@Hardysamnin Without Slash, Axl would have no career. Appetite wouldn't exist. No appetite, no Axl. Or maybe he'd still be around...in hollywood rose or some shit.
@Hardysamnin Slash can remember his solos and plays his solos the same time everytime. And what is the "one scale" that he can play? I've hear him play lydian, mixolydian, and double harmonic scales. And that's just off the top of my head. Are you sure you aren't getting Slash mixed up with someone else?
@LemonCrushMusic There are vids of him on here failing miserably to replicate the simplist of his own solos, then saying "or something like that" . Lydian and mixolydian are simply different modes of the same diatonic scale. And no I'm not getting him mixed up with anybody ;)
@Hardysamnin You think so? That must suck. To have such a faulty sense of logic. Sorry :/ Again what is the "one scale" Slash plays. I'm curious as to what your definition of a scale is. You say modes are just variations of a scale, but that seems to imply that EVERYTHING is a variation on the same scale, meaning Bumblefoot is no better than Slash is no better than Eric Clapton is no better than Jimmy Page.
@LemonCrushMusic Your curious what my definition of a scale is? A scale... lydian and mixolydian are the same thing, just one of the 7 modes of the major scale. Any clown can play diatonically, even me. That in no way whatsoever imply's that EVERYTHING (caps lock) is a variation of the same scale. Slash = The Aeolian mode, and the pentatonic major/minor, any other appearance of another mode he plays is either accidental, or a cameo. Further more, you started this shit with your:
@LemonCrushMusic "He's certainly no Slash" bullshit. No, he isn't, he's ten of the guy. I'm not ripping on Slash, the first 5 GnR albums were class, and they're better than the ones with both Buckethead and Bumblefoot. But as a musician, Slash cannot, and never will, be able to hold a candle to this mans talent, period, end of story, fact.
@Hardysamnin Pure technical ability don't mean shit when you can't compose. In fact, comparing Slash to someone like Bumblefoot is stupid because they don't even ply the same kind of music.This is like saying Buddy Guy is [better/worse] than Bach. The difference in this case is that Bumblefoot is going onstage trying to emulate Slash, and failing REALLY hard. It's equivalent to Muddy Waters trying to emulate Beethoven or Beethoven playing a blues.
@LemonCrushMusic Trying to emulate Slash? Lol.. When this guy was 17 he learned Eruption by ear, ripped open the cassette, and learned it by ear backwards. The simple fact is, as a musician, and a composer, he pisses all over all but a few guitar players. Slash isn't one of them. Only a but hurt Slash fanatic could deny that.
@Hardysamnin Dumbass, he's onstage playing A SLASH SONG. And again compositional ability and playing Eruption don't mean anything if you can't even play in tune.
@LemonCrushMusic - He's playing an improvised solo over a Slash / Stradlin / McKagan written tune. Play in tune? You do not have a clue what you're talking about. Go back to strumming your chords kid. Once you learn some music theory, you will understand what is going on here.
@Hardysamnin Exactly. And we get back to, say, Freddie King, improvising over Mozart. And no the bends in this video are out of tune. Fact. Go back to your music theory books, nerd, hopefully you'll realize music is more than math and trying to see who can come up with the most complex time signature. Hack.
@LemonCrushMusic f you wanna drive your 67 Chevvy that's fine but times have changed. I'll stick to my Bugatti ^_^ Music goes far beyond the minor scale, I just wish you could realize that. If your happy with a mediocre rock/blues player then good luck to you. I was the same for 15 years before it became the same shit different day and my horizons were broadened. Thank fuck for that transition. My musical appreciation has ten folded since.
@Hardysamnin This music is a Bugatti to you?! Damn. That kind of explains everything. It may interest you to know that music is more than just math, speed and complex scales.
@Hardysamnin Have you ever heard a Vivaldi composition? Does it sound like all the instruments in it are playing the same note? Nope, they're HARMONIZING. Harmonies are chords.
@LemonCrushMusic Yet he himself does not play the very definition of a chord, i.e. 3 or more notes played together. Ok then, I'll use a different example, Paganini 5th Caprice is a solo piece on the violin. Is he not a musician for not playing a chord in that piece?
@Hardysamnin Paganini and all you guitarists who think you're violinists can suck my balls. Also Paganini composed for ensembles too. I guarantee he wasn;t going into "violin center" and trying to play as fast as possible. Paganini was a musician because he embraced and participated in all facets of musical creation. Guys like Bumblefoot just try to play as fast as possible and do cool "tricks" on guitar. Thelonius Monk and Pagnini are musicians. Bumblefoot is just a guitarist.
@LemonCrushMusic I have the advantage of having all Ron's albums. If you had heard his material you would know he is not a shredder, who "play as fast as possible and do cool "tricks" on guitar". I've heard everything Slash has done, you have heard a tiny tiny fraction of Rons material and have made an uneducated, ignorant assessment of him. Either educate yourself on the artists you comment on, or shut the fuck up =) Listen to the uncool album and tell me he's a shredder. Not 1 fast solo.
@Hardysamnin Also, memorizing a solo means nothing if what your memorizing completely sucks and/or if you can't execute it properly, like not being able to bend notes correctly.
@LemonCrushMusic Lol if by that you're talking about Ron, Slash is not even in the same game, let alone the same league. People like Greg Howe, Ritchie kotzen, Ron Thal, Frank Gambale, Guthrie Govan etc, are on another planet. Slash is a rounded blues / rock player at an intermediate stage. If your biggest plus about him is he can "bend properly" (rofl) then that doesn't really say much about his prowess as a musician. Ron can play the music in his head, and transfer it to the guitar immediately
@rendestroi1 when did he grow his hair back from that weird ass haircut? also hes dressing more normal in this video and no face paint. im not talkin shit abaout him i just hadnt realized he changed so much from the older vids.
dude i was there. 90% of the crowd watched the concerts since 18.00. Korn, then tool (sucked big time).
GN'R was schedueld forr 0.00 , but we all know our GN'R. SO They came to stage like 1:30, fuckin' rocked till the sun came out again. was fuckin' epic.
@RhodesLives nothing overly technical there. you're either not a guitar player, a shit guitar player, a "feel" guitar player and the final option is just someone who complains because its not the top hatted one ripping up the fretboard. its a good solo, i prefer the original but if i was in his position i'd do the same thing. i'd probably have played a little closer to the original though (just a little) also its live it doesn't have to be note for note especially a guitar solo.
@mrphilcollins If @RhodesLives didn't like this why you have to insult? Is your life so empty that you need to throw shit at someone else's comment so you can feel better? This solo doesn't even have the right 'sound' to start with. It doesn't matter who is playing it, it's about 'the original' vs 'this'. Slash changed this solo 100x times in the old days and it never sounded like some other thing, this is clearly some 'tap-tap' bullshit which I personally don't like in new Gn'R. That's it.
well i commented because i disagreed with what he had said. the solo wasn't amazing but its still far more than "technical dribble" by that same merit he just wrote off several types of guitar music not just rock. jesus he's wrote off classical music too. they all use dissonant notes flashes of speed etc. basically Bumblefoot is an amazing guitar player who for the most part respects slashs playing... however he has the right to play a different solo if he chooses...
@masterofmorphine92 Yeah, it's a shame he didn't compose that, right??! Slash and Izzy did!! Long long time ago, when GnR were still THE GnR. World is full of good guitarist who can play it, but only few very talented people can write a riff like this which will be still played years and years later by others guys (who have NOT some good stuff like that written by themself to play).
@Cescus86 How about This I Loves solo....or the solos in There Was A TIme??? They are some of the best I've heard. I loved Slash and Izzy's solos....but don't discount these guys just because they are playing olf GNR songs. These guys are talented!!
GnR fans are such a fuckin' lucky guys.. We can hear great solos arranged by so many different style guitarists. Slash, Buckethead, Finck, Bumblefoot, Ashba, Fortus, Stradlin, even Tobias in Rocket Queen in 2001. We are lucky motherfuckers but also haters and in spite of LISTENING we are arguing which of them is better -,- Sad
@LajSolSirius D --> Damn, it's about time someone wrote that. Yeah, it really is c001 to hear so many different interpretations of the same songs. Though Buckethead is my personal favorite guitarist, each of them are great. Though I think I have been most impressed with Bumblefoot because he's been playing Buckethead's solos, and that is nothing to take lightly. Watching everyone play Paradise City is a true sight though.
Great song.Watched new band two times,and old once,but some songs are much much better and with more power in interpretation by new band and "nighttrain" is one of them...I don't get people who compare new and old band,why do you do that...
ok change the bands name, get some new original material and get rid of axl and we would have an awesome rock/metal band right here!!! I'm a huge g n' r fan but re-hashing the old materials, espically with axl shit singing is ruining the originals, let them have their glory as classic old rock songs. atleast slash did a re-make of paradise city, and myles can sing nightrain better than axl now
Best Nightrain solo ever? Slash is one of my favourite guitarists, but man, this solo, and this whole performance of the song (If you've never seen the full version from this gig, go watch it now!) is the best Guns has ever done.
Stop dissing Axl's guitarists. Just be glad that stink Finck is gone. Ashba is MUCH better than Robin is for Guns. I think that ChiDem would have been much better with Ashba on the record.
i thought the sweeps at the end were a little tasteless but other than that very good. Cool to see some one doing technical guitar playing over such a gritty hard rock song and still sounding cool.
Bumblefoot is the consumate innovator.Note the tapping with the plecta edge on the humbucker to sweep 2 octaves over the high fretted notes etc. etc.R.T. kicks anyone's ass!!!
Usando como argumento principal que Slash fue el que creó el riff y solo de Nightrain, ya lo hace mejor que Bumblefoot. Sin él, Bumblefoot no estaría parado en el escenario. Punto.
Damn, Bumblefoot rocks the shit out of that guitar. Buckethead may be my favorite guitarist in existence and Slash can rock the blues like no other, but jeez... this guy can jam. He was getting a little bit too off key with some of the solo though. I like his style a shitload though.
It sucks that people keep adding slash to any comparisons, he's a studio and/or warm up guy...at best(insulting to true artists of the guitar). He's just a victim of the mass media, and people follow the mass media like sheep. And 'Deth0' said it in his post...'different styles', but i would omit slash, his 'style' is just filler for regurgitated 80's top 40 rock.
Maybe it comes down to money...you have the money to see any guitarist solo,who in their right mind would pay to see slash? lol.
to be honest i'd rather play his version of the nightrain solo than play exactly what slash plays, cause then you guys would be like bumblefoot is just a copy of slash and a slash wannabe! So go bumblefoot! the best guitar player in the current lineup!
that was top drawer soloing but Bumblefoot is way better without GnR and to those that say aww but Slash did it first, I really dont remember Slash doing it anything like that, theres a lot of improv in there, a fucking LOT!!!!
i am technically better than slash .am i better guitarist ? am i fuck.slash got somthing lads its not technic but the man got it .except when hes pissed that is .
umm...can i just say something about this whole slash V bumblefoot thing.
Its Slashs fucking solo!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He wrote it first, he performed it first, everyone else is copying him! Sure, lots of artists can reproduce the Mona Lisa, but Leonardo Da Vinci's will always be the original and the best.
Well done bumblefoot, im sure slash would think you did a great job, and you did (no doubt about that). Too bad youre not Slash!
@mdogg101slash I'd say he could - I've heard him do some pretty simple pentatonic stuff too. And besides, anyone would have to admit that it is a lot easier to do accurate mimicry of slash than in is the foot
Some retards compare slash and bumblefoot but both guitarists have different style.You can't compare slash who is playing hard rock with bubmlefoot who has metal style.
Good guitar player, for that style and comes across as a nice fella but for me Axl hasn't been able to find a player who can phrase and structure aswell as Slash. Thats a god given talent and give me him over every single whizz bang hired guy Axl has had since the nineties
I love Bumblefoot, Normal is such an amazing album. It's a shame people write him off as a shredder just because he can play some flashier stuff. He's a great singer too.
i dont know what to think of this solo.. the guy has mad skills, but this composing doesnt do it for me. i dont know where hes going with it. i just hear bends and pinch harmonics.
Endless arguments about Bumblefoot, Buckethead and Slash as always. It goes like this, Slash is the shit. Bumblefoot is the shit. Buckethead = Kinda shitty.
slash is alot slower but more melodic and intresting-every note hase meaning-but bumble foot is pure shredding power of doom but u cant fell 1000 notes in 1 second, both thal is obviusly more skilled but slash is pure feeling so both are great to listen too-some guitarist are supposed to play slow and some are supposed to be demon shredders -its called variety
@lonewolfshogun I don't think that Bumblefoot is a real demon shredder. He's not always just speed and skill. He mixes slow and fast melodies, and these arpeggios you can hear are just fragmented chords which announce the colour of the solo he plays.
Also, Slash plays beautiful solos, opened to weak and experimented ears. Bumblefoot's are more difficult to feel and hear, but alot more interesting.
I say what I want, but these two guitar players are both rock heroes and music gods.
epic shit...solo is way better than buckethead...more bends, more feeling, closer to the original version...the whole band is rocking fucking hard! axl is the man...all you haters are just dicks who don't know shit about this band.
Welll, he's no Slash, that for sure lol
LemonCrushMusic 3 weeks ago
@LemonCrushMusic Thank fuck ;)
Hardysamnin 1 week ago
@Hardysamnin Without Slash, Axl would have no career. Appetite wouldn't exist. No appetite, no Axl. Or maybe he'd still be around...in hollywood rose or some shit.
LemonCrushMusic 1 week ago
@LemonCrushMusic I couldn't care less about Axl Rose lol. He can die in a pool of his own vomit for all I care ;)
Hardysamnin 1 week ago
@Hardysamnin So why the fuck are you watching a Guns N Roses video?
LemonCrushMusic 1 week ago
@LemonCrushMusic Because I'm watching a Ron Thal guitar solo perhaps?
Hardysamnin 1 week ago
Comment removed
LemonCrushMusic 1 week ago
@Hardysamnin Written by Slash...who by the way could play in time, and bend in tune.
LemonCrushMusic 1 week ago
@LemonCrushMusic But can't remember his own solo's because he is not pitch perfect, and can onlt play one scale.
Hardysamnin 1 week ago
@Hardysamnin Slash can remember his solos and plays his solos the same time everytime. And what is the "one scale" that he can play? I've hear him play lydian, mixolydian, and double harmonic scales. And that's just off the top of my head. Are you sure you aren't getting Slash mixed up with someone else?
LemonCrushMusic 1 week ago
@LemonCrushMusic There are vids of him on here failing miserably to replicate the simplist of his own solos, then saying "or something like that" . Lydian and mixolydian are simply different modes of the same diatonic scale. And no I'm not getting him mixed up with anybody ;)
Hardysamnin 1 week ago
@Hardysamnin You think so? That must suck. To have such a faulty sense of logic. Sorry :/ Again what is the "one scale" Slash plays. I'm curious as to what your definition of a scale is. You say modes are just variations of a scale, but that seems to imply that EVERYTHING is a variation on the same scale, meaning Bumblefoot is no better than Slash is no better than Eric Clapton is no better than Jimmy Page.
LemonCrushMusic 1 week ago
@LemonCrushMusic Your curious what my definition of a scale is? A scale... lydian and mixolydian are the same thing, just one of the 7 modes of the major scale. Any clown can play diatonically, even me. That in no way whatsoever imply's that EVERYTHING (caps lock) is a variation of the same scale. Slash = The Aeolian mode, and the pentatonic major/minor, any other appearance of another mode he plays is either accidental, or a cameo. Further more, you started this shit with your:
Hardysamnin 1 week ago
@LemonCrushMusic "He's certainly no Slash" bullshit. No, he isn't, he's ten of the guy. I'm not ripping on Slash, the first 5 GnR albums were class, and they're better than the ones with both Buckethead and Bumblefoot. But as a musician, Slash cannot, and never will, be able to hold a candle to this mans talent, period, end of story, fact.
Hardysamnin 1 week ago
@Hardysamnin Pure technical ability don't mean shit when you can't compose. In fact, comparing Slash to someone like Bumblefoot is stupid because they don't even ply the same kind of music.This is like saying Buddy Guy is [better/worse] than Bach. The difference in this case is that Bumblefoot is going onstage trying to emulate Slash, and failing REALLY hard. It's equivalent to Muddy Waters trying to emulate Beethoven or Beethoven playing a blues.
LemonCrushMusic 1 week ago
@LemonCrushMusic Trying to emulate Slash? Lol.. When this guy was 17 he learned Eruption by ear, ripped open the cassette, and learned it by ear backwards. The simple fact is, as a musician, and a composer, he pisses all over all but a few guitar players. Slash isn't one of them. Only a but hurt Slash fanatic could deny that.
Hardysamnin 1 week ago
Comment removed
LemonCrushMusic 1 week ago
@Hardysamnin Dumbass, he's onstage playing A SLASH SONG. And again compositional ability and playing Eruption don't mean anything if you can't even play in tune.
LemonCrushMusic 1 week ago
@LemonCrushMusic - He's playing an improvised solo over a Slash / Stradlin / McKagan written tune. Play in tune? You do not have a clue what you're talking about. Go back to strumming your chords kid. Once you learn some music theory, you will understand what is going on here.
Hardysamnin 1 week ago
@Hardysamnin Exactly. And we get back to, say, Freddie King, improvising over Mozart. And no the bends in this video are out of tune. Fact. Go back to your music theory books, nerd, hopefully you'll realize music is more than math and trying to see who can come up with the most complex time signature. Hack.
LemonCrushMusic 1 week ago
@LemonCrushMusic f you wanna drive your 67 Chevvy that's fine but times have changed. I'll stick to my Bugatti ^_^ Music goes far beyond the minor scale, I just wish you could realize that. If your happy with a mediocre rock/blues player then good luck to you. I was the same for 15 years before it became the same shit different day and my horizons were broadened. Thank fuck for that transition. My musical appreciation has ten folded since.
Hardysamnin 1 week ago
@Hardysamnin This music is a Bugatti to you?! Damn. That kind of explains everything. It may interest you to know that music is more than just math, speed and complex scales.
LemonCrushMusic 1 week ago
@Hardysamnin And I don't get the comment about chords? Are you a musician who doesn't play chords? Because...that's just not really music.
LemonCrushMusic 1 week ago
@LemonCrushMusic vivaldi wasn't a musician?
Hardysamnin 1 week ago
Comment removed
LemonCrushMusic 1 week ago
@Hardysamnin Have you ever heard a Vivaldi composition? Does it sound like all the instruments in it are playing the same note? Nope, they're HARMONIZING. Harmonies are chords.
LemonCrushMusic 1 week ago
@LemonCrushMusic Yet he himself does not play the very definition of a chord, i.e. 3 or more notes played together. Ok then, I'll use a different example, Paganini 5th Caprice is a solo piece on the violin. Is he not a musician for not playing a chord in that piece?
Hardysamnin 1 week ago
@Hardysamnin Paganini and all you guitarists who think you're violinists can suck my balls. Also Paganini composed for ensembles too. I guarantee he wasn;t going into "violin center" and trying to play as fast as possible. Paganini was a musician because he embraced and participated in all facets of musical creation. Guys like Bumblefoot just try to play as fast as possible and do cool "tricks" on guitar. Thelonius Monk and Pagnini are musicians. Bumblefoot is just a guitarist.
LemonCrushMusic 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@LemonCrushMusic I have the advantage of having all Ron's albums. If you had heard his material you would know he is not a shredder, who "play as fast as possible and do cool "tricks" on guitar". I've heard everything Slash has done, you have heard a tiny tiny fraction of Rons material and have made an uneducated, ignorant assessment of him. Either educate yourself on the artists you comment on, or shut the fuck up =) Listen to the uncool album and tell me he's a shredder. Not 1 fast solo.
Hardysamnin 1 week ago
@Hardysamnin Also, memorizing a solo means nothing if what your memorizing completely sucks and/or if you can't execute it properly, like not being able to bend notes correctly.
LemonCrushMusic 1 week ago
@LemonCrushMusic Lol if by that you're talking about Ron, Slash is not even in the same game, let alone the same league. People like Greg Howe, Ritchie kotzen, Ron Thal, Frank Gambale, Guthrie Govan etc, are on another planet. Slash is a rounded blues / rock player at an intermediate stage. If your biggest plus about him is he can "bend properly" (rofl) then that doesn't really say much about his prowess as a musician. Ron can play the music in his head, and transfer it to the guitar immediately
Hardysamnin 1 week ago
Wtf is going on with the crowd?? Its guns n fuckin roses playing and they're all just standing there?
Calameth0802 1 month ago
does anyone know who the guitarists with the long hair and long beard is?
hollowhostile01 2 months ago
@hollowhostile01 Robin Finck. He looks so different now, without the beard
rendestroi1 2 months ago
@rendestroi1 when did he grow his hair back from that weird ass haircut? also hes dressing more normal in this video and no face paint. im not talkin shit abaout him i just hadnt realized he changed so much from the older vids.
hollowhostile01 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
watch Ron Plays Shackler's Revenge and explain the technique while on visit in Israel!!!
search for it:
Bumblefoot plays "Shackler's Revenge" in ISRAEL!!!
Also check my channel for more Bumblefoot!!!
ofekgnr 3 months ago
Ron Thal > all other GnR guitar players. In fact Guthrie > Ron > everyone else.
Hardysamnin 3 months ago
muito foda o show ba e os fogos então muito tri o show xD
562alisson 3 months ago
uhm...buckethead is better...
giova90metal 3 months ago
@giova90metal they are pretty much on the same level it would be hard to say whos better
viejodelbasston 3 months ago
@viejodelbasston yes,Buckethead and Bumblefoot are great guitar player,but in this song i think Buckethead has more feeling...
giova90metal 3 months ago
@giova90metal are u kiddin? look at buckethead solo, he just do the same pattern and combines it with bends
viejodelbasston 3 months ago
you cant really tell who has more feeling.. thats like arguing about politics
viejodelbasston 3 months ago
Bumblefoot has tons of dexterity but no taste or sense of melody. His tone is forgettable, too.
jctkelly 3 months ago
@jctkelly and you are? the son of Jimi Hendrix? jajjaja no taste or sense of melody? just listen any Bumble song. he is GOD
saturasong 2 months ago
This sucks, what an ase for ruining slash's solo
MattyyyM 3 months ago
BUMBLEFOOT IS GOD!
sixxla 4 months ago
Wether people likes it or not, Slash will always be the real deal. Guns N' Roses owes a lot to Slash and his unique style.
daddywhetz 4 months ago
I dont like the new gnr but u have to admit, he did a good job here, still slash's way rules! :D
Gibsonkiller95 4 months ago
dead cloud..
chhau123 4 months ago
0:33 What da fuck is he doing with his right hand?
leandroafd 5 months ago
@leandroafd just damping the strings so dud notes don't ring out
drmoshie 5 months ago
@leandroafd keeping the strings quiet
eX0Noah 5 months ago
Axl should've at least changed the band name or just toured as Axl Rose.This is like David Lee Roth touring as Van Halen.
144church 5 months ago 4
Comment removed
LarryBmx1 5 months ago
guns now sucks!!
InsanityCreature 5 months ago 3
@InsanityCreature
You'll hate guns even more now that I'm going to shoot you in the face with one.
Fluffypopcicle 5 months ago
@Fluffypopcicle anda a cagar boludo!!!!!!
InsanityCreature 5 months ago
It's a very great solo but confused...
P4uloMF 6 months ago
holy shit he is totally on fire!
chhau123 6 months ago
GREAT SOLO , BUMBLEFOOT RULES !
cyraxxxxxxxx 6 months ago
Never mind the solo, Axl's voice was sounding the most impressive I've heard in a long time!
imdynamite7 7 months ago
Ronald J Blumenthal rules!!!
psaunited 8 months ago 2
I always regarded Buckethead's Nightrain solo as the best version but i've got say that this too in it's own way was just as good.
StonkerBuckshot 8 months ago
Buckethead owned bumble
Taybell10 8 months ago
the crowd is full of zombies
magisttr 8 months ago
@magisttr you mentioned zombies and i see 0:43
narfire214 7 months ago
@magisttr
dude i was there. 90% of the crowd watched the concerts since 18.00. Korn, then tool (sucked big time).
GN'R was schedueld forr 0.00 , but we all know our GN'R. SO They came to stage like 1:30, fuckin' rocked till the sun came out again. was fuckin' epic.
peterpuetz 7 months ago
@peterpuetz FUCK YOU MAN! IM JEALOUS! well at least you got some great memories to last a life time.
blaziankhmer 7 months ago
Didnt like that,the classic solo was replaced by technical dribble.
RhodesLives 8 months ago
@RhodesLives nothing overly technical there. you're either not a guitar player, a shit guitar player, a "feel" guitar player and the final option is just someone who complains because its not the top hatted one ripping up the fretboard. its a good solo, i prefer the original but if i was in his position i'd do the same thing. i'd probably have played a little closer to the original though (just a little) also its live it doesn't have to be note for note especially a guitar solo.
mrphilcollins 8 months ago
@mrphilcollins Either that or im someone who just didnt like the solo,simple as.
RhodesLives 8 months ago
@mrphilcollins If @RhodesLives didn't like this why you have to insult? Is your life so empty that you need to throw shit at someone else's comment so you can feel better? This solo doesn't even have the right 'sound' to start with. It doesn't matter who is playing it, it's about 'the original' vs 'this'. Slash changed this solo 100x times in the old days and it never sounded like some other thing, this is clearly some 'tap-tap' bullshit which I personally don't like in new Gn'R. That's it.
Pop2Lock 8 months ago 2
well i commented because i disagreed with what he had said. the solo wasn't amazing but its still far more than "technical dribble" by that same merit he just wrote off several types of guitar music not just rock. jesus he's wrote off classical music too. they all use dissonant notes flashes of speed etc. basically Bumblefoot is an amazing guitar player who for the most part respects slashs playing... however he has the right to play a different solo if he chooses...
mrphilcollins 8 months ago
I'm just saying that this band is not my favorite rock and roll from the 80s, as they were before. I still love this band, but it isn't the same.
MegaSLASH95 8 months ago
isso que dá por um guitarrista desses no gnr, ele transformou o solo de nightrain estilo musica pra anime ¬¬
cr7raposo 9 months ago
even though this still rocks it's still not as good as the man with the marlboro red ciggarette in his mouth !!!
bloodyrottie82 9 months ago
this dude kicks ass
masterofmorphine92 10 months ago 19
@masterofmorphine92 Yeah, it's a shame he didn't compose that, right??! Slash and Izzy did!! Long long time ago, when GnR were still THE GnR. World is full of good guitarist who can play it, but only few very talented people can write a riff like this which will be still played years and years later by others guys (who have NOT some good stuff like that written by themself to play).
Cescus86 5 months ago 5
@Cescus86 I don't even like GnR but Bumblefoot did an amazing work here.
masterofmorphine92 5 months ago
@Cescus86 How about This I Loves solo....or the solos in There Was A TIme??? They are some of the best I've heard. I loved Slash and Izzy's solos....but don't discount these guys just because they are playing olf GNR songs. These guys are talented!!
mhollod 4 months ago
@Cescus86 But only Ron, can make a masterpiece playing this solo :)
MrCraftCraft 1 week ago
Bumblefoot must be a younger brother of Slash...
BalthusCZ 10 months ago
Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
somondocano 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Buckethead = Awesome in his own style
Dj Ashba = Awesome in his own style
Bumblefoot = Awesome in his own style
Slash = Awesome in his own style
Richard Fortus = Awesome in his own style
There are such things as stylistic differences people
Estranged68 10 months ago
This is GUNS N' ROSES
Estranged68 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Buckethead = Awesome in his own style
Bumblefoot = Awesome in his own style
Slash = Awesome in his own style
Richard Fortus = Awesome in his own style
Dj Ashba = Awesome in his own style
There are such things as stylistic differences people
Estranged68 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Dj Ashba = Awesome in his own style
Richard Fortus = Awesome in his own style
Buckethead = Awesome in his own style
Bumblefoot = Awesome in his own style
Slash = Awesome in his own style
Estranged68 11 months ago
They fuckin rock!!
ajaxrulzz 11 months ago
GnR fans are such a fuckin' lucky guys.. We can hear great solos arranged by so many different style guitarists. Slash, Buckethead, Finck, Bumblefoot, Ashba, Fortus, Stradlin, even Tobias in Rocket Queen in 2001. We are lucky motherfuckers but also haters and in spite of LISTENING we are arguing which of them is better -,- Sad
LajSolSirius 11 months ago 62
@LajSolSirius D --> Damn, it's about time someone wrote that. Yeah, it really is c001 to hear so many different interpretations of the same songs. Though Buckethead is my personal favorite guitarist, each of them are great. Though I think I have been most impressed with Bumblefoot because he's been playing Buckethead's solos, and that is nothing to take lightly. Watching everyone play Paradise City is a true sight though.
StopRunningKid 8 months ago
@LajSolSirius well put
Scrappalino 5 months ago
@LajSolSirius i same with you...
MegaApit90 4 months ago
Great song.Watched new band two times,and old once,but some songs are much much better and with more power in interpretation by new band and "nighttrain" is one of them...I don't get people who compare new and old band,why do you do that...
Bfoot solo is amazing
igorsr12345 1 year ago 2
I'm a die-hard Slash fan, and I like Buckethead too, and I usually heavily dislike Axl & Co. But I have to admit; Bumblefoot fucking aced that solo.
TheKingAwesome 1 year ago
i preffer buckethead solo in this song
lostinspacex 1 year ago
ok change the bands name, get some new original material and get rid of axl and we would have an awesome rock/metal band right here!!! I'm a huge g n' r fan but re-hashing the old materials, espically with axl shit singing is ruining the originals, let them have their glory as classic old rock songs. atleast slash did a re-make of paradise city, and myles can sing nightrain better than axl now
adamKlD 1 year ago
Nothing, i mean NOTHING compare Slash in Guns N'Roses.
Giaco17s 1 year ago
Bumblefot's boss
fenepi 1 year ago
Best Nightrain solo ever? Slash is one of my favourite guitarists, but man, this solo, and this whole performance of the song (If you've never seen the full version from this gig, go watch it now!) is the best Guns has ever done.
AdamDK 1 year ago
damn... what a badass motherfucker
guitarczar15 1 year ago
awesome!!! as a lot of smart people say over here... just enjoy it! and forget if slash is better or buckethead or bumblefoot... Guns n' Roses!
Europinguino 1 year ago
Stop dissing Axl's guitarists. Just be glad that stink Finck is gone. Ashba is MUCH better than Robin is for Guns. I think that ChiDem would have been much better with Ashba on the record.
TheGuns1985 1 year ago
What a fKING awesime stage
himalchulicup 1 year ago
this can ron thal is my drum teachers brother jeff thal he tells me about him alot and iv met ron bcuzz of jeff but they got in a fight and dont talk
skyflare452 1 year ago
@skyflare452
Jeff was also Bumblefoot's drummer on "Hermit" & "Hands".
They haven't been making music for almost ten years now. Quite a shame because they were great together.
Great drummer.
TheGlow101 1 year ago
@TheGlow101 ya jeff is my drum teacher now in tampa florida hes great but ya they could have been great if they stayed together in new york
skyflare452 1 year ago
i thought the sweeps at the end were a little tasteless but other than that very good. Cool to see some one doing technical guitar playing over such a gritty hard rock song and still sounding cool.
superbeast3000 1 year ago
Bumblefoot is the consumate innovator.Note the tapping with the plecta edge on the humbucker to sweep 2 octaves over the high fretted notes etc. etc.R.T. kicks anyone's ass!!!
Wrightworth 1 year ago
Usando como argumento principal que Slash fue el que creó el riff y solo de Nightrain, ya lo hace mejor que Bumblefoot. Sin él, Bumblefoot no estaría parado en el escenario. Punto.
dhv18 1 year ago
Didnt really like the solo,sounded like some vai wank and not nightrain.
RhodesLives 1 year ago
@RhodesLives Don't worry, that's just due to ignorance ... it will disappear once you get some sort of education....
o0Slipdisc0o 1 year ago
@o0Slipdisc0o I doubt it
RhodesLives 1 year ago
Best version=Buckethead.
MrSparticus666 1 year ago
Damn, Bumblefoot rocks the shit out of that guitar. Buckethead may be my favorite guitarist in existence and Slash can rock the blues like no other, but jeez... this guy can jam. He was getting a little bit too off key with some of the solo though. I like his style a shitload though.
StopRunningKid 1 year ago
GnR now look like a cover band of Guns n Roses.....
Daz80 1 year ago
@Daz80
100 % AGREE
Oliverto1 1 year ago
It sucks that people keep adding slash to any comparisons, he's a studio and/or warm up guy...at best(insulting to true artists of the guitar). He's just a victim of the mass media, and people follow the mass media like sheep. And 'Deth0' said it in his post...'different styles', but i would omit slash, his 'style' is just filler for regurgitated 80's top 40 rock.
Maybe it comes down to money...you have the money to see any guitarist solo,who in their right mind would pay to see slash? lol.
ZOMBIELANDakaUSA 1 year ago
If Axl and Slash ever do tour together again, they need to keep Thal so the two can have a guitar duel in Nightrain.
SteveNeuge 1 year ago
stinson looks like an idiot to me...no image at all......ron thal is great...there's no need to tell it...
slikkar 1 year ago
It's good to see the crowd is as dead as the band's career.
LikuX 1 year ago
is Axel reading his lyrics off a Teleprompter 0:42
snipazcamper2 1 year ago
@snipazcamper2 yes
ReBeLhIpI 1 year ago
@snipazcamper2 AXL, does that for such a long time, you can see that in tokyo dvd
beptube 1 year ago
to be honest i'd rather play his version of the nightrain solo than play exactly what slash plays, cause then you guys would be like bumblefoot is just a copy of slash and a slash wannabe! So go bumblefoot! the best guitar player in the current lineup!
toxin789 1 year ago
that was top drawer soloing but Bumblefoot is way better without GnR and to those that say aww but Slash did it first, I really dont remember Slash doing it anything like that, theres a lot of improv in there, a fucking LOT!!!!
F4TB0Y69 1 year ago
This sounds WAY better than KFC idiot
Liturgyofwar 1 year ago
@Liturgyofwar You got to be joking.
Really.
xTiLkx 1 year ago
@xTiLkx
Sounds 100 times better in phrasing and tone
Liturgyofwar 1 year ago
@Liturgyofwar Mother of God man, are you tone-deaf?
watch?v=Ylgv-Rg_L5E
It's because the audio quality is better that his tone and phrasing is better..
xTiLkx 1 year ago
@xTiLkx
Keep those insults for youself while you try to fugure out what's real music
Liturgyofwar 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Liturgyofwar I have. A very long time ago.
Why don't you come and join me:
watch?v=RJa9kaT7Lms
xTiLkx 1 year ago
@Liturgyofwar Not* because
xTiLkx 1 year ago
@Liturgyofwar dont insult Buckethead u fucking motherfucker.
kivanaj 1 year ago
@kivanaj
Hes an idiot.Sorry what did you say?lol
Liturgyofwar 1 year ago
Old but fucking cool !!! I Love Mr. Ron 'Bumblefoot' Thal : ) I also like the Bumblefoot and the Slash version, they are really different ...
reisselpud 1 year ago
i am technically better than slash .am i better guitarist ? am i fuck.slash got somthing lads its not technic but the man got it .except when hes pissed that is .
MUDSHARK111 1 year ago
umm...can i just say something about this whole slash V bumblefoot thing.
Its Slashs fucking solo!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He wrote it first, he performed it first, everyone else is copying him! Sure, lots of artists can reproduce the Mona Lisa, but Leonardo Da Vinci's will always be the original and the best.
Well done bumblefoot, im sure slash would think you did a great job, and you did (no doubt about that). Too bad youre not Slash!
Daz80 1 year ago
@Daz80 Slash can't play a single one of bumblefoot's solos.
jaytonbye 1 year ago
@jaytonbye Maybe he can't but I betcha bumblefoot can't play a single one of slash's solos like he can either.
They're different artists, stop comparing
mdogg101slash 1 year ago
@mdogg101slash I'd say he could - I've heard him do some pretty simple pentatonic stuff too. And besides, anyone would have to admit that it is a lot easier to do accurate mimicry of slash than in is the foot
ibanezbloke 1 year ago
Some retards compare slash and bumblefoot but both guitarists have different style.You can't compare slash who is playing hard rock with bubmlefoot who has metal style.
SLaSh2VX 1 year ago
Slash's night train solo is 37,589 times better than this.
xxzzxx99 1 year ago
Good guitar player, for that style and comes across as a nice fella but for me Axl hasn't been able to find a player who can phrase and structure aswell as Slash. Thats a god given talent and give me him over every single whizz bang hired guy Axl has had since the nineties
TheHom 1 year ago
If you say this solo sucks just because its fast i will slap you and i will never respect you as a lover of music.
LehmannDaHero 1 year ago
Yeah Baby!~!
Dudeprelude69 1 year ago
awful
SaintDrizzly 1 year ago
wow that booblefoot guy is really really awful. lolshredding
SaintDrizzly 1 year ago
he sucks slash for ever!
acdcgnrledzepp 1 year ago
I love Bumblefoot, Normal is such an amazing album. It's a shame people write him off as a shredder just because he can play some flashier stuff. He's a great singer too.
ChucklesMginty 1 year ago
plz but this in Palladia
MrSilverDany 1 year ago
DAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUMMMMMMMMMMMMM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ydnalor 1 year ago
whoa axl's voice isn't as bad as i thought
TheAppieJj 1 year ago
i dont know what to think of this solo.. the guy has mad skills, but this composing doesnt do it for me. i dont know where hes going with it. i just hear bends and pinch harmonics.
retx101 1 year ago 2
Buckethead = Awesome in his own style
Bumblefoot = Awesome in his own style
Slash = Awesome in his own style
There are such things as stylistic differences people
Deth0 1 year ago 91
@Deth0 I LOVE YOU
martyfischetti 1 year ago
@Deth0 Finally someone who doesn't have to say slash is king. It's like comparing apples and oranges,
xxnwoxx 1 year ago
@Deth0 Buckethead = Awesome in his own style
Slash = Awesome in his own style
Bumblefoot = awesome at everyone's style.
flacidReece 11 months ago
@flacidReece - Amen to that dude. Guthrie Govan says Ron is hands down the best guitar player on earth, how can you argue with that =)
Hardysamnin 10 months ago
@Deth0 Dude ... You totally get it... :D
marcjuh11 10 months ago
@Deth0 true enough but for guns n roses its slash....no one else..love bumblefoot though..
mulholland1985 9 months ago
Endless arguments about Bumblefoot, Buckethead and Slash as always. It goes like this, Slash is the shit. Bumblefoot is the shit. Buckethead = Kinda shitty.
CatGameDaiyE 1 year ago
Gah I want to know what bumblefoot is doing around 0:35 - a tab would be awesome!
Baadger 1 year ago
slash is alot slower but more melodic and intresting-every note hase meaning-but bumble foot is pure shredding power of doom but u cant fell 1000 notes in 1 second, both thal is obviusly more skilled but slash is pure feeling so both are great to listen too-some guitarist are supposed to play slow and some are supposed to be demon shredders -its called variety
lonewolfshogun 1 year ago
@lonewolfshogun I don't think that Bumblefoot is a real demon shredder. He's not always just speed and skill. He mixes slow and fast melodies, and these arpeggios you can hear are just fragmented chords which announce the colour of the solo he plays.
Also, Slash plays beautiful solos, opened to weak and experimented ears. Bumblefoot's are more difficult to feel and hear, but alot more interesting.
I say what I want, but these two guitar players are both rock heroes and music gods.
badassII 1 year ago
In my opinion, Buckethead fits more with his compositions in GNR., But Thal is fucking increnible.
Thals solo in the concert in Norway was fucking increndible.
heihei2300 1 year ago
bumblefoot destroys slash, but slash definitely does this solo much better than bumblefoot. slash had much more melody.
Fluffypopcicle 1 year ago
i like bumblefoots style of playing allot (going to meet him in person on monday xD) but a cover will never be as good as the original...
iggvf 1 year ago
axl needs to lose those dreadlocks...
theboywhocantollie 1 year ago
epic shit...solo is way better than buckethead...more bends, more feeling, closer to the original version...the whole band is rocking fucking hard! axl is the man...all you haters are just dicks who don't know shit about this band.
PedroRiot 1 year ago