I love listening to her versions of the old songs. It's like painting a house, you get sick of looking at (listening to) the same thing for years, throw on a new coat of paint (singer) and its a whole new house (song)
Tarja voice's even if it's good is nothing opposite anette's,she can sing in many ways from really metal(her voice is so strooooong) to warm and emotional songs
I'm probably going to be flamed by several people for this, but there is no competition in this song. Anette is SO much better at singing this song than Tarja. This gig in particular is outstanding.
Wow! I have heard several versions of this song sang by Anette and this is the best so far!! Perfect!! when she doesnt play with her voice she sing beautiful...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I am afraid I just cannot get behind Annette. Her voice does nothing for me, this was the first time I have listened to this song and felt nothing, and I did not even know it was a new singer until I looked at the comments, I thought Tarja was just having a really bad night.
i think i'm addicted with nightwish, recently more than ever especially the new era, i don't know why.. i listen to dpp everyday, poet and pendulum all the time, listen to new versions like this a lot.. i love tuomas
this is definately one of my Nightwish favorites, and I was there in Rotterdam when they played this version. I LOVE It! Love the final part with the awsome long solo!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Saw them life on Saturday and they performed it. Its definitely not Anettes song to sing, I think her Roxette-like tremollos really destroy this sad ballad that was written for Tarja's voice. They might go well for other tunes but I was surprised to see how bad Nemo sounded in her interpretation. I guess its somehow understandable but imo the Tarja original performances will remain the standard she'll never reach for some songs that really dont fit her voice. It sounded like a good karaoke
I've always loved Anette, I think it's stupid that people get mad at her for not being Tarja-like. It's not her fault. She's wonderfully talented in her own special way!
I've been an Anette lover since the beginning... I fellow in love with her voice when I first listened Eva... Dead boy's poem is my Nightwish's favorite slow song and the performance of Tarja singing it is really great ... but i have to say... Anette have more passion... and I prefer her angelical voice..
Gorgeous, much better than the Album version and I'm a Tarja lover. I haven't seen them live but I didn't like Anette back in 07/08, I could see in videos that she sounded very forced but after a long time I decided to watch some recent videos and I love how much she did grow making many songs "hers". For me the great NW period was until OTHAFW but I seem to like more Anette's versions of the later songs ('cept Ever Dream and The Siren) and enjoy some of the pre CC ones, Anette is fantastic!
so many people talk down on metal with keyboards in it......if you saw the nw show in texas day bfore yesterday seeing tuomas will change youre mind..these guys are loud and clear ...al around exellent musicians and theyre doin this damn near every night......shit i got nothing but respect.....volbeat was actually really good as well.......
Fabulous!!! Singing with heart. Thx Nightwish, I love your music forever. Tarja or Anette? What´s a problem? For me is important only one... NW keep going on!!! I love past I love present and I don´t doubt - I will love in the future. Tuomas is the best.
Beautiful, I really did not like this song with tarja, because with her it just sounded so morbid and dark, but by anette's versions even in alow-quality live version, I see its true beauty and she's just so maternal and graceful. I always thought that on all the soft songs tarja always went over the top. Anette just sings , but she sings it directly form her heart to your heart which is something rare.
On addition to this, anyway, I must say that almost all Nightwish ballads are supposed to be sung like this. It's not like some piece of museum that must be displayed with all the lack of modesty or some vocal virtuosity exercise. It's just an extremely soft and melancholic song that must be let flow. Without any unnecessary ornamentation or exaggerated intensity. Same goes for Sleeping Sun and Ever Dream, if you ask me.
thanx. I actually think tarja's a really great singer and I would adore her if I saw her on broadway or somewhere like that but opera and metal for me just don't fit. Anette is just so much better at this song. I just wish they did the ending :(
Oh well, that one might have been a little bit too difficult for her, actually. It's not about the notes, but having to support them with the diaphragm and breathing and all. Anette handles the heights of the notes really well as long as they're short, but that part isn't really an easy one. Plus, they had already gotten it out during a couple of gigs in 2004, you can check. Probably wasn't so easy for Tarja either.
"But we do know her voice isn't capable of mastering it"
Her voice is, from my point of view, perfectly capable for that part.
At first they said she wouldn't be able to pull off DPP songs live, and she did, then they doubted about Dark Chest of Wonders, but she did. Next it was Escapist, and again she did.
Now Dead boy's poem. everyone said she wouldn't be able to pull it off, but she perfectly did!!
So STFU, she has proven enough already to keep doubting.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
So they did it for their dvds. We don't know if Anette will do it for the next dvd. But we do know her voice isn't capable of mastering it. And by "recorded performances" I thought you meant only the performances recorded on their album. Not their dvd.
The end has been missing since 2004. Look for the versions in Romania and Minneapolis, it's not there. They've put it aside since then, why should they get it back now?:P
Dont say emppu is a regular guitarist. Emppu is the guitarist who made Nightwish a succes. (with the band and tarja). Then Tarja left and Anette joined to do a great performence at stage. So if Emppu is a regular guitarist why Nightwish is such a great band? And why is Nightwish famous all over the world then? Tell me!
I make music (play guitar) and to me Emppu is very personal stylish guitarist and I like him.Many metal people thinking that you are a good guitarist if you can play so fast as you can.All the 5 members of NW are great musicians so you don't have to wonder their success!
@BrandonHarami I think that all the nightwish songs are perfect for the souls, it dosent matter who sing, I like the metal music, and I know so many and nightwish is the only one who can take in a perfect hideaway, and make me feel lonely and content at the same time, is a rare kind of happiness....into a lagoon
I can't stop listening to this solo, it's so goddamn epic! Couldn't decide whether or not to buy tickets for this concert and ended up not going, such a shame.
I really love Nightwish but i more prefer this song with Tarja but most of the songs are better of with Anette. I was at this concert and it was surely the best time of my life.!
If i ever read a comment that Emppu is regular or mediocre guitar player im gonna twist of their head and keep it in a bottle..they have to let this guy play more solos
Actually, he is. He's good at playing rhythm, but solos are not his strong side. Most of the time his solos either repeat the tune or are some random shreddings. And he doesn't have vibrato.
I am not a big fan of Anette in this band. They still sound like a really excellent Nightwish cover band to me. However, she does this song beautifully. I actually got shivers - something that Anette's voice has failed to do for me thus far. Absolutely lovely rendition of the song. Well done. :)
Anette is just a pro here. Take more three month breaks, Nightwish! Not only do you get Tarot to be active again, you also get vast improvements with Anette's voice!
at the end of the song ,emppu played the solo differernt than the original version ,it's awsome new version and kicked ass,awsome performance by the awsome(NIGHTWISH).
02:37 is sooo beautiful. Anette sings this song in a really wonderful way. I love it! She is a great singer. She is getting better and better, and I love her voice in thee melodic songs. Anette, and of course Nightwish, you ROCK!
Anette is awesome..this sounds so awesome and touching..Anette's voice is kinda really warm and i love it <3 i have no reasons to hate Anette. She's just so great singer <33 i can't realize why some people hate her..just so great singer.
for me tarja was always better than annete. but recently i think annete is surpassing her, especially in those soft songs. cant wait to see Eva, For the Heart I Once Had and Meadows of Heaven live.
meadow's of heaven is a very good song Iflaviorochan. I hope they put that as their outro. as for eva they already sung that live and for the heart i once had they haven't done yet.
i don't want to talk about Tarja because i don't wanna start a fight, but i prefer Anette almost in every old nightwish songs. Anette is incredible singer <3
This is much for her voice ? I don´t thing. She sings it really AMAZING! She sings with her heart and she haven´t any problems with this song,so her voice is better and better and she can sings all songs in Nightwish :) Nightwish forever, you are better than ever !!!!
I truly appreciate the respect and the balance in your comment, but I don't think we're the ones to decide what is too much for Anette's voice and what is not.
I personally think she's given this song its quality as a ballad, simple as that. It stopped being something bombastic, strong and full, which was beautiful nevertheless, now it's more delicate, but not fragile, touching, but not overdone. :)
"i love annette and her voice but this is just too much for her voice ...
this song belongs to tarja's voice"
I happen to like Anette's version better than Tarja's. Tarja's was cold and robotic. Anette makes the song alive and gives it feeling. And she certainly has the voice for it.
Blackdawn4-maybe Toumas changed it around a little. I've noticed slight changes in a lot of the old songs. I'm sure they rehearsed, so if it was incorrect someone would mention it to her.
o m g, did anybody ask your opinion about anything? I think I speak for all of us when I say that you can go and shut the whole AAA army the hell up and finally admit that she's an excellent and capable singer and woman!
saw this at brixton, London last wednesday - made me feel like i was gonna cry my lil heart out haha, its so amazing. i love nightwish so much.<3 shes an incredible singer. they're an incredible band.
I love listening to her versions of the old songs. It's like painting a house, you get sick of looking at (listening to) the same thing for years, throw on a new coat of paint (singer) and its a whole new house (song)
hardraynesgonnafall 2 months ago
A lonely soul... An Ocean Soul...????????????
lorien52 6 months ago
@lorien52
They dont play that part maybe.. 7-8 years
babatoa 5 months ago
THIS is the reason why they hired Anette. This is simply amazing.
Blueyluvscheese 8 months ago 4
hahaha
karol243104 11 months ago
Tarja voice's even if it's good is nothing opposite anette's,she can sing in many ways from really metal(her voice is so strooooong) to warm and emotional songs
karol243104 11 months ago
God...Anettes voice is so beautiful. It never fails to amaze and captivate me...
FrostFallenPoet 11 months ago
I'm probably going to be flamed by several people for this, but there is no competition in this song. Anette is SO much better at singing this song than Tarja. This gig in particular is outstanding.
jennythemusicmaker 1 year ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
2:35 WIN!!!!!!!! <3 it so much.
harrawrson 1 year ago
2:35 WIN!!!!!!!! <3 it so much.
harrawrson 1 year ago 3
It was so great being there, Anette wasn't as bad as I expected from all YouTube comments. This song sounded just great
moonIight93 2 years ago 6
Annette is amazing. She really sings the old songs well
Xboxgamer242 2 years ago 3
Yes, his interpretion is really really beautiful ... She put many emotions in, that makes me cry ...
MissTFC 2 years ago 4
i dedicate tis song for 'little people' at Africa,Afghanistan, & Iraq,who was live in 'Hell World' created by Monsterous Man
s0nixGear 2 years ago
these old are songs for tarjas voice, and its a greater feeling when tarja sings it, but its not bad although
DeimosPanturas 2 years ago
and VIVA EMMPU!!!
sylkar8 2 years ago
Wow! I have heard several versions of this song sang by Anette and this is the best so far!! Perfect!! when she doesnt play with her voice she sing beautiful...
sylkar8 2 years ago
this sound makes me so grateful...
RuinedPlans 2 years ago
Very nice song... Anette sing very well
0dalomismoweon0 2 years ago
Anette nails this song! Pure magic! And only 5 nights to go until I see them again...and maybe hear this too :)
suffeli72 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I am afraid I just cannot get behind Annette. Her voice does nothing for me, this was the first time I have listened to this song and felt nothing, and I did not even know it was a new singer until I looked at the comments, I thought Tarja was just having a really bad night.
midian1369 2 years ago
i think i'm addicted with nightwish, recently more than ever especially the new era, i don't know why.. i listen to dpp everyday, poet and pendulum all the time, listen to new versions like this a lot.. i love tuomas
BurgerOfFilth 2 years ago 5
It's just amazing how a song can be so full of emotions... The guitar solo makes me cry sometimes.
Teach my Passion. ;)
NightwishTimmi 2 years ago
Hey, the guitar solo isn't that bad :D
MadHobbit 2 years ago
amazing
i cried when they performed this in london this year
anette your amazing
Zydratezombie 2 years ago 3
So did I.
MistressPassionGreed 2 years ago
i am glad i am not the only one hehe
i think anette did a brilliant job of this song
Zydratezombie 2 years ago 2
Yeah. In fact, I think she did a better job of it than Tarja.
MistressPassionGreed 2 years ago 6
i agree
anette has more passion and she just sang this song so beautifully
anette is amazing
Zydratezombie 2 years ago 5
this is definately one of my Nightwish favorites, and I was there in Rotterdam when they played this version. I LOVE It! Love the final part with the awsome long solo!
mastervestieri 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Saw them life on Saturday and they performed it. Its definitely not Anettes song to sing, I think her Roxette-like tremollos really destroy this sad ballad that was written for Tarja's voice. They might go well for other tunes but I was surprised to see how bad Nemo sounded in her interpretation. I guess its somehow understandable but imo the Tarja original performances will remain the standard she'll never reach for some songs that really dont fit her voice. It sounded like a good karaoke
Hunt4Tzapi 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
omg fucking sux song with this bitch anette
Norf1989Tricker 2 years ago
I've always loved Anette, I think it's stupid that people get mad at her for not being Tarja-like. It's not her fault. She's wonderfully talented in her own special way!
just9988 2 years ago 11
I've been an Anette lover since the beginning... I fellow in love with her voice when I first listened Eva... Dead boy's poem is my Nightwish's favorite slow song and the performance of Tarja singing it is really great ... but i have to say... Anette have more passion... and I prefer her angelical voice..
willagsp 2 years ago 7
OMG! Maybe she doesn't do opera. But there's so much emotion in her interpretation! She adds soul to her perfomance. Amazing!
mofrakker 2 years ago 7
a very beautiful song
dulcecavalera 2 years ago 3
is this Anette 0.o ?
its a beautyful song singing door Anette, but i better like Tarja ^^
XxLoezyxX 2 years ago
Gorgeous, much better than the Album version and I'm a Tarja lover. I haven't seen them live but I didn't like Anette back in 07/08, I could see in videos that she sounded very forced but after a long time I decided to watch some recent videos and I love how much she did grow making many songs "hers". For me the great NW period was until OTHAFW but I seem to like more Anette's versions of the later songs ('cept Ever Dream and The Siren) and enjoy some of the pre CC ones, Anette is fantastic!
Astraknight 2 years ago
it was so amazing. she is a great singer!
anne0mika 2 years ago 4
I hope same
Pexi1991 2 years ago
This is one of the best older songs sung by Anette. I hope they play this at Hartwall Arena in September.
Jupa88 2 years ago 8
This song with Anette is so beautiful...
AkuraNanabi 2 years ago 7
so many people talk down on metal with keyboards in it......if you saw the nw show in texas day bfore yesterday seeing tuomas will change youre mind..these guys are loud and clear ...al around exellent musicians and theyre doin this damn near every night......shit i got nothing but respect.....volbeat was actually really good as well.......
goth8thug 2 years ago 5
Fabulous!!! Singing with heart. Thx Nightwish, I love your music forever. Tarja or Anette? What´s a problem? For me is important only one... NW keep going on!!! I love past I love present and I don´t doubt - I will love in the future. Tuomas is the best.
Morgaanalefay 2 years ago 14
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Have you ever heard Tarja's version? Waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay better
mariusica20 2 years ago
Beautiful, I really did not like this song with tarja, because with her it just sounded so morbid and dark, but by anette's versions even in alow-quality live version, I see its true beauty and she's just so maternal and graceful. I always thought that on all the soft songs tarja always went over the top. Anette just sings , but she sings it directly form her heart to your heart which is something rare.
YOU ROK ANETTE
ROK ON 4EVA YEAH! >8D
Hippydude777 2 years ago 11
I couldn't agree more! You just put it perfectly.
On addition to this, anyway, I must say that almost all Nightwish ballads are supposed to be sung like this. It's not like some piece of museum that must be displayed with all the lack of modesty or some vocal virtuosity exercise. It's just an extremely soft and melancholic song that must be let flow. Without any unnecessary ornamentation or exaggerated intensity. Same goes for Sleeping Sun and Ever Dream, if you ask me.
EndlessCompassion 2 years ago
thanx. I actually think tarja's a really great singer and I would adore her if I saw her on broadway or somewhere like that but opera and metal for me just don't fit. Anette is just so much better at this song. I just wish they did the ending :(
Hippydude777 2 years ago
Oh well, that one might have been a little bit too difficult for her, actually. It's not about the notes, but having to support them with the diaphragm and breathing and all. Anette handles the heights of the notes really well as long as they're short, but that part isn't really an easy one. Plus, they had already gotten it out during a couple of gigs in 2004, you can check. Probably wasn't so easy for Tarja either.
EndlessCompassion 2 years ago
"But we do know her voice isn't capable of mastering it"
Her voice is, from my point of view, perfectly capable for that part.
At first they said she wouldn't be able to pull off DPP songs live, and she did, then they doubted about Dark Chest of Wonders, but she did. Next it was Escapist, and again she did.
Now Dead boy's poem. everyone said she wouldn't be able to pull it off, but she perfectly did!!
So STFU, she has proven enough already to keep doubting.
MrReason09 2 years ago 36
My God She sings this song great. So much power and emotion into it. I just love this girl
AnetteOlzonItalia 2 years ago 5
she sounds amazing!
playgroundlove91 2 years ago 7
I ADORE this song!
And I ADORE Anette!! <3
She is so beautiful and her voice also!!
Never gonna miss respect to Tarja cause I ADORE Tarja too,
but I admit that I REALLY ADORE ANETTE!
Great video!
Thanks for sharing
Panther593 2 years ago 4
NOOOOO! Its missing the end part where its like "A lonly SOUL!!!". Thats what made the song. Tarja made the song.
community647 2 years ago
@Community647:
The song just as it is right now is an excelent song; and does not need the "OceanSoul" part.
however, Tarja didn't sing that part either, because Tuomas didn't like it, and they only did it for the recorded performances.
MrReason09 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
They always did that part live with Tarja!!! Look at the video log on my profile. Or just search it yourself thos song is ruined with Anette.
community647 2 years ago
community647, i suggest you READ THE COMMENTS before saying anything. so go on and read my comment again...ready? done?
now guess what, FWTE is a RECORDED PERFORMANCE, DVD release.
watch?v=V51X8nGJyOg
watch?v=tr9wHWYg10c
MrReason09 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
So they did it for their dvds. We don't know if Anette will do it for the next dvd. But we do know her voice isn't capable of mastering it. And by "recorded performances" I thought you meant only the performances recorded on their album. Not their dvd.
community647 2 years ago
if you think that, you're very very estupid!!! ;)
soraelegido 2 years ago
IT's true!!!!
Tchebycheef 2 years ago
awsome version and i was there :D
mastervestieri 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The different solo was pretty cool but they totally butchered the song.. the end was fucking missing! What the fuck?!?!?
SRAMVS 2 years ago
The end has been missing since 2004. Look for the versions in Romania and Minneapolis, it's not there. They've put it aside since then, why should they get it back now?:P
EndlessCompassion 2 years ago
HOW DOES SHE DO THAT?! daaaaaaaaaaamn
Michellevca 2 years ago 8
Comment removed
Nightwish15March09 2 years ago
Dont say emppu is a regular guitarist. Emppu is the guitarist who made Nightwish a succes. (with the band and tarja). Then Tarja left and Anette joined to do a great performence at stage. So if Emppu is a regular guitarist why Nightwish is such a great band? And why is Nightwish famous all over the world then? Tell me!
Nightwish15March09 2 years ago 2
I make music (play guitar) and to me Emppu is very personal stylish guitarist and I like him.Many metal people thinking that you are a good guitarist if you can play so fast as you can.All the 5 members of NW are great musicians so you don't have to wonder their success!
RockSidi 2 years ago 9
This song is perfect for Anette.
Any song that has a "motherly" feel is excellent for her.
I'm curious how she would sound singing "Swanheart".
BrandonHarami 2 years ago 41
I'm curious about that too =D
MoonAngelsTears 2 years ago 11
@BrandonHarami I think that all the nightwish songs are perfect for the souls, it dosent matter who sing, I like the metal music, and I know so many and nightwish is the only one who can take in a perfect hideaway, and make me feel lonely and content at the same time, is a rare kind of happiness....into a lagoon
musikmood 1 year ago
@BrandonHarami yeah, I also want to listen "Swanheart" in her performance. may be in the next tour we will listen, who knows..
Sun2strider 9 months ago
tarja or anette, this song always kicks ass =)
ichwillsalat 2 years ago 13
This has been flagged as spam show
Facepalm for Anette -.-
Tarja Owna...
sairamon 2 years ago
soooo cool. can't stop listening this song....anette, you rock!
BogdanGitarista 2 years ago 8
I can't stop listening to this solo, it's so goddamn epic! Couldn't decide whether or not to buy tickets for this concert and ended up not going, such a shame.
Grovies 2 years ago 7
it's not a poem its a funeral dirge (
HenryHendricsson 2 years ago
I really love Nightwish but i more prefer this song with Tarja but most of the songs are better of with Anette. I was at this concert and it was surely the best time of my life.!
Nightwish15March09 2 years ago 2
Great video !!!!!!! I love it ...
smanu59 2 years ago 6
If i ever read a comment that Emppu is regular or mediocre guitar player im gonna twist of their head and keep it in a bottle..they have to let this guy play more solos
KevinCarey 2 years ago 7
People like accusing people in NW of being mediocre. I've heard the same thing about Anette, Tarja, and maybe even Jukka. :p
Maaizz 2 years ago 3
Actually, he is. He's good at playing rhythm, but solos are not his strong side. Most of the time his solos either repeat the tune or are some random shreddings. And he doesn't have vibrato.
rozz0666 2 years ago
He's a good guitarist, Tuomas just hasn't been using him correctly. There are many better guitarists than him, though.
1AzureSky 2 years ago
-.-!lol!
keineruma 2 years ago
beautiful!! I have tears in my eyes!
oh, god...tomorrow I'm gonna see them live!! :-)
maiden666baby 2 years ago 3
I am not a big fan of Anette in this band. They still sound like a really excellent Nightwish cover band to me. However, she does this song beautifully. I actually got shivers - something that Anette's voice has failed to do for me thus far. Absolutely lovely rendition of the song. Well done. :)
OrbWeaver 2 years ago 2
WHERE DID MY LOVE FOR THIS BAND GO?! D:
Anette is just a pro here. Take more three month breaks, Nightwish! Not only do you get Tarot to be active again, you also get vast improvements with Anette's voice!
1AzureSky 2 years ago
Anette is soooooo amazing!!!!:) i love her!!
haaaveyoumetted 2 years ago 6
Such a beautiful version of this song. I was there and thought it was absolutely amazing!! Thanks for uploading!!
PhilippaRM 2 years ago 4
Beautiful. :) She's so good... And I liked Emppu's "Walking In The Air" -part. They are just awesome!!
Soyalecitin 2 years ago 6
at the end of the song ,emppu played the solo differernt than the original version ,it's awsome new version and kicked ass,awsome performance by the awsome(NIGHTWISH).
bignade00 2 years ago 12
Anette is just amazing in this song. So beautiful <3
anotherstrangerme 2 years ago 7
This is so beautiful and touching song. Makes me always cry because this brings some sad memories of my friend to my mind :'(
So beautiful song <3
ironheaven 2 years ago 4
She sings this one so well, so full of emotion (not that Tarja didn't). *cries*
Juliette9990 2 years ago 6
The Walking In The Air solo is pretty cool, though the original solo was cooler.
WritherInSilence 2 years ago 4
yesterday i watched your vids from Nightwish concert and at night I had a dream I was at the concert, lol xD i like it :)
truskawka92 2 years ago
OMG YESSSSSSSSSSSSS
BrandonHarami 2 years ago
simply.....beautiful.!
BogdanGitarista 2 years ago 3
What happened to the other part of the song? I
voor23 2 years ago
"What happened to the other part of the song?"
Lol. Tuomas said something about him not really liking the regular part from DBP.
JRadicalll 2 years ago
02:37 is sooo beautiful. Anette sings this song in a really wonderful way. I love it! She is a great singer. She is getting better and better, and I love her voice in thee melodic songs. Anette, and of course Nightwish, you ROCK!
Titti0913 2 years ago 4
to the ones who say that anette sings like BRITNEY SPEARS... Ask Britney to sing this song... without playback...PLEASE....
GIUMAX73 2 years ago 4
Anette is awesome..this sounds so awesome and touching..Anette's voice is kinda really warm and i love it <3 i have no reasons to hate Anette. She's just so great singer <33 i can't realize why some people hate her..just so great singer.
ironheaven 2 years ago 9
I haven't noticed... the stage is sea-themed ^^'... Tuomas is in a boat (or so it seems) and there is an anchor too... great idea ;-)
celticgirl08 2 years ago 3
perfect ambiance for The Islander
KevinCarey 2 years ago
for me tarja was always better than annete. but recently i think annete is surpassing her, especially in those soft songs. cant wait to see Eva, For the Heart I Once Had and Meadows of Heaven live.
lflaviorochan 2 years ago 4
meadow's of heaven is a very good song Iflaviorochan. I hope they put that as their outro. as for eva they already sung that live and for the heart i once had they haven't done yet.
lqleviathan 2 years ago
I longed for hearing Anette singing this song... And it's even better than I thought it would be! And guys are dazzling too :)
Just keep it up, Nightwish!
vinonak 2 years ago 8
i don't want to talk about Tarja because i don't wanna start a fight, but i prefer Anette almost in every old nightwish songs. Anette is incredible singer <3
ironheaven 2 years ago 5
This is much for her voice ? I don´t thing. She sings it really AMAZING! She sings with her heart and she haven´t any problems with this song,so her voice is better and better and she can sings all songs in Nightwish :) Nightwish forever, you are better than ever !!!!
barunka0010 2 years ago 12
This comment has received too many negative votes show
...yeah right!.. Tarja has more beautiful voice.....
blindmaiden211 2 years ago
Comment removed
jauda99 2 years ago
no songs belong to tarja!!.. Anette is the singer of nightwish, she is part of nightwish, tarja doesn't
blessnightmetal 2 years ago 15
I completly agree with you...
muzzykaaa 2 years ago 2
I truly appreciate the respect and the balance in your comment, but I don't think we're the ones to decide what is too much for Anette's voice and what is not.
I personally think she's given this song its quality as a ballad, simple as that. It stopped being something bombastic, strong and full, which was beautiful nevertheless, now it's more delicate, but not fragile, touching, but not overdone. :)
EndlessCompassion 2 years ago
"i love annette and her voice but this is just too much for her voice ...
this song belongs to tarja's voice"
I happen to like Anette's version better than Tarja's. Tarja's was cold and robotic. Anette makes the song alive and gives it feeling. And she certainly has the voice for it.
YulieAna 2 years ago 7
well a meanig is like an asshole .... al got 1 :)
jauda99 2 years ago
along with cliche slogans
YulieAna 2 years ago
completely agree with u there.
xsweetxsacrificex 2 years ago
Blackdawn4-maybe Toumas changed it around a little. I've noticed slight changes in a lot of the old songs. I'm sure they rehearsed, so if it was incorrect someone would mention it to her.
Still amazing and sung right from the heart!
petsitterlinda 2 years ago
anette have really a beautiful voice wow!!!
badbones75 2 years ago
Emppu has added Walking in the air theme to the end f his guitar solo!! great!
omnislo1 2 years ago
wow, this is brilliant.
akaleez88 2 years ago 2
i think she sometimes messes up with the lyrics but that's ok
she's really singing very well now. chapeau
lulalely 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
And where is the end of this song??? It is for Anette hard....
ywonita 2 years ago
o m g, did anybody ask your opinion about anything? I think I speak for all of us when I say that you can go and shut the whole AAA army the hell up and finally admit that she's an excellent and capable singer and woman!
luukkucom 2 years ago
And by "you" I mean "ywonita"
luukkucom 2 years ago
i love anette. she makes this song much softer and nicer. :)
is she completely blonde again?
katja999 2 years ago 8
This is better than Tarjas vocals. Anette forever!
Metall1st 2 years ago 4
ahem. *ROFL* not. at all.
deutschesmaedchen 2 years ago
thats it, im crying ! Love her!
Maxcaster 2 years ago 8
saw this at brixton, London last wednesday - made me feel like i was gonna cry my lil heart out haha, its so amazing. i love nightwish so much.<3 shes an incredible singer. they're an incredible band.
xsweetxsacrificex 2 years ago 8
Thanks Anette for this so beautiful version♥ [2]
I mean, is there anything more beautiful than listenning to her singing with all her heart? *-*
silenttears728 2 years ago 7
Absolutely beautiful performance! Anettes belting is just perfect here and she took this song to a whole new level. Better than the original..
Zeliziouz 2 years ago 9
Thanks Anette for this so beautiful version♥
chichi62ju 2 years ago 13
I couldn't imagine Anette singing this song or Ghost Love Score. But hey, she does a damn good job!
KindDerEwigkeit 2 years ago 18
I didn't either... But the way she manipulates her voice in both of them is just magnificent...
h06anbjo 2 years ago
Anette truly is an angel. She is one of those rare people who sing out of their heart and right into the listener's. <3
OpheliaLestrange 2 years ago 19
Never sigh for better world
It's already composed, played and told
Every thought the music I write
Every wish is this morning light
Why was the last line changed? :p
Blackdawn4 2 years ago
I think that she messed up the lyrics a bit... She also sings written instead of played... But I don't think it's that bad...
h06anbjo 2 years ago
whooooo thank you for this awsome Vid!!!! good for remembering this beautiful version of this song yesterday! Thanks!
mastervestieri 2 years ago 3
She has the BEST voice in the world :) She is my angel :) Nightwish forever !
barunka0010 2 years ago 17
Thank you so much for uploading this =).
Anette's version made me love this song even more. Cheers
NettanFairy 2 years ago 16
Mooie opname! :-)
boteci2001 2 years ago