Added: 5 years ago
From: mastert316
Views: 3,826,463
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (7,631)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Nirvana's version is better.... :)

  • nirvarna .....thats why bowie is still going after how many years???????lots that how many..... a total icon and still gets the crowds and woman...fact..... there will only ever be 1 david bowie .

  • ORIGINAS I'S ORIGINAL!!!! :)P

  • v jeho podání je to jak vystřižené z travesti show

  • Yah Nirvana's is way better sorry Bowie...

  • @joesulub ... DIE

  • One of my favorite Bowie songs

  • THIS IS SHET

    

  • In a word, CLASS!

  • nirvana made it better

  • i love this song! i love Bowie

    , but i think ilike nirvana's cover of it is better. Kurts voice just draws you in cause he puts so much emotion into it

  • It's cool you're doing a Nirvana song.

  • kurt cobain cover is best ;)

  • fuck me sideways... david bowie is handsome ;) that voice makes you melt into a different dimention yes that doesnt make much sense but yeah. i could close my eyes and just listen to this

  • This is Horrible !

  • @Manito165 eh heh? bowie did this song originally in the 70s and i fell in love at the age of 16. YOU are an idiot

  • simply amazing , id love for a reunion tour ( yeah it feels sad saying that but :( ) I just want to see him live I'm sure hes still got it , (course hes still got it) but I guess he's got a kid to look after and his getting older.

  • BYE BYE BIN LADEN!

  • God, he is amazing!!! I love him!

  • both are very talented, both versions are good, i prefer bowie's album version better but im not gonna go to the nirvana video just to post that, im not that lame

  • People are comparing version without stating the obvious first. Nirvana's version was unplugged

  • no me gusta

  • this is a beautiful song

  • fuck Nirvana

  • I prefer Nirvana version =)

  • I love David Bowie! He was the one who inspired me to get into guitar and start singing again. And i'm only 14! ^_^

  • Try singing along to this version and see if you don't have an accent.LOVE IT.

  • I think Kurt's version might have re-interested David in the song both great versions

  • He's never lost control! Definietly :)

  • This music is Ridiculous SEXY... Latino Heat Baby...!!!

  • Nirvana cover is good

    But BOWIE simply is God

  • @judasackiss dont compare them man, its a wonderful song and its not worth the comparison

  • @judasackiss oh yes, oh yes he is

  • @judasackiss now all bow down

  • this sing is definetly better in nirvanas way thums up if you agreee :D

  • I came to this video just to see how it compared to Nirvana's version! Thumbs up if you did the same!

  • @marco81709 e.0 How Nirvana compared to David Bowie.

  • @CliffandLeonardo I think that Nirvana's version is LIGHT YEARS better than this. However, that doesn't mean this is bad. Kurt Cobain was simply one of the greatest singers ever.

  • @marco81709 You think ? Bowie was cool, is cool and will be cool forever and one thing you can guarantee is that he will never blow his brains out.

  • @zargonstaff BUT, we are not talking about their mental health or about things they have done in the past are we? We are comparing their music, and my opinion is that Kurt's version is better than David's...by alot

  • @marco81709 i actually came to this videos because its an original just not the best version.

  • @marco81709 no if you knew your music

  • @marco81709 - and no contest - see the master at work!

  • i don't know what everyone's so angry about. I think it's cool that Bowie's a Nirvana fan.

  • @VonnegutFrusciante

    haahahaha.You know that pisses him (Bowie) off.

    He said once in an interview that he gets really mad when people say that it's nirvana's song

    Nirvana's cover is really better, though

  • @slcdario i was only trolling, i'm a huge bowie fan and i hate kurt cobain.

  • @VonnegutFrusciante U still RRRRRRR Troling

  • @VonnegutFruscianteOr the other way around:)

  • this one goes to nirvana. bowie sings it gay

  • @tigi6915 How do you "sing gay"? That makes absolutely no sense. Also, If it weren't for Bowie, Nirvana's cover would never have existed you moron.

  • I don't recall hearing this get much airplay on radio,who r the idiots who choose what music we like?

  • 320 people didn't sell their world yet

  • Is that frank black of the pixies back there on the keyboard?

  • @mbran111 Nope, it's Mike Garson.

    How do I know this, you ask? The liner notes in the booklet of the dvd ;D

  • @mbran111 Hehe At a first sight I thought it so... but he's Mike Garson

  • Nirvana does this better

  • everyone stop bitching. the nirvana cover was just as good as this, they are just different

  • Comment removed

  • 320 people are deaf and jealous that we get to enjoy the god of music.

  • Oh but my kids (students) dug it. They were excited to hear Bowie's version.

  • GUIRO SOLO

  • that fishlike thing he was stroking with a stick is a Guiro,pronounced weiro by US citizens,I play one.. a lonng long time ago :)

  • this version far exceeds the Drug slowed Nirvana version

  • I noticed a spanish rythym in Bowie's version,the cymbals

  • minds of mush and democrats use it

  • Yep, my guitar student's recently mentioned The Man Who Sold The World "by Nirvana". They were surprised that it was written by Bowie in the 70's; My favorite album by him.

  • @SenseOfReal kids r idiots that's why they voted democrat and Obama

  • Great song by an all time great artist, Nirvana's cover is good, but Bowie's is the original and best, plus he wrote it.

  • Wow this lady did a great job paying tribute to Nirvana, RIP Kurt, you were a genious

  • @Thescreensaverr

    Fail Troll is Fail

  • @tomer1224 Im not a Troll I'm a Goblin, and Im here to watch Jareth butcher a Nirvana classic

  • @Thescreensaverr

    O.k... Fail Goblin is Fail

  • Nirvana sux ass,the most overrated band in fucking history of R`n`R!!!

    now kids go smell like teen spirit and gtfo out of Bowies videos!!!

  • Nirvana's cover is superior.

  • Bowie was 57at this performance and he KILLS the song PERFECT> and a GREAT band....BEST MUSICIANS he toured with

  • it was a Lulu song wasn't it? JOKING

  • his singing voice makes him sound like a douche....

    not saying its a bad sond.....

  • GÊNIO!!!

    

  • i got a bit horny. wow amazing :)

  • good cover

  • @Ibakecookiess

    Whot?..

    Is David Bowie's song.

  • @Ibakecookiess It's not a cover...this is david bowies song and noone else's.

  • @Ibakecookiess

    OMG... :/

    You are a weirdo...

  • Bowie's "the man who sold the world" is NOT a version! it's the original!!

  • I've always loved this song; it seems very intriguing and mysterious. So Bowie.

  • @rallyingtcp has a proble with Bowie because @rallyingtcp secretly is a homosexual and is confused by it. Just come out of the closet already.

  • HAVE A LISTEN TO US, IF WE GET ENOUGH VIEWS WE WILL BE ON RADIO 1!!

  • @rallyingtcp bowie is fuckin transexual

  • @66402755 I think you are a fuckin transdouche and I hope you get the flesh eating disease on your anus you ass clown.

  • @lmrenton fuck urself..

  • A british man with white teeth.....pretty rare.

    I love this song!

  • The whole "The Man who sold the world" album is awesome

  • i never listen to this type of music but i liked it a lot!

  • gay

  • @RHCPMetallicatube yes, yes you are

  • Bowie rarely, if ever, performed this song live . I think he partly chose to re-introduce it into his repertoire in order to show all those deluded Nirvana fans out there that he, not Kurt Cobain, was the one who wrote and originally recorded this song back in 1970. For me, Bowie's version is the definitive and best.

  • @ThefightingCelt I'm a deluded Nirvana fans, and yes, i heard nirvana first, but i knew it was a cover, you can just tell, its not their style at all, not their lyrics, or even music style.

  • @stude444 I'm a huge Bowie fan, My friend is a huge Nirvana fan---I started performing this on gutiar and singin.. he entered and I stopped and told him it's a Bowie song that nirvana covered and he said yeah I knoe Curt says that at the beginning. End of story huh,..

  • @Spirou12345678 "This is a song by David Bowie, we're probably gonna screw it up"

  • Bowie is freakin' LEGENDARY! <3<3

  • 317 people have no conception of true art.

  • Nirvana version is much better

  • Awsome! Bowie rules! :)

  • my version is BEST ,I SOLD THE WORLD!:))

  • nickleback the sigh of the apocolypse theeeeee END IS NEAR!!!!!!!!!!

  • better than his own original i think

  • the both versions have the same awesome level

  • People generally like the version they heard first.

  • kabluwi, you duche bag, Cobain didn't write his own songs, he copied them, the man who sold the world(1974) was written by bowie stupid not Cobain, and look at the songs produced in the 80's, most of Cobain music used the riffs and lyrical content almost exclusively, so if you want to debate moron at least have the knowledge! I am a music historian, what's your excuse? S.T.F.U!

  • @cyberseanx Kurt did not copied, he just covered Bowie's song.

  • @wcarrillod

    Actually, he raped Bowie's song.

  • @AlmightyMercel Indeed.

  • Sou assinante do canal de alguém (sim).Tenho que escrever no canal desta pessoa que envia videos(não, mas querendo pode fazê-lo).ou tenho que dizer que você é o assinante para o meu canal ou direto [para o meu canal?(Não, nada pode assinar tudo que quiser sem depender de nada e de ninguém.

  • ok so Lennon and Bowie are the greatest individuals in this field

  • Me gusta mas la version con Klaus Nomi, la verdadera........

  • Fuckin Class my friends Fuckin Class!!!!...sorry but the profanity could not be helped....p.s. like others have said, comparing david and kurt aint cool...dont think either of them would would dig it..as both are/were top of their respective games ;-))

  • Awesomenesssssssssss!!!:D

  • I fucking hate Kurt, whenever he performs it's like he's not trying.

  • @HornedWarMachine

    Yet he still succeeds, also, don't say you "hate" people, how would John Lennon feel? Give piece a chance.

  • @hobodude68 I don't like Lennon either.

  • @HornedWarMachine

    Fair enough, just don't spread hate.

    Try to love one another right now.

  • @hobodude68 I don't and never will love idiocy. It's the one thing that plagues today's society.

  • @HornedWarMachine

    Because you've met everyone in the world...So you can call "Everybody" idiocy? False accusations.

  • @hobodude68 Yeah, almost everyone. I'd say it's true.

  • @HornedWarMachine

    Smart ass are we?

  • @hobodude68 Nope, you just learn that people aren't that different from one another.

  • David Bowie,I Love You,one of your biggest fans in Canada,Deathnotes mom,Barbara:))))

  • Nao me canso de ver este vídeo! The best!

  • I like Bowies version it sounds great. The Nervana version is good as well.

    To throw a wrench in the works I realy like Jordis Ungas version as well. They are all great but they are all different and stand on thier own.

  • I caught this tour at the Berkeley community theater. Feels like he's kinda retired now, oh well, I saw three tours, all thrilling.

  • Kurt was awesome but Bowie's original is better, but thats just my opinion. I think Kurt would agree too though that the original is better, the reason to cover something isn't usually to make it better its to add your own style too it, but this song is one of the greatest ever. Its like covering Hey Jude and saying its better. Its not, but if its different and well done then its worth its own.

  • 1 of my favourites:)

  • I have the vintage live performance of this song, sung by David Bowie at the Saturday nigth Live show, introduced by a young Martin Sheen. I cant seem to get it uploaded. It would be smashing to show this. Am I doing something wrong? Cheers

  • Lol black guy on drums just like in africa

  • @karanjhalaguy16578 racist much ?

  • DANCE MAGIC DANCE!!

  • Sorry but David sounds gay in this I give him credit for writing this song but Kurt Cobain did it wayyyyyyyyy better

  • @deathknightR The song is just amazing in general. They're both pretty much identical though, minus the vocals

  • I like to listen David Bowie and Kurt.

    That's all the english I can write sorry

  • David bowie is an original badass, and Kurt is the same for doing the cover

  • And he's still sexy. :) In fact, I would say that he's sexier now than he was when he was younger. He's such a beast with long hair! <3

  • ew. don't trip. they're both great musicians and whether you like to believe it or not kurt cobain was the epitome of talent. paul mccartney watched the unplugged in nyc performance of nirvana and said "(kurt) is one of the most talented people to set foot on earth- and that's a lot coming from someone who's worked with john lennon"

    jesus, just stfu and like the song itself and just be thankful miley cryus isn't covering it

  • Bowie is such a badassss. The original is always better than the covers.

  • This version is better than Kurt version but i like boot versions...

  • What is wrong with you people..How can you even try to compare a poser musician such as Cobain (copied most of his music from 80's covers) with the genius of David Bowie who was making modern music back in the late 60's while the rest where still being hippies. Like I always said people lost there taste for real musicians in the 90's and haven't got it back yet! Dont ever compare masters with hack jobs..especially heroin junkies with no talent! give me a break! No taste, no brains!

  • @cyberseanx Poser? How was he a poser? David is more of a poser than Kurt, Kurt actually rote his own songs, so don't say he copied it. Dude, don't bother comparing, or saying one is better than the other, theyre both amazing, and be grateful that Beiber hasn't covered this great song

  • @kabluwi David Bowie wasn't a poser, he did what he wanted, wore what he wanted and didn't care what people thought. He could pull off any style because he had pure class.

    Don't get me wrong, Kurt Cobain was a good musician but, in my opinion, he had nothing on Bowie's writing ability.

  • @TheTidders Jurt did what he wanted too, and yeah Bowies got great writing talents, but Nirvanas songs have just as much, or even more meaning to them than a lot of Bowies work

  • What the hell is wrong with you people..How can you even try to compare a poser musician such as Cobain (copied most of his music from 80's covers) with the genius of David Bowie who was making modern music back in the late 60's while the rest where still being hippies. Like I always said people lost there taste for real musicians in the 90's and haven't got it back yet! Dont ever compare masters with hack jobs..especially heroin junkies with no talent! give me a break! No taste, no brains!

  • I like kurt's cover better

  • All of you comparing David bowie and nirvana, has anyone noticed how well the chick here is playing the bass in the end? Kurt was Kurt and David Bowie is David Bowie. Different people. End of story.

  • More Genius from the most important artist of the past 50 years. Keep going my son!!!

  • bowie is a genius. cobain is a genius.

    bowie actually liked kurt's cover and said he was just upset that he never got the chance to ask kurt why he decided to cover this song before he killed himself.

    it's a great song.

    just be glad freaking miley cyrus didn't cover this song and mess it up like she did with the runaways music :P

  • @SeaAboveSky I think David Bowie said he was upset that he never got to work with him before he died, but I could be wrong

  • cheap cover of Justin Bieber

  • This is such a fun version! Love it, quiet different from his dark version of the 70's!

    I love when Bowie changes his voice and has fun with his old work!

  • Great performance, i've made a cover of it too, please check it out: ?v=0Y1n6DJqG2g

  • Kurt who?

  • everytime i hear you david i go to a new universe

  • Dublin! Twas cool, not as cool as Rotterdam though

  • I prefer Nirvana's cover of the song.

  • @asspirate123456 i loled at your massive fail - bowie covered this song, not nirvana. rong way round idiot

  • @charliehenryrufus Bad news, sir.... Bowie's album "The Man Who Sold The World" came out in 1970, when Kurt Cobain was just... three years old.

  • Thanks for helping me tell of that retard that doesn't understand what a cover is, brentoman.

  • @brentoman well DUH.. kurt obviously covered the song as a 3 year old

  • The Nirvana version isn't bad I'm quite surprised to say but the original on the album is best so 70s so weird

  • Bowie Wrote it, but Kurt's unplugged owns it. BTW, that was the best Kurt ever sang IMO.

  • 316 people are ignorant nirvana fanboys

  • idiots on this post who think Nirvana did this song originally or any other comments about Bowie's "style" on this song. There is no "style" on this song you f'ing tools, Bowie did it originally, it's his, he owns it. If anyone else covers it, then you can talk about "style". Until then, STFU imbeciles.

  • i know this band for 2 minutes now, and i love the music!

  • i perfer kurts version better. i feel like overall his voice sounds better when singing this BUT bowie sang w/ deeper meaning

  • love it!!!