t.A.T.u All the things she said V Power Live Taiwan 12/10 '05

[soulsister181]

the two are so damn hot *__*

[SpanishGurrl95]

Julia is ugly :Ss

[mangomonster26]

yulia is so hot

[xxxlaurenjadexxx1]

Anybody eles Think "a new t.a.t.u " wouldn't work ???

[NisTV]

5 years later

[JussMe3577]

WOW! no lyp syncing! i love it!

[3cheers4Ger]

Does anybody else think the music sounds SO COOL live?!

[Marlene90210]

I actually really liked Yulia's voice here.. I think it sounds really cool.

[aksteb412011]

this song keeps running through my head...

[darkelf743]

R.I.P Yulia's voice :(

[3cheers4Ger]

I feel so bad for Yulia...That vocal cyst and surgery destroyed her voice...I'll forever miss her clear, good voice.

I'm just glad she and Lena haven't lost their singing/performing passion. :)

[Theknifeman1011]

HAHA THEY SEPERATED THE ASAINS FROM AMERICANS!

[EthMan09]

okay, so if they can actually sing, why do they lip sync more than anything else?

[xXchelsearoxXx]

@EthMan09 "more than anything else" Uhh...Britney Spears has never sang live in her whole life..

[iammiket]

@xXchelsearoxXx She actually has, a lot of times lol (of course she lipsyncs more than she sings however)

[xXchelsearoxXx]

@iammiket Well, you got the point, eh?

[Aurelska]

has anybody noticed that when we do conserts we are calm but in other countrys they are all excited and jumping around

[Seekeration]

Curse Katy Perry

[ExcellenceOfInnova]

They do it great!

[SNXninja]

OMG  johnny sins playin drum 0:20 !!

[ivan7083]

mis novias

[InnocenceAL]

Finally stop the lip sing :D

[Megamajz]

why do yulia have such a rasping voice at every live performence? i mean.. it sounds more lighter on the record.

[Jayden1995]

@Megamajz there old manager (the man that created tatu) made yulia pushed yulia into singing such high pitches which had literally damaged her vocal cords, she had a cyst in her throat and had to undergo surgery.

also as lena said at the start "5 years later". peoples voices change within 5 years

[Megamajz]

@Jayden1995

okeey :)

[bobacue]

I never knew Mr. bean could drum lololol

[IceEyedBlackWolf]

they seemed like they were having an argument at once point. and I do agree with the other post, no wonder why they went separate ways. They're both different on stage

[thedragoonknight]

Poor Yulia's throat was destroyed because of that dumbass Ivan Shapovalov

[jayearz]

Hip hop version on my page

[CaitachuLovesYu]

its liveeee

[RexiRawr]

I haven't heard this song in years and they are still amazing :) I think many artists I listen to are fantastic and they ain't from England many from the US, Japan, Russia etc etc :) xxx

[hjmsimons]

It's quite easy to see how the pair of them differ in this live version.. maybe a few reasons there why they went their different ways in the end.

[SamanthaDragon]

I like it how she yells " WHY? " In the middle of it lol

[p0911130239]

t.A.T.u in Taiwan

[xXchelsearoxXx]

I love how Lena says "5 years later" <3

[DanielKremsner]

this is live

[PequenoMini]

@Xfantasyfox actually theyre making almost all schools in US have 2 or 3 languages at least to pick from, and every students has to have at least one. ( other than english of course)

[locodelhouse]

por que si un cantante de mi país (Rusia por ejemplo) no canta en ingles no puede triunfar cuando se que es y tiene un talento sobrenatural ?bueno, y un favor que os pido,no escucheis a esa mierda de Shakira que aparte de cantar con voz de hombre cada vez se le entiende menos y sus letras tienen menos sentido y coherencia.goodbay brothers

[LoOhaNkeYz]

@locodelhouse

estoy totalmente de acuerdo contigo, shakira es un asco de cantante, aunq no niego q su primer cd fue bueno, pro se fue a pique.. y con respecto a el idioma, tal vez es xq como es la lengua q se habla mas a nivel mundial, no se, es solo mi hipotesis jejj saludos de México ;D

[locodelhouse]

dicho esto quiero dejar claro la situación que vive hoy día el mundo de la música en el cual no puedes escribir ni cantar canciones que no estén en ingles por que si no,estas predestinado al fracaso ya que ninguna discográfica apostara por ti , mientras que yo puedo( y lo hago)escucho canciones en ingles de las cuales no entiendo ni papa pero me gustan, y ahora deberíais haceros una pregunta

[locodelhouse]

estas chicas tienen unas de las mejores voces que yo e podido escuchar, muchas de sus canciones poseen muy buenas letras, y hay que añadir el poco reconocimiento que se les ha dado en el mundo de la música, dejandolas de lado por no querer contribuir a la globalización de la música al ingles y apostar por su propio idioma ya que muchas de sus canciones están en ruso,unas chicas valientes al fin y al cavo

[BrickGrease]

They're lip syncing half of it

[BsophieeeB]

I used to absolutely love this song, and after not listening to it for years, I still know every single word by heart!

[smartjsk]

@BsophieeeB Because this song is classic !

[runstygge]

dont sound so good in the mric... but the sound fucking good

[NimiXchip]

when i was about 13 i started to love the red haired girl^^ ... seriously ... i still love her... your music just changed my life somehow and now i can be the 1001 liker^^

[NimiXchip]

when i was about 13 i started to love the red haired girl^^ ... seriously ... i still love her... your music just changed my life somehow

[Selerdor10]

Wow, they really can sing. Glad this is actually live and not a playback. They sound great.

[youestrume]

Muito bom, mas a ruivinha está usando roupas demais. 

[juultje259]

This is the ONLY live performance i found where they are real singing

but when they sing with ther own voices, it sounds beautifull<3

[NihahCatz]

@juultje259 I have seen one more yesterday...I don't remember the key words I used though but yes you are right live its much better! :)

[Susi6588]

i love this song so much!! >333

[ashe984]

I love this song

[cikalispunks]

i like TATU

[tedoubleu]

Love this song!!!!!!

[DarkFire325]

ok guys i fkin get it stop replying -.-

[Bludhoundz8]

@DarkFire325 Lol, maybe you shouldn't have been so biased and judgemental... especially since you have no evidence whatsoever to back it up....

[DarkFire325]

@Bludhoundz8

Lol well maybe if you read it i asked a question i did'nt state anything

so maybe you should'nt saying things if you cant back it -.-

[serilew]

@DarkFire325 you are aware of the fact that they are not from the us right?

[DeMonDog68]

Ummm yeah that drummer is hot haha

[TalyQuiroga]

This is not enough, she is really tryin' to show that she is singing it when she doesn't... 1:12

[arg2032]

the men of minut 0:30 its bored hahá

[ratnaraj2009]

music and lyrics are two different parts of a song

i love the music...not necessarily understanding wht they tell

coz i dont need to.... music is music..no religion no nation no community

[kikee345]

Are they lesbian????!!!!?!?!?

[Sup3rMegaNerd]

@kikee345 No they aren't.

[SirDragonFruit]

i adore tatu. So talented and unique. Definitely have developed as artists a lot since 2002!

[DarkFire325]

hate to sound racist but why do asians take such a massive intrest in our music they cant even understand it.

sorry if that offended anyone :/

[smartjsk]

@DarkFire325

Because music has no boundary. Besides, I am asian and understand English. Plus, our country ranks no.4 in Foreign Exchange Reserves world wide. You may tell how many people could speak foreign language in my country so that we could make that much money from the world.

[pro194757]

@DarkFire325 there are things called the television and the radio!!!!we have E! ..asia isnt filled with coconut tree's and jungle people~

[Kanine61able]

@DarkFire325 it's called globalisation. :D

[turtlebuttmudd]

@DarkFire325 And all the people who take interest in foreign music who can't understand aren't the same?

I love some Japanese music, and I can't understand one word of it lol.

I even went to see Miyavi live in California =c

[Nessera07]

@DarkFire325 Most Asians are taught English as a second lang. starting from a young age. starting at elementary level

[videos22333]

@DarkFire325

stupid white man :-)

[superara1]

@DarkFire325 thats not a racist thing to say. it must be the beat ha ha.

[yeah6373]

@DarkFire325 ur so stupid, are u aware that many many people out the US speak enlgish... i mean i know 3 languages so i listen to music in 3 different languages. i know u dint try to be racist, but ur stupid as hell...

[TheMathsRider]

@DarkFire325 Why is tatu doing the lyrics in English? They had the song in Russian before...they wanted to expand their chances to get more money...and eventough quite a lot of taiwanese or chinese people are poor...if you count the absolute number of rich people in China and Taiwan...it's good enough...I think it's the same thing in Russia...so just don't ask so stupid question....by the way...I am German

[TheMathsRider]

@DarkFire325 @DarkFire325 Why is tatu doing the lyrics in English? They had the song in Russian before...they wanted to expand their chances to get more money...and eventough quite a lot of taiwanese or chinese people are poor...if you count the absolute number of rich people in China and Taiwan...it's good enough...I think it's the same thing in Russia...so just don't ask so stupid question....by the way...I am German

[MBCFWMike]

@DarkFire325 Russians who sing on Englisch for Asians where is the Problem? That is Globalization...

[Xfantasyfox]

@DarkFire325

First of all, way to sound like a stereotypical ignorant kid. Second of all, you're not sounding racist - you ARE racist. Third, I'm Asian and as you can see, I probably speak and write English better than you can. Fourth, English is widely accepted as the language of business. That being the case, many Asian countries teach English right alongside their own language so that the students end up more or less bilingual. How many people where you live can say they are bilingual?

[Krieghandt]

@Xfantasyfox

quite a few. oh, wait, I live in a part of america where only english speakers are a minority. Spanish and Native American languages have more speakers, and 20% of the ppl here dont speak any english.

[ffacfreak]

@DarkFire325 Well half the American make more gramatical errors than the Asians and just for a record many of the Asian countries has engish as there OFFICIAL language.

[empirikal23]

@DarkFire325 people all over the world from different countries know at least 2 languages, with you native english speakers pussies being the exception, because your little brain can't afford learning more than one. And by the way, TATU are Russian and still sing in English and have been a million times more successful than you would be in 1000 lives.

[Colin2k41]

@DarkFire325 because they like it, and hearing a song you can automaticly say the words too it and they know that they are HUGE and one of the best female artists of all time so why not be happy

[Aurelska]

@DarkFire325 lol i speak all english and i listen to spanish,russian and german music im still wierd

[ShaeyTrell]

LMAO OMG THEY FINALLY SUNG LIVE! They hardly ever sing live.

[fbritobr]

0:45 shes like: wheres the freaking playback? lmao

[pazminoproject]

the only performance where they're not lypsincing this song. YES

[leedsfanalways]

Are they Russian?

[MissAmericanDreamO9]

@leedsfanalways yes, they are russian.

[smartjsk]

@leedsfanalways

Yes, they are.

[Isa100Lokaa]

I love this song

[notoriousnews]

This song is fucking sick.

[TATUbetti]

t.A.T.u. COME BACK PLEASE !!!

I LOVE LENA , I LOVE JULIA , I LOVE t.A.T.u.

Chciałabym chociaż jeden ostatni raz zobaczyć was razem śpiewających tą piosenkę :'((((

[LadySarGAGA]

They're singing amazing live, I don't understand why they had to sing on playback all the time in the past and even in those later days they had to sing on playback but only in Russia...

[filfortugno]

damn russian girls are fine

[giantkiller02]

Lol crazy japs

[nasemisc]

@giantkiller02 not japanese

[serenityxoxo]

@giantkiller02 Those aren't Japanese people. And that was rude.

[giantkiller02]

@serenityxoxo crazy to me is a compliment

[tailback08]

@giantkiller02 this concert took place in Taiwan, and the audience are Taiwanese, fyi crazy bse-ridden brit

[Ellis01234567890]

was the dark haird one ill that day?

[slygirl1117]

@Ellis01234567890 She had a vocal cyst removed in 2003-4.

[xXdreamer4alwaysXx]

finally heard them ACTUALLY sing live! gosh took forever to find this

[jayearz]

remix to this on my page check it out guys let me kno wat u think

[prettykitty111333]

They're so different !

[YHaveUForsakenMe]

are they actually singing for once?! o_o

[3BsAlaska]

how old is this song?

[smartjsk]

@3BsAlaska

The Russian version is in 2001. And the English version is in 2003.

[3BsAlaska]

@smartjsk oh wow this song is older than i thought haha :)

[misszoelikesyou]

@smartjsk the English version came out december 2000..

[BaRRRoslaWa]

@smartjsk English Version is autumn 2002

[xnxmxmxnx]

the right woman damn fails she should go home !

[liltdragon97]

are they gay?

[PoPxRockxPoPxME]

@liltdragon97 lol... they are not, read wikipedia it has all information about em.

[oO0Smallville0Oo]

@PoPxRockxPoPxME Yes, I answered too quickly ! :) I'm back to correct me ! They are best friend !

[YHaveUForsakenMe]

@liltdragon97 They had crushes for each other in high school I believe, so kinda. And they used that in the music industry which got them attention. But they're not lesbians, at least not anymore. I'm not sure. lol But if you ask me, using the whole lesbian thing for their music was probably a good thing because even today lesbians and gays are still looked down upon. If I was lesbian, t.A.T.u would be my hero.

[SPROUSELOVER224]

@YHaveUForsakenMe they did have a thing for each other but not anymore. the one with the black hair -srry bad with names- has 2 kids last thing i knew. and the other one has a bf. they dated for a while though. just the emotions got in the way of their music or what not. I had to look it up to haha

[xXchelsearoxXx]

@SPROUSELOVER224 Nooooooooooooooooooooooooo. The red head did a solo concert and the black haired girl called it "stupid" and that started a whole controversy. Neither of them has kids but the black haired has a bf.

[vanya0785]

@xXchelsearoxXx Yulia has two kids...

[chunky52695]

@xXchelsearoxXx um correection, the red head had kids....

[Nekr0C]

1:15 Nice playback :)

[kyiwest76]

='[ I miss tatu

[RexusFlexus]

its not fuckin playback in this performance. not at any time.

[smithhedgehog]

@RexusFlexus its on; but they are singing

[TheTilly010]

is it me or does it not sound as good?

[myvampireskeeper]

@kreativsteff

Not the whole time, just on notes she can't hit like she used to. She's grown up since she recorded All the Things She Said.

[cytoxix09]

They sing Awsome. How old are they?? It would be nice to meet them in person.

[Willdupe15]

5 years later and the drumer never put a t-shirt on

[againme1]

@Willdupe15 Im not complaining

[chunky52695]

@Willdupe15 i wonder, does he ever get cold? lol

[35erZhood]

how old they are???

[Coyannis]

At last a live concert without lip sync...Idk why they lip sync anyway they got pretty good voices :)

[atara17]

wow. it's much better when they sing it live :DD very nice. :DD

[80kazy]

Super,grat tATu!

[XTheXNogginX]

n1ce 1 :D

[vivigaga10]

t.a.T.u is perfect <3

[tATuFanxRoseOnPlayer]

i love this more than the original

they're 1000000times better live than on record

and tehir records are divine

so i dont really have a word to describe it but... perfect! ^^

[Ayamatsuura17]

In an interview she said she had divorced Parviz

[lover0257]

jeez i love this song...

[Jsilvers10]

I think it's so much better when they don't lipsynch! <3

[lekara3219]

@Jsilvers10 agreed : )

[Ayamatsuura17]

yessssssssssssssssssssssssssss­sss



[Ayamatsuura17]

yulia is free, has no husband fuck u Parviz....

[vampskeldragon]

@Ayamatsuura17 wait what?

[PolieAutumn]

@Ayamatsuura17 how do you know? :OO

[RammsteinSniper]

LOL look at that dude in the middle at 0:33 he s like thinking i want to go home and eat sushi :D

[EthMan09]

holy crap! A live performance that is actually more than 0% live(vocal-wise). I was starting to think if they could actually sing since they seem to lip sync a lot, except for here

[MissSweetBee]

I love them <3

[IfUSeekBritneySpears]

not a fan but i agree that they can sing good live!

[tatulover2120]

i wished they kissed like they always did :(

[ChloisMikayla09]

We can tell who wears the pants in that relationship.

[tfsasori]

They're awesomee live.

[theonlykickasskid]

WOOOOO!!!! no Lip Syncing this time!! hahaha

[MaisiKaulitz]

When did they perform this? :D

[smartjsk]

@MaisiKaulitz Please read the video title. Thanks.

[GenerationxPlastik]

They sound like they're on drugs.

[SlashTheCat13]

@GenerationxPlastik one of them had some sort of vocal sist thingy or some shit like that at some point. Maybe it was around this time

[1992geop]

Does remember this song

[davidneposedy]

en taiwan tatu sigue pegando fuerte, tatu por siempre

[xmenlover2003]

they weren't touching like usaual.

[Charlie28340]

J'adore les asiatique a fond dedans !! C'est un super groupe j'adore !

[Charlie28340]

Kiss ??? =( !!!

[1NightwishManiac1]

Ehh. They used to love each other...And the color of their voices was much better..this is bullshit! 

[ilMondoDiPattyBest]

ma sono senza voce o cosa?? O___O :|

[Saramausi1996]

islam is the only true religion.

[laudealizeejacotey]

here are two american Angels from the World Wide Web and for Barack O'Bama

In - God - We - Trust ^^

I love them

[ComeToTheFeastOfWar]

I'm actually pretty surprised they are so... bad live singers, really. But that explains why they are always lip syncing!