Added: 2 years ago
From: knoelknowles
Views: 190,702
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (188)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i like how the original was more a woman's resistance against being forced into a way of life that didn't suit her, while this cover is like a man saying everyone (including him) needs to live for happiness instead of success or meeting expectations. a subtle change, but a good one. :)

  • I don't understand why people are getting their panties in a twist. Glee takes from other covers all the time. Their rendition of I want to hold your hand was from Across the Universe, Rolling in the deep was taken from John Legends acapella cover, etc. Why is it now a crime when they've been doing it for a long time?

  • @ch2010ize i think its because they didn't give any credit to greg laswell

  • @pshemodow confessions of a shopaholic??????? cause.. its from the soundtrack

  • Stupid Glee not giving credit where it's due

  • I heard this song in some movie. I dont remember which one tho. And no, I dont mean Glee...

  • @pshemodow my sister's keeper ?

  • Tweet post from Greg Laswell "Hmm. You know I never even thought of completely ripping off someone's COVER of a song, and I love stealing! Nice job @GLEEonFOX"

  • This song is so beautiful. I almost cried when I heard it performed on Glee but, now that I am hearing this version... It is wonderful what people can do with their musical talent and love for music. :)

  • When I first heard Finn sing the song, I surprisingly found the cover sweet and perfectly sung. I thought it was one of the best covers. However, I had no knowledge that this version was originally performed by this amazing Greg. Glee should have at least given some credit for the cover. I am a bit disappointed and now I prefer to listen to Greg's voice instead.

  • I really dislike the Glee version, but I liked the idea. Then, I knew someone else had sung it because Glee is never original so here I am :)

  • Perfect ...

  • Repeat button has been broken :)

  • @StatusquoRanger you are completely right! everyone listen to her! Just get over yourself

  • it's amazing that someone can take the funniest song then turned it into the saddest song ever

  • It took me a good few seconds to realize that it was a Cyndi Lauper song that he was singing on Glee. Totally transformed.

  • this is how you turn happyness into sadness

  • Everybody shut up. It is a song. I love glee as much as the next girl, but shut up. IT'S a song. You don't see the artists complaining so we shouldn't either. Just Chill.....

  • @StatusQuoRanger Actually, if you google his name and Glee you'll come on some articles about Greg having issues with this. Just some quotes from Greg about it.

    "Of the Glee version, I think they have enough talent over there that they shouldn't need to go rummaging through other artists' work."

    "Public acknowledgement of their note-for-note rendition would have gone a long way."

  • It is a nice song and all, but I don't get what it is about.

  • Can people stop talking about glee on this video and just enjoy the song

  • I'm sorry. But at no point in the Glee episode, did the characters say "this is our original arrangement." Yeah, they didn't say which artist it was by - but so what! It's not like they give credit for every other song, what about the introduction to singing "Perfect" by P!nk? Kurt and Blaine didn't exactly convey that it was "their favourite song by P!nk," so what if someone didn't know it was by P!nk and was commenting on a youtube video saying "Wow, this is awesome; Klaine sang beautifully."

  • @Albertross21 There's no credit given to Gred Laswell's (obvious) arrangement on the CD. That's the credit everyone is talking about. Do you really expect the actors to talk about a song before singing it?

  • @AomahouX You mean on the Glee cd? Oh right - I thought everyone was complaining about the fact that no one mention it was Laswell in the show; just to clear things up, I wasn't trying to say that the actors should talk about a song before singing it. I was actually saying that they don't do it all the time, apart from some e.g. Gaga songs - and that people shouldn't expect the writers to give the artist credit, everytime the characters sing a song. Amen :3

  • Trash...

  • Wow nice rip-off Glee. Pretty low that they didn't credit him and made it look like it was their idea of the Cyndi Lauper cover. It is the exact replica of Greg Laswel. Glee lost a hundred cool points for me at that point.

  • As much as I love Glee, Finn sang this awfully. Ugh.

  • Greg Laswell needs to get credit for Glee's cover of this songs version. So awesome! Love it

  • So prettttttttyyyyyy!!!!!! Gosh. Makes my heart ache.

    

  • When a cover version of a song is covered again by another it is not legally necessary to give credit to the person who performed the cover first. The only credit that must be given is to the original writer and recording label. Glee probably should have given credit where credit is due, but it was not legally necessary for them to do so.

  • @Tdotpescot I totally agree with you.

  • @Tdotpescot I know that's why I'm even more pissed. I think it's even more lame, they figured "we don't legally have to" so we'll take entire credit for it and pretend we have the musical ability to create original things like this. Because right now this is getting HUGE SUCCESS for Glee and they're not doing the right thing which is hypocritical considering their constant "let's do the right thing" messages. Urgh

  • i don't watch glee - but this cover is beautiful.

  • Ahahahhaahha! All this Glee hate. How stupid. Let me ask you something - how does someone not get credit for something when EVERYONE is saying Laswell made the cover? His cover is now MORE know because of Glee. When has Glee EVER done something original in regards to its music? Greg Lawell wasn't cheated. Fuckin Glee REWARDED him for using his cover. Now he's more well known. Get your panties out of a twist. OH, & his Tweet about GLEE was immature and low. Way to stay classy, Greg.

  • @jaraandrew100 he complain on twitter so is from common knowledge that he didn't get anything cuz he never said something like this cuz on glee project they used an chord of him for mad world ;)

  • what glee did too you was unfair you deserve yur credits

  • Glee =D

  • It upsets me that Greg didn't get credit for his cover's use on Glee. ):

  • @fluidstatic How did he not get credit when EVERYONE is saying Greg Laswell's cover was used? It's now common knowledge to anyone who didn't know before.

  • @jaraandrew100 It really isn't. 90% of viewers don't know and thing Glee did it. If you go on the youtube page for this song by glee you won't see comments on it, just comment saying wow this is amazing, so original etc.

  • @fluidstatic Wait, are you implying that it's the writer's fault for not giving credit? Because any person who liked the arrangement; who hadn't heard this version before, would, (like myself), go and find out for themselves who created this arrangement - I mean it took me a while, but I finally found out about Greg Laswell - and I'm adding his song to my Ipod right now - so that is "giving credit." Surely, any fan of the show could find out the original artist if they wanted?

  • @fluidstatic I'll be honest before Glee I hadn't heard this version...my guess people will research it on Wikipedia etc and he will sell more copies. I am sure he was just thrilled they asked to use the song

  • @denisepgalloway uuhm.. not sure about it.. but i think he wasn't, 'cause in his twitter he said: ''Hmm. You know I never even thought of completely ripping off someone's COVER of a song, and I love stealing! Nice job @GLEEonFOX.''

    but maybe... deep inside :)

  • @fluidstatic yes he did

  • @fluidstatic Agreed

  • anyone got the chords for this???

  • Glee <3

  • @KKenzyy13 ew, no.

  • @KKenzyy13

    Thieves.

  • i hate this version :S:S:S:S

  • Glee sing's this version this is awesome <3

  • what's kind of unfortunate is that they're doing this song next tuesday on Glee. And love glee and all, but no guy can do it like Greg can.

  • i can sing this cover but can't sing the real verion

  • "Gone to parents until wedding

    all your CRAP is in the room."

  • I'm going to dance this with my daddy at my wedding:')

  • Fuck Daddy and his No. 1... This Get's my No.21 spot in the "100 greatest covers ever" playlist.

    Such an unusual song to cover and beautifully sung, a worthy cover in my list.

    If I could sing like him and play piano at the sma time, I'd be swimming in pussy..... Ugh, swimming in pussy is disgusting come I think of it.

  • so am i the only one that heard this on the hills ?

  • @ashleighnycole haha so did i! heidi pregnancy scene.

  • @ashleighnycole no i did too :)

  • no i did too :)

  • @ashleighnycole hahaha which episode? Season? They had good music the first season but i don't remember hearing this.

  • So beautiful... What else ?

  • Damages.

  • It's amazing how a simple tune change and piano can change the meaning of so many songs.

  • this song is amazing.

  • 0:00

    There fixed it

  • Interesting spin on the song. In a way it's like taking a view and seeing it through someone else's eyes. Amazingly done :).

  • I love music. Whoever thought of this is a real artist.

  • just watched My Sisters Keeper at school today an needed to know who sings this song... beautiful <3

  • @IOUpunk247 Lmao the dying sister is such a slut

  • @gherkinfantastic no she's not wtf

  • This is such a stunning version of the song; you can't really compare the two as this version seems to give the song a whole new, deeper meaning. Beautiful.

  • it was also in Confessions of a shopaholic :D

  • just heard this on Damages! Awesome!

  • this song was also in "The Hills" finale which was pretty perfect for the ending of that show

  • This version is very good, but he left out "when the working day is done" and he switched the parents rolls, which i really disagree with, he should have left the lyrics as is.....but its a great cover.

  • This song appears in every movie

  • i love this in my my sisters keeper,amazing version<3.

  • this was also on Damages 1.04

  • this really reminds me of effy from skins, i don't know why :')

  • woah. his voice is so soothing!

    <3

  • Is anyone else thrown off and unhappy with this song?

  • @FindTheBody I personally love it but I won't bash your opinion. Why are you unhappy with it?

  • @lyssiepants

    It's originally a very upbeat, empowering song. And this takes it to a level that I don't believe honors the integrity of the song. It's inappropriate and a bit pointless, I think. You just don't mess with some things.

  • @FindTheBody depends on which "original version" your talking about. GJWHF was originally sung by Robert Hazard. It was turned into an empowering song by Cindy.

  • @lilykt7 I apologize for my ignorance, then.

  • lovely :)

  • In love with this song even though it makes me sad

  • LOVE THIS RENDITION

  • Greg Laswell is so unbelivible. To make this song sound, not only good, but beautiful... That's sign of true tallent and an amazing voice.

  • this version is nice(:

  • This song was in My Sister's Keeper. I love this version. To me this song is so sweet, it made me cry, the way he sang it. :)

  • Comment removed

  • great version of the song...

  • such as sad beautiful song!

  • heard in tv show Damages, wonderful

  • This is haunting and amazing.

  • i want to marry this. is that possible? well idc, im gunna do it anyway.

  • fucking beautiful gregg 

  • This is beautiful. It's so calming

  • I listened to this song in the movie and i like it very much..nice voice..great in playing the piano..;)

  • Beautiful :)

  • nice lyric even too sad,,, i wondering,,,this song make me have imagination ,,,

  • hes such a great singer, sooooo calming

  • Very nice song :)...I love all versions of it, except for the Mileys version :-! :D

  • @xxvanskidxx Word to your mother... Her's sucks...

  • @gherkinfantastic what?

    

  • this is amazing.

  • anyone know where you can get sheet music for piano for this song ?

  • @citrusbust its when rebecca is talking to her dad on the river and theres all this snow... its really really sweet :P

  • I LOVE THIS SONGG <3

  • beautiful :)

  • @citrusbust yes it is in Confessions of a Shopaholic. I just watched it today and heard the song, that's why i looked it up on youtube ;)

  • I love this make of the song its sooo much better

  • much different from the original!!

    i really like the mellowness

  • i love this more than the original

  • Just a great make of a great song

  • i first heard it on the TV show Damages - just had to track it down, he takes pop & turns it morbid. so good! perfect timing for the point in the show (Katie Connor whacked out on drugs on Gregory's couch)

  • @robralphi

    Me too! I was just re-watching that episode and I decided to search up this song.

  • It's used in My Sister's Keeper,too,poignant but excellent

  • Greg Laswell always the best

  • i love version really nice.:)

  • goodness this song makes me cry I love it though its so beautiful

  • i love this song. it makes me all teary.

  • i really like this on it like makes me want 2 cry

  • makes me cry

  • Best version of this song i love it a lot <3. Too bad i tunes doesn't sell it by its self. You have to buy the whole shopaholic soundtrack to get this song. It just doesn't make any sense.

  • download it

  • I checked on it not too long ago just look up the singers name and it will have that song on there =)

  • loveeee it

  • this is the best redo of this song ever!

  • lovee it.

  • Beautiful voice, great job. Thanks for posting this!

  • greatest version everr. hes so talented! <3

  • loooveee this versionn! makess me thinkk of the hills and my sisters keeper. (:

  • love this song its amazing :)

  • I'm doing this song for my lyrical duo. It's such a beautiful song!

  • We r doing it for small lyrical group =]

  • his music reminds me of Coldplay, i don't know why...i think it's because his voice in some parts of the songs sounds like chris martin's voice..am i the only one who think this?

  • i agree i thought it was but then red who it was !!

  • THANKYOU been looking for this from my sisters keeper :)

  • Best version of the song, I never liked the song before until I heard this.

    I LOVE the movie ♥ Isla is so adorable, and Huge is so hot!

  • i have been looking for this version for sooo long! i LOVE it and one of the few covers that sounds better than the original! <3

  • this song was on my sister's keeper. good movie and no im not gay

  • it is ! and i love that movie

  • this song make a person think abouthow life should be worth living right.:) better version. wish it could go on forever, just to throw it out there, umm this song was also played on The Hills about Heidi and Lauren. big fan of that show. :) got all the seasons.

  • when that dumbass heidi thought she might have an evil devil spawn in her nasty no talent oven, this song played, very effective

  • lmao that is actual funny. she did think she was pregnant. though i still like her and spencer. lauren always made the show so i won't watch it anymore since she won't be on it.

  • I love this song sooo much!

  • this is a nice twist on this song! love itt

  • lovelovelove this song. soooo relaxing

  • I love this song!

  • i lovee this version. much better

  • i love this version, it's so pretty and calm

  • i love this song. so much.

    but did anyone who read my sister's keeper feel that the movie was a disappointment compared to the book?? just saying.

  • I haven't read the book myself but I heard that from many people.

    And I read about the ending in the book, personally I would of prefered if they'd done that.

    Fingers crossed they made it like that as an alternative ending for the dvd release.

    I think that'd be awesome.

  • :( i just got done seeing my sisters keeper and i had to find out who sang this song :(

  • same!!

    did you cry?? I did :(

  • refreshing :)

  • love it.

    made me cry in my sisters keeper thou :'(

    <3

  • lol me 2. good movie

  • Comment removed

  • i lovee this version

    but it kinda makes me want to cry...

    <333