Judy Garland - Somewhere Over The Rainbow, With Liza

[123sweetgigimusic]

one dislike must of went the wrong way instead they went and followed the red brick road or they didn't get want they wanted from the wizard of oz.

[123sweetgigimusic]

ever since judy garland died, the music went right with it :'( atleast we have something to remember to cherish the memories and moments by.

[123sweetgigimusic]

whoever was the one who disliked this doesn't have the talent as judy garland does.

[elvisuk]

brilliant video thanks so much for this ...judy is a legend

[cinderelmo]

You what her daughter Liza is in this but she is only mouthing the words because like Judy said always be a first rate version of your self not a second rate version of somebody else and Liza is not a second rate version of Judy she is her own star but it would be nice like I said to here Liza is not Dorothy like her mother but every ounce in a while it would be nice to hear Liza today sing this and pay tribute to her mother in concert.

[ShellyBellyZee]

theres a reason this only has one dislike.

[eointr]

I think this concert really pin points the beginning of the end for her, she just seems off there, and then with the interview she did with jack paar around the same time and melbourne i dont think she really ever recovered form it and started to slip...

[minolit]

a gay can DIE of happyness watching this

[cinderelmo]

Aww it would be nice to see Liza sing her mothers songs Especially over the rainbow.

[FRANKHODGES39]

How is it possible for anyone to dislike this recording? This guy needs therapy desperately! Whoever you are, call Dr.Phil, please!

[preslana10]

I love watching liza in this sequence. sitting on the stage like a little girl, just beaming with awe and pride at her mother. What a goddess.

[3rdbase04]

aw that's so great everyone knows the words!

[septube26]

Liza shared so many Lovely moments with her mother.

[djbarcode5xyz]

What's amazing to me is she died almost a month before we actually DID go over the rainbow in Apollo 11!

[MariaInke]

Judy is the great singer ever!

[cutepiku]

I really want to hear a version with Liza singing this, now.

[rileyrossi]

@cutepiku Liza sings her mother's songs very rarely - she has said that Judy told her that she didn't have to and that she thanks her for that - also that "they've been sung" I don't think she would do this unless it was for something VERY special - like a concert dedicated to her mother or something and even then, she probably would only sing parts of it - a "duet" with her mother most likely

[ryanglitter]

@rileyrossi she actually sings her mother's songs quite often: off the top of my head, she's sung The Man That Got Away, The Trolley Song, Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas, Come Rain or come Shine, How Long has This Been Going On, and the end of Over the Rainbow, not to mention singing a video duet with Judy and a bunch of her MGM songs in her show Minnelli on Minnelli

[rileyrossi]

@ryanglitter she has sung them alot, but i was saying that i don't think Liza would do over the rainbow. I love her versions of Judy's songs :D

[TherealRNO]

@sellhouse: Actually, her daughters have said that anything Judy has ever said can be taken as an epic joke, since she just had the gravitational sort of humor that made jokes from anything. But [Rainbow] was the one thing not to be joked about, due to how personal the song was to her.

[DebsTasha45]

It's the way Judy says 'oh i've sung this song for so many years...' you know what song she is going to sing, bravo Judy Garland, may you still be in history for hundreds of years to come!

[daisymay2u]

Listen to Doris Day version. Beautiful..

[whirlyfan]

magical !

[NoOnesBussiness]

I'm not afraid to say that, I just cried, while watching this. God bless you, Judy Garland. You were one of a kind.

[DebsTasha45]

Judy Garland, you just made me cry, congrations.

[Blobbette]

Liza is 18 in this video

[rileyrossi]

she really does look happy in this vid, to hear people singing to her, such a sad thing that she died when she did

[123sweetgigimusic]

@rileyrossi that's what i was thinking too. :) i agree.

[marasu66]

So Liza is how old here? 14?

[Blobbette]

@marasu66

Liza is 18 in this video

[RunawayGurl95]

I just cried...

[phunnychicks]

Whoever disliked this deserves to burn in hell. Like if you agree. JUDY FOREVER!

[jasonesapp]

@phunnychicks thats a little over the top, wiseguy.

[phunnychicks]

@jasonesapp Probably because you disliked it!

[TomCollinsgirl]

when the audience chimes in i get goose pimply cause i know id do the same thing

[lauraaaseross]

Amazing, I just saw Andrew Lloyd Webbers Wizard of Oz in that same theater just tonight. What a history!

[DebsTasha45]

she belts it everytime! this is her song, and her song alone!

[talkindurinthemovie]

I jus love how liza looks at her mom the whole time then claps when she finishes gurl that got me cryin

[thuaners]

she's awesome :)

[DebsTasha45]

wow, if only she was alive now, in England(where i live) not many people adore Judy Garland, and the wizard of oz, the way America does, but Judy, we really do miss you, and no one can sing as fabulously as you did. rest in peace!

[borogal81]

It always amazes me when the audience knows a song word for word like that. That part made me well up more than anything. The idea that that song is a part of so many people's collective psyche. The idea that SHE is a part of so many people's collective psyche. Extraordinary. Never another like her. Never.

[dfwjac]

Mid sixties. That's a blouse bob mackie created for her for the JG show in '64 or '64. It's the Palladium concert.

[perkyNpink]

i.was.born.in.the.wrong.decade­­. :(

[VitaXiBella87]

The song and performance is amazing but I love to see the love between mother and daughter more

[AdamMichaelMercer]

I actually have goosebumps all over my entire body and NOBODY can do that to me except JUDY GARLAND!!!!!!

[daveybeno]

Brilliant !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Lealonna]

In a word: AWESOME

[HoshiChun]

great song..hey does anyone know of the movie they made about her life? know where it is or how to see it. I thougt it was called beyond the rainbow. but that's not it. any help would be great.

[brittquin2009]

@HoshiChun yes and I actually bought this one. Its called "Judy Garland: Me and My Shadows"

[thisissally]

This actually makes me bawl

[blahhduhhx3]

@thisissally Me too.

[Lockbar]

I've never seen this before. I always had a crush on Judy Garland, from this I can see she was much more of a special person then I ever thought.

[NFitalianGuy]

When you get over 2500 ppl singing in tune to their favorite Star is quite an amazing feat. It goesbeyond magical. It send a chill through your body.

[AnnaRoseD95]

she joked about everything but over the rainbow was the one thing no one was allowed to say anything about.

[aimeechicken]

I love her getting everyone involved and encouraging them, she was such a sweetheart <3

[petey8887]

When Judy hits the perfect note at the end of the song and I see the smile on Liza's face, I want to cry.

[shannon376]

Judy was 42 and it was in 1964 and even till the day she died she always have an amazing voice..she is still loved to this day!!!

[FlightlessBird93]

sobbing right now...

[DreaL33]

what year was this?

[Slayerplsko]

@DreaL33 1964 I guess

[WhitneyElizabethH]

The Drugs only made her tone go husky, the vocal power never changed,

LOVE YOU JUDY!

[stylestar07]

I love Judy.. but she seemed a little stoned in this performance.. DRUNK!!!!

[NFitalianGuy]

@EnchantedSilence she was NOT tired of singing this song, her voice was hurting because you can hear she wasn't in the best voice. Judy made the song even more magical by letting the audiece sing it with her and it gave the audience the chance to thank her by serenading her the way they did. Just look at judy's face when she heard them sing it back to her.

[NFitalianGuy]

@EnchantedSilence There is no interview that Judy Garland ever said she didn't like "Over the Rainbow" in fact in 1967 when she was on the TODAY show she said that was the best song ever written. She had great reverance for that song & never joked about it. She rarely sang it on television but always sang it in her concerts. I seen almost every interview and I never heard her say she didnt like the song. Even in her Biographies there never was any mention that she didnt like Over the Rainbow.

[TherealRNO]

@NFitalianGuy: Yeah. [Rainbow] basically become synonymous with her life. It's basically her THEME song! As her daughters would say later, "It's why some people get tears in their eyes when they hear it. It's that personal."

[RosesNightengales]

i love this song. Only Judy can do it.

[rivka614]

Judy Garland and Somewhere over the Rainbow were my Mom's most favorite. We carreid her to her final resting singing this song. May G-D grant them both eternal rest.

[Lexpelliarmus]

I. love. Judy. Garland. She has such a beautiful voice.

[DrApocalypseNow]

Oh how I love her. Ever since I was little, when my sister first sat me down in front of the tv and popped that Wizard of Oz tape in the vcr, no other singer has ever made me feel quite the way Judy does.

[hrryzdlr]

i can't belive it,

i'm actually weeping.

[NFitalianGuy]

I still get chills when you hear the entire Audience singing along with her. They were like some heavenly chorus. This is the connection Judy and her audience and why Judy loved us so much!

[TheMaestroBrad]

Gosh, every time I hear this song I get chills like I'm hearing it for the first time. No one sings this like Judy!

[coldandblank]

my fav video ever.

[dodginraindrops]

Something about her was magical

[lovefooledthegirl01]

this is so sweet!

[foshama]

wow... this is my favourite performance of this song....as she got older i think it meant a lot more to her personally and tht really sdhines through in this perfromance...rest in peace judy

[CARLDAVIDBIRMAN]

This confirms what everybody always said. Judy was always the impeccable stage mommy. Here she shepards the entire audience as if each and every one were her own little vocal offspring. How dear. Is this from the TV show?

[NFitalianGuy]

@CARLDAVIDBIRMAN This was on tv for the concert in Nov. 1964. Judy rarely sang OTR on TV. She saved it for her concerts but when we hear it sung on TV, it was a rare treat. She sang this song about 5 times in the14 yrs she did TV shows. This TV moment wasn't from a talk/variety show. It was a Televised concert, & the LP was recorded by Capitol Records. I wish they did the same for the Carnegie Hall Concert. THAT would have been amazing Imagine seeing stars like Marilyn Monroe in the audience?

[silvershields]

that was amazing look at how liza claps at teh end!!!!

[maxie102]

there is just some people with the ability to perform judy was one of those people i can tell she was just a lovely person i wish i could have known her and goodness she sure did love her kids writing those songs for them and doing everything for them you can tell she loved them by the way she beamed at them

[xVickiex]

This is so beautiful it made me cry!

I've heard this song performed so many times but never like this.

A very special performance.

[SweeneyTodd98]

Probally the most beautiful song evere written.and no one will ever sing it the way she did... :'(

[seismotronik]

i can see my grandma holdin my hand, as i see judy holdin lizas hand, and singin this to me...

[weatdamal]

powerful :)

[MonroseVila]

How was she SO talented???

I love her! I love The Wizard of Oz, I love everything about her...... =]

[sellhouse]

judy asked liza not to sing over the rainbow, because it was her signature song. true story, i'm one of her biggest fans. I wish she was still with us. she was amazing.

[theatrekid32]

not true. She didnt ask her Not to sing them. She told Liza that she should Never feel the need to sing her songs because they were hers....not lizas and she wanted liza to be famous for being liza....not for being judy garlands daughter.

[sellhouse]

@theatrekid32 i WONT EVEN REPLY TO THIS STATEMENT

[theatrekid32]

@sellhouse lol why? Its the truth

[sellhouse]

@theatrekid32 Your basically saying the same thing I said. I heard Judy say that on the Mrev Griffin show back in the sixties, and it is very true. So you can believe what you want and I will believe in what I heard.

[Lealonna]

Why Liza has never sung the song "Over the Rainbow?  I'd like to hear it. :(

[discoguy20]

'you're marvelous!'

love this

[seismotronik]

my favorite video of ALL TIME!!!!!!!

[foreverashcroft]

this lady was pure class..

[miss09lauren]

this made me cry so beautiful!!

[WizardOfOzfan94]

That so bitter-sweet it brings tears to my eyes.

[ChelexBebopMusic]

liza looks just like her mother. wow.

gorgeous.

[MsNeo75]

what can I say I wish I had been there, Love you Judy.

[KitKat652]

what year is this video from?

[musicdream822]

1959-1960???

[AdamMichaelMercer]

1964 I believe at the London Palladium. This footage is on dvd "Judy and Liza: Live at the London Palladium"

[robahmet1]

wow thats so beautiful hearing the hole audience singing

[nakiommi]

i cried durring this video

[LittleAngelic88]

Oh Judy,I will always love you for playing Dorothy and for that song.

[MiiZzJ0kEr]

Great Great Great Great

[nightrainbows1111]

we do love you, Judy ...

... always get tears in my eyes ...

'with permission', I dedicate this song to my loving Grandma Bobba

[kramogura]

We love you Judy!!

[LizzieLamb1993]

this is lovely! xx

[MicheleBell1]

This is a great video ... my favorite version of 'Over The Rainbow' ... sung so many times in so many places ... and frankly, when she was in better voice ... but never so raw, so Judy. I love the way Liza touches her Mother ... the Love is seen between a Mother & Daughter, a performer & her audience.

[actressindemaking]

what a special video! one to be treasured forever....

[beeje]

Wow, I don't know how old Judy is here, but she still had a very strong voice! So good!

[MargeinCharge98]

@beeje She's around 42 years old.

[NFitalianGuy]

@beeje she was 42 here when she did the Palladium Concert with Liza Minnelli in November 1964

[burnbabyburn1957]

@beeje This was probably from the Judy Garland TV show which aired 1963-64 and Judy (born in 1922) would have been 41 or 42. Liza was born in 1946 and would have been 16 or so.

[burnbabyburn1957]

@beeje Nope - I just saw on another post that this was The Palladium in November of 1964: Judy 42 and Liza 18.

[AdamMichaelMercer]

@beeje 42 I believe is how old she was here.

[prckay]

@beeje this is when people kept there vocies in shape

[rileyrossi]

@beeje this would have been like 1963 or 1965, somewhere in there