Bye Bye Beautiful - Nightwish LIVE Copenhagen - 28-11-07

[GreenDay1981]

Looked like one of the flame shooters wasn't working on the intro.

[MrsNaranja]

This song is one of the songs that i prefer live version then studio.

[MissLucySpring]

I am pretty sure thats me you can hear with the very high scream xD

[NightDreamer88]

@MissLucySpring

Then STFU, bitch !

[EUKALIPTUS581]

This song is the truth about Tarja.

[5150warpig]

tarja was dewfinetly better live then anneta. but their both good. tarja just made them unique was all.

[mim1800]

poor pefonmance!!!she can't sing

[doku66655]

@mim1800

Surely you can do better.

[pedraine]

karaoke?WTF??

[iluvme4never]

i'm kind of glad that they've stopped playing this song live...

[SilverSong1234]

great performence, yay! X3 But why was they in Denmark TWO MONTHS beafore i found out they existed... TT-TT

[soldermen]

I hate these amateur,long shot,(probably a stupid cellphone)crappy sounding videos.Great song though!

[Shoguhn]

wow...a crowd that claps on beat,lol.

[Barakonyi]

@Shoguhn Because it's a Danish crowd XD

[darkdead16]

Amazing *.*

[Tsikeable]

now anette have a blond hair... :P

[zsofyka29]

if u love soooo much Tarja, listen to her solo album, i find it so beautiful. And NW with Anette is very good too, in the live performances - in Debrecen (Hungary) they were amazing.

[laideehawk]

Nightwish is one of the few bands out there who actually sound awesome during a LIVE performance! I love both the old and new era Nightwish. Now just to get them to Alaska!!!

[jari700]

FINLAND! YEAH!

[albeanmagz19]

goosebumps..

[ababbey]

ive been a fan of these guys for like only 2 months, and already i REALLY want them to come to Australia for a tour haha.

[kelliemellie666]

That would be mad as :D

[AnOceanbornsSoul]

Thanks once again for posting this one :) I was there, and this brings back memories...

[RPG4ever]

I saw that show ^^

[leftstanding]

dang that was a nice performance!

[ninjabo43]

oh man i wish i could go see them live

[lv99Atmaweapon]

I like Tarja more.

[JRadicalll]

Wasn't her family at this show?

[ExtremAv3]

in this video anette looks like a bitch.

[HSChristianrock]

..... wish Tarja was still the singer

[KevinCarey]

was Anette gargling with steroids before this concert? her voice is just huge and booming, its overpowering the entire band!

[petsitterlinda]

OMG you are right! BTW I'm stil laughing when I read your comment-so funny LOL!

[KevinCarey]

hey man thanks for putting this shit up here. Very good quality recordings.

[LacusBr2]

nice perfomace.

[Kakashi2good4you]

This song almost makes me think as if it was intended toward Tarja...does anyone agree?

[Celjub]

Yes. In fact entire album (Dark Passion Play) was about things that happened with bend in period when Tarja got fired / Anette started. Every song is speaking about that period, and this song is the most direct towards Tarja...

Hope u understood :)

[ImpossiblePunk]

do you mean that its about tarja?

like bye bye (tarja) beautiflu ?

or did i misunderstand u?

[zeegreekgeek]

No, you didn't misunderstand her. Bye Bye Beautiful is about Tarja :P

[sweetladystarlight]

Whoever writes the songs for Nightwish is a master!Super video!

[JoJo45x]

tuomas does

[sweetladystarlight]

Thanks for the info! Tuomos has amazing talent! Every song I"ve heard is a work of art!!

[martinahrovat]

you chose the long road, but we'll be waiting?

[KoLdude42]

bye bye beautiful

[idahofella]

This is the song that really got me into nightwish when I first heard it i liekd soem of thier other songs but this one is one of my favs i guess i am more of a annette fan since i am not really into operatic type music heck being a rammstein and e nomine fan and all what can u expect

[LarkspurSkye]

Wow, no words can describe how fun Nightwish concerts look...Spotlights, strobe lights, fireworks and confetti everywhere. Wow. I can't wait to go to one myself.

[ironheaven]

i've seen them live and it was so awesome..especially the intro of this song..it really was the best day in my life.

[Kanashto]

The song playing at the start, what is it? is it by Nightwish?

[Forunth]

no, that's ressurection. From "The Passion" movie.

[Giacomomoscetti]

this song is very very beautiful!!!!.....W NIGHTWISH!!!......by italian boy!

[FrozenMermaid666]

Awesome!

[arequipense35]

De mas la nueva cantante mejor ubieran puesto a Britney Speear q nada quever lo ha desfigurado al grupo la musica es buena pero lavoz de ella y su estilo no van con el grupo q pena, mucha pena q un grupo de culto se vea opacado por esta vocalista q deberia dedicarse a cantar pop como tanta rubia tonta q hay en el mercado. Como Tarja ninguna q REGRESE.

[emnapier007]

i still wanna say that marco's parts are very hard to sing in one breath

[mofrakker]

Marco is actually better than most singers. My brother heard The siren once (he didn't know the band) 'He sounds like Geoff Tate' and in that song, he is channeling the legendary Queensryche vocalist a bit. Peace bro.

[emnapier007]

right. he's doin' a difficult job and have done it well enough

[rcrush]

Hmm I like Tarja and Anette. But I like Anette more when she sings the new songs and not the old songs.

[SuomiSusi93]

love it <3

[gronfo]

just great xD

[soulsong7]

love this song

anette is great, no matter what anybody says

:)

[emnapier007]

anette is good enough in her age. she sings almost the same in the live as in recording. marco... maybe he's a little bit old.. but also nice . go ahead! love ya guys!

[emnapier007]

did i say sth wrong??? hehe

[sonne52]

i love both anette and tarja. the thing with anette is though, with this song, she sounds quite similar live to the recording, and i think that's a good thing. with songs such as end of all hope, tarja sounds quite different, with a much more shaky voice than the recording. anette's voice is much more solid in my opinion.

but it doesn't matter who's better, as long as the song is cool, which it is!

[001puch001]

totally agree with you!

[keffer67]

agree general arrow i got the same vibe

[GeneralArrow]

Plus its kinda an big F U to tarja if you listen to the lyrics on the video.

[mizzmatrix]

marco isn't THAT good...:P they both have their spots to practice on.. marco can't catch his breath in a sequence, and anette sucks at some tones... they both need to practice, but I think they perform good, with all the energy and spirit on stage :)

[whathappinessis]

I think this song was written to Tarja.

[GeneralArrow]

Uh no. If Tarja had written it, the vocal part would have been a lot higher.

[guitarjunkyalex]

He said "TO" Tarja, not "BY" Tarja. And yes this so is written her.

[GeneralArrow]

I don't see every thing when its 3:00 am in the morning lol.

[PencilPusher212]

MARCO FOR SINGER!!! hes better tarja is good to but yea.. but the lead singer now songs kidna like tarja if you listen carefully o_o

[luchitooo]

is this song for tarja? it seems like it's for her

[4590383493]

yes it is, to even do such a thing to someone u known for such a long time but to play it LIVE? they have no honor

[001puch001]

yes this song is made for tarja.

[LSKB101]

She sounds better here than she did at the one i went to at boardwalk. yeah, she kinda sucked! I seriously think Marco should be the lead singer.He has an awesome voice!

[coolkula1]

Goood

[DrzSpectre]

I like more the other albums than dark passion play but not because of tarja's departure. I wonder why

[Enux123]

T A R J A IS VERRY BIEATAF COMNIN

[ptv1kdbxs]

Anette is good....but Tarja is Tarja!! =)

[maxthebee]

they have a very 'crazy' well live! sounds as awesome as the recording version!

[RocKI4N]

Anette is a good singer but Tarja is a Godess the best female singer i ever hear, She make the angels cry when she sing, the best female singer ever.

My dream is.. she return someday, I miss Tarja =(

Salu2

[ythub]

This is awesome I truly wish i could see Nightwish live in somewhere ower the global, AMAZING music, just what this world needs

[remco11]

very awesome , nice take ;) , quality is a bit not good(vid) but sound is amazing! , wish i had been there T_T

[lovemusicmille]

awesome.. wish I had been there .. (i'm danish), but saw them at least at the skanderborg festival ^^

[FrEakaZ0IdDK]

know*

[FrEakaZ0IdDK]

hey im a dane however i dont like the country really our primeminister is much an asslicker of bush(whom thank god for that no longer are usa's president).. i dont know what else is rotten maybe the fact that we let too many outsiders/immigrants(iraqs,afg­hans and vietnamese people) and they really now how to cause trouble..

[thebeerbaron666]

Then vote someone into office who will make some "immigration reforms". You have a democracy use it

[olea1988]

ANETTE POKEMONA!!!!

[hugoc144]

asshole

[olea1988]

solo acepta que anette mando a la mierda a nightwish y ya no es lo mismo que antes

pd: anette se viste como pokemona!

[ragw33d]

i still think the guitarist should be singer he's class haha

[CriticsConfession]

Bass, not guitar, XD, and yeah Marco is a pretty dang good singer.

[skankskull]

please come to dubai

[CrysonFire]

15 march 2009

Nightwish coming to Holland, OMG I cant wait!!

Anette rocks, together with DPP

They are so good live :p

\m/

[malthe122]

in denmark nice. i am danish

[ravenshmash]

Something is rotten in the state of Denmark...

[Atello93]

What's rotten? o.O

[ravenshmash]

King Claudius' brother killed him and married his wife in order to become king himself, and everyone thinks Claudius' death was just an accident. But Hamlet, the prince, knows it was murder since Claudius' ghost came to him and told him to avenge of his death.

[ravenshmash]

That's what's rotten in the state of Denmark!

[CriticsConfession]

I started listening to nightwish because they got a new vocalist. I love nightwish now! Annete and Tarja are two different styles of vocalizing, and if you haven't gotten over the fact that Tarja is gone, get over it.

[Hellionpriest100]

i prefer anette in DPP but Tarja in the old songs

[DarkPassionPlaay]

truth .

[Train06]

I just love that song!

Will there be a new Live-DVD of Nightwish soon?

[EliteFreak]

As a die hard Nightwish fan I have to say that Anette brings a whole new life to the band and I feel brings out the true potential of Nightwish!!!

[Beecels]

anette isnt bad, shes actually a very good singer. but tarja will always be better imo. oh well obviously having a new singer isnt hindering their success. rock on nightwish

[SummonTheWolves]

What the hell?

Still the "true fans" bitching again here I see.

Wow,these people act like it's the end of the world.

Oh well,anyways I'm so excited fo wednesday night.

I've waited so long to see them live:)

[PerYngveOhlin666]

I suck

[NurseJokerr]

I think Bye Bye Beautiful is my favorite Nightwish song.

But its hard to decide.

[spidermangrip]

She SUCKS big time and is RUINING Nightwish! I wish she would just get lost! She moves in a wierd way coz she's scared stiff that her false hair will detach itself from her head. Why all the fake hair and hair pieces? She's FAKE through and through, never listened to Metal and never even heard of Nightwish until the week before she sent them her demo. She's a FAKE wannabe pop singer who's just in it for the cash! Get back to your ABBA tribute where you belong - you are FAKE and OUT OF TUNE!!!

[JRadicalll]

Oh hey spidey. Funny to see you here. Still crying about Anette I see. This is really unhealthy, you really should move on.

[josehine1983]

you may not insult her that rude, it was not her mistake to be part of nightwish. if you are Tarja fan go to another page to watch her opera song, dont give your shit here.

[ravenshmash]

It's really nice to see someone else who appreciates good music and doesn't worship some talentless opera bitch. I can sing opera better than her.

Btw Anette isn't even pop, either. She's professional musician who can sing an incredibly diverse range of styles, rather than just one (like someone I'm not going to name.)

[OceanSoul1990]

You're right man!!!!!

She si the only one who must be fired form Nightwish not Tarja!!

[rathuskz]

i prefer tarja

[ythub]

Annette in wonderful, just what Nightwish needed to move on!

[brabulma]

Tarja forever!!

I don't like Annette because the voice isn't power

[Opranius]

i think nightwish changed a bit more to power metal because of anette. =)

[ravenshmash]

I think Nightwish changed a bit more awesome because of Anette!

[josehine1983]

i am agree i was not fan of nightwish when Tarja was there but now YES I AM Nightwish Fan, anette vesion is easier to listen, if i gotta choose Opera or Pop I think Pop is better.. Tarja just so much suck, nightwish never lose something big without her just some idiot fans of Tarja and it is not a big deal thought they will get more fans for they new formation, but Tarja without nightwish is no one.

[ravenshmash]

Yea same here I didn't listen to Nightwish when they had their old singer, but as soon as I heard Dark Passion Play with Anette I fell in love. After that I thought that the opera chick was ok until she payed a bunch of people to pretend they were her fans and slander Anette on YouTube. rofl

Now I can hardly stand to listen to old Nightwish songs with her in them.

[ifi2lew]

although I prefer the tarja-nightwish

[ifi2lew]

to me, anette is better live than tarja..

[L0n1d4s]

anette sucks and in live only save us the PLAYBACK!!

[x1x4x7x]

anette sucks

[christi1992]

you suck

[DrzSpectre]

Nether Tarja can sing new songs like Anette

[Vegetrunks44]

This is one of the better live-versions of bye bye beautiful.. but still.. I miss Tarja.. but i don't think Tarja could sing any of the new songs... then again.. Anette can't sing any of the old songs like Tarja! NIGHTWISH RULE ALL!!!

[trollvoodoopriest]

I often wonder what Anette would be like singing Nemo...

[Saaharaa]

Go search for it :p It's allover the interwebs ;)

[PIPHANSDK]

I wish i was there :-O

[DrzSpectre]

as i sayed anette is far more better than Tarja because she can sing songs than tarja's voice can't support,the pop ones

[kanokth]

and by the way how can I know which one is Anette and Tarja I can't tell the different because the looks the same on the performence

[aacblaze]

Singing style

[Acavar]

Anette has does the strangest dance when Marco sings....

[soulsong7]

NIGHTWISH FOREVER!! love them!

[EveryoneIsGemini]

Marco is imressive live.

Great!!

[fedebernd]

awfull-.

[spikydude666]

Suprisingly good quality

[kec228]

This is pretty good quality for a live recording, all the other ones are really staticky and bad

good job :)

[spookybellatrix]

I have to admit that her voice works wonderfully in the dark passion play songs. but, to me, is like another band, 'cause it

[spookybellatrix]

is just not the same as hearing those songs sung by tarja.

[SonoUnaTamarra]

I didn't trust this girl, in the beginning, but now I have to say that she's surprising me more and more.

I like both, Tarja and her. No matter which one is better. They made different Nightwish' eras.

[epicaafterforever]

muito bom mais com a tarja era melhor

[KapJloc]

Why is Marco passing the words at the chorus???? ((

[deejayvee88]

it's a hard song to sing and he can't breathe. it is normal. there are few parts to breathe in his singing parts in this song.

[HerGuardianAngel1991]

Which is one of the main reasons why he should stop FUCKING SMOKING. D<

His voice is amazing, and he ruins the power and potential by smoking.

Annete is decent, but not as "epic" as Tarja, even though she does milk it sometimes. :/

[KapJloc]

He had and more difficalt songs to sing. Remember just Fantom Of The Opera

[Maxcaster]

try to sing the whole thing at once ;)

[Beecels]

in the music video version its all one long strand, but in reality its probably impossible to sing that without running out of breath, this gives him an opportunity to breathe. sounds great still

[SuperstarX]

who is this girlband???

[Pinhax99]

this is not a girlband.... only the singer is a girl...

[siskazeki]

No-one better than other man.

But It's just another way to walk,

like Tarja and Annette.

Open your heart and get the way that you don't like.

No-one can stay together forever.

In the future,

Nightwish mays change bassist,guitarist or another guys.

But If you believe in The Nightwish Rock's band.

Don't find any-word to blame or say something down about Nightwish because that's shit words tell your personal, see ?

So don't come and show the bullshit any-reason of your down opinion.

[hejmeddig2100]

that was a fantastic concert!!!!!!!! I was lucky to expericen it!!

[Thomas19889]

I agree, they are good in different ways, Tuomas was beginning to change the music in Once already.

One kinda weird thing about Tanja is that in some livecd songs she sings wrong so perhaps there is something in what Tuomas meant with ''Did you ever listen to what we played''

[AaronDrake22]

You'll gotta stop talking about this Tarja Anette bulshit man its old news get over it i'm sick of reading those bulshit comments THEY ARE BOTH GOOD!!!

[vault56]

You are my new super awesome best friend now.

Why the hell do people still go to nightwish videos on youtube, and talk down about Annette? Tarja left three years ago!!!! Get over it!!!! Even if Tarja wasn't fired, she was going to leave anyway. May be, they just have no life and that's why there's all these old and stupid Tajra and Annette comments.

[siskazeki]

Who wish you to listen Anette'sing.

If you want to listen Tarja's sound

Go

Don't comment this place

Tarja left NIghtwish

not band left her"

Believe in Band not one person

[Gazzz87]

actually mate, the band got rid of Tarja. There is an open letter from the band to Tarja on the official website, which is ultimately Tarja's marching orders. But yes, just Nightwish on the whole, not per singer. In my oppinion, Annette makes nightwish sound different, but BETTER.

[sara092]

hiskubus can a robot make you cry with its singin (rofl) SOOO stupid.... :X:X:X Nightwish lost their previous style chosing Annette. They could have tried chosing some one with a voice close to Tarja's but....No more symphonic music from them i see

[DarkRavenREE]

there awsome live and there comin to Tn on the sep 23 awsome!!!

[12815991]

omg there actually pretty good live!

[KlizzElf]

Yeah, rocks that shiiiit! :)

[EthanR666]

Beehold, Nightwish in their full glory doin what they do best!!!!

[Poltergust4000]

seeing this makes me SO upset that the live show i was supposed to go to was cancelled :(

[ClokChii]

I preffer nightwish with Tarja, but Anette's voice is beautiful, I like it =)

[Metallicafreak93]

Anybody know what the names of the dances Anette does? lol

[Adjanian]

I think the idea was to change and renew. If they had wanted a new Tarja, they shouldn't have kicked her out in the first place...to be honest I didn't like NW, I mean, I liked the melodies...but Tarja's voice was not nice to me...she's a good singer but has no passion, it's like a porcelain doll...Maybe Anette is not an opera singer but it's far more energetic and makes the music more enjoyable.

[hiskubus]

thats exactly my opinion. tarja has an amazing voice but still she reminds me of a robot on stage :S

[Nightowljrm]

*realizes I'm immitating the keyboard on the computer...* oops! I just get into it too much. =D Nightwish is just awesome enough to get you into it when you're not even there. =3