Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (204)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Are you the same Natalie Gilbert who flubbed up the national anthem?

  • OMG...So a few days ago, Natalie Nicole Gilbert started following me on Twitter. Today, she asked to read a fanfic that I based on her song. I feel blessed.

  • Apparently, four people have no hope... Thank you for this video by the way.

  • <3 Carlislee....I want to be like him soo much

  • i so lvoe this vidoe it so cool and sweet

  • Love It! Who is natalie nicole gilbert? :) Anyway i think this song is amazing xx

  • so gd, i <3 carlise

  • Carlisle

  • :S thx lol

  • this is a good song i think lool x :D my sisters thinks it crap but they are a twilight numba 1 fan x

  • i love carlisle so much, and this song is amaaaazing :) sums him up so well xxxxx

  • <3<3 i love carlisle soooooooo much thx for uploading :)

  • Amazing

  • Carlisle is a really nice person even for a Vampire, i love him!!!!! He and esme click so well and i love the twilight saga! Wooo Xx

  • Lovethiss almost too much ...

    such a lovely song too xx

  • its an amazing song <3

    love her voice, it fits the song perfectly.

    are there any other songs like this?

    cheers/#

  • He turned edward , esme , rosalie cause she was messed up and dying , and emmett cause rosalie was to scared to change him herself.

    He didnt change alice or jasper.

    Jeez , read up guys.

  • he did turn rosalie, she was bleeding in the street when he saw her - she was near death so he saved her the only way he could

  • cool i like it!

  • i love carlise . and i love the fanfic that went with this song

  • he deserves to have a song, hes gorgeous ;) :D

    x

  • He's an important character, I agree.

    But he isn't real.

    Some people get so into this Twilight stuff.

  • omg he is soo important because of him Edward was made what if he never made him - its too sad to even think about!

  • carlisle is the best!

    He made all the cullens he should be recognised!!!!!

    i love you carlisle wahooooo x

  • he didnt technically make them all. he made Edward and Esme into vampires burr not emmett rosalie jasper and alice

  • yes he did ?

    Rosalie carried Emmett over 100 miles,

    because she was scared that if she transformed him she wouldn't stop

    so Carlisle did it

  • jasper and alice are the only ones he didnt :) x

  • oh! Same thingy i meant that!

    Still Carlisle is still bloomin awesome! and thats all that matters!!!!! XD

  • Yeah truee, I love Jasper xx

  • he made rose into a vampire coz her fiance and his mates bashed her, raped her and left her to die, carlisle smelt the blood and found her so he changed her coz he thought it was a waste to let her die..

    he changed emmett coz rosalie wanted him to because rose knew she wouldnt be able to resist his blood.

    ;D

  • Oh right ^_^ Sorry i must of missed it out.

  • He made emmett and rose. jasper and alice came into their lives lol (: x

  • Whatta Greatt Songg Its Actully Amaizingg ♥

    And Whoever Said Why Does He Hav A Song!!! Of Corse He Shud Hav A Song Hes A Cullen!!!

    ;)

    xx

  • The song is really nice, but not generally my type. But i have met Peter Facinelli :D

    He is seriously awesome :D

  • why does he have a tribute??

  • why not? he's an important character. if it wasn't for him, Edward wouldn't exist!

  • @PoisonedPerfection94 Not only would Edward not exist, but neither would the whole olympic coven.. Alice and Jasper would, but they wouldn't be vegetarians and I doubt they'd even be together because Alice only met the cullens (and jazz) because she saw them and if they didn't exist then most likely she wouldn't have seen jasper either.. So no cullens :L and no twilight :(

  • this literally gave me goosebumps:O

    This song is amazing. Amazing job Natalie <3

    Carlisle <3

  • plz no1 hate me if u disagree but part-way through the song i could just imagine evanescence performing it. does anyone agree? even just a tiny bit? i hav no clue where tht idea came frm, it just popped into my mind.

    anywayy awesome song. its so peaceful i love it! great work Natalie!

    xoxo sobie

  • Yea i can see what you mean. I can just see Amy Lee singing this in a video :P

  • 2.51 Esme's face looks weird

    Good song <3

  • the director has nothing to do with the scenes in the movie -__-. its the screenwriter.. the director shoots what they are givin.

    btw; this song is really good :)

  • I meant Screenwriter.. Sorry

  • Carlisle is the best!!!!!

  • ya, everyone TWILIGHT IS AWESOME.....PERIOD

  • ... Amazing <3 ..

  • beautiful

  • this song is really good =)

    lovee itt :P

  • and the person complaining about the story being ruined it happend to me to trust me its not ruined in the least and dont complain just look at it as an advatntage now you will have more suspense and watch out what your saying on the internet if you keep saying stuff like that someone might charge you with threating comments

  • ugh okay seriously you all are bitching now but i am going to admit this will sound bitchy but you need to hear it hey if you don't like the books dont complain about them on a video thats about them cuz that just means your looking for atention go audition for a play it helps and all you that are getting mad at her/him just ignor her/him so what they made a comment you didnt like there is going to be alot of that in life...

  • i've read all 4 books, haven't seen th film yet but i hav got a dvd with extras and cast interviews. it tells u how each of th cast members view th stories and their roles.

    th books r absolutly amazing and i'm sure th film is too.

    i think this song captures carlisles character reli well and th words fit reli nicely too

  • btw sorry if my reponses let any of the story away, didn't mean to ruin it for anyone there amazing books :)

    so sorry if i ruined anything, please still read on, books are amazing.

    x

  • omg 0.57 is soooo hot...

  • the song really matches carlise ^^ i think the books are way better tho =) no hating okay!

  • I don't get why people compare Twilight and Harry Potter. What the hell do either of them have in common? Apart from both being huge hits, movie-wise and especially bookwise. Vampires? Wizards? Um, no.

  • yah exactly. it is soo weird

  • Well I've got to admit- Twilight and Harry potter have NOTHING in common.

    The only thing that is better about Harry potter is the person who directed the movies.. The person who directed Twilight missed out on a lot of scenes.

    I still love Twilight though! :D

  • Also the Twilight Director rushed the scenes too.. I hope New Moon is better with the directing

  • they have a differant director for new moon :)

  • Yay :D

  • cathrine hardwicke did and awsome job, she didnt rush them!

  • She did actually.. they cut out a LOT of bits that were significant to the book. and she rushed the last scene with James and Edward

  • Everyone can find bad points, but if it had all the information the book had it would be way, way too long for one sitting.

  • WOW THIS SONG IS WELL COOL

  • lmao xD haaa lmao tht made me laff dnt ask y lool

  • twilight till i die

    way better than harry potter

  • nice x3

  • Twilight till i die!

  • TWILIGHTTTT :)

  • Why's it gotta be Twilight v. Harry Potter?

  • ummmmm both! probably a bit more Harry potter though

  • Hmm I really like both.

  • Harry Potter ovb.

  • they're both too good

    harry potter wins i think though.x

  • harry potter cause its not a piece of shit and doesn't have a psychotic stalker pedophile loser over protective boyfriend in it

  • erm have you even read the books coz its obv your a fucking dumb ass that doesn't even know what the book's about dipshit!

  • what the hell!?

    are you fucking spaztic, if you had read the books, you would understand, watching the film only captures half the story, so untill you have read all four books explaining everything, go fuck yourself and stop bitching about somthing you know fuck all about,

    this song is amazing, and it captures carlisle perfectly, x

  • ive actually read all of them

    and seen the movie

    hated all four books

    and the movie

    only good part about breaking down was when bella was dying cause her werido child was killing her

  • if the books were as 'shit' as you say they were, why the hell would of read them all then went to the effort of watching the film, it makes no sense at all. renesme is not a 'weirdo child'. what the hell is up with you, you hate twilight great go bitch to yourself, why go onto youtube, onto a video with mentions a charecter out of the book, then bitch.

    pointless and pathetic, i feel quite sorry for you tbh, get a hobby.

  • tbh i agree with this.

    zacefronismyboy, please don't bother commenting on this again because it's just pointless. what you said makes no sense at all; if you hate the books then why make the effort to read them all, watch the film and then comment rubbish on my video!!!

  • CLAP CLAP CLAP

    v v gd I love ur response I think it is 100% true thank u for just brightening my day. I agree. If u hate twilight so much then get out of the vids that are about it!!!!

    Lets be honest ur just here 2 bitch. Which is pointless and sad. I agree. Get a hobby.

  • THANK YOU CLAP CLAP CLAP u rock!!! Gd comment I agree 100%...please don't b so sad as to watch vids about something u no u HATE. Get over urself zacefronismyboy...

  • wtf y don't u just reveal the entrie effing story 2 me. I am only on eclipse uve just ruined it all for me. Thanks a bunch and go *****************

  • thanks a bunch for ruining the entire story for me. I am only on a eclipse so go jump in a lake and stop ruining the books I WAS looking forward 2 reading!!!

  • it was ruined the moment stephenie meyer started writing it

  • Because you are a bestselling worldwide author arent you?

    Go fantasise about Zac and leave Twilight alone.

  • im preeeeeeeeety sure i could do better than her

    i didnt even set up this account and i have a different one know

    suck on that bitch

  • I'll take all that back when you do, I wont hold my breath though.

    No need to get abusive, it just shows how wrong you are.

  • Well, Harry Potter is more complicated and the plot is more exciting and dramatic. However, even though Twilight is exciting too, it mainly focuses on teenage girls as an audience whereas Harry Potter is for all ages. Twilight revolves around the love between the two main characted but the plot of Harry Potter is more complicated.

  • Twilight,, harry potter is just too confussing

  • Beautiful! I <3 Carlisle Cullen!

  • I saw this from the advert on facebook, really good who wrote it?

  • lol same here its ok though

  • Same Here =)

    and Idk who wrote it but the Singer is Natalie Nicole Gilbert (I'm guessing...)

  • Me Too!:)

    It is sung by Natalie Nicole Gilbert!

  • Saaamme lol

    i thought i'd add to the chain :D

  • I love Edward more ;)

    Team Switz Forever Though :D

  • omg this song is awsum. it jst explains Carlisle so well

  • ok, i loved twilight but this song is good- but way over the top if it was actually written for Carlisle

  • eeew could it GET anymore cheesey

  • iLove this song ,, it made me cry .. xx

  • I <3 Carlisle Cullen ~~~~~~~

  • This song is sooo Brill.. Can you download it ??

  • you can get the kareoke version from facebook

  • brilliant, the lyrics reaally explain carlisle. i saw the advert on facebook and had to listen. :D carry on, keep going you could be reaal famous. x

  • i saw the ad on facebook too :P (hi5)

  • ha. hi 5 back.

  • me tooo =p hehe

  • this song is so beautiful. i havnt listened to anything else for 2 days! ive told EVERY friend (and my mum) about it!!!

    LOVE IT SO MUCH

  • I love love love love this song!! I'm so upset though because i downloaded it for free of her facebook page and have been listening to it for ages, months even! And now my itunes has deleted it and its not on my computer any more! Any one know where i can get it? Facebook wont let me download it again!!! Thank you x

  • love the song :) and Twilight rules ;) i need to say thanks to my mate Amy aswell for introducing me to the song XD

  • it gave me goosebumps...

  • omg i <3 this song, this film and this video!! carlisle cullen 4 life^^

  • love this song its sooo nice and peaceful

    =]

    Luv Carlise and every1 in Twilight =]

  • I love this

  • This is an amazing song!! Kinda wierd as the Cullens dnt hv 2 breathe!!

  • lol it's a metaphor...

  • Yer!! I never thought bout tht!!

  • YAY! go carlisle!

    TEAM EDWARD 4EVA!!

  • whoooo!!

  • This is such a beautiful song! I love it!

    It gave me chills! ♥♥♥

    I ♥ Twilight

  • such a beautiful song love it, hes okay not the greatest out of all the guys from Twilight but still alright

    TEAM EDWARD!!!!!

  • ooft he is so fit! :)

  • Edward is better though... Twilight is soo amazingg !! If only it was truee and I was Bella !! Ahh I am soo obsessed.. Edward Cullen watches me sleep every night.. I have a life size cardboard cut out of him facing my bed haa :)

  • its so peaceful!!!!

  • Beautiful Song (-:

  • omg he SOOOOOOOOOOO hot, great song

  • Comment removed

  • are you crazy ?

    wtf goes on in your head.

    he one of the most gorgeous men on earth!

  • well said XD

  • Haha you didn't burst anyones bubbles, love.

    It's in the eye of the beholder.

    He's gorgeous. He's just not to you.

    Good day.

  • chillingly beautiful! and total Carlisle.

  • this is beautiful.

    i am obsessed with twilight. like scarily obsessed!!!!

  • who isn't?? =P

  • Like scarily obsessed.

    Wooow. I'm having trouble holding my laughter back!:P

    Aaaah. I'm joking. But that doesnt make much sence. Liiike, AT ALL. Ahahaha.

    <3TWILIGHT<3

  • Hey i love this song and the video is amazing where did you get the song from itunes??

  • on her facebook you can get the song for free

  • I can´t believe how good looking he is, he is amazing! thanks for the video!!

  • SQUEEE! Carlisle was always my favourite ;')

  • ah-mazing! he's so great! i luvvv him! hawtness lol

  • Nice Song :)

    Good Actor (Y)

  • omq...omq...omq...omq

    he is so cute ii wish ii had a dad like that...

    dam iif i cld of marrie him ii would...LöL

  • Lol no offence but that sounded kinda weird...you want him as your dad, and then you want to marry him too? Hahaha but don't worry, I love Carlisle too XD

  • Haha. I'm the same. I'd LOVE to have him as my dad [COOLEST DAD (not-) ALIVE!], But then he's my facev character and I'd love to marry him. Haha. It's weird.

  • I LOOOOOVVVEEE THE CULLLEEENNNSSSS i love love love them i think the song i beautiful just like him, like all of them there should be one about all of them there own songs :D love them xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

  • Gosh I love Carlisle.

    Team Carlisle for sure.

    He's so my favorite character without a doubt.

  • amazing song!!

  • met him =)

    hesss lush, and soo lovely

    and kissed me on the cheek :)

    and hugged me twice.. ahh gaawd i love him

  • Omggg, i hate you ¬.¬

    =P

    Luckyyy so and so...

  • I luv this songs its so beautiful and sums up carlisle so much x

  • I love Carlisle I feel like everyone just forgets him. Thanks for making such a great video on such a great character :)

  • I LOVE CARLISLE CULLEN!!!

  • i like carlisle but not so much this song

  • i lyk the song but id prefer if it was an edward cullen tribute lol though i lyk carlisle

  • i dont know why everyone is so obesessed with this song

    its not that good people

    however, i LOVE carlisle

  • (L)

  • i love this song!

  • beautiful song :( x

  • luv it!! 5*! Most people just overlook Carlisle :'(

  • 5 ★´s

  • Whaatt happed to himm?

  • this is a very moving song and is really enjoyable

  • I love this song!!!!!!

  • Breathing Hope is now on iTunes. :)

  • I love it...so much...xxx

  • the lyrics can be found on facebook

  • aww i love this song. carlisle cullen seems like a really cool dude saving people evn though hes a vamipre and all.

  • Like It !

  • does anyone know the lyrics for this song??

  • no i wish we could get them tho !!! (i knew ud like this song)

  • Her fan page on facebook has the lyrics.

  • thanx