! So to all COD FANS, STOP HATING HALO!!!! and on a side note, Cod Games are the same thing every freaking year, where is the time an effort?
@brophythebest20 why is halo bad? is it because there are no noob tubes, oh I'm sorry: "pr0 p1pes." is it because it takes skill to play well and not just sit in a corner screaming at your mom to bring you chocolate milk? or maybe it's the fact that the story is more in depth than having a bunch special forces try to hunt down a terrorist leader. how original.
@BENDOVER9810 Personally I hate both, so I have no real opinion on both. I rarely play both. But in Halo 1/4 of the fights end in both of you beating each other down at the same time. But that was the last time I played a Halo game (Halo 3). While in CoD there are plenty of hiding spots in the map, and plenty of 'noob tubes.' But personally I think there are plenty more games that are better than both of them.
@12Profet they dont have to be full time on their instruments but if they practiced for a couple yrs or more or something they could make it really good or did that not ring a bell for you?
@nicamy8988 yea i know that but you type in with an attitude of a full pledged composer,which is instead of congratulating you said do this or practiced more, and that is why i get upset
@12Profet wtf? what type of composer says not bad but if you practiced more it would have been awesome? i dont think ive ever heard a composer even say the word awesome so dont give me that bullshit it is called constructive criticism get over it dude i said it was wasnt bad but even pros need practice to get better fuck simple comment not a big deal
@nicamy8988 holy shit your very fucking right huh? get over it lol you are the one who put the "not a big deal" comment lol. You knew very well that there is going to be a person that is going to be making a big fucking deal of it. Now instead of your constructive criticism you can put Well Done Guys, instead of Well Done but you need practice cause that its been kind of asshole, due to saying is good(they get happy)but you need to practice more(kind of kill tripper right there)
@12Profet i didnt say it was shit and never play it or they sucked or anything remotely like that did i? there are plenty of OTHER people on here who have i dont see you going off at them? so you pick me who said they did ok but if they practiced more (i assumed they only practiced for a few months at most on the specific songs & have been playing for a bit longer) they would be awesome it really ISNT a big deal until you opened your stupid mouth & started an issue where there was none! fuck off
@12Profet well it wasnt 'well done' it was not bad and thats what i fucking said moron. wow if you think thats being an ass hole then you are a sheltered child. i only said they need to practice more if they want to be awesome isnt that what i said lets see here hmm yep thats what i said so get your shit right before calling me an ass hole you fucking retard!!
@nicamy8988 hold on hold hold on,holy shit, you lost me which one goes first,comments, Ok I understand your point that of argument that you did not said it sucks,which I agree, but I'm going that you should have congratulated them, for them practicing and practicing up to the point of covering a halo song in a talent show. Which takes time,which they needed to find the right instruments and so on. Then I was looking at your comment and saying "Really,Really?" "Come On"?
@12Profet we shouldnt congratulate someone if they didnt mark up to our standards sure they were great for some and shit for others for me they were not bad but all i meant was if they wanted to be awesome they should practice more i meant it if they even wanted to this might just be for the talent show or what ever and thats it maybe the group broke after this i dont know it was a suggestion really. where did i say "really really" "come on"?
wooooooow, 1 of 2 things first the crappy comments above r the same. 2. woooooow these people are good that was a awesome job they did that was great!!!
@br33dHATE You are stupid, unless I am wrong here I don't think CoD released 4 games in 2007 considering CoD 4 was released near the same time as Halo 3.
@spaerton117 I'm a casual cod player, used to play it alot when the 1st Modern Warfare came out, then stopped after 2, Still play Halo to death and other great multiplayer games like Assassin's Creed, BF3, L4D2, Red Dead Redemption, and more. I love games with unique gaming experiances and cod's lost its uniqueness with it's back-to-back games that don't change anything gameplay wise. I wish they'd go back to what made it fun and unique.
When every single comment is a response to someone else, you know you've reached the troll part of youtube.
ApprenticeJim 10 hours ago
I take it you won? Either that or everyone's faces had melted as a result of an overload of sheer awesomeness?
ThatBoyIsAnOxtonHero 2 days ago
Are you guys godsend? 'Cause if there's Halo in heaven, I'm jumping off a bridge.
ShadedFall65 2 days ago in playlist Favorite videos
@brophythebest20 what do you mean cod is based on real wars we've had?! uhm haha all call of duty games these days are based on future wars....
JMAN7880 3 days ago
Good job
ForgeMaps101 5 days ago
i voted down brophythebest20's comment, lets all do the same.
Dodge99ist 1 week ago
@brophythebest20 Bro, cod is shit in a box full of herpes. In a landfill. Play something actually good, like Amnesia.
physcogone 1 week ago
Fuck halo hahahahahahahahahahahah go suck cock
21Lunyy 1 week ago
Y'all should check out my vids
jcoschino89 2 weeks ago in playlist Liked videos
Super halo brothers ^_^
M134FANATIC 2 weeks ago
Dat violinest
Number1buttkicker 2 weeks ago
iban perfectamente bien y la tenian que cagar con mario bros
edmadaiosamaachu 2 weeks ago
im suprised a school could have that good of a guitar player
MrXZoRk 2 weeks ago
Holy shit, this is amazing. Makes me wish i had learnt violin instead of guitar =/ Its such a beautiful instrument, you guys played this VERY well. Props.
MichaelLozano12 2 weeks ago
whoever says that COD is better than halo you have problems mate sorry to break it to you. I think you should see a doctor
xXShadow04 2 weeks ago
you people are what makes the halo universe
TheMoodykiller118 3 weeks ago
i love the violin <3
cjhrjone54 3 weeks ago
@KaiserReich when this was made, it was before Reach (look at the release date)
ch13ft1mur 3 weeks ago
it is cool
1followerhalo 3 weeks ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
even though i like the music fuck the game ima COD player all day every day fuck halo! worst game made!
brophythebest20 3 weeks ago
@brophythebest20
Really? Halo practically Made the Multiplayer for all the games in 2001, have some respect for your elders.
MrKiloNation 3 weeks ago 29
@MrKiloNation this has nothing to do with respect.
brophythebest20 2 weeks ago
@brophythebest20
Then why do you think COD is better than Halo?
MrKiloNation 2 weeks ago
@MrKiloNation Im not sure what he said to you , but TBH I think if any game it would be counter strike to be considered the first type of game
geoffy0404 3 days ago
@brophythebest20 Worst game? Go to Halo fest and say that, Why does CoD no have a convention, because it's a shitty war based game with no real story behind it, just the multiplayer, Halo has games, books and comics shaping the universe it's in, Halo is a better made game, no better made franchise, no better made universe than CoD can ever hope to be, now shove your type 95 up in your ass and pull the trigger.
ryakoasakora 3 weeks ago
@ryakoasakora actually COD is based on the wars we have had in the united states and in other countries you moron. you wouldnt know becuase your obviousley a lame halo fan!
brophythebest20 3 weeks ago
@brophythebest20 Retarded 12 year old, every modern shooter comes from halo, and halo comes from quake. Idiot.
Drodriz 2 weeks ago
@Drodriz haha retarted 12 year old im not 12 im an adult.
brophythebest20 2 weeks ago
@Drodriz BUT! it all started with wolfenstein and doom. (probably
TerranWTF 2 weeks ago
@Drodriz accidently pressed enter, I ment to write (probably spelt wolfenstein wrong)
TerranWTF 2 weeks ago
@brophythebest20 Now now kiddo, wars isn't like they seem in CoD, you should know that by now. And the problem with CoD is that it's poorly made, the developers doesn't even put any time into making it anymore. It's all just the same over and over again.
TerranWTF 2 weeks ago
@brophythebest20 Wake up, idiot. You're on a halo video, and any arguement you provide about CoD being better will be proved invalid. Captain Price, or whoever the FUCK he is, can go suck Alex Mason's half-inch dick. And that's my tirade.
ShadedFall65 2 weeks ago
@ShadedFall65
For a moment there, I was thinking Alec Mason from Red Faction
TheCloven 1 week ago
@brophythebest20 rofl, you mad that your gsme is dieing lol
N00bSlayer343 2 weeks ago
@brophythebest20 lol.. this guy is an ignorant moron
xXxMangenkyo 2 weeks ago
@brophythebest20 Hah! Worst game? Look at CoD. The developers don't even put much effort in to their game anyway. Unlike Bungie who looks out for their community. And Halo pretty much made the fps genre.
IAmJeenyuss 1 week ago
@IAmJeenyuss ya no.... that would be wolfenstine
MYSOULOFDOOM 1 week ago
@brophythebest20 I'm sorry, Did you just say Halo sucks and CoD is better. MY GOD!!! when will CoD fans realize without Halo, Cod wouldn't be here! So to all COD FANS, STOP HATING HALO!!!! and on a side note, Cod Games are the same thing every freaking year, where is the time an effort?
TheHybridRebel 1 week ago 12
@TheHybridRebel Amen
frog1599 4 days ago
@TheHybridRebel lol to bad all the halo changes make it worse each year
MrGrumpymeat 2 days ago
@brophythebest20 why is halo bad? is it because there are no noob tubes, oh I'm sorry: "pr0 p1pes." is it because it takes skill to play well and not just sit in a corner screaming at your mom to bring you chocolate milk? or maybe it's the fact that the story is more in depth than having a bunch special forces try to hunt down a terrorist leader. how original.
BENDOVER9810 2 days ago
@BENDOVER9810 Personally I hate both, so I have no real opinion on both. I rarely play both. But in Halo 1/4 of the fights end in both of you beating each other down at the same time. But that was the last time I played a Halo game (Halo 3). While in CoD there are plenty of hiding spots in the map, and plenty of 'noob tubes.' But personally I think there are plenty more games that are better than both of them.
devil55122 1 day ago in playlist Favorite videos
The absolute only thing that could make this better is if they had John-117 on the guitar for a Reach shredding solo.
Or all the Spartan III's making up the rest of the group.
KaiserReich 3 weeks ago
OMFBEZUS u guys friggin rock that place especially Hanna you go girl!!!
meeziebaby101 3 weeks ago
HALO SUCKS JUSTIN BERBER IS BETTER
now i have your attention HALO RULES THE WORLD
mikeland021 4 weeks ago 5
@mikeland021 thank god that was a joke (i mean, about justin gayber)
xXxMangenkyo 2 weeks ago
MEH, ITS OK BUT THE REAL HALO THEME IS 5X AS GOOD. NOT GONA DISLIKE BUT NOT GONA LIKE EITHER...
poopinyoumouth 4 weeks ago 2
727 people were cod fans
halonut96 4 weeks ago
LOL strait from mario to halo
qboots00 1 month ago
I wish my Highschool was cool. :(
Acapnos 1 month ago
giving me goosebumps :D OF AWSOMENES!!!!!!
RivanOmega 1 month ago
way to go ya'll
evildemonoffire666 1 month ago
@SL3APYH3AD11 No. About 5 times.....
lethimguideme 1 month ago
Idk why.... but they kinda remind me of the Blue Man Group lol
TheExplosiveEffect 1 month ago
Violin girl = win:)
redbob13 1 month ago
Was i the only one that got goosebumps?
SL3APYH3AD11 1 month ago 2
@SL3APYH3AD11 nope, same here
halonut96 4 weeks ago
you guys should go on America's got talent, I'd love to see the crowd's reaction of that caliber, simply awesome.
Eternaldarkness3166 1 month ago
@nicamy and 12Profet Shut the hell up, both of you, no one gives 2 shits, they did what they could and they did it pretty well
MrRagingScot 1 month ago
I hate people who write paragraphs for comments.
xpplayax95 1 month ago 3
to make it more epic they shouldve worn master chief suits thumbs up if you think so
ps2man38 1 month ago
these vids make me feel talentless XD
killerluuk 1 month ago
this is so insanely awesome. i dont even like halo
legi0n715 1 month ago
@legi0n715 you don't have to like halo, you just have to love music.
theS3Vtimentals 1 month ago
it doesnt matter how bad or good you are, if you show your talent for halo then youre cool
brandope28 1 month ago
I LOVE THESE GUYS ALREADY!!
brandope28 1 month ago
not bad for what you did but if you had more practice it would have been awesome
nicamy8988 1 month ago
@nicamy8988 yea and the fact that they are still in high school doesnt ring a bell?they cant be fulltime on their instruments,
12Profet 1 month ago
@12Profet they dont have to be full time on their instruments but if they practiced for a couple yrs or more or something they could make it really good or did that not ring a bell for you?
nicamy8988 1 month ago
@nicamy8988 yea i know that but you type in with an attitude of a full pledged composer,which is instead of congratulating you said do this or practiced more, and that is why i get upset
12Profet 1 month ago
@12Profet wtf? what type of composer says not bad but if you practiced more it would have been awesome? i dont think ive ever heard a composer even say the word awesome so dont give me that bullshit it is called constructive criticism get over it dude i said it was wasnt bad but even pros need practice to get better fuck simple comment not a big deal
nicamy8988 1 month ago
@nicamy8988 holy shit your very fucking right huh? get over it lol you are the one who put the "not a big deal" comment lol. You knew very well that there is going to be a person that is going to be making a big fucking deal of it. Now instead of your constructive criticism you can put Well Done Guys, instead of Well Done but you need practice cause that its been kind of asshole, due to saying is good(they get happy)but you need to practice more(kind of kill tripper right there)
12Profet 1 month ago
@12Profet i didnt say it was shit and never play it or they sucked or anything remotely like that did i? there are plenty of OTHER people on here who have i dont see you going off at them? so you pick me who said they did ok but if they practiced more (i assumed they only practiced for a few months at most on the specific songs & have been playing for a bit longer) they would be awesome it really ISNT a big deal until you opened your stupid mouth & started an issue where there was none! fuck off
nicamy8988 1 month ago
@12Profet well it wasnt 'well done' it was not bad and thats what i fucking said moron. wow if you think thats being an ass hole then you are a sheltered child. i only said they need to practice more if they want to be awesome isnt that what i said lets see here hmm yep thats what i said so get your shit right before calling me an ass hole you fucking retard!!
nicamy8988 1 month ago
@nicamy8988 hold on hold hold on,holy shit, you lost me which one goes first,comments, Ok I understand your point that of argument that you did not said it sucks,which I agree, but I'm going that you should have congratulated them, for them practicing and practicing up to the point of covering a halo song in a talent show. Which takes time,which they needed to find the right instruments and so on. Then I was looking at your comment and saying "Really,Really?" "Come On"?
12Profet 1 month ago
@12Profet we shouldnt congratulate someone if they didnt mark up to our standards sure they were great for some and shit for others for me they were not bad but all i meant was if they wanted to be awesome they should practice more i meant it if they even wanted to this might just be for the talent show or what ever and thats it maybe the group broke after this i dont know it was a suggestion really. where did i say "really really" "come on"?
nicamy8988 1 month ago
@nicamy8988 That is the reason for me Making such a Fucking Big Deal about and "squeezing"the subject for more to talk to.
12Profet 1 month ago
Good god what kind of school is this! I didnt know they pumped millions into the lighting and sound these days
Runintotheshadows 1 month ago 25
@Runintotheshadows
I know right?
My School had a par can and an 8mm projector that liked to burn through tapes and get stuck alot.....
xeronicus 1 week ago
I don't believe this is a talent show..
SNWxGaming 1 month ago
@SNWxGaming it is, i was there...lhs brews talented people...example tom morello, marlon brando, mc chris...
golfpapabravo06 1 month ago
that was fucking awesome
Xdizzle2000 1 month ago
Guys... this... is... fucking AWESOME... I WANT TO KISS YOU ALL ON THE LIPS FOR A FULL MINUTE!!!!! (No homosecual
IPWNFORCHEESE 1 month ago
Fake, This is the E3 Convention, Noob.
LeftForTheAngels 1 month ago
Holy crap, Pductions! You're right! Those are totally Blue Man tubes!
superhoboman99 1 month ago
I take it u guys won
abcdefg12435 1 month ago
Beast
abcdefg12435 1 month ago
I used to be able to play like that, but then I took an arrow to the knee.
Mai3173 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
since posting the same thing worked three times...... i'd hate the people coming up next
popguck 1 month ago
is that kid in the back playing on the blue man tubes?
Pductions 1 month ago
Pretty good, a little off but maybe thats just the terrible sound quality of this video. Violin sounds a bit too overwhelming.
Ryhnhart 1 month ago
I think they need a lesson on keeping steady tempo....poor form guys poor form.
TheNotKyleSullivan 1 month ago
wooooooow, 1 of 2 things first the crappy comments above r the same. 2. woooooow these people are good that was a awesome job they did that was great!!!
luke00224488 1 month ago
if they didn't win its because the judges were cod players :P
DonutFun360 1 month ago 123
Comment removed
SuperNukeboy 1 month ago
@SuperNukeboy tell it as it is lmao XD
DroppinMahQuarter 1 month ago
@SuperNukeboy calm down dear its only a commercial
AzelfTheWill 1 month ago
@DonutFun360 And PS3 Playars...
XxBentot06xX 1 month ago
@DonutFun360 but the sound isn't really strong enough
WLBrianW 1 month ago
@DonutFun360 You are stupid. Cod wasn't even released yet in 2006. Therefore none of the judges could have been Cod players.
br33dHATE 1 month ago
@br33dHATE You are stupid, unless I am wrong here I don't think CoD released 4 games in 2007 considering CoD 4 was released near the same time as Halo 3.
tmxboxburn 1 month ago
@br33dHATE I don't think I've ever face-palmed so hard in my entire life.
cornchop5000 1 month ago
@br33dHATE The only good COD games were the ones on PC before 2005.
SigandGibbs 1 month ago
@SigandGibbs cod4 was good stfu <3
xFoKe 1 month ago
@xFoKe CoD4 was ok, nothing special though
SigandGibbs 1 month ago
@br33dHATE Your stupid. CoD has been out since 2003.
meter7000 1 month ago
@br33dHATE *facepalm* dumbass ><
freedomfighter5000 1 month ago in playlist halo talent
@DonutFun360 this was made before cod was even a big thing.
fergernator 1 month ago
@DonutFun360 ps3*
xPlowsi 1 month ago
mario cheif ??
dino2stepx2 2 months ago
wow i hope you guys won
sanitybreedssorrow 2 months ago
first 30 seconds and was already impressed! Great job!
iSteven51 2 months ago
this sucked
manjam720 2 months ago
@manjam720 screw you
alkapwnz1 2 months ago
@manjam720 so did your mum
QuestionableVids 2 months ago
i like how the 2 top coments are exactly the same, by exactly the same person.
TheKittyGamer 2 months ago
You guys rocked!
skillian09 2 months ago
I'd hate to be the people who play after them....
mattjf09 2 months ago
if they didnt get first place someones getting bitch slapped
TheRedvsbluefan117 2 months ago 13
cooooooool
mindlesscontroll 2 months ago
How does the Mario theme connect to the Halo theme? Ah who cares it awsome.
bezerk47 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'd hate to be the people coming up next......
MoAoX 2 months ago
Do you honestly want me to believe this? This is the E3 performance!
GoneLego 2 months ago
@GoneLego i remember someone saying that these guys did that too.
28crazyguy 2 months ago
Where the fuck did highschoolers get all those instruments??
rokkakubeatJet 2 months ago
since posting the same thing worked twice...... i'd hate the people coming up next
voom41 2 months ago 33
@voom41
oliverrocks158 1 month ago
Flawless Victory!
AgonyXIII 2 months ago
it would be very difficult to beat them that is for sure
Igniter100 2 months ago
id hate to be the person coming up NEXT.
BigFootTr4cker 2 months ago
Anyone notice the fool in the red with the mic at the end dancing?
wakeboarder199 2 months ago
WTF, look at the top comments.
BushismsLoL 2 months ago
WTF!!!! WTH!!!! MOMMY,???? WHY ARE THERE 2 OF THE SAME COMMENTS FORM THE SAME GUY?!!... uggghhh caps.. -_-
minicus360 2 months ago
WTH! the same guy has the top 2 comments?... baahh.
jasont2211 2 months ago
Wait, are these the same guys that performed at E3 for the Halo 3 debut?
GreatWhiteGibby 2 months ago
And up next we have the flautist Shane Thompson with his thrilling interpretation of Three Blind Mice.
GreatWhiteGibby 2 months ago
Badass :D
flavor101013 2 months ago
did you guys win the talent show?
WeasleTiger6 2 months ago
random mario
C00kieMonsterGaming 2 months ago
724 people don't have speakers.
WTFDEUTSCH 2 months ago
LOL! the mario song at the end was uncalled for xD
thedragonslayer117 2 months ago
I would assume you guys won the talent show
jtolson11 2 months ago
I wish this had happened at my school...
TehEon 2 months ago
4real that violin killed it hard as fuck..... they all went HAM!!!!!this is some sick shit!!!
Gmanshuckamuck 2 months ago
hvj
MsInreality12 2 months ago
Next morning, they woke up with bitchs
Jumpstylenumbahone 2 months ago 6
two plasma grenades would take care of all that shit.
mortemdrummer 2 months ago
is your high school the circus do le
wutsgoodnukka 2 months ago
this... is... AMAAAAAAAZING!!! >:O but i feel like the violinist just took over xD oh yeah, and what's a PVC?
alboix56 2 months ago
@alboix56 its a type of pipe, you know pvc pipe its the wierd contraption in the backround thats white
bunnylover224 2 months ago
this is epic
Metroidepic 2 months ago
That was amazing!
spartanelete 2 months ago
only thing to say .. amazing
RiZeDESTINY 2 months ago
wait...blue man group?
cruton88 2 months ago
haha violinist ruled them all
napinator121292 2 months ago
i wish i did that at my school talent contest..
tumbleweed459 2 months ago
that violinist is very talented
Bothumus 2 months ago 2
why did this scare me? because my balls fell off my body
LWKconnor 2 months ago
wtf apprentice09M
spaerton117 2 months ago
Kokuyous3ki
you r the only cod player so far that likes halo you know that
spaerton117 2 months ago
@spaerton117 I'm a casual cod player, used to play it alot when the 1st Modern Warfare came out, then stopped after 2, Still play Halo to death and other great multiplayer games like Assassin's Creed, BF3, L4D2, Red Dead Redemption, and more. I love games with unique gaming experiances and cod's lost its uniqueness with it's back-to-back games that don't change anything gameplay wise. I wish they'd go back to what made it fun and unique.
NinjaTyler 2 months ago
@spaerton117 nah i like bf halo and cod and gears theyre all great
OneShotLegendz 2 months ago
epic playing i thought that was awsome and that mario twist was cool
darkfairy11497 2 months ago
Haha, I remember when I found this video years ago, it's as epic as I remember.
BulletCatcher123 2 months ago
240p...we meet again
jjjjj92 2 months ago
Not bad! Violin = pretty good
MrLeonator100 2 months ago
Comment removed
milesozuna 2 months ago
@tehsuperSPECTRE
I did, so I know a FAILED attempt at mixing orchestra music with rock music when I see one.
Wurmo 2 months ago
i love HAlo AWsome job u guys
MagicalThunderWolf 2 months ago
stupid audience didn't recognize it
jungleman68 2 months ago
You are awsome!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Nice job.
LEGOBoy922 2 months ago 2
This is amazing. <3
AlaottCovers 2 months ago
3:04 is amazing
huntercra 2 months ago
720 PEOPLE WANTED 720p
HALO HALO HALO HALO HALO HALO HALO HALO HALO HALO HALO HALO HALO
HALO
Gamedude131 2 months ago