Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (272)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • seriously.. i know people rant about why people dislike videos! but why is it this is disliked like really?!. I LOVE THIS!!!!!

  • Good, definitely nothing spectacular.

  • she's really good, the video quality just isn't good

  • I FREAKIN LOVE THIS! I like the strong voice, it sounds powering and emotional.

  • better than coldplay? Be realistic.

    She's alright..

    the chorus wasn't sung to well.

    But the rest was alright.

    Don't hate. Its my opinion.

  • Was this transposed?

  • i agree. slow it down

    and practice on your vocals a little

    but the piano you got down. great job.

  • dam that was good I hope u like my mussic friends.

  • Yea she has something but i dont know about her singing it better than cold play thats a long stretch buddy...

  • @encoresfall she is live, i have ehard coldplay live and she is better.

  • get a label

  • it would sound better if you sang softer! but you have a good voice :)

  • wel... the singing is better then mine ! :P

  • It was good, but I wouldn't quite say amazing. Maybe with dynamics and some passion it can be improved. Needless to say, she's talented.

  • *speechless*

  • great voice for sure..but a little too fast..slow it down a bit and put a little more emotion into it and you'll make people smile

  • METALLICA

  • Too fast and too loud. Gotta have more feeling for the story that the song is telling and not just sing the lyrics.

  • @coolhand67 i agree. to get emotion she needed to slow down. otherwise she just sounds like she's trying too hard. i've gotten the goosebumps from many performances and i didnt get any from this girl. shes good but not STAR POWER WITH EMOTION which is important for any musician. thank you for this comment.

  • awesome voice... but this song is more emotional more smooth... thiis was sharper than an indian bow

  • incredible, absolutely incredible

  • not really doing it for me im afraid.. needs more meaning, and its too bold for this kinda meaningful soft song, edges are sharp....

  • Work on your breathing, for sure, because you have a wonderful tone. Nice, no less.

  • A little bit flat, but nothing a little breath support can't fix :). Other than that she was pretty good!

  • Kinda flat

  • i like it

  • Good...a bit flat though.

  • nice

    its better than most of the singers these days without editing their voices :)

  • Her voice is a little harsh and flat

  • I love coldplay, and out of all the women who tried to cover this song, you did the best, keep going, this was great.

  • i think you a good talent and should proceed with music with a little work. the only thing i can even try to say is maybe try to put some more emotion into it. dont get me wrong im not being some dick head. i think you could go very far in the music industry if you stick with it and dont give up.

  • amzing singer :):)

  • Comment removed

  • It is o.k... a little Squeaky at the begining

  • chorus is more like a lame shouting. why didn't she use falcetto?

  • i love the piano part but the singing is ok i guess alot better than mine  XD

  • Amazing performance! Go on! Does she have her own chanal?

  • She doesn't really sing it better than coldplay to be honest

  • pretty goooood! check mine out:)

  • She needs to tone it down a bit... It's way to strong, to fast paced. She appears stiff with a really bad stage presence. And the "Nobody said this was easy" kind of hurt my ears.

  • sweet :)

  • i like it. my wife doesnt. but she's doesnt know her ass from her elbow.

  • @BurtLanden tell her to get in the kitchen and shut up!

  • @BurtLanden haha wtf

  • @BurtLanden I JUST LAUGHED SO HARD AT THIS HAHAHA omg made my day

  • @BurtLanden haha she's a woman

  • beautiful :)

  • @revamp94 It makes me think of Kristen Stewart , too . But I really like Kristen ((:

  • ua little more slow the song, can be perfect

  • un poco más lenta de la canción, puede ser perfecto

  • Nice performance, you really have a large power in your voice, i like that. Keep doing what you're doing ;)

  • @revamp94  hahahha

  • IM A BIG FAN OF COLDPLAY BUT THIS IS WAY BETTER THEN THERE VERSION

    SHES REALY GOOD!!!!

  • shes amazing<333

  • SHES nervous chill the fuck out!!!

  • Does she even listen to the song? wots the rush? ... plz .. ur voice is good but slow down ...

  • Spell binding. 

  • great but i guess it's a bit fast

  • your so Good at singing

  • shes ok not bad...

  • That was a really good performance.

    i didnt really feel the song tho.

    you didnt put much emotion into it tho

  • Why do ads never need to load but the vid does?????

  • well, i like her style! she has beautiful voice and she sing with no useless skills. i think it is great.

  • she's REALLY good i love this song too. so it's all really good

  • i luv her voice ur amazing

  • yeah she sings this far to fast and to loud

  • she needs to slow down otherwise it feels like she's singing without any feelings . her voice is good but it's too loud and fast !

  • she needs to slow down otherwise it feels like she's singing without any feelings . her voice is good but it's too loud and fast !

  • This is amazing. I totally love it!

  • she is ok. better than me but still needs work!keep it up!

  • i dont like the accent though. Too strong! But really good voice.

  • maybe a tad bit flat...? 

  • screaming? volume?

    was i listening to the wrong video? .. this girl is singing at like 75 percent of her total volume... that is not screaming.. she is not singing pop or r&b, which requires a breathier tone. plus, her mic is loud. i just dunno if it fits the style of the song.. coldplay isn't my type of genre...

    plus she's pretty :) good luck girl :)

    personally... not the type of music i would attend a performance. but i just hate all those haters.

  • That was crazy amazing. I am blown away. She did all that without the help of electronics or vocal editing stuff. That was just astonishing.

  • @K3NDL3032 It's pitiful when it's "amazing" that someone can sing decently without using vocal enhancement technology.

  • wow.... amazing

  • omg this is great! I think this is better than the original.

  • I loved it! Julia filled both of my arms solid with goosebumps! That never happens to me!! Very Beautifully done Julia!!

  • beautiful girl and beautiful voice...had my heart from the start

  • she has so much potential..she just needs to learn how to "feel" what she is singing.

  • @ineedtobewithyou tough to do when ur not a good piano player .. and not a pro and performing... i think that's what is going on...

  • she kinda look like bella the hair and the way she dress here =)

  • holllyyyy sshhhiittt. thats my friends sister.

  • sounds lxke shes screaminq.!

  • awsome!!!!

  • she has talent and can play an instrument unlike the so called stars of today

  • Very monotonous and amature, although she has potential.

  • I agree with mgmetro7

    It's really not a good song for her, I think her voice should be a bit more gentle but more full of emotion in this song, and slightly slower. She's a wonderful singer, don't get me wrong. But I really think that she could do an amazing job on a different song.

  • It lacks the emotion that the song should very well have.

    Her singing contradicts the lyrics.

    Great singer, just not the right song.

  • loved it loud but only on the parts she needed 2 be so i say wonderful

  • god damnit, a beautiful women who can sing with a powerful voice and play the piano turns me on so fucking much

  • @low72 Nice dude, ha ha same here

  • awesooomeee....

  • good job

    nice pianoskills too

    :D

  • Great job! Very nice! :)

  • calm down

  • Mmmmh... Not the best I've ever seen.

  • so clear  this girl gave me goosebumps wonderful

  • It was ok. It would of sounded better in a higher octave.

  • i see some people comment on how loud she is...but its pretty much impossible to hit that note without it being loud, unless you use falsetto, which she doesn't...

    for the record, when she sings "nobody" in the chorus, the "no" part is a high B flat...that is about Bonos current vocal range, which is higher than most singers can do without falsetto...i agree that it sound somewhat strange because she stops like: "no. body. said..." and so on, but just hitting that note is very impressive!

  • a bit too fast but nontheless it was rlly good clear powerful voice like MrMoxytornado sed but its a bit too loud too :P good nonetheless again xD

  • too fast....

    she's screaming..

    but not bad

  • I loooove your voice, it is exactly the style I like: very clear and really unique timbre to it

    great cover :D

  • Lovely cover... lovely girl.. .. loudy mic, too fast... but still lovely

  • needs more dynamic.

  • i love your voice how can we contact her.

  • shes amazing! lol and love that dudes metallica shirt at the end xD

  • She is really good!!! :) Just let her know if she perfects Dynamics, this song will be singed soo quick!! :)

  • i have a question too. can she marry me haha

  • bitch

  • You just made my life seriously. You sing it better then anyone I've ever heard.

    If you were in my area we'd make a good duo I play guitar :).

  • @pavaoq10 For real?....

  • if she slowed the tempo a little, she would have had so much room to work on a better vocal performance.

    Other than that critique, she stays on key pretty well.

  • awesome

  • Its not better than coldplay.. her voice is to low. (:

  • she has a wonderful voice, but it sounds just like the cover done by natasha beddingfield. if it were me singing, i would slow down the tempo cuz you lose all emotion in the song. you can't hear pain or sorrow in her voice, and that's what you want to hear when you listen to the scientist. she did a wonderful job on the piano though.

  • Amazing

  • She is amazing. I almost cried when I watched this. Haha. Seriously. <3

  • This is just simply amazing!

  • woooo strong voice  she has potential

  • the volume only helps to excentuate her voice.Trust me i'm a singer so i know that sometimes its all about the volume.Amazingly done!! i wish i could sing w/ you.

  • I'd fuck her.

  • nice voice, but the cover as a whole lacks personality imo

  • I think she did a really good job...except for emoting the pain behind the lyrics.

  • if its too loud for you turn your volume down.. This girl Julia is amazing

  • bit loud..

  • a little fast ... but nice :)

  • @Sandylicious20 its a cover, what do u expect?

  • i dunno if i like it.

  • omg your voice is amazing and i love this song and i think you sang it better than cold play your amazing:)x

  • Great Cover. She has a great voice.

  • Shes ok not as gud a Nathan Brake!

  • This wasnt great/ amazing but it wasn't bad

  • muy bueno!

  • your just amazing :)

  • haha it was so good my canary started singing along with it

  • your amazing keep it up :)

  • Amazing.... Many props to you girl. Don't listen to the bullshit that people are posting... you are young, very talented, and will excel in music. Follow your heart and you will never falter....

  • WOW! amazing!!!!! damn ur like the nicest person AND u can sing AND play the piano lol daaaamn

  • it was definitely well done! congrats =] one comment though, don't pound every note because they're not suppose to be equal, sing the words. a phrase suppose to have important words, so sing them!!

  • She has a great set of lungs. She sings with confidence, which is a talent in itself. Not small and sheepishly. Great job. God gave her a talent and she has learned how to use it. Not to say that she won't get better, but I think she is good now. She's definitely better than a lot of over-publicized crap that pollutes the radio today. Keep singing and thanks for sharing.

  • AMAZINGLY GREAT

  • its pretty good

    oh were did you get the sheet music

  • ermm, shes obviously very musically tallented, but not the best singer, but she is alright :)

  • you have a beautiful voice..

  • luv her wan her in my band!!! very cool

  • she is fucking cool!!!!! i have a band could she be my pianist??? and be my girl!!11

  • not bad.. but she could cut down on the volume a little..

  • @TheWoochy

    thats the sound guys problem. not hers.

  • @TheWoochy turn down your computer volume?

  • @TheWoochy turn your volume down if you dont like it, i think its quite amazing how powerful her voice is. :)

  • she is really, really good...

  • Eh, it was okay. A little boring.

  • she's good, but i've seen coldplay live and this was their encore, and no one can touch it...

  • The point is not whether she is/isn't coldplay, the point is that she is a "diamond" in a rough. Sorry for the play on words. :D She can easily fix this all up. And her next talent show is coming up very soon, so hopefully they post her next performance... I bet there is a huge improvement!

  • Oh and check her myspace page, she sings this song much slower and it sounds sooo much better!!

  • i agree @kokushi666

  • wow that was amasing!

  • amazing no ok yes!

  • Did she win?

  • reallu good well done

  • That was amazing I loved it, you have an amazing talent, keep it up, you should try out for american idol you would definately make it!

  • wow im surprised she doesn't have a record deal very talented dont stop singing u have a bright future

  • To be fair, right theres people saying she sings it completely different to Coldplay... tooo fast, not the same pitch or anything, well guess what...SHE'S NOT COLDPLAY...She sang it HER way, and i think she is very talented :) Keep it up :)

  • well done girl lovely clear powerful voice

  • better than coldpaly? she has no expression in her voice, she's good but not that good

  • awesome :D

  • UR REllllyyy GOOD!!

    keep it up!!

  • def not better than coldplay.

  • uhh too bad Cold Play is the worst band in history. So. Its not hard to be better than them. But, she has a good voice.

  • Her voice is kinda disturbing, lacks of skill, the pitch is quite good, her timbre is AWFUL though. Anyways keep it up!

  • in my honest opinion the "nobody said it was easy" part was kinda painful to listen to because you were yelling. other than that it was pretty good. nice piano playing :)

  • agree great voice wayw ay way waywa y x10 too fast.......

  • she sang it fast.. It would be better if it was slower

  • Shes Awesomeee XD

  • great voice, great piano-- i loved it! =) such a soothing voice. Keep up the good work.

  • In my opinion if she sang it slower it would have better.