I don't think the flute does this piece justice. The original with the string instruments is better. If you have the ability i'd post another one like that.
I think the flute fits quite well, it kind of replace the oboe in the beginning of the original, but I know some people prefer the sound of string instruments, all tastes are in nature
:-)
I agree that the original with cello is great though.
If I had one (and knew how to play it^^) I would certainly have used it ! ;-)
yeah well It's better than nothing so I'm glad you posted it. This is the only version that I can find on youtube.
The reason I feel the string instruments + piano of the original are better is because I feel they capture the sombre mood far better. The flute is too high pitched for me ... not depressing enough. I feel violins, cellos and the like are designed for the slow/depressing type of music. I hate the sound of them being peppy or happy.
hi man, i rarely post on you tube. but i must admit, ive been looking for this track everywhere. ur really good!...do u have the originol mp3? if so can you send it to me? cheers!
hi mate, yeah i would very like your version in an mp3 format. in my opinion its just as good as the originol. i hope this track does end up on of the complimation albums. how would you send the mp3?
For this one, it was not easy to synchronise the piano, and the flute,as I had to play them separately. But I think it was worth it. I love the sound of piano and flute together. I sometimes play the flute with my sister at the piano. It always sounds great !
Bien fait encore! combien d'autres instruments est-ce que tu joues? :) J'apprecie beaucoup ce que tu fais!! Je joue la flûte et le piano et j'aime beaucoup créer la musique pour les choses que j'entends aussi. (Playing by ear)
en fin je l'aime beaucoup encore, j'espère que tu vas ajouter les autres vidéos aussitot que possible :D
(désolé pour ma francais, c'est ma deuxieme langue mais j'aime le practiquée si possible!)
Et bien je joue de la flûte depuis un moment , et le piano quand j'ai le temps. Et vu qu'on m'a offert une guitare à mon anniversaire, je vais certainement commencer à en jouer un peu :)
A part ça j'aimerais bien joué du violoncelle et du violon, mais je vois pas comment j'aurais le temps de tout faire, héhé !
Je suis sur que je fais bien plus de faute en anglais que toi en français ;)
(au cas où playing by ear se traduit jouer à l'oreille, enfin je crois :)
Je joue un peu de guitare aussi (quand je peux utiliser celui de mon frère!) et j'ai acheté un violon que je veux essayer après que ma semestre à université est fini!
Il n'y a aucun probleme avec votre anglais! et merci pour la traduction de Playing by ear, je n'etait pas tout a fait certain si c'etait un traduction directe ou non!
WONDERFUL!!! Please can you send me the mp3 ?? i cannot find this music in any video of youtube!
Tihocan89 3 weeks ago
I can't read French. ;)
lordofseas 2 years ago
@lordofseas it's translated in English below ;-)
burnsasgoauld 2 years ago
*cough* From the shadowy look of it, it's a recorder, not a flute.
lordofseas 2 years ago
@lordofseas well flute is the general category : contains recorder , transverse flute (to which you're reffering I think) even ocarina .
But to be precise , yes, I could have said it's an alto recorder (and I did in video description).
burnsasgoauld 2 years ago
I don't think the flute does this piece justice. The original with the string instruments is better. If you have the ability i'd post another one like that.
GodPaidForMySins 2 years ago
I think the flute fits quite well, it kind of replace the oboe in the beginning of the original, but I know some people prefer the sound of string instruments, all tastes are in nature
:-)
I agree that the original with cello is great though.
If I had one (and knew how to play it^^) I would certainly have used it ! ;-)
burnsasgoauld 2 years ago
yeah well It's better than nothing so I'm glad you posted it. This is the only version that I can find on youtube.
The reason I feel the string instruments + piano of the original are better is because I feel they capture the sombre mood far better. The flute is too high pitched for me ... not depressing enough. I feel violins, cellos and the like are designed for the slow/depressing type of music. I hate the sound of them being peppy or happy.
But to each their own.
GodPaidForMySins 2 years ago
wow you play the flute too!
can you play captain Picard's flute melody?
BorgHub 2 years ago
Joliiii! Chapeau tu gères! ^^ Mais j'arrive pas à trouve à quel moment de la série cette musique intervient ^^ même si elle me dit quelque chose.
En tous cas Bravo à toi!
You rock!
ZOEasMarthaKent 2 years ago
in original it`s cello, istn`t it?
QueenOfOwnage 2 years ago
in the beggining it's oboe (or clarinette not so sure now) , then when Sam materialises her cello, the cello kicks in
burnsasgoauld 2 years ago
Hi! This is beautiful. <3 You're wonderful. :]
ChikSewp 2 years ago
OUa mais tu sais jouer de combien d'instruments ? (oua pas très francais tout ca je crois mdr ) en tout cas c'est vraiment magnifique !
baalounette 2 years ago
hey ibegan wokring out this tune
not that good at listenin by ear tho but ive got some down i think
A E G E A B G E A E G E C B G B
but what you're playing for G sounds different, right?
also i cant get the flute part
appreciate some help with the notes, thanks
PilotBreak 3 years ago
Hello !
You have it quite right : in fact what I play on piano is :
right hand :
A E G E A B G E A E G E C B A B
And my G sound different because at the same time I play with the left hand :
A each time I play A with right hand (except the last one of the loop) and
C each time I play G with the right hand .
As for the flute part , I'll try to write it down one of these days. Hope it helps !
burnsasgoauld 3 years ago
Great music. You are really talented! I wish I could play like that!
ArcVitae 3 years ago
5 stars. Really good.
How many instruments do you play?
Darkicon 3 years ago
Thanks
I play two instruments, piano and flute (recorder)...
oh and a little bit of guitar , but I can't really say I know how to play anything convincing on it yet ,hehe
burnsasgoauld 3 years ago
Woah. That's awesome
boredbutentertained 3 years ago
hi man, i rarely post on you tube. but i must admit, ive been looking for this track everywhere. ur really good!...do u have the originol mp3? if so can you send it to me? cheers!
atif101 3 years ago
Thanks ,
I don't have an orignial mp3 , I got it from the dvd's , but if you want I can send you an mp3 from my version (audio from this video)
I don't think this is present on any released soudtrack yet,but maybe I missed it !
burnsasgoauld 3 years ago
hi mate, yeah i would very like your version in an mp3 format. in my opinion its just as good as the originol. i hope this track does end up on of the complimation albums. how would you send the mp3?
atif101 3 years ago
very nice!
starmingate 3 years ago
Wow, that is really good!!!!!!!!!
andrewpn 3 years ago
Once again, another great performance!!! You could have a great reputation...
patty9595 3 years ago
Can you give me the piano notes please
Apophis88 3 years ago
I have become the complette piano notes from unending
Apophis88 4 years ago
ooh fantastic mixing! I just loved that musical sequence in the episode *happy sigh*
nebulan 4 years ago
Cool. In Memory of Stargate Sg1. We will never forgotten
Apophis88 4 years ago
I find it incredible you can play them so well, I am fast becoming a fan of yours :)
1812flo 4 years ago
Thank you again !
For this one, it was not easy to synchronise the piano, and the flute,as I had to play them separately. But I think it was worth it. I love the sound of piano and flute together. I sometimes play the flute with my sister at the piano. It always sounds great !
burnsasgoauld 4 years ago
Another great song!! :)
1812flo 4 years ago
Bien fait encore! combien d'autres instruments est-ce que tu joues? :) J'apprecie beaucoup ce que tu fais!! Je joue la flûte et le piano et j'aime beaucoup créer la musique pour les choses que j'entends aussi. (Playing by ear)
en fin je l'aime beaucoup encore, j'espère que tu vas ajouter les autres vidéos aussitot que possible :D
(désolé pour ma francais, c'est ma deuxieme langue mais j'aime le practiquée si possible!)
nat
natalia5345 4 years ago
Merci beaucoup !
Et bien je joue de la flûte depuis un moment , et le piano quand j'ai le temps. Et vu qu'on m'a offert une guitare à mon anniversaire, je vais certainement commencer à en jouer un peu :)
A part ça j'aimerais bien joué du violoncelle et du violon, mais je vois pas comment j'aurais le temps de tout faire, héhé !
Je suis sur que je fais bien plus de faute en anglais que toi en français ;)
(au cas où playing by ear se traduit jouer à l'oreille, enfin je crois :)
burnsasgoauld 4 years ago
Je joue un peu de guitare aussi (quand je peux utiliser celui de mon frère!) et j'ai acheté un violon que je veux essayer après que ma semestre à université est fini!
Il n'y a aucun probleme avec votre anglais! et merci pour la traduction de Playing by ear, je n'etait pas tout a fait certain si c'etait un traduction directe ou non!
natalia5345 4 years ago