you should be ashamed of yourself. Arafat himself has said that he was already plotting more attacks on Israel on the plane ride home from Oslo. I could give hours of dissertation on why each of the points presented here are either completely false or are presented in an incredibly one sided fashion. Unfortunately youtube only gives me 500 characters. You are a disgusting human being and should hate yourself. I cannot force you to stop spreading your lies. Just know, you are a monster.
That entire film is PREPOSTEROUSLY ONE SIDED utter propaganda.Like looking at a boxing match where EVERY angle shows only one boxer absorbing hits but meting out none.No mention that there was NEVER EVER a country known as "Palestine",that huge tracts of land were simply occupied by migrant Arab squatters. Protected hiways and fences were VERY obviously placed to block radical Muslim suicide bombers and that if "annexation" and "eviction" were the goal, the path would be VERY different...
The arabs want to convince the world the Israelis and Jews are the aggressors and killers, while at the same time trying to cause the world to forget the first massacre, Hebron massacre they committed against Jews,
The Hebron massacre refers to the killing of sixty-seven Jews on 23 and 24 August 1929,
while trying to make people forget that over one million jews were forced to flee arab and muslim lands to save themselves....many died but thanks to G-d many fled and survived.
You can NOT be an accupier of your own land. West Bank has always been Jewish, you can't walk a mile and not come accross a Jewish ancient site. Also, the land is not claimed by Jordan who lost it to Israel. At best West Bank is a disputed trritory. Jews have a claim and nomadic arabs who have no long term connection are also making a claim. The only solution is the transfer of arabs to Jordan.
@ 3:45 palestinian refugees, why are these still refugees ? and live in refugee camps? the last refugee camp in israel was dismantled in 1959, but their neighbour countries keep these prisoners (it's an arab resolution) they won't give them full citizenship like Israel did. there are still refugee camps in palestinian controled areas. BTW this movie doesn't deal with the entire context...why is that?
I just watched this video on dutch public tv. Frankly, it's nothing new. Everybody living outside Israel and USA (where media and demographics are affiliated one way or another), including majority of Jews, condemn Israel's human rights violations (policy, not exception), and warm crimes.
As for suicide bombing, it's a means (for lack of more effective conventional weapons that Israel has), not a goal. Cluster bombs used by Israel, kill more innocent people, so don't be distracted by symbolism.
There are truthful statements in this film but I don't like the excessive, crude, and inappropriate emotive music. It would have been better to let the facts speak for themselves
Second - I don't give a shit about your family - Pals made their bed, now let them sleep in it.
Third - I'm not a nazi (love how you capitalize the word nazi lol).
Fourth - Maybe the pals would have better living conditions if Hamas used the billions in foreign aid they recieve each year for infrastructure instead of weapons.
Finally, Arabs who actually live in Israel have more rights and a better standard of living than any other arab shithole.
@boskinator well, i`m glad that israel is building that wall, it will be the biggest prison for the jews and zionist,at least if you are hit by a tsunami?? you have no where to run??,, but the irony in building the wall shows that jews like to live in concentation camps,so why blame the germains??PS , i dont know if you are a jew?? but if you love israel, why dont you live there?? or are you scared to be stoned by kids??or is it to warm for a canadian??
The pals have the keys to their own destiny. They can stop the daily rocket and mortar attacks on Israel, recognize its right to exist and stop FUCKING WHINING ALREADY. It was not Israel who chose the corrupt Arafat to lead (and rob) them, now was it?
How dare you compare Gaza with the Holocaust...apples and oranges, you mental midget.
Also I know English may not be your first language but I never wrote you were a westerner, I wrote "the same Westerners retards like yourself insist", that is, "the same Westerners (pause) THAT retards like yourself insist". A subtly you might not understand.
It was the Irgun terrorists who FOUGHT the British, forcing the partition plan through. The British supplied and trained the Arab legion, enemies of the Jews, while preventing Jewish immigration during the holocaust and confiscating Zionist weapons. It was private Jewish donations that bought the guns (mostly German), not goyim. Idiot. You need to do a little reading, asserting that "they did and still do" flies in the face of the facts and reveals your turbidity and stupidity.
Crack open a book sometime. US "support" (bribery and coercion) of Israel didn't begin until 1973, around the same time they started giving money to Egypt. The US gives more money to Arabs than to Israel. The US forced Israel to give up the Sinai, an area of both historic and geographical (depth of defense) importance to Israel, given aid to Egypt, Jordan, and Saudi Arabia, enemies of Israel, and bribes Israel into appointing court Jews to do their bidding. Some friends all right.
Thank G-d Rabin (y"sh) is dead. Giving the Land of Israel to the Arabs is no different than giving it to the Canaanites, a blasphemous act which warrants the death penalty.
@1200strong could you tell me why it is taking the jews and zionist 3000 years to build a peaceful homeland? ah?? maybe they kill anyone who has a reasonable hope??? than again jews been assasinating prophets and massenger through out their history,,why not Rabin??
Actually not at all. Did the UN come and defend Israel after the partition? No they watched and expected it to be destroyed. In fact the Jews had to SNEAK weapon in to fight the Arabs. Not to mention the 1947 "borders" were and are completely indefensible. 1948 was to be the last year of the Holocaust, but the Jews defied the same Westerners retards like yourself insist "made" Israel. Britain gave away 85% of the land promised to the Jews. It's the world vs Israel, battleground Jerusalem.
Psychopathic? You make me laugh. Have you even been to Israel? It's the only sane, productive, and free country in the entire middle east.
Israelis do not want to exterminate anyone, so please stop using the buzz words "Nazi" and "ethnic cleansing" for shock value. If the Israelis wanted Arabs dead, why would they allow them to live in Israel, with more rights and freedoms than they would get in any of the surrounding arab countries?
Keep believing the propagandic filth you are being fed by your imam.
There never was a "Palestine", as far as indigenous arabs go. Jews existed in the area, on and off, for over 5 milennia! Look it up, habibi.
In 1948, equal land was given to both Arabs and Jews...but who decided to attack? Oh yeah, it was the indigenous arabs, with the help of the surrounding arabic nations.
Palestinians don't want peace...they want dead Jews. They want an all-arab, all-muslim middle east.
Israel has already given land for peace - what do you think the Gaza pullout was??? What about giving back the Sinai to Egypt for peace?
Find me one other nation, in all of recorded history, that has given back land acquired in a conflict.
Israel has bent over backwards for peace - the pals and the rest of the surrounding arab/muslim world simply do not want "dirty jews" in their midst. Period.
The wall is a big mark of racism from the israeli community against the palestinians. nothing in the Torah suggests zionism, there is nothing in international law that says it is okay to be racist, nothing in international law says it is okay to kill people and still their rights to life. Israel is only doing what the Nazis did to the jews, which was recognized after. If anything, the jewish community should have opposed such actions, not commit the harm that was done to it to others
Israel is not putting "palestinians" on trains, shipping them to concentration camps, working them to death or executing them in gas chambers and ovens, performing horrible experiments on the elderly, the infirm, women and children or stealing all of their possesions (including gouging out the cold caps from their teeth after they die).
this is the biggest peace of crap i have ever read in my entire life. clearly, u have no idea how it affects the people, and clearly, u only see the israeli side, not seeing the abuse that the people are getting in the palestinian areas. i am not speaking because i believe this video, i speak on the behalf of people i know, who experienced it. they are totally equal to nazi actions, no person in the right mind set would believe this bullshit u r saying, unless they are being brainwashed by crap
how have they given land for peace, when they decided to go to gaza in the first place. u say that having the wall is stopping the suicide bombers, yet, the attack on gaza was said to be defense.. they clearly wanted to get rid of the palestinians. U clearly have no idea of the history of the land either, no idea who the first jews are, no idea how it was like before 1948. i would strongly encourage u to actually read some history- will ya? u're too brainwashed to actually dare and read truth
I'm not a historian, i have no specific versions of history i;d like to know, but i'm definately more open minded to know the truth about a current situation and understand the history from people who experienced the negativity of such terrible situations, and not just accept what the media is feeding the public
"I don't read books, and I'm not educated. I believe what I see on the BBC and al-Jazeera...and I don't particularly like Jews or Israel. I make moral judgements with my heart and intuition, and dispose of any kind of documented truth or history, or fact. I see people suffering, so Israel MUST be at fault, right? I mean, did you see those poor children???"
You should not speak of that which you have no clue. Period.
excuse me? are you accusing me of anti-semitism based on the fact that i do not like the israeli way of conducting their "peace"?... you are surely wrong "boskinator" whatever the fuck u wanna be identified as. first off... your claims are ones of irrational and are clearly manipulated by the idea of anyone hating israel or its actions as being anti-semitic. let me tell you one thing, i don't even watch al-jazeera, bbc, or anything of the sort, i actually interview ppl with experience. "period"
Yeah? And how many Israelis have you interviewed? I'll bet you've never even SEEN a Jew.
You're suprised that the Israeli people hate palestinians? When they bomb them daily, perpetrate disgusting suicide bombings aimed DELIBERATELY at civilian innocents, when they indoctrinate their children FROM INFANCY to hate, kill, and worship martyrdom?
Never mind the constant threats from the despotic surrounding arab/muslim dictatorships.
Are you really that surprised that they erected that wall?
ACTUALLY.... i have met many jews, some who are even ANTI-ISRAEL... jews who do not support israel.. and i met those who do support israel, but they have NEVER been there, and they can not say anything because they have never been there, because they know nothing about it. Those who did go there harrassed me and everyone who was against israel. if we do not accept israel, we are harrassed, and if it was a palestinian, the harrassment is twice as bad, so knock off ur bullshit there, alright?
Palestinians are the shit-disturbers of the world. They do not know their own history, and they are infused with the delusion that something is owed to them. They cannot demonstrate peacefully - look up vids here on YT of them holding plackards reading "RIP HITLER", etc.
It's not Israel's fault pals have been led astray by corrupt leaders (Arafat stole 100s of millions of $ in foreign aid to pad his personal bank account).
This conflict is NOT about land - it's about Jew-hatred.
gosh u're so out of it and have no idea what this is really about. it is NOT jew hatred, it is about the land. clearly, u do not even know why this conflict even started, u clearly do not know Palestinians know their history. If you think it is about Jew hatred, u are clearly mislead. It is not the main reason for conflict, Jew hatred is obviously a principle you have been brought up to think is what is happening. Palestinians do not hate jews, they hate zionists, and there is a difference there
Jews and arabs lived side by side relatively peacefully before 1948.
Once Israel was given statehood (and equal land was alotted to the arabs, the surrounding arab countries rallyed together in a show of unity to rid the middle east of the jew. Only, the Jews defended themselves and built a modern, thriving country in the meantime.
Up to now, history has repeated itself, over and over, with arabs/muslims attacking and Israel repelling them.
Funny - you haven't addressed the topic of Hamas' terror. Why is that? Are you blind? Is your head in the sand? Do you have blinkers on?
I, on the other hand, can see the big picture with regards to the Pals. Generations have been brainwashed into thinking that it's Israel's fault that they live in destitution, when in reality, it is the fault of their zealoutrous leaders who teach them to hate and kill and commit suicide for the "cause". Sadly, they are puppets of Iran and Syria.
Your inane comparison between the Israeli wall and what the Nazis did to the world is nauseatingly naive, and is a grave insult to those who suffered and died at the hands of the Nazis.
Instead of "interviewing" people, why don't you go Auschwitz (or any of the other concentration camp "museums" in Europe. Open a history book. Go to Israel. See what it's like. Learn about current political affairs - maybe you'd find out that Iran and Syria are waging war against Israel thru the pals n hezbollah
i am not insulting ANY one who died in the Nazi regime, i recognize their deaths, and it is a terrible shameful time for those who were affected by it. on the other hand, Israel is doing the same thing to the Palestinians without having as much media outlets see it because Israel has the power and support from the Americans and the British, since they wanted control in the middle east anyways. I am a political science student, i am learning this, and the last few things there, make no sense FYI!
Yes you have, by comparing a wall that keeps out SUICIDE BOMBERS to the horrors perpetrated by the Nazis.
Your professors are either biased or ignorant (they usually go hand in hand).
So what - you think the Jews control the media? Try watching BBC, CBC, al-Jazeera, CTV and tell me that they are not slanted towards the palestinian agenda. There's propaganda on both sides,no doubt.
Bottom line: the people of Israel want to live in peace amid a sea of arab/muslim zealots who want them DEAD.
You do not make any sense - I guess you're being brainwashed by your so-called "professors".
Answer this question for me: is Israel systematically rounding up all pals, putting them on trains to concentration camps, working them to death or executing them in ovens and gas chambers, carrying out horrific experiments on children, women and the elderly and stealing all of their money and putting it in swiss bank accounts (this includes the dead's gold teeth fillings)?
The wall works great! When was the last time a crazed shahid blew him/her/itself up in Israel?
Calling this an Apartheid wall is an insult the the indigenous population of South Africa that actually suffered at the hands of their white oppressors. They did not carry out suicide bombings or fire mortars and rockets daily, as Hamas does.
See the difference???
Fuck Hamas - until they recognize Israel, put down their weapons and stop ALL attacks, there will never be peace. Israel must defend.
Terrorist Zionist Israel was founded on terror, exists on terror and its evil nature cannot be preserved without terror. The great crimes committed against the Palestinian people by the Jewish Zionist who today run Israel .Zionist Israel stole the Palestinian land, and for over 60 years terrorized its inhabitants, tortured and murdered those who resisted. these Jewish extremists control American politics, your government, your media, and your consciences.
The terrorist Israeli State is a non-state It never has been a state. it never will be a state . it is an occupation of land, an occupation that must end. The time has come to say "Get Out!" This land is not yours! This land belongs to the Palestinians It will always belong to the Palestinians. It has never been your land! Stop your murdering! Stop your genocide! Stop your terror! Go back to Europe and America where you came from.
I know that I am shocking many of you who are hearing this for the first time. I am sure some of you are thinking that this cannot be true! Just go to Google and write ( Moed Kattan 17a ) you will find yourself what I mean ,truth and nothing except truth .
Look at Some Teachings of the JEWISH Talmud, Where a JEW Should Do EVIL.
Moed Kattan 17a : If a JEW is tempted to do EVIL,he should go to a city (GAZA) where he is not known and do the EVIL there.
Anyone needing more proof of this EVIL massacre should simply visit some of the photos of the most recent holocaust against the Palestinians Christian and Muslim alike.
The Zionist Jews have now got most of the Americans so deceived and so blinded and so deafened by their propaganda,that they follow along,tag along,like they are on a leash.Gentile dogs is exactly what the Zionist Jews call the"Goyim",and they are certainly on the leash now,trotting along right behind,assisting the anti-Semitic Jews promote the Godless STATE of Israel and her MURDERERS.going everywhere the Zionist Jews go, and doing exactly as they want them to do.
Israel has learned from history and created modern day concentration camps. Too bad that they have learned the wrong lesson from their sad history. I wish peace and independence to occupied Palestine.
t4705mb6...why are you contradicting yourself you fool?? you say there is no God yet you use the term "hell" in ur argument! so believe in the heavens and hell yet choose not to believe in the creator???
Great documentary, thanks. Israeli hasbara is spinning itself dizzy saying and doing anything to prevent the objective story of zionism from being told.
WW2 was not fought so Jewish people could put Palestinians in concentration camps. We watch Palestinians wither away in death camps, people piled upon people, filth, disease and death everywhere. The children will battle Goliath. A Palestinians future is to fight honorably, defend and free their people from Israeli persecution. Dozens of movies and documentaries are churned out using WW2 Concentration camp pictures and films - Never Again! Tell that to the Palestinians; Shame on the WW2 Allies.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
before fatah/hamas took over palestinian life there were no fences/borders/checkpoints. palestinians traveled anywhere they wanted. their unemployment was less than 5%. they had israel national health insurance in israeli hospitals. their world turned into a prison
because fatah/hammas theological gangsters sent suicide bombers, and even fired over 7,200 rockets into israel since 2005.
Since there is no "god" or "gods" & NEVER EVER has been, what in hell is REALLY going on?
Well, this has to do with using myth on very stupid & childlike people who refuse to think for themselves & LOVE to be led around by the nose. They want to "belong" so join a CULT for power & money. (Its clled selfish & GREEDY!)
Zionists simply stole Palestine along with British & U.S. help & are systematically murdering the indiginous population...because they FEEL LIKE IT.
The thing i wanna know is how can one not see the truth after watching this?????
i mean when one SUPER POWER takes over a country with missiles that were made in the stone age u know its gona be one sided...the palistenian ppl deserve to live there lives in peace not in constant maham.....one min ur living and the next min ur house is demolished and ur olive trees witch take at least 8 years to grow are distroyed in less than 5mins i mean come on ppl please look in hearts and see the truth....
wow its really sad how the Jews are doing what has been done to them... and isnt it written in the Torah that Jews should not own any land but rather should live amongst all Nations....hmmm and about sucide bombers.. i really dont think they are a big issue here, someone has to fight for their land... one mans terrorist is another mans freedom fighter.
Israel will not inherit the promised land until the next Joshua(Yeshua Mashiach) returns which requires the present situation to come to pass. Praise Yahweh Elohim for He shall send His Son and put an end to all foolish man made leaderships when half of the city goes into exile and is encompassed by armies.
Can all please respect other peoples opinion, ive only uploaded these vids to stimulate discussion. any obscene messages, whether directed against muslims or jews, will be deleted and user blocked. Thnx
Why is it not mentioned that Kfar Etzion land was purchased by Jewish settlers in 1927. They were driven out by Arabs. Settling in again, they were again driven out. A third attempt ending in the Kfar Etzion massacre in which most of the Jews were murdered by Arab rioters.
i wonder under what conditions that land was purchased in any case one town compared to the hundreds of palestinian towns facing prolonged israeli brutalities?
With all due respect Afarsek, i have not heard of such. Although, i am quite aware that many arab nations dissallowed foreign ownership of land due to the after effects of what happened in palestine i wouldnt say it did not happen. Nonetheless, one cannot say that the vast majority of land israel is occupying is purchased. Wouldnt you agree???
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
deen - Obviously I havent researched exchange of land ownership. I do know that the city I live in was founded in 1891. The land was purchased from a Sami Khoury who ruled the area. It was useless swampland but Jews imported eucalyptus trees from Austr to dry swamps.
To all.... this entire documentary has been seperated into 6 parts as youtube has a limit to the maximum file size. to see the others fo to my main page and select the corresponding vids
not necessarily, if i had my way id return things to what they were like prior to partition/protectorates after the first world war.. if the land was once used by all three great religions harmonuosly, then why cant it happen again?? wishful thinking i know, but people are increasingly discussing this
While it is easy to look back at those times and see what we want to see and paint a picture as we'd like it painted, the fact remains that Arabs were killing Jews daily in what amounted to small genocides that the British did nothing about. There will never be a return to "partition/protectorates after the 1st ww".
The only way that will happen is if Israel is destroyed.
In my opinion, the only way there will be peace, is if the Arabs let Israel exist and completely stop all their aggression against it. And that my friend will never happen either.
But, yes! you are right it will only happen if either scenario plays out. However, i do believe that the tide is slowly turning against israel, for 2 reasons. Firstly, America, or should i say the United States, is forcasted to lose its dominant position in world politics, mainly due to the rise of China, India and other Supranational organisations like the EU and possibly GCC
thank you for posting this video hope it stays on for some time i have seen a propensity for these kinds of videos to dissapear from you tube after a while hope this one stays
Only 3% is a wall, to protect motorists who used to be fired on by snipers. 97% is a fence. Since its construction, suicide bombings have fallen to almost zero. Shame the Palestinians forced Israel into having to take this measure.
again i doubt your figures but wall or fence they serve the same purpose and there have been suicide bombings in the last few weeks and the dropping down of same is for different multiple reasons and something tells me that you are well aware of them
and,amazing simply amazing your mind set,maybe reflective of the majority of israelis(?)when you say "shame the palestinians forced israelis!!!try leaving palestine,israelis.
One could add that suicide bombings have not fallen to zero. furthermore, many of those wouldbe suicide bombers are now tsking part in their internal palistinian conflict currently raging. devide and conquer happening all over again......
deen - Suicide bombings have fallen drastically, but have been in places where there isnt a barrier such as Eilat. My city has had 7 suicide bombings but none since the security barrier.
jews came took their land..they bomb the arabs..murder them but when the arab only means of protection is suicicde bombing they cry like babys..give the land back to its people..if somebody comes here in takes texas they'll ww5..i agree with battahblue
a fence that the concrete has not ben laid out yet, it will be replaced. still doesn't give israel a right to rob and from stopping people moving in their own land.
I want to thank you Mr. Attar for this documentary. It's perfect. I watched it today at Berzeit University, and I bought a copy.
I wonder, why don't you connect with other Palestinian directors and try to organize a "Palestinian Week" instead of you tours showing your documentary only? I think that it will be more effective. :)
you should be ashamed of yourself. Arafat himself has said that he was already plotting more attacks on Israel on the plane ride home from Oslo. I could give hours of dissertation on why each of the points presented here are either completely false or are presented in an incredibly one sided fashion. Unfortunately youtube only gives me 500 characters. You are a disgusting human being and should hate yourself. I cannot force you to stop spreading your lies. Just know, you are a monster.
mookosh 1 month ago
That entire film is PREPOSTEROUSLY ONE SIDED utter propaganda.Like looking at a boxing match where EVERY angle shows only one boxer absorbing hits but meting out none.No mention that there was NEVER EVER a country known as "Palestine",that huge tracts of land were simply occupied by migrant Arab squatters. Protected hiways and fences were VERY obviously placed to block radical Muslim suicide bombers and that if "annexation" and "eviction" were the goal, the path would be VERY different...
wrightfl3 5 months ago
6 million it a big lie, and were is fn in this, but bad thing will come back at them ,
MrRodde76 9 months ago
where did they get this voice-over artist from? you can hear she is reading it, and i'm not convinced she even knows what she's reading about.
panacea2010 9 months ago
The arabs want to convince the world the Israelis and Jews are the aggressors and killers, while at the same time trying to cause the world to forget the first massacre, Hebron massacre they committed against Jews,
The Hebron massacre refers to the killing of sixty-seven Jews on 23 and 24 August 1929,
while trying to make people forget that over one million jews were forced to flee arab and muslim lands to save themselves....many died but thanks to G-d many fled and survived.
panafilmxxx 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Rancid, corrupt, misogynist, stultified and stultifying, backward, retarded, dark-ages mess of a Muslim country?
Or groovy, gorgeous, fun, brilliant Israel?
You decide.
IslamicFarming 1 year ago
You can NOT be an accupier of your own land. West Bank has always been Jewish, you can't walk a mile and not come accross a Jewish ancient site. Also, the land is not claimed by Jordan who lost it to Israel. At best West Bank is a disputed trritory. Jews have a claim and nomadic arabs who have no long term connection are also making a claim. The only solution is the transfer of arabs to Jordan.
MrSicarii 1 year ago
@ 3:45 palestinian refugees, why are these still refugees ? and live in refugee camps? the last refugee camp in israel was dismantled in 1959, but their neighbour countries keep these prisoners (it's an arab resolution) they won't give them full citizenship like Israel did. there are still refugee camps in palestinian controled areas. BTW this movie doesn't deal with the entire context...why is that?
arievanscholten 1 year ago
Nazi Israel
Mehmet66Yozgat 1 year ago
I just watched this video on dutch public tv. Frankly, it's nothing new. Everybody living outside Israel and USA (where media and demographics are affiliated one way or another), including majority of Jews, condemn Israel's human rights violations (policy, not exception), and warm crimes.
As for suicide bombing, it's a means (for lack of more effective conventional weapons that Israel has), not a goal. Cluster bombs used by Israel, kill more innocent people, so don't be distracted by symbolism.
ZeKritik 1 year ago
5:41 - looks like terrorists to me
kayakergod 1 year ago
There are truthful statements in this film but I don't like the excessive, crude, and inappropriate emotive music. It would have been better to let the facts speak for themselves
Prunesqualer 1 year ago
What, they're FACTS because a douche like you says so? Don't make me laugh.
I love how you compare Israel with nazi Germany. It's propagandic, and intellectually dishonest.
Nazi Germany: Millions rounded up, put in trains, robbed, put in work camps, worked to death, burned in ovens, gassed,etc.
Gaza: A territory ruled by terrorist, Islamist, fanatical orgs. , bent on ridding the world of the Jew. Suicide bombing, mortar attacks, etc.
The wall is a success - it keeps the scum out of Israel.
boskinator 2 years ago
First of all - there is no 'Palestine'.
Second - I don't give a shit about your family - Pals made their bed, now let them sleep in it.
Third - I'm not a nazi (love how you capitalize the word nazi lol).
Fourth - Maybe the pals would have better living conditions if Hamas used the billions in foreign aid they recieve each year for infrastructure instead of weapons.
Finally, Arabs who actually live in Israel have more rights and a better standard of living than any other arab shithole.
boskinator 2 years ago
@boskinator well, i`m glad that israel is building that wall, it will be the biggest prison for the jews and zionist,at least if you are hit by a tsunami?? you have no where to run??,, but the irony in building the wall shows that jews like to live in concentation camps,so why blame the germains??PS , i dont know if you are a jew?? but if you love israel, why dont you live there?? or are you scared to be stoned by kids??or is it to warm for a canadian??
maatiuk 1 year ago
@maatiuk
The pals have the keys to their own destiny. They can stop the daily rocket and mortar attacks on Israel, recognize its right to exist and stop FUCKING WHINING ALREADY. It was not Israel who chose the corrupt Arafat to lead (and rob) them, now was it?
How dare you compare Gaza with the Holocaust...apples and oranges, you mental midget.
boskinator 1 year ago
The UN is a farce.
They are currently trying to pass a law to make illegal to criticize religion (Islam, that is...).
Bomb the UN.
boskinator 2 years ago
Also I know English may not be your first language but I never wrote you were a westerner, I wrote "the same Westerners retards like yourself insist", that is, "the same Westerners (pause) THAT retards like yourself insist". A subtly you might not understand.
1200strong 2 years ago
It was the Irgun terrorists who FOUGHT the British, forcing the partition plan through. The British supplied and trained the Arab legion, enemies of the Jews, while preventing Jewish immigration during the holocaust and confiscating Zionist weapons. It was private Jewish donations that bought the guns (mostly German), not goyim. Idiot. You need to do a little reading, asserting that "they did and still do" flies in the face of the facts and reveals your turbidity and stupidity.
1200strong 2 years ago
Crack open a book sometime. US "support" (bribery and coercion) of Israel didn't begin until 1973, around the same time they started giving money to Egypt. The US gives more money to Arabs than to Israel. The US forced Israel to give up the Sinai, an area of both historic and geographical (depth of defense) importance to Israel, given aid to Egypt, Jordan, and Saudi Arabia, enemies of Israel, and bribes Israel into appointing court Jews to do their bidding. Some friends all right.
1200strong 2 years ago
Thank G-d Rabin (y"sh) is dead. Giving the Land of Israel to the Arabs is no different than giving it to the Canaanites, a blasphemous act which warrants the death penalty.
1200strong 2 years ago
Comment removed
maatiuk 1 year ago
@1200strong could you tell me why it is taking the jews and zionist 3000 years to build a peaceful homeland? ah?? maybe they kill anyone who has a reasonable hope??? than again jews been assasinating prophets and massenger through out their history,,why not Rabin??
maatiuk 1 year ago
Actually not at all. Did the UN come and defend Israel after the partition? No they watched and expected it to be destroyed. In fact the Jews had to SNEAK weapon in to fight the Arabs. Not to mention the 1947 "borders" were and are completely indefensible. 1948 was to be the last year of the Holocaust, but the Jews defied the same Westerners retards like yourself insist "made" Israel. Britain gave away 85% of the land promised to the Jews. It's the world vs Israel, battleground Jerusalem.
1200strong 2 years ago
@mjlodina
Psychopathic? You make me laugh. Have you even been to Israel? It's the only sane, productive, and free country in the entire middle east.
Israelis do not want to exterminate anyone, so please stop using the buzz words "Nazi" and "ethnic cleansing" for shock value. If the Israelis wanted Arabs dead, why would they allow them to live in Israel, with more rights and freedoms than they would get in any of the surrounding arab countries?
You don't make any sense - lol!
boskinator 2 years ago
@mjlodina
Keep believing the propagandic filth you are being fed by your imam.
There never was a "Palestine", as far as indigenous arabs go. Jews existed in the area, on and off, for over 5 milennia! Look it up, habibi.
In 1948, equal land was given to both Arabs and Jews...but who decided to attack? Oh yeah, it was the indigenous arabs, with the help of the surrounding arabic nations.
Palestinians don't want peace...they want dead Jews. They want an all-arab, all-muslim middle east.
boskinator 2 years ago
Furthermore:
Israel has already given land for peace - what do you think the Gaza pullout was??? What about giving back the Sinai to Egypt for peace?
Find me one other nation, in all of recorded history, that has given back land acquired in a conflict.
Israel has bent over backwards for peace - the pals and the rest of the surrounding arab/muslim world simply do not want "dirty jews" in their midst. Period.
boskinator 2 years ago
The wall is a big mark of racism from the israeli community against the palestinians. nothing in the Torah suggests zionism, there is nothing in international law that says it is okay to be racist, nothing in international law says it is okay to kill people and still their rights to life. Israel is only doing what the Nazis did to the jews, which was recognized after. If anything, the jewish community should have opposed such actions, not commit the harm that was done to it to others
murtajay 2 years ago
I disagree wholeheartedly, murtajay.
Israel is not putting "palestinians" on trains, shipping them to concentration camps, working them to death or executing them in gas chambers and ovens, performing horrible experiments on the elderly, the infirm, women and children or stealing all of their possesions (including gouging out the cold caps from their teeth after they die).
So please stop with the Nazi comparisons
See the following post regarding the wall:
boskinator 2 years ago
this is the biggest peace of crap i have ever read in my entire life. clearly, u have no idea how it affects the people, and clearly, u only see the israeli side, not seeing the abuse that the people are getting in the palestinian areas. i am not speaking because i believe this video, i speak on the behalf of people i know, who experienced it. they are totally equal to nazi actions, no person in the right mind set would believe this bullshit u r saying, unless they are being brainwashed by crap
murtajay 2 years ago
The wall was put up to keep suicide bombers out. Period.
And guess what? It works.
The "palestinians" have made their bed, and now they have to sleep in it. For anything to change, they must:
a) Stop all suicide, mortar and rocket attacks
b) Lay down all weapons
c) Officially recognize Israel's right to exist
d) Stop indoctrinating their children to hate, kill and martyr themselves, and give them an honest education.
Peace will never be acheived if these criteria are not met. Period.
boskinator 2 years ago
how have they given land for peace, when they decided to go to gaza in the first place. u say that having the wall is stopping the suicide bombers, yet, the attack on gaza was said to be defense.. they clearly wanted to get rid of the palestinians. U clearly have no idea of the history of the land either, no idea who the first jews are, no idea how it was like before 1948. i would strongly encourage u to actually read some history- will ya? u're too brainwashed to actually dare and read truth
murtajay 2 years ago
What (specific) history of the middle east do you suggest I read, o enlightened murtajay? "The Protocols of the Elders of Zion"?
I'd be happy to read your version. Bring it.
boskinator 2 years ago
I'm not a historian, i have no specific versions of history i;d like to know, but i'm definately more open minded to know the truth about a current situation and understand the history from people who experienced the negativity of such terrible situations, and not just accept what the media is feeding the public
murtajay 2 years ago
I'll paraphrase murtajay's last post:
"I don't read books, and I'm not educated. I believe what I see on the BBC and al-Jazeera...and I don't particularly like Jews or Israel. I make moral judgements with my heart and intuition, and dispose of any kind of documented truth or history, or fact. I see people suffering, so Israel MUST be at fault, right? I mean, did you see those poor children???"
You should not speak of that which you have no clue. Period.
boskinator 2 years ago
excuse me? are you accusing me of anti-semitism based on the fact that i do not like the israeli way of conducting their "peace"?... you are surely wrong "boskinator" whatever the fuck u wanna be identified as. first off... your claims are ones of irrational and are clearly manipulated by the idea of anyone hating israel or its actions as being anti-semitic. let me tell you one thing, i don't even watch al-jazeera, bbc, or anything of the sort, i actually interview ppl with experience. "period"
murtajay 2 years ago
Yeah? And how many Israelis have you interviewed? I'll bet you've never even SEEN a Jew.
You're suprised that the Israeli people hate palestinians? When they bomb them daily, perpetrate disgusting suicide bombings aimed DELIBERATELY at civilian innocents, when they indoctrinate their children FROM INFANCY to hate, kill, and worship martyrdom?
Never mind the constant threats from the despotic surrounding arab/muslim dictatorships.
Are you really that surprised that they erected that wall?
boskinator 2 years ago
ACTUALLY.... i have met many jews, some who are even ANTI-ISRAEL... jews who do not support israel.. and i met those who do support israel, but they have NEVER been there, and they can not say anything because they have never been there, because they know nothing about it. Those who did go there harrassed me and everyone who was against israel. if we do not accept israel, we are harrassed, and if it was a palestinian, the harrassment is twice as bad, so knock off ur bullshit there, alright?
murtajay 2 years ago
Palestinians are the shit-disturbers of the world. They do not know their own history, and they are infused with the delusion that something is owed to them. They cannot demonstrate peacefully - look up vids here on YT of them holding plackards reading "RIP HITLER", etc.
It's not Israel's fault pals have been led astray by corrupt leaders (Arafat stole 100s of millions of $ in foreign aid to pad his personal bank account).
This conflict is NOT about land - it's about Jew-hatred.
boskinator 2 years ago
gosh u're so out of it and have no idea what this is really about. it is NOT jew hatred, it is about the land. clearly, u do not even know why this conflict even started, u clearly do not know Palestinians know their history. If you think it is about Jew hatred, u are clearly mislead. It is not the main reason for conflict, Jew hatred is obviously a principle you have been brought up to think is what is happening. Palestinians do not hate jews, they hate zionists, and there is a difference there
murtajay 2 years ago
I do know why the conflict started.
Jews and arabs lived side by side relatively peacefully before 1948.
Once Israel was given statehood (and equal land was alotted to the arabs, the surrounding arab countries rallyed together in a show of unity to rid the middle east of the jew. Only, the Jews defended themselves and built a modern, thriving country in the meantime.
Up to now, history has repeated itself, over and over, with arabs/muslims attacking and Israel repelling them.
Check ur facts
boskinator 2 years ago
Funny - you haven't addressed the topic of Hamas' terror. Why is that? Are you blind? Is your head in the sand? Do you have blinkers on?
I, on the other hand, can see the big picture with regards to the Pals. Generations have been brainwashed into thinking that it's Israel's fault that they live in destitution, when in reality, it is the fault of their zealoutrous leaders who teach them to hate and kill and commit suicide for the "cause". Sadly, they are puppets of Iran and Syria.
boskinator 2 years ago
Your inane comparison between the Israeli wall and what the Nazis did to the world is nauseatingly naive, and is a grave insult to those who suffered and died at the hands of the Nazis.
Instead of "interviewing" people, why don't you go Auschwitz (or any of the other concentration camp "museums" in Europe. Open a history book. Go to Israel. See what it's like. Learn about current political affairs - maybe you'd find out that Iran and Syria are waging war against Israel thru the pals n hezbollah
boskinator 2 years ago
i am not insulting ANY one who died in the Nazi regime, i recognize their deaths, and it is a terrible shameful time for those who were affected by it. on the other hand, Israel is doing the same thing to the Palestinians without having as much media outlets see it because Israel has the power and support from the Americans and the British, since they wanted control in the middle east anyways. I am a political science student, i am learning this, and the last few things there, make no sense FYI!
murtajay 2 years ago
Yes you have, by comparing a wall that keeps out SUICIDE BOMBERS to the horrors perpetrated by the Nazis.
Your professors are either biased or ignorant (they usually go hand in hand).
So what - you think the Jews control the media? Try watching BBC, CBC, al-Jazeera, CTV and tell me that they are not slanted towards the palestinian agenda. There's propaganda on both sides,no doubt.
Bottom line: the people of Israel want to live in peace amid a sea of arab/muslim zealots who want them DEAD.
boskinator 2 years ago
You do not make any sense - I guess you're being brainwashed by your so-called "professors".
Answer this question for me: is Israel systematically rounding up all pals, putting them on trains to concentration camps, working them to death or executing them in ovens and gas chambers, carrying out horrific experiments on children, women and the elderly and stealing all of their money and putting it in swiss bank accounts (this includes the dead's gold teeth fillings)?
That is what the Nazis did.
boskinator 2 years ago
Whats the difference between jelly and jam? You can't jelly 6 million Jews into an oven.
assman896650 2 years ago
The wall works great! When was the last time a crazed shahid blew him/her/itself up in Israel?
Calling this an Apartheid wall is an insult the the indigenous population of South Africa that actually suffered at the hands of their white oppressors. They did not carry out suicide bombings or fire mortars and rockets daily, as Hamas does.
See the difference???
Fuck Hamas - until they recognize Israel, put down their weapons and stop ALL attacks, there will never be peace. Israel must defend.
boskinator 2 years ago
jews will be killed one time forever
ajutubos 2 years ago
Israel is a disgrace
mab999 2 years ago
AMERICA says no more USA DOLLARS for APARTHEID ISRAEL
TARASTWO2 2 years ago
israel is murders
lumbeewoman38 2 years ago
Terrorist Zionist Israel was founded on terror, exists on terror and its evil nature cannot be preserved without terror. The great crimes committed against the Palestinian people by the Jewish Zionist who today run Israel .Zionist Israel stole the Palestinian land, and for over 60 years terrorized its inhabitants, tortured and murdered those who resisted. these Jewish extremists control American politics, your government, your media, and your consciences.
mohammedalswaidi 2 years ago
The terrorist Israeli State is a non-state It never has been a state. it never will be a state . it is an occupation of land, an occupation that must end. The time has come to say "Get Out!" This land is not yours! This land belongs to the Palestinians It will always belong to the Palestinians. It has never been your land! Stop your murdering! Stop your genocide! Stop your terror! Go back to Europe and America where you came from.
mohammedalswaidi 2 years ago
I know that I am shocking many of you who are hearing this for the first time. I am sure some of you are thinking that this cannot be true! Just go to Google and write ( Moed Kattan 17a ) you will find yourself what I mean ,truth and nothing except truth .
mohammedalswaidi 2 years ago
Look at Some Teachings of the JEWISH Talmud, Where a JEW Should Do EVIL.
Moed Kattan 17a : If a JEW is tempted to do EVIL,he should go to a city (GAZA) where he is not known and do the EVIL there.
Anyone needing more proof of this EVIL massacre should simply visit some of the photos of the most recent holocaust against the Palestinians Christian and Muslim alike.
mohammedalswaidi 2 years ago
The Zionist Jews have now got most of the Americans so deceived and so blinded and so deafened by their propaganda,that they follow along,tag along,like they are on a leash.Gentile dogs is exactly what the Zionist Jews call the"Goyim",and they are certainly on the leash now,trotting along right behind,assisting the anti-Semitic Jews promote the Godless STATE of Israel and her MURDERERS.going everywhere the Zionist Jews go, and doing exactly as they want them to do.
mohammedalswaidi 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The wall saves lives, no maniac killers can do their dirty murders of civilians so of is a good idea.
AlyBlack 2 years ago
Comment removed
lww500 2 years ago
Israel has learned from history and created modern day concentration camps. Too bad that they have learned the wrong lesson from their sad history. I wish peace and independence to occupied Palestine.
sisyevmasis 3 years ago 11
t4705mb6...why are you contradicting yourself you fool?? you say there is no God yet you use the term "hell" in ur argument! so believe in the heavens and hell yet choose not to believe in the creator???
TaShBebEk 3 years ago
Great documentary, thanks. Israeli hasbara is spinning itself dizzy saying and doing anything to prevent the objective story of zionism from being told.
ninasnake 3 years ago 6
WW2 was not fought so Jewish people could put Palestinians in concentration camps. We watch Palestinians wither away in death camps, people piled upon people, filth, disease and death everywhere. The children will battle Goliath. A Palestinians future is to fight honorably, defend and free their people from Israeli persecution. Dozens of movies and documentaries are churned out using WW2 Concentration camp pictures and films - Never Again! Tell that to the Palestinians; Shame on the WW2 Allies.
5x5s 3 years ago 7
@5x5s
LOL - please direct me to evidence of Pals in death camps, with people piled upon people.
You are intellectually dishonest, and blantantly biased.
Shame on YOU.
boskinator 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
before fatah/hamas took over palestinian life there were no fences/borders/checkpoints. palestinians traveled anywhere they wanted. their unemployment was less than 5%. they had israel national health insurance in israeli hospitals. their world turned into a prison
because fatah/hammas theological gangsters sent suicide bombers, and even fired over 7,200 rockets into israel since 2005.
2GfH345N 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The Moslems is a champions in the incitement and propaganda,
Hammas terrorists shoot missiles eight years
and now hide and cry to the world.
Known that the Hammas terrorists hide in the hospitals,
schools And behind children as defends human.
How much it's possible to be blind, dumb and naive ?
Mossad2008 3 years ago
Since there is no "god" or "gods" & NEVER EVER has been, what in hell is REALLY going on?
Well, this has to do with using myth on very stupid & childlike people who refuse to think for themselves & LOVE to be led around by the nose. They want to "belong" so join a CULT for power & money. (Its clled selfish & GREEDY!)
Zionists simply stole Palestine along with British & U.S. help & are systematically murdering the indiginous population...because they FEEL LIKE IT.
And the world watches. SHAME!
t4705mb6 3 years ago 4
Shame !!!!!!!!!!!!
nashooo86 3 years ago
GOD BLESS THE PALESTINIAN PEOPLE AND LONG LIVE PALESTINE.....inshallah bittit 7araru 2arthkoon!!!!
ohyearyan 3 years ago 6
The thing i wanna know is how can one not see the truth after watching this?????
i mean when one SUPER POWER takes over a country with missiles that were made in the stone age u know its gona be one sided...the palistenian ppl deserve to live there lives in peace not in constant maham.....one min ur living and the next min ur house is demolished and ur olive trees witch take at least 8 years to grow are distroyed in less than 5mins i mean come on ppl please look in hearts and see the truth....
ohyearyan 3 years ago 7
thank you for posting this video to open up some blind eyes,, and thanks to muhammed alatar too.
FadyFalasten 3 years ago
wow its really sad how the Jews are doing what has been done to them... and isnt it written in the Torah that Jews should not own any land but rather should live amongst all Nations....hmmm and about sucide bombers.. i really dont think they are a big issue here, someone has to fight for their land... one mans terrorist is another mans freedom fighter.
Waiting4PCE 4 years ago 15
thanks for posting this
more people have to see this
J1NX1337 4 years ago 3
Intresting Vid
mab999 4 years ago 4
Afarsuck - 100% of the wall is ILLEGAL as deemed by the World Court - UN and the 4th Geneva Conventions (article 49)
East Germans used to call their wall a "security fence" as well...
AIPACOWNSCONGRESS 4 years ago 3
MUST READ -- The Law of The Jungle - Oct, 31 2006
heathlander.wordpress com/2006/10/31/the-law-of-the-jungle-2/
"Wherever law ends, Tyranny begins." --- John Locke
"if the powerful don't want peace, there won't be peace. There can be no better example of this than the Israel/Palestine conflict."
"...weak states have no legal protection against aggression by the powerful, as Nicaragua discovered to its dismay in 1986."
AIPACOWNSCONGRESS 4 years ago
Israel will not inherit the promised land until the next Joshua(Yeshua Mashiach) returns which requires the present situation to come to pass. Praise Yahweh Elohim for He shall send His Son and put an end to all foolish man made leaderships when half of the city goes into exile and is encompassed by armies.
7YHWH7 4 years ago
Shalom wa'alaykum.....
Can all please respect other peoples opinion, ive only uploaded these vids to stimulate discussion. any obscene messages, whether directed against muslims or jews, will be deleted and user blocked. Thnx
deenishpie 4 years ago 4
Why is it not mentioned that Kfar Etzion land was purchased by Jewish settlers in 1927. They were driven out by Arabs. Settling in again, they were again driven out. A third attempt ending in the Kfar Etzion massacre in which most of the Jews were murdered by Arab rioters.
Afarsek 4 years ago
i wonder under what conditions that land was purchased in any case one town compared to the hundreds of palestinian towns facing prolonged israeli brutalities?
adeelmc 4 years ago
With all due respect Afarsek, i have not heard of such. Although, i am quite aware that many arab nations dissallowed foreign ownership of land due to the after effects of what happened in palestine i wouldnt say it did not happen. Nonetheless, one cannot say that the vast majority of land israel is occupying is purchased. Wouldnt you agree???
deenishpie 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
deen - Obviously I havent researched exchange of land ownership. I do know that the city I live in was founded in 1891. The land was purchased from a Sami Khoury who ruled the area. It was useless swampland but Jews imported eucalyptus trees from Austr to dry swamps.
Afarsek 4 years ago
To all.... this entire documentary has been seperated into 6 parts as youtube has a limit to the maximum file size. to see the others fo to my main page and select the corresponding vids
ciao
deenishpie 4 years ago
its all twisted bulshit
elischlanger 4 years ago
so i guess the jewish people who appeared on this video are all twisted too?
deenishpie 4 years ago
When one country loses a war over land to another, they lose the land! Sorry.
Yaak14 4 years ago
I guess thats every incentive for muslims to invade israel for the land and take all the land for itself then????
deenishpie 4 years ago
yes, you are right. I think thats the best solution, one final war. Winner takes all. wouldnt you agree??
Yaak14 4 years ago
not necessarily, if i had my way id return things to what they were like prior to partition/protectorates after the first world war.. if the land was once used by all three great religions harmonuosly, then why cant it happen again?? wishful thinking i know, but people are increasingly discussing this
deenishpie 4 years ago
While it is easy to look back at those times and see what we want to see and paint a picture as we'd like it painted, the fact remains that Arabs were killing Jews daily in what amounted to small genocides that the British did nothing about. There will never be a return to "partition/protectorates after the 1st ww".
Yaak14 4 years ago
The only way that will happen is if Israel is destroyed.
In my opinion, the only way there will be peace, is if the Arabs let Israel exist and completely stop all their aggression against it. And that my friend will never happen either.
Yaak14 4 years ago
i believe i am talking about "pre" protectorates!
But, yes! you are right it will only happen if either scenario plays out. However, i do believe that the tide is slowly turning against israel, for 2 reasons. Firstly, America, or should i say the United States, is forcasted to lose its dominant position in world politics, mainly due to the rise of China, India and other Supranational organisations like the EU and possibly GCC
deenishpie 4 years ago
thank you for posting this video hope it stays on for some time i have seen a propensity for these kinds of videos to dissapear from you tube after a while hope this one stays
adeelmc 4 years ago
that wall only looks like that for a tiny portion. for the vast mojarity of it its just a fence, basicly a boundry sign.
stevemasterus 4 years ago
hmmm, yeah your right, as that boundary fence is the boundary that the remaining wall will be built on, lol..
deenishpie 4 years ago
Only 3% is a wall, to protect motorists who used to be fired on by snipers. 97% is a fence. Since its construction, suicide bombings have fallen to almost zero. Shame the Palestinians forced Israel into having to take this measure.
Afarsek 4 years ago
again i doubt your figures but wall or fence they serve the same purpose and there have been suicide bombings in the last few weeks and the dropping down of same is for different multiple reasons and something tells me that you are well aware of them
adeelmc 4 years ago
and,amazing simply amazing your mind set,maybe reflective of the majority of israelis(?)when you say "shame the palestinians forced israelis!!!try leaving palestine,israelis.
adeelmc 4 years ago
One could add that suicide bombings have not fallen to zero. furthermore, many of those wouldbe suicide bombers are now tsking part in their internal palistinian conflict currently raging. devide and conquer happening all over again......
deenishpie 4 years ago
deen - Suicide bombings have fallen drastically, but have been in places where there isnt a barrier such as Eilat. My city has had 7 suicide bombings but none since the security barrier.
Afarsek 4 years ago
May God kill all the evil jews asap.
BattahBlue 4 years ago
are you a nazi or something?
ar223 4 years ago
YOUR AN IDIOT.
trumuskatear 3 years ago
jews came took their land..they bomb the arabs..murder them but when the arab only means of protection is suicicde bombing they cry like babys..give the land back to its people..if somebody comes here in takes texas they'll ww5..i agree with battahblue
a2thezy 4 years ago 4
a fence that the concrete has not ben laid out yet, it will be replaced. still doesn't give israel a right to rob and from stopping people moving in their own land.
deenishpie 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
97% of the barrier is a fence, 3% a wall. Pals used to shoot at Israeli drivers driving past.
Afarsek 4 years ago
I want to thank you Mr. Attar for this documentary. It's perfect. I watched it today at Berzeit University, and I bought a copy.
I wonder, why don't you connect with other Palestinian directors and try to organize a "Palestinian Week" instead of you tours showing your documentary only? I think that it will be more effective. :)
damaryo 4 years ago
top documentary
robredo00 5 years ago
All I'm going to say is that wall reminds me of the Berlin wall.
gnrdude 5 years ago
there are 5 parts to this video, i will be uploading them as soon as possible, check back to see its progress :D
deenishpie 5 years ago