I love how when she started singing the rewritten chorus for the solo version she looks around as she is interuptted. It made me smile and then the wave at the end did too. Also, at the end, when she's in the lift can almost see her thinking 'OK, get me out of this lift now.'
Idina Menzel doesn't have asthma. During her Broadway run she had vocal problems, though. This is basically what she sounded like her entire Broadway run, give or take a few earlier performances. Many other Elphabas have proven themselves superior in vocal talent and technique, as well as stability and consistency. Idina's acting is good, but there have been better. She deserves redit for originating the role in San Francisco/Broadway/London, but that doesn't mean she was the best Elphaba ever.
I think everyone says that other Elphabas are better than Idina because Idina's voice is so much different than other people who have played this role. Most of them have deeper sounding voices, Idina's is higher but it's awesome and unique
Idina, you are my idol. I cried when i first heard you doing this. I've seen Wicked 6 times in 6 different cities, and this coming up December i get to go see it at the Gershwin Theatre. When i saw this video, i got teary eyed. God bless you, Idina.
No, I worded that comment really badly. I think she is really good, just a lot of the time her breathing is like really weird, and I think that is what bothers me. Like it's rumored she has asthma and all, but just like her breathing is legit weird sometimes. So yeah. haha.
oh really bc im pretty sure she doesnt do it live or get lifted into the air by a harnest and have to memorize lyrics play lines and act...yeahh no competiion
Hmm, I'd say I prefered the original performance on the disc. However, I just read that she was recovering from the flu so that makes sense. A tiny bit off a couple of times but brilliant none the less, especially to be sick.
idina menzel and kristen chenoweth are the best glinda and elphaba ever i love them and this song and this musical GO WICKED !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I figured out why it sounds rushed, It is because they do not have kirsten there as Glinda so they had to cut out there part but they also gave Idina a very long-winded part with no break... I thought it was very risky, also i thought the part when the guards broke in i was doing something else, and i thought she actually lost her breath... It is a bit of a quicker tempo than the soundtrack... oh well
she is so pretty and her voice is amazing!i tried singing this and i lost my voice. it's such a hard song to sing and idina does an amazing job with it
Idina IS Elphaba! She has the most amazing voice and this song is simply brilliant! it's my favorite song in the whole musical! especially her version 'cause she pulled it off so perfectly! I saw the musical in England and it was AMAZING!
Idina did an amazing job in Wicked, as in rent. This is a VERY difficult song to perform, but she was able to pull it off beautifully two times a day over and over again. An amazing performer.
yeah. at this point in the musical, the emotion was so powerful that I just started crying. and I'm a guy! guys aren't meant to cry because of music. but steven schwartz is my idol!!!
yeh. I live in Canberra, australia. I saw the Australian production.
i feel so unfortunate living in a country that doesn't provide me with any privilege to see wicked. i've read the book, and fell in love with it. i wish, oh how i wish i could see the play :(
Oh my goodness SABVILLA!! you really need to see this show. It's so great. I also read the book and love both the book and show. Do you have the soundtrack? If you can't see the show, the next best thing is to listen to the music. I'm pretty much in love with the soundtrack. :)
probably idinas best vocally. . . she just has such shitty breathing control..she like gasps for breath SO LOUD between words. if you listen to all of her recordings they're all like that. still a true talent though
are you making that comment in reference to this video cuz this is one of the most vocally horrendous renditions of this song ever performed, this and the tonys both just awful!!
oh I don't think they're THAT bad I mean it's just when she's in the air. I'm thinking maybe that flying haress that they put on her might cause strain on her breathing habits y'know?
This was a nice performance and all and I LOVE idina's voice but the effect that you see in the show was kind of lost here. Here where she's starting to fly is WAY more dramatic in the show and it's more like she's flying. But still, great job.
yeah. she has a truly unique and characteristic voice. Some things work with her voice that don't work with anyone else's. I think she is the only Kate in The Wild Party that I will ever like! lol.
can someone please tell me who is playing elphaba in Wicked currently? as in who will be playing it in june because thats when i'm going to see it :] thank you!
peaceelovetennis- Stephanie J. Block is currently portraying Wicked, but I don't know if she will still be pportraying Elphaba then. As for the touring cast, I have heard that Carmen Cusack is the curent Elphaba, instead of Victoria Matlock, because I heard that Victoria did her last show like 2-3 weeks ago. I'm not sure.
Kudos to the Green Diva! Love you, Idina!
Brenda2OOO 3 months ago
Tears T_T I LOVE IDINA !!
MonLeAmour 4 months ago
Lea Michele really sounds a little like her in GLEE.. XD
StrawhatxLuffy 6 months ago
1:15 - 1:20 i love how even though her skin is green, idina can really pull it off and be beautiful
MaddieNae101 6 months ago
Goosebumps....
jr1006495 8 months ago
its amazing how idina can sing this without a g(a)linda
MultiPearl007 10 months ago
love it
starsloveone 1 year ago
I love wicked.
starsloveone 1 year ago
Ahhhh! I love indina menzel!
starsloveone 1 year ago
IDINA is the BOMB!!! she's freakin' goood!
apoy300 1 year ago
I just saw her live yesterday; she is absolutely amazing :D
epacmo1807 1 year ago
the 7 others can't defy gravity.
zsa1299 1 year ago
7 People can't defy gravity with Idina Menzel :)
Flytheshapeshifter 1 year ago 7
lol i love how energetic musical theatre performers are
hilly998 1 year ago
Where was Galinda?? O wait ITS GLINDA NOW!!!!!!! Lol!
tytippy2 1 year ago
3:17 voice crack :o
supernatt924 1 year ago
I love how Idina gives this amazing out of this world perfromance and The guys just like o good job..
I'd be like
OMG!!!!
I <3 UUUU!!!!!!
JustforThisMoment1 1 year ago
2:44 was that part of the act or some kind of mistake? Whatever I still love her!
1313hahaha 1 year ago
@1313hahaha they cut the song short....there was supposed to be talking there and a few more lyrics
cupcakexkx 1 year ago
@cupcakexkx Oh. So how come she sort of freaked out and ran to the lift?
1313hahaha 1 year ago
I love how when she started singing the rewritten chorus for the solo version she looks around as she is interuptted. It made me smile and then the wave at the end did too. Also, at the end, when she's in the lift can almost see her thinking 'OK, get me out of this lift now.'
I love Idina Menzel!!
twilightfan1231000 1 year ago
IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIDDDDDDDDDDDDIIIIIIIIIIIIIINNNNNNNNNNNNNNAAAAAAAAA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
OliverKelly1995 1 year ago
this is an odd version of defying gravity LOL!
markncheese 1 year ago
So good!!!!
sonson226 1 year ago
Those were the good ol' days.
gdcat777 1 year ago
Amazing!
DutchCountryAngel 1 year ago
she plays rachels mom in glee lol
candiiapple15 1 year ago
Idina is really good in GLEE
LittleMissNoName1 1 year ago
didnt indina play in rent right??/
candiiapple15 1 year ago
yes! she was maureen
DonKairi 1 year ago
@candiiapple15 yes she did in the broadway version and the movie
keriah17 1 year ago
@candiiapple15 she played Maureen in Rent, broadway and film :)
zombiesandaliens 1 year ago
Idina Menzel doesn't have asthma. During her Broadway run she had vocal problems, though. This is basically what she sounded like her entire Broadway run, give or take a few earlier performances. Many other Elphabas have proven themselves superior in vocal talent and technique, as well as stability and consistency. Idina's acting is good, but there have been better. She deserves redit for originating the role in San Francisco/Broadway/London, but that doesn't mean she was the best Elphaba ever.
Gomezzio 1 year ago
@Gomezzio *credit
Gomezzio 1 year ago
@Gomezzio couldn't agree more
supernatt924 1 year ago
It's somewhat of a mashup of Wizard and I and Defying Gravity :D
thenight92 1 year ago
I think everyone says that other Elphabas are better than Idina because Idina's voice is so much different than other people who have played this role. Most of them have deeper sounding voices, Idina's is higher but it's awesome and unique
LizSmiles1 1 year ago
wow. she can scream at the top of her lungs ans still make it sound good
camptowngirl 2 years ago 4
i just went to see this tonight and it was amazing!! i wanna see it again
i'd pay to see it again
UxMakexMyxKneesxWeak 2 years ago
so lucky! I wanna see it!!!
softball90876 2 years ago
that audience is so lucky.. i paid $80 to see it, but hey, i'd pay to see it again!
ericleemar 2 years ago 4
the night i went to see wicked, the cast were personally signing programs!! lol, my program is covered in signitures!
Genora100 2 years ago 3
Beautiful voice
mariama12 2 years ago 2
idina is the best i don't care what anyone says
dericjeter2 2 years ago 5
wickedd<333333333333333!!!
i love you idina i think this performance is absolutley amazing!
xxmengggx 2 years ago 5
me too!! :)
aviya43 2 years ago
there is nothing like it in person, but video-wise, i completely agree :) :)
Meowman78 2 years ago
Idina, you are my idol. I cried when i first heard you doing this. I've seen Wicked 6 times in 6 different cities, and this coming up December i get to go see it at the Gershwin Theatre. When i saw this video, i got teary eyed. God bless you, Idina.
ElphieCrazy123 2 years ago
She does? She sounds pretty good in the videos I've seen of her. Did you have a bad experience or something?
CrueNRoses 2 years ago
No, I worded that comment really badly. I think she is really good, just a lot of the time her breathing is like really weird, and I think that is what bothers me. Like it's rumored she has asthma and all, but just like her breathing is legit weird sometimes. So yeah. haha.
mdancer94 2 years ago
amazing!
lexi186 2 years ago
I'd love to see Lea Michele do this
fogelbaby 2 years ago
@fogelbaby She does! in Glee! Check it out on iTunes!
keylimepie7729 2 years ago
oh really bc im pretty sure she doesnt do it live or get lifted into the air by a harnest and have to memorize lyrics play lines and act...yeahh no competiion
xxmengggx 2 years ago
Hmm, I'd say I prefered the original performance on the disc. However, I just read that she was recovering from the flu so that makes sense. A tiny bit off a couple of times but brilliant none the less, especially to be sick.
jpopdancingkeyboard 2 years ago
poor idina. aparently she was recovering from flu when this was performed. i love her to peices though shes amazing
talenokoyo 2 years ago 2
LOVE Idina so much, ever since RENT. Such a voice. GO GIRL!!!
cubbear88 2 years ago
idina is wonderful.
almost the best elphaba
ThePeachLaura 2 years ago
i would pay big money to see the orginal cast back together again on broadway.
Saw them in feb 04. Just utterly BRILLIANT.
masonTganes 2 years ago 5
I loathe you. You got to go see the ORIGINAL BROADWAY CAST!!!!!!! LUCKY!!!
ElphieCrazy123 2 years ago
amazing, better with glinda though, just to fill in the spaces. the bit where she says 'my future is unlimited' doesn't sound as good.
i heard she has asthma, that must be so difficult for her!
Tommy1The2Bat3 2 years ago
i loooooooooove wicked!!!!!!!!! amazing performance.
ruirate 2 years ago
Idina Menzel is my Hero <3
PhotoFrie 2 years ago 31
JinxDagger,the ''Flying''thing is defying gravity
marvinalmodal 2 years ago
Incredible <3
1990emmie 2 years ago 5
She had to change the words because Glinda wasn't there
CaptainSamTodd 2 years ago 11
lol, everytime I watch this I get crazy goose bumps. Espically the last note. Idina is incredible
BlackFox15 2 years ago 5
the winged monkey, is it's wings robotics because it moved??
Pc3out 2 years ago
no. the wings are attached to the costume.
BroadwayLegs 2 years ago 2
yeah the wings are so cool arnt they i love them lol
bobbie406 2 years ago
They have a part on the costume to make it move back and forth at their will.
XSneekyKarmaX 2 years ago
I love the "flying" thing, it's my favorite part! lol
JinxDagger 2 years ago
idina menzel and kristen chenoweth are the best glinda and elphaba ever i love them and this song and this musical GO WICKED !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
hannahmontana093456 2 years ago 4
i love how they changed the lyrics beacause they had no glinda
LightInGate 2 years ago
lol, I know. I noticed that too. Very creative.
CandyHiccups 2 years ago
who was the other "elphy"?
lol ik this is idina menzel but who was the other person who played the other elphaba? diana something?
photoshopgal67 2 years ago
diana played glinda i think. the others who played elphaba was kerry ellis, dunno the others
LightInGate 2 years ago
well it is kinda rushed considering they had no Glinda, but still it was well done
Disneydanny 2 years ago 2
i saw the musical it was so good.
askee22 2 years ago
she is really good but i think i like nicole parker better. she was amazing on broadway this past weekend
hiiilly45 2 years ago
i saw it with nicole parker too xD it was GREAT, normally i hate musicals, but i loved this one =)
seetherroxmysox 2 years ago
i like idina menzel as alphaba
soccerchic005 2 years ago
She is a great Elphaba! I luvd her in rent to!
BroadwayStar1313 2 years ago
What part of this book is this suppose to be?
StrangeFate3 2 years ago
The musical butchered the book. But if you HAD to put it in, its right after Glinda and Elphaba meet the wizard, and she calls him a sham.
dragontorch14 2 years ago
I haven't seen the musical, but it does seem quite different from the book.
skittler335 2 years ago
a LOT better than her performance at the tony awards. this is so awesomee!!!!
fmcambo6251 2 years ago
is it just me or does the song seemed rushed?
nash613 2 years ago
its u
babygirl79e4 2 years ago
Hey!
I figured out why it sounds rushed, It is because they do not have kirsten there as Glinda so they had to cut out there part but they also gave Idina a very long-winded part with no break... I thought it was very risky, also i thought the part when the guards broke in i was doing something else, and i thought she actually lost her breath... It is a bit of a quicker tempo than the soundtrack... oh well
apkbarry 2 years ago 2
she is definitely the best actress of broadway
Paolita13 2 years ago 3
Omg! Best song in the world!
LuvHoli14 2 years ago 3
she is so pretty and her voice is amazing!i tried singing this and i lost my voice. it's such a hard song to sing and idina does an amazing job with it
reddy3001 2 years ago 2
im seeing it in june!
a bit of a wait -_- but IM SO EXCITED!!!!
kanumbra 2 years ago 2
Good for you! I saw it on Broadway, and it's super awesome!:)
JorisH92 2 years ago 2
Idina IS Elphaba! She has the most amazing voice and this song is simply brilliant! it's my favorite song in the whole musical! especially her version 'cause she pulled it off so perfectly! I saw the musical in England and it was AMAZING!
thanks for posting 5* and fave
-Tilde
kissepus 2 years ago 37
she really is! =)
latinasfinest65 2 years ago 3
wow. i get chills every time i listen to her..
iimatthebeach55 2 years ago
I was fortunate enough to see this LIVE at portland in washington =D
SHE ROX!!!!
glontol2 2 years ago 2
thank you
i love my username too!<3
xoTossTossxo 2 years ago
Idina did an amazing job in Wicked, as in rent. This is a VERY difficult song to perform, but she was able to pull it off beautifully two times a day over and over again. An amazing performer.
jhille85 3 years ago 6
for all those people who say she sounds crap....
Idina has a very powerful voice....
which sound bad through a carmera coz the silly little mics can't handle it
i got to see Wicked in australia and Amanda Harrison was amazing.....but Idina would have been AMAZING to see live
apparently she did alot of shows even when she was sick because she didn't want to disapoint people who travled there just to see her
Amazing woman :)
pinkpolish9 3 years ago 8
everytime i hear this song i get major chills
yahyahchick92 3 years ago
i totally love Idina as Elphie!
elphie4evergreen 3 years ago 2
wow she just blows me away
Rockerbabe16 3 years ago
im going to go see this at the Gershwin theature next week im so excited
paperpad12 3 years ago
IT'S AMAZING!!!
musicalfreak1993 3 years ago
ok, i saw the musical after idina left the cast, but this serously just gave me the chills.
i mean, this has always been my favorite song from the show, especially the ending, but wow.
peacelovehappiness17 3 years ago 4
yeah. at this point in the musical, the emotion was so powerful that I just started crying. and I'm a guy! guys aren't meant to cry because of music. but steven schwartz is my idol!!!
yeh. I live in Canberra, australia. I saw the Australian production.
musicalfreak1993 3 years ago 3
Well that's cool. :]
I want to go to Australia someday.
peacelovehappiness17 3 years ago
Why can't guys cry at music?
WishingOnIyWounds 3 years ago
I sware Ive seen wicked 3 times and listen to this song every day...never gets old always gives me chills
NobodyInAllofOZ1 3 years ago
I want to see Wicked sooooo bad! I have the soundtrack, but I still haven't gotten my musical experience :(
cpper22008 3 years ago
i feel so unfortunate living in a country that doesn't provide me with any privilege to see wicked. i've read the book, and fell in love with it. i wish, oh how i wish i could see the play :(
sabvilla 3 years ago
me too... i feel so unfortunate living in a country that doesn't provide me with any privilege to see ANY musical..
gabriellecorinne 3 years ago
i see you live in indonesia. i'm from the philippines. how sad for both of us.
sabvilla 3 years ago
Oh my goodness SABVILLA!! you really need to see this show. It's so great. I also read the book and love both the book and show. Do you have the soundtrack? If you can't see the show, the next best thing is to listen to the music. I'm pretty much in love with the soundtrack. :)
13Elphaba13 3 years ago
yes i've heard a few songs and i have to say i'm going crazy over them. i really want to see the play :(
sabvilla 3 years ago
this song is AMAZING =]
PrincessRosiex 3 years ago
oh my god! i wanna see wicked soooooo much! shes got on ehell of a voice on her!
xxx
reenie996 3 years ago
omg she is the best wicked witch their 's ever been! im in love with this musical!!!
yaminashy 3 years ago 3
shit this one literally sent shivers down my spine
doggydew 3 years ago
jacobmacinnis leave her alone. She's freaking Idina Menzel. She can breath as loud as she wants.
SaVeStHeDaY37mm 3 years ago
she has asthma give her a break i think the breathing puts a cool effect on it
xoTossTossxo 3 years ago 2
dude shes hot
bobbyjj331 3 years ago
probably idinas best vocally. . . she just has such shitty breathing control..she like gasps for breath SO LOUD between words. if you listen to all of her recordings they're all like that. still a true talent though
jacobmacinnis 3 years ago
umm...she has ASTHMA.
vivaelphaba 3 years ago
u kno I think shes sposed to be, as part of her character, or maybe to emphasise the drama
Phantomthedubber 3 years ago
She has asthma.. get things straight before you say that kind of stuff..
poohbearlover07 3 years ago
not that great, she has sung much better, she hit some bad notes there ...ouch! and the mix doesn't work.
daisy5050 3 years ago
what happened to the freakishly large cape????? eeither way THIS IS AWSOME!! Idina Menzel ROCKS!
totofan4ever 3 years ago 4
I hate how the song is shortened to fit it into the show. It really doesn't do it justice.
Maskerus 3 years ago 3
Hahahah that was a clever little promo performance! I loved how they combined the songs well!
Bona07 3 years ago
I don't think this song records very well...
xXxEchosChildxXx 3 years ago
where was glenda?
faggleu 3 years ago
I'm seeing wicked in London this week!
aislinggrace 3 years ago
she has an amazing voice
i cant even explain it
jaynik14 3 years ago
are you making that comment in reference to this video cuz this is one of the most vocally horrendous renditions of this song ever performed, this and the tonys both just awful!!
Elphaboy 3 years ago
oh I don't think they're THAT bad I mean it's just when she's in the air. I'm thinking maybe that flying haress that they put on her might cause strain on her breathing habits y'know?
ColorxConfused 3 years ago 2
Edina Menzel is mezmerizing. I am going to
see Wicked in Ottawa. I fell in love with this musical when I saw her do this on the Tony awards and she was stunning in this role.
I bought the CD and fell in love with it.
Kath13669 3 years ago
is she from rent?
idina?
kiraroxyoursox 3 years ago 2
yeah
musicluvver0013 3 years ago
that was a mix of march of the which hunters, the wizard and i and defying gravity
Travmann777 3 years ago
what episode is this. mabey they will show a re-run. :)
totofan4ever 3 years ago
Why do they put everything good in the Late Show? I would of recorded this episode if I would of known.
totofan4ever 3 years ago
her so if you care to find me....sounded painful....and why was it RUSHED???? love idina
NyBoundJoe 3 years ago
thats amazing.
if only i could be that good of an actress.
and for the person who said she doesnt have talent,
there is a difference between stage singing and recording singing.
big difference.
and she is amazing.
wootblah345 3 years ago
I GOT CHILLS... SO AMAZING
eleivadainculo 3 years ago 3
i love this play
i saw it a couple years ago and i still love listening to the soundtrack
mistycalpunk 3 years ago
truely amazing!
stargal95 3 years ago 4
AMAZIN AMAZIN AMAZIN
ilovenirvanaandmcr 3 years ago 4
im actually a fan of the original elphaba, but she's good
ImaLionRawr12 3 years ago 2
that is the original Elphaba. =)
latinasfinest65 3 years ago
really, oh my bad i read the name wrong, srry!!! i thought it was her, then i saw the name and i thought it said idna, srry!!! muah!
ImaLionRawr12 3 years ago
ahhh but it isnt :)
there was SJB(correct me if im wrong) before her but before Wicked became permanently fixated to broadway they brought Idina Menzel into it.
InsertAnimation 3 years ago
Best Elphaba. Clearly superior.
dragonfan20 3 years ago 6
idina menzel is incredible.
i would kill for her talent.
christininee 4 years ago 3
Oh man, Idina has the most lovely voice! She and Kristen Chenoweth really found each other with the beauty of their voices! *clap clap clap*
olivelivylover 4 years ago 5
This was a nice performance and all and I LOVE idina's voice but the effect that you see in the show was kind of lost here. Here where she's starting to fly is WAY more dramatic in the show and it's more like she's flying. But still, great job.
Kryptonsuperfan 4 years ago 5
I love how in the beginning the audience is kinda clapping and at the end everybody is cheering like heck.
sup9412 4 years ago
2:37 is so amazing!
ALittleDramaNeverHur 4 years ago
my god... Idina makes it look easy!
LiveAndLoveLife 4 years ago 3
She is way to awesome!!! Lol.
gamezb2013 4 years ago 3
i love her!
i wish she sang in Enchanted.
idk why they didnt use her
misslia 4 years ago 4
well, they did use her... she's an actress too, you know lol. Personally, i like her acting as much as her singing! maybe even more...
LiveAndLoveLife 4 years ago
lol yeah i know she's an actress.
but i wish she sang.
maybe when they went back into the other world she could have sang!
i absolute adore her voice!
misslia 4 years ago
yeah. she has a truly unique and characteristic voice. Some things work with her voice that don't work with anyone else's. I think she is the only Kate in The Wild Party that I will ever like! lol.
LiveAndLoveLife 4 years ago
haha she was happy about being hired for her acting talents
they offered her the job when like everyone else had to audition
YAY IDINA
pinkpolish9 3 years ago
wow did such a good job combining it to make it flow
sweetness010 4 years ago
This song still gives me goosbumps lol.
xXFashionK9Xx 4 years ago
Daaaaaannmm!!
GG621 4 years ago
can someone please tell me who is playing elphaba in Wicked currently? as in who will be playing it in june because thats when i'm going to see it :] thank you!
peaceelovetennis 4 years ago
you can look it up on the site! :D
I'm not really sure!
latinasfinest65 4 years ago
peaceelovetennis- Stephanie J. Block is currently portraying Wicked, but I don't know if she will still be pportraying Elphaba then. As for the touring cast, I have heard that Carmen Cusack is the curent Elphaba, instead of Victoria Matlock, because I heard that Victoria did her last show like 2-3 weeks ago. I'm not sure.
IdinaGrl101 4 years ago
No one is at the moment cos of the Broadway Strike! But it's Stephanie J Block
twistednature18 4 years ago
actually BROADWAY IS BACK! the strike ended.
I recieved an email about it last night!
=)
latinasfinest65 4 years ago
WAHOO! :D
I wanted the Broadway strike to be on the news but it hasn't been, damn UK news!
twistednature18 4 years ago
Vocally it was a good performance but just listen to her gasps of breath. Diaphragmic breathing is what she needs to be doing.
bondingo 4 years ago
singing with asthma keep that in mind
idinakristinwicked 4 years ago
I never even knew she had asthma. I thought it was just because she smoked :\
bondingo 4 years ago
bondingo- Wtf? Where the hell did ya hear that from?- "I thought it was just because she smoked"
IdinaGrl101 4 years ago