This religious solo motet was composed at the time Mozart was visiting Milan. It was written for the castrato Venanzio Rauzzini, Mozart's favourite for his operas, who had been Cecilio in Lucio Silla the previous year. Although nominally for liturgical use, the motet has many features in common with Mozart's concert arias, such as those drawn from his operas.
I think people need to make up their minds. You complain when a singer sings something the same way as everyone else does; THE WAY IT WAS WRITTEN. Yet when they make stylistic changes and interpret it in their own way you bitch anyways. Make up your minds.
I myself love Renee, and I think that this was a wonderful performance. There are better ones, but for what it was this is a good performance.
I like Renee Fleming. But I don't know if Mozart like her interpretation or not because I do not know music much. I lie Renee's voice. Mozart would not mind others interpret his songs/music in a different way? ??
I think it is great that she added a cadenza... it is what singers during Mozart's day would have done. I am sure that Ms. Fleming has done thorough research on ALL of the performance practices of Mozart.
I always enjoy watching Ms,Fleming- she seems to get so much joy out of her singing. But, I highly doubt that Mozart had anything resembling this interpretation in mind when he wrote this piece. Of course, had he been forced to watch La Bartoli, he may have quit writing altogether! Please, I'm not looking to argue, but some singers need to go back to Music History 101 and connect with the composer.
You have a point but when artists execute their creativity, it is really very hard to say what should and shouldn't be done. I agree, however, that care should be taken that the interpretation respects the composer's wishes.
you must be a really intelligent person to have come up with something that clever. i've never heard anyone say something quite that smart in my entire life, do you write your own insults or have you hired a team of professionals to do it for you???
in the event that you're too stupid to realize i'm being sarcastic and think you're a complete retard, and you may as well just go jump from a bridge or play in heavy traffic. fucking idiot.
wow you're more stupid then i'd originally thought. just kill yourself and get it over with, you're a waste of space and obviously don't know how to read. just go die, you pathetic excuse for a human. you're a horrible little man and are taking up valuable air that intelligent people need.
I don't know why, but to me this seems to suit mezzo soprano voices better. My favorite version is by Anne-Sophie von Otter. I like Christine Schaefer singing it too. I would certainly not dismiss what Renee has done here, like some other posters. She does well singing a difficult piece.
She started wonderful (the record with Mozartarias) and some years later she changed her voice with her to much darkenings 8do she think that she will get a voice like Jessye Norman?) Cant understand her ambishions.... This is not anymore creamy this is an old aunt from Kentucky ....excuse...
She always rises her palate high to produce a sweet voice. I went to her performance in Taiwan on 2007. She had very good eye-contact with audience. I remembered that she looked at me when she sang some phrases. It was a wonderful evening to hear she sang Strauss's last four songs and popular song-'somewhere over the rainbow.'
This is great fun... and Ms Fleming clearly enjoys the ad lib at 2.00 in. For a touch of heaven though please go and listen to Arleen Auger, sublime and very focused on the music rather than giving a show... both ladies terrific in their own way of course but for an enduring satisfying musicianly version give Auger a moment of your time,
I agree. Diana is magnificent with Mozart, her queen of the night is unmatched. Renee is more suited for lyric romantic stuff, she's lovely here though. Kiri te Kanawa (I'm prejudice...she's my favorite by far) is incredible with Mozart. It is actually one of her specialties (even not being prejudiced!)
I actually think Dessay is the best as the queen of the night. I agree that Te Kanawa is the best with Mozart overall, as she is also my favorite soprano. Fleming does a great job here, too.
Hey..You're all so critical one must asume you are superb musicians.I prefer Kathleen Battle singing this, but gee...it's pretty damn good to my untutored ears !
The cadenza with straight-tone is awful for this piece. Oddly enough, theres a vid of her singing the 3rd section of this on YouTube and it's quite decent.
This religious solo motet was composed at the time Mozart was visiting Milan. It was written for the castrato Venanzio Rauzzini, Mozart's favourite for his operas, who had been Cecilio in Lucio Silla the previous year. Although nominally for liturgical use, the motet has many features in common with Mozart's concert arias, such as those drawn from his operas.
Wikipedia
RuntyDev 1 week ago
Well, she's better than Damrau or Sutherland. Her vibrato is damaging, however, to the melodic integrity, and her tuning is short of perfect.
lodovicosforza 2 weeks ago
A real singer.
Cissy97 1 month ago
Wonderful ...thank you ! :)
zara2255 1 year ago
Love it. She's having fun with the piece and she sounds wonderful.
Anyone notice that the video is not in sync with the sound?
Buggs the hell out of me.
Mandryka2009 1 year ago
Sing to me, Renee!!! Sing to me!!! There is nothing quite like that smooth, buttery legato hers. I get chills <3
RavenSiren 1 year ago
Her cadenza is so beautiful. Whoever wrote it for really understands the beauty of her voice.
asdfopera 2 years ago 4
@asdfopera ,Mozart? I did not know he was able to see the future.
marshallrkeith 2 months ago
@marshallrkeith
nope. i think it was christoph eschenbach.
asdfopera 2 months ago
this is absolutely beautiful. Her interpretation, stylistic choices, and ornamentation are spot on. what a truly beautiful instrument she possesses.
tenorlovesasoprano 2 years ago
I think people need to make up their minds. You complain when a singer sings something the same way as everyone else does; THE WAY IT WAS WRITTEN. Yet when they make stylistic changes and interpret it in their own way you bitch anyways. Make up your minds.
I myself love Renee, and I think that this was a wonderful performance. There are better ones, but for what it was this is a good performance.
tenor220 2 years ago
The best version of this is Kiri Te Kanawa (concert in london in the early 90's)
diradour 2 years ago
Je n'aime pas ses ports de voix et ses glissando et ce n'est pas dans le style. Une bellevoix quand même,
oscardaher0865 2 years ago
Comment removed
fairlytaleofnewyork 2 years ago
I like Renee Fleming. But I don't know if Mozart like her interpretation or not because I do not know music much. I lie Renee's voice. Mozart would not mind others interpret his songs/music in a different way? ??
udon890 2 years ago
TTrylistening to secret2singer2
secret2singer2 2 years ago
I think it is great that she added a cadenza... it is what singers during Mozart's day would have done. I am sure that Ms. Fleming has done thorough research on ALL of the performance practices of Mozart.
MrRickster74 2 years ago
i am exulting and Jubilate listening to this!
kstewintheart4u 2 years ago
lol
alilapointe1 2 years ago
she treats this like wagner! i'll pass!
GosfordAbercrombie 2 years ago
I always enjoy watching Ms,Fleming- she seems to get so much joy out of her singing. But, I highly doubt that Mozart had anything resembling this interpretation in mind when he wrote this piece. Of course, had he been forced to watch La Bartoli, he may have quit writing altogether! Please, I'm not looking to argue, but some singers need to go back to Music History 101 and connect with the composer.
suzanneetmoi 2 years ago
You have a point but when artists execute their creativity, it is really very hard to say what should and shouldn't be done. I agree, however, that care should be taken that the interpretation respects the composer's wishes.
monlamdrompa 2 years ago
shes good!
stagesix6 2 years ago
jackkjack: shut up !
222mozart 2 years ago
you must be a really intelligent person to have come up with something that clever. i've never heard anyone say something quite that smart in my entire life, do you write your own insults or have you hired a team of professionals to do it for you???
in the event that you're too stupid to realize i'm being sarcastic and think you're a complete retard, and you may as well just go jump from a bridge or play in heavy traffic. fucking idiot.
tenor220 2 years ago
Why thank you contradictive sir..!
Calling me smart at first then retarded and again smart.. i guess you're the plucking id i ot here, not?
jackkjack 2 years ago
wow you're more stupid then i'd originally thought. just kill yourself and get it over with, you're a waste of space and obviously don't know how to read. just go die, you pathetic excuse for a human. you're a horrible little man and are taking up valuable air that intelligent people need.
tenor220 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i owned u.. admit it
fuck your mother, Okay?
jackkjack 2 years ago
pretentious much???
tenor220 2 years ago
not only pretentious, but incredibly stupid as well
hulkchicken 2 years ago
i love renee, she's one of my favorite sopranos by far.
tenor220 2 years ago
does anyone really believe this is Mozart?
Gabriel13187 2 years ago 2
I don't know. It's too deep. Amadeus is more silly, but Wolfgang may be the composer :-)
alexanfaria 2 years ago
my answer: No, I don't belive.
alexanfaria 2 years ago
Comment removed
flouraki 2 years ago
Beautiful!
bellasong75 3 years ago
I don't know why, but to me this seems to suit mezzo soprano voices better. My favorite version is by Anne-Sophie von Otter. I like Christine Schaefer singing it too. I would certainly not dismiss what Renee has done here, like some other posters. She does well singing a difficult piece.
swanningaround 3 years ago
She started wonderful (the record with Mozartarias) and some years later she changed her voice with her to much darkenings 8do she think that she will get a voice like Jessye Norman?) Cant understand her ambishions.... This is not anymore creamy this is an old aunt from Kentucky ....excuse...
lamusicahera 3 years ago
She always rises her palate high to produce a sweet voice. I went to her performance in Taiwan on 2007. She had very good eye-contact with audience. I remembered that she looked at me when she sang some phrases. It was a wonderful evening to hear she sang Strauss's last four songs and popular song-'somewhere over the rainbow.'
YingYingChang 3 years ago 7
This is great fun... and Ms Fleming clearly enjoys the ad lib at 2.00 in. For a touch of heaven though please go and listen to Arleen Auger, sublime and very focused on the music rather than giving a show... both ladies terrific in their own way of course but for an enduring satisfying musicianly version give Auger a moment of your time,
hugothebear 3 years ago
I prefer Diana Damrau.
Her voice is more versatile and is THE ONE for Mozart's vocal music.
materialmyra 3 years ago 2
After Cher
rscmrcmd 3 years ago
you better be kidding if you're saying cher is better then renee
tenor220 2 years ago
I agree. Diana is magnificent with Mozart, her queen of the night is unmatched. Renee is more suited for lyric romantic stuff, she's lovely here though. Kiri te Kanawa (I'm prejudice...she's my favorite by far) is incredible with Mozart. It is actually one of her specialties (even not being prejudiced!)
saxamaphoneguy1 2 years ago 2
I actually think Dessay is the best as the queen of the night. I agree that Te Kanawa is the best with Mozart overall, as she is also my favorite soprano. Fleming does a great job here, too.
nothinbetta2do 2 years ago
Very good. But I still prefer Gruberova's and Battle's.
gemininer 3 years ago
i've been looking for just this video!!! thank you so much for posting it! <3!
nightbeauty02 3 years ago
I wish the first part of the Exultate Jubilate were on here, and not just the second half.
ising4god87 3 years ago
I love it.
jamesaugusta 4 years ago
Not her best performance for sure...
Pablo81 4 years ago
I love Renee Fleming, but I definitely don't like her interpretation of this.
She does look delighted after her 'freestyle' though (2:16). :P
cabbalistic 3 years ago
Excellent performace
j1015512 5 years ago
Oh God this is awesome! I've been looking for something like this, from Fleming for a long time...Thanks!
sexybcl21 5 years ago
Hey..You're all so critical one must asume you are superb musicians.I prefer Kathleen Battle singing this, but gee...it's pretty damn good to my untutored ears !
yeahbyme 5 years ago
Fleming makes it like opera...well she can do it.
Sh is Fleming.
andreasscholl 5 years ago
where was this sung?
The cadenza with straight-tone is awful for this piece. Oddly enough, theres a vid of her singing the 3rd section of this on YouTube and it's quite decent.
ARReith 5 years ago
tacky and cheap; where is the purity?
xgianpatrick 5 years ago