I'm impressed you got the strumming and singing down. Like everyone's saying, it's not easy to reach his high notes for a guy (if it's easy for me being a chick, it's probably hard for a guy). You're actually helping me learn it from your strumming. Well done, thank you. :)
That is absolutely amazing! Great Job! Your vocals are good, even if English was your first language. Considering that your first language is German, they are great! Really great guitar playing.
Excellent job! The guitar sounds just like the original, and your voice is really good! I'm learning to play that song now but I'm not that good--yet!
I enjoyed your rendition, like it alot, your a good singer and guitarist. I did one just the other day of old man and its in video format I dont do all of the pickin while strumin but its ok. take a listen and tell me what you think.
The vocals are about as close as your going to get to Neil Young. Listen to Neil sing it than listen to him. Thoda04 don't even listen to these negative comments. I've been scouting music talent for years and I'm telling you you have some serious talent bud.
Thanks. I know that some People have some problems with my Vocals. So many years I heard them say "Oh I don't like it" or the other told me I'm good. I think it's ok what they wrote. So I'm not angry or anything else as long as they are offend me not personally.
Excuse me please, my English is probably very bad. But I hope you'll understand. ;-)
Don't even worry about it bro. People are just mad because they can't play or sing it near as good as you. They just get on here and critise other people, because they are upset with themselves. You are very good man. You ever record any cds or anything man?
klar ist leichter in deutsch.Vielen Dank für die mail.Ich meine weniger die Akkorde sondern mehr was du mit den Fingern machst wenn Du F C G spielst vor dem Vers.
Ich finde diese kleinen Noten ( Anschläge)bei den Akkorden so toll.
Aber ich erwarte keinen Privatunterricht von Dir. Dont worry.
Ich bin halt nicht so gut.
Deine Version ist sehr authentisch und ich habe Dein Video als Favorit gespeichert.
Habe irgenwie falsch geklickt bei der anderen mail.
just perfect and brilliant.I am from Hamburg (ol Hippie 57)Saw him life here in the 70th.
I would like to play it, but I cant work it out what you doing when you start singing and going from the chord D to F (your fingers I cant follow could you help me.
great covewr man im an old neal young fan you did justice to this righton ^5
noreply45 4 months ago
your amazing. your playing is like listening to angels playing!
licksnkicks 6 months ago
Great Job!!
metallica0925 10 months ago
You're great dude! I don't notice an accent at all. Nice playing and singing!
zorgen123 11 months ago
Nice Job.
rhstorm 1 year ago
Great job on Old Man.
ad1juster 1 year ago
Ich lerne das lied auch gerade, doch so gut gelingt es mir noch lange nicht;) und dann noch dazu singen..
Respekt! :D
inchskater 1 year ago
Five stars all day long! Great cover, thanks
bluetownbarry 1 year ago
great sing, guitar, song! You're amazing man! ;-)
JonasGuitar11 1 year ago
I love your voice and you have great tone on the guitar! Nice! ;)
kasshroom 1 year ago
Hell. I'd like to hear more from you.
dahger7 1 year ago
The vocals are great, of course it won't sound like Neil but its cool in its own way.
MrWiiPS360 1 year ago
I'm impressed you got the strumming and singing down. Like everyone's saying, it's not easy to reach his high notes for a guy (if it's easy for me being a chick, it's probably hard for a guy). You're actually helping me learn it from your strumming. Well done, thank you. :)
KoalaCD 1 year ago
nice job great sound i really enjoyed it keep it up man
mandr8k 1 year ago
good job dude!! neil young's voice is a hard one to get close to, its super unique. but over all u did a good job.
low72 1 year ago
That is absolutely amazing! Great Job! Your vocals are good, even if English was your first language. Considering that your first language is German, they are great! Really great guitar playing.
mxpmw 1 year ago
nice cover man keep on rockin the long hair i got that too
Familyman1313 1 year ago
The way u r singing that song is very pleasant !! U did a nice cover !
theSnoreful 2 years ago
great work mate :)
foleyxl18 2 years ago
Very good....tried this one myself...
Well Done...
thewoodguy11 2 years ago
Comment removed
Sportybob 2 years ago
Well done mate! Trying to perfect playing this myself. Very impressive vocals, great highs!
senatorsfc 2 years ago
Excellent
3sonsdad 2 years ago
wonderful my friend.
iheartenjoi 2 years ago 2
Very good! I enjoyed that! good work on the singing of the chorus, especially!
analmongus 2 years ago
Awesome job with the guitar, Neil has a hard style to get down, but you play him well. Check out my cover if you get a chance!
twostep03 3 years ago
Kudos to you my man..You did a kick butt job on this one for sure..
Ruraljohn 3 years ago
I'd like to hook up with a singer like you some day when I finally play my guitar with others.
bucinaus 3 years ago
Great job. I'll have to revise how I play this a bit- Thanks! Nice vocal delivery!
Sean-DejaVuAcoustic
DejaVuAcoustic 3 years ago
The other level...Good cover man.
guitboy74 3 years ago
Ooo---pretty voice. Perfect guitar.
Giselle62 3 years ago
Really nice job man.. I did this tune too. If you want to check it out just click my username or paste: watch?v=BXT3Co0AFlk
Canstey84 3 years ago
Excellent job! Thanks !
AnotherSavage 3 years ago
Excellent job! The guitar sounds just like the original, and your voice is really good! I'm learning to play that song now but I'm not that good--yet!
cameraman5449 3 years ago
Hey Thoda - that's really good. Great guitar phrasing and you have a really nice voice. Cool.
winedemonium 3 years ago
very nice play.
dspencer3 3 years ago
Very nice ! Thanks !
kammhron 3 years ago
This is some great stuff man!
botto12 3 years ago
Very good, Great way to capture one of the great hits of the master of playing and singing..
caincole128 3 years ago
good play !
FRUITxSHAKE 3 years ago
I enjoyed your rendition, like it alot, your a good singer and guitarist. I did one just the other day of old man and its in video format I dont do all of the pickin while strumin but its ok. take a listen and tell me what you think.
Thanks
AcousticPhases 3 years ago
Very good, smooth and sweet guitar's sound, I like your playing and your guitar! Beatyful song.
iischia 3 years ago
damn i envy your guitar playing
i wish i could nail this song like you did
justin18222 3 years ago
keep playing it is a easy song to play.
jdmarcus59 3 years ago
great guitar playing
Greystash 3 years ago
Man brotha! Your guitar playing was dead and I mean Dead on! Hats off to you old man. You did a historical song justice.
rmstudio 4 years ago
excellent!
jivechump 4 years ago
Awesome job man! Great playin and u really nailed the high part! Ur German yes?
MakeViolntRevolution 4 years ago
Thank you all for leaving comments.
Yes I am German
Thoda04 4 years ago
I don't like the vocals, doesn't fit the song
loserbiotch2 4 years ago
The guys German give him a chance, i think he does well. He obviously aint gonna sound like Neil
AlfiesRevenge 4 years ago
I know he won't sound like Neil Young but I was just stating my oppinion, allthough I love the guitar
loserbiotch2 4 years ago
no crap :P no one can sound like neil young
CoversUnited 4 years ago
The vocals are about as close as your going to get to Neil Young. Listen to Neil sing it than listen to him. Thoda04 don't even listen to these negative comments. I've been scouting music talent for years and I'm telling you you have some serious talent bud.
sgwrestler11 3 years ago
Thanks. I know that some People have some problems with my Vocals. So many years I heard them say "Oh I don't like it" or the other told me I'm good. I think it's ok what they wrote. So I'm not angry or anything else as long as they are offend me not personally.
Excuse me please, my English is probably very bad. But I hope you'll understand. ;-)
Thoda04 3 years ago
Don't even worry about it bro. People are just mad because they can't play or sing it near as good as you. They just get on here and critise other people, because they are upset with themselves. You are very good man. You ever record any cds or anything man?
sgwrestler11 3 years ago
Thanks :-) But I'm sorry, i haven't any CDs.
Thoda04 3 years ago
Great vocals !
pachacamacs 4 years ago
good job*****
gumpie361 4 years ago
Hallo Thomas,
nochmals vielen dank für Deine Mühe.
Geht schon viel besser, noch nicht so gut wie Du, aber soll ja auch jeder ein bißchen sein eigenes Ding machen.
Schönen noch Abend nache Stuttgart.
Gruß aus Hamburg
Horst
P.S. Hast Du noch andere Sachen im Netz ?
sempaphore 4 years ago
Fantastic man, you've a great voice. check out my songs if you get a chance. :)
petetheweet 4 years ago
Thanks Thomas.Versuche das morgen in aller Frische.
Gruß aus Hamburg
Horst
sempaphore 4 years ago
Hi Thoda,
klar ist leichter in deutsch.Vielen Dank für die mail.Ich meine weniger die Akkorde sondern mehr was du mit den Fingern machst wenn Du F C G spielst vor dem Vers.
Ich finde diese kleinen Noten ( Anschläge)bei den Akkorden so toll.
Aber ich erwarte keinen Privatunterricht von Dir. Dont worry.
Ich bin halt nicht so gut.
Deine Version ist sehr authentisch und ich habe Dein Video als Favorit gespeichert.
Habe irgenwie falsch geklickt bei der anderen mail.
Gruß
Horst
sempaphore 4 years ago
Hi Thoda,
just perfect and brilliant.I am from Hamburg (ol Hippie 57)Saw him life here in the 70th.
I would like to play it, but I cant work it out what you doing when you start singing and going from the chord D to F (your fingers I cant follow could you help me.
Thanks mate your fan Horst from Hamburg
sempaphore 4 years ago
Nice job man, I enjoyed it. :)
JeffreyC2 4 years ago
good job
goldengreek25 4 years ago
Nice job !
rp691200 4 years ago
GREAT COVER!
andrewvegaSTL 4 years ago
nice cover well done
klutz94306 4 years ago
pretty great dude about time i heard someone do it somewhat right with out destroying it completely
great i like your own rendition it is awesome keep it up
bostongeorgegj 4 years ago
Well done, this is fantastic. Your voice is great.
Gregman11 4 years ago
no you play very well i give ya point all the way no your voice is ok but keep playing
check me out im a singer with out a band but i have a studio hehheehe mercy
diamondave103 4 years ago
Very nicely done!
bubba344 4 years ago
great song, great cover
projectnick26 4 years ago
Hey very well done! Really nice job..please check out my version too if you like..I hope you like it.
DAvid87 4 years ago
Yeah, I like it - pleas give us more.
autoandimat 4 years ago
Watching this helped me fill in the gaps when I play the song.. Great job, thanks for posting.
adder80 4 years ago
You have great chops on that takamine. Nice voice too. Post more!!
neanderpaul 4 years ago
AWESOME!!!!!! 8-)
lightnintrucker 4 years ago
great job! you really captured the feel of the song
jsz1962 4 years ago
great job! keep it up!
lnknptheory 4 years ago
Sauber !!!!!!!!!!!!!
harbob1 4 years ago
great... 5 stars
Bitterblue86 4 years ago
Hell! What a fucking good musician :-) :-)
AschiCH 4 years ago
Very nice!
Throned78 4 years ago
Nice song!
stepalb 4 years ago
Good job!
timthelder 4 years ago