brian1234567894 - The reason Henry killed Sully was because he had to kill everyone in order for him to be left alone to live on the island with Abi (as they wished as young children). The wedding was just a fake from Henry, to get Abi back to the island as a wedding was the only way, even if it invalid killing everyone (I suppose that's how much Abi meant to him) so he killed everyone alongside John Wakefield but John thought he was on his side when really henry was just using him to help kill
This makes no sense why would henery kill everyone he caired about. so what you were adopted and lied to. so you kill all your friends. why didn't he just say no to marrying trish then henrey is a fuckind bitch.
@brian1234567894 Henry didn't care about any of those people, he was crazy. The wedding was a lie because it was the only way to get Abby to go back to the island. Henry wanted to live alone on the island with Abby forever, because she promised him that when they were kids.
i'm confused, i never got it till now even after I saw the whole season.. did Henry not want to kill Sully but since he stayed on the island he had no choice?
This had to be one of the, if not THE saddest death...I can't imagine standing before one of my childhood friends and learning that he/she is a serial killer about to kill me. How heartbreaking.
I don't really understand why Henry said "you shoud have never dogged Trish" to Sully because anyway he doesn't mind he was in love with Abby, doesn't he?..
@romanelikeme Sully has nothing to do with what happened in the past on the island or his relationship with Abby. So, he may have been just trying to find a "rational" reason to kill his innocent best friend
@Wynbis Yeah I agree. It looks like Henry was super conflicted about killing Sully. Especially in the first 90 sec of the clip when he seems genuinely shocked that Sully stayed behind. I think he was counting on Sully going home so he wouldn't have to kill his best friend. Henry may have been a sociopath, but he really did care about Sully
what's wrong with Henry? Why would he do those things? Why on earth would you kill your fucking best friend?!? And I don't care if it was "part of the plan" Henry is stupid -.-
I really enjoyed this series, i thought it was quite original. One thing i did like was the writing, it always seemed to keep me hooked and this scene shows it very well too with the double meanings and dramatic irony, like when Sully says "and abandon you?", when we know that Henry is one of the killers, or "That is quite possibly the stupidest thing you have ever done" because we now know what Henry will do. Some may call it cheesey but i liked it.
I actually think the motive behind the killers is very original too, How many times have you seen something like this were the killer is just a seemingly omnipotent being with no clear motive and a high gore factor? Even though i know some people who complained about the ending/motive i thought it made this even better because of how 'sick' it was. Some pretty bad things must have happened to make you like Henry and kill your own best-friends, then enjoy it. But enoughm im rambling now.
i was watching this scene with subtitles on, and he actually says "you never should have DOGGED trish"..... can someone explain that? haha did i skip an episode or something?!
@nykkiL101 no, he said you never should have dogged trish. sully told henry in ep. 4 during the bachelor party that he pursued trish when they broke up and she turned him down flat
but look, see, Henry's all 'WHAT?! Why didn't you go with them?', which means he cares for Sully. Of course, then he stabbed him, which kind of negates the previous thing. :/
It should have gone by this way: Sully:Zomg i got five dollarz at bar Henry:I am going to kill you noob Sully: Zomg i got shotgunh i am going to pwn u! - Then wakefield comes - Sully:ARGH AN ALIEN MONSTER wakefield: Omg i am not monster asshole Sully: omg you noobs think i am gonna die? Henry & wakefield:Noob ofcourse Sully: Say hello to my little friend! Sully pwns henry and wakefield like this He kicks henry at balls & henry flyes to moon. And wakefield says omg and he self destructs
Henry you SICK BASTARD. He used Trish, betrayed his so called "friends".. sick. So fucking sick. He killed almost everybody on the island, and then thought "HEY, now that everyone's out of the way, ABBY PROBABLY LOVES ME NOW, HOORAY". Yeah, everyone loves him for killing all of her friends. GREAT JOB, HENRY.
yeah but he was trying to change that's what makes it more sad:(...he came back for henry his BEST FRIEND...that's what makes him not deserve to die even more...if anyone deserves to die it's not sully for trying to do the right thing...it's henry for betraying his bestfriend :)
okaay so, this is an old show now but i loved it since day onee. HENRY, rot in hell. i feel bad for him at the end but sully ? =[ he was my favoritee.
its sooooo sad because Sully trusted Henry sooo much as his best friend. Sure Sully isn't perfect but he didn't deserve to be killed by his own best friend like that....
It's sad that wat makes him snap was when he laughed at malcom's death.
After all this, I still thought malcom's story was the saddest. Not only did he die, but henry made his life a living hell before he did... even after malcom made the right choice at the end.
Oh well, at least someone knew what happened to him in the end.
well yeah he did hit on chloe but chloe was leading him on.I'm not justifying it but it's not ALL him.She shouldn't of flirted with him...either way both of them were wrong not JUST him...I don't care what he did I felt horrible for him :(
that's ok it's just a lot of people talk about how sully's wrong and don't even realize what chloe was doing...they both were wrong.I feel bad for cal in that situation because sully was trying to take chloe away from him and chloe was always flirting with other guys
shot that basterd!
thexhorrorloverx33 1 month ago
he should have went with them!
thexhorrorloverx33 1 month ago
my life is now ruined :(
thexhorrorloverx33 1 month ago
what does he say to sully about trish?
92LiamO 1 month ago
You made this with final cut x
KaelanFournierTV 2 months ago
Such an underrated show
lostfan73 2 months ago
matt is hot as hell
jagelskarmcfly 3 months ago 2
Comment removed
xXxNoXGirlyXGirlxXx 3 months ago
Why are them two killing everyone????
Narwhalsss 4 months ago
D': I cried.
BillyJayXX 5 months ago
brian1234567894 - The reason Henry killed Sully was because he had to kill everyone in order for him to be left alone to live on the island with Abi (as they wished as young children). The wedding was just a fake from Henry, to get Abi back to the island as a wedding was the only way, even if it invalid killing everyone (I suppose that's how much Abi meant to him) so he killed everyone alongside John Wakefield but John thought he was on his side when really henry was just using him to help kill
MissElenorRose 5 months ago
This makes no sense why would henery kill everyone he caired about. so what you were adopted and lied to. so you kill all your friends. why didn't he just say no to marrying trish then henrey is a fuckind bitch.
brian1234567894 7 months ago
@brian1234567894 Henry didn't care about any of those people, he was crazy. The wedding was a lie because it was the only way to get Abby to go back to the island. Henry wanted to live alone on the island with Abby forever, because she promised him that when they were kids.
LadyBria1996 4 months ago
i'm confused, i never got it till now even after I saw the whole season.. did Henry not want to kill Sully but since he stayed on the island he had no choice?
Nytex03 8 months ago
awwwwwww sully!!!!!!! i hate this part he was my favorite character!!! UGH
CoolGirl701 8 months ago 2
'Lifes Hard; Grow A Pair' i loved sully:(
he was my favoruite character, this was the saddest death, alongside cal and chloes :(
annaanicolee 8 months ago 7
i knew trish would die once she donned her wedding dress.
idk it looked like the white would show dark red so well, the producers just had to do it.
ayumunarumi15 10 months ago
Sully even stayed on the island for Henry and his friends. Now thats a good friend and then u come to find out Henry kills him.... so sad
ChrisMarquette22 10 months ago 12
This had to be one of the, if not THE saddest death...I can't imagine standing before one of my childhood friends and learning that he/she is a serial killer about to kill me. How heartbreaking.
silkcorset 11 months ago 4
odio henry è un bastardo figlio di puttana
grecy11 1 year ago
I FUCKING LOVE HARPERS ISLAND!!!
alnuggy 1 year ago 48
I don't really understand why Henry said "you shoud have never dogged Trish" to Sully because anyway he doesn't mind he was in love with Abby, doesn't he?..
romanelikeme 1 year ago 2
@romanelikeme Sully has nothing to do with what happened in the past on the island or his relationship with Abby. So, he may have been just trying to find a "rational" reason to kill his innocent best friend
Wynbis 1 year ago
@Wynbis Yeah I agree. It looks like Henry was super conflicted about killing Sully. Especially in the first 90 sec of the clip when he seems genuinely shocked that Sully stayed behind. I think he was counting on Sully going home so he wouldn't have to kill his best friend. Henry may have been a sociopath, but he really did care about Sully
JGT021 11 months ago 5
@romanelikeme jealousy? maybe he's still pissed over it. i mean we're all human.
or he felt like he was justifying the death to some extent. idk. ur rite
ayumunarumi15 10 months ago
This is too messed up....
what's wrong with Henry? Why would he do those things? Why on earth would you kill your fucking best friend?!? And I don't care if it was "part of the plan" Henry is stupid -.-
WowWtfKasumi 1 year ago
Sully was my favourite..
FANvonANTO30 1 year ago 2
sully(matt barr) is sooo cuuteee! (i hate henrie)
selinaundclara 1 year ago
SULLYYYYYYYYYY NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO i loved him so much
avater509 1 year ago
I really enjoyed this series, i thought it was quite original. One thing i did like was the writing, it always seemed to keep me hooked and this scene shows it very well too with the double meanings and dramatic irony, like when Sully says "and abandon you?", when we know that Henry is one of the killers, or "That is quite possibly the stupidest thing you have ever done" because we now know what Henry will do. Some may call it cheesey but i liked it.
Phill1794 1 year ago
I actually think the motive behind the killers is very original too, How many times have you seen something like this were the killer is just a seemingly omnipotent being with no clear motive and a high gore factor? Even though i know some people who complained about the ending/motive i thought it made this even better because of how 'sick' it was. Some pretty bad things must have happened to make you like Henry and kill your own best-friends, then enjoy it. But enoughm im rambling now.
Phill1794 1 year ago 4
Henry should have at least kept sully and not killed him. :(
ChrisMarquette22 1 year ago
i was watching this scene with subtitles on, and he actually says "you never should have DOGGED trish"..... can someone explain that? haha did i skip an episode or something?!
BurntOutYesterdays 1 year ago
@BurntOutYesterdays its an expresion they use, somewhere in the US. Its like "hitted," he never shoud have hitted on trish.
Watch "Harper's Island Solved" and they explain it :-)
MathiasMoeller 1 year ago
"And abandon you?" Gosh, I love Sully. Damn you Henry.
GlassWonderland 1 year ago 6
"I cried seeing his face" oh come on, is he really that ugly :P
energizer61bunny 1 year ago
wow, talk about some serious "father-son" bonding... =)
nykkiL101 1 year ago
he never sould have what trish?
proudtobeme824 1 year ago
Comment removed
nykkiL101 1 year ago
@nykkiL101 no, he said you never should have dogged trish. sully told henry in ep. 4 during the bachelor party that he pursued trish when they broke up and she turned him down flat
ZWKA1 1 year ago
Sully was my favourite (and Chloe and Cal). I think it's because he grew up most as a person during these episodes. I loved him!
isingtoyou13 1 year ago 4
I wiah they made new eps on Harpers Island :o
xjelyxbearx 1 year ago
but look, see, Henry's all 'WHAT?! Why didn't you go with them?', which means he cares for Sully. Of course, then he stabbed him, which kind of negates the previous thing. :/
veemarsrocks 1 year ago 6
Sully's look...very sadly :'(
Naomi1990Strawberry 1 year ago 4
"Life's hard, grow a pair." Oh, Sully, I miss you <3
chelly1688 1 year ago 6
i love sully!!! i was so upset when henry killed him! :(
but i love how he says "your dad is dead, i went to his funeral" at 4:23. he just sounds so cute there.
joejonasgirlie 2 years ago
hahah "dude lifes hard grow a pair"
sasquatch000006 2 years ago
oh my god this is very nice
StVoReNaZaLjUbAv555 2 years ago
Tikkariheppu3 2 years ago
sully lives on
in here <3
tiff123321 2 years ago 2
sully is the best!♥
JBfashionfreak 2 years ago
Sully was my favourite :(
gokulauri 2 years ago 4
whats the last henry said about malcom before he wanted to shoot him?
cherrystylerx 2 years ago
"He made good beer didn't he".........henry's a real jerk!!!
energizer61bunny 2 years ago 3
if anyone deserves to die its definetely henry and not SULLY. i love him soo much :'( ♥
cherrystylerx 2 years ago 5
"That is quit posibly the worst thing you have ever done" lol Henery was a cool vilian... Until he got all crazy with Abby at the end.
wormywils 2 years ago
HOW CAN SOMEONE BE SUCH A FUCKING LYING BACKSTABBING PERSON!?!?!?
I HATE THAT GUY!!! ;____; Sully you can't die *sobs*
SnowChild297 2 years ago 6
Henry you SICK BASTARD. He used Trish, betrayed his so called "friends".. sick. So fucking sick. He killed almost everybody on the island, and then thought "HEY, now that everyone's out of the way, ABBY PROBABLY LOVES ME NOW, HOORAY". Yeah, everyone loves him for killing all of her friends. GREAT JOB, HENRY.
LeneChokle 2 years ago 7
I freaking HATE Henry.
Jason2468p 2 years ago 6
Henry war so ein Mistkerl. Fand auch Sully war die coolste Person in der Serie.
Juudai1 2 years ago 2
Sad, but Sully had the Chance to escape that dang psychos.
Kakarott06 2 years ago
yeah but he was trying to change that's what makes it more sad:(...he came back for henry his BEST FRIEND...that's what makes him not deserve to die even more...if anyone deserves to die it's not sully for trying to do the right thing...it's henry for betraying his bestfriend :)
energizer61bunny 2 years ago 7
sully was my favourite person
PvtElder 2 years ago
ich hasse Henry auch ;)
NuriaFrankPanik 2 years ago
scheiße
NuriaFrankPanik 2 years ago
mit' vittuua sää rotta selität
ParkourTeamEJJP 2 years ago
okaay so, this is an old show now but i loved it since day onee. HENRY, rot in hell. i feel bad for him at the end but sully ? =[ he was my favoritee.
beachchickXx3 2 years ago
oh yes he was my favourite too...
PvtElder 2 years ago
vitun äpärä saatana kannattaa miettii kaks kertaa kenelle auott päätäs vitun homo rotta (thaimaalainen kääpiö siili)
ParkourTeamEJJP 2 years ago
H E N R Y
I
H A T E
Y O U
bavaro6 2 years ago 5
You are My friend!!!you deserve to know before... Poor Sully and the others...
Epiyblassa 2 years ago 4
Fuck you Henry for killing my favourite character on the show. I loved Sully.
Hamburgo100 2 years ago 5
its sooooo sad because Sully trusted Henry sooo much as his best friend. Sure Sully isn't perfect but he didn't deserve to be killed by his own best friend like that....
LazyDaisyxo 2 years ago 93
@LazyDaisyxo i know right and sully stayed on the island for him....GOSHH
CoolGirl701 8 months ago
henrx :(
MultiSchnute 2 years ago
Sylly and Trish were the best characters ;( But now both are gone
FINJohnny 2 years ago 2
Sori vaan jos puhun kaverilleni joka on samas koulus ku minä vitun nyyppä homo
ParkourTeamEJJP 2 years ago
Suully!
Wait for me in the dark ;__;
I hate henry
Pikochan 2 years ago 4
voll scheiße
NuriaFrankPanik 2 years ago
this death makes me think of trish's death...I feel so bad for her :(((
energizer61bunny 2 years ago
noooo, sully was so cutee. :(
SilverSunshine12 2 years ago
i hate henry because he kiling almous all that island
TheMengy 2 years ago 4
ei se niitä kaikki tapa vitun pässi eikä ees lähes kaikkia
ParkourTeamEJJP 2 years ago
noooooooooo Sully died T_T
LoveTheDARKNESS2 2 years ago 4
henry is a son of a bitch
Jambajoba 2 years ago 4
I loved Sully! I wish he didn't die.
When Henry was telling him about all the deaths, Sully's face made me so sad!
suprnatrlluvr10 2 years ago 5
It's sad that wat makes him snap was when he laughed at malcom's death.
After all this, I still thought malcom's story was the saddest. Not only did he die, but henry made his life a living hell before he did... even after malcom made the right choice at the end.
Oh well, at least someone knew what happened to him in the end.
Captbigbeard 2 years ago
yeah malcolms death was sad but
1.yeah malcolm made the right choice but so did sully he didn't go on the boat to come back for henry who ended up killing him
2.yeah malcolm was put through a lot before he died but so was sully he was taunted by his bestfriend
there's a few similarities in their deaths but their is one difference that makes sully's sadder and that is:
3.malcolm died not knowing who did it.Sully died knowing his bestfriend killed all those people.
energizer61bunny 2 years ago
how sad... they were best friends =,(
i loved Matt Barr's character!
haha harper islands rocks ;)
LisaB94 2 years ago
loved all of harpers island
TheEmptyPuppet 2 years ago
Weah me too.Well...except this part hehe
energizer61bunny 2 years ago
Henry said 'You should never have dogged Trish' meaning that Sully tried to hit on her when she and Henry were on a break.
AbbyLeanne24 2 years ago
what does dogged mean??
Numba1Narnian 2 years ago
well yeah he did hit on chloe but chloe was leading him on.I'm not justifying it but it's not ALL him.She shouldn't of flirted with him...either way both of them were wrong not JUST him...I don't care what he did I felt horrible for him :(
energizer61bunny 2 years ago
o sorry
tgrwp42j12 2 years ago
that's ok it's just a lot of people talk about how sully's wrong and don't even realize what chloe was doing...they both were wrong.I feel bad for cal in that situation because sully was trying to take chloe away from him and chloe was always flirting with other guys
energizer61bunny 2 years ago
what does he mean when he says "you never should've dogged trish"?
killarubbaduckie 2 years ago
trish and sully were going out in high school.
and he said ''dumped'
BRITTG111 2 years ago
the actor who plays henry said that he said dogged :)
energizer61bunny 2 years ago
ohhhh
BRITTG111 2 years ago
henry and wakefiel are ' who - rain - zone's '
eddericahooj 2 years ago
i was sad when he died but stikll flipped out over trish's deatha nd henry being the killer
zodythekuraikodomo13 2 years ago
yeah I felt AWFUL for her but I still think sully's was sadder I don't know why.You'd think hers would be sadder but...
energizer61bunny 2 years ago
D':
I cried actual tears... Not Sully!!!!! :'(
MsManicDepressive 2 years ago 6
me 4 :( :( :( ;(
ilovemysimmys 2 years ago 5
Me too :(
77TwiNe77 2 years ago 4
me three :( :(
energizer61bunny 2 years ago
i cried so much , he was my favourite
beldoge 2 years ago 51