The guitar sounds so fucking thick and thrashy, and the gritty drums on the chorus just makes me wish this demo had the real lyrics because it sounds 200% more thrashy than the final recording which itself is the fucking epitome of thrash
@dusted04 there sound went weird because of the "load" album, now that there starting to come back they should start using those maps again. come to think of it i think they are using those maps but different settings
@megaflyinbrian Most of the songs don't have the real lyrics, just James filling it with 'Na-na-nahs', this means that these demos were recorded before most of the writing began.
Yeah well, Metallica is still great... Nothing wrong with a change in musical direction, you have to be universal when it comes to music and so Metallica has a little bit of everything for everyone
@SerkantKnight not everyone tihnks that they sell out because they change because they wanted not because someone tell them. some metal heads can be so narrow minded that they think all the bands must play like 100 mph everytime. megadeth slayer, anthrax, kreator have changed their music style
i wish lars couldve died in a car accident or something after this masterpiece of an album was released, then everyone would've remembered him as a badass drummer rather than the piece of shit he is today. also wouldve been cool if metallica broke up after this album. then they would've have had one of the most consistent & awesome music catalogues of any band ever, and they would get the respect they deserve... without shitty death magnetic etc. weighing down their reputations as musicians
@underscoreisnotvalid lol retard. if you dont like their music, dont listen to it and dont tell us your opinion about metallica today. they changed their music, so what?
@oelapaloma yeah true. lol, i was exaggerating but ok. im just saying lars sucks now. if he had died after this, he wouldve been immortalised as a legend, like jimmy hendrix and all that, opposed to a douche that can't play drums, like he is now days
@underscoreisnotvalid how is he a douche now a days when he does more for the fans than he ever has and please explain to me how he sucks? have you not heard him play at Nimes, France in 2009 or Mexico City in the same year? He did the best that he has done in almost 20 years.
@Catsfan90 hey im not saying hes a shit dude, im sure hes a lovely guy & is great with fans, but im just saying everything about his drumming, technique style, sloppiness & his 'trying-to-always-be-as-philosophical-and-intellectual-as-possible' personality just annoys me. he just comes across like an idiot most of the time & thats coming from a huge metallica fan. & its pretty much universally accepted that lars is a shitty drummer post 2000's. ive got the nimes dvd & that only confirms my point
Metallicas most technical and heavy sounding album... Why couldn't they get stuck in justice for all mode forever !? Ok, maybe not forever but at least 2 or 3 more albuns...
this is awesome, but it poses the question, if Lars cud do the double bass for this demo in the one take, why did he have to do the actual studio recording of the double bass in multiple takes? i think the album version is slightly faster so maybe the higher tempo was too much for him
the production here sounds better than the actual album. No crappy clikcing bass drum and the guitars sound heavier. It still needs work of course, but polished version of this would of been better.
whats pretty impressive is that the do not have any vocals but the dear mother dear father part and what have you put me through line... he obviously was pretty sure its gonna be about mother and father...
for those who don't get why he sings like that, you need to see the making of 1991's Black Album, on VH1 Classic. He would do that for demo's, where he didnt have the full lyrics written, he would improv
You know, I'm willing to bet that "wananana" thing is a good way to outline a song that you're creating for the purpose of being able to play on guitar and sing at the same time. Just a rough idea.
you should look up MourningKnight on myspace i got bored and made a music channall so jion and comment and request songs i love metallica and will play any song request
Harvester of Sorrow is about a man growing steadily angry with his family through drug use, and eventually kills them. Hence the amazing chilling was he whispers "INFANTICIDE" before the outro.
Somehow, the lack of real lyrics makes it remind me of how I write songs... it's mostly a guitar melody over which you hum (or in James' case, growl) the basic idea of what the vocals should sound like. Works really well for me.
The solo is almost better than the original version.
klb2000000 1 day ago
4:19 Dissposile heroes????
strix9011 1 month ago
4:24 - 4:28 'Disposable Heroes Eve' lol ...And Demos For All!
Iolous 1 month ago 3
I absolutely love the complete ...And Justice For All album.The songs are dark, heavy, sometimes even a bit doomy and Hetfield's vocals...oh man.
The only thing that bothers me about the album is the fuzzy guitar tone.If they had a guitar tone similiar to this demo, I would be 100% happy.
ThrashTillDeath123 1 month ago
@ThrashTillDeath123 it's not fuzzy at all ahaa it's the best metal tone i've ever heard
oT0MJHo 4 days ago
lol
av3nger3 2 months ago
From this to Lou Reed WTF?!?!?!
ReaperWEare 2 months ago 11
Wadananana
D3feitoDeFabrica 3 months ago
this sounds so good xD i like the version you hear on the album but this is the shit xD
drunkwithpowerNDV 3 months ago
The guitar sounds so fucking thick and thrashy, and the gritty drums on the chorus just makes me wish this demo had the real lyrics because it sounds 200% more thrashy than the final recording which itself is the fucking epitome of thrash
Niruzmeister 3 months ago 4
bahaha wanananananananana all XD
NathanBro1 4 months ago
they need to go back to using the mesa mark series amps
possibly the mark v
these amps suite there style so good
dusted04 4 months ago
@dusted04 there sound went weird because of the "load" album, now that there starting to come back they should start using those maps again. come to think of it i think they are using those maps but different settings
MetaITV 4 months ago
..And Wa nana For All Q LOKO KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
xMrJtfs 4 months ago
FUCKING LOL!
mitchymoo0 5 months ago
James' lyrics on this demo are isnpired by Kirk Hammet.
johnthegreek178 6 months ago 8
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA dear mother, dear father i wanna a nana!
Deeplyy69 6 months ago
Wanana's Eve.
thelegendoflink52 7 months ago 14
Dear Nana, please send more cookies, mom and dad are being total bitches.
Vaizorg 7 months ago 27
I want a finished Metallica album with lyrics like these xD
NorrisArt 7 months ago
Fucking awesome solo !
klb2000000 7 months ago
dear mother, dear father, here i am at camp granada!
(just picture it, how much cooler it would be sung by metallica.)
spadehatesscrewtube 8 months ago
Studio lyrics > Demo Lyrics
Demo Solo > Studio Solo
Demo Tempo > Studio Tempo
Demo Snare > Studio Snare
Demo Quality > St. Anger Quality
lol
pchermidafilho97 9 months ago 15
@pchermidafilho97 i think you really hit the nail on the head with the hammer of justice with that one.
spadehatesscrewtube 8 months ago
disposable heroes at 4:23
alexkiller444 9 months ago 3
Still no fucking bass.. :(
Reapex1 9 months ago
my favortite quote of the year - wanananananananawananwanananana - James Hetfeild
metaldrummer2397 9 months ago
why James sounds so younger than the final version?
Senesse05 9 months ago
Comment removed
megaflyinbrian 9 months ago
@megaflyinbrian Most of the songs don't have the real lyrics, just James filling it with 'Na-na-nahs', this means that these demos were recorded before most of the writing began.
Senesse05 9 months ago
@Senesse05 thanks
megaflyinbrian 9 months ago
@megaflyinbrian it's in the description lol
Senesse05 9 months ago
OMG the demo sounds 841663284194% heavier and better!
johnthegreek178 10 months ago 3
dear mother dear father, wanananananananana
JLLproductions 10 months ago
still no bass lol
Shougunner 10 months ago
Yeah well, Metallica is still great... Nothing wrong with a change in musical direction, you have to be universal when it comes to music and so Metallica has a little bit of everything for everyone
kabaara 10 months ago
i dunno, but i can somehow hear the real lyrics, rofl
HellBrYnger 10 months ago
@HellBrYnger at some pionts james sings some of the real lyrics.
sammagehtsnoch 10 months ago
@underscoreisnotvalid wtf y would you wish for them to break up their music is fucking badass
Xxale1025579xX 10 months ago
@Xxale1025579xX
because now no one in the metal community tag Metallica as Metal, reason, they sell out themselves.
SerkantKnight 10 months ago
@SerkantKnight not everyone tihnks that they sell out because they change because they wanted not because someone tell them. some metal heads can be so narrow minded that they think all the bands must play like 100 mph everytime. megadeth slayer, anthrax, kreator have changed their music style
Contreras1991 4 months ago
@Contreras1991 I AGREE! WHAT WOULD REALLY SUCK IS IF THEY MADE THE SAME STYLE ALBUM LIKE 12 TIMES!! C'MON PEOPLE! SMH. LOL.
dapianoman76 4 months ago
@dapianoman76 LOL @ SMH. This isn't facebook.
Kylan0728 3 months ago
@Kylan0728 I was using the SMH abbreviation years before I got a FB acct.
dapianoman76 3 months ago
@dapianoman76 Was still popularized on facebook and Reddit, and honestly that's where it should stay. lol
Kylan0728 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
LYRICS ARE AMAZING!
SirMetalGH 10 months ago
ill never be able to hear this song the same again. ill go to sing, and just WAHNA WAH WAH NAH NA NA!
XxZero97531xX 11 months ago 5
GUARANA ! jajaja
kashmir930114 11 months ago
underscoreisnotvalid
Seriously dude? What band today has a consistent catalogue? What band has like 10 albums out and every one of them is a masterpiece?
kabaara 11 months ago
i wish lars couldve died in a car accident or something after this masterpiece of an album was released, then everyone would've remembered him as a badass drummer rather than the piece of shit he is today. also wouldve been cool if metallica broke up after this album. then they would've have had one of the most consistent & awesome music catalogues of any band ever, and they would get the respect they deserve... without shitty death magnetic etc. weighing down their reputations as musicians
underscoreisnotvalid 11 months ago
@underscoreisnotvalid lol retard. if you dont like their music, dont listen to it and dont tell us your opinion about metallica today. they changed their music, so what?
Ipwnshaxxors 11 months ago
@underscoreisnotvalid lol at lars instead of anyone else. what you said seems messed up, but yeah ,death kindof immortalizes you
un4tun8prez 8 months ago
@underscoreisnotvalid how can you wish death to a person that has never done anything to you idiot?!!!
oelapaloma 7 months ago
@oelapaloma yeah true. lol, i was exaggerating but ok. im just saying lars sucks now. if he had died after this, he wouldve been immortalised as a legend, like jimmy hendrix and all that, opposed to a douche that can't play drums, like he is now days
underscoreisnotvalid 7 months ago
@underscoreisnotvalid how is he a douche now a days when he does more for the fans than he ever has and please explain to me how he sucks? have you not heard him play at Nimes, France in 2009 or Mexico City in the same year? He did the best that he has done in almost 20 years.
Catsfan90 6 months ago
@Catsfan90 hey im not saying hes a shit dude, im sure hes a lovely guy & is great with fans, but im just saying everything about his drumming, technique style, sloppiness & his 'trying-to-always-be-as-philosophical-and-intellectual-as-possible' personality just annoys me. he just comes across like an idiot most of the time & thats coming from a huge metallica fan. & its pretty much universally accepted that lars is a shitty drummer post 2000's. ive got the nimes dvd & that only confirms my point
underscoreisnotvalid 6 months ago
4:22 - Part from disposable heroes :D
TheOrionification 1 year ago 3
@TheOrionification yeahh true
juancho970 1 year ago
Metallicas most technical and heavy sounding album... Why couldn't they get stuck in justice for all mode forever !? Ok, maybe not forever but at least 2 or 3 more albuns...
megahurtz30 1 year ago 8
@megahurtz30 I couldn't agree with you more, this is my favorite album.
SteinthorB 11 months ago
If metallica played this song at this tempo right now I am sure Lars could do the double bass no problem.
omnikickflip9000 1 year ago 7
@omnikickflip9000 no...
Conviviumsweden 1 year ago
damn this sounds better that the production on st anger
88fanforlife 1 year ago 7
They should compile the demos into an album and name it "..And Wana Nana Na All"
BillyOfPyrovore 1 year ago 56
@BillyOfPyrovore
Hell Yeah.. And Wana nanas for All... :D
CraZyEddy2010 1 year ago
@BillyOfPyrovore Would nananana be wananana nana na na na nanana epic
6693BellRinger 5 months ago
@BillyOfPyrovore what about...
...And Wa nana For All??
soap1294mctavish 5 months ago 3
Every Metallica song, I headbang in a "yes" motion, but for some reason this songs makes me headbang in a "no" motion. I have no idea why.
Jonathannovak1 1 year ago 9
yeah double bass
manhthang 1 year ago
1.18
DEAR MOTHER DEAR FATHER!!!!!
WAH-NA-NA-NA-NA-NA-UAR-E-OU!!!!
Imagine little James really screaming at his parents like this because he wants to stay out longer or sth :-D
hetfield4president 1 year ago 6
@hetfield4president he dose the whanna na na na na in make every song so he nose were he wants the words and see what he can fit in there
txxshad0wxxt 1 year ago
@txxshad0wxxt I know, dude! I just imagined James as a kid yelling at his parents ;-)
hetfield4president 11 months ago
are you kidding me. this is the crappiest sound i´ve ever heard. u destroyd it man
jimpornse 1 year ago
@jimpornse Metallica made this themselves, genius, this is the rough version they recorded before the album
jurnag12 1 year ago
lyrics please?
pumishumi 1 year ago
@pumishumi
Wah nana wah nana dear mother dear father wananananaaaaaaaaaaa *guitar solo* wah na.
ShdowSora 1 year ago
y does they only do calm music now? we want more music like these
omega0078 1 year ago
@omega0078 Have you even listened to Death Magnetic?
GUITARPLAYAx93x 1 year ago
@omega0078 Have you listened to Death Magnetic? It's thrash like this for the most part.
MrCherryKush 1 year ago
Lyric - nanananananananananannnnaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
much better than:
iiiiiiiiieeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
123leoantitv321 1 year ago
Dyers Eve is the last time Metallica did a real thrash metal music.
After and justice for all, music for the people.
123leoantitv321 1 year ago
i love that raw live sound, sounds so organic especially with the drums
altjff15 1 year ago
I gotta say this song is probably my favorite. Did anybody notice that one part of Disposable Heroes during the solo?
xxxCarnesxxx 1 year ago
bananananana
alacar91 1 year ago
@alacar91 XD
JackMcK123 1 year ago
I na na na na na love na na na na this na na na song!!
juandiegometallica 1 year ago
This is the most kickass song Metallica ever made. The reason is, I can't get a degree on my asskicking meter.
kgkologlu 1 year ago
whoever thinks Lars uses a drum machine for the double bass needs to listen to this
MrCoww 1 year ago 9
better than the album version music wise.
Bacinari09 1 year ago
FUCKING THRASH
MarioRubino22 1 year ago
anthology of lyrics...snif snif
kletox124 1 year ago
the nananana parts are unfinished lyric.
blaaaaaarrgh 1 year ago 5
nananananan mother nananananan father nanananana wananananananana(superdouble bass) nananananananananananananan xDDDDDDDDDD
Metall666Megadeth 1 year ago 65
Comment removed
Xdrxd29 4 months ago
Responder a este vídeo... xDDDDDD
Xdrxd29 4 months ago
¿Que chuchas dice James, esta taradeando la canción?
Bekloquendo06 1 year ago
@Bekloquendo06 que acaso no es obvio
es una guia melodica de como iria la voz, que obviamente aún no estaba terminada
lespaul084 1 year ago
this is awesome, but it poses the question, if Lars cud do the double bass for this demo in the one take, why did he have to do the actual studio recording of the double bass in multiple takes? i think the album version is slightly faster so maybe the higher tempo was too much for him
HeartlessNobody1314 1 year ago
@HeartlessNobody1314
to make it absolutely perfect...they had over 100 takes on enter sandman and the complexity of that song is nothing at all compared to this.
they perfectionist sorta i guess
thebirdman0 1 year ago
Thank you Lars and your double bass. Sucks Metallica is getting older =(
Freak2009 1 year ago
the production here sounds better than the actual album. No crappy clikcing bass drum and the guitars sound heavier. It still needs work of course, but polished version of this would of been better.
poonoo87 1 year ago
@poonoo87 yeah!!! that's what i think of the last album "crappy clicking bass drum"!!!! "CLICKING"
perfect definition!
mankepierdasss 1 year ago
But it can't be worse than the frying pan snare on St. Anger...
Fond3ll 1 year ago
They should come out with another garage Inc CD! With a llll of there demos and I will be a happy plant!
MetaITV 1 year ago
"dear mother dear father, nana na na na nana na wah"
guitardouche666 1 year ago
This is the shit that punches people right in the fuckin face!!! Metallica loud and fuckin heavy!!
dethmag 1 year ago
METALLICA FOR LIFE \m/
fuckingmetalheadbang 1 year ago
whats pretty impressive is that the do not have any vocals but the dear mother dear father part and what have you put me through line... he obviously was pretty sure its gonna be about mother and father...
Mortif3r 1 year ago 3
wow i've heard this demo a lot and this is the first time i noticed the disposible heroes riff in the solo at 4:25.
rocafella142 1 year ago
for those who don't get why he sings like that, you need to see the making of 1991's Black Album, on VH1 Classic. He would do that for demo's, where he didnt have the full lyrics written, he would improv
Taydude411 1 year ago
JAMES WORDS TOUCHES ME
EMOMETALDINO666 1 year ago 8
Eric Cartman on vocals
ThrasherOfPuppets 1 year ago
Is it just me or do these demos put a huge smile on your face??? One word.....TREMENDOUS! \m/ \m/
SirPimpafizzle 1 year ago 7
funny! :D
RCT3VideosRock2010 1 year ago
As I always say "It's Headbangin' Good!!"
dddgggddgg 1 year ago
Epic lyrics
MrMetalloidMan 1 year ago
These were the original lyrics, you guys just didnt like em
BooVII 1 year ago
@BooVII james say that in the ''classic albums: the black album '' jejeje xD its funny
HotFanNaruto 1 year ago
yeeh we can hear some bass here!
TehSorso 1 year ago
Dude this definitely is from disposable heroes...
oelapaloma 1 year ago
If dyers eve is about james growing up, damn he growed up fast!
Headthorn 1 year ago 6
the lyrics are better than rap
DaveShredder5150 1 year ago 88
@DaveShredder5150 Rap done right is acutaly quite alright.
JackMcK123 1 year ago
I like this lyrics but they are hard to remember xD
MetallicaSlipknotRok 1 year ago 7
heres the lyrics: dear mother dear father wah na la na na ha la bla bla bla
Frijolero18 1 year ago
I like these lyrics better than the original ;D
GetoutofMyYard1 1 year ago
hahaha! Wtf are those lyrics :)
MetallicaOrTrivium 1 year ago
Gotta love the lyrics: Dear mother, dear father! Wanananana! Wanananana! What is this hell you have put me through? Wanananana!
DethCr0wz 1 year ago 2
my fucking god, this wananana stuff is epic
MetalMilitia393 1 year ago
You know, I'm willing to bet that "wananana" thing is a good way to outline a song that you're creating for the purpose of being able to play on guitar and sing at the same time. Just a rough idea.
EvisceratorBand 1 year ago 7
So to everyone who said that he didn't play the double bass part can kiss my ass.
justinjoewills 1 year ago 11
@justinjoewills true but he cant play it anymore without screwing up big time
Traedeer 1 year ago
WNANANAANA!
TheCheese889 1 year ago
wa na na na na na na na na!
nookieorgasmatron 1 year ago 8
I dare someone to write a full lyric page for this song!
If I ever make a song, I'll be sure to say 'WANANA' all the time.
LuwiigiMaster 1 year ago 2
is that lars playing? OMG he can actually do db on dyers eve chours :OOOO
Daniel513555 1 year ago
@Daniel513555
ofcourse Lars can do double bass, that dude is like a human metronome o_o" (or however you spell it, i 4gots :|)
deathsavilion 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
you should look up MourningKnight on myspace i got bored and made a music channall so jion and comment and request songs i love metallica and will play any song request
secretman666 1 year ago
I imagine that this is what 2 year old James Hetfield sounded like. haha
duffmasterofpuppets 1 year ago
I'm liking the lyrics ;)
AndJusticeForAlI 1 year ago
best lyrics ever lol
TimSpickler 1 year ago
is james just going wa na na na? Kinda sounds like kurt cobain lol
legendaryskulls 1 year ago 3
Lol Why Wa na na na na na?
But still James even makes this sound cool!
Awesome demo!
LordMalekith1 1 year ago
Comment removed
LordMalekith1 1 year ago
best... Metallica song... ever.... omg I just jizzed listening to this
JonBiggE 1 year ago
Imagine you spect to hear dyers eve with full lyrics Metallica live
and suddenly james hetfield sings "Dear mother dear father wa na na na na nana! no!"
Lehjiot 1 year ago
such a brutal track, makes me want to punch a baby and kick a preist in the nuts :P
MexicanSeadude 1 year ago 7
DEAR MOTHER DEAR FATHER, WA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
DEAR MOTHER DEAR FATHER WA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
WA NA NA NA NA, WHAT IS THIS HELL YOU HAVE PUT ME THROUGH
DEAR MOTHER DEAR FATHER, WA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
ahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
jian2069 1 year ago 10
id think they had the full lyrics written yet but funny
TheJAMStudios2009 1 year ago
4:24 haha Kirk is doing a lil bit from Disposable Heros of Master of Puppets. I feel so proud that I knew that! :)
kirk45hammett 1 year ago
I just have one question, WHY THE HELL DID THEY NOT USE THE UNUSED SOLO PARTS ON DEATH MAGNETIC?
dudo5000 1 year ago 14
yeah, most of death magnetic's solos suck balls
queenville 1 year ago
not all
TheJAMStudios2009 1 year ago
fuck you they are awesome!!
xxsilentnigjtmarexx 1 year ago
@dudo5000
Because you know, it's probably in a different key and pattern than their other songs. But you seem to know nothing.
Heaterboy 1 year ago
@Heaterboy Transposing is possible. Besides, not saying note for note but bette to base off from the unused solos.
dudo5000 1 year ago
@dudo5000 hahahaha they like changing it up AS YOU KNOW...good question though ahah
mbd303030 1 year ago
wa-na-na-na!!!
purplehalfstack 1 year ago
much better and heavier
Aussiemetallica 1 year ago
no this isnt about abort, but i think harvester of sorrow maybe.
but i think its about james childhood (harvester) and when he was a teenager (dyers eve).
XXXkLeCiIj69XXX 2 years ago
@XXXkLeCiIj69XXX
Dyers Eve is him growing up.
Harvester of Sorrow is about a man growing steadily angry with his family through drug use, and eventually kills them. Hence the amazing chilling was he whispers "INFANTICIDE" before the outro.
VivaLaSer21 1 year ago
I cannot get enough of this version of the solo and the drums during it...
Moulessas 2 years ago
you gotta love the drums here, they sounds much better then in orginal studio version
SSSoM3 2 years ago
i don't know if anyone did notice but lisent to 4:23 that looks like a bit of Disposable Heroes x)
osmeustomates 2 years ago 45
lol maybe he did this before disposable heroes xD then thought of 4:23 and put it in that song xD
bboy4050 2 years ago
no dude read the description
XXXkLeCiIj69XXX 2 years ago
ok and what about it. just says the other demos.
bboy4050 2 years ago
This demo was recorded in January 1988.
Master of Puppets demos were made in 1985.
XXXkLeCiIj69XXX 2 years ago
ah ok i see. haha.
bboy4050 2 years ago
yes, i think so xP
osmeustomates 2 years ago
@osmeustomates Sure is.
SlipknotMaggotism 1 year ago
@osmeustomates haha the solo part xD
XxZero117xX 1 year ago
@osmeustomates i didnt know you can see music XP (lsd)
MetaITV 1 year ago
@MetaITV hun? i didn't get it...
osmeustomates 1 year ago
@osmeustomates sorry
MetaITV 1 year ago
@MetaITV np...
osmeustomates 1 year ago
@osmeustomates oh i know what happen, i meant to reply to someone else , i reply to you on accident
MetaITV 1 year ago
@MetaITV okay dude no problem
osmeustomates 1 year ago
@osmeustomates 8D
MetaITV 1 year ago
Somehow, the lack of real lyrics makes it remind me of how I write songs... it's mostly a guitar melody over which you hum (or in James' case, growl) the basic idea of what the vocals should sound like. Works really well for me.
JackieHakalaJackson 2 years ago