Doctor Who: Waters of Mars - Gone Too Far

[XxCarlieCullenxX]

Thankyou for putting Charley in there. Because not many know about her and she's probably one of the most important companions, she change the Doctor completely.

[dbvixxen]

@XxCarlieCullenxX My pleasure. I thought it was an interesting parallel :).

[TheMonsterphil]

Wow i saw this at 4:00 on pbs it is pretty good

[Reinbeast]

Amazing, beautiful job here. This is one of my favorite videos and it's going in my playlist.

[dbvixxen]

@mzedong001 ...huh? What in the bloody hell does that have to do with my video?

[MrIcelander]

Very well put together, both technically and artistically.

Very moving, I lumped up a wee bit, actually.

[BadWolf2722]

amazing what lovely work i aploud you

[ldramageek]

THAT was BRILLIANT!!

[ICanHearMyHandsRoar]

Amazing. Just amazing. You did absolutely amazing with this! It isn't just adding clips to music like most, it actually sends a message through its edits and its beauty, which you pulled off. Thank you

[Soki1298]

what is the name of the song you used?

[dbvixxen]

@Soki1298 Lost and Forgotten by Audiomachine

[FireflyFanatic3]

LOVE IT! I loved so much what they did with this episode! All about him going way too far and going against the laws of time because he'd become so arrogant and so bitter and sad without his companions ... I love this so much! :)

[Beep12gurl]

This is an AMAZING video!!! And actually this is the 1st time I have heard the Doctor say "I love you" to any1. Even if it is 8. I started watching a few years ago about right after "X-mas Invasion" and I've been hooked ever scince. Sorry, i'm rambling. :P Fantastic job on the video!!! I absolustly love it!!!

[786tauri]

lol this is brilliant!

it shows what the time lord has been through.

[kierany1]

This made me feel sad it was really good :)

[TMontannaScarface]

great vid

[hoodatwhatzit]

Brilliantly done! And although I haven't managed to listen to the Big Finish audios yet, you set it up nicely in the video and it makes perfect sense. I thought Waters of Mars was a fantastic episode. Yes, there were moments when you were made uncomfortable by the Doctor but it's the Doctor! He should make you a little uncomfortable sometimes. For me Waters of Mars was Nine's start of not going gently... :)

[SuperWolsey]

@hoodatwhatzit You mean Ten

[hoodatwhatzit]

@SuperWolsey ah yes... I did. :) oops! Interesting mistake on my part since Nine actually was very... accepting... of his regeneration. I do wish Eccleston had not gone so gently however... one season was too short. Ah well.. they come, they go... I keep watching. :)

[spacexbutterfly]

Nice work! (in a depressing sort of way). I totally forgot about that Joan quote, it fits nicely.

[dbvixxen]

@spacexbutterfly Yes, well... Waters of Mars was a depressing sort of episode! ;) Thanks, though.

[deadmonarchs]

Awesome video...and OMG@Charley/8th Dr audio addition. Made a lovely surprise!!!

[TheDarkBatgirl]

I'm really sad, I have tears, great vid! -favourites-

[topliff12345]

fantastic!

perfect, beautiful vid.

[AbbyRomana]

Gorgeous matching! And you are so right about similarities. The saving of Charley was one of those that WoM reminded me of.

Thank you so much for sharing this with us! :)

[myorli29]

EXTRAORDINARY! :D :D :D

[digitalfare]

This is brilliant; absolutely beautiful.

[keepingthetardis]

Absolutly fantastic.

[The10thDoctorForever]

Beautiful! The music, the voice overs and the memories of the compainions calling him on his faults. It made me cry and the conversation with the eight doctor and his companion - i've never seen it but OMG you can feel the pain!

Well done!

[Janiqua]

Beautiful, beautiful, beautiful! The first time I watched this ep, I could hear Donna's voice in my head. He needs someone to stop him. Thanks for putting that in here. The other clips didn't occur to me, but they're equally impressive. Great job. This is amazing.

[withintemptationrock]

this was..wow!beautifully edittied!i loved it.seriously u done amazing job

[MST3K86]

There is literally nothing I could say right now that could put into words just how incredibly brilliant these 2 minutes are.

Bravo dbvixxen. Bravo.

[gracefulangel47]

That was so beautifully done, LOVED all the voice overs. Nice work!

[DWaDDLJ]

Oh that is very clever!!! I'd forgotton about The Eigth Doctor and Charley!!! I guess the main difference here between the two Docs is that Ten has become smug about saving someone huge in history, while the Eigth tried to save a friend, with no selfishness really. Beautifully done!!

[SoldierofFortune07]

@DWaDDLJ I think we have to take into context the fact that the tenth doctor had to destroy his own people to save the universe whereas 8 hadn't gone through that trauma yet.

[eversoplucky]

Oh, wow.

[heroestwdw]

I love this! It is brilliant! Waters of Mars is probably one of my favorite eps now. David Tennant played it brilliantly and the supporting cast was fantastic. You really showed off the power of the ep in your vid. I love the use of the audio books. You chose great voiceover clips. LOVE IT!!

[LeylaKier]

Oh wow. Thankyou.

[arwynt]

I've got goosebumps all over... Amazing video! Bravo, bravo, bravo! You've captured the essence of the Doctor, a Time Lord trapped between duty and hearts. He's an amazing character and you show a good part of him brilliantly!

[CS1723]

Awesome work as always.

[Savedbygrace015]

AMAZING!!!

I immediately put this in my favorites

[pirateAngel1688]

You captured him going to far perfectly! Just blew me away! Fantastic Job!

[Pinkhoney0269]

oh my god! This is amazing!!! I'm gonna have to watch this over and over it's so good!! I've never listened to the Audio..but I'm gonna find it now cause I gotta know what happened!

[dbvixxen]

Oh good! Paul McGann is in my top three when it comes to actors playing the Doctor pretty much because of his portrayal in the Eighth Doctor Adventures audio plays.

My suggestion: Find these three stories, as they're really closely connected: "Neverland", "Zagreus" and "Scherzo".

[CS1723]

I am listening to those now which reminded me of WoM.

[seduff]

Absolutely stunning work Tara! I am thrilled it all managed to come together so beautifully. My little prompt helped to give you that initial spark you needed, the rest is all you. Bravo :)

[dbvixxen]

Thank you, thank you. That prompt helped me so immensely. It's been ages since I made a video so fast, and you are definitely responsible for that. :) Sometimes all it takes is a nudge in the right direction.

I'm glad you enjoyed it.

[dbvixxen]

By the way, did the Doomsday clip make any sense during the "You've saved the universe before so do it again" part? I wasn't sure. It makes sense to me, but I wasn't sure if it would translate.

[seduff]

I thought it made sense. He saved the universe, but lost Rose. His very own words coming to fruition.

[dbvixxen]

Oh good! I'm glad it worked.

[Rhumer]

brilliant!

[misskennedy06]

wow....really powerful stuff that was great

[mladywolf]

Great Job and a wonderful video.

[dbvixxen]

Thank you. :)

[kelgadis]

woah. good one!

[dbvixxen]

Thanks!

[ecafssot]

★★★★★

Excellent no two ways about it! Created inside of 48 hours bloody marvellous!

[dbvixxen]

I have to thank Seduff for how fast it went. I was struggling for video clip ideas and she made a few suggestions that just got me flying.

Thank you so much for the kind words. :)

[Specialisyou]

wow!! this is amazing!! wow.

[dbvixxen]

Thank you!

[HogwartsProductions]

Great video, really powerful and emotional. Loved it!

I've watched the DW movie but I can't recall those quotes. maybe I just missed them, or maybe I watched a different version of it or something.

[dbvixxen]

Thank you! But it's not from the Movie. It's from the Eighth Doctor Adventures audio plays from Big Finish.

All of these come from a story called, "Neverland", from series 2 of Eight's stories.

[misscynthia17]

Wow !!!! That was just so powerful, perfect use for the quotes ! did not recognize some of them (cause I have never watched the DW movie :s) but I loved it !

[dbvixxen]

Thanks! Nah, it's from the Big Finish audio story, "Neverland." Not the movie. :)