I like Edward in full CGI because it seems to bring out his personality and character more. same for James. The rest, I think were better off without CGI. Just my thoughts
@TheThomastank1 Average, awful and REALLY average. GOOD Edward and Thomas episodes are Old Iron, Edward's Exploit, Thomas and Gordon, Thomas, Percy and the Post Train, Thomas, Percy and the Post Train, Edward the Great, Wrong Road. ANY episode from S13 onwards can NEVER be considered as good episodes involving Thomas and Edward.
Stop That Bus - was only good because of Bertie, but was basically a re-write of Thomas and Skarloey's Big Day Out
Stuck On You - Overrated. It may see Butch speaking for the first time in 13 years, but it followed the same formula as the rest, and a lot of it was illogical.
Tree Trouble - He was just selfish because he wanted the limelight that the Diesels got.
@TheThomastank1 Why, should I have done? I haven't bullied you, I've just told you my opinions. Not really my fault we don't agree on a lot of things.
@TheThomastank1 So you're seriously telling me that a railway is the perfect environment to have fun?! Seriously, am I the only one to live in the real world and realise that railways are some of the most dangerous working environments in the world?! While I agree with that phrase, there is a time and a place for fun and frolics, and railways are not places to have fun, not in a million years.
This one was alright but still improvements could be made. Edward's character is rather poor here and he HAS been the hero many times, in Edward and Gordon, Old Iron, Edward's Exploit and Edward the Very Useful Engine.
@roloboy97 A TV show watched by CHILDREN that teaches - or at least SHOULD teach - them IMPORTANT LIFE LESSONS! Series 15, in fact MANY recent episodes, DO NOT do this.
I'm not going to even try and explain anymore. It's clear that all you care about is the visual shiny shiny, and it is absolutely dosgusting and, more importantly, disheartening that those who actually want to make a difference are a part of a fanbase consisting of fickle people like you that will accept ANYTHING...
@roloboy97 Try telling that to the Awdrys. EVERY situation an engine was put in was inspired from a real life event. To them, Thomas was like the Rev Awdry's imaginary son, and it was a book series that children could LEARN from.
I also laugh at your swearing. What's the matter? Can't take the fact that someone can see this series for what it TRULY is? Or is it just because I insinuated that you were fickle? Seriously, grow up. I'm not the only one who feels this way.
@roloboy97 No, that's what I know. The plots are worse than they have ever been and THAT makes a good series? If Thomas and Friends is so good, why has the head writer quit? Why are so many fans - mainly the ones who actually HAVE a brain - angry with what we're seeing. And the third thing, why is this series not winning awards? One answer: IT'S CRAP! The only good thing is the voice acting and the CGI itself.
@roloboy97 How is pointing out facts trying to change your mind? You give me ONE GOOD REASON why these poor excuses for episodes are good and I'll say no more about it (without mentioning the animation).
@ThomasPercyandToby2 well i like the voicing and the new engines like CHARLIE i dont care if u dont like him cos u say he dont do any work and can only be bothered to have fun
@roloboy97 I said a GOOD reason. Charlie is the worst character in the history of television, let alone Thomas the Tank Engine and Friends. Railways are dangerous environments and to have a character like him is sending out dangerous messages to children. Or does that not bother you?
@ThomasPercyandToby2 not realy why should it i dont have kids and i think kids are smart to keep of railway tracks and its not real get again i tell you its a show and i dont care how much u hate charlie i actully think he is a great engine sure HiT does have some down side like not realy showing donald and douglas and duck and oliver and stepney oh well they have better engines now like hiro and victor and CHARLIE and whiff ETC but i will miss D&D and oliver and duck and stepney
@roloboy97 I'm sorry, I had to re-read that to believe what I was seeing. Charlie better than those five? HAHAHA, you don't half crack me up... Charlie is a disgrace, and I'm appalled that you think that kids think things are safe when crap like this is written for them. As well as parents, kids learn from what they see on television and if they SEE something dangerous happening, nine times out of ten they'll want to do it.
@ThomasPercyandToby2 sure sure kids learn alot from TV thats why there is lots of sex drug and violence and u ever seen a 4 year olr robbing a bank ? no and you ever seend a 3 years old shoot some1 ? no
@roloboy97 Do you ever see those things on kids TV? No, you doofus! If you're gonna put a convincing argument over on me, you're gonna HAVE to more kids TV research...
1. We're talking about toddlers here, I highly doubt they know what a television remote does and how it works.
2. It is a PARENT'S responsibility to keep their children safe, NOT the child's. Kids will watch whatever Thomas is in because... it's Thomas. Only a select few know that something's wrong, the rest semingly rely on these things to show them right from wrong, which NONE of these episodes do.
@ThomasPercyandToby2 1 i have no idea wat ur twatting on about and i dont care i watch the tv show i enjoy it i dont give a rats ass wat u think off it end off
@roloboy97 Of course you don't know what I'm on about, you're too stupid to understand. Wouldn't surprise me if you were under 13... Here's a little tip: go to school and actually LEARN something. It's OBVIOUS to me that you haven't...
@ThomasPercyandToby2 well do excuse me, is it me or do u think ur a smartass get ur fucking head out ur fat ass cos it looks to me u spent all your time sitting it on ur computer chair try to find facts wat will upset me and let me tell u its not working if u want to find out somting there is a big wide world out side go out side and have a look cos it seems to me u spend all ur time sitting on ur computer chair and have u even seen day light or are you to much of a fat ass to have a look?
@roloboy97 Resorting to swearing again? What immaturity. Unlike you, I KNOW what I am talking about, because I actually went to SCHOOL and I READ the Railway Series, two things you've never done. Also, FYI, I am a college student currently on half term, so I DO study, I DO get out, and I actually HAVE respect for people's views, which is more than can be said for you... And before you inevitably turned it around to me (that's what morons like you do), I pointed out FACTS to you.
@ThomasPercyandToby2 ur at collage and ur arguing with a year 9 u r a little pillock and a child how old are you 16 17 im 13 and ur acting like a 8 year old grow up
@roloboy97 XD, you're a Year 9? No wonder you're so stupid :P. Kids like you should NEVER be allowed on computer as you have little or no maturity. If anyone is acting younger than their real age, look in the mirror, junior, since you're the one that's swearing like a sailor and I'm the guy who actually knows what he's talking about.
@ThomasPercyandToby2 ur in collage and ur still arguing with me ur such a little baby get a life oh and get a girl friend ur computer dont count oh and y are you at collage are you redoing ur GCSE's is it cos u failed ur last ones and u need higher marks cos mcdonalds did let u work there?
@roloboy97 Judging by your appalling spelling, your English lessons aren't working. Face it, you're only getting mad because you don't like the truth being told to you. More than likely because you're treated like a spoiled brat by your parents. I am in COLLEGE (EGE, not AGE) because I want to be an animator, something that needs HARD WORK and DETERMINATION, two things you don't have...
@ThomasPercyandToby2 well i dont care about my spelling and by hard work do you mean by looking at some fat chick and masturbating and i dont realy wanna do this any more im going to be a adult 1 and say seeya good luck arguing with more people younger then
@roloboy97 Dude, you don't even know what an adult is, considering you're the one getting angry/upset over someone pointing out facts that you can't handle. Not to mention the fact that YOU'RE the only one who's been swearing. REAL adults don't NEED to swear to make their point. Here's a little saying for you: act your age, not your shoe size.
@ThomasPercyandToby2 cheers for the shit advice bye dont want to talk to u no more ur just a person who likes bullying younger peopl ebcause u cant do it to people your own size
@roloboy97 lol, you said that in the last comment, so forgive me if I don't believe you... The thing you can't comprehend is that YOU'RE the one who turned it into a fight due to your immaturity. All I said was railways are dangerous environments and I hate Charlie :P
@ThomasPercyandToby2 good luck wid that oh and it was me who turned it into a fight ur the 1 who is talking piss outa my spelling its not my fault and ur saying im stupid ffs bye i dont want to talk to u no more
@roloboy97 Dude, have you actually SEEN your spelling? Seven year olds are better spellers than you. And YOU were the one who went ape over someone (me) hating Charlie. That was BEFORE I even mentioned your spelling. But it's usual for people like you to turn it around on those who outsmart them... And if you're not gonna talk to me again, don't bother replying, 'k?
@roloboy97 XD, I know you weren't a kid that keeps your word... As for the collEGE (not collAGE, idiot) comment, I really laughed at your immaturity. I couldn't care less if I pass or fail, I will do the best I can and have fun. And at least I'll LEARN something, which is more than you've done in, what, 8 years of school?
@ThomasPercyandToby2 GO AND FUCK UR SELF U LTTILE BASTERD U HAVE PISSED E OF SO MUCH ITS NOT MY FAULT ABOUT MY SPELL IM DYSLEXIC I WAS BORD WITH IT ALL U DO IN COLLAGE IS MASTERBATE OVER UR FAT MUM AND YES COLLAGE IS HARD IF U HAVE TO MASTERBATE OVER THAT STOP MESSAGEING ME GO FUCK UR SELF U SCET
@roloboy97 Swearing AND shouting now? What an immature, spoiled little brat you are... Dyslexia is, in your case, just a lame excuse for your downright stupidity. And if you're SO bothered about my messages, don't bother replying. It's not that difficult you moron...
@ThomasPercyandToby2 can u piss off u asterd i swearing cos im pissed off stop messageing me cos ur a bully and yes i am dyslexic ur only atalking me cos u most likely like lettle boy u pedo
@roloboy97 lol, just when I thought you couldn't get more pathetic. You're only butthurt because I think Charlie is the worst television character in history. If you have a problem with opinions, then that's YOUR problem. I'm not attacking you, you're the one attacking since YOU'RE the one that's calling people a paedo. Think about that before your next pathetic comment, junior. God your parents must be SO proud of you(!)
@ThomasPercyandToby2 its his cousin u wanna shut the fuck up about his parents cuz ur statin to piss me off if u wanna start on anyone start on me cuz im 16 hes 13 u fukin dick get a life n stop mouthing of a 13yr old cuz ur the pethetic one grow the fuk up u silly dickhead
@roloboy97 ...lol, are you quite finished? It's not my fault that he goes ape over an opinion about a fictional character. Besides, he's called me every name under the sun, but then so are you, so I can see where he gets his potty mouth from... You must literally be from a gutter family...
@roloboy97 Maturity, thy name is roloboy97 and his gutter family here, folks... First swearing, now violence? God, your parents must be proud of you, too... You are absolutely pathetic. Grow up. Your idiotic cousin should've been taught about the dangers of the internet before he created this account.
Besides, if you think which college I go to is ANYTHING to do with you lowlives, then you're even more retarded than your pathetic little cousin...
@ThomasPercyandToby2 hiya sorry to hear whats going on here , im the MOTHER ... and i must say i would be proud if you was my son.... NOT......... as you are the same age as my eldest son .... and he seems so much grown up than you .. may i ask have you been bullied in your life ?????? cause you seem to be a bit of a PRAT ... any way are leave it at that ............ so please leave my son alone !!!!!!!!!
@roloboy97 I think you should be lecturing your son about accepting other people's opinions, madam. You should also tell him that swearing doesn't make him sound ANY better. I will gladly leave your son alone, and I will apologise for any distress caused to you (and him). I am not going to bother him any more, but HE should also leave me alone and stop responding to my comments, and I shall do the same.
@ThomasPercyandToby2 it (roloboy97) and this is my last comment i dont want to talk to u any more so bye and yes i am sorry 4 swearing and i would like u to apolagise 4 taking the mick out of my spelling and talking about my family saying im from a guttler family
@roloboy97 I do, sincerely, apologise for ALL my comments about you and your family. You have every right to ay that you prefer the CGI series to the model series and you have every right to say that Charlie is your favourite character.
@TroPicTank He's been "out of character" for a long time now. Unfortunately he's been like this for so long that he you might as well say this is now the real Edward.
you know part of this is charlie is a joke train and I never seen that and he does 1 joke 1 JOKE HE IS MAD! it is not 1 joke if a kid came up late the joke would be non-re done!
Seems that HiT gave a LITTLE creative control to the makers, who know what the older show was like, and it's been advancing slightly with each season.
Of course, I don't think that every character has to be rendered in TrackMaster.
I still dislike HIT. Because I don't like kid's shows turning into pop-culture icons.
This was pretty good! Liked all the new angles, and the cameos by Arry, Bert and Salty, which reminds me- Just before Edward puffs into Knapford, look to the right and you'll see Salty.. with two 'Works' coaches! :O
Edward is my favourite out of all the engines ever sonce I watched the old series and this episode is pretty good. Sure it's like any episode HIT made but at least it shows what Edward should of been.
It's definitely better than the past for episodes, but it could have been better. All the angles were great though. That was cool to see the back of Knapford Station.
One of my fav episodes of S15 so far ^^ Im glad that Edward has his own episode again, he joke was funny and its proves that HIT is listening to us about Edward is himself again ^^
This wasn't too bad. At least there were some acknoledgements to Edward's old self. But still, it was quite bland. I wish we'd had a more exciting story.
I think this is a fantastic episode. It's a bit weird how Edward stops the way he does, and it's a bit weird that Edward would be worried about not being a hero, but all the cameos, the new angles, the plot as a whole were all stunning. It's a lot bettr than it sounded in the TV guides.
At 0:08, we see two tracks going under the rail-bridge that Edward crossed. These must be narrow gauge tracks, which might explain how Victor is able to leave the Sodor Steamworks to collect parts ("Charlie & Eddie") or go to the Transfer Yards ("Steamy Sodor"). On the episode, a great story with Edward is his old, wise personality.
@southparkluvva Victor is NARROW-GAUGE. He is probably 4ft 6in whereas STANDARD GAUGE is 4ft 8.5in. The transfer table has three rails - on the right, there are two rails close together, making it clear that Victor was regauged from 4ft 8.5in to 4ft 6in to work at the Sodor Steamworks.
I was sad seeing the dog alone, then when it was reunited with Farmer Mcoll I felt very happy inside, I can't stand seeing animals alone and scared.
OperationAnime262 3 weeks ago
he's just being himself all the time.
importednascar 1 month ago
maybe 6/10 no 9/10.
importednascar 1 month ago
not enjoying their individual voices, when i was young, that was the best times of thomas.
in fact, viewing more, the voices are AWFUL
MattNIcholsBeatle 1 month ago
I like Edward in full CGI because it seems to bring out his personality and character more. same for James. The rest, I think were better off without CGI. Just my thoughts
Midnafan725 2 months ago in playlist James and Edward
That why Edward's my favorite character from Thomas the Tank Engine. He's kind, generous, caring and helpful. He's just being himself.
joe65TVS 2 months ago
@TheThomastank1 I gave this a 5/10, which is average, not high.
ThomasPercyandToby2 3 months ago
@TheThomastank1 Average, awful and REALLY average. GOOD Edward and Thomas episodes are Old Iron, Edward's Exploit, Thomas and Gordon, Thomas, Percy and the Post Train, Thomas, Percy and the Post Train, Edward the Great, Wrong Road. ANY episode from S13 onwards can NEVER be considered as good episodes involving Thomas and Edward.
ThomasPercyandToby2 3 months ago
@TheThomastank1 One of the worst ever. I hate any episodes involving Misty Island. It's an unrealistic death trap.
ThomasPercyandToby2 3 months ago
@TheThomastank1 Surprise Surprise - not really.
Stop That Bus - was only good because of Bertie, but was basically a re-write of Thomas and Skarloey's Big Day Out
Stuck On You - Overrated. It may see Butch speaking for the first time in 13 years, but it followed the same formula as the rest, and a lot of it was illogical.
Tree Trouble - He was just selfish because he wanted the limelight that the Diesels got.
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@TheThomastank1 Why, should I have done? I haven't bullied you, I've just told you my opinions. Not really my fault we don't agree on a lot of things.
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
7:41 Who was that taking 2 Breakdown Train Coaches?
SegaMario 4 months ago
@TheThomastank1 So you're seriously telling me that a railway is the perfect environment to have fun?! Seriously, am I the only one to live in the real world and realise that railways are some of the most dangerous working environments in the world?! While I agree with that phrase, there is a time and a place for fun and frolics, and railways are not places to have fun, not in a million years.
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@TheThomastank1 Thomas gets the best episodes? Not these days he doesn't.
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
i love that music!
JurgenYong96 4 months ago
Edward: charlie, what are you doing here?
Charlie: I have a squeaky wheel, so I can't move apparently.
Edward: ....Gtfo.
truro125 5 months ago
This one was alright but still improvements could be made. Edward's character is rather poor here and he HAS been the hero many times, in Edward and Gordon, Old Iron, Edward's Exploit and Edward the Very Useful Engine.
7Lightening 5 months ago
they need to make a bachmann charlie
roloboy97 5 months ago
@roloboy97 ...I hope to God they don't...
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 why?
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 I hate Charlie with a passion. He doesn't do any work and is too bothered about having fun.
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 well i love charlie is a awsome and i think ur wrong
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 OK you go and play in the middle of a railway track, and don't say I didn't warn you when an oncoming train flattens you dead...
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 WTF are you going on about its a tv show durr
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 A TV show watched by CHILDREN that teaches - or at least SHOULD teach - them IMPORTANT LIFE LESSONS! Series 15, in fact MANY recent episodes, DO NOT do this.
I'm not going to even try and explain anymore. It's clear that all you care about is the visual shiny shiny, and it is absolutely dosgusting and, more importantly, disheartening that those who actually want to make a difference are a part of a fanbase consisting of fickle people like you that will accept ANYTHING...
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 shut the fuck up it a tv show that children like its on a show its not real
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 Try telling that to the Awdrys. EVERY situation an engine was put in was inspired from a real life event. To them, Thomas was like the Rev Awdry's imaginary son, and it was a book series that children could LEARN from.
I also laugh at your swearing. What's the matter? Can't take the fact that someone can see this series for what it TRULY is? Or is it just because I insinuated that you were fickle? Seriously, grow up. I'm not the only one who feels this way.
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 erm 1 i have no idea wat ur going on about 2 i like the cgi i think it better than the rev W awdrys thomas
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 1. If you actually picked up a book and READ the stories you WOULD know what I was on about.
2. Humanity's intelligence is going down the toilet... BIG time...
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 thats wat u think but i like the cgi series way better than the models
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 No, that's what I know. The plots are worse than they have ever been and THAT makes a good series? If Thomas and Friends is so good, why has the head writer quit? Why are so many fans - mainly the ones who actually HAVE a brain - angry with what we're seeing. And the third thing, why is this series not winning awards? One answer: IT'S CRAP! The only good thing is the voice acting and the CGI itself.
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 well i like it so stop trying to change my mind
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 How is pointing out facts trying to change your mind? You give me ONE GOOD REASON why these poor excuses for episodes are good and I'll say no more about it (without mentioning the animation).
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 well i like the voicing and the new engines like CHARLIE i dont care if u dont like him cos u say he dont do any work and can only be bothered to have fun
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 I said a GOOD reason. Charlie is the worst character in the history of television, let alone Thomas the Tank Engine and Friends. Railways are dangerous environments and to have a character like him is sending out dangerous messages to children. Or does that not bother you?
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 not realy why should it i dont have kids and i think kids are smart to keep of railway tracks and its not real get again i tell you its a show and i dont care how much u hate charlie i actully think he is a great engine sure HiT does have some down side like not realy showing donald and douglas and duck and oliver and stepney oh well they have better engines now like hiro and victor and CHARLIE and whiff ETC but i will miss D&D and oliver and duck and stepney
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 I'm sorry, I had to re-read that to believe what I was seeing. Charlie better than those five? HAHAHA, you don't half crack me up... Charlie is a disgrace, and I'm appalled that you think that kids think things are safe when crap like this is written for them. As well as parents, kids learn from what they see on television and if they SEE something dangerous happening, nine times out of ten they'll want to do it.
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 sure sure kids learn alot from TV thats why there is lots of sex drug and violence and u ever seen a 4 year olr robbing a bank ? no and you ever seend a 3 years old shoot some1 ? no
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 Do you ever see those things on kids TV? No, you doofus! If you're gonna put a convincing argument over on me, you're gonna HAVE to more kids TV research...
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 well i think kids no how to change a channel u dinlo
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 lol.
1. We're talking about toddlers here, I highly doubt they know what a television remote does and how it works.
2. It is a PARENT'S responsibility to keep their children safe, NOT the child's. Kids will watch whatever Thomas is in because... it's Thomas. Only a select few know that something's wrong, the rest semingly rely on these things to show them right from wrong, which NONE of these episodes do.
3. XD, what's a dinlo?
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 1 i have no idea wat ur twatting on about and i dont care i watch the tv show i enjoy it i dont give a rats ass wat u think off it end off
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 Of course you don't know what I'm on about, you're too stupid to understand. Wouldn't surprise me if you were under 13... Here's a little tip: go to school and actually LEARN something. It's OBVIOUS to me that you haven't...
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 well do excuse me, is it me or do u think ur a smartass get ur fucking head out ur fat ass cos it looks to me u spent all your time sitting it on ur computer chair try to find facts wat will upset me and let me tell u its not working if u want to find out somting there is a big wide world out side go out side and have a look cos it seems to me u spend all ur time sitting on ur computer chair and have u even seen day light or are you to much of a fat ass to have a look?
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 Resorting to swearing again? What immaturity. Unlike you, I KNOW what I am talking about, because I actually went to SCHOOL and I READ the Railway Series, two things you've never done. Also, FYI, I am a college student currently on half term, so I DO study, I DO get out, and I actually HAVE respect for people's views, which is more than can be said for you... And before you inevitably turned it around to me (that's what morons like you do), I pointed out FACTS to you.
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 ur at collage and ur arguing with a year 9 u r a little pillock and a child how old are you 16 17 im 13 and ur acting like a 8 year old grow up
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 XD, you're a Year 9? No wonder you're so stupid :P. Kids like you should NEVER be allowed on computer as you have little or no maturity. If anyone is acting younger than their real age, look in the mirror, junior, since you're the one that's swearing like a sailor and I'm the guy who actually knows what he's talking about.
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 ur in collage and ur still arguing with me ur such a little baby get a life oh and get a girl friend ur computer dont count oh and y are you at collage are you redoing ur GCSE's is it cos u failed ur last ones and u need higher marks cos mcdonalds did let u work there?
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 Judging by your appalling spelling, your English lessons aren't working. Face it, you're only getting mad because you don't like the truth being told to you. More than likely because you're treated like a spoiled brat by your parents. I am in COLLEGE (EGE, not AGE) because I want to be an animator, something that needs HARD WORK and DETERMINATION, two things you don't have...
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 well i dont care about my spelling and by hard work do you mean by looking at some fat chick and masturbating and i dont realy wanna do this any more im going to be a adult 1 and say seeya good luck arguing with more people younger then
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 Dude, you don't even know what an adult is, considering you're the one getting angry/upset over someone pointing out facts that you can't handle. Not to mention the fact that YOU'RE the only one who's been swearing. REAL adults don't NEED to swear to make their point. Here's a little saying for you: act your age, not your shoe size.
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 cheers for the shit advice bye dont want to talk to u no more ur just a person who likes bullying younger peopl ebcause u cant do it to people your own size
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 lol, you said that in the last comment, so forgive me if I don't believe you... The thing you can't comprehend is that YOU'RE the one who turned it into a fight due to your immaturity. All I said was railways are dangerous environments and I hate Charlie :P
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 good luck wid that oh and it was me who turned it into a fight ur the 1 who is talking piss outa my spelling its not my fault and ur saying im stupid ffs bye i dont want to talk to u no more
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 Dude, have you actually SEEN your spelling? Seven year olds are better spellers than you. And YOU were the one who went ape over someone (me) hating Charlie. That was BEFORE I even mentioned your spelling. But it's usual for people like you to turn it around on those who outsmart them... And if you're not gonna talk to me again, don't bother replying, 'k?
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 bye dont care about my spelling hope u fail in collage and end up living on the streets :D
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 XD, I know you weren't a kid that keeps your word... As for the collEGE (not collAGE, idiot) comment, I really laughed at your immaturity. I couldn't care less if I pass or fail, I will do the best I can and have fun. And at least I'll LEARN something, which is more than you've done in, what, 8 years of school?
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 GO AND FUCK UR SELF U LTTILE BASTERD U HAVE PISSED E OF SO MUCH ITS NOT MY FAULT ABOUT MY SPELL IM DYSLEXIC I WAS BORD WITH IT ALL U DO IN COLLAGE IS MASTERBATE OVER UR FAT MUM AND YES COLLAGE IS HARD IF U HAVE TO MASTERBATE OVER THAT STOP MESSAGEING ME GO FUCK UR SELF U SCET
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 Swearing AND shouting now? What an immature, spoiled little brat you are... Dyslexia is, in your case, just a lame excuse for your downright stupidity. And if you're SO bothered about my messages, don't bother replying. It's not that difficult you moron...
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 can u piss off u asterd i swearing cos im pissed off stop messageing me cos ur a bully and yes i am dyslexic ur only atalking me cos u most likely like lettle boy u pedo
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 lol, just when I thought you couldn't get more pathetic. You're only butthurt because I think Charlie is the worst television character in history. If you have a problem with opinions, then that's YOUR problem. I'm not attacking you, you're the one attacking since YOU'RE the one that's calling people a paedo. Think about that before your next pathetic comment, junior. God your parents must be SO proud of you(!)
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 its his cousin u wanna shut the fuck up about his parents cuz ur statin to piss me off if u wanna start on anyone start on me cuz im 16 hes 13 u fukin dick get a life n stop mouthing of a 13yr old cuz ur the pethetic one grow the fuk up u silly dickhead
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 ...lol, are you quite finished? It's not my fault that he goes ape over an opinion about a fictional character. Besides, he's called me every name under the sun, but then so are you, so I can see where he gets his potty mouth from... You must literally be from a gutter family...
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 what fucking collage u go too? cuz if i see you ur gettin ur head smashed it watch out u skank !!!!
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 Maturity, thy name is roloboy97 and his gutter family here, folks... First swearing, now violence? God, your parents must be proud of you, too... You are absolutely pathetic. Grow up. Your idiotic cousin should've been taught about the dangers of the internet before he created this account.
Besides, if you think which college I go to is ANYTHING to do with you lowlives, then you're even more retarded than your pathetic little cousin...
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 hiya sorry to hear whats going on here , im the MOTHER ... and i must say i would be proud if you was my son.... NOT......... as you are the same age as my eldest son .... and he seems so much grown up than you .. may i ask have you been bullied in your life ?????? cause you seem to be a bit of a PRAT ... any way are leave it at that ............ so please leave my son alone !!!!!!!!!
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 I think you should be lecturing your son about accepting other people's opinions, madam. You should also tell him that swearing doesn't make him sound ANY better. I will gladly leave your son alone, and I will apologise for any distress caused to you (and him). I am not going to bother him any more, but HE should also leave me alone and stop responding to my comments, and I shall do the same.
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 it (roloboy97) and this is my last comment i dont want to talk to u any more so bye and yes i am sorry 4 swearing and i would like u to apolagise 4 taking the mick out of my spelling and talking about my family saying im from a guttler family
roloboy97 4 months ago
@roloboy97 I do, sincerely, apologise for ALL my comments about you and your family. You have every right to ay that you prefer the CGI series to the model series and you have every right to say that Charlie is your favourite character.
ThomasPercyandToby2 4 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 thank you and u have a right to hate charlie and the cgi series and i apolagis for my swearing
roloboy97 4 months ago
Eck! Bertram? What was wrong with just plan Topham? I like CGI but some of the changes annoy me.
sjmore 6 months ago
4:32 "Three cheers for you!"
Haha no-one cheered. XD
Timmehhemmit 6 months ago
7:41 "I dont feel like a hero"
"YAAAAAAAAAY"
lol
Transformice9 7 months ago
What did HiT do to his character?
billa107 8 months ago
6:30 Transcribe Audio.
Edward: I was only Gentle!!
Transcribed: genital
LOL
Transformice9 8 months ago
@Transformice9 LMFAO thats what hit has turned him into
captainofthetitanic 7 months ago
All the steamies are heroes!
MikeD57s 8 months ago
People are going to thumb me down for this, but I honestly didn't like this episode. It was pretty overrated to me.
thomasfan69 8 months ago
Edward was more heroic in old iron.
ClearwaterMK2 8 months ago
@IndianaJones772
Have you ever though that it might not be farmer mc ? they would to put it on a bulletin board.
LBPStrikerInc 10 months ago
5:59, Edward has no eyebrows
MrTrainboy1 10 months ago
@MrTrainboy1 Err... He does. Its just really close to his eyes.
Transformice9 8 months ago
this episode not the best is decent i mean its better then edward strikes out stupid idiotic episode
FanboyD2 10 months ago
Edward is completely out of character.
TroPicTank 10 months ago
@TroPicTank He's been "out of character" for a long time now. Unfortunately he's been like this for so long that he you might as well say this is now the real Edward.
484berkshire 7 months ago
Thomas has a better voice in the us version.
TroPicTank 10 months ago
"I'd like to be a hero, but I'm not sure I would be good at it"
WHAT, Edward rescued James in Old Iron.
bobo577 10 months ago
you know part of this is charlie is a joke train and I never seen that and he does 1 joke 1 JOKE HE IS MAD! it is not 1 joke if a kid came up late the joke would be non-re done!
trainguyrocks 11 months ago
Sticks to the show. It got a SOMEWHAT better.
Seems that HiT gave a LITTLE creative control to the makers, who know what the older show was like, and it's been advancing slightly with each season.
Of course, I don't think that every character has to be rendered in TrackMaster.
I still dislike HIT. Because I don't like kid's shows turning into pop-culture icons.
super58173 11 months ago
7:38. Is james pulling the old grean coaches from season 1? O.o
MrBerrillProductions 11 months ago
7:39 Spencer and Salty but next minute Henry is in Spencer's place!
93DOL 11 months ago
actually it's ma'am in Uk version.
conorboy931 11 months ago
When will u make an Arsdale railway with Rex,Bert,Mike,Frank,Jock,ect.
legofan605 11 months ago
Another bad thing about the new animation is that they have really bad rymes. I dislike it so much!
thomasandpercy1and6b 1 year ago 2
@thomasandpercy1and6b I like the animation, I just don't like the rhyming.
TTTEpisodeS15 1 year ago 5
@thomasandpercy1and6b well at least they have movin mouths you idout
titanicboy477 7 months ago
must.....resist.....GLaDOS.....reference.....FFFFFF
camscott 1 year ago
@camscott what do u mean??
SuperMarioNJ 11 months ago
@SuperMarioNJ Nice job breaking it hero
camscott 11 months ago
This reminded me of Saved You! abit..
Btw, Notice how Edward Calls Dowager hatt "Mom" :P
thomasfan69 1 year ago
@thomasfan69 It's not "Mom", it's how some of British people pronounce "Ma'am".
TTTEpisodeS15 1 year ago 2
@TTTEpisodeS15 Yeah, us Brits say Ma'am very posh :P
TheDirtyTrain1 8 months ago
@thomasfan69 i think he said mam
bluecomet10 9 months ago
@bluecomet10 Could have...
thomasfan69 9 months ago
Lol @ dowager hatt's voice
truro125 1 year ago
00.50 Orange Coaches?
etenks1 1 year ago
3:17 That's the angle from season 1!
TrainzFanNumber1 1 year ago
Cool camera angles! Reminds me of Trainz. 0:16 The tree wagon from henry's forest!
TrainzFanNumber1 1 year ago
This episode was quite good, and it was WAY BETTER than Percy's New Friends, although it did have good angles.
Overall this one is good. It has cameos by Spencer, Arry, Bert, Henry, Percy, and Salty.
My Rating: 4.5/5
NEXT UP: James to the Rescue
lbbrian 1 year ago
@TMRReturns thanks
monsterjamcj 1 year ago
@TheDonaldDouglas It sounded a lot like mum though! XD
SodorProductions 1 year ago
@TMRReturns I gave it an 8
SodorProductions 1 year ago
my ratings: 5.7/10
trainboy62 1 year ago
My ratings: 5.7/10
trainboy62 1 year ago
where is Spencer?
monsterjamcj 1 year ago
Loved it the best series 15 episode so far.
cactus190706 1 year ago
wow no dislikes a record
arandomguy222 1 year ago
@arandomguy222 Too late, someone missed the like button.
SodorProductions 1 year ago
@SodorProductions ok but still..wow
arandomguy222 11 months ago
@SodorProductions that sounds suspisios
arandomguy222 11 months ago
best episode of season 15 so far
emilyandhenry 1 year ago
Edward was nice, i like him.
LionelThomas200 1 year ago
I liked this episode, despite its few -- if not many -- flaws. It really brings out the kindness and compassion in Edward's repertoire.
disneyrangerblue02 1 year ago
This is awesome episode
Supermariofan682 1 year ago
AMAZING! Five episodes and Thomas still hasn't had any starring roles or major appearances, and the episode is pretty good!
BramGroatFilms 1 year ago 14
@BramGroatFilms I just wished that he didn't appear ONCE (no wait, maybe twice or thrice just like in Season 12)
Zorran202 8 months ago
Interesting episode. One of Edward's better roles
DannerBoone 1 year ago
Is it me or did Edward call Dowager Hatt 'Mom' in this episode?
BiggestThomasFan 1 year ago
@BiggestThomasFan No, he called her "Ma'am", it's a polite greeting that British people say to important women.
ThomasPercyandToby2 1 year ago
my only question is why are the engines calling Dowager Hatt mom?
I know that its the Fat Controller's mom but still
benr1512 1 year ago
This ain't half bad! Better than the rubbish that aired before!
SodorProductions 1 year ago
This is a pretty decent episode, new footage and seeing Arry, Bert, Salty, and Spencer make cameo appearances too! :)
Zorran202 1 year ago
When did Arry and Bert appear I didn't see them?
trainboy62 1 year ago
@trainboy62 6:37. They're both pulling trains of tankers
ThomasPercyandToby2 1 year ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2
trainboy62 1 year ago
@trainboy62 They can be seen when Edward enters the Steamworks towards the end :)
TTTEpisodeS15 1 year ago
@TTTEpisodeS15 Don't ya mean the Search and Rescue Center? That's where I saw them
Zorran202 1 year ago
@Zorran202 Yeah, that's what I mean :P
TTTEpisodeS15 1 year ago
This was pretty good! Liked all the new angles, and the cameos by Arry, Bert and Salty, which reminds me- Just before Edward puffs into Knapford, look to the right and you'll see Salty.. with two 'Works' coaches! :O
Lightninging63 1 year ago
@Lightninging63 You can also see Spencer with his special coach too! :D
Zorran202 1 year ago
@Zorran202 Omigosh you're right! lots of nice cameos!
Lightninging63 1 year ago
Edward is my favourite out of all the engines ever sonce I watched the old series and this episode is pretty good. Sure it's like any episode HIT made but at least it shows what Edward should of been.
clashrogers 1 year ago
''Edward you're a Hero'' :)
ThomasAndFriends02 1 year ago
Best episode of s15 so far, there was hardly any reused angles, Edward was in character, and the cameos like Arry & Bert's were nice.
1:31, Annie's asleep! :P
TheBlueE2 1 year ago
"I don't know HOW to be a hero!"
Well, DUH, all you have to do is look for people in trouble and help. :S
Still, good episode. :D
crazyracer12 1 year ago
I can safely say this is my favorite episode of S15 so far. Now we're getting somewhere.
FlameAmigo619 1 year ago
is it just me or is that the Sodor Dieselworks at the begining? its the right colour
SkarloeyFan 1 year ago
@SkarloeyFan That's the Steamworks.
TTTEpisodeS15 1 year ago
It's definitely better than the past for episodes, but it could have been better. All the angles were great though. That was cool to see the back of Knapford Station.
trainboy62 1 year ago
One of my fav episodes of S15 so far ^^ Im glad that Edward has his own episode again, he joke was funny and its proves that HIT is listening to us about Edward is himself again ^^
PrettyRosie1995 1 year ago
I love how Edward and Charlie's friendship is still acknowledged. They still make jokes with each other. :P
TheUnluckyTug02 1 year ago
@TheUnluckyTug02 Yeah and Charlie still calls him Eddie XD
TTTEpisodeS15 1 year ago
Charlie's actually doing work! :o
That was epic! Those first few shots were amazing, especially the very first one.
TheUnluckyTug02 1 year ago
This wasn't too bad. At least there were some acknoledgements to Edward's old self. But still, it was quite bland. I wish we'd had a more exciting story.
alexanderprice6 1 year ago
I think this is a fantastic episode. It's a bit weird how Edward stops the way he does, and it's a bit weird that Edward would be worried about not being a hero, but all the cameos, the new angles, the plot as a whole were all stunning. It's a lot bettr than it sounded in the TV guides.
9/10
ThomasPercyandToby2 1 year ago
Stopping like that cannot be good for Edward's tires and wheels.
CarGuyZM10 1 year ago 14
@CarGuyZM10 Trains don't have tires.
Naylte 10 months ago
@Naylte Steam engines are fitted with a steel band around the driving wheels, called the tire, to prevent wear to the actual wheel.
CarGuyZM10 10 months ago
I wasn't gonna like this episode, but now I do! It's my Favourite so far ;D
NemesisHero123 1 year ago
This was pretty good. Edward usually always gets good episodes.
TheFattHatt1943 1 year ago
I read Edward's lips when he said "the Fat Controller", and he actually lipped "Sir Topham Hatt".
CalleyFan 1 year ago
At 0:08, we see two tracks going under the rail-bridge that Edward crossed. These must be narrow gauge tracks, which might explain how Victor is able to leave the Sodor Steamworks to collect parts ("Charlie & Eddie") or go to the Transfer Yards ("Steamy Sodor"). On the episode, a great story with Edward is his old, wise personality.
SteamieWithGlasses 1 year ago
@SteamieWithGlasses But how come at the Sodar Steamworks he fits on the same rails as the standard gauge engines?
southparkluvva 1 year ago
@southparkluvva Those are DUAL GAUGE rails.
SodorProductions 1 year ago
@southparkluvva Victor is NARROW-GAUGE. He is probably 4ft 6in whereas STANDARD GAUGE is 4ft 8.5in. The transfer table has three rails - on the right, there are two rails close together, making it clear that Victor was regauged from 4ft 8.5in to 4ft 6in to work at the Sodor Steamworks.
SteamieWithGlasses 1 year ago
Does anyone know where Edward is at 0:05?
TheSodorSteamworks 1 year ago
My favourite to now! =D Even though it didn't suit Edward at all :/ I love all the new camera angles, and the cameos.
TheSodorSteamworks 1 year ago