Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (2,911)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Watch this, then watch Miley Cyrus on Dancing With The Stars, or Demi Lovato on Dancing With The Stars.

  • the 764 likes show how many stupid girls there are out there.

  • Yes she can't sing at live AND WHAT? is not for compare her with Demi

  • i like how she didn't even try singing the "yoouuu!" part. if she did, those dancers probably would've fell down and screamed in pain

  • why does everyone thing now that just cause you act you can sing?!?

  • It feels so sad that she's strangling by singing.

    Some day she will drown singing her own song! So cruel.

  • i think she has a different voice so stop hateing just because she dosnt belt out notes

  • ooh man 

  • sounds like shes constipating at the beginning.

  • she is pretty but she should stick to acting

  • ugh! that was horrible!, but i guess she sings way way better now in 2011

  • @MegaSchoolGirl1 No, she is still HORRIBLE. my friend told me to watch her. EWWWWW. The only reason she gets to have a better chance at getting to do professional singing, is because she was a disney star. I HATE SELENA GOMEZ

  • @TheYoungTudorQueen ARE YOU SERIOUS???!!!!!!!!!!! oh i know that already, but there no reason to hate her, because she can't sing or because of JB, but I SOOOO AGREE SHE CAN'T SING, i was just paying attention to her autotuned music videos, but i never relized i never REALLY heard her sing, AND NOW WHEN I DO HEAR HER REAL SINGING, IT MAKES ME FEEL ALL DIZZY, the music indrustry is crazi to pick selena gomez over so many better singers, i sing wayyy better then selena, just saying.......:)

  • she is bad,but somethimes she sing like a dead animal,and somethimes she is ok!

  • She have got a beatiful voice BUT it is weak...thats everything

  • it was playback?

  • I think that she got better than her first couple of live performances. Saying this as much as I like Selena Gomez, her singing is terrible

  • I hate the fact that she can't even sing, yet she gets more attention than Demi, who can actually sing! SMH!!

  • @xxpunkxprincessxx1 BUT NO ONE LIKE DEMI! AND I MEAN SELENA CAN SOMETIMES SING!

  • @TheZorba8 I lyk demi, nxt time check ur facts b4 u try to diss demi!!

  • @TheZorba8 Uhh...I like Demi, a lot of people do...

  • C'mom.. This was terrible. I prefer demi's.

  • that was horrible. selena's awesome and all.... but lets face it.

    that perfomance was BAD.

  • Fail.

  • I love Selena Gomez..

    But let's be honest..

    This was not her best performence..

  • Seriously I feel bad for ALL of you stop criticizing her you try to get that much courage to sing on stage in front of thousands of people she does need work yes but EVERYONE needs work whether their amazing or not

  • @jadeine97

    I could sing on stage in front of thousands of people. A singer is what I want to be when I grow up.

  • I like the song but she doesn't sing good live...

  • 0_o

  • At least she got the courage to sing live.. not like some other singers.. use autotune when singing life..

  • Why the heck does this have more likes than dislikes .? her voice is horrifying. she gets a lot more credit for her singing than she should .

  • my goodness.look at the dislike bar to the like,waaw

  • SHE"S HORRIBLE, oh gosh my cat woke up and went to the next room geez.

  • I would love to see her with NO background music.. Haha!

  • ich wollte nur mal sagen woher wisst ihr denn alle das sie nicht singen kann hat sie euch das erzäht oder was labbert nicht slle so ne scheiße wen ihr es gar nicht wisst

  • Just watch Miley Cyrus or Demi Lovato in Dancing With The Stars. They CAN sing live. But Selena really can't. Sorry fans, but this is fact. I like Selena as actress not as singer. :S

  • she pretty but she cant sing at all

  • ohmygosh, she can't sing at all

  • wow ...... she sucks

  • Eww.

  • This is one of the reasons I hate Disney. They have to make EVERY girl a singer, when this one clearly isn't. That doesn't make her a bad person, but now she's getting hate for it.

  • give her a break. it was her first live performance EVER!!!

  • she is so pretty but she can´t sing

  • oh come on, people. i mean, i don't even know a thing about this girl, but even i can see that there is much worse than this. have you ever heard kesha live? kesha is my ultimate guilty pleasure, but the last thing i'd ever do is pay to see her live lol.

  • This isn't even that bad. stop over-reacting.

  • If you guys think this is really bad... well guess what?!?! this was 2 years ago. She got a whole lot better. You should hear the live acoustic version of who says. it is really good.

  • @rockinsox723 but it sucks at all high notes haha

  • @sylviaimora But still she has the courage to do this. And she can sing, and guess what. There a billions of people hating on her saying she can't sing but so many people can't sing. She is better than half of the singers out there. So I am pretty sure you can't even sing. So why don't you shut up.

  • It's funny how everyone is picking on Selena when she isn't that bad live. HOWEVER, Kesha is HORRIBLE live and shoul dbe banned from performing live.

  • .-. Ya'll are haters!! Guess what??

    Just guess!!

    Its Important!!!

    FUCK YOU!! LEAVE HER ALONE

  • comparing this to her recent DWTS performance (Who Says) the only difference is she's learned to keep her voice softer so it doesn't sound bad... he recorded songs are amazing, she's a beautiful, amazing and nice girl.. but live.... ehh

  • she's gotten better retards this was her first time live try listening to her live now then talk!!

  • I don't understand. I think it was good

  • @snuttanjonas89rocky

    Have you ears?

    Can't you hear that this isn't a good live voice?

    Sorry but this is a fact.

    Her CD Voice consists of 24 Computers.

  • @Mileyfan2111 Listen I don't listen with others ears and it's legal for me to have my own ears and opinion

    

  • :O ....I DON'T LIKE SELENA SORRY BUT THIS IS.......AWFUL....ALL THE DISNEY STARS CAN SING? ....NO! THUMBS IF YOU THINK THAT

  • @MrThevideofamily But Demi can sing

  • @SuperXXangieXx yeah right, I love demi lovato that's the only who can sing ;)

  • she cant sing 

  • i only favorited this video for the incredible dancing. selena sounds soooo awful. but to be fair i think this might have been her first live performance.

  • her voice is too high.. i hate it but i love her songs and her acting

  • her singing isn't THAT bad, stop overreacting

  • the voice was goos.. but ts crap that she cANT HIT A SINGLE HIGH NOTE

  • There is a lot singers who cant sing without autotune.

    And this girl.. is only one of them in some of her songs

  • i like her band the scene... but its a shame they have her as there lead singer:(

  • Amazing actress, beautiful person. She's an amazing artist, but Disney made her sing... That was just wrong that everybody on Disney NEEDS to sing.

  • And people wonder why she didnt sing the high notes.

  • She wasn't that bad. If you don't like it, don't watch it, simple. This is when you see her true fans. But I gotta say, Team Demi all the way ;) <3

  • @BabiiHolly13 i was thinking the same thing. although, i feel that i must say, if derek and karina weren't there to dance and save her, she probably would've gotten boo'd. lol, but this was her first tv performance and so i can see where her nerves might have taken over.

  • WELLY SANG !

  • i think the audience was clapping at the dancers........wait no im SURE

  • i think the audience was clapping at the dancers........wait no in SURE

  • i feel sorry for the dancers who had to dance to this !!!

  • autotune = her best friend :D

  • @memyselfandtime77 lol so true !!!

  • Love ya Selena your so pretty

  • so awful!

  • just another disney star getting fed songs and she'll be gone in about 2 years tops

  • *shakes head* Selena has NOTHING on Demi...

  • Shes Talking About Herself

  • No one is perfect in the world . Everyone has their own opinions .

    Stop hating on her . She seems good in her first performance ..

    Guess what ? This is her first performance .. -,-

  • I like her as an actress, not a fucking singer. Disney, just stop pushing your actors into singing? Okay.

  • she really can't sing. she sucks! and everybody who clicked the i like button has no taste of music or is trying to make this performance good. THIS SUCKS!

  • ohh myy she fucking sucks i feel bad for justin hes going out with her

  • She's terrible. She can just stop singing now!

  • This is not good

  • everytime when I hear her voice my ears bleed. she sounds like a dying whale!

  • This is dreadful. I feel bad for everyone there and everyone that just watched this.

  • I'm not a fan of selena, but I really don't think she sings that bad in this performance :/ probably just the choice of song, it's not really a "song song"

  • i wish disney would stop trying to make all of their actors into singers too. obviously it isn't working.

  • Yeah not her best.. But still love her.!

  • i love selena gomez

  • im a hugee fan of selena gomez, but considering how much she gets paid for this she should sound alot better.

  • sure is better than fucken kesha and a lot of other artist that lip sing

  • This girl has a record deal? That is to say... someone hired her on PURPOSE to sing for a living? I mean, she really, REALLY can't sing.

  • i feel for the band.

  • @sarcasticalot dont, they are prob getting paid a lot! guessing how millions of ppl bout the girls c-d just because she is pretty :) Her band got enough money.

  • I came to this video thinking she literally fell down.... I am disappointed.

  • I think people who press 'dislike' are dummies :))

    Love this vid, keep moving forward Selena :D

  • even when shes not sick she sings like that but i still kie Selena very beautiful girl 1. Demi Lovato 2.Miley Cyrus 3.Selena Gomez

    love you Sel<33

  • Come on guys don't be mean. That was one of her FIRST performances live. Of course she's gnna sound a bit bad. But she did good..

  • If she have sing bad: Ok!

    She just trying to send fun to the people... She don't wanna be the best!

    You need to think about it!

  • Yaaa thiswas very special

  • She was sick that night

  • sounds like kareoke... :P

  • crikey it really is a good thing she's pretty

  • I think we should blame it on her singing tutor... thumbs up?

  • she's real bad ..

  • she cant sing without autotune, and live... well im not even gonna comment..

  • at least shes  actually singing live. besides she doesn't sound that bad.

  • this sucks

  • People keep saying she just needs more training and I think your completely dumb if you think that! Yes, you can train your voice with different techniques to help when you sing, but she is lacking one of the basic components, a good singing voice or any talent. You can't improve with the voice she has. I love Selena but I think she is a way better actress and should just stick to that.

  • thank god shes pretty then. LOL

  • This was bad but she's actually improving!

  • i think she is way talented, but some just cant sing live, not just her, there are many others too. she cant sing live.

  • why do you think she is bad i know half of you culdn't sing beter

  • @Lulu2664 well, but those 'half of us' dont go in public and sing like .. that.

    no offense.

  • she annyos me

  • selena your falling down =( selena is a good actor but a singer .. i don't think so .. im sorry but miley and demi are better than selena

  • I hate to say this, but she look stiff and fake that even Barbie is jealous. LOL

  • i love selena but she can't sing!

  • She needs dancing lesson. She also needs to learn by HERSELF how to perform by moving around and keep the audience motivated.

  • omg my ears are bleeding

  • POOR!

  • porque no canta en playback?

  • She is still developing....She just needs more training in her voice like Miley and Demi...Shes not bad...she needs more training....THATS ALL!!!! CALM DWN GUYS!!!

  • sHE SOunds Like crap hey selena need a bowl of eyeball/wHeart stew. she is so she had cousins named stew and pid

  • i love u girl and dont car what these people say they just mad cause the sing or ack lol love u

  • damn wth, did she have a sore throat or something?

  • the sound of crap coming out of a butthole sounds better

  • She sounds good on cd and TV and the songs are good but live she's not that great neither is Miley but she and selena are "popular" and the look good on camera so they keep them there plus disney and nick. usually have alot of singing on they're shows so they play it up to make it like they're stars can sing.

  • she sounds different than the music video of falling down

    i'm real suspicious

    but i still love selena

  • she sounds like a winey little twat i like er but she is fuckin tone deaf

  • WAhhhhhhHHHHhh. Love You, Selena, But that was just absolutely HORRIDD!

  • oh my gosh,what a masacrre... i don't know but... Selena can't sing.

  • she is rubbish boooo

  • she cannot sing 

  • my little sister can sing better! ROFL

  • oh please! all you people saying selena can sing would laugh if some one off the street try to pull this of. i get it shes cute but that doesn't mean she can sing.

  • lol.. she can't even sing her own songs

  • Oh Crap.. Is she exempted on the YOOOUUU part??? I thought its her own song?? This is stupid.. I should've listened to haters.. ughh..

  • she was so nervous :( you can noticed at the end when she take a breath like saying OMG! and to me was good :D GOOD JOB SELENA! *-*

  • ...i honestly dont hear a difference in her voice...

    is she tht bad all the time?

    o.o huh...didnt notice xD

  • i love selena but she can't sing live!

  • @lovetami12 not a fan. support her no matter what thats what true fans do

  • love her!! i think shes a good singer. this....maybe not her best but still...come on! u try to sing in front of a bunch of people. she still sounded realllyyyy good so oh well

  • no she dosent suck u can she shes scared as crap give the girl s chance

  • she sucks DEMI LOVATO IS A REAL SINGER

  • @lexcinaw oh crap 718 people missed the DISLIKE button...or they like the way shes being HORRIBLE...

  • she should stop singing I MEAN SHE CANT SING AT ALL. she should make some one else who wants to be a rich and famous singer live their dream

  • @lexcinaw she not going to stop singing because of you .

  • most singers sound different live than on cd......duh.....most dont sound as good live as on cd either...and the reason being think of all the performances they do....you know their voice has to be wore out...at least with it bein made onto a cd they can mess with the equalizer and stuff.....i love selena and alot of the other disney stars now back off of them ppl

  • I really hope for her sake, that she only had a sore throat, because if she sings like this the rest of her career, she'll be GONE within the next couple years.

  • OMG! she sucks -______- she just lost me as fan.

  • OMG if you hear this and then do a 2010 performance there is HUUUUUUUGE difference im not flippen kidding!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thumbs up if you agree. and you have to know that this is at the begining of her singing career so dont give her crap!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • i like the part , "smile for the camera , everybody's lookin at you , smile for the camera , their all about to trash you ." so true , the media , paparazzi , and haters have no life .

  • maybe it´s not the best singer in the world, but at least she sings live, lots of artists don´t

  • i think shes an amazing person :) i know her singing isnt the best at singing but shes getting better and better :)

  • i think this is average live singing. you know who's amazing live? hayley williams.

  • ppl juss need to leave her alone she sounds the same 2 me

  • who cares what "what the buck" said she is good she probally is nervous so her voice is getting shakey

  • Comment removed

  • wow this is terrible good thing she is pretty. that made me feel like i can sing and i sound like shit .

  • This so isn't a good example of her singing ability! Can't anyone tell that she's kinda

    nervous? You can hear it in her voice! She's an awesome singer! Have you heard her sing Round and Round live? It was AWESOME!

  • Thumbs up if you knew that she now uses olive oil and she sounds awesome now... seriously i heard her the otherday on day break shes better than here but i think this performance is alright no real singer that i really know can sing FANTASITICALLY live although i must admit lady gaga is awesome live.

  • she could use some editing stuff but not much

  • her pitch transitions are a little rusty and some of the notes fall flat but that's just what you'd expect from either a bad throat or nerves. all in all not that bad! especially when you take the other wannabe jail-bait mannequins that have saturated the market in to account. im not going to buy any of her crap but there are far worse acts out there to be trashing.

  • THIS IS NOT EVEN THAT BAD AT ALL. UR ALL LAME FOR TRASHING HER!

    "Smile for the camera cause theryr all about to trash ya"

    its like she perdicted the future with this song :/

  • @DUANEMUSIC1 Not all people say that some think shes good some dont, that is just what they think