CNN YouTube Debate Question: Immigration

[students4jerrybrown]

I have an idea. Let's pass a law that says anyone who comes in this country illegally AND commits a violent crime (such as murder) should be deported within 96 hours.

If they come back, we try them for the crime + 10 years. HARD LABOR. Not this b.s. panty-waist prison system but CHINA style, HARD labor & brutal conditions. One shower a week. One meal a day (1,500 calories).

Thumbs up if you agree.

[rocketsredglare101]

I have found the best info on the subject of illegal immigration on the numbersusa(dot)com site, I like it becuase you can join for free and send faxes to your senator on immigration. I think it has a million members and helped stop the last amnesty.

[ferrarriguy]

Unpaid costs for treating illegals has directly caused the closings of nearly 100 hospitals in California alone.

Illegals consume nearly $69 BILLION in social services annually.

Children of illegal immigrants cost public schools $28.6 Billion annually.

Illegal immigrant labor depresses wages for American citizens by 200 BILLION a year.

The cost of illegal immigration to the American taxpayer is $55,000 PER illegal.

The total cost annually is over is a whopping $ 338.3 BILLION DOLLARS A YEAR

[historyscoper]

The U.S. and Mexico have a great future - as one. Google "Megamerge Dissolution Solution"

[midtownhm]

lol, yea right. The US would berenamed Canada before joining with Mexico.

[historyscoper]

All I ask is that you read my article before commenting.

[vivalaleta]

@historyscoper Blech. You're nuts.

[mbflys]

The current economy just shows that honkees are incompetent of running a country ... it figures... that's what happens when you let squatters take over...

[historyscoper]

Funny! Google "Megamerge Dissolution Solution" for the real answer to the U.S.-Mexico border problem.

[merinoarnoldo]

"Don't call me 'gringo' you fucking beaner! Stay on your side of that goddamn river don't call me, 'gringo' you beaner!" "No me digas 'beaner' Mr.Punetero, te sacare un gusto por racista y culero, No me llames 'frijolero' pinche gringo punetero!"

[Reaper2thaaztecs]

I am a white man you bungling European pre astilopithicus apes... your all must be those honkites who goes around hiding their honkee tail.. The Mexicans should have let you honkite squatter shrivel up in the desert sun.. they should have let the Indians pick you off in droves ... little did they know that you brough European darkness and filth to the southwest ... They should have allowed you to continue molesting your daughters in the name of god.. Whayte Pauwer...

[Iregretmostofmyposts]

A self hating white man romancing the myth of the Native American utopia who portrays white men of being sexual perverts who would be nothing if it were not for the minorities? How novel.

[AmErIGuRl]

Ahahahaha you crakers crack me up!!

[Arley2011]

LOL Osama Bin Laden

[MotorcycleK9]

But if you believe that to be true than you'll just be blatantly believing lies because that would not be possible. Why? Because the rise of illegal entry into the US manifested itself from mid eighties right up the present day.

[MotorcycleK9]

Also this is similar to what happend when the US was in Vietnam. Even when the Vietnam war ended the US economy still suffered all the way up till 1985. Take some economics and history classes because you are speaking out of your ass without even knowing what you are talking about. If you say that illegals are the cause of our poor economy than you are also saying that the illegals were responsible for the economic downturn of 70's and 80's.

[Iregretmostofmyposts]

" If you say that illegals are the cause of our poor economy than you are also saying that the illegals were responsible for the economic downturn of 70's and 80's" ---I'm not saying who's right or who's wrong, I just wanted to point out that your logic is flawed here.

[jimj122680]

Liberals who support illegal immigrants are actually - unknowingly - siding with greedy U.S. corporations. Why? Because they (ie. liberals) are protecting corporations profit rich, cheap labor workers.

WHO WINS? Greedy companies AND illegal workers (earning FAR more than in Mexico).

WHO LOSES? The U.S. labor class (U.S. proletariat) via job losses to illegal workers & depressed wages.

Thus 120 years of American wage struggles fought since the Haymarket Rebellion of 1886 are being undermined.

[MotorcycleK9]

In fact you are wrong. The reason why wages are so low and the economy is struggling is because 35% of the US budget is going towards the war effort. And the U.S. keeps borrowing from foreign nations to stay afloat here in the US. Also if it werent for the illegal workers the price of goods would skyrocket and people would spend more money on buying few things instead of having lots of money and buying lots of things.

[jimj122680]

35% of the U.S. budget always goes towards defense and has for the past 30 years.

You're wrong. Let me help you understand. Cheap labor provided by illegals only means more profit for greedy companies. Companies NEVER pass the labor savings onto the consumer. You live in some fantasy world in which you think companies actually pass the savings onto the consumer. Do you see the prices of new homes built by wetbacks cheaper than other homes? Of course not dummy.

[mbflys]

Jimj... your logic is flawed... Mexicans dont work for the "greedly corporations".. they create a labor force and labor pool for small businesses competing with the large corporations.

[WhereEaglesDareUK]

tamesidecitizen.blogspot

[drummer703]

NO AMNESTY!!!!

[mmagana007]

Why just mexicans?? what about Canadian, English, French, Irish, Norwegean, Swedish?? oh yeah! thats because they look white!! racist prick

[crashit0079]

No you stupid fuck its because there is a massive influx of MEXICANS crossing the southern border causing schools and hospitals to close...We are a giving country but we have had enuf and if you dont like it moxe to mexico you ignorant mindless worthless bag of shit!

[mmagana007]

what about all the homeless who go to the hospitals and never pay a dime!! why dont you blame them?? because they are so called american?? how are they helping to our economy?? they are not! in the otherhand, mexicans work and pay taxes and they dont complain if they dont get social security benefits. the country is how it is because of immigrants. just think about that? speaking about ignorance!!

[crashit0079]

Ok mush head if you had half a brain you would research the issue not go off emmotion...#1 your right they are Americans! Illegals are NOT Americans...#2 if you research the issue We pay 8 times as much for health care schools,etc than they contribute in taxes it dosent balance out not to mention how many Americans DIE! each day because of Illegal murders,and or Drunk driving!they also mollest hundreds of children in this country! NO MAS!!!

[crashit0079]

were done Americans are fed up! Im a police officer here and i know alot of things that are about to happen and trust me when i say laws are gonna be passed and enforced that will make it so freakin hard on illegals that they will want to go home...were gonna adopt Mexicos immigration policy...Read it and you will see how serious we are....

[IrreplacablePerry]

@mmagana007 I'm sorry but are the NORWEGIANS coming here by tens of thousands?! Why didn't anyone TELL me? Closing our hospitals, taking our jobs, burdening our school system - those damn Norwegians.

[cwcalderon]

it will imposible for the goverment to capture all illegals...once again they are using this issue to make us use the NATIONAL ID and then implant the chip...dont let them !

[cwcalderon]

and how is the demographic make up of this country suppose to be?are there any ratios we are suppose to follow, as in only certain amount of this group but not of the other?

[crashit0079]

Thats right its America NOT MEXAMERICA we dont need 20 million + unskilled mexicans comming here for a free handout ...you have no clue what they cost the american tax payer and were Finished !!!!!you hear ME!!!!!were done and soon you will see

[crashit0079]

You are a stupid mindless fuck! When you get back from MARS and your feet are firmly planted on plannet earth then make a post.Until then fuck off

[doodleduh7]

You know, youre like a computer program, constantly giving me the same anser every time I ask a question, just with more swearing each time. Ive asked you to explain why its racist to NOT check (unless you mean racist against whites), and you keep mentioning the irrelevant fact of 70%.

Just answer, please... Why is it Mitt's responsibility to check, and WHY IS IT RACIST NOT TO?

[doodleduh7]

Again, that could be called racist.

Also, its still not Romneys responsibility to check his landscapers legality. Is it your responsibility to check the credentials of a person serving you at McDonalds?

[doodleduh7]

Umm... doing nothing is racist? Again, it would seem that ordering a man to prove he is here legally just because he is hispanic is more racist than doing nothing.

And... raising taxes isn't going to help fight illegal immigration (unless thats not what you meant, which would make your second paragraph irrelevant).

[doodleduh7]

First, you say is it a loophole, yet you don't explain how. Secondly, you accuse Republicans of racism, but you don't explain how. I hear that so many times!

[doodleduh7]

Um, its not Romney's reponsibility to check his landscapers' legality.

What should he do? If he sees a Hispanic working on his lawn, should he check just because the man is Hispanic? A bit racist, don't you think?

[awill334]

this was very dumb

[HermSon25]

jajajaj muy chistoso ( very funny)

[pedroz84]

i am mexican i like this guys this are real americans funny ajajaj i love america also exexpt for glen beck and lou dobbs will also bush only because i am againt the war

[doodleduh7]

Why not Glenn Beck?

[pedroz84]

and thats only my personal opinion and sometimes he says stuff that i realy find insulting and offencive to other countries he better wash out about what he says(ups read the upper part i reply myself by mistake)

[pedroz84]

will man glen beck is pure propaganda and the way he talks about other countries it seems that he doesnt know anything about other cultures (doesnt know what he is even talking about) i thinks he is pure hate he hates on people bacause his life used to be bad. plus he is making a bigger problem and by the things he said he can produce a war between people

[highlander924]

The Terbuloses guy.

so funny

[AmericanCountryPride]

How the hell ARE we going to catch them? Really?

[joey11011]

You can't; it's that simple, so deal with it.

[hectela]

People can be so ignorant. how the hell a person can get money from the government without an ID be real..People please go back to school. it really sickens me to hear all these false information.

[ahowell71]

live from new york it's saturday night live!

that's FUNNY

[willtrib]

YUP!

GRAVEL IN '08

[fearthenoise]

Dang! You're saying my daddy could of gotten all these things.....for free!!!!! Man, did we miss out..The gov't giving money without an ID check....that'd be day if i'm wrong let me know, I wanna tell the whole world about it. check your facts turd.

[acpunk321]

'the fuck, man?

[stilllfresh]

crackers

[RevelAngel]

-Free Health Care ?.

Yeah right, call medicaid, geez, I hear this every day.

-Free Food Stamps? people who don't even have a license driver how the hell going to get money from the goverment, if they can even provide basic documents, ( don't tell me the goverment takes fakes id's or stolen SS numbers ).

-Earned Income Tax Credit ? you think the IRS going to give you money away with a false SS number ( that was a good one!)

[RevelAngel]

-Low Income Housing Subsidies ???? Dude you should lay down the Lou Dobbs watchin and get the facts straight.

[RevelAngel]

-Free Health Care ?.

Yeah right, call medicaid, geez, I hear this every day.

-Free Food Stamps? people who don't even have a license driver how the hell going to get money from the goverment, if they can even provide basic documents, ( don't tell me the goverment takes fakes id's or stolen SS numbers ).

-Earned Income Tax Credit ? you think the IRS going to give you money away with a false SS number ( that was a good one!)

[RevelAngel]

-Low Income Housing Subsidies ???? Dude you should lay down the Lou Dobbs watchin and get the facts straight.

[jzmet]

Medicaid, food stamps, free meals and registration fees galore at school, section 8 housing, and a special non-SS ID card they can use to file their taxes.

If you don't KNOW all of this has been going on for a very long time, you don't get out much. Just come by my town of ~30,000 in little ole Iowa and I'll take you on a tour. It's been going on here for 20+ yrs!

[cutejoker69]

oh by the way mexicans need to be sent to iraq to fight the radical islamic terrorists that are a posing a great security risk to america cuz u know americans are real lazy especially white americans with goofy irish and german names.

[cutejoker69]

hey dont mexicans look like american indians they look just like em i mean there a dead ringer

[ginzalzman]

Zeitgeist - The Movie: Federal Reserve (Part 1 of 5)

search on above and open ur eyes what really going on!

[masda2000]

I'm italian but veryinterested in the political issues of the US...could someone write the text of this questions?It sounds funny but I can't catch it completely!Thank you

[soutrik1993]

Yeah, let's think about that for a second. Illegals oppressed, hmmmm.... Maybe they should have thought about that before illegally coming into the US. The rights of criminals should not be the top priority of this election.

[oneslickjackrabbit]

ROFL

[Skotophilic]

Why don't you people protect your future with an education? America really can't afford unskilled people and she can't afford the brain drain as other nations are holding on to their educated populace. Look at all the professionals from other countries - Medical professionals, Professors, Engineers, and other scientists and you might be able to get an idea what I am talking about. The minutemen don't fit this class do they?

[postmann1000]

dammm cool!

[lbutler45]

LOL...thanks guys for making the debate last night enjoyable!! The way you used sense of humor to raise important issues in America was brillant. I hope you'll send in questions for the next bunch of idiots in the White House. Your questions are welcomed by me guys. Hopefully your jokes opens the heart of our next President. Keep 'em coming guys. Good luck & may God Bless us all

[charles1967]

Hella funny. Nice work!

[kalijasin]

"we barely caught the tuburculosus guy" that was so funny!!!!!!!! These guys are the best!!!!!!

[nhprman]

"we barely caught the tuburculosus guy." Bwahahahahaha!! These guys are hilarious!

[atomiccherrnoble]

Hahah this was hilarious.

This wasn't meant to be discriminatory at all but this is by far amazing, ingenious with the tuberculosis comment. I believe these guys are genius and people need to relax

[ThuhBull]

All of us at ThuhBull love it !!! That's why we put em on our websight!!!!

RickHisself

[Nepheshxoxo]

froffy mexicans? GET A FUCKING RIDICULOUS LIFE MEN.

[putittogether]

Now that funny, love it.

[cherrygirl3]

ahhahahahhahah. the "turboculosis" comment was genious. sooo funny.

[HMEHaldir]

I am from Tennessee and this video makes me sad, now everyone will think Tennesseans are all redneck, ignorant scumbags.

[BoboTalkClownA]

Uhh... MOST are... Actually most americans are...

[usnationalist]

...and you would prefer more of a "liberal douche bag" image?

[houihoi]

私は移民でない。

[mazinani12]

these guys rule!

[linwooddeaton]

Don't hire them, jail employers that do.

Don't give them benefits,our income taxes pay for.

Don't rent/sell houses to them.

Or if the traitorous U.S. Mexican government demands..

[enseign]

If they put as much effort into illegal immigration as they put into catching those danged ole pesky and severely dangerous non-seatbelt drivers, you could eliminate illegal immigration by the 4th of July 2007.

[josuegrover]

your fucken stupid

illegal immigrants since they don't have any documents i.e they don't have their permanent residency or US citizenship -- then they do NOT get any benefits. thedrunkpianist two comments below will tell very well about how he is not applicable to receive financial aid (a benefit!) for college because he is undocumented.

and with out these documents as simple as a SSN one can't buy a house.

do your fucken research before you say stupid shit.

[thedrunkpianist]

hold up. i need you to ellaborate, im confused whether your insult me or enseign.

[call1]

Your the one who's shown how "Stupid" he is. I can show you thousands of Undocumented Illegals in the US who, A.. Get government benefits..B.. Own their own home through a bank loan.. & C.. Get financial aide to go to school. As long as the illegals can find a social security number/ name/ date of birth to "steal" (which also makes em thief's, & Lier's).

[josuegrover]

Mr. LINWOODDEATION:

[vshagios]

Live traps...tortilla bait.  Or, snare traps...tortilla bait.

[thedrunkpianist]

tortilla with frijoles for me sir. oh and a can of the all american classic coke

[Illegalsgo2hell]

hire them to build the wall and then simply dont pay them....and make whoever hires them to come build the wall..man by the time that puppy is built there shouldnt be many illegal scum left.

[thedrunkpianist]

you have a great imagination. but that wont quite work on us. keep it up though maybe someday you'll have your own tv show or something.

[Illegalsgo2hell]

look there are peanuts on the ground.

[thedrunkpianist]

hahaha that was rather a bit funny than offending. am i suppose to come up with the same type of weak rebuttal? look there are cheeseburgers on the ground

[Illegalsgo2hell]

yeah I know..jezzzz

[thedrunkpianist]

oh wait i just thought of a funnier one:

look there are "God Bless America" bumper stickers on the ground

[StarofDavid]

an infectious disease that may affect almost any tissue of the body, esp. the lungs, caused by the organism Mycobacterium tuberculosis, and characterized by tubercles a grotesque effigy of Guy Fawkes that is paraded through the streets and burned on Guy Fawkes Day... That is what I;m talkin bout

[revjmike]

You put up a sign saying, "Free Tacos," and wait for them to come in.

:-)

I'm just kidding; but this IS a legitimate question unlike the Obama/Edwards good looking one.

It's also quite funny.

[mmcattle]

so true/so true..goatmaan

[tamitchell00]

You don't have to catch them they will go home if they can't get a job, health care, or education and there is at least 20 million

[thedrunkpianist]

deport the real criminals i say. i am one of the good illegals i must say so myself. i've continue my education in a community college and i will further my education in a 4 year college. somehow, someway i will live here regardless of my status. home is where you make it

[KuroiXHF]

Wrong. There is no such thing as a good illegal. It's an oxymoron. If you step foot into this country, and you are not allowed to, then you are breaking the law, which means that you are not good. Now please, get off this country.

[thedrunkpianist]

You think they'll pull out a book of laws and double check to see if their mistake will be impacted by consequences? When your nation is corrupt with crooked politicians, law 'enforcements'. When people hardly receive any education past the 8th grade, Do you really believe its possible to become a law-abiding human under those conditions? Enough the bullshit, Lets Keep It Real.

[katotheother]

Screw the REAL! Let's keep it self-riteous like it ought to be!

[thedrunkpianist]

yea screw the real. sit infront of the television and let it feed you. how far will you get with your worthless mentality?

[katotheother]

My, aren't you young, half-educated, self-riteous and cocky? By the way, I'm sitting in front of a computer screen, not at TV.

[salesgaines]

don't you realize that this is just a joke?

[abolof]

who is ron paul? find out.

[azh01e]

Dunlap is showing video making fatigue, stay strong.

[LotSix66]

I noticed that, too.

[paintedhorse1957]

these guys are great

[cujothekitten]

I think this is the one guys! See you on CNN :D

[ultraollie]

I really like the entire Redstate update collection, but this one is the best! You have to make a DVD of these and sell them.

[PizzaGod]

This is one that needs to be used

[noles1733]

Great question! I hope they show it.