hello classical music fans, i've written an in-depth analysis and commentary on each movement of ravel's piano concerto in my blog, based on this video/performance. see my blog at asiyclassical,wordpress,com .
@ExeterBassoon Really? I thought the orchestra was pretty good... At least that trumpet player was. He plays that beginning lick the cleanest out of any recording here on youtube!
@YoJoe456 Philadelphia Orchestra. Ormandy is always with them, he was their conductor for 40 some years or so. One of the big hit conductor/orchestra duos in the 60's and 70's along with bernstein
There are elements of this performance that are slightly unexpected—relatively extreme tempo changes (that are not Ravel's), and a quite a few wrong notes.
HOWEVER, you can NOT say that you don't get anything out of it—so what if the tempi are exaggerated and there's the odd slip. Bernstein gives us, in my opinion, a valuable and valid interpretation that is exciting, moving, expressive. He certainly brings out Ravel's love of Jazz music.
I thought the orchestra is getting f***ed up near the end. Just saying.
You can hear clearly Lenny keeping the tempo and trying to pull the orchestra together WITH HIM, but their slow plodding prevail around 8:26, at which point i guess Lenny just went and finished the movement with his emotion alone.
It seems to me that if the orchestra can't keep pace with the soloist/conductor, both get f***ed. Lenny gives this piece a wonderful raw energy that many performances lack, and is the main reason why I like this recording a lot. But his playing is anything but precise (he certainly doesn't care nearly as much about not missing a note, or not hitting the wrong note, than that sucking trumpeter does). Just saying.
@EmperorOfWei I agree, the ending seems like an entirely different tempo from the other recordings I've heard. But I think Lenny made it work bereft of any 'dragging' this piece seems to invite.
is it just me? i feel the piano kind of sounds angry ( for some parts) instead of cute rabbit jumping and dancing around. He's too old to perform this piece lol
@moyxx030 You sound like you don't like lang Lang very much. I watched him with the NYPO performing Rachmaninoff and it was unreal. Sure he's young and lacks the Occidental pinache but you can't have it all,
Who better to conduct/play this piece than Bernstein, whose understanding of jazz more than qualifies him to interpret Ravel's attempt at jazz? I love this work. It turned me onto 20th century music, and I love the flashes of Gershwin and "Rhapsody in Blue!"
Ravel has a way to combine jazz harmonies with classical elements. Listen to the seventh part in Valses Nobles et sentientales... you can not clearly hear where nr 7 starts cause they're normally played as one piece, but anyway, it's one of his goosebumps pieces. AWESOME!
It's really good to hear these insights that's hard to notice without the knowledge of the instrument! Thanks! It did sound very smooth and beautiful, but what makes this part so difficult?
The tessitura for the solo is very high, reaching C above the staff. To put that in perspective, most orchestral Horn parts never stray above the G or A below that C. The fact that the solo is meant to be played softly and sensitively adds an element of difficulty, as Horns typically only play that high in loud passages like the infernal dance from The Firebird and certain points in Mahler symphonies.
Well it goes bloody high for one thing and it's slow AND like ppp! The first 5 notes are pretty high to be honest but then it goes another 4th higher than that so yeah. Luckily i've never had to play it myself... yet
Not actually difficult at all. There is much controversy about the purpose of the conductor as most orchestras, well decent ones anyway, can play perfectly well without one!
well, of course the orchestra could play fine without him. the difference a conductor makes, however, in an orchestra of this quality is making a good performance into an inspired one! There is a reason why some conductors are famous: the best make the orchestras they conduct sound better and play more inspired! Similarly, the conductor's sense of proportion, balance, color, timing, and emotion (this list could go on forever) has a significant effect on the "quality" of the performance.
Not to mention that the Conductor also is in a position to hear the entire orchestral sound, not just to an individual instruments sound or at most how an individual instrument's sound fits in with the overall sound (as a instrumentalist within the orchestra is limited to)
Meu herói!!!
fabiohme 1 week ago
5:32 Mind blowing.
StevenOBrienComposer 1 month ago
WOW!
Strawbelissimo 2 months ago
how could anyone possibly dislike this video?
BenEvz94 2 months ago
who unlike this!!!!
kplrovios 3 months ago
Komponieren, Dirigieren, Spielen.......was gibt es noch mehr?
arrangeur55 4 months ago 2
nodame!!!!! =))
schle07 4 months ago 3
@schle07 hahaha xD
marcelita9402 3 months ago
@schle07
Ah ah ah i had the same thought XD
Valk72 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hello classical music fans, i've written an in-depth analysis and commentary on each movement of ravel's piano concerto in my blog, based on this video/performance. see my blog at asiyclassical,wordpress,com .
asiyclassical 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
When was this recorded?
whneo97 5 months ago
When was this recorded?
whneo97 5 months ago
THUMBS UP IF NODAME BROUGHT YOU HERE
kembooo000 6 months ago 23
Bernstein. Fucking genius.
PhilipOMeara 7 months ago
Phila orch - Not a chance. Check out the principal bassoon.
gorfully 7 months ago
Wow! Che agilità!
Albertoferro68 8 months ago
The best.
dasteufelhund 8 months ago
弾き振り!!!!
jijiart 8 months ago in playlist ラベル ピアノ協奏曲ト長調
This has been flagged as spam show
A true genius, and a real artist. I almost cried during the second movement... There are no more pianists/conductors like him.
ZioJafar 8 months ago
Comment removed
ZioJafar 8 months ago
No offense
moragapiano 9 months ago
11 mans who dislikes have a ear
jimmymoomoojimmy 10 months ago
Orchestra isn't the best but Bernstein's performance is amazing!! (as one would expect from a master)
ExeterBassoon 10 months ago
@ExeterBassoon Really? I thought the orchestra was pretty good... At least that trumpet player was. He plays that beginning lick the cleanest out of any recording here on youtube!
YoJoe456 8 months ago
@YoJoe456 Well yes i will admit the trumpet playing is very good! I'm just biased towards my Ormandy/Entremont recording i guess! :)
ExeterBassoon 8 months ago
@ExeterBassoon Haha, fair enough. Which orchestra is that with?
YoJoe456 8 months ago
@YoJoe456 Philadelphia Orchestra. Ormandy is always with them, he was their conductor for 40 some years or so. One of the big hit conductor/orchestra duos in the 60's and 70's along with bernstein
ExeterBassoon 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ravel sucks cock! This Expressionist shit is completely unlistenable.
PTR131 11 months ago
@PTR131 It's Impressionism you fool. That comment was uncalled for.
maternalheart66 11 months ago
@PTR131 Criticizing is not a crime. But first learn your vocabulary.
ppgppgppgppg 10 months ago
bravo
enthu15 1 year ago
There are elements of this performance that are slightly unexpected—relatively extreme tempo changes (that are not Ravel's), and a quite a few wrong notes.
HOWEVER, you can NOT say that you don't get anything out of it—so what if the tempi are exaggerated and there's the odd slip. Bernstein gives us, in my opinion, a valuable and valid interpretation that is exciting, moving, expressive. He certainly brings out Ravel's love of Jazz music.
Excellent.
Pavlvs34 1 year ago 3
@Pavlvs34 Sure!! It´d be pretty boring if all orchestras attempted to sound EXACTLY alike as the score says, there wouldn´t be any interpretation
milosbar 10 months ago
It sounds very good to hear Ravel interpreted this way.
6347285 1 year ago
OMG! BRAVO!
Schuhann 1 year ago
I thought the orchestra is getting f***ed up near the end. Just saying.
You can hear clearly Lenny keeping the tempo and trying to pull the orchestra together WITH HIM, but their slow plodding prevail around 8:26, at which point i guess Lenny just went and finished the movement with his emotion alone.
Also, that solo trumpeter sucks
EmperorOfWei 1 year ago
It seems to me that if the orchestra can't keep pace with the soloist/conductor, both get f***ed. Lenny gives this piece a wonderful raw energy that many performances lack, and is the main reason why I like this recording a lot. But his playing is anything but precise (he certainly doesn't care nearly as much about not missing a note, or not hitting the wrong note, than that sucking trumpeter does). Just saying.
nickelit 1 year ago
@EmperorOfWei I agree, the ending seems like an entirely different tempo from the other recordings I've heard. But I think Lenny made it work bereft of any 'dragging' this piece seems to invite.
MrAkihiros 1 year ago
@EmperorOfWei
100% agree. Especially about that trumpet player. Guy's crappy sound was getting on my nerves
Lymphaticnessicity 1 year ago
is it just me? i feel the piano kind of sounds angry ( for some parts) instead of cute rabbit jumping and dancing around. He's too old to perform this piece lol
darken192 1 year ago
the piano is bald!!! :O
fieryphoenixchick 1 year ago
No one makes the opening 0:41 to 0:50 more explosive than bernstein.
mcnardo 1 year ago
incredible video. Respect Lenny!
JLGosselin12345 1 year ago
THE JAZZ!
ukks63 1 year ago
I saw Bernstein do this with the Vienna Phil. in Paris in the early 70's, with Schumann's 4th symphony. A fabulous concert.
muslit 1 year ago
@muslit a symphony won't have a soloist. this is a concerto, and bernstein conducts from the piano
gnimez 1 year ago
@gnimez
ok, with schuman's 4th symphony on the same program. better?
muslit 9 months ago
Ravel the first acid jazz artist XD
yukikoforevernoise 2 years ago 2
holy cow, conducting and playing piano at once!
froggyhare46 2 years ago
Yea I always get a kick out of that when I see conductors doing that. One thing we will never see Lang Lang do, lolll.
moyxx030 1 year ago 34
@moyxx030 very true. :D
gnimez 1 year ago
@moyxx030 You sound like you don't like lang Lang very much. I watched him with the NYPO performing Rachmaninoff and it was unreal. Sure he's young and lacks the Occidental pinache but you can't have it all,
MrAkihiros 1 year ago
@moyxx030 green venom!
MrAkihiros 7 months ago
@froggyhare46
As was done for dozens of years preceding the Romantic era in music...
jumponthebandwagon 1 year ago
Both Ravel and Bernstein admired Mozart without reservation.
2009xellos 2 years ago 2
applause at the end??
y1g1tcn 2 years ago
why would you applaud? this is only part 1... theres 3 parts, it's not over
Medsas 2 years ago
o yes you are right. i totally forget..
y1g1tcn 2 years ago
mmm yeah.
ccppgg1 2 years ago
Bernstein, you ole' show-offy queen.
ohlordbabyjesus 2 years ago 6
siempre ha sido un genio americano (una excepciòn sin duda), America no tuve demasiados musicos....
Nimenicamine01 2 years ago
The music sounds like Paris.
hermitking100 2 years ago 4
@hermitking100 You´re right
tornado2000000000000 2 years ago
wow bernstein is a fab pianist!!
its not often a famous conductor takes the keyboard like this and it is wonderful to watch!
pianoenthusiast11 2 years ago 4
I just love the sound of French basoon.why don't they use them any more?
davisbone 2 years ago
genio...
Alitha84 2 years ago
Who better to conduct/play this piece than Bernstein, whose understanding of jazz more than qualifies him to interpret Ravel's attempt at jazz? I love this work. It turned me onto 20th century music, and I love the flashes of Gershwin and "Rhapsody in Blue!"
LevMysh68 2 years ago 42
Ravel has a way to combine jazz harmonies with classical elements. Listen to the seventh part in Valses Nobles et sentientales... you can not clearly hear where nr 7 starts cause they're normally played as one piece, but anyway, it's one of his goosebumps pieces. AWESOME!
antiPNOS 2 years ago 2
Bernstein was both soloist and conductor.
serloisse737 2 years ago
does anyone know when was this performance and with which conductor and orchestra?
ryoushinchan 2 years ago
70's; ny phil ..
culturehorse 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Modern as if it were something from the techno/house 90's.
LogicSmash 2 years ago
5:33 melody looks very modern.
LogicSmash 2 years ago
¡Diosssss!!!¡Qué buen gusto! Lo amé.
padrenatas 2 years ago
Fantastic piano concerto, fantastic performance!
JJKjaer 2 years ago
Fabulous!!!!!!!
MillerMusicStudiosTV 2 years ago
Oh my god, the horn solo is so good, 5:42 and they don't even show him. One of the hardest solos out there and this guy does it justice
Finners1551 2 years ago 6
It's really good to hear these insights that's hard to notice without the knowledge of the instrument! Thanks! It did sound very smooth and beautiful, but what makes this part so difficult?
Snufkin999 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
Finners1551 2 years ago
The tessitura for the solo is very high, reaching C above the staff. To put that in perspective, most orchestral Horn parts never stray above the G or A below that C. The fact that the solo is meant to be played softly and sensitively adds an element of difficulty, as Horns typically only play that high in loud passages like the infernal dance from The Firebird and certain points in Mahler symphonies.
nstevensofrochester 2 years ago 2
Sounds like the Bassoon solo - goes up to an E, and I've only had to play D in extremely high, weirdly written parts :P
AmateurBassoonist 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Well it goes bloody high for one thing and it's slow AND like ppp! The first 5 notes are pretty high to be honest but then it goes another 4th higher than that so yeah. Luckily i've never had to play it myself... yet
Finners1551 2 years ago
@Finners1551 Totally in agreement. Am a horn player myself and that's no joke.
gmhots 1 year ago
amazing and wonderful , well he knows his piano part by heart, it should be. but all the orchestral score? incredible. lovely.
haimcito 2 years ago
It amazes me that someone can do both--conduct AND perform on the piano--at the same time, it's really phenomenal!
thepianomaniac 3 years ago 3
Not actually difficult at all. There is much controversy about the purpose of the conductor as most orchestras, well decent ones anyway, can play perfectly well without one!
pobz100 2 years ago
well, of course the orchestra could play fine without him. the difference a conductor makes, however, in an orchestra of this quality is making a good performance into an inspired one! There is a reason why some conductors are famous: the best make the orchestras they conduct sound better and play more inspired! Similarly, the conductor's sense of proportion, balance, color, timing, and emotion (this list could go on forever) has a significant effect on the "quality" of the performance.
bene951 1 year ago 4
@bene951
Not to mention that the Conductor also is in a position to hear the entire orchestral sound, not just to an individual instruments sound or at most how an individual instrument's sound fits in with the overall sound (as a instrumentalist within the orchestra is limited to)
nmitchell076 1 year ago
Wonderful!
camileludwig 3 years ago
PERFECT!!
redolentlook 3 years ago
Trumpet solo at :50 is considered by some the most demanding, though short, in concerti for other instruments. High, staccato with leaps.
2:30 very soulful piano, like looking out the window on a beautiful day.
highlandsh 3 years ago
The conductor plays while conducting!Amazing!
4evaFanFuruba 3 years ago 3
Orchestre national of France
armailh 3 years ago
Che talento straordinario!! Pazzesco come dirige e suona insieme.... :)
fricoepolente 3 years ago 3
ci sono sempre i coglioni che applaudono dopo il primo tempo,anche qui hahaha
miliona1re 3 years ago 4
great conductor and great pianist,Berstein the great!
miliona1re 3 years ago 3
That's a really live hall... it makes the orchestra sound kind of sloppy.
GORGEOUS basson français at 2:50!!!
tyrelroo 3 years ago
素晴らしい!!!
1224luca 3 years ago
Comment removed
salexlindsay 3 years ago
you're quite right, and i have never hera 1:10 played so slow.
coelhofsp 3 years ago
When you're a conductor, you can do these things!
xzzap 3 years ago
I LOVE that the first trumpet player nails that excerpt while looking at Bernstein!
Srach 3 years ago
HAHAHA!!! I know. He had that deadpan look, as if to say, "that's right. I'm good."
Meliere 3 years ago 2
It's so psychedelic the way the colors appear at 5:22 ... lol ...
jannokas85 3 years ago
wow i love how Mr. Leonard Bernstein plays and also is the director!!!! =D. Leonard Bernstein 4 ever!!!!
bulSAdeCV 4 years ago
THANKS!
Gonec 4 years ago
Thank you very much!
I love it to see and too hear Bernstein as conductor and a pianist in this beautiful Ravelconcert.
3tristan 4 years ago 5